Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dissertation Childrens Literature
Dissertation Childrens Literature
Debojyoti Ghosh
Roll-ME200045
Department of English,
Declaration
This is to certify that Debojyoti Ghosh, student of Master in English, have carried out this
Dissertation Project titled "Imlementation of societal norms and cultural values through folklores
such as Panchatantra and Aeshop fables” under the supervision and guidance of Prof. Tamalika
Das, Department of English, Rishi Bankim Chandra College Naihati. The work submitted is
original to the best of our knowledge and has not been carried out elsewhere in any other
University or Institute.
(Signature of Student)
Department of English
Supervisor's Certificate
This is to certify that Debojyoti Ghosh, student of Master in English, has carried out this
Dissertation Project titled " Imlementation of societal norms and cultural values through
folklores such as Panchatantra and Aeshop fables ” under the supervision and guidance of Prof.
Tamalika Das in the Department of English, Rishi Bankim Chandra College Naihati. The work
submitted is original to the best of our knowledge and has not been carried out elsewhere in any
(Signature Of Supervisor)
Department of
English
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to extend my humble gratitude towards everyone concerned with my paperwork for
their valuable insights and contribution. I would first like to thank my paper supervisor Prof.
Tamalika Das, Professor of English, Rishi Bankim Chandra College, Naihati. His doors were
always open whenever I needed any help regarding my research paper. He consistently allowed
this paper to be my work and helped me to learn new things, and guided me in the right direction
I would also like to thank our Principal for encouraging such project works in the P.G.
department.
Finally, I want to thank my family and my classmates who kept motivating me with their
positive energy and their support that led me towards completing this work.
Ghosh 5
CONTENTS
Chapter 1: Introduction
Chapter 4: Discussion
Chapter 5: Conclusion
Works Cited
Ghosh 6
Chapter 1: Introduction
Human beings have always shared a good relationship with literature and literary works which
itself remains vast, and amazing. Children’s literature is one such field which actually can be
defined as a piece of work exclusively for the young generation, adults and children’s mostly. It
deals with informations and entertaining materials majority of which makes the whole as non
The most probable emergence of Children’s literature arises significantly in the second half of the
18th century. Considering that this area was at its best in it’s embryonic stage. Recognition of such
a fascinating area took its deliverance towards the 20th century, making it a mainstream,
In the term children’s literature, the more important word is literature. For the most part, the
adjective imaginative is to be felt as preceding it. It comprises that vast, expanding territory
recognizably staked out for a junior audience, which does not mean that it is not also intended for
seniors. Adults admittedly make up part of its population: children’s books are written, selected for
publication, sold, bought, reviewed, and often read aloud by grown-ups. Sometimes they seem also
to be written with adults in mind, as for example the popular French Astérix series of comics
parodying history. Although under such a field Folklores and Fables which are considerably one of
the important genre’s of Children’s Literature responsible in shaping a child’s initial learning days,
making him well aware of the culture he’s going to be a part of, the tradition that followed his
ancestry, the societal values that surrounds his environment and the moral values that he needs to
learn. There are many such tales from various part of the world which are ancient classics and
which are widely used and known by any human being, making him remember his childhood
nostalgia as at that point of time, he was made to understand the difference between good and bad,
Panchatantra written by Pandit Vishnu Sharma in and around 200 BC is one such collection of
fables considered sacred and useful for every individual of India. On the other hand Aeshopica or
Aeshop Fables said to be written by Aeshop himself who was a slave and a story teller, probably
living around 620 and 564 BCE in ancient Greece is another collection of fables which has kept
generations compact and learned since their childhood. The stories also provided an opportunity for
a measure of self-reflection. At those moments when Greeks suspected their culture or civilization
was not living up to expectations, the fables provided an opportunity for a degree of self-reflection.
Although humans and animals share similar traits, humans are different due to their power of
reason which allows humans to make different choices about life and living.
My paper mainly focuses on the how these two texts serve in representing their culture and how
both of them help educate the younger minds of a society, making them knowledgeable about their
traditional values, and mostly important, making them know “what to do, and what not to” with a
moral lesson. Thus my paper will deal and uphold how these texts are being used over centuries in
A literature review is mainly an overview of the previously published works on a specific topic.
This literature review surveys articles, books and other sources related to a specific area of
research. This review should enumerate, describe, summarize, objectively evaluate and clarify
about the previous research. It should provide a theoretical base for the study and assist in
determining the scope of the study. Literature review helps to acknowledge the work of earlier
researchers, assuring the readers that the work is well-thought. By acknowledging a previous work,
it is believed that the author has read, evaluated, and also assimilated that work in order to do the
current work. This section includes the gist of journals and articles by scholars, books, and other
Very few scholars have specifically worked upon this piece of literature amongst which some
comparative analysis and study of Dr Nidhi Rastogi and Nandana NG caught my attention,
although both of them are vast and focus mainly on the background, history, origin and not on what
or how the tales are being employed in shaping the minds of the children’s. Thus I will provide a
picture on how these stories serve to deliver their moral value and cultural history.
Ghosh 9
To write this paper, I will be using the Descriptive method in order to explain quest for female
self identity. This novel describes discrimination in various fields whether in educational
institutes, job sectors, courts, school or colleges. Descriptive method is a type of research mainly
focuses on answering the questions of “what” rather than the “why” of the research topic. This
method usually answer to what, where, when and how type of questions. Before doing research
on a particular topic we should know how this happens, when and where occurred . There will be
a proper descriptive analysis research approach in order to define a topic by analyzing it any
further. To write this paper, I will first throw light upon on the philosophy of Panchatantra and
Aeshop Fables and then will discuss the points of my dissertation title. Thus as the title of the
paper suggests, this paper will try to make the idea about how two notable literary work are
Chapter 4: Discussion
Mahilaropya. The king in the city was Amarshakti. He in order to develop interest
In his sons in knowledge and develop their minds gave Vishnu Sharma the
Responsibility. Vishnu Sharma took his three sons home. He had developed his
Characters.
The origin of Panchatantra as have been earlier said has been divided into four
Versions. Pahlavi is the first version of the Panchatantra that was created before
A.D. 570. Though it is lost now it can be recreated from an Old Syrian and an
Arabic version with the later texts based on the Arabic version. The second is the
Gunadhya’s Brhatkallui. The third is the two Kashmir versions styled Tantra
Khyayika and by two Jain texts. Fourth is the common ancestor of the Southern
Panchatantra and the Southern Panchatantra are derived from a version sister to
Hertel concluded that these four sources ought to be reduced to two, the
Tantrakhyayika original and ‘ K’, the source of the other three groups. This is
Transitional archetype from which the Pahlavi, the Southern Panchatantra group
Are descended.
The sense of the term Is uncertain. It is uncertain as to what the word Tantra
It is a thesis dealing with five contents. It has been considered that it was written
Long after 200 B. C. It is sure that it has definitely been written after the Christian
Suggest that it fell in the period of the Brahmanical restoration and expansion
It has also been considered that the author was a Brahmin. Vishnusharma is
The Deccan as a sign of southern origin. According to Hertel this book was
On the other hand traces of Aeshop leads to where the birth of Aesop takes place,
Who was an ancient and Black storyteller, is celebrated on this day c 620 BC. He is
Known for his stories, which are called “Aesop’s Fables,” which have become a
Animals. Aesop was a Black slave of Iadmon, located in the south of Greece near
Northern Africa. Most accounts describe Aesop as a deformed man whose name
Was freed by his master in Iadmon. Other accounts connect him with many wild
Adventures and attach him with such rulers as Solon and Croesus.
The first extensive translation of Aesop into Latin was done by Phaedrus, a
Freedman of Augustus in the first century AD. The first printed version of Aesop’s
Fables in English was published on March 26, 1484, by William Caxton. William
Dugard translated his stories from the Greek text of Planudes in 1715. There he
Also describes Aesop as one whom “Nature had gratified with an Ingenious mind,
His fables are some of the most well-known in the world and remain a choice for
Such as “The Fox and the Grapes” (from which the idiom “sour grapes” was
Derived), “The Tortoise and the Hare,” “The North Wind and the Sun,” and “The
Boy Who Cried Wolf,” are well-known throughout the world. A few famous
Quotations by Aesop are; “After all is said and done, more is said than done.” “Any
Excuse will serve a tyrant.” “United we stand, divided we fall.” “Be content with your lot; one
cannot be first in everything.”
We have evidence of fables in the wisdom books of Eastern civilizations as early
As 1800 BCE among the Babylonians, Assyrians, Sumerians, Akkadians and Egyptians.
Even in the Mesopotamian period, fables were part of the tradition of wisdom literature
That contained an undifferentiated assortment of animal fables, proverbs and parables. Aesop and
his brand of critical and popular wisdom is a major influence
Philosophical figures, but also with satire and comedy, all of which may have influenced
The later representations of the fabulist, while it is less likely that Aesop directly
Influenced the depiction of Socrates. Aesop was associated with the philosopher Socrates,
And their lives share some interesting parallels often found in the lives and deaths of
Lion king and a bull. It tells us how they become friends with each other
And later how they are separated by a jackal. There are two jackals in this
Story, Damanaka and Karataka as the ministers of Lion King. The basic
Role in deciding what is good for their king at a certain point of time. They
Can bring somebody to the king for friendship, if they find it hard to fight
With that person as his strengths and weaknesses are unknown. When they
Understand that friendship with this person is not so useful for the King and
For the kingdom, they can bow the seeds of misunderstanding between the
Importance of gaining good friends. It underlines the principle that one, who
Has good friends will never taste defeat in one’s life in any kind of situation.
This is a story of four friends; a crow, a rat, a deer and a turtle, and how they
The third strategy is Kokolukiya (Of crows and owls). The main story
Is about the enmity of crows and owls. It tells about how to deal with the
Enemies with tact and wisdom. It also strengthens the moral that never believe a person who is your enemy
and never believe a friend who was your
The fourth strategy is Labdhapranash means loss of gains. It says that one
Can lose the things which are earned earlier because of one’s foolishness. The
Or hasty deeds. The stories starts with a moral that one should never do
Will lead to permanent loss. The basic story is of a merchant and a fool guest
At his house and how the hasty deeds of the guest later on leads to death of
Some monks.
Vishnusharma brought the princes back to the King as well learned men.
Since then Panchatantra has played a pivotal role in the life of Indian
Families within and outside India. As per the time change, the stories are
Also converted into animation form and attracting viewers even outside
India. What are the reasons of its immense popularity? What is so unique
The narrator and participation by the listener. It has also been part of formal
Education for many years. In the nineteenth century, student teachers were
Has shown through his study, that positive enjoyment improves learning. It
Used the stories of different animals and human beings. As his students
Were not so eager to study through the routine method he found an exciting
And entertaining method, that is, teaching through narration or with the
Help of stories. Interestingly, the characters in the fables are often animals,
Perhaps because children find animals interesting, and have a strange way of
That engages a reader very effectively. The end result is the communication of
With the help of the characters of the story he tried to explain simple
But useful and important concepts. As people remember stories that are well
Told and are centered on ideas the listeners either know well or want to know
Structure keeps the reader or the listener involved in the story. Draper (2006)
Says that “stories use words to create imaginings in hearers. That could be a
Description of education”.
Also wanted them to learn, remember and use their knowledge afterwards,
For teaching, Williams (2000) says that narrative text (fiction) is easier to
Material).
There is no room for educational storytelling. We have to think outside limits. Narration need not be always
related to morals but it can be related
To a story of invention in science. In Panchatantra, the stories are in the form of dialogues making them
Very interesting as the characters are arguing about something. Gillon (2011)
Says that the natural human tendency is to listen to logical arguments. In India, there has been an old
tradition of logical arguments in the form
One form of rational inquiry, are not definitely known, we are aware that
Public debates were common in pre-classical India (Gillon 2011). With this
Of the earlier books which generate and popularize the structure of frame
Story and linking them with each other with the help of arguments. The
His students to learn the logical and analytical thinking. For debate, it is
Necessary to develop the ability to think rationally and pose questions if you
Find the other person is speaking irrationally. Other perspective is about the development of moral and
social identity.
The students at an early age. Through the stories the personal and social
Responsibility can be imparted into the students. They can understand the
Society and their role in the society. So in all it can be said that this method
In many Aesop’s Fables, the lesson is not that the “bad character” is punished and the “good character” is
rewarded. Rather, they are cautionary tales in which (typically) an animal symbolizing a human character
flaw (greed, arrogance, stupidity, timidity, naïveté, carelessness) is deceived by another character,
inadvertently helping the deceiving character to fulfill his/her intention. In many cases the “good character”
can be weak and the “bad character” strong. This kind of characterization sends the message that power and
evil can win out over innocence and good will unless thoughtful action is taken (Clayton, 2008).
Alternatively, fables may exploit a situation in which a good character attribute is revealed (kindness,
empathy, intelligence), resulting in an unexpected positive outcome. An essential component of
comprehending the meaning of fables is knowing the relationship of who is tricking or surprising whom,
and for what purpose. To that end, children’s understanding of mental states may be needed for competence
in narrative structure particularly when it involves deception (Sodian et al., 1991; Gamannossi and Pinto,
2014), as is common in Aesop’s fables. Second order theory of mind, in particular, has been linked to
understanding of deception (Wimmer and Perner, 1983) because it involves beliefs about another’s beliefs
or intentions.
Interestingly, Aesop’s fables feature animals as protagonists rather than humans. In some contexts, the use
of non-humans is meant to illuminate the human experience through “humans in disguise” (Sutton-Spence
and Napoli, 2010, p. 442) in a metaphoric way. This kind of anthropomorphism is ubiquitous across cultures
(Tehrani, 2013) and is considered acceptable for evoking emotion and appealing to broad audiences (Sutton-
Spence and Napoli, 2010). However, behavioral scientists point out some potential drawbacks of
anthropomorphism when it concerns teaching children scientific understanding of the natural world (Ganea
et al., 2014). Yet Shettleworth (2012), using training tasks inspired by Aesop’s fables (for example, the
thirsty stork using stones to raise the water level in a pitcher), along with neuroscientific imaging, maintains
that animals can indeed show insight. Clayton (2008) argues that anthropomorphism illustrates that
hierarchies in the animal world are analogous to human hierarchies in the context of everyday life. There
must be similarities between animal and human behavior, otherwise “the animal fable would not exist”
(Clayton, 2008, p. 183). Although animals can get themselves into similar situations as humans, all would
agree that animals can not use reason to solve a problem. Thus the anthropomorphized life lesson is useful
in showing human audiences that they have the advantage of mentalistic reasoning to help them avoid or
escape the unfortunate situation. In the Aesop’s Fables the tenor is generally formal because there are very
little
Dialogues and the narrative is in the third person. All the stories begin with the traditional
Formulaic utterances, ―once upon a time…‖ line which gives it a feeling of belonging to the past
And hence creates a greater impact as people often feel that what has already happened in the
Distant past is far more significant rather than the things that happen in the immediate present.
Due to this the power of the story to grasp the attention of the adult readers increases. Small
Children or young readers are not concerned with any of this because all they are interested in is a
Good story.
In the Aesop’s Fables there are dialogues between certain characters in stories that are
Otherwise only long narratives by the narrator. For example, in a story titled ‗The Lion and the
Mouse‘ there is a series of a few dialogues between the mighty lion and the little mouse which is
As follows,
―Oh, your Majesty! Your Majesty!‖ squeaked the mouse, ―please me! I had no idea
You were a lion. I thought you were a haystack! And I wanted some nice hay to line
Ghosh 18
My new nest with. But, if you will forgive me and let me go, I will repay you some
Panchatantra. Yet, major part of the narrative is formally narrated. The stories are addressed to mankind in
general. The reason
Is that their main objective is to impart wisdom. So they also cannot be narrated in the mind of a
Character. Therefore, no interior monologues are present in any story of either of the collections.
However, some shrewd and cunning characters speak to themselves as they cannot express their
Thoughts outwardly. So, in a very few instances interior monologues do occur. By focusing mostly on
animals as protagonists of the fables, Aesop managed to partially hide the human element, but still portray
wholly human themes – creating an entertaining combination that the common populace of the past
appreciated. And with this crafty combination, he created a legacy whose importance is unmatched – he
gave world lessons that would influence society on a whole new level.
The fables were made from the same fabric as daily life, exploring themes such as ambition, greed, humility,
strength, weakness, deceit, honesty, love, hate, and poverty. By simplifying these crucial and large themes,
the populace of the Classical Times was introduced to a higher step in the ladder of a civilized world.
But some themes of Aesop’s fables also give us an insight into the life of common peoples in Classical
Greece. Fables such as The Thief and His Mother, The Miser and His Gold, Hercules and the Wagoner, The
Satyr and the Traveller, Horkos, the God of Oaths – and many others – reflect in some sense, the social
norms of that time, with obvious emphasis on morality. Honesty, humility, and wit were held in high regard
by the Greeks and these fables confirm it.
Even from the earliest times, from the very beginnings of society, we can see that the written word, as well
as the oral traditions – played a significant role in every nation. You know that a story or a fable carries so
much influence when it is repeatedly shared through generations – father to son – for centuries. And when
every child and every elder alike are able to draw a life-changing moral lesson out of it, you can be sure that
such significance is timeless.
The fable preaches unity and
Support for others. The stories in this fable provide an excellent way to teach kids about the
Consequences of good and bad behaviour, the importance of team-work, and the recompenses of
The unity of purpose. The resolution and quickness in attending to other plights are also displayed.
This fable is a kind of means of appreciating other people’s concerns and desires dedicating our
Time to support whosoever the world over. This gesture will bring about respect for our diverse
The importance of togetherness and spirit of assisting others is explored in the fable. The
Fight of lizards costs extermination of many other higher placed animals as shown in the fable.
What could be regarded as their own business, results to be a bad premonition to many others? The
Self-centered attitudes and the impression of not ready to intervene in another person’s problem
And or to find solutions result in many current problems in our societies. Looking at the present
Ghosh 19
Age, everyone is self-centered with little or no time for any other person. The case of family,
Nuclear one in the present days is quite different from the olden ages of extended family, any
Problem that emanates is collectively solved by the extended family, whereas the nuclear family
Is only concerned with his little difficult and solutions are limited to such members constituting
The family. Isolated life is not reckoned with in the pre-colonial days, before the introduction of
Western cultures. A whole village may be concerned about the welfare of one another. Nowadays,
Hardly could neighbours intervene in the affairs of his immediate community partner. This idea is
Connected with the training of their children. Historically, moral is to be a collective thing and
Collectively impacted on every child of the community, but in this present era, it is no more so.
Many parents do not allow their children to be corrected by another person, the beginning of crises.
In the efforts of instilling morals in the young ones the societal ethos is also orated and preserved.
The high profile of Aesop’s Fables has also been supported by their relation-
Ship with Christianity. These morality tales were widely approved as constitu-
Ents of the mediaeval and Renaissance syllabus partly because they were felt to
Aesop’s Fables have, since the mediaeval period, appeared alongside or even
Ing example is the fables of Reynard the fox-trickster derived in turn from the
Conclusion
Thus we can see that though both the writers belong to different cultures and
Different life styles they had many similarities as well as dis similarities. Both the fable
Writers contributed imagined qualities super infused by human analogy upon the animal
World anddeveloped the stories to their supreme heights through the animal character
Ghosh 20
With a moral interpretation. Both The Panchatantra Tales and Aesop Fables have a great
Purpose of giving moral instruction at the end of the story.In a nutshell it can be said that
Panchatantra and Aesop’s fables contain wisdom of ages for people of all classes.
Through simple but fascinating stories, it teaches us important lessons of life that we tend
To overlook as we mature. The Fables may not be able to define Virtue and Vice, but they
Can give you some examples of what these things look like and suggest for which of the
Two should be chosen in particular situations and what the outcome of that choice is
Likely to be. In this ever dynamic and competitive world, the lessons from Panchatantra
Are still highly relevant enlightening us to the path of success and peace. Through the
Wisdom of its fables the `Panchatantra’ offers a vision of ourselves, and in the process, it
Makes us aware of the fact that solutions lie within ourselves.The fact cannot be denied
That Vishnu Sharma in the east and Aesop in the west are instrumental in animal stories
Rapidly getting popularized in the television cartoons in the present generation. The stories comprise of an
introduction to the animals and the rising action emerges from
The introduction of the motives and the comparability of each character in the active
Practice of worldly wisdom; the conclusion is invariably loaded in favour of the wiser,
The stronger, and the more diplomatic. This is followed by the moral lesson about virtue
And vice. The plot construction and styles of the fables in both The Panchatantra Tales and
Citations
Forgotten Books.
Ashliman D.L. (2003).Aesop’s Fables, New York. Barnes & Noble Classics
http://www.brown.edu/academics/comparative-literature/about
Sharma, Vishnu. Tr. Ryder, W. Arthur. Panchatantra. Mumbai: Jaico Publishing House,
2010.