1

### Definition of a Company

A company is a legal entity formed by a group of individuals to engage in and
operate a business—commercial or industrial—enterprise. It is a separate legal
entity distinct from its members, meaning it has its own legal rights and
obligations. The primary goal of a company is to generate profit for its
shareholders.

### Characteristics of a Company under Company Law

Under Company Law, particularly the Companies Act 2013 in India, several key
characteristics define a company. Here are the primary attributes, along with
relevant sections where applicable:

1. **Separate Legal Entity (Section 9)**

- A company is considered a legal entity distinct from its members. It can
own property, incur debt, sue, and be sued in its own name.
- *Example:* In the landmark case Salomon v A Salomon & Co Ltd, the court
held that a company has a separate legal personality from its shareholders.

2. **Limited Liability (Section 34)**

- The liability of the members or shareholders of the company is limited to
the amount unpaid on their shares. They are not personally liable for the
company's debts. - *Example:* If a shareholder has paid the full amount
for their shares, they have no further liability to the company's creditors.

3. **Perpetual Succession (Section 9)**

- The company continues to exist beyond the lives of its members. Changes
in membership do not affect the continuity of the company.
- *Example:* The death, insolvency, or retirement of a member does not
dissolve the company.

4. **Transferability of Shares (Section 44)**

- Shares of a public company are freely transferable. This feature provides
liquidity to the shareholders.
 2

- *Example:* Shareholders can sell their shares on the stock exchange

without the company's consent.

5. **Common Seal (Section 22)**

- Although optional after the Companies (Amendment) Act 2015, a common
seal is used as the official signature of the company.
- *Example:* Documents like share certificates, deeds, and contracts are
authenticated with the common seal.

6. **Separate Property (Section 9)**

- The company owns property in its own name, and the members do not have
any direct ownership rights over the company’s property.
- *Example:* Company assets cannot be claimed by shareholders in personal
capacity.

7. **Capacity to Sue and Be Sued (Section 9)**

- A company can initiate legal proceedings in its own name and can also be sued
for its actions.
- *Example:* A company can sue a supplier for breach of contract.

8. **Artificial Person**
- A company, while not a human being, is recognized by law as having duties and
rights.
- *Example:* It can enter into contracts, own assets, and employ people.

9. **Registered Office (Section 12)**

- Every company must have a registered office to which all official
communications and notices may be sent.
- *Example:* The address where the company's statutory records are
maintained.
 3

10. **Statutory Compliance (Various Sections)**

- Companies are required to comply with various statutory requirements such
as annual general meetings (Section 96), maintaining books of accounts
(Section 128), and filing annual returns (Section 92).
- *Example:* Failure to hold an annual general meeting can result in penalties.

**Case: Tata Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar (1964) 34
Comp Cas 458 (SC)**

- **Facts:** Tata Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. (TELCO) was incorporated
under the Companies Act and had established a factory in the State of Bihar.
The State of Bihar attempted to levy a tax on the company’s activities,
contending that TELCO was an agent of Tata Sons Ltd. and thus not a separate
entity.
- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court of India held that TELCO was a separate
legal entity distinct from Tata Sons Ltd., even though Tata Sons held a
significant number of shares in TELCO. The court reiterated the principle of
separate legal personality, confirming that a company is distinct from its
shareholders.

**Case: Workmen of Associated Rubber Industry Ltd. v. Associated Rubber

Industry Ltd.
(1986) 59 Comp Cas 134 (SC)**

- **Facts:** The workmen of Associated Rubber Industry Ltd. sought to make

the shareholders personally liable for the unpaid wages and other dues of the
company. They argued that the shareholders should be liable as the company
was merely a façade. - **Judgment:** The Supreme Court emphasized the
principle of limited liability, stating that shareholders cannot be held
personally liable for the debts of the company. The corporate veil could not be
lifted merely to satisfy the claims of the workmen without proof of fraudulent
conduct or misuse of the corporate structure.
 4

Incorporation of a company under Indian Company Law, specifically under the

Companies Act, 2013, provides several advantages and disadvantages. Here
are the key points, along with relevant sections where applicable:

### Advantages of Incorporation

1. **Separate Legal Entity (Section 9)**

- **Advantage:** The company is recognized as a separate legal entity distinct
from its shareholders and directors. This allows the company to own property,
enter into contracts, and sue or be sued in its own name.
- **Example:** The company's assets and liabilities are distinct from those of its
members.

2. **Limited Liability (Section 34)**

- **Advantage:** Shareholders' liability is limited to the amount unpaid on
their shares. This means that personal assets of shareholders are protected
from the company’s debts and liabilities.
- **Example:** If a company goes bankrupt, shareholders are only liable to
the extent of their unpaid shares, if any.

3. **Perpetual Succession (Section 9)**

- **Advantage:** The company continues to exist even if there is a change in
membership, such as the death or resignation of shareholders or directors.
- **Example:** The company’s operations are not affected by changes in
ownership.

4. **Transferability of Shares (Section 44)**

- **Advantage:** Shares of a public company are freely transferable,
providing liquidity and an easy exit mechanism for investors.
- **Example:** Shareholders can sell their shares on the stock exchange
without any restriction from the company.
 5

5. **Capacity to Sue and Be Sued (Section 9)**

- **Advantage:** The company can initiate legal proceedings in its own name
and can also be sued for its actions.
- **Example:** A company can sue a supplier for breach of contract.

6. **Raising Capital**
- **Advantage:** Companies can raise capital more easily by issuing shares,
debentures, and other securities. Public companies can attract investments
from the general public. - **Example:** A company can issue an Initial
Public Offering (IPO) to raise funds for expansion.

7. **Professional Management**
- **Advantage:** The structure of a company allows for the appointment of
professional managers who can run the company efficiently.
- **Example:** A company can hire experienced professionals to manage
different aspects of the business.
1. **Separate Legal Entity**

**Case: Tata Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar (1964) 34
Comp Cas 458 (SC)**

- **Facts:** Tata Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. (TELCO) was

incorporated and had a separate legal entity from its shareholders and
directors. The State of Bihar attempted to impose a tax on TELCO's operations,
arguing that TELCO was just an agent of Tata Sons Ltd. - **Judgment:** The
Supreme Court held that TELCO was a separate legal entity distinct from Tata
Sons Ltd. This case reinforces the principle that an incorporated company is
distinct from its shareholders and directors, thus highlighting the advantage of
separate legal entity.

2. **Limited Liability**
 6

**Case: Workmen of Associated Rubber Industry Ltd. v. Associated Rubber

Industry Ltd.
(1986) 59 Comp Cas 134 (SC)**

- **Facts:** The workmen sought to hold the shareholders personally liable

for unpaid wages, arguing that the company was a mere façade.
- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court upheld the principle of limited liability,
stating that shareholders are not personally liable for the company’s debts.
This case demonstrates the advantage of limited liability where shareholders'
personal assets are protected.

3. **Perpetual Succession**

**Case: Mrs. Bacha F. Guzdar v. Commissioner of Income Tax, Bombay (1955)

25 Comp Cas 1 (SC)**

- **Facts:** Mrs. Bacha F. Guzdar received dividends from a tea company

and claimed it should be considered agricultural income.
- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court ruled that the company is a separate
legal entity with perpetual succession, and the income it generates is distinct
from the income of its shareholders. This illustrates the principle of perpetual
succession, as the company's existence continues despite changes in its
membership.

4. **Transferability of Shares**

**Case: V.B. Rangaraj v. V.B. Gopalakrishnan (1992) 73 Comp Cas 201 (SC)**

- **Facts:** A private company had an agreement among shareholders

restricting the transfer of shares, but this restriction was not mentioned in the
articles of association. A shareholder transferred his shares to an outsider,
leading to a dispute.
 7

- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court held that restrictions on the transfer

of shares must be explicitly stated in the articles of association. This case
underscores the importance of adhering to statutory requirements for
transferability of shares.
### Disadvantages of Incorporation

1. **Compliance and Regulatory Requirements (Various Sections)**

- **Disadvantage:** Companies are subject to stringent regulatory
requirements and compliance obligations, including maintaining statutory
records, filing annual returns, and holding annual general meetings.
- **Example:** Companies must adhere to provisions in sections like
Section 96 (AGM), Section 128 (Books of Accounts), and Section 92 (Annual
Return).

2. **Disclosure Requirements**
- **Disadvantage:** Companies, especially public ones, are required to
disclose significant information to the public and regulatory authorities, which
might be exploited by competitors.
- **Example:** Financial statements, director’s report, and other significant
events must be disclosed as per Section 134 (Financial Statement, Board's
Report, etc.).

3. **Cost of Formation and Compliance**

- **Disadvantage:** Incorporation involves initial formation costs, including
registration fees, legal fees, and ongoing compliance costs.
- **Example:** Fees for filing incorporation documents and continuous
expenses for compliance with statutory requirements.

4. **Separation of Ownership and Management**

- **Disadvantage:** There can be a conflict of interest between the
shareholders (owners) and the directors (management), leading to issues in
corporate governance. - **Example:** Directors might pursue their own
interests over the interests of the shareholders.
 8

5. **Complex Decision-Making**
- **Disadvantage:** Decision-making in a company can be slow and
complex due to the need for approval from the board of directors and
sometimes shareholders.
- **Example:** Major decisions require board meetings and, in some cases,
shareholders' meetings, which can delay implementation.

6. **Double Taxation**
- **Disadvantage:** Companies are subject to corporate tax on their
profits, and shareholders are taxed again on dividends received, leading
to double taxation. - **Example:** Profits are taxed at the corporate
level, and dividends distributed to shareholders are taxed at their
individual rates.

### Conclusion
Incorporation under Indian Company Law provides significant benefits like
limited liability, perpetual succession, and easier access to capital, which can
enhance a company's growth and stability. However, these benefits come with
drawbacks such as regulatory compliance, disclosure obligations, and potential
conflicts between management and shareholders.

1. **Compliance and Regulatory Requirements**

**Case: N.R. Murty v. Industrial Development Corporation of Orissa Ltd. (2003)

113 Comp Cas 168 (Orissa HC)**

- **Facts:** The company failed to comply with several statutory

requirements, including holding annual general meetings and maintaining
proper books of accounts.
- **Judgment:** The High Court emphasized the importance of compliance
with statutory obligations and imposed penalties on the company. This case
 9

highlights the disadvantage of extensive compliance and regulatory

requirements that companies must adhere to.

2. **Disclosure Requirements**

**Case: Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Escorts Ltd. (1986) 59 Comp Cas
548 (SC)**

- **Facts:** LIC sought to acquire a significant stake in Escorts Ltd., which

led to a dispute over the disclosure of information and transparency
requirements.
- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court emphasized the necessity for
transparency and full disclosure in the acquisition of shares. This case
illustrates the disadvantage of stringent disclosure requirements for
companies.

3. **Cost of Formation and Compliance**

**Case: Bennett Coleman & Co. v. Union of India (1973) 43 Comp Cas 675
(SC)**

- **Facts:** Bennett Coleman & Co. challenged the government's

restrictions on the import of newsprint, which had significant financial
implications for the company.
- **Judgment:** While not directly addressing formation and compliance
costs, this case reflects the financial burdens and regulatory challenges that
companies face, indirectly pointing to the high costs associated with
incorporation and ongoing compliance.

4. **Separation of Ownership and Management**

**Case: Shanti Prasad Jain v. Kalinga Tubes Ltd. (1965) 35 Comp Cas 351 (SC)**
 10

- **Facts:** There was a dispute between shareholders and the

management over control of the company.
- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court addressed the conflict of interest
between shareholders and directors, highlighting issues arising from the
separation of ownership and management. This case underscores the potential
disadvantage of conflicts in corporate governance.

### Definition of Promoters

In the context of Indian Company Law, promoters are individuals or entities

who undertake the process of forming a company. They take the necessary
steps to create a company and ensure it gets registered under the Companies
Act, 2013. The role of promoters includes identifying a business opportunity,
arranging for capital, assembling a team, preparing the necessary documents,
and fulfilling all legal requirements for incorporation.

### Duties and Roles of Promoters

- **Identification and Conception:** Identifying a viable business idea and

bringing it to fruition.
- **Financing:** Arranging necessary funds for the business.
- **Legal Compliance:** Ensuring that the company complies with all legal
requirements during formation.
- **Documentation:** Preparing the memorandum of association, articles of
association, and other necessary documents.
- **Initial Management:** Setting up the initial management team and
operational structure.

### Position of Promoters with Regard to Pre-Incorporation Contracts

 11

Pre-incorporation contracts are agreements entered into by promoters on

behalf of a company before it is formally incorporated. The legal status and
enforceability of these contracts are addressed by Indian Company Law.

#### Legal Framework Under Indian Company Law

1. **Pre-Incorporation Contracts (Specific Relief Act, 1963, Section 15(h))**

- **Section 15(h) of the Specific Relief Act, 1963:** This section allows for
the enforcement of contracts entered into by promoters before the
incorporation of a company, provided that the company ratifies these
contracts after its formation. - **Key Point:** The company must ratify
the contract after incorporation for it to be binding on the company.

2. **PersonalLiability of Promoters**
- **Personal Liability:** Promoters are personally liable for pre-
incorporation contracts. Since the company is not yet in existence when the
contract is made, it cannot be bound by the contract unless it ratifies it post-
incorporation. - **Case Law: Kelner v. Baxter (1866) LR 2 CP 174**
- **Facts:** Promoters entered into a contract for the purchase of goods
before the company was incorporated. The company, once incorporated,
refused to fulfill the contract. - **Judgment:** The court held that the
promoters were personally liable because the company did not exist at the
time of the contract.

3. **Ratification of Pre-Incorporation Contracts**

- **Section 19(e) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872:** Once incorporated, a
company can ratify the pre-incorporation contracts, thus assuming liability for
them. Ratification means the company adopts the contract as if it had been
made by the company from the beginning.
- **Effect of Ratification:** Upon ratification, the liability shifts from the
promoters to the company.
 12

4. **Disclosure Obligations**
- **Section 102 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Requires promoters to
disclose any interest they have in the contracts entered into on behalf of the
company. This ensures transparency and prevents conflicts of interest.
- **Key Point:** Disclosure of interests is crucial for maintaining the
integrity and trust of stakeholders.

5. **Fiduciary Duties of Promoters**

- **Section 300 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Imposes fiduciary duties on
promoters, requiring them to act in good faith and in the best interest of the
company. Promoters must avoid conflicts of interest and ensure that they do
not derive any undue benefit from their position.
- **Key Point:** Promoters have a duty to act honestly and not exploit their
position for personal gain.

6. **Liability for Misstatements**

- **Section 35 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Holds promoters liable for any
untrue statements or misrepresentations in the prospectus. This ensures that
promoters provide accurate and honest information to potential investors.
- **Key Point:** Promoters can be held accountable for any misleading
information that influences investors' decisions.

### Conclusion

Promoters play a critical role in the formation and initial structuring of a

company. Their position regarding pre-incorporation contracts is delicate as
they can be personally liable for these contracts unless the company, once
incorporated, ratifies them. Indian Company Law, particularly the Companies
Act, 2013, and the Specific Relief Act, 1963, provides a framework for
understanding the rights, responsibilities, and liabilities of promoters in
relation to pre-incorporation contracts. Promoters must navigate their duties
with care, ensuring compliance and transparency to protect both their
interests and those of the future company.
 13

### Doctrine of Indoor Management

The Doctrine of Indoor Management, also known as the "Turquand Rule," is a

principle in corporate law that protects outsiders dealing with a company. It
stipulates that persons dealing with a company are entitled to assume that
internal requirements and procedures have been complied with. In other
words, if an outsider enters into a transaction with a company, they are not
required to inquire into the regularity of the company's internal proceedings
but can presume that everything has been done according to the rules and
regulations.

This doctrine is a counterbalance to the Doctrine of Constructive Notice, which

holds that any person dealing with a company is presumed to know its public
documents (such as the memorandum and articles of association). The
Doctrine of Indoor Management mitigates the potentially harsh effects of the
Doctrine of Constructive Notice.

### Legal Basis in Indian Company Law

The Doctrine of Indoor Management is recognized in Indian Company Law, and

its principles have been applied in various judicial decisions. However, it is not
explicitly codified in the Companies Act, 2013, but is derived from common law
principles and judicial precedents.

### Key Case: Royal British Bank v. Turquand (1856)

 14

- **Facts:** The directors of the Royal British Bank had issued a bond to Mr.
Turquand. The company’s articles required that bonds should be issued under
a resolution passed by the shareholders. No such resolution was passed.
- **Judgment:** The court held that Mr. Turquand was entitled to assume
that the necessary resolution had been passed. He was not required to
investigate the internal proceedings of the company.

### Exceptions to the Doctrine of Indoor Management

There are several exceptions to the Doctrine of Indoor Management where the
protection offered by this doctrine does not apply:

1. **Knowledge of Irregularity**

If an outsider dealing with a company has actual knowledge of the internal

irregularities, they cannot claim protection under this doctrine.

- **Case: Howard v. Patent Ivory Manufacturing Co. (1888) 38 Ch D 156**

- **Facts:** The plaintiff knew that the directors he was dealing with had not
been properly appointed.
- **Judgment:** The court held that since the plaintiff had knowledge of the
irregularities, he could not rely on the Doctrine of Indoor Management.

2. **Suspicion of Irregularity**
If circumstances surrounding the transaction are suspicious or suggest that
there might be an internal irregularity, the outsider is expected to inquire
further.

- **Case: Anand Bihari Lal v. Dinshaw & Co. (1942) 12 Comp Cas 211
(Oudh)** - **Facts:** A company secretary sold the company's property
without authority. The transaction appeared suspicious as the secretary was
not typically authorized to sell property.
 15

- **Judgment:** The court held that the buyer should have been
suspicious and inquired about the secretary’s authority.

3. **Forgery**

The Doctrine of Indoor Management does not apply to acts that are outright
forgeries. A company cannot be held liable for a forged document purportedly
executed on its behalf.

- **Case: Ruben v. Great Fingall Consolidated (1906) AC 439**

- **Facts:** The secretary of a company forged a certificate of shares and issued
it to the plaintiff.
- **Judgment:** The court held that the company was not liable because the
document was forged.

4. **Acts Outside Apparent Authority**

If the act of the officer or agent of the company is beyond their apparent
authority, the company is not bound by such acts.

- **Case: Kreditbank Cassel v. Schenkers Ltd. (1927) 1 KB 826**

- **Facts:** An employee of the company fraudulently obtained money by
exceeding his authority.
- **Judgment:** The court held that the company was not liable for acts beyond
the apparent authority of the employee.

5. **Ultra Vires Acts**

Acts that are ultra vires (beyond the powers) of the company as defined by
its memorandum of association are not protected by the Doctrine of Indoor
Management.
 16

- **Section 245 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Deals with actions against
the company and its directors for ultra vires acts.
- **Case: Lakshmi Ratan Cotton Mills Co. Ltd. v. J.K. Jute Mills Co. Ltd. (1957)
AIR All 311** - **Facts:** A managing director of a company took a loan,
claiming it was authorized by the company’s articles, which was not the case.
- **Judgment:** The court held that the act was ultra vires the company’s
articles and not binding on the company.
### Doctrine of Constructive Notice

The Doctrine of Constructive Notice is a principle in company law which

presumes that any person dealing with a company has knowledge of the
contents of the company's public documents, such as its memorandum of
association and articles of association. This principle is based on the premise
that these documents are publicly accessible, and thus, anyone entering into a
contract with the company is deemed to have read and understood them.

### Legal Basis in Indian Company Law

While the Doctrine of Constructive Notice is not explicitly codified in the

Companies Act, 2013, it is an established principle derived from judicial
precedents and the requirement for companies to file certain documents with
the Registrar of Companies (ROC), making them publicly accessible.

#### Key Provisions Related to the Doctrine

- **Section 399 of the Companies Act, 2013:** This section provides for the
inspection, production, and evidence of documents kept by the Registrar. It
states that the documents kept by the Registrar are open to public inspection
and anyone can obtain copies. - **Section 7 of the Companies Act, 2013:** It
requires the filing of the memorandum and articles of association with the
Registrar during the incorporation of the company.

### Key Cases Illustrating the Doctrine of Constructive Notice

 17

1. **Oakbank Oil Co. v. Crum (1882) 8 App Cas 65**

- **Facts:** A company’s articles of association restricted the directors'

authority to borrow money beyond a certain limit without the sanction of
a general meeting. The directors borrowed money in excess of this limit
without the required approval. - **Judgment:** The House of Lords held
that the lender was deemed to have constructive notice of this restriction
as it was clearly stipulated in the articles of association. Consequently, the
lender could not enforce the repayment beyond the authorized limit.

2. **Kotla Venkataswamy v. Chinta Ramamurthy (AIR 1934 Mad 579)**

- **Facts:** A company executed a mortgage deed which was not in

compliance with the company's articles of association. The articles required
such deeds to be signed by at least two directors and the secretary, but in this
case, it was signed by only one director and the secretary.
- **Judgment:** The court held that the mortgagee (the lender) was
deemed to have constructive notice of the requirement as stipulated in the
articles. Therefore, the mortgage was not binding on the company.

3. **Guinness Plc v. Saunders (1990) 2 AC 663**

- **Facts:** This case involved a payment made to a director that was not
in accordance with the articles of association of the company.
- **Judgment:** The court reaffirmed that parties dealing with a company
are presumed to know the contents of the company's public documents.
Hence, any payment or transaction not compliant with these documents would
not be enforceable against the company.

### Implications of the Doctrine

1. **Assumed Knowledge of Public Documents:**

 18

- Anyone dealing with a company is presumed to have knowledge of the

contents of the company's memorandum and articles of association. This
means they cannot claim ignorance of any provisions or restrictions contained
therein.

2. **Protection of the Company:**

- The doctrine protects the company from unauthorized acts by its agents or
representatives. If a transaction or contract violates the company's articles, the
company is not bound by it, as third parties are expected to be aware of these
restrictions.

### Exceptions to the Doctrine

1. **Indoor Management Rule:**

- The Doctrine of Indoor Management, also known as the Turquand Rule, serves
as an exception to the Doctrine of Constructive Notice. While the latter
presumes that outsiders know the external documents of the company, the
former protects outsiders by allowing them to assume that the company's
internal procedures have been duly followed.
- **Case: Royal British Bank v. Turquand (1856) 6 E&B 327**
- **Facts:** A company issued a bond signed by two directors, although the
articles required a resolution from the general meeting, which was not passed.
- **Judgment:** The court held that the third party dealing with the company
could assume that the internal requirements were fulfilled.

2. **Forged Documents:**
- Constructive notice does not apply to forged documents. A company
cannot be held liable for documents that are not genuine, even if they
appear to be in order. - **Case: Ruben v. Great Fingall Consolidated
(1906) AC 439** - **Facts:** A company secretary forged share
certificates.
 19

- **Judgment:** The court held that the company was not liable
because the documents were forged and no amount of constructive notice
could validate a forgery.

### Definition of Debentures

In the context of company law, debentures are a type of debt instrument that
companies issue to raise funds. A debenture is a written instrument
acknowledging a debt, usually under the company’s seal, and typically
providing for the payment of interest and the repayment of principal at a future
date. Unlike shares, debentures do not confer any ownership rights in the
company; rather, they represent a loan made to the company.

### Legal Basis in Indian Company Law

Debentures are governed by various provisions in the Companies Act, 2013,

which provides the legal framework for their issuance, regulation, and
redemption.

#### Relevant Sections

- **Section 2(30) of the Companies Act, 2013:** Defines a debenture as

including debenture stock, bonds, or any other instrument of a company
evidencing a debt, whether constituting a charge on the assets of the company
or not.
- **Section 71 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Governs the issuance of
debentures by companies.
- **Section 2(16) of the Companies Act, 2013:** Defines “charge” as an
interest or lien created on the property or assets of a company or any of its
undertakings or both as security and includes a mortgage.
 20

- **Section 77 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Requires companies to

register charges created on their property or assets to secure debentures.

### Essential Features of Debentures

1. **Written Acknowledgment of Debt:**

- A debenture is a written instrument that acknowledges a debt. It specifies
the terms and conditions under which the company agrees to repay the
principal amount and interest. - **Section 2(30) of the Companies Act,
2013:** Includes debenture stock, bonds, or any other instrument evidencing
a debt.

2. **Interest Payment:**
- Debentures carry a fixed rate of interest, which is payable periodically
(e.g., semiannually or annually). Interest is payable irrespective of the
company's profitability. - **Case: **Commissioner of Income Tax v.
Standard Vacuum Oil Co. (1966) 59 ITR 685 (SC)**
- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court of India held that interest on
debentures is deductible as an expenditure.

3. **Repayment:**
- Debentures provide for the repayment of the principal amount on a
specified date, which can be at maturity or through periodic installments.
- **Section 71(1) of the Companies Act, 2013:** Allows companies to issue
debentures with an option to convert such debentures into shares, either
wholly or partly, at the time of redemption.
4. **No Ownership Rights:**
- Debenture holders do not have ownership rights or voting rights in the
company. They are creditors of the company, not shareholders.
- **Case: **Yenidje Tobacco Co. Ltd. v. Financial Times Ltd. (1916) 2 Ch 426**
- **Judgment:** The court held that debenture holders are not entitled to
participate in the management of the company as they are creditors and not
owners.
 21

5. **Security:**
- Debentures can be secured or unsecured. Secured debentures are backed
by a charge on the company’s assets, providing security to the debenture
holders in case of default. - **Section 71(3) of the Companies Act, 2013:**
Mandates that secured debentures must be secured by the creation of a charge
on the properties or assets of the company.

6. **Transferability:**
- Debentures are generally transferable, and the transfer process is governed by
the terms and conditions of the debenture and the company's articles of
association.
- **Case: **Borland’s Trustee v. Steel Bros & Co Ltd. (1901) 1 Ch 279**
- **Judgment:** The court held that debenture holders are free to transfer their
debentures unless restricted by the terms of the debenture.

7. **Convertible and Non-Convertible:**

- Debentures can be classified as convertible or non-convertible. Convertible
debentures can be converted into equity shares of the company at a specified
future date or upon fulfilling certain conditions.
- **Section 71(1) of the Companies Act, 2013:** Provides for the issuance
of debentures with an option to convert them into shares.

1. **Re Hindustan Development Corporation Ltd (1966) 36 Comp Cas 461

(Cal)** - **Facts:** The company issued debentures secured by a charge
on its property. The question was about the priority of claims.
- **Judgment:** The Calcutta High Court held that secured debenture
holders have a priority claim over the company's assets compared to
unsecured creditors.

2. **Laxman Bharmaji v. Emperor (1935) 5 Comp Cas 39 (Bom)**

- **Facts:** This case dealt with the issuance of debentures and compliance
with the legal provisions.
 22

- **Judgment:** The Bombay High Court emphasized the need for

adherence to statutory requirements when issuing debentures to protect the
interests of investors.

3. **I.C.D.S. Ltd. v. Smithaben H. Patel (1999) 96 Comp Cas 417 (SC)**

- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court held that debenture holders must
adhere to the terms of the debenture agreement, including the maturity date,
unless the company defaults on its obligations.

### General Features of Allotment of Shares

Allotment of shares refers to the process by which a company allocates its

shares to applicants. This process is crucial as it marks the moment when the
contractual relationship between the company and the shareholder begins.
The process is regulated by the Companies Act, 2013, to ensure transparency,
fairness, and legal compliance.

#### Relevant Sections in Indian Company Law

- **Section 39 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Deals with the allotment of

securities by a company.
- **Section 42 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Pertains to private placement.
- **Section 62 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Covers the further issue of share
capital.

#### Key Features of Share Allotment

1. **Application for Shares:**

- Individuals or entities interested in acquiring shares must apply to the
company. The application is typically made in response to a prospectus issued
by the company (for public issues) or through a private placement offer letter.

2. **Acceptance and Allotment:**

 23

- The company, upon receiving applications, reviews them and decides on the
allotment. The allotment is done in accordance with the terms specified in the
prospectus or offer document. Allotment becomes legally binding once the
company accepts the application and allots the shares.

3. **Return of Allotment:**
- Once the shares are allotted, the company must file a return of allotment
with the Registrar of Companies (ROC) within 30 days. This return includes
details of the allotment such as the number of shares allotted, the nominal
value, the names of the allottees, and the amount paid.

4. **Minimum Subscription:**
- According to Section 39(1), a company cannot proceed with the allotment
unless the minimum subscription (the minimum amount which, in the opinion
of the directors, must be raised by the issue) is received. If the minimum
subscription is not received within 30 days from the date of issue of the
prospectus, the amount received must be refunded.

5. **Allotment Letters:**
- The company sends allotment letters to the applicants whose applications
have been accepted, confirming the number of shares allotted.

### Restrictions on Allotment

Several restrictions and conditions must be adhered to during the allotment
process to ensure compliance with the law and protect investors' interests.

#### Relevant Sections:

- **Section 39 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Contains provisions
regarding the minimum subscription and the refund of application money if
 24

the minimum subscription is not met. - **Section 42 of the Companies Act,

2013:** Details the process and conditions for private placements.
- **Section 62 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Regulates the issue of further
share capital. - **Section 26 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Prescribes
matters to be stated in the prospectus.

#### Key Restrictions

1. **Minimum Subscription:**
- As per Section 39(1), no shares shall be allotted unless the minimum
subscription amount has been received within the stipulated period. If not, all
money received must be returned within 15 days after the closure of the issue,
and any delay beyond this period will attract interest.

2. **Return of Allotment:**
- Section 39(4) mandates that the return of allotment must be filed with the
ROC within 30 days of the allotment. Failure to file the return attracts penalties.

3. **Private Placement Restrictions:**

- Section 42 imposes stringent conditions on private placements, including the
issuance of an offer letter, filing of the offer letter with the ROC, maintaining
records of the offer, and ensuring that the offer is not made to more than 200
persons in a financial year.
- **Case: Sahara India Real Estate Corporation Ltd. v. SEBI (2013) 1 SCC 1**
- **Judgment:** The Supreme Court held that the issuance of debentures to
more than 50 persons amounted to a public issue, thus violating the provisions
of Section 42 and the SEBI guidelines.

4. **Public Issue Restrictions:**

- Section 26 outlines the requirement for a company issuing shares to the
public to provide comprehensive disclosures in the prospectus to ensure
transparency and protect investors. - **Case: SEBI v. Akshya Infrastructure
Pvt. Ltd. (2014) 51 taxmann.com 389 (Bom)** - **Judgment:** The Bombay
 25

High Court emphasized the importance of compliance with the disclosure

requirements under Section 26 for public issues.

5. **Prohibition of Allotment in Contravention:**

- Section 39(3) states that any allotment made in contravention of the
provisions of Section 39 will be void. This includes allotments made without
receiving the minimum subscription or failing to refund the application money
within the prescribed time.

### Memorandum of Association: Content and Clauses

The Memorandum of Association (MoA) is a fundamental document required

for the incorporation of a company in India. It defines the constitution of the
company and is essential for its legal recognition. The Companies Act, 2013,
provides detailed guidelines on the content and clauses of the MoA.

#### Relevant Sections in Indian Company Law

- **Section 4 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Specifies the requirements for the
memorandum of association.
- **Table A to E in Schedule I:** Provides the model forms for the MoA for
different types of companies.

### Content and Clauses of the Memorandum of Association

The MoA contains several essential clauses, each serving a specific purpose.
These clauses include the Name Clause, Registered Office Clause, Objects
Clause, Liability Clause, Capital Clause, and Association Clause.

#### 1. **Name Clause**

- **Section 4(1)(a) of the Companies Act, 2013:**

- This clause states the name of the company. The name must be unique and not
identical or similar to an existing company’s name.
 26

- For
public companies, the name should end with "Limited," and for private
companies, it should end with "Private Limited."

#### 2. **Registered Office Clause**

- **Section 4(1)(b) of the Companies Act, 2013:**

- This clause specifies the state in which the registered office of the company will
be situated.
- The registered office is the official address of the company where all
communications and notices are sent.

#### 3. **Objects Clause**

- **Section 4(1)(c) of the Companies Act, 2013:**

- This clause defines the scope of activities the company intends to undertake.
- It is divided into two parts:
1. **Main Objects:** The primary objectives for which the company is formed.
2. **Matters Which Are Necessary for Furtherance of the Main Objects:**
Ancillary activities that support the main objects.

#### 4. **Liability Clause**

- **Section 4(1)(d) of the Companies Act, 2013:**

- This clause specifies the liability of the members of the company.
- For companies limited by shares, the liability of members is limited to the
amount unpaid on their shares.
- For companies limited by guarantee, the liability is limited to the amount each
member undertakes to contribute to the company’s assets in the event of its
winding up.

#### 5. **Capital Clause**

- **Section 4(1)(e) of the Companies Act, 2013:**

 27

- This clause states the amount of capital with which the company proposes to
be registered (authorized capital).
- It also specifies the division of this capital into shares of a fixed amount.

#### 6. **Association Clause**

- **Section 4(1)(f) of the Companies Act, 2013:**

- This clause states the desire of the subscribers to form a company and agree
to take shares in the company.
- It is accompanied by the names, addresses, and descriptions of the subscribers
(minimum seven for a public company, two for a private company, and one for
a One Person Company).

### Additional Provisions

- **Subscribers’ Details:**
- The MoA must be signed by the subscribers in the presence of at least one
witness who attests the signatures.
- Each subscriber must also write the number of shares he or she agrees to take
in the company.

- **Alteration of Memorandum:**
- **Section 13 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Provides the procedure for
altering the memorandum of association. Any alteration must be approved by
a special resolution in a general meeting and, in certain cases, with the
approval of the Central Government or other regulatory bodies.

### Key Points for Compliance

1. **Unique Name:** The proposed name of the company should not be
identical or resemble the name of any existing company.
2. **Clear Objectives:** The objects clause should clearly outline the main
activities and ancillary activities of the company.
 28

3. **Registered Office Address:** Ensure the specified state in the registered

office clause aligns with the actual registered office address post-
incorporation.
4. **Subscriber Information:** Ensure accurate and complete details of the
subscribers and their commitment to subscribe to the shares.
### Annual General Meeting (AGM) of a Company

An Annual General Meeting (AGM) is a mandatory yearly gathering of a

company's shareholders. During the AGM, the company’s directors present an
annual report containing information for shareholders about the company's
performance and strategy. This meeting is crucial for maintaining transparency
and allowing shareholders to exercise their rights regarding corporate
governance.

### Relevant Sections in Indian Law

The Companies Act, 2013, governs the requirements and procedures for
conducting AGMs. Key sections include:

- **Section 96:** Specifies the requirement for holding an AGM.

- **Section 97:** Provides for calling an AGM in case of default.
- **Section 129:** Requires the presentation of financial statements at the
AGM.
- **Section 134:** Concerns the approval of the Board’s report at the AGM. -
**Section 136:** Relates to the right of members to copies of audited financial
statements.

### Importance of the AGM

1. **Transparency and Accountability:**

- The AGM ensures that the management of the company remains
accountable to its shareholders. Directors present the company's performance,
financial health, and future strategy, promoting transparency.
 29

2. **Approval of Financial Statements:**

- As per **Section 129**, the financial statements, including the balance
sheet, profit and loss account, and auditor’s report, are laid before the
shareholders for their approval.

3. **Declaration of Dividends:**
- The AGM is the forum where shareholders approve the dividend proposed
by the board of directors.

4. **Election of Directors:**
- Shareholders elect or re-elect directors to the board. Any new appointments
or retirements by rotation are confirmed here.

5. **Appointment and Remuneration of Auditors:**

- According to **Section 139**, the appointment of auditors is discussed and
approved by the shareholders.

6. **Review of Corporate Governance:**

- Shareholders discuss corporate governance issues and raise any concerns
about management practices, ensuring that the company adheres to good
governance standards.

7. **Other Business:**
- The AGM provides a platform for discussing other significant matters like
alteration of the company's capital structure, approval of related party
transactions, and any changes in the company’s memorandum or articles of
association.

### Procedures and Requirements

1. **Notice of the Meeting:**

 30

- **Section 101:** Requires that a 21-day clear notice be given to all

members, directors, and auditors, specifying the date, time, venue, and agenda
of the meeting.

2. **Quorum:**
- **Section 103:** Specifies the quorum necessary for the AGM. For a private
company, two members personally present, and for a public company, five
members personally present, constitute a quorum.

3. **Chairman of the Meeting:**

- Usually, the chairman of the board presides over the AGM. If he is absent,
the members present can elect one of themselves to chair the meeting.

4. **Minutes of the Meeting:**

- **Section 118:** Requires that minutes of the AGM be prepared and signed
by the chairman, ensuring that a written record of the proceedings and
decisions made during the meeting is maintained.

### Legal Consequences of Not Holding an AGM

1. **Penalties:**
- If a company fails to hold an AGM, the company and its officers in default
may be subject to penalties under **Section 99**.

2. **Intervention by Tribunal:**
- **Section 97** empowers the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) to call
or direct the calling of an AGM if the company fails to do so.

### Case Laws

1. **In Re: El Sombrero Ltd. (1958) 1 Ch. 900**

- This case highlighted the importance of holding AGMs and that failure to
hold an AGM can result in legal consequences and intervention by the court.
 31

2. **Narayana Murthy v. Indo Swiss Time Ltd. (1975) 45 Comp Cas 315 (P&H)**
- The Punjab and Haryana High Court emphasized the obligation of the
company to hold an AGM and the rights of shareholders to demand one.

### Directors: Definition and Position in a Company

### Definition of Directors

Directors are individuals appointed or elected to the board of a company to

manage its affairs and make key decisions. They act as agents, trustees, and
sometimes officers of the company, providing strategic direction and ensuring
that the company complies with legal and regulatory requirements. The
Companies Act, 2013, outlines the duties, roles, and responsibilities of
directors.

### Position of Directors in a Company

Directors hold a multifaceted position in a company, encompassing roles as

agents, trustees, and officers:

1. **Directors as Agents:**
- Directors act on behalf of the company, entering into contracts and making
decisions that bind the company. Their actions are considered actions of the
company itself.
- **Case Reference: Ferguson v. Wilson (1866) LR 2 Ch App 77**
- The court held that directors are agents of the company, and the company, as
principal, is liable for their actions within the scope of their authority.

2. **Directors as Trustees:**
 32

- Directors are considered trustees of the company’s assets and property. They
must act in the best interest of the company and its shareholders, avoiding
conflicts of interest.
- **Case Reference: Percival v. Wright (1902) 2 Ch 421**
- The court held that directors, as trustees, owe fiduciary duties to the company
and must act in its best interests.

3. **Directors as Officers:**
- Directors are also officers of the company, responsible for managing day-to-
day operations and implementing policies and decisions made by the board.
- **Section 2(59):** Defines an officer to include any director or manager of the
company.

### Roles and Responsibilities of Directors

1. **Strategic Management:**
- Directors are responsible for setting the company’s strategic goals and
ensuring that it pursues these goals efficiently and effectively.

2. **Corporate Governance:**
- Directors ensure that the company adheres to good corporate governance
practices, maintaining transparency and accountability in its operations.

3. **Fiduciary Duties:**
- As fiduciaries, directors must act in the best interests of the company,
avoiding conflicts of interest and self-dealing.
- **Section 166:** Enumerates the duties of directors, including acting in
good faith, promoting the company’s objectives, and exercising due and
reasonable care.

4. **Statutory Compliance:**
 33

- Directors must ensure that the company complies with all applicable laws
and regulations, including those related to financial reporting, shareholder
meetings, and regulatory filings.

5. **Risk Management:**
- Directors are responsible for identifying and managing risks that the
company faces, ensuring that appropriate risk management frameworks are in
place.

### Types of Directors

1. **Executive Directors:**
- These directors are involved in the day-to-day management of the company
and hold specific executive positions, such as CEO or CFO.

2. **Non-Executive Directors:**
- These directors do not engage in the daily operations but provide oversight
and guidance to the executive management.

3. **Independent Directors:**
- Appointed to provide an unbiased perspective, independent directors do
not have any material relationship with the company that could affect their
independence.
- **Section 149(4):** Requires certain classes of companies to have a
minimum number of independent directors.

4. **Nominee Directors:**
- These directors are appointed by specific stakeholders, such as financial
institutions or investors, to represent their interests on the board.

### Powers of Directors

 34

1. **Management of Business:**
- Directors are responsible for the overall management and administration
of the company. They make decisions on day-to-day operations and strategic
planning.
- **Section 179(1):** States that the board of directors shall exercise all
such powers, and do all such acts and things, as the company is authorized to
exercise and do, subject to the provisions of the Companies Act, or the
memorandum or articles of the company.

2. **Power to Make Investments:**

- The board has the authority to invest the company’s funds in various
securities, properties, and ventures.
- **Section 179(3)(e):** Specifically provides the power to invest the funds
of the company.

3. **Power to Borrow Money:**

- Directors can borrow money on behalf of the company and create security on
the company’s assets.
- **Section 179(3)(d):** Allows the board to borrow monies.
- **Section 180(1)(c):** Requires shareholders' approval if the borrowing
exceeds the aggregate of the company’s paid-up share capital, free reserves,
and securities premium.

4. **Power to Approve Financial Statements:**

- Directors are responsible for the preparation and approval of the financial
statements before they are presented to the shareholders.
- **Section 134:** Requires the board to approve and sign the financial
statements.

5. **Power to Appoint Key Managerial Personnel (KMP):**

- The board can appoint the company’s key managerial personnel, including
the CEO, CFO, Company Secretary, and other executive officers.
 35

- **Section 196:** Provides the power to appoint a managing director,

whole-time director, or manager.

6. **Power to Issue Shares:**

- Directors can issue shares of the company, subject to the approval of
shareholders and compliance with the Companies Act and SEBI regulations.
- **Section 62:** Deals with the issue of shares and the rights issue.

7. **Power to Call General Meetings:**

- The board has the authority to call for general meetings of the
shareholders, including the Annual General Meeting (AGM) and
Extraordinary General Meetings (EGMs). - **Section 100:** Grants the
board the power to convene EGMs.

### Special Powers Requiring Shareholder Approval

1. **Selling, Leasing, or Otherwise Disposing of Company Property:**

- Directors need the consent of the shareholders to sell, lease, or otherwise
dispose of the whole or substantially the whole of the company’s undertaking.
- **Section 180(1)(a):** Requires special resolution by the shareholders.

### Case Laws

1. **Automatic Self-Cleansing Filter Syndicate Co. Ltd. v. Cuninghame (1906) 2 Ch

34** - This case established that the board of directors has the power to
manage the company, and shareholders cannot interfere in the management
unless they alter the board through a valid resolution.

2. **HowardSmith Ltd. v. Ampol Petroleum Ltd. (1974) AC 821**

- The case emphasized that directors must exercise their powers for proper
purposes and in the best interests of the company.
### Winding Up of a Company
 36

**Winding up** of a company refers to the process of closing or dissolving a

company, during which its assets are sold off, liabilities settled, and any
remaining assets are distributed among the shareholders. This process leads to
the formal cessation of the company's existence. Winding up can be initiated
either by a court (compulsory winding up) or voluntarily by the company's
members or creditors.

### Voluntary Winding Up

Voluntary winding up is initiated by the company itself, without court

intervention, and can be categorized into two types:

1. **Members' Voluntary Winding Up**

2. **Creditors' Voluntary Winding Up**

#### Relevant Sections in Indian Company Law

- **Section 304 to 323 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Deal with the procedures
and circumstances for voluntary winding up.

### Circumstances for Voluntary Winding Up

1. **Members' Voluntary Winding Up:**

- **Section 304(a):** When the company passes a special resolution to wind

up voluntarily.
- **Section 304(b):** When the company in general meeting resolves to
wind up voluntarily as a result of expiry of the period of its duration fixed by its
articles or on the occurrence of any event in respect of which the articles
provide that the company is to be dissolved.

2. **Creditors' Voluntary Winding Up:**

 37

- Occurs when the company is unable to pay its debts and the winding up is
initiated by the creditors. This typically follows a resolution passed by the
members for winding up, with a subsequent meeting of creditors where the
decision is confirmed.

### Procedure for Voluntary Winding Up

1. **Resolution:**
- A special resolution must be passed in a general meeting. Notice of this
resolution must be filed with the Registrar of Companies (ROC).

2. **Declaration of Solvency (for Members' Voluntary Winding Up):**

- **Section 305:** The directors must make a declaration of solvency stating
that the company will be able to pay its debts in full within a specified period
not exceeding one year from the commencement of winding up. This
declaration must be made within five weeks before the resolution is passed.

3. **Appointment of Liquidator:**
- **Section 310:** In a members' voluntary winding up, the company
appoints one or more liquidators in the general meeting to oversee the
winding-up process.
- **Section 313:** In a creditors' voluntary winding up, the creditors and
the company may nominate different persons to be the liquidator, but the
creditors' nominee prevails if there is a disagreement.

4. **Meeting of Creditors (for Creditors' Voluntary Winding Up):**

- **Section 306:** The company must call a meeting of creditors on the same
day or the next day after passing the resolution for winding up.

5. **Notice to Registrar:**
- Notice of the resolution for winding up must be given to the ROC within 10
days of passing the resolution.
 38

6. **Final Meeting and Dissolution:**

- **Section 318:** Once the affairs of the company are fully wound up, the
liquidator calls a final general meeting and presents an account of the winding
up. After this, the company is formally dissolved.

### Case Law

**Kesoram Industries and Cotton Mills Ltd. v. CWT (1966) 59 ITR 767 (SC)**

In this case, the Supreme Court of India provided clarity on the concept of
voluntary winding up. The court observed that a company may be voluntarily
wound up by the members or creditors, and outlined the procedural
requirements, emphasizing the need for a special resolution and compliance
with statutory provisions.

### Conclusion

Voluntary winding up is a process initiated by a company to close its affairs in

an orderly manner. It involves the liquidation of assets, settlement of liabilities,
and distribution of any remaining assets to shareholders. The Companies Act,
2013, provides a structured framework for voluntary winding up, ensuring that
the process is conducted transparently and fairly. Understanding the
circumstances and procedures for voluntary winding up is essential for
companies considering dissolution and for stakeholders affected by such
decisions.

### Winding Up of a Company by Tribunal

**Winding up** of a company refers to the legal process through which a

company’s existence is brought to an end. During this process, the company's
 39

assets are liquidated to pay off its liabilities, and any remaining assets are
distributed to the shareholders. After the winding-up process, the company
ceases to exist as a legal entity.

### Circumstances for Winding Up by Tribunal

The Companies Act, 2013, outlines specific circumstances under which a

company can be wound up by the Tribunal (National Company Law Tribunal or
NCLT). These circumstances are specified in **Section 271** of the Companies
Act, 2013.

#### Relevant Sections in Indian Company Law

- **Section 271 of the Companies Act, 2013:** Specifies the circumstances

under which a company may be wound up by the Tribunal.
- **Section 272:** Deals with the petition for winding up.
- **Section 273 to 288:** Detail the procedural aspects of winding up by the
Tribunal.

### Circumstances for Winding Up by Tribunal

According to **Section 271**, a company may be wound up by the Tribunal

under the following circumstances:

1. **Inability to Pay Debts:**

- If the company is unable to pay its debts, it may be wound up. The inability
to pay debts is a critical factor for winding up by the Tribunal.
- **Section 271(1)(a):** A company is deemed unable to pay its debts if a
creditor to whom the company owes more than one lakh rupees has demanded
payment and the company has neglected to pay the debt within three weeks.

2. **Resolution Passed by the Company:**

 40

- If the company has, by special resolution, resolved that the company be

wound up by the Tribunal.
- **Section 271(1)(b):** The company may voluntarily resolve to wind up by
passing a special resolution.

3. **Acting Against the Interests of Sovereignty and Integrity of India:**

- If the company has acted against the interests of the sovereignty and
integrity of India, the security of the state, friendly relations with foreign states,
public order, decency, or morality.
- **Section 271(1)(c):** This clause ensures that companies engaged in
activities detrimental to national interest can be wound up.

4. **Default in Filing Financial Statements or Annual Returns:**

- If the company has made a default in filing its financial statements or
annual returns with the Registrar for five consecutive financial years.
- **Section 271(1)(d):** Non-compliance with statutory filing requirements
can lead to winding up.

5. **Just and Equitable Ground:**

- If the Tribunal is of the opinion that it is just and equitable that the
company should be wound up.
- **Section 271(1)(e):** This is a broad and flexible ground allowing the
Tribunal to wind up a company when it is fair and just to do so.

6. **Fraudulent Conduct:**
- If the affairs of the company have been conducted in a fraudulent manner
or the company was formed for fraudulent and unlawful purposes.
- **Section 271(1)(f):** Ensures that companies engaging in fraud can be
wound up to protect public interest and creditors.

### Procedure for Winding Up by Tribunal

1. **Petition for Winding Up:** (- **Section 272:** )

 41

2. **Hearing of Petition:**

3. **Winding Up Order:**

4. **Appointment of Liquidator:**

5. **Report by Liquidator:**
- The liquidator submits a report to the Tribunal on the company’s affairs and
the causes of its failure.

6. **Final Order:**
- The Tribunal passes a final order for the dissolution of the company after
the affairs of the company have been fully wound up.

### Case Law:

**Madhusudan Gordhandas & Co. v. Madhu Woollen Industries Pvt. Ltd. (1972)
42 Comp Cas 125 (SC)**

In this landmark case, the Supreme Court of India dealt with the circumstances
under which a company can be wound up for inability to pay its debts. The
court held that a presumption of inability to pay debts arises if a company
neglects a creditor’s demand for payment, and the burden shifts to the
company to prove solvency. This case reinforced the legal principle that a
creditor’s winding-up petition must be supported by evidence of the
company’s financial instability.
Investigation of Company Affairs: Sections 201-229 of the Companies
Act

The Companies Act, 2013, includes detailed provisions for the investigation of
company affairs to ensure transparency, accountability, and protection of
stakeholders' interests. Sections 201 to 229 outline the procedures, powers,
 42

and consequences related to the investigation of a company's operations and

conduct.

#### Section 210: Investigation into Affairs of Company

- **Provision:** The Central Government may order an investigation into the

affairs of a company:
- On the receipt of a report from the Registrar or inspector under section 208. -
On the passing of a special resolution by a company that its affairs ought to be
investigated.
- In public interest.
- **Process:** The Central Government appoints inspectors to carry out the
investigation.

#### Section 211: Establishment of Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO)

- **Provision:** Establishes the Serious Fraud Investigation Office (SFIO) to

investigate frauds relating to a company.
- **Authority:** The SFIO is granted extensive powers to investigate serious
frauds and can take over investigations from other agencies.

#### Section 212: Investigation by SFIO

- **Provision:** The Central Government may assign the investigation of a

company's affairs to the SFIO:
- On its own initiative.
- On request from any department of the Central Government or a State
Government.
- On a court or Tribunal's direction.
- **Powers:** SFIO has the authority to investigate under this section and take
all actions as provided under the Act.

#### Section 213: Investigation into Company's Affairs in Other Cases

 43

- **Provision:** The Tribunal may order an investigation into a company's

affairs: - On application by not less than 100 members or members holding at
least one-tenth of the total voting power.

#### Section 214: Security for Payment of Costs and Expenses of Investigation

- **Provision:** Requires applicants requesting an investigation to provide

security for payment of costs and expenses of the investigation.

#### Section 216: Investigation of Ownership of Company

- **Provision:** Allows the Central Government to investigate and report on

matters relating to the company’s membership or ownership if there is a
reason to believe that certain conditions are not being met.

#### Section 217: Procedure, Powers, etc., of Inspectors

- **Provision:** Specifies the powers and procedures for inspectors appointed

under Sections 210, 212, and 213. Inspectors have the authority to:
- Examine on oath any officer or other individual connected with the company.
- Require production of documents and evidence.
- Enter and search premises and seize documents with authorization.

#### Section 218: Protection of Employees During Investigation

- **Provision:** Protects employees who provide information during an

investigation from being discharged or discriminated against by the company.

#### Section 219: Powers of Inspector to Conduct Investigation into Affairs of

Related Companies
 44

- **Provision:**Empowers inspectors to investigate the affairs of any other

related company if they believe the affairs of the first company are
interconnected.

#### Section 220: Seizure of Documents by Inspector

- **Provision:** Allows inspectors to seize documents that are relevant to the

investigation after obtaining permission from the Magistrate.

### Case Law Examples

#### Rohtas Industries Ltd. v. S.D. Agarwal (1969) 39 Comp Cas 781 (SC)

- **Facts:** This case involved the investigation into the affairs of Rohtas
Industries. The Supreme Court of India provided significant interpretations
regarding the extent and scope of investigations under the Companies Act.
- **Ruling:** The court upheld the powers of the Central Government to order
investigations in the interest of transparency and accountability.

#### N. Narayanan v. Adjudicating Officer, SEBI (2013) 12 SCC 152

- **Facts:** This case dealt with issues related to the investigation of company
affairs by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).
- **Ruling:** The Supreme Court emphasized the importance of thorough
investigations to protect investors' interests and maintain market integrity.
KINDS OF COMPANY

### 1. **Classification Based on Incorporation**

#### (a) **Statutory Companies**

These companies are formed by a special Act of Parliament or State Legislature.
Examples include the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and Life Insurance
Corporation of India (LIC).
 45

#### (b) **Registered Companies**

These companies are registered under the Companies Act, 2013 or any
previous company laws.

### 2. **Classification Based on Liability**

#### (a) **Company Limited by Shares** (Section 2(22))

In these companies, the liability of members is limited to the amount unpaid
on their shares. If shares are fully paid, members have no further liability.

#### (b) **Company Limited by Guarantee** (Section 2(21))

Members' liability is limited to the amount they agree to contribute to the
company’s assets in the event of its winding up.

#### (c) **Unlimited Company** (Section 2(92))

There is no limit to the liability of the members. They are liable for the
company's debts and liabilities.

### 3. **Classification Based on Number of Members**

#### (a) **Private Company** (Section 2(68))

A private company restricts the right to transfer its shares, limits the number
of its members to 200, and prohibits any invitation to the public to subscribe
to its shares.

#### (b) **Public Company** (Section 2(71))

A public company is not a private company, has no restriction on the transfer
of shares, and can invite the public to subscribe to its shares. It must have a
minimum of 7 members and no upper limit.

#### (c) **One Person Company (OPC)** (Section 2(62))

 46

An OPC is a company with a single member, designed to encourage individual

entrepreneurs. It enjoys certain exemptions compared to other companies.

### 4. **Classification Based on Control**

#### (a) **Holding Company** (Section 2(46))

A company that controls the composition of the board of directors or holds
more than half of the nominal value of the equity share capital of another
company.

#### (b) **Subsidiary Company** (Section 2(87))

A company in which another company (the holding company) controls the
composition of the board of directors or holds more than half of the nominal
value of its equity share capital.

### 5. **Classification Based on Membership**

#### (a) **Government Company** (Section 2(45))

A company in which not less than 51% of the paid-up share capital is held by
the central government, state government, or partly by one or more state
governments.

#### (b) **Foreign Company** (Section 2(42))

A company incorporated outside India that has a place of business in India.

### 6. **Other Specific Types**

#### (a) **Section 8 Company** (Non-Profit Company) (Section 8)

These companies are formed for promoting commerce, art, science, sports,
education, research, social welfare, religion, charity, protection of
environment, or any such other object, and apply their profits or other income
in promoting these objects.
 47

#### (b) **Dormant Company** (Section 455)

A company formed and registered under this Act for a future project or to hold
an asset or intellectual property and has no significant accounting transaction.

### Case Laws

1. **Salomon v. Salomon & Co. Ltd.** [1897] AC 22

- This landmark case established the principle of a company as a separate
legal entity distinct from its shareholders.

2. **Tata
Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar** [1964] AIR
40 SC - This case emphasized the separate legal identity of a company
and that its property belongs to the company and not to its shareholders.

3. **Ashbury Railway Carriage and Iron Co Ltd v Riche** [1875] LR 7 HL 653

- This case clarified the concept of ultra vires acts, where any act done beyond
the scope of the company's objects as stated in the memorandum is void.

Understanding these classifications is essential for compliance with legal

requirements, governance, and leveraging the benefits provided under
different company structures.

### Commencement of Business under Indian Company Law

The commencement of business is a crucial step for companies incorporated

under the Companies Act, 2013 in India. It marks the point at which a company
can legally start its business operations.

#### Section 10A: Commencement of Business

 48

**Provision:** According to Section 10A of the Companies Act, 2013, a

company having a share capital cannot commence any business or exercise any
borrowing powers unless:

1. **Declaration by Director:** A declaration is filed by a director within 180 days

from the date of incorporation of the company in the form INC-20A. This
declaration must state that every subscriber to the memorandum has paid the
value of the shares agreed to be taken by him on the date of making such
declaration.
2. **Verification of Registered Office:** The company has filed with the Registrar
a
verification of its registered office as provided in sub-section (2) of section 12.

**Non-compliance:** If the company fails to comply with the provisions of this

section, it cannot commence its business or borrow money. Additionally,
penalties may be imposed on the company and its officers in default.

### Importance of Commencement of Business

1. **Legal Requirement:** It is a statutory requirement ensuring that the

company has received its initial capital and has a verified office before starting
operations.
2. **Regulatory Compliance:** It helps in maintaining transparency and
compliance with regulatory frameworks, ensuring that the company has
fulfilled all preliminary requirements.
3. **Protection of Stakeholders:** By confirming the receipt of initial share
capital, it protects the interests of creditors and other stakeholders by ensuring
that the company has a financial base.

2. **Case Law:**
- **Registrar of Companies v. Active Transport Company Pvt. Ltd.:** This case
dealt with the consequences of a company not filing the necessary declaration
for the commencement of business. The court upheld the penalties imposed
 49

for non-compliance, emphasizing the importance of adhering to statutory

requirements.

### Penalties for Non-compliance

- **Company:** A fine which may extend to fifty thousand rupees.
- **Officer in Default:** Each officer who is in default shall be liable to a penalty
which may extend to one thousand rupees for each day during which such
default continues but not exceeding an amount of one lakh rupees.

### Prospectus under Indian Company Law

A prospectus is a critical document in the context of company law, particularly

when a company seeks to raise capital from the public. Under the Companies
Act, 2013, a prospectus is a legal document issued by a company that invites
the public to subscribe to its securities.

#### Section 2(70): Definition of Prospectus

> “Prospectus” means any document described or issued as a prospectus and
includes any notice, circular, advertisement, or other document inviting offers
from the public for the subscription or purchase of any securities of a body
corporate.

#### Section 26: Matters to be Stated in Prospectus

This section outlines the specific information that must be included in a
prospectus: - **Details of the company:** Name, address of its registered
office, and the names and addresses of the company’s directors.
- **Financial information:** Financial statements, auditors’ report, and
information about profits and losses over the past five years.
- **Capital structure:** Information on the company’s capital, including shares
and debentures.
- **Objects of the issue:** The purpose for which the money is being raised.
 50

- **Risk
factors:** A clear description of the risks involved with investing in the
company.
- **Management:** Details about the management of the company.

A prospectus must be dated and signed by all the directors or their authorized
agents. Additionally, a copy must be filed with the Registrar of Companies
before it is issued to the public.

### Case Laws

1. **NewBrunswick & Canada Rly & Land Co. v. Muggeridge (1860) 1 Dr &
Sm 363** - **Facts:** Involved misstatements in the prospectus issued
by a company. - **Ruling:** The court held that those who issue a
prospectus are bound to state everything with strict and scrupulous
accuracy.

2. **Rex v. Kylsant (1932) 1 KB 442**

- **Facts:** The case revolved around a prospectus that failed to disclose
critical financial information.
- **Ruling:** Established the principle that non-disclosure of material facts
in a prospectus could constitute fraud.

3. **Derry v. Peek (1889) 14 App Cas 337**

- **Facts:** Concerned a prospectus that contained misleading information
regarding the company’s rights to use steam-powered trams.
- **Ruling:** The House of Lords ruled that fraudulent misrepresentation
occurs when a false statement is made knowingly or without belief in its truth.

### Share Certificate under Indian Company Law

A share certificate is a formal document issued by a company to its

shareholders, serving as proof of ownership of a specified number of shares in
 51

the company. Under the Companies Act, 2013, the issuance, contents, and
regulations surrounding share certificates are clearly outlined.

#### Definition
A share certificate is a document issued by a company certifying that the
named person is the owner of a specified number of shares in the company.

#### Sections Governing Share Certificates

- **Section 46**: Deals with the certificate of shares.
- **Section 56**: Pertains to the transfer and transmission of securities.
- **Rule 5 of the Companies (Share Capital and Debentures) Rules, 2014**:
Provides specific rules regarding the issue of share certificates.
#### Issuance and Procedure

- **Issuance Timeframe**: According to Section 56(4) of the Companies Act,

2013, a share certificate should be issued:
- Within 2 months from the date of allotment of shares.
- Within 1 month from the date of receipt of instrument of transfer.
- Within 6 months from the date of allotment in the case of any allotment of
debentures.

- **Authority**: The board of directors must authorize the issuance of share

certificates through a resolution.

#### Importance of Share Certificates

1. **Proof of Ownership**: It serves as a legal proof of ownership of shares.
2. **Rights and Liabilities**: The certificate outlines the rights and liabilities of
the shareholder.
3. **Transferability**: It is an essential document for the transfer of shares.

### Legal Cases

1. **Gopal Paper Mills Ltd. v. CIT [1967] 63 ITR 425 (SC)**

 52

- **Facts**: This case involved the issuance of share certificates and the
evidentiary value of such certificates in proving share ownership.
- **Ruling**: The Supreme Court held that the share certificate is prima
facie evidence of the title of the person to the shares mentioned therein.

2. **Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Escorts Ltd. [1986] 59 Comp Cas

548 (SC)** - **Facts**: The case dealt with issues related to the transfer
of shares and the role of share certificates.
- **Ruling**: The Supreme Court emphasized the importance of share
certificates as legal documents evidencing ownership of shares and the
necessity of adhering to proper procedures in their issuance and transfer.
### Floating Charge under Indian Company Law

A floating charge is a security interest over a fund of changing assets (such as

stock-in-trade, receivables, etc.) of a company, which allows the company to
use these assets in the ordinary course of business until the charge crystallizes.
This concept is recognized under Indian law and is an important tool in
corporate finance.

#### Key Characteristics

1. **Nature of Assets**: Unlike a fixed charge, which is tied to specific assets,

a floating charge applies to a pool of assets that are changing in nature, such
as inventory, accounts receivable, and other current assets.
2. **Management Flexibility**: The company retains the ability to use, sell,
or dispose of the assets in the ordinary course of business until the charge
crystallizes.

#### Legal Provisions

- **Section 77 of the Companies Act, 2013**: It mandates the registration

of charges (including floating charges) with the Registrar of Companies
within 30 days of creation. - **Section 100 of the Transfer of Property Act,
 53

1882**: This section covers the general principles of charges on property,

including floating charges.

#### Advantages of Floating Charges

1. **Flexibility**: Companies can continue to use their assets to generate

revenue while still providing security to lenders.
2. **Efficient Use of Assets**: It allows companies to maximize the use of
their current assets, which are essential for day-to-day operations.
3. **Additional Borrowing**: Companies can secure additional financing by
offering a floating charge over their fluctuating assets.

#### Disadvantages of Floating Charges

1. **Uncertainty for Creditors**: Lenders may face uncertainty since the

value of the charged assets can fluctuate, and their priority can be affected by
the creation of fixed charges.
2. **Crystallization Risks**: The charge can suddenly crystallize upon specific
events, potentially disrupting the company’s operations.

### Legal Cases

1. **Illingworth v. Houldsworth [1904] AC 355**
- **Facts**: This is one of the landmark cases that defined the
characteristics of a floating charge.
- **Ruling**: The House of Lords held that a floating charge hovers over a
pool of changing assets until it crystallizes, differentiating it from a fixed charge.

Membership in a company refers to the individuals or entities that own shares

and are thereby part of the company. The Companies Act, 2013, provides
various modes through which a person can become a member of a company.
Here’s an overview of the primary modes of membership:
 54

### Modes of Membership

1. **Subscription to Memorandum of Association (MoA)**

- **Section 2(55)(i)**: The subscribers to the memorandum are deemed to
have agreed to become members of the company and are automatically
entered in the company’s register of members.

2. **Allotment of Shares**
- **Section 42**: A person who is allotted shares in a company becomes a
member upon the entry of their name in the register of members. This can
happen through various means like private placement or public issue.

3. **Transfer of Shares**
- **Section 56**: Membership can be transferred by an existing member
to another person through a share transfer form, duly stamped and signed,
and subsequent entry in the register of members.

4. **Transmission of Shares**
- **Section 56(2)**: Transmission occurs by operation of law, such as in the
case of death, bankruptcy, or lunacy of a shareholder, leading to the legal heir,
executor, or administrator becoming a member.

5. **Acquiring Qualification Shares**

- **Section 270**: For becoming a director, an individual might need to
acquire qualification shares, as specified by the company’s articles, which
results in membership.

6. **Conversion of Debentures or Bonds**

- **Section 71**: Convertible debentures or bonds can be converted into
equity shares, resulting in the holder becoming a member of the company.

7. **By Court Order**

 55

- Membership can also be acquired through court orders in situations such as

amalgamation, merger, or other legal proceedings that result in a transfer of
shares.

### Legal Case Examples

1. **Borland’s Trustee v. Steel Brothers & Co. Ltd. [1901] 1 Ch 279**

- This case established that membership in a company carries with it both rights
and obligations, and these rights are proprietary in nature.

### Who May Be a Member of a Company?

Under the Companies Act, 2013, the membership of a company can be

acquired by various entities. Here’s an overview of who may be a member of a
company:

#### 1. **Individuals**
- **Natural Persons**: Any individual who is competent to enter into a contract
can become a member of a company. This includes adults of sound mind who
are not disqualified under any law.
- **Minors**: Generally, minors cannot enter into contracts, including
becoming members of a company. However, shares can be held in trust for a
minor.

#### 2. **Companies**
- **Corporate Entities**: A company can be a member of another company. This
is common in holding and subsidiary relationships where the holding company
owns shares in the subsidiary.

#### 3. **Partnership Firms**

 56

- **Partnerships**: While a partnership firm cannot be a member in its firm

name, partners in their individual capacities can be members.

#### 4. **Trusts**
- **Trusts**: Trusts can hold shares in a company. The trustees of a trust can be
registered as the members of the company.

#### 5. **Societies and Cooperative Societies**

- **Societies**: Registered societies can become members of a company.

#### 6. **Foreign Nationals and Entities**

- **Foreign Nationals**: Foreign individuals and entities can become members
of a company in India, subject to compliance with Foreign Exchange
Management Act (FEMA) regulations and other relevant laws.

#### Case Laws

1. **Vijay Kumar Sharma v. Bharat Trading Company Ltd.**

- **Facts**: This case involved the transfer of shares and the registration of
the transferee as a member.
- **Ruling**: The court emphasized the right of the transferee to be entered
in the register of members upon proper documentation.

2. **Borland’s Trustee v. Steel Brothers & Co. Ltd. [1901] 1 Ch

279** - **Facts**: The case involved the proprietary rights
of shareholders.
- **Ruling**: It established that a member’s interest in a company is a form
of property and can be bequeathed or transferred.

REGISTER OF MEMBERS (SECTION 88)

 57

1. **Name and Address**: Full name and address of each member. This
includes both individual members and corporate entities if applicable.

2. **Date of Entry**: The date when each member was entered into the
register. This is usually the date when they became a member of the company.

3. **Number of Shares Held**: For each member, the number and class of
shares they hold in the company. This includes details such as the nominal
value of shares and any distinguishing rights attached to those shares.

4. **Date of Cessation**: If a member ceases to be a member of the

company, the date on which this happened should be recorded.

5. **Transfer of Shares**: Any transfers of shares should be recorded,

including details of the transferee.

6. **Other Details**: Any other relevant details related to membership, such

as the type of membership (e.g., ordinary, preference), any restrictions on
transferability of shares, etc.

WHO CAN APPLY FOR WINDING UP

1. **By the Company Itself**: A company can initiate its own winding-up
process voluntarily if it determines that it cannot continue its business due to
financial difficulties or other reasons. This is known as voluntary winding up.

2. **By Creditors**: Creditors of the company, including those to whom the

company owes debts, can apply to the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT)
for the winding up of the company if they have a valid claim and can
demonstrate that the company is unable to pay its debts. This is known as
winding up by the creditors.
 58

3. **By Contributories**: Contributories are the shareholders or members of

the company. They can apply for winding up if they believe it's just and
equitable to do so, such as in cases of oppression or mismanagement.

4. **By Regulatory Authorities**: Regulatory authorities, such as the

Registrar of Companies or the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI),
can also apply for the winding up of a company if they have grounds to believe
that the company is acting against the interests of the public or violating
regulatory provisions.

5. **By Tribunal**: The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) itself has the
authority to initiate winding-up proceedings if it deems necessary in the
interest of justice or public interest.

An Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM) is a meeting of

shareholders or members of a company that is convened for
specific purposes outside of the regular Annual General
Meeting (AGM). Here are some key points about EGMs:

1. **Purpose**: EGMs are typically called to address urgent or significant

matters that cannot wait until the next AGM. These matters might include
important decisions such as amendments to the company's articles of
association, approval of major transactions, changes in share capital,
appointment or removal of directors, or any other business that requires
shareholder approval.

2. **Authority to Convene**: An EGM can be convened by the board of

directors, the managing director, or by shareholders holding a specified
percentage of voting rights as per the company's articles of association or
relevant regulations. In some cases, regulatory authorities may also have the
power to convene an EGM.
 59

3. **Notice**: Shareholders must be given proper notice of an EGM, which

includes details such as the date, time, and location of the meeting, as well as
the agenda items to be discussed. The notice period and requirements for
convening an EGM are typically outlined in the company's articles of
association and relevant legal provisions.

1. **Section 100: Calling of Extraordinary General Meeting (EGM)**:

- This section outlines who can call for an EGM, including the board of
directors, the managing director, or requisitionists representing specified
percentages of voting rights. - It specifies the procedure for requisitionists
to make a request for calling an EGM, including the content of the requisition
and the timeframe within which the meeting must be convened.

2. **Section 101: Notice of Meeting**:

- Section 101 specifies the requirements for giving notice of an EGM to
shareholders, including the minimum period of notice required, which is
typically not less than 21 days. - The notice must include the date, time,
place, and agenda of the meeting, as well as any relevant explanatory
statements or documents related to the agenda items.

3. **Section 102: Statement to be Annexed to Notice**:

- This section requires that a statement specifying the nature of the business
to be transacted at the EGM must be annexed to the notice of the meeting.
- The statement should provide sufficient information to enable
shareholders to understand the implications of the proposed resolutions.

4. **Section 103: Quorum for Meetings**:

- Section 103 outlines the quorum requirements for an EGM, stating that
unless the articles of association specify a higher quorum, the quorum for an
EGM of a public company is five members personally present if it has up to
1,000 members, and 15 members personally present if it has more than 1,000
members.
60