Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Sem 3 Yeats Poems Analysis
Sem 3 Yeats Poems Analysis
Sem 3 Yeats Poems Analysis
Introduction
The Tower, published in 1928, 1s probably Yeats' most important single
volume. Certainly it contains many of his most famous, most widely read,
anthologized, quoted, studied and explicated poems, major works like "Sail
ing to Byzantium, "Leda and the Swan," "The Tower'" and *Among
School Children." Indeed, as one leafs through this section in the Collected
the consistently high the brilliant level of
Poems, one is struck by
-
of
achievement that the poet was able to maintain throughout. Yeats, course,
was as skillful and
careful a craftsman as there has been in this century, but
even he, especially
in earlier volumes, had off moments. Yet in The Tower it
is succeeded by one as great or greater, as though
seems as though each poem
talisman
Yeats had found a kind of philosopher's stone of poetry, magic
a
which enabled him to transmute whatever dross he happened upon into the
purest literary gold.
at least
The role of magic talisman was, as we have noted before, played and
that wasA Vision. "Leda
in part by the system of metaphors and symbols
written deliberately to illustrate Book V of
that
the Swan," for instance, was
out of which the poet might gradually
work, as a kind of texte d'explication to Byzantium," too,
develop his theory of history. "Sailing
"annunciation"
"Leda"" or its
on A Vision, ough much less centrally than either
depends *"All Souls' Night," of course,
was
later companion-piece, "Byzantium."" it
as an Epilogue to A
Vision, and so it involves, though
originally intended
truths" of the book. And "Two Songs
does not enunciate, the "mummy on which"Ledaand
the
elaborates further the historical pattern
From a Play'"
Swan is based. are not
and they are many which
-
Tower
what of the poems in The
-
just as
he had discovered its joys. "The abstract joy/The half-read wisdom
daemonic images'" must "suffice theaging man, as once the growingboy
he wrote. No wonder he was bitter! Yet his bitterness was magic too;itg
even more of a shine to his verses, as it if were still another aspect ofthe
wonderful stone that turned life's mud and bones to gold. Hisemotionalstue
at this time seems to have involved a curious, marvellous corjunction
fulfillment and dissatisfaction - one of those accidental combinations o
Circumstance and preparation which so often act upon genius to producethe
greatest art.
'Sailing to Byzantium"
This first poem of The Tower, probably Yeats' most sl famous
poem, superbly expresses in its careful oppositions of age and youtn,
SOn
dilemmas of the book and, inuecu
sOme of the keenest central
-
reality, ncem
of the poet's own longest-standing preoccupations. lts maln
course, is Yeats' oldest theme - the subject of The Wanderings oj
man's mortality
"The Wild Swans at Coole aging, passing time, man's mu poe
gether with "The Tower" and Among School Children,
58
ather more autobiographical in tone) "Sailing to Byzantium,"" (more purely
imaginative and almost mythical in its style) forms a group of meditations on
age and its implications which is at the heart of The Tower, informing all the
rest of the book. Even those poems on completely different subjects have
some of the bitter intensity of the aging poet's soul.
Sailing to Byzantium" is quite a short poem, consisting of four rather
simply put together stanzas (abababce, all in roughly iambic pentameter). In
the first, the poet describes the natural world, where the young of all species-
birds, fish, people - are busy loving, reproducing and "commending'" the
flesh. Though these "generations" are "dying'" from the moment of their
birth, they do not notice it. "Caught" in the "sensual music"" of life, they
neglect/Monuments of unaging intellect" - works of art, religion or philos-
ophy, the products of man's non-physical imagination. But what place is there
among these young sensualists for an old man whose senses have already
begun to fail, his fesh to falter?
In stanza 2 Yeats describes the predicament of the old man more closely
An aged man is no more than a scarecrow, a 'tattered coat upon a stick,"
and
unless he rejects the flesh which has in any case become inadequate
-
be
Decause it is in the past. .
59
dead." And R. P. Blackmur has proposed a similar
Yeats," he says, "the heaven of the man' view:
in eternal or miraculous forms; there all
mind; there the mi"Byza
are
things are
known to the soul. [it) represents both possible ot soul dwe
state of insight. Lastly, Henn remarks
a dated.
that there
is, and aall th
for "might
epochbecause
spondence between Ireland and Byzantium, t Byzantium
symbolize new Ireland breaking away from its à Yeats, tecure
a
As we have
mythical "lords an
already
ings for Yeats. Most noted, Byzantium
has a number of
of the itimportant,
represents "the artifice of different mea
imagination,
Vision), the point ofsituated, in its
greatest glory, ateternity," aland
the
veins are superseded by Full Moon, where phase 15
"the fury and the (in terms of A
walls with their miracle and by a mire of huma
little
a
supernatural
function as symbol of glimmering cubes of blue and spendour, thes
than its Ireland, though green and gold." Is
function
devoted to the study of
as
climax the perhaps
of a certain real, is
clearly less significant
kind of Christian
Wisdom. Thus, in Sailing *monuments of unaging society, a city
world, the world of to
Byzantium" intellect," and of "the
Holy
"sensual Yeats contrasts
world of the music,"
spirit. *"Whatever is with'*the holy city of the tempor
wishes to transcend begotten, Byzantium,"
the cycle of born, and dies," the
lect/Monuments of
identical, and
"those dying
unaging intellect. ought not, if 1
generations,"
lifeless artifacts, though it may seem thatimagination Art,
and
"neg to
nint where
where their ow
theirown greatness, splendour"" to
the point the greatness
attain immortalits and a kind of omniscience.
of the soul, enables them to
Soveral critics have noted that in his Essays Yeats
ent a supernatural one beyond and above the four writes of a fifth
natural and tradi-
al clements, and calls it "a bird born out of the fire." (cf. Friar and
Bnnin, Modern Poetry) The soul, freed from flesh, becomes such a bird, an
aificial bird singing in the ecstatic flames of Byzantium, the "heaven of
man's imagination." *"Even the drilled pupil of the eye,*" Yeats
in A
Vision, when the drill is in the hand of some Byzantine worker says
"
in ivory,
undergoe s a somnambulistic change, for its deep shadow
ofthe tablet, its mechanical circle, where all else is among the faint lines
rhythmical and flowing, to
give to Saint or Angel a look of some great bird staring at miracle." And in
"Sailing to Byzantium" Yeats asserts that if Soul
sing. ." it rises from *a clap its hands and
.
tattered coat upon a stick" and becomes such a
Saint or Angel of the imagination, staring thus at miracle.
The Tower
and "childish memories.
and
beauty'" ('a tells more specifically about Irish events
sacrifice.Sixteen Dead Men"
men were
killed by the English
inspired: sixteen
the particular heroism they that as a kind
of logical
1916, and Yeats argues
ater the uprising of Easter
situation
have changed the political
deaths
of "Easter 1916*" their conciliation are
no longer
result acceptance,
Appeasement, passive
new
the r o s e in a
uterly. old symbol of
Markiewicz, a
possible."The Rose Tree uses Yeats is about Con
Political Prisoner Sligo, the
political context. "On a beautiful girl in
she was a mind "a"
Woman whom Yeats had known when had made her
political activity
poet's native county, before years of 53
bitter, an abstract thing." Thus the poem combines its political concern (Con
arkieWicz was imprisoned for her part in the 1916 uprising) withtheidea,
stated earlier in *Michael Robartes and the Dancer,"" that women should no
with unnatural
Ocstroy the natural spontaneous genius of their physicai beauty
mental exertions, especially exertions of a political nature.
visionary artistic whole. In the first stanza the poet describes the nra Coming,
secondar
of the world its political upheavals, the chaos and
civilization, the haphazard brutality of contemporary culture.
cynicism Sent state
of
The firsg . Yeats
of the falcon (hunting hawk) losing touch with its keeper as it flies qut o4g Robartes
of his call or whistle, summarizes all this. The fixed point, the central kge Stanza
tianity) has lost its power, it can no longer hold society in an orderly i s tcha
like a wheel around it (a structure which Yeats depicts as a series structh ucture paysica
of gvres pby
putward-spiralling circles). Instead, things are flying away, falling apartres, o
civilization is disintegrating. Our
In the second stanza the poet declares that all this
chaos, confusion and
disintegration must surely be a sign that a revelation, aSecond Coming" of
the Messiah is at hand. And even as he
says this, he experiences the extraord
nary vision which is the poem's climax. He sees a vast
image out of Spiritus hape
Maundi' (the world-spirit, or what the psychoanalyst Carl Jung would call
shape
the racial unconscious), a grant
sphinx-like creature, ""a shape with lion-body and of th
the head of a nan,"" moving
inexorably across the desert. Having had sucha
vision, Yeats has had, as he guessed he would,
a revelation "that twenty
thos
centuries of stony sleep/Were vexed to nightmare by a rocking cradle" Like
is, that the two-thousand
years-sleep of pre-Christian man was roused tha
-
sta
troubled by the first coming, the and ma
wonder now, coming of Christ. This moves the to
poet
two thousand years later, as he waits for
the second
such an earth-shaking new
spirit, "what rough beast, its hour comecoming of
last/Slouches toward Bethlehem to be born? round at
More than most of
Yeats post-Vision poems this one
theories the ghostly instructors brought the poet their depends on the
Specifically it depends on Yeats cyclical theory of metaphors for poetry.
-
history moves in vast two thousand year history, his idea that
cycles,
civilization and each one ushered in by a dramatic each cycle representing a
of some kind: a revelation symbolized by an religio-mystical revelation
annunciation
tion) and birth, such as the
annunciation of Mary and birth(mystical
of
concep
ushered in the Christian era of
0-2000 A.D.)and, earlier, the
Christ (which
Leda and birth of Helen (which ushered in the annunciation of
2000-0 B.C.) Thus the Second Coming here classical,
is not Graeco-Roman era of of
going to take
place in
the cradlee at Bethlehem, where it will **vex'" man's old
Christ's
nightmare.
sleep
new
to a
Praver For My Daughter
(Albnght,. 6 28-29)
30. Sailing
Thispocmto waswritten
Byzantiumin the autumn(August-Seplcmbcr)of 1926 an
was
(1927). Thefirstdralt
ofthepocm w
October Blast thelinal shapc. Thetittle
il wasfirst publishcdin was given
times beforc it
editcd by thepoet several of Byzantiu,an ancient cin
from the name ofthe city
ofthepoem derives (?287-337). From A.D 1
Roman Emperor
Constantine
that wasbuilt by the Eastern or Greck empire andalso for
to 1453, it was the
headquarters ofthe
was believed to
be the place where Cod
the Eastern Christianity.
The city
first to Constantinople and then
changcd
existed. The name of the city
was
scinaend
histi
of the
oppositc sexes, The
mackerel
Yeats Pctry and Plays
'coming in' poet also
remen
(Jcffares.214).
are
cngrossed The poct
to
harbours
alsoreme
remembers the
bours and shores
memories of the
in the west of
,lesh
embers*"'Fish,
Ireland
only in apdSowl,-all tha
first stanza births,
n the
ousness and deaths
sensuou
that in sch country (in The poei means
engrosscd in sensuousness. a
this worlul).
t
poct urgcs the sagcs and wise men to lift him up from of the dross hisanuns
passions and desires that, even though
he is now an old man,cntail lon
hcart away; sick with desire/And fastcicd 0 to a
Consume my
not know itstnuenalur.
animalThe poet says that his soul docs
he them to take his soul upwards and emplake
therefore. urgcs
Fot (* Selected Pocms
211
andunn uh hih the
sy mbol of etcrnity, for thecily of
is
ntre
thenre of art and
philosophy disciplincs that are cternal, Byrantium is
disciplines
ha hae ctcralapycaland gather me/ntothe artificeof eternity" This
ans tha
cans that the poct wants their help to enjoy the ctcrnal bliss in the
nlncs of art and philosophy "Monuments of unaging intellect
dIs
may be mindcd
remi of Bocthius's (Consolations
ere
Her
one
Philosophy
of
u the fourth or the last stan/a, the poct declares that once he has been
hted up from this sensuous natural world, he will ncver comc back to put
on lesh Once out ofnaturelsshall ncver takc/My bodily form from any Cuk
Rather, he will take such a shapc as "Grociangoldsmiths
"
odl shall wecar trousers rolled ") But he does not despair for that
my
Docause he thinks that the decaying of the body is rather cssential for the
AS union
with the Supreme Spirits-- with art and philosopny. in
214
W.B Ycats Poetry and Pha
Ryzantium. In this sense, the poem bcars an
optimistic notcBut, as Da
Albright has shown," "for gll its seductiveness,
toconfcss itsinadequacyThere isa covertallusion Byzastism is finally fon
inthe poem's firss
toTir ma nóg. the paradise which Oisin scarchcs in 7The Wanderi
for line
Oisin, and in that carly poem, as in so many latcr oncs, paradise lerimgs
a
famishes the appetites that promises to glut. All represcntations of
supernatural must contain sorie grotcsqueire, a straining for eft effea
juxtaposition of incompatible clements, as Yeats himsclf noted (4v
292); but the poet's metamorphosis into a golden bird, at the end of
poem, may suggest a certain laborious triviality as well as an
splendour, as iflife in Byzantium were at last shown as a super sortoffol
(Albright, 630).
31. The Tower