Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Full Ebook of Infinite Groups A Roadmap To Selected Classical Areas 1St Edition Martyn R Dixon Online PDF All Chapter
Full Ebook of Infinite Groups A Roadmap To Selected Classical Areas 1St Edition Martyn R Dixon Online PDF All Chapter
Full Ebook of Infinite Groups A Roadmap To Selected Classical Areas 1St Edition Martyn R Dixon Online PDF All Chapter
https://ebookmeta.com/product/random-walks-on-infinite-
groups-1st-edition-steven-p-lalley/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/texas-snakes-a-field-guide-james-r-
dixon/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/the-spread-of-almost-simple-
classical-groups-scott-harper/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/acceptance-and-commitment-therapy-
for-behavior-analysts-a-practice-guide-from-theory-to-
treatment-1st-edition-mark-r-dixon/
Studying Engineering A Roadmap to a Rewarding Career
5th Edition Raymond Landis
https://ebookmeta.com/product/studying-engineering-a-roadmap-to-
a-rewarding-career-5th-edition-raymond-landis/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/a-paradise-to-die-for-1st-edition-
david-james-dixon/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/a-paradise-to-die-for-1st-edition-
david-james-dixon-2/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/methodological-concepts-a-critical-
guide-1st-edition-martyn-hammersley/
https://ebookmeta.com/product/becoming-your-own-banker-the-
infinite-banking-concept-second-edition-r-nelson-nash/
Infinite Groups
In recent times, group theory has found wider applications in various fields of algebra and math-
ematics in general. But in order to apply this or that result, you need to know about it, and such
results are often diffuse and difficult to locate, necessitating that readers construct an extended
search through multiple monographs, articles, and papers. Such readers must wade through the
morass of concepts and auxiliary statements that are needed to understand the desired results,
while it is initially unclear which of them are really needed and which ones can be dispensed
with. A further difficulty that one may encounter might be concerned with the form or language
in which a given result is presented. For example, if someone knows the basics of group theory,
but does not know the theory of representations, and a group theoretical result is formulated in
the language of representation theory, then that person is faced with the problem of translating
this result into the language with which they are familiar, etc.
Infinite Groups: A Roadmap to Selected Classical Areas seeks to overcome this challenge.
The book covers a broad swath of the theory of infinite groups, without giving proofs, but with
all the concepts and auxiliary results necessary for understanding such results. In other words,
this book is an extended directory, or a guide, to some of the more established areas of infinite
groups.
Features
• An excellent resource for a subject formerly lacking an accessible and in-depth reference
• Suitable for graduate students, PhD students, and researchers working in group theory
• Introduces the reader to the most important methods, ideas, approaches, and constructions
in infinite group theory.
Taylor & Francis
Taylor & Francis Group
http://taylorandfrancis.com
Infinite Groups
A Roadmap to Selected Classical Areas
Martyn R. Dixon
University of Alabama, United States of America
Leonid A. Kurdachenko
Oles Honchar Dnipro National
University, Ukraine
Igor Ya. Subbotin
National University, USA
First edition published 2023
by CRC Press
6000 Broken Sound Parkway NW, Suite 300, Boca Raton, FL 33487-2742
Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the author and publisher cannot as-
sume responsibility for the validity of all materials or the consequences of their use. The authors and publishers have
attempted to trace the copyright holders of all material reproduced in this publication and apologize to copyright holders
if permission to publish in this form has not been obtained. If any copyright material has not been acknowledged please
write and let us know so we may rectify in any future reprint.
Except as permitted under U.S. Copyright Law, no part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or
utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including pho-
tocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission
from the publishers.
For permission to photocopy or use material electronically from this work, access www.copyright.com or contact the
Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400. For works that are
not available on CCC please contact mpkbookspermissions@tandf.co.uk
Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are used only for iden-
tification and explanation without intent to infringe.
DOI: 10.1201/9781003147572
Preface xi
Authors xvii
vii
viii Contents
Bibliography 315
xi
xii Preface
of a finite group become less important for infinite groups, although a similar effect
can be achieved by imposing other additional conditions, which, in turn, require fur-
ther analysis. Thus, in the case of torsion-free groups, for example, the situation is
completely different from finite groups.
An important role was also played here by the concurrent restructuring of algebra
carried out by E. Noether and her associates. One indicator of this was the signifi-
cant use of finiteness conditions (conditions that are automatically satisfied in finite
groups), whose use in the theory of rings and modules achieved spectacular success.
Finiteness conditions turned out to be just as useful, although not always so conclu-
sive, in group theory. Significant roles in the formulation of this approach were played
by the likes of P. Hall, R. Baer, O. Yu. Schmidt, A. G. Kurosh, H. Wielandt, A. I.
Maltsev, S. N. Chernikov, K. A. Hirsch, B. I. Plotkin, S. A. Chunikhin, B. H. Neu-
mann, M. Curzio and others.The key concepts of finiteness conditions were pushed
further by the next generation of algebraists; among them were B. A. F. Wehrfritz, J.
E. Roseblade, S. E. Stonehewer, R. E. Phillips, D. J. S. Robinson, J. Wiegold, J. C.
Lennox, M. J. Tomkinson, L. A. Kaluzhnin, B. Huppert, H. Heineken, O. H. Kegel,
W. Gaschütz, V. S. Charin, M. I. Kargapolov, V. M. Glushkov, Yu. I. Gorchakov, L.
A. Shemetkov, D. I. Zaitsev, V. P. Shunkov and B. Hartley. Their work was continued
not only by their students, but also by many other algebraists. The result of these
efforts was the creation of an important and extensive field of group theory, often
called “classical group theory” by some experts. One reason for this is that it was
created by people who themselves became classics of group theory. Its problems are
connected with the classical problems of group theory related to the description of
the structure of groups, and in this sense the subject matter is internal to the field.
This does not mean that its results do not find applications. A wide variety of meth-
ods and results from other disciplines such as the theory of rings and modules, linear
groups and non-associative rings and algebras are used, not just purely group theo-
retic techniques. Evidence of this comes, for example, from the methods incorporated
to solve the well-known long-standing problems of Burnside. Among the examples of
infinite finitely generated periodic groups, only the example of V. I. Sushchanskii was
constructed using a purely group theoretical technique. Among many other examples,
the intricate example of R. I. Grigorchuk can be distinguished by its elegance and
clarity of construction; many details concerning its structure are still emerging. The
examples constructed by A. Yu. Olshanskii use a very specific technique, showing how
complex and varied the situation with periodic groups can be. The positive solution
of the restricted Burnside problem obtained by E. I. Zelmanov was achieved using
the results he obtained for non-associative algebras.
The number of people working in group theory has skyrocketed. The number of
publications has also increased rapidly. On the other hand, the theory of groups,
unlike, for example, calculus, has practically no common methods. Thus, often its
branches, even in some areas close to each other, have a different methodology and
ideology. All the observations above are especially true for infinite group theory.
There is a large array of textbooks on group theory concerned with some of its
more important components; we provide details of such textbooks (understandably
incomplete) in the bibliography. Some of these textbooks, such as those of A. G.
Preface xiii
theorems. We supply it with direct references to the articles, surveys and other books.
In some cases, we will not only show the final result but the main stages of its de-
velopment. As can be seen from our experience, some results, which are auxiliary,
but not very important, proved to be very significant in other studies, thus becoming
part of the general theory. We will try to exhibit such results. No proofs will be given
which makes it possible to provide a sufficiently deep penetration into the area, and
detailed references provide an opportunity, to those who need them, to find proofs
independently in the original articles.
It is clear that the range of topics under consideration will be limited. We have
no intention to make the entire theory of infinite groups the object of consideration.
The subject of this book is naturally limited to those areas of the theory of infinite
groups in which the authors are experts, and which interest them. Even so, some very
interesting topics have of necessity been left out.
Recently, group theory has found wider applications in various fields of algebra
and mathematics in general. But in order to apply this or that result, you need to
know about it. To find out about the result, you need to find an article in which
it is proved or a monograph in which it is cited. This can involve wading through
the gamut of concepts and auxiliary statements that are needed to understand the
desired result, while it is initially unclear which of them are really needed and which
ones can be dispensed with. Another difficulty that one may encounter is the form
in which the result is presented or the language in which it is presented. For ex-
ample, if a person knows the basics of group theory, but does not know the theory
of representations, and the group theoretical result is formulated in the language of
representation theory, then this person is faced with the problem of translating this
result into the language with which they are familiar, etc. The authors themselves
encountered similar circumstances at the beginning of their mathematical careers.
The idea to write a book covering a large area of infinite group theory in which the
results would be given without proof but with all the concepts and auxiliary results
necessary for understanding such results blossomed. In other words, we imagine some
form of an extended directory, a guide to the most developed areas of infinite groups.
As we can see, group theory, as any other mathematical theory, was developed by
many mathematicians from various countries from different parts of the world. The
current book again confirms the famous words of David Hilbert.
Acknowledgments
We would like to extend our sincere appreciation to The University of Alabama
(Tuscaloosa, Alabama, USA) and National University (California, USA) for their
support of this work.
The authors would also like to thank their families for all their love and much
needed support while this work was in progress. An endeavor such as this is made
lighter by the joy that they bring. Finally, it is a pleasure to thank the staff of our
publishers for their co-operation and dedication. We would especially like to thank
Shashi Kumar for help with latex.
One of the authors of this book, L. A. Kurdachenko, is a professor at the National
University of Dnipro, Ukraine. During the final stages of writing this book, Russia
Preface xv
started its war against Ukraine on February 24, 2022. Some of the grandchildren
of L. A. Kurdachenko learned something that most people in the Western world
cannot imagine; they learned what air raids and cruise missile attacks are. L. A.
Kurdachenko was able to take his grandchildren to the United Kingdom. On the
way, his grandchildren had to spend 15 hours in a standard train carriage, where
there were more than 500 people. They were forced to freeze in the basement of
the Vinnitsa railway station during a massive bombardment by Russian hypersonic
missiles and to spend 8 hours on the Polish-Ukrainian border. L. A. Kurdachenko
wants to thank all the people in Ukraine, Poland, Great Britain, USA, Spain, Italy
and other countries who supported him during this difficult time and provided real
help. He also wants to thank the Institute of Mathematics of the Polish Academy of
Sciences, and especially Professor Piotr Nowak, for providing free accommodation in
Warsaw.
Martyn R. Dixon
Leonid A. Kurdachenko
Igor Ya. Subbotin
Taylor & Francis
Taylor & Francis Group
http://taylorandfrancis.com
Authors
Dr. Igor Ya. Subbotin is a Professor at National University, USA. His main area
of research is algebra. His list of publications includes more than 170 articles in alge-
bra published in major mathematics journals around the globe. He has also authored
more than 50 articles in mathematics education dedicated mostly to the theoretical
basis of some topics in high school and college mathematics. Among his publications
there are several books published by such major publishing companies as Wiley and
Sons, World Scientific, Birkhäuser, and others. His research in algebra has been sup-
ported by several international prestigious grants, including grants issued by FEDER
funds from European Union, The National Research Committee of Spain and Aragon,
Volkswagen Foundation (VolkswagenStiftung), and others.
xvii
Taylor & Francis
Taylor & Francis Group
http://taylorandfrancis.com
CHAPTER 1
In this first chapter, we begin by establishing some notation and collecting some
well-known facts which will prove to be useful throughout.
Perhaps, the most important types of subgroups of a group are the ones associated
with the key concept of commutativity, one of the strongest properties in algebra.
Therefore, when passing to the study of non-commutative groups, it is reasonable
to study groups saturated with certain types of commutative objects (specifically
subgroups, factor groups and families, such as series, of specific subgroups and factor
groups). One of the first such specific subgroups that is met in group theory is the
center of a group.
As usual if G is a group, then we let ζ(G) denote the center of the group G.
The size of this normal subgroup is an indicator as to how close to being abelian
the group is and of course G is abelian if and only G = ζ(G). In particular, the
size of the factor group G/ζ(G) can be considered as an indicator of the degree of
non-commutativity in the group G.
A group G is called central-by-finite if G/ζ(G) is finite.
For arbitrary elements x, y ∈ G we denote the (simple) commutator of x and y,
−1 −1
x y xy, by [x, y] and clearly [x, y] = 1 if and only if xy = yx.
As usual we’ll write y −1 xy as xy so that [x, y] = x−1 xy . Furthermore, a commu-
tator of weight n > 2 is defined recursively by
DOI: 10.1201/9781003147572-1 1
2 Infinite Groups
(ii) [xy, z] = [x, z]y [y, z] and [x, yz] = [x, z][x, y]z ;
−1 −1
(iii) [x, y −1 ] = ([x, y]y )−1 and [x−1 , y] = ([x, y]x )−1 ;
(iv) (Hall-Witt identity) [x, y −1 , z]y [y, z −1 , x]z [z, x−1 , y]x = 1.
and since [y, x] = [x, y]−1 it is clear that [X, Y ] = [Y, X].
The subgroup G0 = [G, G] is called the commutator subgroup (or derived subgroup)
of the group G.
The factor group G/G0 is clearly abelian and if H is a normal subgroup of G
such that G/H is abelian, then G0 ≤ H. Figuratively speaking, G0 is also a com-
mutativity controller for the group G: the smaller G0 is, the closer the group G is
to being abelian. A group G is called finite-by-abelian if the derived subgroup G0 is
finite.
Let n > 2 and suppose that X1 , . . . , Xn are subsets of G. We recursively define
(ii) if H is a subgroup of G, then [X, H]H = [X, H] and [X, H, H] ≤ [X, H];
The subgroups G0 and ζ(G) are special cases of the more general concepts of
verbal and marginal subgroups, which we now discuss.
Let X = {xn |n ∈ N} be a countable set and let F be the free group, freely
generated by X. Let W be a non-empty subset of F and let G be an arbitrary group.
Let w = xk11 xk22 . . . xknn ∈ W , where ki ∈ Z for 1 ≤ i ≤ n. If g1 , . . . , gn are elements of
G, then let
w(g1 , . . . , gn ) = g1k1 g2k2 . . . gnkn and
w(G) = hw(g1 , . . . , gn )|(g1 , . . . , gn ) ∈ G
|
×G×
{z
· · · × G}i.
n
The subgroup w(G) is called the verbal subgroup of G determined by the word w.
Also let W (G) = hw(G)|w ∈ W i. The subgroup W (G) is called the verbal sub-
group of G determined by W .
Clearly if w = x−1 −1 0
1 x2 x1 x2 , then w(G) = G .
A normal subgroup H of G is called W -marginal in G if
w(g1 , . . . , gj−1 , gj h, gj+1 , . . . gn ) = w(g1 , . . . , gj−1 , gj , gj+1 , . . . gn )
for all elements g1 , . . . , gn ∈ G, h ∈ H and all words w ∈ W . This is equivalent to the
following assertion:
uj ∈ gj H for 1 ≤ j ≤ n always implies w(g1 , . . . , gn ) = w(u1 , . . . , un ).
It is easy to show that the subgroup generated by all W -marginal subgroups of
G is the largest W -marginal subgroup of G, a subgroup that we denote by W ∗ (G).
Clearly, W ∗ (G) is a normal subgroup of G.
For example, if w = x−1 −1
1 x2 x1 x2 and W = {w} we see that if g ∈ G, h ∈ W (G),
∗
then [g, h] = [g, 1h] = [g, 1] = 1 so that h ∈ ζ(G). Conversely, if z ∈ ζ(G), then
[g1 , g2 z] = [g1 , g2 ] from which it follows that z ∈ W ∗ (G). Thus, in this case W ∗ (G) =
ζ(G).
We note here the following property.
4 Infinite Groups
1.5 Let W be a non-empty set of words. If G is a group such that W (G) is trivial,
then W ∗ (G) = G. Conversely, if W ∗ (G) = G, then W (G) is trivial.
Next, we give a generalization of the center of a group.
Let G be a group and let X be a class of groups. Let
XC(G) = {g ∈ G|G/CG ({g x |x ∈ G}) ∈ X}.
We note that in general XC(G) is not a subgroup of G, but we now give some
examples of classes of groups X for which XC(G) is in fact a characteristic subgroup
of G.
A class of groups X is called a formation of groups if it satisfies the conditions:
(F1) if G ∈ X and H is a normal subgroup of G, then G/H ∈ X,
(F2) if A, B are normal subgroups of G such that G/A, G/B ∈ X, then G/(A∩B) ∈ X
also.
It is easy to see that if X is a formation, then XC(G) is a characteristic subgroup
of G, called the XC-center of the group G.
If X is the class of trivial groups, then XC(G) is the center of G and if X is
the class of finite groups, then XC(G) is called the FC-center of G. In this case, we
usually write F C(G) rather than FC(G).
is called the lower central series of the group G. The terms of this series are called
hypocenters and they are again characteristic subgroups of G. The last term γδ (G) is
called the lower hypocenter and we have γδ (G) = [γδ (G), G].
We note that γα (G)/γα+1 (G) ≤ ζ(G/γα+ (G)).
Let H, K be normal subgroups of G such that H ≤ K. The factor group K/H
is called G-central if K/H ≤ ζ(G/H) (or CG (K/H) = G). Here CG (K/H) is the
preimage in G of CG/H (K/H). If CG (K/H) 6= G, then we say the factor K/H is
G-eccentric.
If the lower hypocenter of G is trivial, then the group G is called hypocentral.
Moreover, in this case if the lower central series of G is finite, then G is called
nilpotent. Then, the length of the lower central series is called the nilpotency class of
the group G, denoted by ncl (G). If ncl (G) = 1, then G is abelian.
We note the following properties of hypocenters, but begin by recalling that a
group G is called finitely generated if G contains a finite subset M such that the
subgroup generated by M coincides with G.
1.6 Let G be a group and let M be a subset of G such that G = hG0 , M i. Then
1.7 Let X be a class of groups which contains every homomorphic image of the
tensor product of two abelian X-groups. If G is a group such that the factor group
G/G0 ∈ X, then γn (G)/γn+1 (G) ∈ X for each natural number n.
1.8 Let G be a group. If j, k are natural numbers, then [γj (G), γk (G)] ≤ γj+k (G)
and γj (γk (G)) ≤ γjk (G).
1.9 Let G be a group and let K be a normal subgroup of G. Then [γn (G), K] ≤
[K, n G] for all natural numbers n. Furthermore, if H is a subgroup of G such that
G = HK, then γn+1 (G) = γn+1 (H)[K, n G], for all natural numbers n.
1.10 Let G be a group and let K be a normal subgroup of G. If K and G/K 0 are
nilpotent, then G is nilpotent. Moreover,
! !
ncl (K) + 1 ncl (K)
ncl (G) ≤ ncl (G/K 0 ) − .
2 2
6 Infinite Groups
The derived and lower central series of a group G are but two examples of the
notion of a descending series. More generally, the family
G = V0 ≥ V1 ≥ V2 ≥ . . . Vα ≥ Vα+1 ≥ . . . Vγ = 1
T
such that Vα+1 is normal in Vα and Vλ = β<λ Vβ , for all limit ordinals λ is called a
descending series. A descending series is called normal if each Vα is normal in G.
The subgroups Vα for α ≤ γ are called the terms of the series and the factor
groups Vα /Vα+1 for α < γ are called the factors of the series.
If X is a class of groups, then a group G is called a hypo-X group if it has a
descending series of normal subgroups, which is infinite in general, terminating in 1,
whose factors belong to X. If X = A, the class of abelian groups, we again obtain the
class of hypoabelian groups.
Since in a group the factor K/H is abelian if and only if K 0 ≤ H, we have:
1.13 A group G is soluble if and only if G has a finite descending series of normal
subgroups
G = V0 ≥ V1 ≥ · · · ≥ Vn = 1
whose factors are abelian. Furthermore, dl(G) ≤ n.
G = V0 ≥ V1 ≥ · · · ≥ Vn = 1
We can construct a further canonical series of a group G this time starting with
the center. Let ζ0 (G) = 1, ζ1 (G) = ζ(G) and recursively define ζα+1 (G)/ζα (G) =
ζ(G/ζα (G)) for all ordinals α and ζλ (G) = ∪β<λ ζβ (G) for all limit ordinals λ. The
series
1 = ζ0 (G) ≤ ζ1 (G) ≤ . . . ζα (G) ≤ ζα+1 (G) ≤ . . . ζγ (G)
is called the upper central series of the group G.
The terms of this series are called hypercenters; they are characteristic sub-
groups of G. The last term ζγ (G) is called the upper hypercenter of G and we have
ζ(G/ζγ (G)) = 1. The notation ζ∞ (G) is also frequently used for the upper hyper-
center. The ordinal γ is called the hypercentral length of G and will be denoted by
zl(G).
A group G is said to be hypercentral if ζ∞ (G) = G.
We next note some of the properties of the hypercenters of groups.
We say that a group G has finite exponent e, for some natural number e, if the
order of each element of G is a divisor of e and e is the least natural number with
this property.
Let π be a set of primes. A group G is said to be π-torsion-free if G has no
elements of order p for each p ∈ π. As usual, when π is the set, P, of all primes, the
P-torsion-free groups are just called torsion-free.
(i) If the center of G has finite exponent e, then ζn+1 (G)/ζn (G) has finite exponent
dividing e, for each natural number n;
(ii) If the center of G is π-torsion-free for some set of primes π, then the upper
hypercenter of G is also π-torsion-free.
The first assertion here is proved in the paper [Dix64] of S. Dixmier, whereas
the second assertion appears in the paper [McL56b] of D. H. McLain. Thus, certain
properties of the center can be transferred to other upper central factors.
Next we describe the connections between the terms of the upper and lower central
series.
(iii) if H is a subgroup of G such that G = Hζn (G), then γn+1 (G) = γn+1 (H).
1 = V0 ≤ V1 ≤ . . . Vα ≤ Vα+1 ≤ . . . Vγ = G
8 Infinite Groups
S
such that Vα is normal in G and Vλ = β<α Vβ for all limit ordinals λ < γ is called
an ascending series of normal subgroups or normal ascending series of G.
As with descending series, the subgroups Vα , for α ≤ γ, are called the terms of
this series and the factor groups Vα+1 /Vα are called the factors of the series.
Let X be a class of groups (which can also be defined by means of a group
theoretical property). A group G is called a hyper-X group if it has an ascending
normal series, which is infinite in general, whose factors belong to X.
Thus if X = A, the class of abelian groups, we obtain the class of hyperabelian
groups. If X = F, the class of finite groups, we obtain the class of hyperfinite groups.
1 = V0 ≤ V1 ≤ · · · ≤ Vj ≤ Vj+1 ≤ · · · ≤ Vn = G
This result shows that the lengths of the upper and lower central series of a
nilpotent group are the same and that the nilpotency class of G may then be defined
as the smallest of the lengths of the finite series of normal subgroups of G whose
factors are G-central.
If the group G has an infinite ascending series of normal subgroups whose factors
are G-central, then it may no longer have a descending series of normal subgroups
whose factors are G-central. An example of this type is described next.
Let A be a quasicyclic 2-group (see page 18), say
Since A is abelian, there is an automorphism α such that α(a) = a−1 for all a ∈ A
and clearly |α| = 2. This automorphism defines a semidirect product G = A o hdi,
where |d| = 2 and ad = α(a) for all a ∈ A. Then, the upper central series of G is the
series
1 ≤ ha1 i ≤ ha2 i ≤ · · · ≤ han i ≤ . . . A ≤ G
whereas A = G0 and γ3 (G) = [A, G] = A so that γ2 (G) = γ3 (G) 6= 1.
However, the following interesting result was proved by D. M. Smirnov [Smi53b].
1.20 Let G be a hypercentral group such that zl(G) = ω, the first infinite ordinal.
Then γω+1 (G) = 1.
Important Subgroups 9
1 = XC0 (G) ≤ XC1 (G) ≤ . . . XCα (G) ≤ XCα+1 (G) ≤ . . . XCγ (G)
by letting XC1 (G) = XC(G) and recursively defining XCα+1 (G)/XCα (G) =
XC(G/XCα (G)) for all ordinals α such that XCλ (G) = ∪β<λ XCβ (G) for all limit
ordinals λ.
The last term XCγ (G) is called the upper XC-hypercenter of G and we have
XC(G/XCγ (G)) = 1.
A group G is said to be XC-hypercentral if the upper XC-hypercenter of G co-
incides with G. Also, G is called XC-nilpotent if the upper XC-hypercenter of G
coincides with G and the upper XC-central series of G is finite.
In particular, when X is the class F, of finite groups, the corresponding terms are
upper FC-central series, upper FC-hypercenter, FC-hypercentral and FC-nilpotent,
respectively.
Next we consider a further canonical series of groups.
Let G be a group and H be a subgroup of G. Starting with the normal closure
we can construct a series as follows. We let v0,G (H) = G, v1,G (H) = H G and define
vα+1,G (H) = H vα,G (H) for every ordinal α. As usual, vλ,G (H) = ∩β<λ vβ,G (H) for all
limit ordinals λ.
We may then construct the lower normal closure series
G = v0,G (H) ≥ v1,G (H) ≥ . . . vα,G (H) ≥ vα+1,G (H) ≥ . . . vγ,G (H) = D
G = V0 ≥ V1 ≥ V2 ≥ . . . Vα ≥ Vα+1 ≥ . . . Vγ = H
10 Infinite Groups
T
such that Vα+1 is normal in Vα and Vλ = β<λ Vβ for all limit ordinals λ. A descending
series is called normal if each term of the series is normal in G.
It is easily seen that a subgroup H is descendant in G if there exists a descending
series from G to H.
Again, the subgroups Vα , for α ≤ γ, are called the terms of this series and the
factor groups Vα /Vα+1 are called the factors of the series.
A subgroup H is said to be subnormal in a group G if H is descendant in G and
the lower normal closure series of H in G has finite length.
It is easy to see that a subgroup H is subnormal in G if there is a series
G = V0 ≥ V1 ≥ · · · ≥ Vk ≥ Vk+1 ≥ · · · ≥ Vn = H
α the subgroup Nα+1,G (H) = NG (Nα,G (H)) and Nλ,G (H) = ∪β<λ Nβ,G (H)) for all
limit ordinals λ. In this way, we may construct the upper normalizer series
Slightly weakening the last condition we obtain a further important type of sub-
group.
A subgroup H of a group G is called abnormal in G if g ∈ hH, H g i for each
element g ∈ G.
Abnormal subgroups were studied in the paper [Hal37c] of P. Hall, while the term
“abnormal subgroup” is due to R. Carter [Car61].
We note that abnormal and weakly abnormal subgroups are contranormal, but
the converse is false.
Ascending and descending series are a special case of the following general con-
struction.
Let G be a group and let S be a family of subgroups of G. Then S is called a
Kurosh-Chernikov series if it satisfies the following conditions:
(KC1) G ∈ S;
(KC3) for every subfamily L of S the intersection of all elements of L and the union
of all elements of L belong to S. In particular, for each non-trivial element
g of the group G, let
[
Vg = {H ∈ S|g ∈
/ H},
\
Λg = {H ∈ S|g ∈ H}.
Then Vg , Λg ∈ S.
(KC4) for each non-trivial element g of the group G the subgroup Vg is normal in
Λg .
The factor groups Λg /Vg are called the sections of the system S.
If every subgroup of S is normal in G, then S is called a normal Kurosh-Chernikov
series. In this case, the factor groups Λg /Vg are called the factors of the system S.
Such families were introduced by A. G. Kurosh and S. N. Chernikov in their
fundamental classical article [KC47]. Further information concerning series in groups
can be found in [KC47] and [Rob72a].
Let S, R be Kurosh-Chernikov series (respectively normal Kurosh-Chernikov se-
ries). If R contains S, then we say that R is a refinement of S. The refinement is
called proper if R =6 S.
The Kurosh-Chernikov series (respectively normal Kurosh-Chernikov series) S is
called a composition (respectively chief ) series if S has no proper refinement.
We note the following result from [KC47].
1.23 Let G be a locally soluble group. Then G has a normal Kurosh-Chernikov chief
series whose factors are abelian.
Important Subgroups 13
1.25 Let G be a locally soluble group. Then the chief factors of G are abelian. Fur-
thermore, the chief factors are either elementary abelian p-groups for some prime p
or are torsion-free divisible groups. In particular, simple locally soluble groups have
prime order.
1.26 Let G be a locally nilpotent group. Then the chief factors of G are central of
prime order.
The classes of hyperabelian and locally soluble groups are distinct (see [Rob72a],
for example). In particular, a finitely generated hyperabelian group need not be sol-
uble and a locally soluble group need not be hyperabelian. Furthermore, every free
group is hypoabelian (indeed hypocentral), but free groups are not soluble in general.
The following result is often useful.
1.29 Let G be a group and let S be a normal locally finite subgroup of G such that
G/S is locally finite. Then G is locally finite.
1.31 A group G is hypercentral if and only if for each element a ∈ G and every
countable subset {xn |n ∈ N} of elements of G there exists an integer k such that
[. . . [[a, x1 ], x2 ], . . . , xk ] = 1.
1.34 A group G has the normalizer condition if and only if every subgroup of G is
ascendant.
The following basic property of groups with the normalizer condition appears in
the paper [Plo51] of B. I. Plotkin.
If π is a set of primes and G is a group, then we let Oπ (G) denote the largest
normal π-subgroup of G. If π = Π(G), the set of prime divisors of the orders of
elements of G, then Oπ (G) is the largest normal periodic subgroup of G, which we
denote by Tor(G). This subgroup is called the periodic part of G. In some cases,
when Tor(G) consists of all the elements of G of finite order, then it is called the
torsion subgroup of G.
Locally nilpotent groups enjoy some of the properties of abelian groups as the
following result shows.
1.37 Let G be a locally nilpotent group and let π be a set of primes. Then
(iii) For each prime p, the set Torp (G), consisting of all elements of p-power order,
is a characteristic subgroup of Tor(G) and Tor(G) = Dr Torp (G).
p∈Π(G)
Now we consider the basic properties of torsion-free locally nilpotent groups which
were proved in the paper [Mal49].
Let G be a group. We recall that a subgroup H of G is called pure, or isolated, in
G if either hgi ∩ H = hgi or hgi ∩ H = 1, for each g ∈ G.
16 Infinite Groups
1.39 Let G be a torsion-free locally nilpotent group. Then G has a central Kurosh-
Chernikov series whose terms are pure subgroups of G.
1.40 Let G be a group. The subgroup generated by all the normal locally nilpotent
subgroups of G is a normal locally nilpotent subgroup of G.
This result implies that every group G has a unique maximal normal locally
nilpotent subgroup called the locally nilpotent radical or the Hirsch-Plotkin radical
of G, denoted by Ln(G). Of course Ln(G) is a characteristic subgroup of G.
We also note the following useful result which was proved by Plotkin in [Plo55].
The results above show that the class of radical groups is precisely the class of
groups with an ascending series each factor of which is locally nilpotent. Locally
nilpotent groups and hyperabelian groups are examples of radical groups.
We define the radical series
1 = R0 ≤ R1 ≤ . . . Rα ≤ Rα+1 ≤ . . . Rγ
Important Subgroups 17
of a group G by
R1 = Ln(G)
Rα+1 /Rα = Ln(G/Rα ) for all ordinals α < γ
[
Rλ = Rβ for limit ordinals λ < γ
β<λ
Ln(G/Rγ ) = 1
It may happen that Ln(G) is trivial. The group G is radical if and only if G =
Rγ for some term Rγ of this series. Since the Hirsch-Plotkin radical is always a
characteristic subgroup, a group G is radical if and only if G has an ascending series
of characteristic subgroups with locally nilpotent factors.
Here are some other useful properties of radical groups.
The next result is also due to Plotkin [Plo55], this time concerning a different
type of radical.
(i) The subgroup generated by the normal locally finite subgroups of G is a normal
locally finite subgroup of G;
(iii) The subgroup generated by the normal radical subgroups of G is a normal radical
subgroup of G;
The result above shows that if G contains a non-trivial ascendant locally finite
subgroup, then it has a unique largest characteristic locally finite subgroup, the locally
finite radical, which we denote by Lf(G). This result in turn allows us to coalesce
the Hirsch-Plotkin radical and locally finite radicals to obtain the following class of
groups.
A group G is called generalized radical if G has an ascending series whose factors
are locally nilpotent or locally finite. It should be noted that in the past some authors
have used a more restrictive definition where the factors are locally nilpotent or finite,
which we later call nearly radical.
The basic properties of generalized radical groups are as follows.
We can also form the still larger class of groups, the class of locally generalized
radical groups. In such groups, every finitely generated subgroup is generalized radical.
Prüfer p-groups also arise somewhat more concretely; they can be thought of as
the multiplicative group of complex pth roots of unity, or as the set of elements of
p-power order in the additive abelian group Q/Z.
A further example of a divisible group is the additive group Q of the field of
rational numbers.
These groups are the building blocks of divisible abelian groups as the following
result shows.
The following important property of divisible abelian groups was obtained in the
paper [Bae40a].
Suppose now that the abelian group G is F-perfect, but that there is a natu-
ral number n such that G 6= Gn . Then (G/Gn )n = 1 and using 1.47 we see that
G/Gn is a direct product of finite cyclic groups. This shows that G then has a non-
trivial subgroup of finite index, a contradiction which shows that G = Gn for all n.
Consequently, G is divisible.
20 Infinite Groups
1.48 Let G be a hypercentral group and let A be an abelian normal p-subgroup for
some prime p. If G/CG (A) contains no subgroups of index p, then A ≤ ζ(G).
(ii) D0 ≤ ζ(G);
(iii) Dα ∼
= Q for all 0 < α < γ;
(v) Aα ∩ Dα = 1;
(vi) Aγ = G.
Finally, we note several results concerning radicable locally nilpotent groups ob-
tained by V. M. Glushkov in the paper [Glu52].
(ii) If G is radicable, then every term of the lower central series of G is radicable.
(iii) If G is radicable, then every term of the lower derived series of G is radicable.
Important Subgroups 21
x = n1 y1 + · · · + nk yk
and we merely note that the book of L. A. Kurdachenko, N. N. Semko and I. Ya.
Subbotin [KSS08] is concerned with the theory of modules over Dedekind domains.
Let R be an integral domain and let K denote the field of fractions of R. A
non-zero R-submodule A of K is called a fractional ideal of R if aA ≤ R for some
non-zero element a ∈ R.
This definition shows that all elements of A have a “common denominator”. If
the ring R contains a fractional ideal A, then A is an ideal in the usual sense and the
converse holds for non-zero ideals.
If A, B are fractional ideals, then their product AB is defined as the set of all sums
a1 b1 + · · · + am bm , where ai ∈ A, bi ∈ B for 1 ≤ i ≤ m. Then AB is also a fractional
ideal and a non-zero R-submodule of K. If x, y are non-zero elements of R such that
xA ≤ R and yB ≤ R, then for every element c of the form c = a1 b1 + · · · + am bm we
have
Obviously, A(BC) = (AB)C for all fractional ideals A, B, C of R. This means that
the set FI(R) of fractional ideals of R is a commutative semigroup and R is its
identity element.
A fractional ideal A is said to be a principal fractional ideal if A = xR for some
0 6= x ∈ R.
If A is a fractional ideal of R, then let A0 = {x ∈ K|xA ≤ R}. It is possible to
prove that A0 is also a fractional ideal of R. We say that A is invertible if AA0 = R
and in this case we write A−1 instead of A0 .
An integral domain D is called a Dedekind domain if each of its fractional ideals
is invertible. In this case, the semigroup FI(D) is a group.
There are several definitions of Dedekind domains, but we shall not give them here
and refer the reader to [KSS08]. Note that every Dedekind domain is a Noetherian
ring and that every prime ideal is maximal.
theory, we have the following fundamental result. The reader can find a proof in
[Fuc70, Chapter III], or any one of a number of other excellent books.
(i) If G has an infinite Z-independent subset, then all maximal Z-independent sub-
sets of G have the same cardinality;
1.56 Let G be a torsion-free abelian group and let k be a natural number. Then
rZ (G) ≤ k if and only if G is isomorphic to some subgroup of A1 × · · · × Ak , for
certain groups Ai such that Ai ∼
= Q for 1 ≤ i ≤ k.
24 Infinite Groups
From this we see that an abelian group G has finite Z-rank at most r if and only
if G/Tor(G) is isomorphic to a subgroup of the additive group
Q ⊕ ··· ⊕ Q.
| {z }
r
1.57 Let P be an abelian p-group for some prime p. Then rp (P ) = r is finite if and
only if every elementary abelian p-section U/V of P is finite, with rp (U/V ) ≤ rp (P )
and there is an elementary abelian section A/B of P such that rp (A/B) = r.
Our next result characterizes abelian p-groups with finite p-rank. The definition
of Chernikov group is given following 3.8.
1.59 Let P be an abelian p-group for some prime p. Then rp (P ) is finite if and only
if P is a Chernikov group.
Important Subgroups 25
1.60 Let G be a group. Then the Frattini subgroup of G coincides with the set of
non-generators of G.
1.62 Let G be a finite group and let K, L be normal subgroups of G such that
K ≤ L and K ≤ Frat(G). If L/K is nilpotent, then L is nilpotent. In particular, if
G/Frat(G) is nilpotent, then G is nilpotent.
This result implies the following assertion which was obtained by G. Frattini in
the paper [Fra85].
We also note the following useful result which was obtained by B. Huppert in the
paper [Hup54].
1.64 Let P denote a group theoretical property satisfying the following conditions:
(i) if the group S has the property P, then every factor group of S has the property
P;
(ii) if K is a group and K/Frat(K) has the property P it always follows that K
has the property P.
26 Infinite Groups
If G is a finite group and L is a normal subgroup of G such that G/L has the
property P, then G contains a subgroup S having the property P such that G = LS.
1.65 Let G be a finite group and let L be a normal subgroup of G. If G/L is nilpotent,
then G contains a nilpotent subgroup S such that G = LS.
1.66 Let G be a finite group and let L be a normal subgroup of G. Then L is nilpotent
if and only if L0 ≤ Frat(G). In particular, G is nilpotent if and only if G0 ≤ Frat(G).
This leads us to the determination of groups which can (or cannot) act as the
Frattini subgroup of a group. For example, the following result was proved in the
paper of C. Hobby [Hob60].
(i) If ζ(H) is cyclic, then H cannot be the Frattini subgroup of any finite p-group
G;
(ii) If H 0 has index p2 in H, then H cannot be the Frattini subgroup of any finite
p-group G.
The following property of the Frattini subgroup is known as the Burnside Basis
Theorem.
1.69 Let p be a prime and let G be a finite p-group. Suppose that the Frattini
subgroup of G has index pd in G and let G/Frat(G) be generated by the elements
yj Frat(G), for 1 ≤ j ≤ d. Then G is generated by the elements y1 , . . . , yd . Fur-
thermore, if M is a set of generators for G, then M contains a subset X such that
G = hXi and G/Frat(G) is generated by the set {xFrat(G)|x ∈ X}.
1.70 Let G be a finite p-group for some prime p and let A be a subgroup of the
automorphism group of G. If A = CA (G/Frat(G)), then A = 1.
Madison
[Calmly regarding her with great good humour and breaking into a
laugh as she fails in her search.] Eh, yah, yah, sea’ch an’ look,
sea’ch an’ look.
Lucy
Oh, Madison, ain’ yo’ got no honin’ ter be hones’ at all?
Madison
Hones’! What kin’ er fool talk is dat? I done got my ear-string bus’
now an’ dem preachah wu’ds can’t fool me no mo’. You’ll neveh fin’
it, honey. ’Cause why? ’Cause I’m got it in my pants an’ I goin’ to
keep it f’um a foolish woman.
Lucy
[Running to him desperately.] You got to give it to me.
Madison
Gal, ef you don’ tu’n me loose I’ll git ugly. Now, look heah. I wants
to heah de las’ er dis. I got new ideahs. I got big plots en plans. I
done give you de plankses in my flatfo’m an’ I’m a-goin’ to stan’ on
hit. When I makes a lot mo’ money in de broker business I’m a-goin’
to give you all de gold youah ap’un’ll hold, ev’y day er youah life, an’
you won’ have to wait long. But till dat day an’ to dat time I’m de
treasu’eh er dis lodge an’ I’m de stake holdeh er dis race an’ dat
money stays in de pu’se in de hip er my ol’ jeanses.
[He says this last slowly and with growing emphasis
and as he ends, gives himself a resounding
thwack on the hip over his pocket. There is a
moment’s pause. He puts his hand hurriedly in the
pocket and then dazedly into one on the other
hip.]
Oh, my Lawd, Oh, wheah is it? I got to have it. Oh, I couldn’ lose it,
hit ain’ mine ter lose. Stay by me, Lucy, an’ he’p me fin’ it, git down
on youah knees, Lucy. Oh, wheah did I drop it? I’m gittin’ old an’
needs it. Ef I lose dis I lose all my push. I was jes’ goin’ into business
an’ we all wuz goin’ to fly high. I got to fin’ it. I ain’ give up. Lemme
think. Oh, I hopes some hones’ puhson foun’ it. Lemme come on
down—Know I put it on dat side ’cause dat de side Mistah Long he
wuz on—Oh, I’ll go crazy— [He strikes his forehead groaning.]
Lucy
[Starting.] Mistah Long! He’s cashiah in de Dime Savin’s! How he
give you money?
Madison
Oh, lemme see—he gimme de money an’ I put it right in yere. [He
fumbles again distractedly in his pocket.]
Lucy
[Pursuing him desperately.] Onliest money at de Dime Savin’s is
de money. You couldn’t draw hit out. You didn’ do dat,—you
couldn’—Tell me if you did fo’ I’ll fin’ it out tomorrer—Oh, tell me true
—you couldn’ when it’s in my name—tell me now fo’ I’ll find it out.
Madison
Oh, I can’t stand it.
Lucy
Ef you wan’ me to he’p you den be free wif me. How you draw
money from de Bank? I give you no papeh. You couldn’ draw de
money.
Madison
Wilson Byrd, he gimme de papeh.
Lucy
I give him no papeh.
Madison
He write it fo’ you.
Lucy
Oh, Gawd, dat w’ite man write my name. You drawed de money—I
see it now. You had dealin’s wif a fo’geh, Wilson Byrd.
Madison
Spar’ me an’ he’p me. He tol’ me ef I draw de money he’d take me
into business wif him an’ gimme de guitar besides.
Lucy
Did you spar’ me? Fifty dollahs! You said fifty, didn’ you? How
could you do hit? More’n six months’ ha’d slavin’. Six months mo’
befo’ I can resto’ it back. I could a bought de house tomorrer mo’nin’
an’ now hit’s six months off to pay in dat fifty. It was fifty, didn’ you
say? Maybe ’twuzn’ dat much. Tell me right. I’ll fin’ it out tomorrer.
Madison
Dis yere’ll kill me ef I can’t think.
Lucy
How much you draw? Tell me right. Look at me. Were hit fifty?
[She holds his eye.] Less? Mo’? How much? [She continues to hold
his lustreless eyes, reading them.] A hunde’d? Two hunde’d? Eight
hunde’d? [A pause ensues as she reads the truth in his face.] All of
hit! [She sinks in a chair.] Twelve yeahs’ labour sence I married you
an’ termorrer I wuz goin’ to mek de payment an’ we’d a bin undeh
owah own roof. I’m done. I could a paid off pa’t, mebbe fifty, but I
won’ las’ twelve yeahs mo’ at de same thing. But I thank Thee,
Lawd, dat it wuz stole f’um us all ef hit had to be stole.
Madison
Ef I could on’y think. Had hit in de bank—felt hit an’ had it on Thu’d
Street—slapped hit an’ had it at Joe’s house—slapped hit an’ had it
comin’ up de alley—jes’ fo’ I clum de hill—lemme see—clum de hill
—went in th’oo Wilson Byrd’s hedge fence—he gimme de guitar—
scrape my back comin’ out— [His face shows gradual recollection,
and suddenly brightens.] I knows now! Dat’s hit! In dat white man’s
yard wheah he gimme de guitar! I wuz jes’ goin’ to give him de
money when somebody grabbed him f’um behin’. He give a squawk
an’ skeered me. I run out th’oo his hedge fence an’ scrape my back.
I scrape de pocketbook out. She’s dere! In dat Wilson Byrd’s yard. I’ll
git it yit. Watch me. [He grabs his hat and runs excitedly toward the
door.]
Lucy
[Rushing toward him.] No, sumpin’ might happen. You might git
mix up wif him ergin. Lemme go, but I mus’ resto’ dis guitar at Uncle
Williams, as I go by his house. I’ll slip it on his porch. Maybe he’ll
neveh know it wuz gone. Oh, if somebody had seen it heah! How
could I have stood it?
Williams
Good evenin’, Lucy.
Madison
What he say? Do he know?
Lucy
[Desperately seizing the bag and pressing it into his hands as she
turns him again toward doorway at back.] Oh, I cain’ tell. On’y resto’
dis in case he don’ know er case he do. Now’s de one chance to be
hones’.
Madison
Huh. What erbout dat eight hunderd dollah?
Lucy
I don’ know. Trus’ Gawd an’ be hones’.
Madison
Huh uh. One of us has got to go look fo’ dat money.
Lucy
One of us has got to take back de guitar.
Madison
I’m goin’ fo’ de money.
Lucy
Den I’ll take dis. [She takes up the guitar and she and Madison go
toward door at back. Then she halts.] Oh, Madison, you can do bofe.
One of us has got to stay wif Uncle Williams. But take back de guitar
first.
Madison
All right. I’ll go. An’ I ain’t played on dis heah but twice. [He takes
the guitar from her.]
Lucy
Go now. Can you fin’ youah way to his porch in de dahk?
Madison
Will we find de money? Dat’s de p’oblem I wants de answeh fo’.
Lucy
[Haltingly, after a pause.] How—you like—de stove?
Williams
[Entering more vigorously than before.] Well’m, befo’ we goes any
furder we betteh come neareh de real p’int an’ question. I didn’ come
fo’ no stove dis night. [Madison shrinks back into the shadows.]
Lucy
[Slowly.] Yo’—don’—wan’—
Williams
No’m. To be sho’, I might tek de stove one er dese days, but dat
ain’ my erran’ now. Hit’s dis; does you know when we mek de
bargum about you buyin’ dis heah house?
Lucy
Twelve yeah ago.
Williams
Gal, you dreamin’! ’Tweren’t but las’ year. ’Twere de fus’ er
Octobah las’ year an’ I say I gives you de refusals fer one yeah.
’Membeh dat?
Lucy
Yassuh.
Williams
So fur so good. Now does you know what day de month dis is?
Lucy
Fus’ er Octobah.
Williams
Dat’s true as preachin’. Well’m, time’s up.
Lucy
What you mean?
Williams
I’m er man er my wuhd. Pay me de money an’ tek de house.
Lucy
Termorrer—
Williams
No. Termorrer won’ do.
Lucy
Why you push me so? Oh, please spar’ me an’ wait—wait anutheh
day.
Williams
No, I’m er business man. I kin sell de house fer mo’ money
termorrer but I hold’s to my wuhd ter sell it to you. I holds to it an’
loses money, but it falls due dis day an’ night an’ I won’ stretch it one
jump er my hea’t.
Lucy
You know—de bank—ain’t open—
Williams
Sign de check fer hit. You kin do dat, cain’t you?
Lucy
I—s’pose—I—kin.
Williams
Den up an’ do hit. Heah’s er check, all wrote out but de signin’.
[She takes the check he produces.] An’ heah’s one er dese fountum
pins. [She takes the pen.] Octobeh fus’—pay to Zek’l Williams—eight
hunderd dollahs. Des write “Lucy Sparrow.” [She mechanically turns
to do so.] Looks easy, sho’. But de law allows hit; dis writin’ out
money. [He pauses, then adds impressively.] Dat is, ef you got de
money in de bank. Co’se ef de money ain’ dah an’ you writes de
check fer hit de law puts you in State prism. [She stops and stares at
him.] [The pen falls from her hand and the check flutters to the floor.]
What de matteh? You wants de house, don’ you? [Lucy’s head
sinks.] An’ you got de money, ain’ you?
Madison
Dat’s de question. [He comes forward out of the shadow.]
Williams
[Seemingly observing Madison for the first time during the
evening.] Why, heighyo, Madison. I bin lookin’ fer you dis very
evenin’. Whah you bin?
Madison
Bin home.
Williams
Sho’ly not, Madison, sho’ly not all evenin’? Has you?
Madison
Yes.
Williams
Well, ain’ dat de whu’lygig? I wuz lookin’ fer you at Pratt’s sto’ at
eight o’clock an’ dey say you jes’ lef’ dah. You wuz dah, weren’t you?
Madison
No, suh.
Williams
Well, dere I am fool agin. An’ who you think done fool me?
Madison
Dunno.
Williams
Well, suh, ’tweren’t no one but— [He pauses a moment.] Wilson
Byrd.
Lucy
Byrd! [Springing to her feet with the shock.]
Williams
[After watching the two a moment.] So you ain’ got de money no
mo’, is you? [They are speechless before him.] I knows you ain’
’ca’se I knows who has got hit.
Madison
[Involuntarily.] Who?
Williams
I has. [He observes them and then chuckles softly.] I has de
money an’ de bargum’s closed, fer de goods is bin delivered an’
dey’re right in dis room in dat corner. One guitar at eight hunderd
dollahs. Insterments comes higher’n what dey did once but you
would have it an’ now you got it an’ everybody’s fixed.
Madison
[Groaning and bending over the table.] Oh!
Williams
Yassuh, de man what buys guitars at dat price su’tinly plays on de
golden strings. Eight hunderd fer one guitar makes ’m mighty near
twenty thousand dollehs er dozen. De cos’ er livin’ is shore gone up
but ef you mus’ you mus’.
Madison
Oh!
Williams
Well, I cain’ stay heah, I got er be amblin’ on. I much erblige ter
you to mek youah plans to move out er heah fo’ I got ter sell de
house befo’ sundown. Well, so long, an’ I hopes you gits all de good
er youah high price music. [He turns again with his feeble old man’s
step toward the doorway, putting on his hat.] I wish y’all good
evenin’.
Madison
[Moving toward him with the threatening determination of despair.]
Say, I’ve got to have dat money. I sees red. I’m gone bad an’ I’ll kill
befo’ I’ll lose hit.
Williams
You kill me! You tek money away from me! Why, you po’ grain er
chaff, you don’ know me. I’m a king in my own right. I got ways an’
means er pertecktin’ myse’f dat you don’ even dream on an’ I don’
need to lay a fingeh on you to do hit. Furdermo’ I could brain you wif
dis stick but ef you cross me I won’ be dat easy on you. Ef you don’
wan’ wuss’n dat don’ cross me no furder er youah troubles’ll begin
fer fa’r.
Lucy
Oh, please don’ lay nothin’ on him.
Williams
You po’ sufferin’ gal, I won’ lay nothin’ onto ’im but I’m a-goin’ to
tek sumpin’ off’n you. I’m goin’ tek de burding er dish yere pack er
laziness off’n you. An’ fus’ I wants ter show you dish yere piece er
papeh. [He produces a folded document and opens it.] Does yo’
know who wrote it? Answeh me. [He shoves the paper under
Madison’s eye.]
Madison
It looks like dat Wilson Byrd’s writin’.
Williams
Yassuh, an’ what’s mo’ it is dat man’s writin’. It’s his confession dat
he fo’ge Lucy Sparrow’s name. I saw dat man steal my guitar an’
follered him home. Dah I grabbed him, dah I foun’ de purse wif
Lucy’s name inside an’ dah I made dat thief write out his confession.
Knowed so much of his meanness already dat he had to do hit. An’
now I owns you. Does you undehstan’ dat? Answeh me.
Madison
Yas suh, no suh.
Williams
Well, I’ll take’n cl’ar up de myst’ry fer you. I got dis confession
outer Byrd an’ I got other things ter prove hit an’ I kin bring him an’
you too, bofe befo’ de gran’ jury.
Lucy
Oh, my sweet Jesus, save him. [The old man stands watching the
two before him for some time in silence. Lucy falls on her knees
before him.] Oh, don’t sen’ Madison to de lawyers.
Williams
No, Lucy, I ain’ wishful ter.
Lucy
You won’t?
Williams
Mebbe not. But fus’, les’ put all dis talk aside dat I bin talkin’ up to
now. I bin puttin’ on an’ pretendin’ in ordeh ter try you bofe an’ sif’ de
chaff from de grain in you. I des bin playin’ wif you ter see how good
you is an’ how ornry dish yere man er youahn is. Yit I’ll take an’ give
him er chance even so, an’ I’ll pluck him f’um de bu’nin’ ef he follers
de paf I p’ints out ter him. But we all got ter have cl’ar unde’stan’in’
’bout dat. Fus’ an’ fo’mos’ youah money is all safe wif me. De house
is youah’n.
Lucy
You means you sell it fer de money.
Williams
In co’se. You didn’t speck I’d steal too, like a w’ite man, did you?
I’ll fetch you de deeds fo’ hit fus’ thing in de mo’nin’.
Lucy
Oh, fu’give me, I was all mix up. But you won’ sen’ Madison to de
gran’ jury neitheh?
Williams
I say I ain’ honin’ ter.
Lucy
Oh, my Makeh, I thank Thee fo’ Thy mercy.
Williams
But I shorely goin’ to put dis man er youah’n th’oo er tes’ ter see
whetheh he’s fitten ter keep out er jail. Madison, will you tek er tes’?
Madison
[Humbly.] Yassuh. What is it?
Williams
A guitar.
Madison
A guitar!
Williams
Yassuh, dat’s hit, no mo’ ner no less. I’m goin’ give you dat guitar
—but—dere’s suhtinly goin’ to be a string tied to it. You kin take dat
guitar but you got to make somethin’ outer yourself wif her or back
she’ll come to me. You kin give lessons an’ learn folks music or you
kin write down de music you make, but you got to do somethin’ wif it
fer Lucy. You got to wake up or I’ll take de guitar. Which’ll it be?
Make youah choice.
Madison
[Crushed.] I’ll—keep de guitar.
Williams
An’ dat ain’ all. You got ter quit runnin’ wif Byrd an’ Byrd wif you,
you got ter be a better husban’ an’ you got to min’ everything Lucy
tells you. Will you do hit?
Madison
Yassuh.
Williams
An’ yo’ ain’ much of er temp’unce man neitheh, is you, Madison?
Madison
I’s a temp’unce man but I ain’ no frantic.
Williams
Well, suh, you got ter jine de frantics now. No dram drinking at all.
Will you quit hit er go ter jail?
Madison
I’ll quit.
Williams
Well, dat’s on’y a promise but I’ll shore hol’ you to hit er put you
behin’ de bahs. Why, look heah, man, does you know how you stan’
’pon top er dis yu’th? Does you know how you liken to er tree?
’Sposin’ sumpin’ wif er cool eye like er tree could see you an’ talk. I
cain’ jedge you ca’m but er tree could. Tree would look at you an’
say, “Does dat ’ere man wu’k?” Win’ ’ud whispeh, “No.” “Do he eat?”
“Yas ’n git fat,” respon’ de win’. “Who shines on him?” “His wife,” win’
say. “Do he put fo’th flower an’ bless de wife?” say de tree. “No.” “Do
he give shade an’ shelteh ter de wife?” say de tree. “No.” “Well,
chop’m down an’ bu’n him befo’ he rots,” say de tree. “Dat’s all.” But
mebbe I kin mek mo’ of him dan dat an’ so I’ll try prunin’ him an’
graftin’ some good labeh onto him. An’ I kin’ er think hit’ll save him