Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Improving Reading Proficiency of G10 Learners Action Research
Improving Reading Proficiency of G10 Learners Action Research
An Action Research
Teaching Internship
April 2023
ABSTRACT
Many teachers encounter students with reading difficulties due to low reading
proficiency. Nowadays, reading problem is still evident due to various reason and factors. In
this study, the researchers examine the reading proficiency of selected grade 10 learners. A
total of 25 students from five sections participated. The students were identified as needing a
targeted intervention.
effective way for providing improvement in reading proficiency of grade 10 students from
Basic Education Curriculum (BEC) in Camarines Sur National High School. Reading
proficiency of not mention curriculums such as Science Technology and Engineering (STE),
Sports and Arts (SPS), SPA, and STVL are not included in this research.
This study focuses on the reading speed, fluency, and comprehension as main
variables in identifying proficiency level of the respondents. These variables are believed to
be important for students to realize the level of their reading proficiency which is necessary
for them to improve. Researchers use pre-test and post-test as data gathering tools and results
were indicated in data analysis. Thus, RRP model and strategies for improvement or
1
ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The completion of this undertaking could not have been possible without the
assistance extended to the researchers. Their contributions are sincerely appreciated and
acknowledged. With these, the researchers would like to express their deepest gratitude to
those people behind the completion of the study, especially to the following individuals:
First and foremost, we would like to thank God for giving us strength each day to
make accomplish our action research and for all the blessings in our life. His love, guidance,
and protection have never failed us. We are deeply grateful for surviving the conduct of
To our whole family who morally, emotionally, and financially supported us for our
To the Dean of the College of Teacher Education, Dr. Onward Ognita, for the
continuous support to research studies growing its purpose among student individuals
To the Area chairpersons: Ma’am Jocelyn Romero, Ma’am Teresita Almoite, and
Ma’am Evelyn Anagao, who assisted us to have sensible action research, thank you for the
To the Camarines Sur National High School Heads for giving us the opportunity to
To our very kind Cooperating Teachers, who tirelessly assisted us with the ideas that
To our respondents who eagerly collaborated with our study. It wouldn't be feasible
2
To all the researchers for their time, effort, and ideas in crafting this study
3
I. CONTENT AND RATIONALE
Reading plays an essential role in students’ success. Reading for various purposes is a
to teaching and learning. It is important to consider the conditions in which the developing
child is necessary to extract and utilize meaning obtained from the text (Clarke, Truelove,
application and integration”. It is the process of making and getting meaning from printed
and ideas.
characters in a story, or learning about the world. Reading fluency is the speed and accuracy
of decoding words. Reading comprehension is the ability to understand what you are reading.
A student is considered a proficient reader when reading fluency and reading comprehension
Achieving the proper balance between reading fluency and reading comprehension is
important. Some students who struggle with learning to read will focus more on the
mechanics of reading (decoding) and miss comprehending what they are reading. Other
students can easily understand what they are reading even though they struggle with
decoding.
National Book WEEK from November 24 to 30, 2023 “The government should prioritize
programs and interventions that would improve Filipino learners’ proficiency in reading” The
4
senator also recalled that even before the COVID-19 pandemic struck, international large-
scale assessments showed that the country’s learners were already struggling to meet the
In the 2018 Program for International Student Assessment (PISA), the Philippines
scored lowest in Reading out of 79 countries that participated. Results of the PISA further
showed that only one out of five Filipino learners aged 15 achieved at least the minimum
Results of the 2019 Southeast Asia Primary Learning Metrics, on the other hand,
showed that only 10 percent of the country’s Grade 5 learners achieved the minimum
“Reading is one of the foundations that we must strengthen in our youth and students. Now
we need to focus more on their reading, especially since the pandemic has worsened the
The students’ experienced difficulties in reading and learning could serve as a basis for a
strategy-based program to be designed for them to have better reading skills. Hence, this
study was conducted to assess the students’ reading profile and perceived challenges in
reading to serve as a basis for schools’ agenda and initiatives for the enrichment of reading
programs.
5
II. REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE AND STUDIES
This chapter comes out with related literature and studies that the other scholars talk
through reading remediation program. Thus, this chapter will present studies, journals, and
RESEARCHERS.
RELATED LITERATURE
According to RAND Reading Study Group, (2014) it has been proven that reading
comprehension is the process of extracting and constructing meaning from print when a
reader interacts with a text for a specific purpose or activity. Furthermore, Perfetti and Hart
(2013) stated that this process boosts word learning by furnishing students with
contextualized uses of new words. Consequently, it requires the readers to have sufficiently
and Spaull (2016), the learners are not given the foundation of reading at an early age, and
The definition of reading fluency, given by Logdon, A. (2014) a Learning Diability Expert, it
is "the ability to read phrases and sentences smoothly and quickly, while understanding them
6
as expressions of complete ideas". Thus, it is the capability of students to read fast and easily
to understand the texts. In order to do that the students must be able to read and comprehend
the words automatically and accurately. According to Wright (2013), Reading fluency is
considered the most important factor to develop students' reading skills. In connection, it does
not only differentiate good readers from poor, but it also indicates the problems concerning to
reading comprehension.
Reading forms is the foundation for learning. It is not inborn or cannot be learned naturally
from parents or others. As Talley (2017) stated that reading is an essential segment of our
day-to-day societal pursuit. With that being said, effective reading approaches need to be
implemented to teach and improve reading proficiency and to instil the culture of reading in
learners. Moreover, Ercikan et al., (2015) tackled that reading proficiency has a strong
positive correlation with mathematics and science abilities. Also, achieving reading
proficiency through independent reading outside the school environment was found to
Krawczyk (2017) stated that to compare the proficiency progress and effort of the student to
Speed reading drawn the interest of professionals, teachers, and students as a type of
skilled reading. According to Carpenter, P. and Just, M. (2019), it is a form of rapid reading
that is reputed to increase reading speed by a factor of three to ten without much, if any, loss
7
in comprehension. Since speed reading has such widespread appeal and potential pedagogical
speed reading from normal reading, as well as the degree to which it lives up to its reputation.
Consequently, the readers can increase their reading speed by sacrificing the amount they
understand from a text; faster speed usually implies lessened comprehension, a trade-off.
In addition, the article entitled “Mind Tools Content Team article”, define speed
reading as a process of rapidly recognizing and absorbing phrases or sentences on a page all
at once, rather than identifying individual words. Thus, we likely feel pressure to get through
Moreover, in a blog named Iris Reading, shares that speed reading is about reading
several words per a specified unit of time. Instead of focusing on individual words, speed
readers do word group reading in phrases, sentences, or even lines. In connection, learning
how to speed read enhances the ability to comprehend what have read by engaging both
hemispheres of the brain, optimizing your focus, and improving logical thinking of students.
comprehension skills of these students has proven extremely difficult. According to Foorman,
B., & Al Otaiba, S. (2018), reading remediation strategy has the potential to improve the
reading proficiency of all learners. Also, foundation phase learners participating in a reading
remediation clinically achieved progress. This was confirmed in the study by Hansen (2016),
that it increased the reading comprehension in average readers. Thus, the majority of the
8
participating high school learners advanced one to two text levels and developed skills in
RELATED STUDIES
reading comprehension for high school students with reading comprehension difficulties.
According to, Solari, E, (2022) not all English learners have difficulties with reading
comprehension solely as a result of poor English linguistic comprehension. With that being
Low literacy among adolescents and adults worldwide remains a serious problem,
levels can be harmful in many ways for both the individuals concerned and their communities
in terms of health, political, social and economic outcomes. While large-scale international
assessments do assess reading proficiency, the data they provide for the bottom end of the
scale are still somewhat undifferentiated. What is of particular concern to scholars and
policymakers alike is to better understand the nature of reading difficulties among low-
literate adolescents and adults. Addressing this need, Durda, et al., (2020) presented in their
article a new integrative process model which takes into consideration reader-related, text-
related and task-related factors along different stages of the reading process that can cause
reading difficulties. Thus, this article identifies core difficulty-generating factors, in particular
task and text characteristics relevant in evaluating the difficulty of a reading task and thus in
In addition, Gedik, et al., (2022) included in their study aim to remediate the reading
9
difficulties and to develop their skills of reading fluency. For this purpose, the repeated
reading, paired reading, and word repetition techniques were used in the research process.
Consequently, the meaning analysis, word map and vocabulary notebook techniques were
also used due to the positive effect of rich vocabulary knowledge in remediating reading
Furthermore, Thage, E. (2021) argue that the Grade 10 syllabus does not have a
resource to help learners who missed on reading skills in primary school and have difficulty
complicated academic literacy tasks they encounter in their content areas and there is limited
In response to the challenges, this study initiated the Read to Lead Campaign to
promote the culture of reading in schools by introducing reading clubs and a Drop All and
Read campaign which promotes reading for 30 minutes at least once a week. These initiatives
are aimed at igniting the passion for reading and inculcating a reading culture, turning
learners into proficient readers. The challenge is that the programmes do not address reading
difficulties and promoting reading with understanding. Thus, it explains that the researchers
context.
Lastly, Harpine & Pazda (2019) stated in their study that in looking at group
instruction rather than one-on-one tutoring they found that students in the group-centered
greater improvement than those in one-on-one tutoring. Those in the group-based tutoring
10
III. ACTION RESEARCH QUESTIONS
This study aims to determine the reading proficiency level of Grade 10 learners in
Camarines Sur National High School, school/year 2022-2023. Specifically, this study will
1.What is the reading proficiency level of Grade 10 slow readers in terms of:
a. Reading speed?
b. Reading fluency?
c. Reading comprehension?
2.What are the strategies to improve and develop the reading proficiency of the students?
Methodology
This chapter embodies the discussion on how the study will be conducted. It presents
the method and procedures to be used in the conduct of the study to enable the researcher to
realize the goal of the study. It includes the methods used, respondents of the study, the
Method Used
11
The researchers will utilize the descriptive method of research to evaluate and assess
the reading skills of the Grade 10 student in Camarines Sur National High School. The
questions based on the present and current phenomenon. We will use descriptive method to
The participants of the study are the selected 25 grade 10 students with reading
difficulty.
The study is limited only for 25 selected Grade 10 students, particularly from Basic
Education Curriculum (BEC) of Camarines Sur National High School S/Y 2022-2023. The
respondents are selected students from Grade10 Caldera (6), Grade 10 Dela Torre (6), Grade
10 Nepomuceno (5), Grade 10 Kasilag (5), and Grade 10 Abelardo (3). This study focuses on
improving the reading proficiency learners with reading difficulties. Students from other
The researchers will utilize the use of a questionnaire checklist as the researchers’
data gathering technique to acquire the data they needed for the study. The questionnaire
checklist contained questions that correspond to the researchers’ statement of the problem.
Survey. A written set of questions is given to selected learners for the study to collect data
regarding our topic. The survey method will be used to study different learners in the
classroom to compare their progress in reading proficiency. They will be then exposed to the
12
Observation. Observation will be used to record the facial expression of the student when
taking the reading exercises. This instrument will also be used to assess the behavior of a
Definition of terms
Reading proficiency. Decoding skills that enable learners to read a text and meaning making
Literacy. The ability to read, write, speak, and listen to communicate effectively.
Reading Assessment. A tool to measure the reading fluency and comprehension of the
learners.
13
V. DISCUSSION OF RESULT
This section presents the results and the analysis from the data.
Table 1
The students’ scores in Pre-Test (including Speed Test, Fluency Test, and Comprehension Test)
Number of Speed Interpretation Fluency Interpretation Comprehension Interpretation
Student (# of (Mispronounced (Correct
minute) Word/s) Answer)
1 3.47 satisfactory 9 fair 2 fair
2 3.8 satisfactory 6 satisfactory 1 poor
3 4.3 fair 9 fair 1 poor
4 3.7 satisfactory 8 satisfactory 3 satisfactory
5 2.81 good 7 satisfactory 2 fair
6 3.56 satisfactory 9 fair 2 fair
7 2.53 good 6 satisfactory 3 satisfactory
8 3.28 satisfactory 8 satisfactory 2 fair
9 1.44 very good 5 good 2 fair
10 2.0 very good 8 satisfactory 3 satisfactory
11 1.15 very good 4 good 3 satisfactory
12 2.40 good 6 satisfactory 2 fair
13 3.47 satisfactory 6 satisfactory 2 fair
14 3.27 satisfactory 5 good 1 poor
15 4.42 fair 10 fair 0 poor
16 3.27 satisfactory 9 fair 3 satisfactory
17 2.13 good 6 satisfactory 1 poor
18 4.5 fair 11 fair 2 fair
19 3.14 satisfactory 6 satisfactory 3 satisfactory
20 1.09 very good 2 very good 3 satisfactory
21 3.28 satisfactory 9 fair 0 poor
22 4.14 fair 11 fair 2 fair
23 3.6 satisfactory 6 satisfactory 1 poor
24 2.22 good 6 satisfactory 1 poor
25 3.28 satisfactory 7 satisfactory 2 fair
1-2 minutes very good 0-2 words very good 5 very good
2.1-3 minutes good 3-5words good 4 good
3.1-4 minutes satisfactory 6-8 words satisfactory 3 satisfactory
4.1-5 minutes fair 9-11 words fair 2 fair
5.1 mins. & more poor 12 words & more poor 0-1 poor
Table 2
The students’ scores in Post-Test (including Speed Test, Fluency Test, and Comprehension
Test)
14
of Student (# of (Mispronounced (Correct
minutes) Word/s) Answer)
1 1.27 very good 2 very good 3 satisfactory
2 2.57 good 4 good 4 good
3 3.0 good 3 good 3 satisfactory
4 2.67 good 2 very good 4 good
5 2.4 good 3 good 4 good
6 2.7 good 0 very good 3 satisfactory
7 1.43 very good 0 very good 5 very good
8 2.44 good 0 very good 3 satisfactory
9 1.28 very good 2 very good 5 very good
10 2.0 very good 3 good 4 good
11 1.12 very good 1 very good 5 very good
12 1.23 very good 2 very good 4 good
13 2.51 good 3 good 4 good
14 2.48 good 2 very good 4 good
15 3.8 satisfactory 3 good 3 satisfactory
16 2.16 good 4 good 4 good
17 1.49 very good 0 very good 4 good
18 3.46 satisfactory 4 good 2 fair
19 2.56 good 4 good 4 good
20 58 sec very good 0 very good 5 very good
21 2.14 good 5 good 2 fair
22 3.52 satisfactory 4 good 4 good
23 3.0 good 0 very good 3 satisfactory
24 2.6 good 3 good 3 satisfactory
25 3.5 satisfactory 3 good 2 fair
1-2 minutes very good 0-2 words very good 5 very good
2.1-3 minutes good 3-5words good 4 good
3.1-4 minutes satisfactory 6-8 words satisfactory 3 satisfactory
4.1-5 minutes fair 9-11 words fair 2 fair
5.1 mins. & more poor 12 words & more poor 0-1 poor
a. Data Analysis
The two tables show the difference of the scores gained by the respondents in speed
test, fluency test, and comprehension test during pre-test and post-test. The table 1 is the data
Using the weighted mean and percentage, the reading survey show that in Pre-Test for
speed test; out of 25 students; 4(16%) are very good; 5(20%) are good; 12(48%) performed
15
satisfactorily; 4(16%) are fair; and none performed poorly. Meanwhile in Post-Test for speed
test; out of 25 students, 8(32%) are very good; 13(52%) are good; 4(16%) are satisfactory;
For Pre-Test in fluency test, the data shows that; out of 25 students, only 1(4%) is
very good; 3(12%) are good; 13(52%) are satisfactory; 8(32%) are fair; and none for poor
score. Meanwhile in Post-Test for fluency test; 12(48%) out 25 students are very good; and
For Pre-Test in comprehension test; out of 25 students, none (0%) got a very good and
good score; 7(25%) got satisfactory score; 10(40%) are fair; and 8(32%) for poor score. On
the other hand, in the post-test; out of 25, 4(16%) got very good rate; 11(44%) are good;
7(28%) are satisfactory; 3(12%) are fair; and none got poor score.
Using the Paired T-Test statistical tool, the researchers found out that:
16
(calculated from https://www.graphpad.com/quickcalcs/ttest2/)
In speed test, the two-tailed P value equals 0.5048. By conventional criteria, the
17
(calculated from https://www.graphpad.com/quickcalcs/ttest2/)
In fluency test, the two-tailed P value is less than 0.0001. By conventional criteria,
b. Reflection
Findings show that reading proficiency of learners with reading difficulty in terms of
speed test increases. However, the result from pre-test and post-test is not statistically
significant, which means the improvement level is not that very high. In view of fluency test,
the difference between pretest and posttest is extremely significant which means the
improvement level is very high. In comprehension test, the data shows that pretest and
posttest is extremely significant, which means the improvement level is also high.
Using the above statistics, the researchers realized that the reading proficiency level
18
Unlocking reading difficulty of students who find hard to read, pronounce word, and do not
even comprehend what they read are the primary goal of tutoring struggling readers.
Furthermore, this study suggests that through RRP, it improve the reading ability of identified
c. Recommendation
universal screenings identify students who need additional support and supplemental
intervention. Intervention targeted the reading skills in the areas of speed, fluency, and
comprehension. The researchers look forward for the below model as recommendation to
The table presents the target timeline, topic, area of focus, number of hours for
weekly remediation; starting with the easiest topic, phonemic awareness focus only on
recognition which focus on the relationship between phonemes and individual letters/group
of letter; next is the reading fluency which focus on improving ability to read a test with
accuracy, speed, and expression; next one is building reading vocabulary; and lastly, the text
comprehension which is the ability to recognize, understand, and interpret what has been
read.
Following this format gives careful attention to five essential components of reading
that will be able teach students how to develop strong decoding ability, build vocabulary
knowledge, and increase comprehension level of classified learners with reading difficulty.
19
Additionally, on the basis of result obtained and conclusions drawn from them, the following
are recommended:
The school administrators must make institutional programs that drive everyone to
The teacher should give more emphasis in teaching strategies and give them more
practice materials.
The future researchers may conduct the study at the broader scope or enhance the
strategies.
VI. REFERENCES
RAND Reading Study Group. (2014). Reading for understanding: Toward an R&D program
Perfetti, C.A., & Hart, L. (2013). The lexical quality hypothesis. In L. Verhoeven, C. Elbro,
20
Logdon Ann (2014). About Health: What is reading fluency? Retrieved from
Wright J. (2013). How To: Assess Reading Speed With CBM: Oral Reading Fluency
Ercikan K., Chen M. Y., Lyons-Thomas J., Goodrich S., Sandilands D., Roth W. M., Simon
Krawczyk, R.M. (2017). Effects of Grading on Student Learning and Alternative Assessment
Strategies. Retrieved from Sophia, the St. Catherine University repository website:
https://sophia.stkate.edu/maed/223
Durda, T., Artelt, C., Lechner, C.M. et al. Proficiency level descriptors for low reading
proficiency: An integrative process model. Int Rev Educ 66, 211–233 (2020).
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11159-020-09834-1
Solari, E. et al. (2022), Effectiveness of Interventions for English Learners with Word
Thage, E. M., Mokgosi, P. N., & Mthembu, J. T. (2021). Exploring the effects of
21
second language learners in South Africa. Problems of Education in the 21st Century,
Foorman, B., & Al Otaiba, S. (2018). Reading remediation: State of the art. In K. Pugh & P.
McCardle (Eds.), How children learn to read: Current issues and new directions in the
struggling, middle and high-level readers, Education Masters Paper 360, Fisher Digital
Pretorius, J., & Spaull, N. (2016). Exploring relationships between oral reading fluency and
https://nicspaull.files. wordpress.com/2011/04/pretorius-spaull-2016-readingand-
writing-esl-orf-and-comprehension.pdf
University.
Comprehension.
http://www.ccbi.cmu.edu/reprints/Just_Carpenter_Psych-Read-2019_speedreading.pdf
Iris Reading. June 29, 2018 “How to Speed Read for Increased Comprehension”
https://irisreading.com/
Harpine, E. C., & Pazda, A. (2019). Is Group-Centered Better than Classroom Instruction for
Teaching Reading? The Need for a Group-Centered Approach. Testing Two Group
22
Methods. In After-School Programming and Intrinsic Motivation (pp. 29–47).
Springer, Cham.
VII. APPENDICES
a. Letter to Principal
JAVIER C. VILLAROSA
23
English Teacher
Camarines Sur National High School
Sir:
Greetings!
In partial fulfillment of the requirement in the subject PROF ED 12: Participation and
Teaching Internship, we the undersigned, are conducting action research entitled “The
Integration of Effective Reading Strategies to Improve the Reading Skills in English of Grade
10 Students at Camarines Sur National High School”.
Rest assured that the study is purely academic in nature. Data gathered will be used
objectively and with utmost confidentiality.
We hope this request merits your approval. Thank you very much.
Respectfully yours:
Noted by:
Jocelyn D. Romero
College Supervisor
AMY T. GARCIA
English Teacher
Camarines Sur National High School
24
Ma’am:
Greetings!
In partial fulfillment of the requirement in the subject PROF ED 12: Participation and
Teaching Internship, we the undersigned, are conducting action research entitled “The
Integration of Effective Reading Strategies to Improve the Reading Skills in English of Grade
10 Students at Camarines Sur National High School”.
Rest assured that the study is purely academic in nature. Data gathered will be used
objectively and with utmost confidentiality.
We hope this request merits your approval. Thank you very much.
Respectfully yours:
Noted by:
Jocelyn D. Romero
College Supervisor
25