Campbell 1

Rojae Campbell

Prof. Moore

English – 121

15 November 2023

“In what ways does a college Basic Writing course challenge their language identity and

encourage them to bridge the gap between their past and present selves?”

Rita Mae Brown put it well when she said that language is like a complex road map

that leads us through the beginnings and ends of a culture. This idea is made all the more

poignant when one realizes the transformative journey that college Basic Writing courses

send their students on. These classes, which are frequently regarded as first steps in the vast

field of education, demand of their students that they carefully tread the line between who

they were in the past and who they are now—a journey that causes language to change

dramatically. According to Brown, the essay sets out to investigate how language, as taught

in College Basic Writing courses, not only helps students develop a unique identity but also

serves as an essential link between the various parts of their academic journey. This essay

explores the complex implications of these classes, elucidating the ways in which they shape

and test students' linguistic identities. College Basic Writing courses play a key role in the

complex dance of education because they offer a dynamic platform for the development of

language skills, maintain a supportive learning environment, and act as catalysts for personal

growth and self-expression. As we make our way through this terrain, we realize that these
 Campbell 2

courses are more than just language courses; they are life-changing opportunities that help

students walk the tightrope between their past and present.

Barbara Mellix's story in "From Outside, In" beautifully illustrates the complex

challenge of linguistic adaptation to varied social and educational contexts that is entwined

with identity. Mellix skillfully captures the complexities of language dynamics, especially the

difference between the formal, standard English required in educational settings and the

culturally embedded Black English of her daily life. This linguistic duality caused her to

experience internal conflicts and feelings of embarrassment and shame as she tried to strike a

balance between her true self and what society expected of her. These changes are put

through their paces in educational settings, such as College Basic Writing courses, where

students are required to adhere to academic language standards while still feeling a

connection to their cultural and linguistic heritage. Mellix's journey highlights how crucial it

is to comprehend linguistic identity and stresses that language is not merely a means of

communication, but a fundamental component of individual identity. People navigate this

linguistic adaptation by deeply negotiating how they express themselves, reshaping and

molding their linguistic identities in the dynamic field of education. In order to promote

environments that embrace linguistic diversity and recognize the transformative power of

education in shaping individuals' linguistic and cultural identities, it is imperative to

acknowledge the significance of language identity.

 Campbell 3

When it comes to Basic Writing courses, there is a great deal of significance to the

complex interactions that occur between student perceptions, feedback responses, and the

development of language identities over time. By using the insightful information from

Britton and Austin's article, "'That's Just How We Say It': Understanding L2 Student Writers'

Responses to Written and Negotiated Corrective Feedback Through Critical Incidents," as a

starting point, we can explore the complex experiences that L2 students have when

navigating the nuances of corrective feedback. This investigation not only clarifies the

difficulties faced by language learners, but it also emphasizes how important feedback is in

helping them develop their language identities in the context of Basic Writing. Critical

incidents become apparent as students struggle with written and negotiated corrective

feedback; these moments are critical because they provide a deeper understanding of the

complex dynamics between L2 learners and instructors. In order to ensure the authenticity of

perspectives and experiences, it is imperative that student voices be included in this research.

Instructors use student feedback as a compass to fine-tune their pedagogical approaches in

order to better meet the varied needs of students enrolled in Basic Writing courses. This study

highlights the challenges that students encounter and highlights the sense of empowerment

that comes from recognizing and including their voices in the conversation about education

through the prism of critical incidents. By looking at how students react to criticism, we can

learn important lessons that guide pedagogical practices that work and help create a more

inclusive and student-centered approach to Basic Writing instruction.

 Campbell 4

The academic approach discussed in the third source is not specifically described in

the text that is provided, but from what is known about "Journalogue," it seems to be a novel

way to deal with language identity problems that foreign students encounter. "Journalogue"

combines blogging, journaling, and conversation to give students a forum to express their

difficulties with writing on a class blog. By fostering a sense of belonging and support, this

method seeks to enable students to overcome linguistic and cultural obstacles together.

"Journalogue" is in line with the Blog Assisted Language Learning (BALL) approach, which

emphasizes the development of linguistic skills, metacognitive skills, and intercultural

competence in the context of innovative teaching strategies in language education. By

utilizing technology and collaborative learning, the approach improves socio-cultural

interaction, knowledge sharing, and engagement. Students' writing motivation is increased,

and their overall writing performance is enhanced, as it promotes reflective and

communicative practices. By fusing expressivism and socio-cognitivism, "Journalogue"

creates a dynamic learning environment by fusing creativity and self-expression with group

discussion. By enabling students to share their struggles, think back on their experiences, and

interact with a caring community, these strategies have a significant potential influence on

students' language identities. This cooperative method not only helps each person develop

their skills but also helps the community create a language identity that values variety and

promotes ongoing learning.

An essential link between a student's past and present, a college Basic Writing course

fosters personal growth and shapes linguistic identity. The course is essential for assisting

students in overcoming obstacles related to written communication, giving them a solid

academic foundation, and building their sense of self-worth. In order to fill in the gaps in

students' fundamental literacy skills, basic writing courses take into account the fact that
 Campbell 5

students may come to college with different educational backgrounds and different levels of

preparation. These classes provide a special chance for students to evaluate their writing

skills, pinpoint areas that need work, and actively participate in the learning process in the

framework of personal growth. Students are encouraged to confront any insecurities or gaps

in their language proficiency and make connections with their past experiences through the

reflective nature of Basic Writing courses. Students will be able to take a more deliberate and

mindful approach to their academic journey by doing this, as they will have a better

understanding of the trajectory of their language development. Additionally, Basic Writing

classes are very important in forming students' linguistic identities. Language identity is a

complex notion that includes how people view their own language use, expression, and

fluency. A Basic Writing course becomes a transformative space where students who have

faced difficulties in the past can redefine their relationship with written language. It enables

them to develop a positive language identity, gain confidence, and accept their linguistic

abilities. Getting through a Basic Writing course can be a big part of helping someone grow

personally. Students acquire critical thinking, problem-solving, and effective communication

skills at the same time that they improve their writing abilities. These abilities go beyond the

classroom and support more extensive personal and professional growth. Therefore,

beginning writing classes act as a catalyst for the development of a growth mindset by

motivating students to see obstacles as chances for growth and learning. In conclusion, a

college course on basic writing serves as a transformative link between students' prior

learning experiences and their current academic pursuits. These classes become forums for

introspection, the development of linguistic identities, and general personal development in

addition to teaching fundamental literacy skills. Recognizing and appreciating the students'

varied linguistic backgrounds, Basic Writing courses empower individuals to navigate their

academic journeys successfully and contribute to their holistic development.

 Campbell 6

In conclusion, college Basic Writing courses act as transformative tools, assisting

students on a deep journey that helps them connect the dots between their past and present.

These classes, which are frequently seen as the first steps in formal education, require a

careful balance and have caused language to change dramatically. When viewed through the

prism of Rita Mae Brown's analogy, language is examined as a crucial component of

students' academic journeys, helping them to forge their own identities while remaining

connected to their linguistic and cultural heritage. Barbara Mellix's experience serves as an

example of the difficulties, which highlight the intricate dance students do to balance

academic and cultural language. Novel strategies like "Journalogue," along with insights

from Britton and Austin's feedback dynamics, demonstrate the complexity of Basic Writing

courses. This comprehensive analysis demonstrates that these courses are much more than

just language instruction; rather, they are transformative experiences that greatly advance

students' overall growth and create welcoming, productive learning environments that value

linguistic diversity and the transformative power of education in forming cultural and

linguistic identities.