z

AnnexureA

sub

ofthe Case
Category 2

Title of the Case

VKX 9 M 0554
HQ i MS
of the counsel making
Signature menti

Name
3 B1
of the counsel makin nention bk
W

Date and time of the mentioning

01I 3 0
F Al

Name of the Branch Secretary

Designation

CourtRoom No
0

Fixlo 20 n if

tocIear
9 er
any
2

Ra n 3
9
A

n9
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
C

BrijPhotostat

lilf3tezmedical college hospital

1 message

BRIJ PHOTOSATE ltbrijhc15gmailcomgt

To advancecopysatyapajaincom

5740K collegehospita2852pdf
E White medical

28 November 2023 at 1225

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 QT
M
J
IN 7
THE HIGH COURT or PUNJAB AND HARYANA
55
AT CHANDIGARH

cwp
No aQyo of 2023

White Collegeand Hospital

Versus

Union of India and Others

mmx nts
Petitioner
Responde

Sr
No Particulars Dated Pages Court
fee
Court Fee

List of Dates and Events AG

Civil Writ Petition 28112023 129

Afdavit 30

Annexure P1 A true copy of

registration certicate of the
petitionersociety 31

Annexure P2 A true copy of

the resolution dated
20 1 12023 20112023 32

Annexure P3 A true copy of

Public Notice dated
22022023 issued by the
National Medical
Commission publishing a list
of recognized medical
colleges in the State of
Punjab 22022023 3334 yo

Annexure P4 A true copy of

the letter 04052022
intimatingabout the change
of name of the petitionerto
State of Punjab 04052022 3536 oo

10 Annexure P5 A true copy of

the letter 30082022
intimatingabout the change
of name of the petitioner to
NMCandMARm 30082022 3738 303
11 Annexure P6 A true copy of
judgmentdated 28012021
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42 passed by Honble Supreme
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL Court of India in Civil Appeal 28012021 3950 2100
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 No 1552021
12 Annexure P7 A true copy of
the chart depicting the
monetary infusion in the
petitionerscollege 51

13 Annexure P8 A true copy

letter dated 1 1042022
issued by the National
Medical Commission
granting renewal of
recognition and permission
to the petitioner for 1st
MBBS batch for the
Academic Year 202122 11042022 5257

14 Annexure P9 A true copy

letter dated 26102022
issued by the National
Medical Commission
granting renewal of
recognition and permission
to the petitionerfor the 2nd
MBBS batch for the
Academic Year 202223 26102022 5859 o
15 Annexure P10 A true copy
of the report by MARB dated
18052023 18052023 6096 zwao
16 Annexure P11 A true copy
letter dated 22052023
issued by the National
Medical Commission
the permission
soughtby the petitionerfor
the 3rd MBBS Batch 2nd
Renewal for the Academic
Year 202324 22052023 9798 90
17 Annexure P12 A true copy
of the letter order dated
31052023 31052023 99100

18 Annexure P13 A true copy

of Public Notice dated
14072023 issued by
National Medical
Commission allowing the
medical collegesto admit the
MBBS students without
under deemed permission 14072023 101
W
19 Annexure P14 A true copy
of order dated 25072023
passedby the Division Bench
of Honble Punjab85Haryana
MUKUL SHARMA High Court in petitioners
2023.11.29 15:42 CWP No 135692023 25072023 103
102 300
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
god
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 20 Annexure P15 A true copy 25072023 104 1

of letter dated 26072023

filed by the petitionerto the
Universityand to the State of
Punjab making fresh
representation requesting
them to permitfresh batch of
MBBS students in terms of
Public Notice dated
14072023 issued byNMC

21 27072023 105
of letter dated
Annexure true copy
P16 A27072023 106
led by the Universityto the
NMC seekingclarification in
respect of the petitioners
process of admission for the
current Session 202324 20
22 27102023 107
of judgment
Annexure P17 A true dated
copy 111
27102023 of the Allahabad
High Court in Writ C No
28058 2023 3100
23 23112023 112
of order dated
Annexure A true copy
P18 23112023 of 113
the Allahabad High Court in
Writ C No 280582023 20
24 Annexure P19 A true copy 21112023 114
of the order dated
21112023 in WP 0 No
150282023 of the Delhi
HighCourt 1
25 Power to attorney 28112023 115 21
26 Aadhar card of petitioner 116DJ

NOTE

iii
iv

vi Copy points
petition insuppliedcase11toCommission
India atopposite
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
of the
iii Whether
Similar
No
TheAct writ
Case
Relevant
main
of Caveat
the
law No
Statues blahave
has
petition
RulesVires are Constitution
been has
The
Total challenged
2019
been
contained
been
received
Act National
Court Medical
inothis
fee
fpara No
Q pageo5
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL Counsels on their email ids
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 SI TH SANDIU SH HAM BHALLA YAJUR
7812015 P 9002007 P 11622011

VARUN PURI
PH6289
2022 P75 20 16
ADVOCATES
COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS

Place Chandigarh ti 6 K PHYboJ

no 233 03 Y

Dated 28112023

am N1

619rQltW3

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH

5f 0 2
CWP No of 2023

White Medical College and Hospital

Petitioner

Versus

Union of India and Others

Court Fees

vi

s1 P7812015
HARTI ANDHU
9002007

sHU3
1162201
VAR PURI GURKAMAL
Q KANDHOLA
PH6289 2022 P75 20 16
ADVO CATES
COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER
Place 2 Chandigarh
Dated 28112023

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 Pf
SYNOPSIS

That by way of presentwrit petitionbeingled under Article 226

of theConstitution of India the petitionernamed the WhiteMedical

College85 Formerly known as Medical Collegegt81

Hospital is seekinga writ in the nature of mandamus

or any other

writ order or direction to the respondentsto grant permissionto the

for admission in the MBBScourse for a periodof one

year Academic Year 20232024 in terms of the Public Notice dated

l4hJuly 2023 issued by the National Medical Commission respondent

No 2 throughthe UndergraduateMedical Education Board respondent
No 3 herein It is submitted that the petitioner is a registeredand

recognizedMedical College81 Hospitalfor the Medical

Courses MBBS and was recognizedand permittedto admit the MBBS

students with 150 intakes for the academic year 20212022 1st batch

and was thereaftergrantedpermissionfor renewal of MBBS Course for

the 2nd batch 1st renewalfor the annual intake of 150 MBBS seats

duringthe Academic Year 20222023 but has not been approvals

for the said course for the Academic Year owing to certain

allegationsof deficiencies purportedlyobserved during the physical

inspection However in the meantime the National Medical

CommissionrespondentNo 2 herein NMC for short issued a Public

Notice bearingNo U 12023Ol2023UGMEB dated 14th July 2023

wherebyall the Medical Colleges Institutions that were due for

upto
recognition the year 2023 have been givenone year deemed en

bloc recognitionsand approvalsfor the admissions in the MBBS Course

for the Academic Year 202324 without any physical inspectionof the

collegesinstitution and without completingany other formalities

Howeverdespiterepeatedrepresentations
and correspondences
having

been made by the petitionerCollege

and despite specic queries and
MUKUL SHARMA
clarifications
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE havingbeen soughtby the concerned Universityie Baba
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 9
Farid University of Health Sciencesrespondent No 5 herein

University for short the NMC respondentNo2 has neither allowed

the petitionerCollegeto grantadmission to the MBBS students for the

Academic Year 20232024 nor any clarication has been givenby it to

the University thereby causing serious loss injury prejudice and

injustice to the petitionerCollegeinasmuch as it is an admitted fact

that the present petitioner

is a dulyrecognized
and registered
Institute

for the MBBS Course and is alreadyhaving two consecutiveMBBS

batches andis due for for 3rd batch 2nd renewalfor the

Academic
Year 20232024 and since the petitioneris fully entitled for

the relief grantedin the Public Notice dated 14072023 and thus

there is no reason or occasion for the respondentsto with

the petitionerand not to recognizethe present for the same

courses
and therefore the action of the respondentsis most illegal
arbitrary unjust and without jurisdiction and the same is nothing but

a
classic exampleof unjustifieddiscrimination and hence immediate

interference of this Honble Court is warranted

Tgrga I glmblam

pawl 2ltznrgtgt CW
C p Aelvoc W

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 2011

approved
PetitionerCollege
Society
Punjab Chintpurni
formerly petitioner
Registration
recognized
subsequently
College 85
registered
by University
petitionerThe
recognized
approved
Hospital
has 150
The
founded
Societyregistered
by
College
Chintpurni by to
85
petitionerthe
petitionerCollege
Hospital
college
petitionercollege
NMCrespondent
college
College
reasons i85
85 The
Hospital
Undergraduate
submitted
including
Hospital
28012021
is
Medical
from
That
with
located
No
National
herein
that
Medical
5the
Baba
the aCourses
herein
withat
Needless
LIST
known
Medical
and
Farid
a nd as
the
intake
OF to
is
1860was
run
Medical
DATESsay referred
Commission
of
Medical
due
in
Whiteto
The
the
medical
the the
seats
year
EVENTS
ofCouncil
Medical
various
M
Healthas
Tehsil
edical
in
for under
State
of
the
the University
yearto
the the
Government
It is s2011
Education
is now
Societies
isstill
White
also
affiliated
its No a

C2
That A ct VillageBungal
MBBS 2022 85 MCI and
District of

alleged deciencies found during the inspections

petitioners was cancelled by the Government of

India and petitionerwas debarred from admittingany

MBBS student for two academic years
ie 201718 and
201819 and said decision of the respondentswas first

by the petitionerbefore
challenged this Honble Court and
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE having been failed therein the petitioner approached the
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 p
Honble SupremeCourt of India and Honble Supreme
28012021
Court vide its judgment dated passed in Civil

AppealNo 155 of 2021 titled as Medial College

Chintpurni
85 Hospital ampAnr vs Union of India ampAnr though

dismissed the appealof the petitionerbut permittedthe

petitionerto apply for renewal of recognitionalongwith

permissionto admit students for academic year 202122

11042022That in view of the liberty granted by HonbleSupreme

Court vide its Judgment dated 28012021 the petitioner

applied vide dated

01092021 for grant of Renewal of and

permission
to admit fresh batch of 150 MBBS students for

the academic 202122 and

year after completing all
requisiteformalities and complyingwith all directionsand

after long proceduraland technical fights the National

Medical Commission No 2 herein vide

NMCrespondent
its letter dated 11042022 informed the petitioner
that the
Medical Assessment 85 Rating Boardrespondent No 4
herein has decided to grant renewal of to the

petitionerCollegepermittingit to admit 150 MBBS

students for the academic year 202122

subsequentlythe
26102022That Medical Assessment and

Boardrespondent No 4 herein vide its letter No5NMCI

UGR20222304816672 dated 26102022 granted
further permission for renewal of MBBS Course of 2nd

batch lsl Renewal for annual intake of 150 MBBSseats to

the Collegeduring the Academic Year 202223

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 22052023That however when the petitionersought for

3 Batch 21 Renewal of 150 MBBS seats for the

Academic Year 202324 under Section 261 a b and

Section 28 1 2 of the National Medical Commission Act

2019 the respondentNo 2 and 4 vide their letter dated

22052023 declined to grant approvalforthe to the

petitioner on the ground of alleged deciencies and for

somewhat same reasons the University No 5
herein also temporarily withdrawn the afliation of the

for
petitionercollege the Academic Year 2023204 vide its

letter dated 31052023

14072023That the said letter of disapprovaldated 22052023

followed by letter issued by the Universityon 31052023

was before
challenged
by the petitioner the Honble Punjab
85 Haryana High Court vide writ petition CWP No

13569 of 2023 However while the aforesaid

writ
was
pendingbefore the Honble Punjab85 HaryanaHigh
Court the National Medical No 2

herein through the UndergraduateMedical Education

Board respondentNo3 herein issued a Public Notice dated

14 July 2023 whereby all the Medical Colleges

Institutionsthat were due for recognition the year

2023 have been givenone year deemed enbloc recognitions

and approvalsfor the admissions in the MBBS Course for

the Academic Year 202324 without any physical

inspectionand without completingany other formalities

25072023That the aforesaid writ petitionbeingCWP No 135692023

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
led by the petitionerherein came to be listed before the
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 F
Division Bench of Honble Punjab 85 High Court on

25072023 and duringthe course of hearing Honble

the
High Court was apprisedby the petitionerthat the National

Medical Commission has issued the aforesaid Public Notice

dated 14072023 allowingall Medical Collegeswhich are

due for recognition upto 2023 to admit fresh batch of

MBBS students with the intake

same as
in the Academic

Year 202223 which was not before the while

issuing the letter dated 31052023 deaffiliating the

andthus the Division Bench

petitionercollege was pleased
to of
thewrit petition of
thepetitioner vide order

dated 25072023 therebypermittingthe to

approachthe UniversityrespondentNo5 herein by ling a

fresh representationwith the direction to the Universityto

consider the said representation

as earlyas possible

26072023That in terms of the grantedby the

libertyand permission
Division Bench of Punjab85 Haryana Court vide its
order dated 25072023 petitioner made a fresh

vide
representation its letter dated 2607 2023 together
with documents attached therewith therebyrequestingthe

State of Punjab with copy to the

No5 herein to permit them to admit fresh batch of MBBS

students with the same intake as in Academic Year 2022

23 in terms of Public Notice dated 14072023 issued by

the National Medical Commission

27072023That subsequently the Universityrespondent No5

herein vide its letter dated 27072023 sought clarication

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
from the National Medical Commissionrespondent
No 2
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 herein therebygiving completedetails of the matter and

asking the NMC to clarify as to whether the present

petitionerCollegecan go ahead with the admission process

of current Session 20232024

However despiteexpiry of substantial period of more three 03

than
monthsthe respondent
N0 2 has failed to allow the to admit

the fresh Batch of MBBS students for the Academic Year 2023204 nor

any clarification as
sought be the University has been givenby the

NMCand this inactionnonaction is causingserious loss

injuryand

prejudice to the petitioner and hence the present petition has been

necessitated to le

THE PRESENT WRIT PETITION

Ha
QaCO13t Q
D51J 21ngtor3
C Ottawa
222 gl55LnL 2 ti 0 A

91a0
C Vdwuh Q
5llWWQ K
V

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

AT CHANDIGARH

CWP No

MEMO OF PARTIES of 2023

White Medical Collegeand Hospital VillageBungal Dalhousie Road

Tehsil and District Pathankot Punjab its authorised

representative
Dr Dinesh Sharma Chief Executive Officer agedabout

73 years son of Sh Kedarnath Sharma resident of Dr Mathur

Memorial TagorePublic School Nalwa Bridge Barfaani Mandir Ward
No 25 Tehsil and Post Pathankot District Pathankot
orce
Gurdaspur Punjab 145001 9138 1861 7809 Mobile
UID
No
9814195502

Petitioner

Versus

1 Union of India

Through the SecretaryHealth

Ministryof Health 85FamilyWelfare

Nirman Bhawan New Delhi1 10011

2 National Medical Commission

Through the Chairperson

Pocket14 Sector8

Dwarka Phase1 New Delhi110077

3 Medical
Undergraduate Education Board

Through the President

National Medical Commission

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
Pocket14 Sector8
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 1 New Delhi110077

9
5 2

1
4 86RatingBoard MARB

President

National Medical Commission

14
Pocket Sector8
Z

Dwarka Phase1 New Delhi110077

5 Baba Farid Universityof Health Sciences

Throughthe Registrar

Sadiq
Road Faridkot151203 Punjab

6 Director Education and Research PunjabSector69

District SAS NagarMohali Punjab

Respondents

HARTH SHUBHAM BHALLA YAJU

ltV
BHALLA
P7812015 9002007 11622011

v N PURI GU L KANDHOLA
PH62892022 P752016
ADVOCATES
COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONER
Place Chandigarh
Dated 28112023

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 Civil Writ Petition under Article 226 and 227 of

the Constitution of India for Issue a writ of

Mandamus or any other writ order or direction

directing the respondentsto grant permission

to the petitionerCollegefor admissionin the

MBBS course for a period of one year

Academic Year 20232024 in terms of the

Public Notice dated 14hJuly 2023

P13 issued by the National

Medical Commission respondent No 2 through

the Undergraduate Medical Education

Board respondentNo 3 herein

I

AND

Issue a writ of Mandamus or any other writ

order or direction therebydirectingthe National

MedicalCommission No 2 herein

to respond to the letter dated 27072023

ANNEXURE P16 written by Baba Farid

Universityof Health Sciences respondentNo 5

herein with clarication that the present

is fullyentitled
petitionerCollege and thus can

go ahead with the admission process of current

Session 20232024 for MBBS Courses in terms

of the Public Notice dated 2023

issued by the National Medical

No 2 through the

Undergraduate Medical Education Board

respondentNo 3 herein as sought by the

UniversityrespondentNo 5 vide its letter

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE dated 27072023
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 l
AND

Issue writ of Certiorari

a
quashing setting
aside the letter dated 22052023Impugned

ANNEXURE P11 issued

bythe Medical

Assessment 85 Rating Board declining

permission
to the petitioners
to admit students

for the 3rdBatch 2nd Renewal of 150 MBBS

seats for the academic year 202324

AND

Summon the record of the carried

outbyrespondentno3
AND

Exemptthe petitionerfrom ling the certied

copiesof Annexure P1 to Annexure P20

and
further permissionbe granted to le the

photocopies
of Annexure P1 to Annexure P

20

AND

Exempt the petitionerfrom ling typedlegible

I

copiesof Annexures P1 P2 P11

AND
Allow of petition in of
thecosts the
1

petitioners
AND

In
theinterim
With the interim prayed that during the

pendency of the present writ petition the

impugned order dated 22052023

ImpugnedAnnexure P11 may kindly be

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE stayedin the interest of justice aslthe college
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 5
and its students will suffer irreparableharm

and injuryin case the impugnedorder dated

22052023 the petitionercollegewill suffer

irreparableharm and injury

RESPECTFULLY SHOWETH

1 That by way of presentwrit petitionbeingled under Article 226

of the Constitution of India the petitioner named the White

Medical College 85 Hospital Formerly known as Chintpurni

Medical College85 Hospital is seekinga writ in the nature of

mandamus or any other writ order or direction to the

respondentsto permitthe petitionerCollege

to admit students in

MBBS course for a of one year Academic Year 20232024

period
in terms of the Public Notice dated 14th July 2023 issued by the

National Medical Commission respondentNo 2 throughthe

Undergraduate MedicalEducation Boardrespondent No 3

herein It is submitted that the National Medical

Commissionrespondent
No 2 herein NMC for short has issued

a
Public Notice bearing No U 12023Ol2023UGMEB dated

14th July 2023 wherebyall the Medical Colleges Institutions

that were due for recognitionupto the year 2023 have been given

one year deemed enbloc recognitions and approvals for the

admissions in the MBBS Course for theAcademic Year 202324

without any physical inspection and without completing

any
other formalities However petitionerhas been denied the said

benet without consideringthat other collegeswith more

deficiencies have been grantedpermissionwithout assigningany

reason whatsoever in a most illegalarbitrarydiscriminatory

and

unjust manner without having any jurisdiction and hence

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE immediate interference of this Honble Court is warranted
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 2 That the factual matrixes leadingto ling of the present petition

are as
follows
8
a
That the petitionerThe White Medical College 85 Hospital

formerly known as Chintpurni Medical College85 Hospital

located at VillageBungal Tehsil 85 DistrictPathankot

Punjab founded in the year 2011

was
The Petitioner
Collegeis run by ChintpurniSchool Education Society a

registered Society registered under the Societies

Registration Act 1860 The is an

unaided privateinstitution duly recognizedby the National

Medical Commission A true copy of registrationcerticate

of the petitioner
societyis annexed herewith as ANNEXURE

P1

The petitioner is ling the present petition Dr

Dinesh Sharma Chief Executive Ofcer duly by

resolution dated 20112023 A true copy of the resolution

dated 20112023 is annexed herewith as ANNEXURE P2

That the answering respondent runs a duly

Medical College 85 Hospital as a hospital

offering750 beds and employs242 Doctors nursingstaff

of 309 400 nursing students and 258 MBBS students The

hospital attached
tothe Medical Collegeoffers OPD and

most of all is equippedtoperform all sorts of

medical procedures

The medical Collegeand Hospitalis at Bungal

District Punjab an area on the borders of

Punjab Himachal Pradesh and Jammu 85 Kashmir It

UT

would be pertinent to mention that the medical college 85

Hospital of the answering respondent was granted an

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
EssentiallyCerticate because the inhabitants of the rural
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
J

populationof around 1900 villagesdid not have any

r
quality

85 facilities before
V

medical care settingup of the College

and Hospital

That the Medical College85 Hospitalin particularcaters to

the Districts of Pathankot and

TheDistrict of

Pathankot has 3 tehsils and 5 tehsils with 1900

villagesto which Medical Collegeand Hospitalprovides

much needed medical care and basic medical health The

rural population of this far ung and most backward of

areas
dependsupon the Medical Services by the
provided
answering respondent At the same
time the Medical

Collegeand Hospitalhelps to uplift societyby

quality medical and nursing education The Medical College

and Hospitalprovidesspeciality and super specialty

medical care to the rural population in close proximityto

their homes

That at this junctureit would be appropriate

to point out

that the Medical College 85 Hospital of the answering

respondent served
a role during the COVID19

pandemic The Hospital was offered free of cost to the State

Government as a designatedCOVID Hospital The District

Magistrate Pathankot in exercise of power under the

Epidemic Diseases Act 1897 designated the medical

collegeand hospital as a COVID videorder dated

A

20032020
1

The petitionercollegeis afliated with Baba Farid

Universityof Health SciencerespondentNo 5 herein

hereinafterreferred to as the University and is

by the Medical Council of India MCI now National Medical

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE Commission NMC respondent
No 2 herein with intake of
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 X
150 seats for the Undergraduate Courses MBBS
5

The petitionerCollegeis also approvedand recognizedby

the State Government of Punjab Needlessto say the

collegeis
petitioner still a and approved
recognized medical

college It is submitted that the petitioner

hasin the

2022 changedits name from Chintpurni College85

Hospitalto the White Medical College85

A true copy of Public Notice dated 22022023 issued by

the National Medical Commission publishing a list of

recognized medical colleges in the of Punjab is

1

State

annexed herewith

A true copy of the letter 04052022 about the

change of name of the petitioner to State of Punjab is

annexed herewith as ANNEXURE P4

A true copy of the letter 30082022 intimatingabout the

changeof name of the petitioner to NMC and MARB is

annexed herewith as ANNEXURE P5

That subsequentlydue to reasons

various including

alleged deciencies found during the

petitionersrecognitionwas cancelled by the Government of

India and petitionerwas debarred from admittingany

MBBS student for two academioyears ie 201718 and
201819 and said decision of the was rst
by the petitionerbefore
challenged the Honble Delhi High
Court and having been failed therein the petitioner

approached the Honble Supreme Court of India The

Honble Supreme Court vide its judgment

28012021 passedin Civil Appeal No 155 of 2021 titled as

Chintpurni Medial College85 Hospital85Anr vs Union of

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
India 85Anr though dismissed the appealof the petitioner
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 d
but permittedthe petitionerto apply for renewal of

recognitionalong with permission to admit students for

academic year 202122A true copy of judgmentdated

28012021 passedby Honble SupremeCourt

of in

Civil Appeal No 1552021 is herewith

annexed and
marked
I
as P6

That after the inceptionof the collegein 2011 the petitioner

college faced teethingproblems but currently the college

has all the proper facilitythat are required to the

standards set out by the NMC and the regulationsframed

by the Act of 2019 The petitionerwould like to

submit that they have infused huge monetary

considerations into the collegeonly after which the NMC

grantedlimited permissionof renewal recognitionA

and
true copy of the chart depictingthe monetary infusion in
the petitionerscollegeis annexed herewith as ANNEXURE

P7

That in View of the liberty grantedby Honble Supreme

Court vide its dated 28012021 the petitioner

applied vide applicationNMCUGR2020000049 dated

01092021 for grant of Renewal of and

permissionto admit fresh batch of 150 MBBS students for

the academic year 202122 and after completingall

requisiteformalities and complying

with all directions
and
after long procedural and technical the National
ghts
Medical Commission NMC respondent
No 2 herein vide

its letter dated 11042022 informed the petitionerthat the

Medical Assessment 85 Rating Boardrespondent No 4

herein has decided to grant renewal of recognitionto the

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
petitionerCollege permitting it to admit 150 MBBS
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 0
students for the academic year 202122 A true copy letter

dated 11042022 issued by the National

Commission granting renewal of and

permission to the petitioner for 1st MBBS batch for the

Academic Year 202122 is annexed and

herewith marked

as
ANNEXURE P8

That subsequently the Medical Assessment and Rating

Board respondentNo 4 herein vide its letter No NMC

UGR20222304816672 dated 26102022 granted

further permission for renewal of MBBS of 2nd

batch lst Renewal for annual intake of 150 MBBS seats to
the Collegeduring the Academic Year 202223A true copy

letter dated 26102022 issued by the National Medical

Commission granting renewal of recognition and

permissionto the petitionerfor the 2nd MBBS for the

batch
2

Academic Year 202223 is annexed and marked

as
ANNEXURE P9

That the MARB conducted a surprise in

December 2023 where certain were pointed

out MARB issued a show cause letter
The dated
13012023 to which the petitionerduly replied on

19012023

That MARB conducted an inspectionof the petitioners

college in May 2023 and submitted a report dated

18052023 wherein the deciencies are A true

copy of the report by MARB dated 18052023is annexed

herewith and marked

i
as ANNEXURE P10

That however when the soughtpermissionfor

3rd Batch 2nd Renewal of 150 MBBS seats for the
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42 Academic Year 202324 under Section 261 a and
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
b
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
J

Section 28 1 2 of the National Medical Commission Act

U
2019 the respondentNo 2 and 4 vide letterdated
their
22052023 Impugned declined to grant approval
for the
same to the petitioneron the ground of allegeddeciencies

and for somewhat same the

No 5 herein had also temporarily

withdrawn the afliation of the petitionercollegefor the

Academic Year 2023204 vide its letter dated
3l052023A

true copy letter dated 22052023 issued by the National

Medical Commission disapproving sought

the
bythe petitionerfor the 3rd MBBS Batch 2nd for

the Academic Year is annexed herewith and

marked as ANNEXURE P11 Impugned

That the said letter of disapprovaldated 22052023 was

followed by orderletter dated 31052023 temporarily

withdrawing
the of the petitionerto theuniversity
which was challengedby the petitionerbefore the

Punjab85 HaryanaHigh Court vide writ petitionbearing

CWP No 13569 of 2023A true copy of the letter order
dated 31052023 is annexed herewith as ANNEXURE P

12
i

That while the aforesaid writ petition was pending before

the Honble Punjab85 HaryanaHigh Court the National

Medical CommissionrespondentNo 2 herein through the

Undergraduate
Medical Education Board No3

herein issued a Public Notice dated 14th July 2023 which

reads as under

National Medical Commission

UndergraduateMedical Education
Board
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
K No

2023
U12023012023UGMEB Dated the 14 W July

PUBLIC NOTICE

Subject Recognition
Continuation ofRecognition
COR of
MBBS degreefor the year 202223

the
Considering schedule of NEETUG 2023
for counseling
Medical CollegesInstitutions that were due for
RecognitionCOR due upto the year 2023 and have not been
communicated for specic denial or stoppageof admission
for the academic year 202324 by MARBNMC are hereby
grantedRecognition
for a periodof ONE YEAR ONLY i e A Y
202223 for all the admitted MBBS batches upto the
academic year 201819

These medical collegesnstitutions are allowed to

admit fresh batch of MBBS students with the same
intake as in the academic year 202223

Sd

Dr Aruna
V Vanikar

President UGMEB

A true copy of Public Notice dated 14072023 issued by

National Medical Commission allowingthe medical

to admit the MBBS students without under deemed

permission is annexed and marked as

ANNEXURE P13

That the aforesaid writ petitionbeingCWP No 135692023

led by the herein came to be listed before
the
Division Bench of Honble Punjab 81 Haryana on
High Court

25072023 and duringthe course of hearing the Honble

High Court was apprisedby the petitionerthat the National

MUKUL SHARMA
Medical Commission has issued the Public Notice
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH dated 14072023 allowingall Medical Collegeswhich are
t
J
due for recognition upto 2023 to admit fresh
l3
batch of

MBBS students with the same intake as in the Academic

Year 202223 which was not before the University while

issuing the letter dated 31052023 deafliating the

and thus
petitionercollege the Division Bench was pleased
to dispose of the writ petition of the petitionervide order

dated 25072023 permittingthe petitionerto

approachthe University respondentNo5 herein by ling a

fresh with
representation the direction to the Universityto

consider the said as earlyas possible A true

copy of order dated 25072023 passed by the Division

Bench of Honble Punjab 85 Haryana High Court in

petitionersCWP No 135692023 is annexed herewith and

marked as ANNEXURE P14

That the petitionerwould like to humbly that in

terms
1

of the liberty granted by this Honble Court vide

order dated 25072023 in CWP No 135692023 the

petitioner led his representationwithrespondent no 5

which is still pendingadjudication

That at this stage it is importantto mention that an

MBBS student of the petitionercollege has sought his

transfer from the to some other colleges

petitionercollege
for his own personalreasons by ling a writ petitionin the

Punjab 85 Haryana High Court which has since been

numbered as CWP No 12324 2023 Similar

other
have also been led by various other students pursuing

their MBBS course and the said writ petitionsare presently

pending before the learned Single Judge of Punjab 85

Haryana High Court It is signicant to mention that the

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE National Medical Commission has led its specic afdavit
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
R1 in

the said batch of petitionsbefore the Honble

W
Punjab 85

Haryana High Court therebyspecically objectingto

and
contestingthe prayers made for transfer and reiterated that

the concerned studentpetitionerin the said writ petition

has to pursue his course with petitionercollege

only
Be that as it may in terms of the liberty andpermission

grantedby the Division Bench of Punjab85 Haryana

Court vide its order dated 25072023 petitionermade a

fresh representationvide its letter dated 26072023

togetherwith documents attached therewith thereby

requesting the State of Punjab with copyto the

University No5 to permitthem to

herein admit

fresh batch of MBBS students with the same intake as in

Academic Year 202223 in terms of Public Notice dated

14072023 issued by the National Medical CommissionA

true copy of letter dated 26072023 filed

bythe petitioner
to the to the
Universityand of Punjabmakingfresh
representationrequestingthem to permit fresh batch of

MBBS students in terms of Public Notice dated 14072023

issued by NMC is annexed herewith and marked

as
ANNEXURE P15

That subsequently the Universityrespondent No5

herein vide its letter dated 27072023 soughtclarication

from the National Medical Commission No 2

herein therebygiving completedetails of

thematter
and
asking the NMC to Clarify as to whether the present

petitionerCollege
can go ahead with the admission process

of current Session 20232024A true copy of letter dated

27072023 led by the University to the NMC seeking

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE clarication in respect of the petitioners process of
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
xx
1

admission for the current Session 202324 is annexed

herewith and marked as ANNEXURE P16

That howeverdespiteexpiryof substantialperiodof more

than three 03 months the respondent
No 2 has failed to

allow the petitioner to admit the fresh Batch of MBBS

students for the Academic Year 20232024 nor any

clarication as soughtby the University has been givenby

the NMC and this inactionnonaction is causing serious

loss injury and prejudiceto the petitionerand hence the

present petitionhas been necessitated to le

That at this junctureit would be to

appropriate narrate the

statutory framework permissionsgrantedand

conducted by the appropriateauthorities are narrated as

under

That with the coming into force of the National Medical

Commission Act of 2019 hereinafter referred to as the Act

the duties of the Medical Council of

IndiaSection
2h denes the Medical Assesesment and Rating Board

MARB Section 2i denes a Medical Institution

That Section 16 of the Act providesfor of

autonomous supervision of
boards the the
Commission who are to carry out their functions as

assigned by the Commission by way of

Section 16 is reproducedherein under for the ready

reference of this Honble Court

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

fsection16 1 The Central shall

by
notification constitute the following Autonomous

Boards under the overall supervision of the

Commissionto performthe functions to such
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42 Boards under this Act namely
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH a the UnderGraduate Medical Education Board
 C
b the PostGraduate Medical Education Board

c the Medical Assessment and RatingBoard and

d the Ethics and Medical Registration
Board
2 Each Board referredto in subsection 1 shall be
an autonomous bodywhich
shall carry out its functions under this Act subject
to the regulations
made by the Commission
JOOCXJCJCJCJOCXJOOCXX

That Section 26 providesthe functions of the Medical

Assessment 8 Rating Board hereinafter referred to as

MARB which includes power to grant recognition renewal

of recognition permissions carry out inspections of

medical colleges amongst others to throughout India

Section 26 is reproducedvherein under for the ready

reference of this HonbleCourt

Section 26 1 The Medical Assessment and Rating

Board shall performthe following namely

functions
a deterrnineithe
procedure for assessing and rating
the medical institutions for their compliance
with the

standards laid down by the UnderGraduate

Education Board or the PostGraduateMedical

Education Board as the case maybe in accordance
with the made
regulations under this Act

b grant permissionfor establishment of a new

medical institution or to start any postgraduate

course or to increase number of seats in accordance
with the provisions
of section 28
c carry out inspections of medical institutions for
assessingand ratingsuch institutions in accordance

with the regulations

made under this Act
Provided that the Medical Assessment and Rating
Board may if it deems necessary hire and authorise

any other third party agency persons for carrying

or

out inspections
of medical institutions for assessing
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE and ratingsuch institutions
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
24
Provided

further that where Pr

of medical
institutions is carried out by such third party
agency or persons authorised by the Medical
Assessment and RatingBoard it shall be obligatory
on to such
such institutions to provideaccess agency
or person

at conduct or where it deems necessary

empanel independentrating agenciesto conduct

assess
and rate all medical institutions withinsuch
periodof their opening and every year at

such time and in such manner as may be specied

by the regulations
e make available on its website or in publicdomain
the assessment and ratings of institutions
at regular intervals in accordance with the
regulationsmade under this Act
take such measures including issuingwarning
of monetarypenalty reducingintake
imposition or

stoppage of admissions and recommendingto the

Commission for withdrawal of recognitionagainsta
medical institutionforfailureto maintain the minimum
essential standards specifiedby the UnderGraduate

Medical Education Board or the PostGraduate

Medical Education Board as the case may be in

accordance with the regulationsmade under this Act

2 The Medical Assessment and Rating Board

may in the dischargeof its inctions make such
recommendations to and seek such directions

from the Commission as it deems necessary

COCCXXOOOCCOCXX

That Section 38 lays down the power of the Commission on

a report from
receiving the MARB

38 1 Where upon a from the

Medical Assessment and RatingBoardunder section

26 or otherwise if the Commission is of the opinion

that

MUKUL SHARMA a the courses of study and examination to be

2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
undergone in or theprociency requiredfrom
kg

candidates at any examination held by a University

ormedical institution do not conform to the

standards specifiedby theUnderGraduate Medical

Education Board or the PostGraduate Medical
EducationBoard as the case may be or

b the standards and norms for

faculty and qualityofeducation
in medical institution
as
determined by the UnderGraduate
MedicalEducation Board or the PostGraduate Medical

Education Board as the case

maybe are not

adhered to by any University or

institution and suchUniversityor medicalinstitution

has failed to take necessary corrective action
tomaintain specied minimum standards the
Commission may initiate action inaccordance with the

of subsection 2
provisions
Provided that the Commission shall beforetaking
any suo
action for motu withdrawal of
grantedto the medical qualyication
awarded by a

Universityor medical institution imposepenalty in

accordance with the provisionsof clause0 of sub
section 1 of section 26

2 The Commission shall aftermakingsuch

inquiryas it deems t andafterholdingconsultations
with the concerned State Government and the

authorityofthe concerned or medical

institution comes to the conclusion that

grantedto
therecognition a medical qualication ought

to be it may by orderwithdraw
recognitiongranted to such medical qualification
and direct theUnderGraduate Medical Education

Board or the PostGraduate Medical EducationBoard

as case to
the amend the entries
the
maybe
against University or

concerned in the list maintained by that Board to the

effect that the to such medical

qualificationis withdrawn with effectfrom the date

MUKUL SHARMA speciedin that order
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL XXlCXXrXC7CCJCXOC7CC
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
V
bb That Section 57 y z and zc providesthe power of the
Commission to make regulations

y the procedure
for assessingand ratingthemedical
institutions underclause a of subsection 1 of
section 26
the
4

z manner of carrying out inspections of

medical forassessingand rating such
institutions under clause 1
section 26zc the
c toof subsection of
measures be taken against a
medical institution for its failure tomaintain the

minimum essential standards under clause 0 of sub

section 1 of section 26
zThat Section 612 providesthe Transitoryprovisions

of the MC Act of 1956

visavis the applicability

2 Notwithstanding the of the Indian

Medical Council Act repeal
1 956 theeducational
and other provisionsof the
standards requirements
Indian Medical CouncilAct 1956 and the rules and

regulationsmade thereunder shall continue to be in

forceandoperate till new standards or requirements

are or
specified under this Act the rulesand
regulationsmade thereunder
i

XCXlXXCJCCXXJCJCXXX

3 That the petitionerhas been able gather

to available
in the public domain that many collegesthroughoutIndiahave
been granted renewal of to admit the next batch of

202324 students without any That some of the

instances are as under

a
Rama
Medical CollegeHospital 85research Center Hapur
b Panimalar Medical CollegeHospital 85 Research Institute

Tamil Naidu

c
Meenakshi Medical College Hospital and Research
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
Institute Tamil Naidu
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 90
d Saraswati Medical CollegeUnao

e
Medicity CollegeAndhra
f Mada Medical CollegeTamil Nadu

That onlyrecentlythe HighCourt of in a similar case

of Dr BS Kushwah Institute Of Medical Sciences situated at

Lakhanpur Kanpur208024 UP decided Writ C No 28058 2023

vide judgmentdated 27102023 permitting

the college
therein to

remove the deciencies in order to rectify the defects directing

NMC to conduct an inspectionand in case found the

collegewas permittedto reapplyby way of a freshapplication A

true copy of judgment dated 27102023 of the Allahabad High

Court in Writ C No 280582023 is annexed herewith as

ANNEXURE
I

P17

That the aforementioned medical collegealso led

for extension of time which was allowed vide order dated

23112023 A true copy of order dated 23112023 of the

Allahabad High Court in Writ C No 280582023 is annexed

as
ANNEXURE
P18
That under the above facts the presentpetitionis beingled on

the followinggrounds

GROUNDS

A BECAUSE the facts narrated herein above would clearly

indicate that there is clear discrimination on the part of the

respondents inasmuch as on the one hand the

respondentNo 2 to 4 have allowed all the similar medical

collegesto admit the MBBS students for 202324 batch

but on the other present petitionernot been permittedto

admit the students for same course

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
J BECAUSE

the illegal arbitrary

and
discrimination is writ largefrom the impugned
action of the

respondents inasmuch as the other similarly situated

collegeshave been allowed the benet of Public Notice

dated 14072023 in admittingthe MBBS studentswithout

any fresh inspection and without completing any

formalities petitionerhas been deprivedof the

benet of said Public Notice and thus has been deprived

parity

BECAUSE it is an admitted position that the petitioneris

duly registered and recognizedcollege and is already

running with two batches of MBBS Courses and hence

there is ground why

no reason or as to
thepetitioner
cannot be grantedpermissionin terms of Public Notice

dated 14072023

BECAUSE a perusal letter dated 22052023 would show

that there are no deciencies visavis and

there is no deciency regardingclinical materials in the

college of the respondent That the only

deciency pointedout by the inspectionreportis that of the

teaching faculty which is 5714 which is due to the

factor that the collegeof the answering

respondent
onlyhas
2 85
batches presently 202122 1202223and the

deciency that is pointedout to

theoverall 5year

course

BECAUSE the petitioner fullls all eligibility criteria laid

down in the Public Notice dated 14072023 to avail benet

of the said Public Notice and thus the petitionerhas been

deprivedof the same without any justiable reason and

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
ground
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 7
I

BECAUSE it is an admitted fact that the University

respondent
No 5 has soughtclarication in the petitioners

matter with specic pointsand issues but the respondent

No 2 to 4 have decided to keep silent and thus the

conduct of said respondents gives a reasonable and

justiable reason and suspicionof malade onthe part of

the said respondents

BECAUSE even otherwise the NMC or any of its organ

and
has no rightor power to discriminate amongstthe colleges
inasmuch as every institutecollege under the

NMC norms has a right to be considered

forthe benet

beinggivenby way of Public Notice dated 14072023

BECAUSE the petitioners would like to to this

Honble Court that their faculty consists of adequate

doctors and tutors to teach the students for the 2 batches

that are currentlystudyingin the collegeThat currently

there are only 2 batches studyingin the college That in all

there are 258 students currently studying MBBS

whereas the strengthof the facultyof the is around

80 a day each batch has around4 to 5

Further in classes

which facultymembers a day whichshows

onlyrequire10
that there is adequate strength available in the

collegeof the answeringrespondent

the petitionerwould like
to categorically
submit
that there is no in the faculty for the 2
deficiency
batches ie 202122 and 202223 that are currently

studyingin the collegeFurtherthe petitionerwould like to

humbly submit that for the remaining3 years thefacultyis

by the collegeand will start comingto

alreadyemployed the
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 l3
collegeas and when the batch for 202122 to

3 year

BECAUSE regardingthe issue whether there are

patients available for the students to learn from the NMC

reportmay be perusedwhich shows that there were around

442 patientsin the OPD available at the the

inspectionwas carried out The primarybatch of the MBBS

requiresonlyimpartingtheoretical knowledge
and there is

no
practicalexperiencerequiredfrom the patientsthat are

admitted in the college However in the second year the

students start their practicalexamination bylearningfrom

the patientsavailablein the medical college85 hospital
The
reportof the NMC shows that at the time inspection
ofthe
there were around patients which than
442
is more
adequatefor the students to gainpracticalexperience
no prejudicewould be caused
to any of the

respondentsor any other person if the petitioner is also

allowed and permittedto admit the students of MBBS

Couse with 150 intakes which would givean opportunity

to

150 students to get admission in their dream course of

MBBS

BECAUSE the letter dated 22052023 passed by MARBA

respondentno 4 is in violation of the provisionsof the

NMC Act 2019 andin violation of the of natural

justice as it has condemned the petitionerunheard

BECAUSE respondentno while letter

4 MARB issuing
dated 22052023 failed to consider the mandate of Section g

26 of the NMC Act 2019 which provides that the initial

measures case a
in of deciency in collegeare not to deny
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
permissionfor the next batch but are to give a chance to
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 2
the decient the defects
collegerectify to issue warnings

then imposemonetary penalty reduce intake of stoppageof

admission and thereafter recommend for withdrawal of

recommendation However in the present case
respondent
no
4 has taken anvery strict view and any

permission
to the petitioners

N even
BECAUSE the impugnedaction of the is

otherwise not sustainable and tenable in theeyes of law

beinginfringing and abridgingthe and fundamental

rights of the as also of numerous students

enshrined under 14 19
Article 16 and 21 of the

Constitution of India and therefore immediate interference

of this Honble Court is warranted for preventingthe

miscarriageof justice

0 BECAUSE the petitionerhas been caused serious loss

injury and without any of its fault due to

the
impugnedaction of the respondentswhich has otherwise

also caused total miscarriageof and hence

immediate interference of this Honble
Courtis warranted
P BECAUSE the impugned action of the respondentsis
otherwise also discriminatory unfair and and

hence deserves to be quashedand set aside

That under the above circumstancespetitionerAssociationis left

with no alternative but to approachthis Honble Court by way of

present petitionfor necessary relief and redressal It is humble

and respectful submission of the petitioner that the impugned

actions of the respondents are most illegal arbitrary

discriminatory irrational unwarranted irregular

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE unconstitutional and totally without jurisdiction and hence
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 10

11

12

13 Court
1 I

That
Honblethe
justice
petition
petition
including
impugned
petition before
Whether
following
petitionerapproached
petitioner
jurisdiction
petitioner
High petitioner
principles
petitioner
petition
provisions
orno in Honble before
permission
case questions
equally the
fSupreme fHonble
efficacious
Supreme before
respondentsDelhi
ofalternative
inwarranted
oradmitting
prayed petition
High respect
declining
arbitraryremedy3rd
by
seeking
or of
That
available
similar
the
immediate
other
circumstances
writ
this
there
ii to
iiiireliefs
Court Whether
the
writ
interference
Whether
the
batch
of
is the
clauses
of
Court
illegal the
of
mainthe
other
has
has
this
or not
not
students
the
the
of
of
is
and for
letter
Honble
action
of
the
led
the
forthis
any
notification
this
oled
action
led Honble
natural
dated
the
of
NMC
Court
the
any
ofrom
of Court
MARB
Court
relief
law
Honble
22052023
year
involved
similar
other
Act arise
and writ
India
202324
2019
Court
justicewrit
Court
is
in
from
isany
is
the
forin
the
of isin
thein
India
the
instant
other
violation
in
interest
facts
this
third
in writ
any
under
Court
and
this
the
of
writ

way of Writ Petition bearingWP C No 15028 2023 which

75 was

withdrawn with liberty to approach this Honble Court A true

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 7B
copy of the order dated 21112023 in WP C No 150282023 of

the Delhi HighCourt is annexed herewith as ANNEXURE P19

14 That the petitioner has left with no other remedy but way of

appealor revision but to knock the door of this Honble Court of

law for the Redressal of his grievancesprojectedin this writ

petition

PRAYER

Keepingin view the above mentioned facts and circumstances of the

case
it is respectfullyprayedto

i Issue a writ of Mandamus or any other writ

order or direction V

thereby the
respondents to to the

for admission in the MBBS

course a
for period of one year Academic Year
20232024 in terms of the Public Notice
dated
14th July 2023 ANNEXURE P13issued
by
the National Medical Commissionrespondent

No 2 through the Medical

Education Board respondentNo3 herein

Issue a writ of Mandamus or any other writ

order or direction directingthe National

Medical Commissionrespondent
No 2 herein

to respond to the letter dated 27072023

ANNEXURE P16 written by Baba Farid

Universityof Health Sciences respondentNo 5

herein with clarication that the present

MUKUL SHARMA is fullyentitled

petitionerCollege and thus can
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
go ahead with the admission process of current
 iii

Vi Exempt
copies the
Undergraduate
Rating Renewal
permission
tby
opetitioner
Commissionrespondent
respondent
Universityrespondent
petitioners
byrespondent
aof petitioner
by 150
befrom
declining
herein
fMedical
ogranted
ling
Annextire typedlegible
inspection
as sought
through
Courses by
setting
termsP85
Exempt
out
Issue
19
further
academic
Summon
Session
of
issued
dated
aside
P11the
2nd 27072023
the Board
Annexure
issued
Public
writ
year
letter
the N
of 202324
admit 3
orecord
of of the
Notice
Annexure
dated
Medical
Certiorari
the
no3
for
P1
of to
dated
MBBS
rom
N MBBS
the
No to
National
P1 seats
Education
5for
ling Annexure
2videto
Assessment
thethe3rd
its
P19
ile
ANNEXURE
July to
certied
nfor
Medical
carried
Batch
letter
2023
Board and
the
the

copiesof Annexures P1 P2 85 P11 Q3

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 vii Allow the costs of petitionin favour of the

petitioners

INTERIM PRAYER

With the interim prayed that during the pendencyof

petition the impugnedorder dated

P11 may kindly be stayedin the interest of justice as the college and

its students will suffer irreparableharmand injury in case the

impugned order dated22052023 the petitioner college will suffer

irreparableharm and injury

1
ea smhiw
c93lt

THROUGH COUNSEL

SI

TH SAN DHU SHUBIIAM BHALLA

P7812015 P 9002007
YAJU
P
v
BHALLA
11622011

V 9N PURI
Q
GURKAMAL KANDHOLA
PH62892022 P752016
ADVOCATES
COUNSEL FOR THE PETITIONERS
Place Chandigarh
Dated 28112023

MUKUL SHARMA VERIFICATION

2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 23
Veried that the contents of paragraphsno 1 tolq An
true and correct to

my knowledge
whereas that of paragraphs andBlare also believed to be
no
correct on the basis of the legaladvice soughtfor from counsel No part of
my
the same is false and nothinghas been kept concealed therein

Place Chandigarh
Dated 28112023

byN H H
Ilt

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND
ll HARYANA AT CHANDIGARH 30

CWP No of 2023

IN THE MATTER OF
White Medical Collegeand Hospital Petitioner
VERSUS
Union of India and Others Respondents

Affidavit of Dr Dinesh Sharma Aged about 63 So Kedar Nath

Sharma Ro Dr L K Mathur Memorial Tagore Public School
Nalwa Bridge Barfani Mandir W No 25 Pathankot 145001
Punjab
Aadhar No 913818617809 Mobile No 9814195502

1 the above named deponent do hereby solemnly affirm and

declare as unden

1 That the deponentis the petitionerno I in the present Writ

Petition The petitioner no is filing the accompanying
applicationin writ petitionbefore this Honble Court

2 That I have read the applicationfor Placin 8 on record and

understood its contents The facts stated in the application
35 2 are
true to my knowledge
and belief
iii04 That the annexures filed withtheapplicationare
53 of the
true copies
original om filing certified
43
E2 That
typed clear and legi
g
3 O
3533
A
3 g
Place Chandigarh
Date R1 12023 DEPONENT
tvtH
a
Place Chandigarh
Datefa112o23

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 ma 7
W
NoDCfBTl g3a 2014 AGT335
2AQ95f
ceifytiit 1

HS 3158dab been
Amended by
195r
Given undermyhand at Batahathis

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH

Etl 7ZE1l1we4sultrv
rlt
 wgt
11
AOLTlRl3llMT9E1lilElEEllI99JgHis B0AFl1lBF5lt5Ti9
9 ITIYIlll1IME11q1lL lto14zgi ampIiQPIlAL VIJLAiLampnjqrgrggsg
EjfIlgiI9TlfgBMTERY KNOWN as ClliiNTTPURl MEDICAL QOLLEGE E
I

19sI3LI11ji3r on SATIIRDAY 2o112o2a mr VILLILGIE BUNGA1

commune 0 AT mi AND co CLU13 an AT 200 rum

almvmg rtszolmim1 mas pmzircl

RESULEI WAT Dr Dincsli Shamm Chief Executive Ofccr of the Institute be and
is hcrvlvamhoriscd to institute and clefcncl both civil and crimiiml
cases
Conn High Court at Disuici
und Suprrme Court on behalf of the Compcmy amd all legal
prmciings in thecourts of raw on behalf of the compan3anlto file Signand verify
plmmscrimlnal complaints pleadings replications applicaIloris written
stnlIicnc1ls counter claims replies rejolndersappeals revisions in connection with
clue proceeding and to do all mlacr acts dccds matter and things as
necessaryin cninmzminn wiili above iTJ1jwbe

FURTHER RESOLVED TO auihorisc him to

Advocatcfsl and appear in courts in or
to behalf
given evidence onof the company and in engage
AdvocaimslSignVakallrnama for the proper conduct of the case

Certied True Copy

For The White Mcdi College
3 Hospital

Piuthoscd Signatory
The White Medical College5 10

IJJ llnngnl
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
Dnlhuuslc
RoadTehsil5 Dlsil man
we
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL Cnnlndj
gmnlcnm
PHHC, CHANDIGARH 3
 TYPED COP

NationalMedical Commission

Medical EducationBoard

No the Feb 2023

22
PUBLIC NOTICE

National Medical Commission is in receipt of number of

medical
regarding allowed to

conduct Medical
Rotating for ForeignMedical
Graduates

2 A Statewise list of
updated amp Medical
which are allowed by the National Medical
Commission to conduct RotatingMedical
CRMI for Medical
Foreign the numberof FMGS
indicating
seats is herewithfor
attached of Information among all
concerned

Sd
SharanKumar
Shambhu
Director UGMEB

RUE OP

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 TYPED COPY
Punjab
List of medical colleges
recognised
S
No TState U College
Name of Medical Afliatin g University ement
Manag Year
incept
ion intake
Annual efor seats
Availabl
FMGS
Punjab Government
Medical
Baba
of Farid University
Amritsar College Faridkot
Health Sciences Govt 1943 250

Punjab Christian Medical

College Ludhiana Baba
of Health
Farid University
Sciences
Faridkot Trust 1953 I00
Punjab Government
Medical
Patiala CollegeBaba
Faridkot
of Health
Farid University
Sciences Govt 1953 225
Punjab DayanandMedical
CollegeampHospital
Ludhiana BabaHealth
Farid University
Faridkot
of Sciences Trust 1963 100

GuruGovind Singh
Medical College
Faridkot Faridkot
Baba
of Health
Farid University
Sciences Govt 1973 125
Punjab Sri Guru Ram Das
Instituteof Medical
Sciences and
Research Sri
Amritsar Sri Amritsar
Sri Guru
Sciences
University RamHealth
of Das Trust 1997 l50 ll
Punjab Adcsh Instituteof
Medical College
Pathankot
Gurdaspur Bathinda
Adesh UniversityTrust 2006 150 ll
Punjab Chintpurni
Medical
CollegePathankot
BabaHealth
Farid University
Faridkot
of Sciences Trust 201i 150 ll

Punjab PunjabInstituteof
Medical Sciences
Jalandhar BabaHealth
Farid
Faridkot
of Sciences Trust
University 2011 150 ll

TRUE OPY

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
g r

to The
p

Government
To
Ref
Mohall and
SubjectRegarding
Principal College
Qunjab
SOCIETY
A No of
of amp
Medical
CMCH202201
CHINTPURNI Education
REGISTERED
Punjab
Change the
Hospital
Hospital Pathankot
Pathankot
SCHOOL amp
name
UNDER
TYPED Research
College
SOCIETIES Dated
Chintpurni
REGISTRATION
EDUCATION
COPY From
White ACT
Medical
SOCIETY 1860
04052022
College
Medical

Sir 33 V
Respected
It is to inform you that we intendsto the name of
change
from
ChintpurniMedical Collegeamp
Hospital to The White

amp
MedicalCollege HospitalPathankot In this connectionplease
find
enclosedherewith of School Education Society
letter No CSESResolution2020 dated 05122020 alongwithall
connected documents duly received by The Additional

of SocietiesCum GeneralManager
Registrar on 27012022 Now we are

willing to publish notice in issue of State

GazetteNotication Hence I requestyou to issue necessary orders for

this purpose Gazette I shall be highly
obliged

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 Pleasenote thatthereis no in SchoolEducation

Societywhich as per Certicate of Societies

of Registration

bearing
No DICBTL2305 20042005 dated 18032005

Sd V

Yours
Chairman
SchoolEducationSociety
BungalPathankot
Enclosures As above

VILLAGEBUNGALDALHOUSE ROAD
TEHSHIL amp
DISTT PATHANKOT PUNJAB

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 33
Commission
Medical Assessment RatingBoard MARB
NoM2001 1 2021MARBNMC035083 Dated 30082022

To
The
Medical College
amp
Hospital
Bungal Panjab
Emall

The change
Subject of name of medicalcollege
from Medical

CollegeampHospitalPathankot to The White

MedicalCollegeand
Hospital

SirMadam

The undersignedis directed to refer your three letter nos

CMCH2022142 CMCH2022143 amp

CMCH2022144 dated 1708
2022 on the subject
cited

2 In this regard
you are to submit the following
document for

of thecase

i An Affidavit mentioningthat there is no

changein other

ii structureof Medical College

exceptname change
Letter head amp other material the name of medical

collegeshould also display

the old name for 5 years

New NameThe White Medical and Hospital

College Pathankot

Formerlycalled MedicalCollegeampHospital
Pathankot

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 Q3

iii Copyof letter of permission establishment of

for newmedical
collegeand recognition
letterfrom obtainedNMCMCI

Yours faithfully

Sd
PrabhatKumar
Under to Govt of India
Copyto

1 The RegistrarBoba Farid Universityof Health Sadiq

NagarFaridkotPunjab151203
Rd Society
2 GuardFile

TRUE OP

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 it
in
NonRe ortable

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Civil Appeal No 155 of 2021

Chintpurni Medical College and Hospital amp

Anr

Appellants
Versus

Union of India amp

Anr
Respondent s

IU D G M E N T

L NAGESWARA RAO

1 i
The Appellants the Medical Council of India
for permissionto admit 150 students in MBBS course for the
I

academic year 20192020 The Board of Governors in

supersession of Medical Council of India rejectedthe request

on Writ in the
21052019 The Appellantsled a

High Court of Delhi questioning the correctness of the

dated 21052019
proceeding The HighCourtdismissed the
Writ Petition by its judgment dated 09122020 This Appeal

is led the said judgment

challenging
2 The rst Respondentgrantedletter of permissionto the
rst AppeantColege on 30062011 for intake of 150

students in the MBBS course for the academic

year2011

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 Lin
As
the inspections out by the assessors of the
Medical Council of India revealed gross deciencies of the

teaching faculty clinical material and the other physical

facilities in the medical college the Board of

recommended that the renewal of permission should not be

grantedto the rst AppeantColege

for the academic years

20122013 and 20132014 The Writ Petition led by the rst

was dismissed by the Punjaband Haryana

High Court pursuant to which no admission could be made

for the academic years 20122013 and 20132014

3 The rst AppellantCollege sought renewal of

permissionfor the academic year 20142015 In view of the

deciencies in teachingfaculty clinical material and the

other physical facilities in the college recommendation
was
made by the of the Medical Council of

India not to renew the permission for the year

20142015 whichwas accepted by the rst Respondent The

rst informed the AppellantCollege on

15072014 that the request for renewal of permissionfor

admitting150 medical students for the academic year 2014

2015 was rejected

4 Orders were issued by this Court on 18092014 and

20092014 in Writ Petition C No469 of 2014 titled as

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
52 Page
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 Hind Charitable Trust Shekhar Hospital Private
Limited l Union of India Ors by which private

medical for renewal of permission

collegeswhose application

was disapprovedwere permittedto make subject

to the undertakingby the PresidentChairman and Secretary
of the Medical Collegethat there is no existingin
the college
medical This Court held that if the

was be
found to at the time of next

inspection of the medical college the bank guarantee of

RupeesTen Crores furnished by the shall be

forfeited of penalty
byway The second

submitted an undertakingon 28092014 that there is no

deciency existing in the facilities and that in the event of

any deciency being found in the inspection the bank

guarantee of Rs95 Crores shall be forfeited

upon the undertaking the rst AppellantCollegewas

permitted to admit students for the academic year 2014
I

2015

5 Renewal of permission
for of 150 for

the academic year 20152016 was rejected after an

inspectionwas conducted and it wasfound that there were

gross deciencies of clinical materialteaching

facultyand other physical facilities The rst Respondent

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
3Page
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 My
accepted the recommendations of the Medical Council of

India and rejectedthe requestof the AppellantCollegeto

grant renewal of permissionfor admissions for the

year by its 15062015

6 On 16122015 physical assessment for grantof

recognitionwas carried out Another physical assessment

was on
held 2526 February2016
as there were allegations
against the rst AppellantCollegerelatingto arrangingfake

faculty residents patients etc onlyfor thepurpose

of Medical Council of Indias It was decided by

the Medical Council of India to conduct another surprise

physical inspection In the surprise inspectionwhich was

conducted on 16032016 deciencies were found on the

basis of which the Medical Council of India

the Central Government not to grant recognition

to the

AppellantCollegeunder 11 2 of the Indian Medical

Council Act 1956 The rst Respondent accepted the

recommendations made by the Medical Councilof India and

decided not to renew the permission for admission for the

academic year 20162017

7 The OverSight Committee recommended grant of

conditional recognitionsto privatemedical colleges which
was dated
acceptedby the rst Respondentby a notication

MUKUL SHARMA
4
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
I Page
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 no
26092016 Conditional recognition was granted to the

MBBS degreeawarded to the students admitted in the

rst
Collegeonthe followingtwo

14n undertaking on afdavit from the

and the Chairman of the Trust afrming that the

deficiencies pointed out by the assessors of the Council

in the compliance verication assessment stands

rectified
II A bank guarantee for a sum of Rs2 crores in favour of

the Council which shall be valid for a period of one year

or
till such time the rst renewal inspectiontakes place
whicheverisate1
8 A verication assessmentwas held on 07032017 to

verify the claims of the rst Appellant Collegethat they

have all the minimum requirements necessary for

recognition In the verication the followingdeciencies

were found
Deciency of faculty is 8712 as detailed in the

report
ll Shortageof Residents is 8235 as detailed in the

report
I OPD attendance was 401 at 2 pm on day of

assessment againstrequirementof 1200 Very few

patients were seen in OPD at the time of visit
M Bed Occupancy was NL on day of assessment There

was the round

NL admitted patientseen during

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 W
V There was only 1 Major NL Minor on day

of assessment
VI There was NIL Normal Delivery NL Caesarean
I

Section on dayof assessment

VI CT Scan workload is NL on dayof assessment
Vll Histopathologyworkload is NL on day of assessment
X CUs Except 1 patient in SICU there was NL patient in

CCU MCU PCU NCU

I

X Labor Room There was no woman in Labour Room It

XI appears that data in the Registeris

Data of Number of Admissions Discharge

Radiological Laboratoryinvestigationsas provided

by institute are grosslyinated V

XII CasualtyThere was NIL patientat time of round

Xlll Speech Therapistis not available Only space is

provided for SpeechTherapy

XIV Nursing Staff Very few Nurses were seen in the

hospitalduringthe round
XV Paramedical Staff Very few paramedical staff were

seen
duringthe round
XVI Orthopaedicsward was locked duringthe round
XVII 0 Ts Some 0Ts were locked during the round Some

are not
X properlyequipped
Vlll Examination Halls These are temporary structures
I

without lightfan Deciency remains as it is

XX Central Library It is not airconditioned Capacity of

Students readingRoom Outside is only 32 against

I

requirement of 150 Available Internet Nodes are 32

againstrequirement
of 40 Deciency as it 5

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
6Page
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 ll3
XX Students Hostels Available accommodation is for 453

students against requirement of 565 Ancillary

facilities are as detailed in the report
XXI Interns Hostel Available accommodation is for 42

Interns againstrequirementof 150

XX Residents Hostel ibtal 40 rooms are available against

requirement of 85 They are partially furnished

Deciency remains as it is
XXI Residential Quarters Only5 quarters are available for
faculty against requirement of 26 NL quarters are

available for Nonteachingstaff

9 The Medical Council of India recommended to the

Central Government that the rst should

be debarred for two years ie 20172018 and 20182019

from admittingstudents and to encash the bank guarantee

furnished A decision was also taken not to consider rst

the
Appellant for processing applications
for
courses for the academic year 20172018 There was also a

recommendation to initiate for withdrawal of the

proceedings
recognition of the courses pursuant to a cause

noticewas given to the collegeon 24032017 The rst

Respondent accepted the recommendations of the Medical

Councilof India and debarred the rst from

M

making admissions to MBBScourse for the years

20172018 and 20182019 The rst Respondent also

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE 7Page
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 W
permittedthe Medical of India to encash the bank

guarantee
M
b

10 Pursuant to a givenby this Court by itsorder

dated 01082017 the status of ratication of deciencies in

the rst AppeantColegewas reconsidered and

adecision
was
taken by the Executive Committee of the Medical Council

of India not to the rst

for the award degree granted by Farid 0

of MBBS
of
University Health
Sciences

11 In the meanwhile students who were admitted in the

rst AppellantCollegeduring the years 20112012 2014

and 20162017
2015 were shifted to other colleges
12 Thereafter the rst requested the Medical

Council of India to permit admission of 150 studentsin the

MBBS course for the academic year The Medical

Council of India rejectedthe request of the rst Appeant

College According to the Medical Council the

conditional granted to the rst AppellantCollege

has become invalid in view of the failure of the rst

AppellantCollege to comply with the conditions stipulated

therein It was mentioned in the letter dated 21052019

that proceedingspursuant to the show cause notice dated

24032017 are underway The rst AppeantColege was

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
8Page
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 bl
advised to make an under Section 10 A

of the grant of
Medical Council Act 1956for
I

permission to admit for the 2020

2021 Aggrieved by the order dated the

led
a
Writ Petition in the HighCourt of Delhi which

was dismissed
13 The High Court held that there is no merit in the

contention of the Appellants that admissions for the

academic year 20192020 should withoutany

further as the debarment by the notication dated

inspection
26092016 was only for a period of two years As the relief

claimed by the Appellantsfor the year 20192020 cannot be

granted the High Court whether any relief

can be granted to the Appellants for the academic

year
20202021 The HighCourt took note of the fact that there

are students in the rst

admittedlyno as

those admitted for the academic years 2014

2015 and 20162017 have been shifted to the other

The request made by the Appellantsthat thereshouldbe a

direction for inspectionwas refused by the High Court as the

V

last date for grantingpermissionfor the academic year 2020

2021 was 31082020 As the recognitionof the collegehas

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
Pa 9 e
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 Ki
not been cancelled the Appellants were given liberty to
make an application for renewal of recognition

14 We have heard Mr Dhruv Mehta Senior

Counsel for the Aishwarya

Appellant Ms Bhatilearned
Additional Solicitor General for the rst Respondent
andMr T
Singhdev learned counsel for the second Respondent The

contention of the Appellants that the ban for

students imposedby the rst Respondenton 26092016 is

only for a periodof two years ie 20172018 and 20182019

was Court the

rightly rejectedby on that

they were not entitled to make admissions for the academic

years 20192020 and 20202021 without any inspection

Reliance placed by the Appellants on the order dated

10052018 passedby this Court in Writ Petition C No423 of

2017 is misplaced In the said Writ Petition request of the

Appellantsthat theyshould be permittedto make admission

for the years 20172018 and 20182019 was While

dismissingthe Writ Petition an observation was

madethat
the Appellantswould be entitled to pursue their request for

permission for the academic 20192020 and 2020

2021It does not mean that the to

admit for the academic year without an

inspection A bare look of the inspectionsconducted from

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
10Page
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 WI
the 20112012 makes it clear that the Appellantshave
not utilized
theopportunities given to them to rectifythe
deciencies in the past The Medical Council of Indiahas
even recommended cancellation of the recognition granted
to the Appellants in view of lack of infrastructureclinical

teachingfacultyand other facilities

15 We nd no merit in the contention of the Appellants

that the Medical Council of India committed an error in not

permitting admission of students for the academic year

V

20192020 Havingfound that the request made by the

Appellants for permittingMBBS course for the academic year

20192020 had become infructuous the High Court rightly

considered the entitlement of the AppellantCollege
for the

academic year 20202021 In accordance with the time

schedule xed in respect of permissionsto be grantedto the

medical colleges for admission to students the last date for

grantingpermissionfor the academic year 20202021 was

31082020 As per the schedule an application for renewal

of permissionshould have been made by the on

o7o72o2o We nd no fault committed High Court in

bythe
refusing permission to the AppellantCollegefor making
admissions for the academic year 20202021

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE 11Page
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 g0
16 We
arein agreement with the High Court that the

AppellantCollege
is a recognised College and that it is open

to the second
totake appropriatestepsunder
Respondent
Section 19 of the Indian Medical Council
Act As the
recognitionwas for a period of ve years which in the
ends
year 2021 it is open to the Appellantsto applyfor renewal of
the recognition Any application preferred by the Appellants

shall be considered in accordance with law by the second

Respondent We make it clear that the

shall be entitled for admissions for the academic 2021

2022 only of the recognition is granted to the rst

AppellantCollegeand it is found that

g

there are no
deciencies like infrastructure
clinical teachingfacultyand

other facilities

17 For the abovementioned reasons we see no merit in

the Appeal and the same is accordinglydismissed

n NAGESWARA mo

j
S ABDUL

lNDU MALHOTRA

I4
January
New Delhi
28 2021 If a
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
12 P g e
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 me
WHITE
Bill i0UHiE 1 HOSPHM

DETAJLS OF EXPENDITURES IOR COMPLETING FULL MEDICAL COLLEGE INFRASTRUCTURE

sex Nomenclature Quantity
No
1 Triplestorey Hostel buildingswith attach Kitchen and Washroom 102 Rooms
2 Construction of additional Rooms in girls Hostel with attach 40 Rooms
washroom I

3 ComputedTomography Scan Wipro GE Health Cate 01 No

4 Cath lab Innovation Imaging Technology
Complete Pvt Ltd 01 No
5 Dialysis Machine Fresenius Medical Care India Pvt ltd 03 Nos
6 New Modular OperationTheatre Nanak Surgical 02 Nos

Purchase of new Ventilators 22 Nos

9 02 lac sq t oor tiles newly fitted in collegebuildings
9 150 lac sq ft area Inter lock Tiling on internal paths roads
collegepremises
10 False ceilingin auditorium 22000 sq ft
1 LectureTheatre both AC and furnltures
ooring
12 Completednew Lecture Theatre with 500 seating capacity at 4th
floor

l3 Installed servo control stabilizer 01 No

14 Puztohase of New ambulances for Hospital Patients 25 Nos
15 Renovation and paints collegepremisesbuilding 18 lac sq ft
16 Gymfor MBBS students 01
k

17 Install new A0 in Hospitaland collegespremises 49 Nos

18 Install geyser in Hospital Girls and Boys Hostel and private rooms 200
19 33 Smart TV set in Hospital and collegepremises 33 Nos
LED
20 Skeleton and mannequin
in Anatomy
departments

1wn Rs 138 Crores Rupees one hundred Thirty Eight ct res

Note yl
Ifyou so desire you can take the photography
of the above works do
I

stalwart
iamloarsw
vm Bungal
Dalhousie Tehsil mm Pathankot
Road Punjabi I15
WW CNEGE
Contact01 mmKwUNm

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
wig
 n i7

5Vr
TYPED C0Pi1

Phone 25367033 25367036

Fax 00911125367024
Email
Pocket14 Sector8Dwarka
Phase1New Delhi77

NationalMedical Commission
Medical Assessmentamp
RatingBoard MARB
UNDERGRADUATE SECTION

No NMCUGR2020000049015529 Dated 11042022

LETTER OF LIMITED RENEWAL OF RECOGNITION amp

PERMISION
To
The Principal
Medical Collegeamp
Chintpumi Pathankot
Hospital
amp
Medical College Hospital
Near DLM valley
ResortDalhousieRoad
BungalPathanlotPunjab145001

Sub for Renewal of by Medical

and Hospital
College under Baba
Pathankot Farid University
of
Health SciencesFaridkot dated 28012021
passedbythe Honble Supreme
Court of India in Civil AppealNo
155of 2021 Surprise on O7 amp
08 January
2022Virtual
hearingheld on 250222Appealto MOHFW for renewal of
recognitionVi1tual hearingon 060422 for AY 202122
Limited renewal of amp for 150 MBBS
CourseMARB of NMC us 2628 29 amp
35 and section612 of
the NMC Act 2019 for the Academic year 202122

DearMadam

Chintpumi and HospitalPathankot

Medical College was granted
Punjab
Letter of Permission for its establishment on dated 30062011 for

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 gt

admitting150 MBBS students annuallyThemedical collegewas

thereafter conditional
granted dated26092016 The medical

the academicyears 2011122014

has admittedstudentsduring
college
201617 who had been later shifted to othermedical
15 amp under
orders from the Honble amp
Punjab Haryana Courtas well as the
High
Honble Court Thus the medical collegehas
Supreme non
functional the medical collegewas debarred from

for the academicyears 201718 amp

freshbatchedof students

201819 by the Central Govt on the recommendation

of the
MCI has
The medial college the Honble Delhi HighCourt
byway of WP C No 79182019whichwas decided on 09122020
wherein the decision of the erstwhile MCI to not to
grantpermission
admit fresh batches of studentsfor the academicyear 201920 amp
202021

without conductionan was

upheld The Honble
Court vide judgement
dated 28012021 passedin Civil AppealNo 155

of 2021 hadconrmed theaforesaid dated09122020 passed

by the Honble Delhi HighCourthoweverhad the medical

collegeto applyfor renewal of recognitionalongwith permissionto

admit studentsfor academic year 202122

Since the Conditional Recognition

dated 26092016 was Valid for a

periodof 5 years ie 201617 to 202021 thus the collegehas applied

vide dated01092021 for grantof

Renewal of and permissionto

Recognition admit fresh batch of 150

MBBS studentsfor the academic year 202122

The Medical Assessment ampRating Board of Medical

Commission had conducted a surpriseinspection
of the infrastructure

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 st
facultyresidentsclinical materialas well as other physical
facilities
availablein the medicalcollege
on 07 amp
08 January
2022 for Renewalof
to admit freshbatchof 150MBBS students
and permission

for the academic year 202122 The dated 01092021was

application
initially since therewere no batchesof MBBS
studentswho were currently trainingat the
teachingamp
medical collegewho will finallybe granted
MBBS

The decisionwas communicatedto themedical

vide letter dated12012022

The medical collegehas an affidavit dated

19022022 with letter dated 21012022 requesting
for of
renewal of and for 150 MBBS students

The Medical Assessment and RatingBoard had thereafter granted

an

of personal
hearing
to the medical collegeon 25022022

virtual mode and vide letter

informedthe medical collegethat grantof Renewal of Recognition

could
not be consideredsince there were no batches of MBBS

studentswho were currently and training

teaching at the

medical college who will

nallybe grantedlBBS
and also that the inspection
of the standard of examination which is

whenthefinal yearbatchof MBBS students

conducted in
the nal examination for the purpose of grantrenewal
of recognition
could not be carried out There were no nal year MBBS students

in the nal examinationfor assessment the

during
nal examination for grantrenewal
of recognition

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 Sf

The medical hadsubmittedan appeal

06042022 to the Honble

MinisterMinistryof Health and FamilyWelfareGovt of India

for granting
requesting of renewal of and permissionfor
recognition
150MBBS studentsin the academicyear 202122 The same
to theMedical Assessmentand
hasbeenforwarded Board to take
Rating
necessaryaction at the earliestunder intimation to the said Ministry

The Medical Assessment

amp Board has
Rating conducteda
virtual hearing
on 06042022 with the Principal
Off the Medical College
and veried the facultyinfrastructureand patient
load as
per the
notified on 28102020 and also directedthe to

submit an afdavit as per the regulationsnotied on 28102020

thatthereare
certifying no deficienciesin theMedical College

The Medical Assessmentamp

Ratingboard in View of the aforementioned
thatall the previous
factsincluding had to
batchesof studentsadmitted

be shiftedto othermedical on account of deciencies

as well as since there are batches of MBBS studentswho
presently no

are amp at theMedical College

who
currently teaching training
will nally be grantedMBBS and also the fact
qua1ications degrees
that assessment during
the final examinationscould not be conducted
has

decidedto grantlimited renewal of to the Medical College

for theacademicyear 202122 onlyandalso to grant to admit

I50 MBBS studentsfor the academic year 202122 only The Medical

Assessmentamp Board is
Rating the presentcommunicationafter
issuing
considerationof theaffidavitsubmittedbyyou

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 The present is valid for one yearand for onlyone
the annual intake of 150MBBS seats during
batch of studentsagainst the
academic year 202122 The next batch of studentsin MBBScourse will

be in the college
onlyafter Assessment
of Medical
amp
RatingBoard of NMC for renewal Admissionsmadein
recognition
violation of the above conditionwill be treated as and action
irregular
will be initiatedunder NMC Act amp made there under

Discrepancies
if any may be brought
to the notice of the

Medical Assessmentamp Board of theNMC andthe StateGovt

Rating

We are furtherdirectedto inform that you and your institutionis fully

to fulll
responsible and maintain norms
including both

and human
physical andclinical materialetc
faculty
the academicyear as stipulated
in Regulations
ofNational
Medical Commission In case declaration or
falsewrong
NMC
fabricateddocumentshave been used for of the
permission
MARB and the said misconductis broughtto the notice of National

Medical CommissionNMC or found during assessment at

surprise any
the current academic
stageduring is liable not be
year Your institution

of the degreeThis letter of permission

consideredfor recognition will be
revoked for the current academic year in such exigency
arise Besides

National Medical CommissionNMC is entitledto takeall such measures

you and your collegeinstitution as permissible

underthe law

It is to a websiteon theMedical College

and displayall the information of the college courses offered faculty
available and their of the last 5 years studentsjoined and

afliatinguniversity the hospital

To display servicesfacilitiesavailable

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 5

and the in each specialty

also OP and IP census

births and deathsas

including per the municipal
government
records

Kindly thereceipt
of thisletter

sd
MemberPresident
Medical Assessmentand RatingBoard MARB
NationalMedical Commission

Copyforwarded for informationand necessaryaction to

1 The Deptof Healthamp
FamilyWelfareGovt of Punjab
Mini Email

2 The Director of Medical EducationGovt of PunjabSectior69

SAS NagarMohali 08 Email
3 TheRegistrarBaba Farid of Health Sciences
Sadiq
RoadF aridkotPunjab151203Email
4 The of the Govt of India Ministryof
Secretary Health amp
family
WelfareNirman BhawanNew Delhi1 10011
5 The Assistant Director General ME DirectorateGeneral of
HealthServices352A Nirman BhawanNew Delhil 10011
6 The Pocket14 Sector8
National Medical Commission
DwarkaPhase1 New Delhi110077
7 The President
UnderGraduateMedical EducationBoardNMC
8 DM1II NMC
9 Guard File

TRUE OPY

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 7
Sr
COP 1
p
National Medical Commission
Medical Assessmentamp
RatingBoard

No NMCUGRENEWAL202223048166 Date26102022

The
Medical amp
College Hospital
Near DLM ValleyResort
BungalPathankotPunjab145001
Email

Sub Renewal of for MBBS Course for 2 batch lst

renewal of ChintpurniMedical College Pathankot under Baba
Farid University
of Health SciencesFaridkot against the annual
intakeof 150MBBS seats u s 112 of the IMC Act 1956to be
read with section 612 of the NMC Act 2019 for the
Academic year 202223

SirMadam
I directed to convey the
am of Medical amp
Rating
Board MARB for renewal of for admissionof 2 batch 1s

renewal the annualintakeof 150MBBS studentsat

Medical CollegePathankotus 112 of the IMC Act 1956to be read
with Section 612 of the NMC Act 2019 for the academic Year 202223
The MARB has grantedapprovalafter consideration of the affidavit
submittedbyyou

2 The Permission is valid for one year and for admitting

onlyone batch
of MBBS studentsagainstthe annual intake of 150 MBBS seats during
the academicyear 202223 The next batch of studentsin MBBS course

will be admittedin the collegeonly after of Medical

Assessmentamp
Rating
Board of NMC for

3 Admissionsmadein violation of the abovecondition

willbe treated as
andaction will be initiatedunderNMC
irregular Act amp made

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 53

thereunder if any may be to the

notice of the Medical Assessment amp Board of
rating and the
theNMC
StateGovt

MemberPresident
Medical Assesmentamp Board
Rating
National Medical Commission

Copyforwarded for infonnation and necessaryactionto

l The Addl Chief Secretary
Healthamp of Health
amp
FW
FamilyWelfare Governmentof PanjabR No 314 3 Floor
Mini Secretariat Sector9
Punjab
The
Sector
Director of Medical EducationMedical Education
69 SAS NagarMohali 140308
The Baba Farid University
Registrar of Health SciencesSadiq
RoadSociety
NagarFaridkot
The SecretaryGovt
of India Ministryof Health amp
Family
WelfareNirman BhawanNew Delhi
The ADG ME Directorateof Health Services Bhawan
Nirman
New Delhi
Guard File UGMARB Section

Sd

Medical Assessment amp

RatingBoard
National Medical Commission

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 C

v V
l 1o s
Awmwere
l
I

AIn vzozo
0 LZ
NATIONAL MEDICAL COMMISSION
Q
ASSESSMENT
2
FORM FOR ANNUAL INTAKE OF 150
ADMISSIONS
5
INCREASE IN INTAKE FROM TO
E
For AY 202223
Part AII

to be filled by the Assessors

All relevant sections of IMC Act1956read with sec 612 of NMC Act 2019

11 Type of Assessment

Letter of Permission
US 10Aregu1arcompliance renewal 2 renewal 30 renewal 4 renewal
15
U S 10A Increase CapacityRegular ComplianceLetter 2nd renewal
3 renewal 4h
Admission
renewal
of Permission
15irenewal
US 11 Recognition RegularCompliance

Continuation of Recognition

11
I
2
Any Other 2 Surprise

I
I

N g
Dr Amn Lara Agarwal Dr Sy anazirAli Dr Decpak
Malviya Dr Jasvindcr Knur Kohli 1
cg
MUKUL SHARMA I

2023.11.29 15:42 Signatures xi

TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL of theAssessors D816 15052023 A

signatures
01 mp tI 9
ixE9
Qi Q5
A

PHHC, CHANDIGARH q
cftag
CW
c
 All V2010
FORMNMC1UGASESSMENTFORM

Name of the Institution THE WHITE MEDICAL COLLEGE 8 HOSPITAL FormerlyKnown as

A
Chintpurni
Medical College8 Hospital
Add155 1 NEAR PATHANKOT
DLM VALLEY RESORT BUNGAL

TelephoneNo 01870256001

Email

CollegeMebsile wwwllxewmcl1gmaicorn
NMC Letter NoampDate 2 NMC letter dated 1805203

Assessment Date 18052023 Last Assessment Date 15122022

PC Courses No

Particulars of Assessors

Name of the Assessors Correspondence

Address Contact No Email

Dr Arun Lain Agarwal GB Pant Institute of Postgraduate9968818184 drala2016gmailcom

8 Medical Education amp Research
New Delhi
Dr SycdManazir Al Jawahar Lal Nehru Medical 983714555 manazir1958yahoocom
CollegeAMU Aligarh
Dr DeepalMalviya DR RML lMS Lucknow 8176007063 drdm58gmailcom
Dr Jasvindcr Kaur Kohli ABVMIS Dr RML HospitalNew 9810563556
Delhi

r
hs in i9
Drrun LitaAgnrwal DrDccp1k ulviya Dr vin KnurKohli

MUKUL SHARMA
Dir
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
ofthc Assessors
Signatures Date 18052023 Si
A

PHHC, CHANDIGARH
gnaturcs
at I
tier cs
gViA
 A41 V2D2D
FORlvllsMC1UGAF5SMENTFORM

12 The Collegehas followingthis is to be filled

The only duringLOP and Recognition
campus plotis
I unitary ox

BuildingPlan approval
from the competent
authority Name PWD B No PWD BampR
Pathankot No 316 Date
14102015

Building Use Occupancy

authority competent 14102015 amp BampR
Pathankot No 316
Certicate from
the Name PWD B No PWD Date

13 DeanPrincipalDr Sunanda Raina with 32 of teaching

experience 11yrsof professor 05 yrs of experience
years of
Assoc Prof She is also holdingthe postof Professor in the Department
of Anatomy

DrAmnLaLaAguwa
l lib
MUKUL SHARMA
I9 DrDccpnk
iyn Drlns Ne
mdc nur Kohll

2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
of the
Signatures Assessors Dam l8052023
36Spacemks
54
80 42 sq
College
Dean
Staff Principal
Room
Office Space
Council Requirement
Office
Room Requirement Yes
Yes 100
56 sq mt
Available mt gtx
A
me eff
ATP i
 AIt v1ozo

E
14 Medical Education Unit 04052022
MEU

traininghas been undertaken

Details of the Orientation programme and Basic Course Workshop Ludhiana

undergoneby MEUNo of programmes organizedduring
Academic year No of People attended proceedings to be
verified at the me of assessment
Date s of the above workshops Nil

Details ampDuration of Workshopsin Medical Education Nil

conducted
Technology by MEU
Details of facultywho have undergonebasic course workshopin 3
Medical Education Technology
at the allocated NMC MCI Regional
Centre
Details of faculty who have undergone advanced course

workshop in Medical Education at the allocated

NMClCI RegionalCentre

Feedback evaluation of workshops taken reports on the

I

basis of feedback obtained A L

1
KI I
Dr Arun 1

Dr Kaur Kohli F

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
K prgj A

Date 13 05 2023
Ja r h
qQ5
1

PHHC, CHANDIGARH
Signatures Assessors amp p
I

Signatures
lt2S3QQ
Name Designation
ofihe of
Available
Name
Name of as per
the
theNIEU
NMCRegulations
Experience
MCI Regional Nodal Centre
of affiliated facultywhere above Yes
DrLudhiana
Professor
Ashok Forensic
ChananaMedicine
anI61
w
 FORMNMC1UGkES5MENTFORM All V20l0

15 ContinuingMedical Education 04052022

No and Details of CMEsworkshoporganized

by the collegeheld in Nil
the past 1 year

Details of the credit hours awarded for the pastone year NA

16 a CollegeCouncil 04012023

Name designationcontact no and address of the President Dr Raina WMCJI M9419195926

Secretary
Compositionof the Council HODS as members Principal Dean as Details attached
chairperson
No of times the Council
College meets per year 02
min 4
Details of collegeCouncil meetingswhere students Welfare was In campus
discussed and Action taken reportdetails comments in annexure ll

lt9 at
Dr Arun DecpakMalvnyaDr 155 Ind C3
Lataiganyal r d nazlr I Dr KuurKohl1
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42 1
Date
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
7 ggt
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH Signatures
ofthc Assessors 18052023 Signatures
of en
amp
sex
 F0 Ail V20Z0 I

116 b Curriculum Committee Yes 06052022

g
The Names of the Members to be mentioned
Dr Ashok Kumar Dr SwaranjitDr KuldeepSingh Nikita Kalara
Sodhi Dr Dr Ridhum Tuli

17 PharmacovigilanceCommittee Present
No of meeting
in the previousyrs 01 Minutes to be checked

18 Examination Hall

Requirement Available
No 1 2 3 Available 02
Area 250 Sq mt 260 Sq mt each
Capacity 250

19 Lecture Theatres
Medical college Hos ital
Req Available Req Available Comments
Number 4 5 1 1

Capacity 180 each 180 each 200 200

Type Yes Yes

Gallery
AV Aids Yes Yes

Dr a
viya Kohli

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH DrC1olithc
Assessors
Date 18052023

rb3
 A41 V202D

110
C

Library0800 AM to 0800 PM
Aiconditioned Yes
orlting Hours
a room
Stack Available
b ReadingroomAvaiab1e
as
Required Available Remarks

Area 1500 Sqm 1500 SqIn

Student Reading
Room 150 Capacity 150 Capacity
Inside
Student Room
Reading 50 Capacity 50 Capacity
Oubide
Staff ReadingRoom 30 Persons 40 Persons
Room for
Residenl PG
readingroom
Farticulars Required Nos Available Nos Remarks
No of Books 11000 11072
IournalsIndian 70 85
JournalsForeign 30 40
lntemet Nodes 40 45

Boys8 Girls
12l1Common Room for

Area Available Area

Sq Mt Sq Mt Toilet Attached YN
Boys 150 152 YES
A

Girls 150 153 YES

Qwx
Dr Arun Lula Aganval r Dccpal viya Dr Kohli I r A

I9 Jas t
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH Signatures
onhc Assessors Date 18052023 Signatures
of
lt Ga
Q
 FORMNMC1UGASSESSMENTFDRMAll vzozo

112 Central Section

Photography Available Yes 649
Staff Yes
Equipments Yes
113 HostelLocation Within campus
Available AC Visitor room AC
Capacity 1 l Hygieneoi Studyroom with
No of6 Computer
internet 8
H0991 CS Rm5XCPaCi Mess Hostel Recreation room with Remarks
Ifq1
P yof
ota
AlumP YN TV Music Indoor
Games
capacity YN
UG Students Boys83 in triple Adequate
50 Capacity 565 beds YES YES YES YES
Girls 90 in triple Adequate
beds YES YES YES YES
lntans 50 Adequate
Capadtv 150 150 YES YES YES
Resident 100 Adequate
Capacity 85 86 YES YES YES yes
including PG
Nurses 20 75 75 YES Adequate YES YES YES
Capacitv

Residential Quarters

Category RequiredNos Available Nos Remarks

Teaching 20 50 50
Staff
Capacity y

Non Teaching f 36 36

20
ftaf r
Calmlty
W
Dr Arun Lara Agarwal Dr Dr O 55

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
7
l
Jnsvi r QV

PHHC, CHANDIGARH Signatures

ofthc Assessors D816 l8052023 Signa ofD

9gt
z FORMNMC1UGASSSSMENTFORM theV2020 Is theYes yes amp
21
117 Play
Type
Outdoor
Indoor games
games
Gymnasium
Name
115Gender
116 Ragging
biometric
Biometric
No
Anti
eld
ofOwned
ofgames Society
by Hospital
5 Harassment
A4
offacilities
114Recieational
3 Devices
Facilities
b
c Committee
devices
ye
Committee
Whether
installedallinYes
record devices
of are working
college
thebiometric
Yes
Indoor
Available
attendance
TEACHING
outdoor
conditions
available Not
HOSPITAL workingfor last 02 days
55

an 4c
D rArun Law A Dr naz Dr Jasv Kohli
S
1Der ya
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
W n
of the Assessors
Signatures Date l8052023
1
1
1
E
a
i
E
s

22
23

Dr Arun Lam Agarwal

MUKUL SHARMA C1UGASSESSMENTFORM
Assessors
FORMNM Name
Dr the
patients
Enquiry
Separate
JavedBhatti
Teaching
Medical rooms
All
and
Administrative
OPD
No
available
Are
No of
of
ofthe
Staff waiting
SeparateRegistration
Adequate
Availability
Timings
registration
Supdts
Registration
Registration
registration
Superintendent
teaching
r
I2o2o
available
Desk
Medical
for
other
offor computerized
counters
Office
MS
Officecounters
counters
examination
facilities center
infor
offor
eachabove
patients
department SpaceRequirement
areas
area
areas for
OPDIPDMS Yes 154
patients
witl1
available
MDmale female years
experience
Dr 38 sqyyes
02
yes
Availability
1 yes
mt
ES
36Kohli
02
150 mt to 0400 PM
AMmt
administrative
0900
yes
available
yes
sqMt sq
sq
Dcep
2023.11.29 15:42

J
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL Date I8052023
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 FORMNMC1UGSESSMENFORll AMI VZ020

24 Facilities available in OPD

Dr Arun zxa rwai Dr

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
SQ6 T
PHHC, CHANDIGARH Assessors Date
ufthc
Signatures amp
Injection
Dressing
Surgery
Orthopaedics
Ophthalmology Malviya
Dressing
Speech
Audiometry
Immunization
Infertility
FamilyBaby 18052023
Therapy Room Plaster
ampKohli each
cutting
ENT
Medicine
Plaster
Dressin
Pdiai5
OBS room
Female room
room
room
GYN
Male
Female
Male
Female Yes
Yes
Refraction
Well
Child
Antenatal
Cancer Dr
Detection
Rooms
Rehabilitation
Welfare
C
Clinic
Rooms
Clinic
linicClinic
Clinic
Clinic
ECG
Minor
Minor
AC
Clinic
OT
Room in proof
Procedure
Sound room
surgicalspecialty
Room Y es
Yes
Yes
YES
YES
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Y
5
Jm
x

iI
1
I S Medicine 01
01
01
03
01 130
100
600
75
20
20Outside
10
75 130
100
600
75
10
20
75 Campus
130
the 8Beds Store Demo Remarks
V V

Dermatologv
Orthopedics
Ophthalmologv
G61
03 Departmem
Surgery
Teaching
If PG courses
CYN Hospitals
03
02
vzozurunning
are Of Required
130
20 beds BedsDistance
Teaching
BdS Campusrequirement
Total
Beds Station
Nursin
to Y Room
Treat Campus
YY two Room
YYY Duty
accordingly
Room
YYY 2515m
N RemarksCapacity
YYYRoom NICUPICU06
6 Beds
Gen
Pediatrics
Medicine
Pscl1iah
ENT
Total
25
RspiratorTotal T314
Number los in Available
with Total be
YN increased
between
630
Exam
WithinYN beds
YN should be YN lCU
lCCUI0
SICU08

Dr Aganral Manazir
Dr Dr Y3 D 3
QQ
MUKUL SHARMA
M All
i
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
ofme Assessors
signatures 13052023
Date Signatur
 I

All v20z0

26 Clinical material Random verification to be done by the Assessor

9V

Item on the Day of Remarks

assessment
OPD attendance at 200 PM 150
On rst day
i Casualtyattendance 01

E 24 hrs data
No of admissions 00 w
discharges 00
g N of
occupancy at 1000AM 126
E Bed on

rst dav
g Operative Work
No of majorsurgicaloperations Nil
No of minor surgical
operations Nil
No of normal deliveries Nil
3
No of caesarian sections Nil
Radiological
No Investigations
3 of patients OP D LED
5 02 02
Xray
02
C

Ultrasonography 02
1 Contrast Xrays
CT Nil
5 Scan 02

Dr Aru Lam 21
Agarwal Dr d zir Ali Dr Deepa iya Dr Ja ind Kohli
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH Date
Signatures
oF1hcAsscssors 18052023 Signal
rc
V
C

x
 FORMNMC1UGASSESSMENTFDRMAi lt 2LU
7

V20Zl Uc
8
llJ

f X
Item On the Day 0 Remarks 0
assessment
f
Laboratory Investigations No of
Patients samples 0P D lPD
8
128 92
I

Biochemistry E
Microbiology O U
8

Serology Nil J
L V

Hematology
40
5
2
Clinical pathology
Histopathology 02 I
V

Z
07

DrDecpak

DjsCd dalviyzi
om
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
of the Assessors
Signatures
DrJ
18052023 signatureso
 FORl1NMG1UGSF5SIl ENTFORM All VlO2O A

27 Medical Record Section

Manual ComputerizedComputerized
ICD X classication of diseases followed for indexingyesno
28 Central casualty
services
No of Beds Required 30 Available 30
00
Number of CI4O postedShift 04 Noof CMO presentduring Assessment round 02
Number of nurses posted Shift 06 Total No of CMO 04
0
Separate
casualty
for OBGY cases
available if yes N o of beds 06
Equipment Availability Number
YN
g Central Oxygenamp
suction facility Y 30

Pulse oximeter Y 02 4
i
Arnbu bag Y 03

Machine
Ultrasonography Y 00

Crash Cart Y 01

Emergency
Drug Tray Y 03

Debrillator Y 01

Ventilator Y 07

Xray Unit Mobileamp

Xray Static Y 01

Minor OT A

Y 01

Comments
Dr mm Lam Agarwa Date Dr J5Vi
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
Signatures
ofthc ASSCSSOTS
eQAa 18052023 llli Signatures
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH

Signatures
Obstamp Assessors
Agarwa
A4lV1Dzo Syc Dccpzik ya 13052023 Si 0
A i I I

29
110Dr
211 Arun Ememency
Surgery
Separate
Operation
Equipment
Lara
Clinical
Central
Gen
Ortho
Gvne
ENT
Sgpc Major
Ophthal
ofthc Type
Nlinor
pt Clinical 93
Q1
Laboratory
Dr
1for
Laboratories
sections
theatres
available
3
1
Ql
Q pathology
in O Y
Y
Y
TYUnderDrcontrol
Requirement
microbiology
Block Specifynumbers
Y
YY
Y YNofDate
YNitrous
Oxide Anesthesia
department
Y
Y
Y Dr JYiv
Machine of 2 biochemistry
vi nmy
5igtV
Available
mi Y Kohli
Y
Dr
Y Remarks
ators
Defibrill
YN Prof Y
Suman Y YN Pumps
YInfusion
available
Micro YN Remarks
lt
b 09 MP
z
1

E
available06 2 06
4

212
213 No ofPreoperative
tic CasesOperative
Cases
Room
Intensive
Clean
Labor
of AlR
Post V2llDFollowing
ooms
Care Bedsintensive
Bedsavaable areas are available

5
Edam sia

Dr Arun Lala Agarwal

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
Assessors Date
PHHC, CHANDIGARH Signatures
ICU
SICU
ICCU
NICUType
ofthc PICU Required
Becis
5
5 Available
Beds
Z
Q Q of18052023
DrDeepaassessment
Malviya
01
Q1
day
Q1
Patients DrJz1sv
one AC
YN
X
Y Oxygen
Carma
Suction
YNY
1 P0159Yes
Major Equipment
0Xlmel
etc
YN
MonitorAB G APP0lIlfd
Yes Appointed
Yes any
Remarks 11

J de
5
2

1
X
60
100
300
S001000 Equipment
Spiral
XEquipment
XRay
Ray Required
Required Approval Functional Functional
posxvt2 214 Radiological
ue4sszssveMTogM
Mobile
Static
60DmA
CT
slice
n mA Mn
mAMinimum
Facilities16
Q3 no no
Available
E
Q PNDT
AERB
YN
X the
the
Functional
time
time of
of
1
Y
YNXassessment
Status at
at
assessment
Status Remarks
Remarks two
four
ifif any
any
USG X I 1 functional

it
Dr

MUKUL SHARMA
Arun Lam Agarwal yaw
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH of the Assessors
Signatures d MnnazirAli Dr Dale K0S2023
Deep Malviyn Dr Jas
9
 Blood Bank Yes
Available and functional Yes
Number of units dispensed in a day
Number of units stored on dayof assessment
License valid up to under process LICENCE NUMBER AND COPY TO BE APPENDED AS ANN EXUREVII
All v2ozo Facility Available
Blood Separation
0 T i

215
216

Pharmacy available List to be included

i I
14
0
w
No of substores located in different partsof hospitalNA

217 Central sterilization Department

0
Timings 0800 to 0800 PM Shifts 06
0
EquipmentHorizontal autoclaves Sterilizers yes 2 in number

Separate
receivingand distribution points Yes

218 Intercom Available yes

No of incominglines l57Noof extension Lines 145

119 Central laundryAltemativeArrangements

In House

Typeof Laundry MechanizedAutomatic

Drrun
J iiin at
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
Lam

A
garwal D S anzizir Ii

ii
DrDeep Malviya
W
Date l80S2023
aurKohli

p
F Q Qvg
cg
ORIGINAL signatures
of can
Q
ltewgu
PHHC, CHANDIGARH

Emit
 Provision of specialdiet yes
m LIJ
F0s9ftxit1UIsSSESSMENTFOTt available Zto
L

4 Services
Food freeof
220 v Kitchen
InHouse Alternative
nutritionistdietician
ofa charge
AiV201D Arrangements
yes Number of patientsAll admitted patients m
X
0L
U
c
u

E2E
of Canteens 03 For staff 301 For students
I

2213 Total no 01 For PatientsRelatives01

6
222 Arrangementsfor Biomedical Waste Management
0
Outsourced if outsourced append specifydetails of facilities available
MOU If inhouse please
223 Central Research Lab
Available Yes
Facilities Adequate
9
Research Projects
0
CompletedNos 12
o 04
OngoingNos

Dr Lam Agarwal Dr Manazir Deep Malviya Dr

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
81 Assessors
Ja5v
Date 18052023 A
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
Signatures
ofihc Sigmilurcs
of Q
c p

K
 FORMNMC1UG
ASSESSMENTFORM
AIl VZ0z0

224 Nursingand Paramedical staff

Nursingstaff No of Beds

Category RequiredNos Availabl Nos

Staff Nurses 309 309
Sister Incharge45 45
ANS 12 12
DNS 05 05

Nursing 01 01
Suptd
Total 372 372

Paramedical N 05
Required Available Nos
And 187 187
Non teaching
staff

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH am A Assessors
val Date 18052023
Dr Arun ofthe
V T

Signatures Dr Dr E 3Rx u
0 lt5 9cR
AIt J w
 Au V3019 MEDICAL

31
CollegeVvebsite
COLLEGE N
Sr N Details of information YesN0
1 Details of Dean Principal and Medical Superintendent Includingtheir name Yes
qualificationcompleteaddress with telephone and STD code and Email etc
2 Teaching s taffResidentdoctors nonteachingstaff Technical staff Nursingstaff yes
amp
adepartment designation amp
wise with joining date 13 Unit wise faculty resident list
3 Details of the affiliated universityand its ViceChancellor and Registrars yes
4 Citizen Charter No
5 List of students admitted meritwise categorywiseUG amp PG for the current and yes
previous year A

6
7 Result of all the examinations of last one year mil 1
Details of members of the Anti RaggingCommittee with contact details including yes V W74
landline Phone mobile email etc
8 Details of members of the Gender Harassment Committee with contact details including yes
landline Ph mobile email etc
9 Toll free number to report ragging yes
10 Details of the sanctioned intake capacityof various courses UG as well as PGs by the
MCI with the scan copiesof permission letter
11 research publication d uring the last one year No
Any
12 Details of any CME programmes conferences and or any academic activities conducted Yes
by the institution
13 Details of any awards and achievements received by the students or faculty No
14 Detailed status of recognitionof all the courseswiththe scan copies of permission yes
letter
15 Details of clinical material in the hospital
16 unit deptwise beds distribution Yes

r
Dr Arun Lata Aganval r
Deep viya Dr 3215indc Kohli
Dr Dr

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH ofthc Assessors
Signatures Date 18052023
 g

All v2ozo
4
l

31 E

32
a Collegetimings 0900AM To 400 PM
gV dd

Programme
Teaching
Didactic
teadiing Yes
5
2
Demonstration Yes
Vertical Yes
E
V

teaching
Clinical posting Yes
Clinical Pathological
Conference Yes
Grand Rounds Yes
StatisticalMeeting Yes
Seminars Yes

TeachingFacilities

33 Anatomy

Required Available Required Available

Demonstration Rooms 02 75 each AV Aids 02
0
No 02
o
Capacity 75 to 100students
0
Histologypracticallaboratory Yes Museum seating 50
Number of Lab seats 75 Capadt 100
0
Number of microscopes 59 Mf9d SPECmens
Dissection Microscgxas N Models Wet amp
D3
Dissection Hall 75 Be 595 Al1d
5 Disarticulatecl
MRI 8 CI Nil
iv
Dr Arun Lata Agnrw Dr cd Manazir Ali Dr Dr Jasvi
ftQ
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
JC1M Dccp
PHHC, CHANDIGARH ofthc Assessors
Signatures Dale 8052023 Signature
0 1

lc lt63
 Required
AII v1u2o

Available Required Available

Q
Number of dissectiontables 15 Number of cadavers 06 Available

Cold store coolingchambersCapacity 02 with 08 capacity

each
of Bodies H ragetank
Embalming
room 01 Band saw yes

I0ClltE15 150 Library Available 90 b00llt5

80100Books

Adequateexhaustlightwater supplyand drainage

facilities Availab1enot available

34 Physiology

Required Available Required 7

Demonstration Room s Available

02 AV Aids 01
N0 50 each
Capacity
Library 80100 Books
Departmental 90 Haematology
laboratory 01

Clinical Lab
Physiology 01

Dr Arun A garwal Dr Kohli

Q36
Azgt
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH of the Assessors
Signatures il Date 18052023
Jm ean
Q1

9lS
 All V 2020

35 Biochemistry

Required Available Required Available

DemonstrationRoom 5 2
N0 so each
0
Capacity
Number of practicallaboratoryies Aids Seminar
Library
AV rooms
80l00 Books 100
01
Number of Lab seats 60

36 Pathology Required

Available Required Available

Demonstration Rooms
No
0
Capacity 01 50 AV Aids 1
Practical labs
Morbid AnatomyHistopath
Cytology
Microscopes
0
Clinical PathologyHematology MicroscopesT 01 20gt

Departmental library 80100Books 100

Service Lab
Histo pathoIogy 01 students Seating
Capacity 80
specialized CytopatholoHematology
Any gy Specimens
Catalogues
0o
Museum
Unmounbed
Mounted 100
work

Ia
Agarwal Dr
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
ofthc
Signatures Assessors Deep Date 18052023 Kohli Signatures
Dr Malviya Dr of

ar v
2
 AH vzozu

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
38Arun Lara
Signatures Assessors
00I Aga
practical students
s 80100
so100Books
Books 01
Lab7 DeepaMnlviyalBO52023
il each90 50 Charts seatingcapacity Yes AV3llal7l9
g
Dr
37 Computer
Capacity
Pharmacology
Departmental
Departmental
Microbiology
oflhc
Number Virology
Demonstration
NC
BSL2
N0
Number
Clinical
Demmstraon microscopes
laboratory
Lab
of Required
library
library
Required
Assistedlrning
Iof seats
students
service
lab
Rooms
Room laboratory
laboratories
Lab microscopes
Dale
0250
60 capacity
20Dr
Available
yes
N
01Available Specimen
seating
A utoclaving
Museum
Media
AV AV History
Catalogues
specimens
preparation
capacity
Mannequins
I00
Kohli
AidsCharts
Models
Museum Aids Washing
Required
facility
and8drawing
Required
of Medicine
Models Catalogue
room 85105252050
0Y5 CQ1 n
available
Nil
Ye5
Available C
l

3 lt9Q J4x 9
i Jn WW
 I l V

39 AlV20lD

Forensic Medicine gg
DemonstrationRoom sRequired 03
Available AV Aids Required Yes AV3ll3ble
No
Capacity students
Forensic Medicine Practical Lab Yes Museum
AutgpsyB10ck Specimen100
MedicoLegal
Location In Near hospital separatestructure
in a Ch55 50
Cold storage Capacity of Bodies me am575
Books 80 es
Departmental
library sumo
PoisonsJ00
0
10020
Photographs
0
Catalogues20
310 Community Medicine

Required Available Required Available

Demonstration Room s 02 AV Aids Available
N0 80 each
Capacity students
Museum yes Practical lab 1 Avajjable
0
Charis 100
Models 50
0
Specimens 30
0
Catalogues 20
Library so100 Books
Departmental Available 90
books

J
Dr
m
Ag
Lam Agarwal Dr Dccpa alviya aur Kohli

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
r D
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL Date 18052023
PHHC, CHANDIGARH Signatures
of the Assessors
 All V2010

311 Health Centers Departrnent

of Community Medicine
RHTC Shahpur 15
Kandi place Distancefrom the college

Dr
4
Ql
Arun Lara Agarwal Dr d ManazirAli Dr Dee ak MalviyaDr his in

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL Assessors Date
isofthc
Signatures the
any in 18052023
the yes
yes
T b I A V M I V

PHHC, CHANDIGARH Specialist

Population
Separate
Daily
Survey
Acvies
It
No
No of chain
Facilities
Coldof OPD
lnterns
beds
afliatedforequipment
cooking
vcovered
isits
toGirls
blocks
under if
MCHImmuniza
StudentsVisit by
College
for dining
National
8Posted
the rooms
available
RHTC
Yes per
No registers
Health
tionFlper having
Yes
batchProgrammes
batchthroughout
No boys jrooms
the
year
year
bedsFor Interns
having Yes
Yes
More
Yes all
NA than 2 lac
medical
Medicine specialists
surgery OBG
available
Anesthesia
iI

l Was
3130o0 DCentre the
University
eDeficiency
Population
Daily
Diagnostics
Survey
Specialist v2uzo
cany
standard amps
writtenpractical
NMC 18 20197
appeared
by
College FPPlace
PartIIwas
posted batches
registersonly for Yes
ofDistancefrom
34501000
satisfactorily
asrequiredcollege
byRegulations
312 tisax
section
No
The
No
CONDUCT
It 1
ofsfor
ofOPDA1which
visits
OF
Candidates
MBBS
Students
1afliated
of
612 MCHof
if
UHTC interns
examination
to
IIIImmunization
covered conducts
if
and
sufficient
MBBS
any
Act theExamination
examination
inUHC
Examination
EXAMINATION
KM
Y for
esNo MBBSin Examination
conducted
BFUHS
NA NA
Moth under
NA 112 of the Medical Council of India read with
9 Dr Agnmal
J LLiU
Signatures Dr Manazir Ali Dr E3
MalviyaDr
Deepak
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH of theAssessors JM
Daze 13952023 Signatures
0
TnPrincipal
u
XX
I 7N11
PG
16 arne
16
Number
i

314 A 7V202D
College212
of of Medical
Courses students
No 17
The If8Strength
White Medical
CollegeStaff 13
3yes
13 NO specifyamp
College
I

HospitalBungal
4 14
9 19 10
5 15
Pathankot 20

a
I
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH ofthe
Signatures
Dr Arun Lula Assessors
Agarwal Dr Sy ManazirAli Dr DcepakDate 18052023
Malviya Dr Jmvin e r Kohli Signatures
0

9 W
J O9
 All v
zozo A

0
Calculation Sheet Date 18052023
W
Additional

Department faculty Total

Designation UG 9
Accepted Deficiency
Professor if any PC
Assoc Prof
1
1
01 5
Assttprot 3 91
Aatmy oz 01 Sanctionleave
Tutor 5
Professor O4 01 Sanctionleave
1 02
Assoc Prof 1
Assttpmf 3 01
Ph513Y
Tutor 3 02 compensate1 Prof
02 01
pmfsm 1
As Prof 0 01 sanction leave
1 01
31031935hY 2

Tutor 4 0 0201 sanction leave

02 02
Professor 1
Assoc Prof 01
Assttprof 2 02
3 01 oz
Tutor 4
01 03

Prof 3 01

l Pathology Aoc
AssttProf
3
01 02

I
Tutor 5
62
gm
I Microbiology Assoc Prof
AssttProf
1
3
4 03
Tutor
i
Dr Arun Lata Agarwal
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH SignatureQrlhcixsscssors Date l8052023 Signatures
 ll
All v 2910 Designation per MSR UGas
Requirement PG
Addt courses Tom Accepted D atrcxency 5
as any gg 9
Professor 1 01
Foratsic Medicine Assoc Prof 1 01
AssttProf 1 01
Tutor 3 02 01

Professor 1 D1
Assoc Prof 2 02
C mm AssttProf 4 O1 03
StatisticianCumTutor
1 O1
Tutor 4 02 02

Professor 1 O1
G1 Mde Assoc Prof 2 02
AssttProf 3 01 02
Sr Resident 3 03

Professor 0 01
A Pr f 1
Paediatrics 1 01
AtfProf
Sr Resident II 01
1
Professor 0
Assoc Prof 1
Respiratory 1
Medidne AssttPro 1 01
Sr Resident 1 01
Professor 0
I

Dermatology Assoc Prof

AssttPro 1
1 a1 01
Sr Resident 1 D1
4

it
Dr Arun Lata Agarwal d Dr
ErDeep
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
ofthc Assessors Daze 1go52o23
Jan
lmn
 FORM
Amv zozo Additional

Department
faculty Tom
Accepted
av
Designation
as Deficiency
1if
P5ychi at Assoc Prof 1 01
AssttProf 1
Sr Resident 01
1 01
Professor 1
Assoc Prof 01
Gma al S
r 2 03
Prgeq AssttProf
3 O2
Sr Resident 3 O3

Professor 0 01
Assoc Prof 01
Orthopaedlcs 1
AssttProf 1 01
Sr Resident 1 01

Professor 0
OIoRhino Assoc Prof 0
Laryngology A5sttProf 1
01
Sr Resident 1 01

Professor D
Assoc Prof
0Phtha1m1gy 0
AssttProf 1 01
Sr Resident 1 01

Professor 1 O1
Obstetrics Assoc Prof 1 03
Assttlrof 2
Sr Resident 2 01 01
Professor 1 01
Assoc Prof 2 01 01
Anaesthesiology AssttPro 2 02
Sr Resident 2 oz

Dr Arun Lara Aganval D Dr ur Kohli W

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
QtVofthc
Signatutcs Assessors Date 18052023
13 S935
TH
0
re H0 y

PHHC, CHANDIGARH 8
 All
2o2o Q3
Department Designatign Requirement Additionalfaculty
as
requiredfor running Toml
per MSR Accepted
UG PG courses Deficiency
Profasor 1
gg
R a d 10 D xagnosls Assoc Prof 1 01
Assnof 1 01

3 1 01
Sr Resident 01 02
Profasor
o
Assoc Prof 1
AssttProf 0
Dennsm 1
SR 1 01 1
Professor 01
1
01
Emergency
Medicine
tPff 1 3
SR 9
09

Notes
For purpose of workingout deficiency
the

1 The deciencyof teaching

faculty
and Resident Doctors shall be counted separately

A For TeachingFaculty
a For calculating the deciencyof facultyProf Assoc Prof Asst Prof Tutor in respectivedepartments shallbe counted
together
b Anyexcess teaching facultyin highercadre can compensatethe deciencyof lower cadre of the same
c Anyexcess teaching facultyof lower cadre categoryin any department cannot compensate
department
the deficiency only
of any teaching
facultyin the highercadrecategory of the same department or any other department eg excess of Assistant Professor
cannot com ensate the deciency of Associate Professor or Professor p

1 teachingfaculty of any departmentcannot compensate the deficiencyof any teachingfacultyin any other
Dr Arun Lam Agarwal Dr DcepakMa 1 Dr

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
5y
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
ofthe Assessors Date 18052023 Signatures
TH F AL
DIRECPRINC
of liz
PHHC, CHANDIGARH

E
i1
i
v gt

VZDZu
d Details
Excess the any
management attendance
Professor
signed
night Noany amp
Declaration should
any done for 2000 comingafter
I

Only
ResidentsSenior
1100
315
Sr eg
and
B
a
tr
C
3
2 facultyresidents
A
Forseparate
ofResident
department
Colleges
Any
Anyaltcess
Excess
am
excess
run by
excess
the
of
of
of
SR FacultyResidents
SR IR
rfirst day
unning
AllJR
department
same
Residents
can
extra
of
who
Assistant
of of
be
PG
Doctorsassessment
on
com
cannot pensated
compensate
teaching
of not
program duty
fcountedaccepted
department
Dentistry
aculty
require
cannot
1200 compensate
cannot
toof compensate
deficiency
deficiency
same
tsheet
the
Dental
he or
additional
noon before staff
faculty
1100 JR
offtdeficiency
am
verication
the
other
ois not
he
SR department
deficiency
ofrequired
in
beds same
onthe
of
the same
other
rst SRday
cannot
any JR
SRforms
of
other
JR compensate
orequirements
department
oforwhere
f or department
dental
in only
college
aassessment
as other
be
per
shoulddepartment
the
the
is be facultyresidents
deficiency
Regulations
available
PG veried
the osame
inIn f case
SRJR campuscity
oflunior
No Name Designation Department RemarksReasons
for Not Considering

We Ca
12w17 JpliuP

Dr Deepa iya Dr Jasvi dc Ii

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
Am of the Assessors
Signatures Date 18052023 Si es of
 U
C
C

lg
I
g
316 1 Deficiency
of TeachingFaculty 5714 O
5
2 Deficiency
of Resident doctors 6451 E
3C
317 Statusof dischargenoticenoticesissued in respect of irregularadmissions UGPG if
any I
E
Summaryof Assessment V
I
1 ie White Medical College HospitalBungalPathankot FormerlyKnown as
ChintpurniMedical
Collegeand Hospitalis run by Society
2 The collegehas gotPermission from GOI NMC with intake of 150 seals for the last academic
year
3 Typeof assessment Renewal Recognition
No of seats 150

4 PG courses No

5 Deciencyof teaching
staff if any

Shortage
of teaching
facultyis 5714 For UG
6 Deficiency
of resident doctors if any

Shortage
of resident doctors is 6451 For UG
7 of
Deficiency the infrastructureof college
and hospitalIf any Pl mention category
wise No

8 of
Deficiency clinic terial If any Pl mention category
wise AdequateL
Dr Kaur
J law
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
oflhe Assessors
Signatures
S D3 13052023
Kohli

Signatures
of canPrincipal
FT iiCAL
PPJ ampiiilikl
TPUiiJAB
 son ENTFORMAll v2ozo
MNMC1UGASSSSM

9 LIJ
0
Any otherRemarks ZW
as
C
L
en
X

2
E
5
cu

C
U
U
cn

Dr Arun Lala Aganval Dr Manazir Ali Dr Deep Malviya Dr Jasv nd Kohli

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH of the Assessors
Signatures D316 l3052023
 Q
g1ll5iPhone25367033
hasFax 25367036
25367035 titrco14 ems armvtit
00911125367024 13 itat77Pocket 144sector8
mgxg M in 3 mmm mampgnl DwarkaPhase 1 NewDelhi77
gmml

National Medical Commission

Medical Assessment 8t RatingBoard MARB

FLNOA
NMCUGR202324 o 2 5 Dated 052023
q z
DlSAPPROVAL OF PROPOSAL FOR 3 BATCH 2 RENEWAL OF 150MBBS
SEATS FOR THE ACADEMIC YEAR 202324

The DeanPrincipal
The WhiteMedicalCollege8 Hospital
VillageBungal Dalhousie Road
Tehsil Distt Pathankot Punjab
Email facultymchgamllcom

Subject Request for 3 Batch

for permission of 150 MBBS seats by The
2 Renewal
White Medical CollegeampHospital Pathankot Punjabunder Baba Farid
of
University HealthSciencesFardikotPunjab the Academic Year 2023
for
24 us 261ab and 2812 of the NMC Act 2019 Disapprovaiof
proposalreg
SirMadam

MedicalAssessmentand Rating Board of National MedicalCommissionvide letter

No NMCUGR20Z22304816672 dated
26 October2022 grantedpermissionfor
renewal of MBBS Course for 2 batch 1 Renewalfor the annual intake of 150 MBBS
seats to the College the Academic Year 202223
during
2 As per the directionsof Medical Assessment and RatingBoard MARB an
of the
inspection Collegewas conducted on 16 December2022 to assess the
of facultyand infrastructure
facilities in the College Based on the Assessors
reportUGExpert the Committee decided to issue the Show Cause Notice to the College
with the following
deficiencies

i of Teaching
Deficiency Faculty 37
ii of ResidentsTutor
Deciency 24
iii OPD attendance 600442 inadequate
lv Bed Occupancy 6048 Inadequate
v Blood Bank licence Not available
vi BSL2 Lab Under process
vii lCU Facilities inadequate
viii Clinical Material lnadequate
ix Hostelfacilities inadequate
x Number of Major8 Minor Surgeries
and Number of deliveries Nil
xi Central Library NonAC reading
room

inadequate
Capacity
xi Websiteof theCollegeis not changed
namechanged as the name ofthe college
hasalso
c
25

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 3 Medical Assessment and RatingBoard of National MedicalCommission again
conducteda Physical Verication Assessmentof College
Compliance on 18 May2023 and
based on the Assessors Report
the following
has been observed

a Gross deciencyinthe clinical material on the dayof assessment

b OPD attendance i5O
c Bed Occupancy 126
d Major Operations Zero
e Minor Operations Zero
f Deliveries Zero
g Radiological also inadequate
investigations
h Laboratoryinvestigations
Inadequate
i No Admissionand No discharge
on the dayof assessment

j Shortageof TeachingFaculty 5714

of ResidentDoctors 16451
llt Shortage
4 Inview of the above the application renewal of permissionfor
of the Collegeseeking
3 Batch 2 Renewalof 150 MBBS for Academic Year is herebydisapproved

5 No further in this regardwill be entertainedby the MARB for the

AcademicYear 202324

the receipt
acknowledge
Kindly of thisletter2 pages

V4 7
7gt
entRating
Board
V NationalMedical Commission

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 9

BABA FARID UNIVERSITY OF HEALTH SCIENCES

SadiqRoad Faridkot151203 PB
INDIA

Fax 01639256234
Vwwbruh5acjn Email

73 Date
31gsyj

Chintpurni
Medical College Hospital
VPO Bungal
Distt Pathankot

Subject Withdrawal of Afliation Temporarily

for the session 202324
This is to inform you that the Competent of the University
Authority has ordered for
withdrawal of Affiliation of your collegefor
Temgorarily the session 202324 on the

followinggrounds

1 The University
conducted surprise of the college
inspection on 17022023 to check the
facilitiesavailable for MBBS150 students
Gross deficiencieswere found in the college
as as
well hospitalas per report

2 The issued
University a Show Cause Notice bearingno 06BFUHSColleges
C420233334dated23022023 uponthe collegeintimating
gross deficienciesfound
in inspectionreport as why the Universitymay not withdraw the provisionalaffiliation
of MBBS course with an intake of 150 seats The collegewas requiredto sent replyto
the Principal
the ShowCause Noticethrough

3 The managementof the collegevide letter no WMCH2023198 dated 11032023

sent
to Show Cause Notice which satisfactory collegevide
reply was not found and the

letter no 06BFUHSColleges20233986
dated 13032023 was to send
requested
replyto Show Cause Notice properly
4 Another letter no WMCH2023202 dated 14032023 received from the management

of the was againnot satisfactory

college

PTO

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 00

5 As per Clause no 482 of University Act No18 of 1998 and Clause no 10 of

Rules and Regulationsfor afliation of Collegesand those under which

afliation may be withdrawn dated 10042007 the rightsconferred on a
collegeby
affiliation may be withdrawn in whole or in part or may be modified if the collegehas
failed to comply
withany of the provisions
of the statutesor the

affiliationor if the affairs of the collegeare conductedin a manner which is prejudicial

to the interests of education I

In extensionof the above the collegeis not allowed to admitanystudentsto

courserunningunder the University
for the session 202324

This letter is beingissued with the approvalof the Competent of the

University

Registrar

Endst Date
A copy is fonvardedto the following
for information
1 The Principal to Govt of IndiaMinistry
of Health amp
FamilyWelfare ME1
Section New Delhi
2 The Principal Secretary
to Govt of Punjab Departmentof Medical Education
ResearchCivil SecretariatllSector9 Chandigarh
3 DirectorResearch Medical EducationPunjabMedical EducationBhawanSector69
Mohall
The Secretary National Medical CommissionPocket14 DwarkaPhase1 New Delhi
The PrincipalChintpurni Medical College Hospital VillageBungal Distt Pathankot
PA to Vice Chancellorfor the informationof the Honble Vice Chancellor
PA to Registrar
for the informationof the worthy Registrar
Controllerof Examinations
9 Finance Officer
10 Proflncharge
11 lncharge
Meetings
12Master copy r

Registrar

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 QTYPEDCOP l

National Medical Commission

Medical Education Board

No U 12023012023UGMEB Datedthe 14 July

PUBLIC NOTICE

of
Subject CORof
I
MBBS
for the year 202223
degree
Consideringthe NEETUG 2023 Medical
that were due for due upto the
year 2023 and have not been communicated
forspecic denial or

stoppage
of for the academicyear 202324 by MARBNMC
are for a
hereby
granted period
of ONE YEAR ONLY ie
AY 202223 for all the admitted MBBS batches uptothe academic year

201819

These medicalcollegesinstitutions
are allowed to batch of

MBBS studentswith the same intake as in theacademicyear 202223

Sd

Dr AmnaiV
Vanikar
I

UGMEB

TRU COP

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
l we
cwp135592023 1

IN THE HIGH COURT

AT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA
CHANDIGARH
I0

CWP135692023OampM
Date of decision 25072023

White Medical College

and Hospital
Petitioner
Versus

of Punjab
State andothers
Respondents

CORAM HONBLE MR JUSTICE RAVI SHANKER JHA CHIEF JUSTICE

HONBLE MR JUSTICE ARUN PALL1

Present Mr GurrninderSinghSenior Advocatewith

Mr Shubham BhallaAdvocate
Mr JatinderSingh
Gill Advocate
Mr SiddharthSandhuAdvocateand
Mr Varun Pun Advocate
for the

Mr ArjunSheoran
DAG Punjab
Mr Naresh KumarAdvocate
for No3 University

tltllt

RAVI SHANKER JHA CHIEF JUSTICE Oral

CM11802CWP2023

AnnexuresA1 to A4 are takenon record

is accordingly
Application allowed

CWP135692023 OampM

Learned senior counsel for the petitioner

submits that

subsequent
to the ling of this petitionthe petitioner
is in receiptof

notice dated 14072023 issued by the National Medical

A1
Commission in short NMC and other documentswhich were not

before the and other authoritiesat the time of

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
the impugned
issuing orderdated31052023 P28 prays
He therefore

lofz
 2023PHHC093686DB

CWP135692023 2

that the may be to the

Universityby ling a detailed which may be directed to

I

beconsideredbythe University
Learned counsel behalf of
appearing
on
therespondent
submitsthatthe issue regarding
University of the
shifting of the

is already
College beforethe learned
pending SingleJudge

wherein the NMC has alreadyenteredappearance He submits

further

thatthe hasalso received

University fromthe

NMC its disapproval

to the afliation of the petitioner
College

takingall the aspectsinto

and therefore the
I

would consider the if led bythe petitioner

In view of the the

aforesaid is to
the respondent
approach Universityas prayedfor and the

if led by the petitionershall be considered and by the

decided

University
as earlyas possible

Petition is accordingly of

Pending also standsdisposed

application of

RAVI SHANKER JHA

CHIEF JUSTICE

ARUN PALLI
JUDGE
July25 2023
ndj

Whether YesNo
Whether reportable YesNo

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
ta
Neutral Citation No2023PHHC093686D8

2amp2
 93

Wt
jTYPED COPY in

THE WHITE MEDICAL COLLEGE amp

HOSPITAL

FOMERLY DNOWN AS CHINTPURNI MEDICAL COLLEGE amp

HOSPITAL

RefNo WMCH2023360 Dated 26072023

To
Chief to the Govt of Punjab
Secretary
Chief Office6thFloor
Civil Secretariat1
Punjab Sectorl
160001

Subject Continuation
of COR of MBBS 4

for the year 202223

Honble Sir

We havereceivedthe Public Notice issuedbyNationalMedical Commission

vide No Ul2023012023UGMEB dated 14 July 2023 where in we are

collegeand we requestyou to kindlyallow

recognised us to admit fresh batch
of MBBS studentswith thesame intakeas in academicyear202223

Sir In case you desireto seek clarication from National Medical

Commissionyou ask them whether The White Medical College amp
can

HospitalFormerlyknown as Chintpumi amp

Medical College Hospitalcovers
to admitfreshbatchof 150MBBS students
thenoticeattachedalong

Thanking
you

Sd
DirectorPrincipal
The WhiteMedical College
amp
Hospital
BungalPathankot
Honble Vice ChancellorBaba Farid Universityof Health Sciences
FaridkotPunjab

VillBungal Dalhousie Road Tehsil amp Punjab

email Contact
01870292300
RU OP

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 I

I05
3
TYPED COP

BABA FARIDUNIVERSITY OF HEALTH

RoadFaridkot151203PB
Sadiq
256236
Phone01639256232
INDIA
Fax

wwwbfuhsacin Email

No Date

The PresidentUGMEB

NationalMedical

Pocket14 Sector8 Dwarka

Phasel New Delhi

Subject Clarification of Public Notice issued vide

U l 20230l2023UGMEB datedl4072023

We havereceiveda communicationfrom the college

thatthe University
should allow admission in the collegeas in a Court case Honble High
Court has ordered that the should consider the requestof
University
collegein lightof the Public Notice NoU 12023Ol2023UGMEB dated

1472023 issued bythe NMC and take decision

Vide separateletter No Ref NoWMCH2023359 dated26072023the

Collegehas requested
for assessment by the University

Earlier on the University

17022023 had foundthis college
with gross

for admissionsThereafter
NMC has giventhe

reporton 2252023 wherein some were there

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 W
tb
Earlier in the LETTER OF LIMITED RENEWAL OF RECOGNITION
amp PERMISSION issued by NMC vide no

NMCUGR2020000049015529 dated 11042022 issued for the

year 202122 it has been mentioned as under The present

is valid for
one year and for onlyone batch of
students againstthe annual intake of 150 MBBS seats during the
academicyear 2021 22 The next batchof studentsin MBBS
course will

be admitted in the college

onlyafter of Medical Assessment

amp
RatingBoard of NMC for Admission made in

violation of the aboveconditionwill be treatedas and action

irregular
will be initiated under NMC Act amp made there under
Regulations
if any
Discrepancies may be brought
to the notice of the

Medical Assessmentamp Board of theNMC andthe

rating Govt

At this stage in view of the directions of Honble Court as well as

of the concernedcollege
request and Public Notice datedil4072023
issued byNMC it is requested
to clarifythatduring whether

this Collegecan go ahead with the admission of current Session

20232024 Kindlyclarify
urgently
Sd
Dean Colleges

Endst No C263Date Copyis

to Director Principal
forwarded Medical Collegeamp
Chintpurni Hospital
BungalPathankot
Sd
Dean Colleges
TRUE OP

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
f

oar
NeutralCitation No 2023AHC205365

Court No 10

Case WRIT C No 28058of 2023

Petitioner Dr BS Kushwah Institute Of Medical Sciences And

Another
Union Of IndiaAnd 4 Others
Counsel for Petitioner Pranjal Kumar Pandey
Counsel for Respondent ASGICSCVivek Kumar Singh

Honble KshitijShailendraJ
1 Heard Shri HN Singhlearned Senior Advocate assisted by

Shri PranjalSinghlearned counsel for the petitioners

andShri
Vivek Kumar learnedcounselfor No 2

2 The wanted
petitioners to establish a Medical Collegeto run

MBBS Course and for that purpose before the

applied
The
No 2 for recognition claim has
petitioners been

rejectedunder the first order impugneddated 24052023 by

pointingout certain in consonance with the

of sections28 and 29 of National Medical Commission

provisions
Act 2019 The Statutory
First and Second Appealsagainstthe

aforesaidorderhavealsobeendismissed

3 Shri HN Singh learned Senior Advocate has arguedthatthe

ordersimpugned
are basedupon the assessment reportsand though

there are no on the part of the petitionerscontrary

observationshave been recorded

4 I haveperused
the entirerecord andI find that the

Authoritieshave recorded regarding faculty

and residents doctors These observations are based upon the

conductedbytheAuthoritiesand I am
enquiry of the that

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
xi

78
in the event of invitingresponse from the respondents
that would

be certainly
in consonance withthe reportsthe
writ would remain pending
petition for a considerable period
of
time andwould serve no purpose

5 I have ofthe Act of 2019

the provisions
sections28 and 29 whereofwhich read as follows

28 for new medical college

1 No person shall establisha new collegeor

medical start

any postgraduate
course or increase number of seats

without prior permissionof the Medical

Assessment and RatingBoard

2 For the purposes of under sub

permission
section 1 a person may submit a scheme to the Medical

Assessmentand RatingBoard in such formcontaining

such

particulars bysuch feeandin such manner

as may be specied bythe regulations

3 TheMedical Assessmentand RatingBoard shall having

due regardto the criteria specified
in section 29 consider

the scheme received under 2 and either

or such schemewithin a period six
of
monthsfromthedate ofsuch receipt

Provided that before such scheme an

to rectify if any shall be givento the

the defects

person concerned

4 Wherea schemeis undersubsection3 such

approvalshall be the permission

under subsection 1 to

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
j

establishnew medical college

5 Where schemeis under subsection 3 or

a
where no decision is taken within six months ofsubmitting
a

schemeundersubsection 1 the person concerned may

preferan appealto the Commission for approval

of the
scheme within fifteendaysof such disapproval
or as the

case may be ofsix monthsin such manner as

lapse maybe

bythe regulations
specified

6 The shall decide the appeal

received under

5 within a periodof fortyfivedaysfromthe

date of receiptof the appealand in the Commission
case
approvesthe schemesuch approval
shall be the permission
undersubsection1 to establisha new and
college
in case the Commission the schemeor fails to
give its decision within the the person

concerned may prefera second appealto the Central

Government within thirtydaysof communication of such

or as the case may be lapseof specified

period

7 The Medical Assessment and RatingBoard mayconduct

evaluationand assessment ofany medicalinstitution at any

time either directlyor any other expert having

integrityand experience
of medical profession
and without

any priornotice and assess and evaluate the performance

standardsand benchmarksof such institution

29 Criteria forapproving
or scheme

While approving
or a scheme under section

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
so
no

28 the Medical Assessment and Board or the

as the case may be shall take into

considerationthe following
criterianamely

a adequacy
offinancial
resources

b whetheradequate
academic facultyand other necessary
to ensure
have beenprovided proper
facilities of
medical college
or would be provided the timelimit
within
in the scheme
specified

C whether hospital have been

or
would be providedwithin the timelimitspecified
in the

scheme

d such other factorsas may be prescribed

Provided that subjectto the previousapproval

of the

Central Government
the criteria may be relaxed for the
medical colleges
which are set up in such areas as may be

bythe regulations

6 A bare perusal
of aforesaidprovisionsrevealsthatthe Institution
has to submit a scheme before the No 2 for the

purposes of permissionand the are

to consider the scheme and after providing

competent opportunity
to the defectspointed
out bythe
rectify theycan take
a decisioneitherway

7 There is nothing
in the aforesaidprovisions
to assume that any

exercise conductedunderthe aforesaidprovisions

in relation to
schemeoffered by the concernedInstitutionwould be a one time

exercise Rather the provisionsare to facilitateopportunity

to the

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
Digitally by
signed
SAZIAAOUIL
HighCourtofJudicature
at Allahabad to and to
l

verified
be
the
orders
and
its
Institution
times
scheme
factual
uponthe
While
fresh such
petitioners
again
passed
physical
a own othernecessaryfactorsand
within
submit
approachthe
impugned
merits
by
soonstatutory the
the
the
position any
asrejected
verification
finding
come an based
removal
law
fresh
this
ton the
is
Authorities
the
hedefects
petitioners
respondent
when
application
evenarectify
nomandate
rectifyaperiod
infirmity basis
the
defects
the
Even
months
the
orders
2the
theclaimwould
a relating
period componentswhile
the
The
grant
rectification
filed
application
petition
rectify ismonths
from thethe
be
appropriate
otherwise
same impugned
pointed
disposed
as
come a it date
considered
anorders
which
defects
appropriate rectified
shall
under
when
shall
consequence
recognition
are record
tbased
endfor
behat
may
also
the
be
the
application
today
examining all
permitting
they by
on
Sazia
look
Order
98 As to
concerned
ifinto
Date is to
Institution
ofconcerned
within
27102023 upon
of
writ
oftwo
in No to
of three
of shall
with
certainofof fromout
cannot
of shall
of
if
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
W
W
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 I

W
Court No 10

Case WRIT C No 28058 of 2023

Petitioner i Dr BS Kushwah Institute Of Medical Sciences And

Another
Union Of IndiaAnd 4 Others
Counsel for Petitioner PranjalSinghPrabhakar
AwasthiSantosh
Kumar Pandey
Counsel for ASGICSCVivek Kumar Singh
Honble KshitijShailendraJ
Order on Civil Misc Modification No
Application 3 of 2023

1 By means of this application

the orderdated27102023 passed
bythis Court to be modified onlyto the extent that
hasbeen sought
rectification of the defects may be directed to be verified by the
concerned as as possibleso that petitioners

claim for the academicsession202324 may survive

2 Learned counsel for the submits

petitioner that the deficiencies
as noticed in the orders impugned have already been rectified by
the petitioner and a fresh has been filed before the
authorities as directed in para 9 of the order dated 27102023
Relevant documents have been brought on record by means of the
affidavit

3 Sri Vivek Kumar Singhlearnedcounsel for the no 2

disputes the contention of the in respectto rectification

of the defectsand andsubmitsthatthe situation is as
it was at the time of passingof the orders impugned in the writ
petitionand no fresh hastakenplace

4 Be that as it may since directions have alreadybeen issued for

the fresh application
filed by the which has
been filed by themand orderis stillawaitedthough time fixed in
the order dated 27102023 has not yet expired the modification
application is disposed of directing the concerned to
pass orders on the petitionersfreshclaim submitted before them
within 15 daysfrom the date a self attested downloaded copy of
this orderis before them

5 It is made clearthat in case after due etc

it is found that the defectspointedout in the ordersimpugned are

still intact and no fresh stepshavebeentaken bythe petitionersit

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 shallbe openfor the pass ordersas this
Court has already the orders impugned
upheld while the
deciding
writ petition

Order Date
KK Maurya

Digitally
signed
by
KAMLESH KUMARMAURYA
HighCourtal Judicatureat Allahabad

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 K

This Is a
The signedorder
digitally I

to
v
a
3
Nckv
4
2
CORAM
HONBLE
I47 The
seeks
whileAll
KNOWN
IN instant
Learned
Libertythe
WHITE
THE
MR counsel
150282023
OFaHIGH
liberty
rights 21
so ASto withdraw
petition
prayed
2023 for
MEDICAL
INDIA 0 amp
ndcontentionsRis
21112023
and Ethe instant
f the
Court
behalf
thusdisposed
Through
Through
versus Dgranted
Highon
COLLEGE
CM R Kumar
APPL o
MrAvadh f600712023
MrShobhit
MsAvshreya
parties
AND
MsArchana
SPC
DELHI the
as
are
writ
MEDICAL
with Advocate
left
petition
Surve
HOSPITAL
Advocates
MsUsha Jamnal
and
with
withdrawn
AT
KUMAR
Kaushik
KUMAR
open further
after
COLLEGE
GP and
Petitioner
PratapSinghRudy
NEW arguing
FORMERLY
KAURAV
DELHI
for
for R1
R5
MrRishabh for
liberty
ANDJ
NOVEMBER
WPC THE
HOSPITAL
UNION JUSTICE COURT
CHINTPURNI
is PURUSHAINDRA
ORSPURUSHAINDRA
o OF of KAURAV
7 ea
MUKUL
aulhenticily SHARMAcan be Iwverled from Delhi HighCourt Order Parlal byscanningthe OR code shown above
of theorder
2023.11.29 15:42
The Order is TRUE
downloaded
SCANNEDfromCOPY
the DHC THE on 27112023 at 194012
OF Server
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 IN THE HONBLE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATES OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

3
5 OF 202
V
mPetitionerAppellants
AJr
VERSUS
es
F 35 p on d ens t
R

M0qQ
the
SIDDHARTH
KNOW ALL by these presents that
undersigned appoint Shri BHALLA
SANDHUGURKAMAL SINGH KANDHOLA Advocates
QTN I
SHUBHAM
to
YAJUR
be
BHALLA
Advocate
AND
for
me n to
the the above mentioned case do the following
Acts Deeds and Things or
any of them that is to say
1 To Act appear and plead in the abovementioned case in this
Court or any other Court in which the same may be tried or heard in the
first instance or in Appeal or by way of Letters Patent Appeal or
Review or Revision or Execution or at any other stage of its progress
until its final decision
2 To Pleadings Letters Patent
present Appeals Appeals Cross
objections or Petitions for Execution Review or
Revision Withdrawal
Compromiseor other Petitions or Affidavits or other documents as shall
be deemed necessary or advisable for the of the said case
prosecution
in all its stages
3 To withdraw or
compromise the said case or to submit to
arbitration any differences or that shall or may arise
disputes
touching or in any manner relating to the said case

4 To receive money and grant thereof and to do all

receipts
other acts and which may be necessary to be done for the
things
progress and in the course of the prosecution of the said case
5 To employ any other Legal Practitioner them to
authorizing
4

whenever he may think fit to do so

AND I hereby agree to certify whatever t
substitute shall do in the said case and in its co
AND I hereby agree not to hold the Advocate me
responsible for the result of the said cas d
consequence of his absence from the Court when the said case is called
for hearing
AND I hereby agree that in the event of the whole or any
part of
the Fee agreed by me to be paid to the Advocates remaining unpaid
they shall be entitled to withdraw from the Prosecution of the said
case same
until the is paid
AND I hereby agree that the Advocates will be eligible to appear
for me if the case is transferred to any other Court from the present
Court or if the Court sits at any other place other than its normal
place of sitting and I will be liable to pay additional Fee
IN WITNESS WHEREOF I do hereby set my hand to these presents the
contents of which have been read by me and explained to me
This the of uoy
Way 203
M xqbp
NWH9fatu
pau
HAM BHALLASIDDHARTH SANDHUGurkama1
BHALLAYAJUR Singh
Kandhola

Advocatels
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
MOB
PHHC, CHANDIGARH91 9654427273
Email shubhambhallahotmailcom
MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH
 33r
14rs

MUKUL SHARMA
2023.11.29 15:42
TRUE SCANNED COPY OF THE
ORIGINAL
PHHC, CHANDIGARH