Child Labour in The Fashion Industry

You might also like

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 20

Child Labour affect the Fashion Industry

Student’s Name

Student ID

Professor’s Name

Institutional Affiliation

Course Code and Name

Unit Code and Name

Due Date
Last Name2

Introduction

Only the petroleum business generates more pollutants than the clothing sector. Fast

fashion leads to excessive dumping of clothing pieces as customers try to stay on the same page

with current trends and the clothes have short lifespan. Therefore, this industry is faced with

challenges in ensuring sustainability. When the entire quick-fashion logistical process is

considered, from the gathering of initial components to the finished product's disposal, this sector

is shown to be responsible for 10% of the world's total carbon footprint. The clothing sector is

notorious for taking advantage of its workforce, which is disproportionately comprised of

women and children. About 80% of the global forty million textile employees are women under

the age of thirty-five, as reported by the International Labor Organization 1. When such

inappropriate information is disclosed to the public, the firms lose reputation. Most of them are

paid much below the poverty line and are required to work inhumanely long hours 2. Women in

the textile industry often lack access to basic amenities like toilets and showers. The fast-fashion

industry struggles to get appropriate textiles and components for the unique designs they dream

up.

So, it is on them to find an entity that can make clothing from those textiles at an

affordable price. After production, these items must be shipped to retailers in every region of the

world. Creating a line of clothing requires a significant investment of money upfront 3. After that,

the company has to sit on plenty of merchandise without comprehending how well the products

will retail. Insufficient insight into this intricate network causes several inefficiencies, which in

1
Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
2
Somani, Vishakha. “5 Common Problems Faced by the Fashion Industry.” World Fashion Exchange (WFX.com), March 25,
2022. https://www.worldfashionexchange.com/blog/5-common-problems-faced-by-the-fashion-industry-with-solutions/
3
International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182)." (1999).
Last Name3

turn cause items to be brought to the marketplace late and, therefore, underperform4. The

meaning of child servitude, the reasons the fast Fashion sector employs children, the widespread

abuse of kids, well-known brands that engage in child labour, possible responses to the

challenge, and tips for determining if a company exploits children in any stage of its logistics

network or production are all covered in this article.

Definition of Child Labour

Not all job duties performed by juveniles should be considered child labour. It is typically

seen as a good thing when kids and teens who are older than the legal working age participate in

productive labour that does not compromise their health or well-being or get in the way of their

academic progress. This comprises helping out with the family company after classes and on

weekends, as well as taking on additional work during the summer months 5. Childhood

extracurricular practices like these help kids grow up healthy and strong, benefit their

households, and position them for success as contributing adults in the world. Child servitude is

typically characterized as activities that are detrimental to a child's psychological and physical

growth, as well as those that rob them of their energy, opportunities, and humanity 6. The term

"child labour" is used to describe situations in which children are subjected to work that poses

significant risks to their health and safety, both psychologically and physically, as well as

socially and ethically, and which prevents them from completing their education.

The definition of child labour changes depending on the developmental stage of the kid,

the nature of the activity, the number of hours spent on it, the quality of the working

circumstances, and the goals of the country in question. The response differs from one nation to

4
Moulds, Josephine. “Child Labour in the Fashion Supply Chain Where, Why and What Can Be Done.” The Guardian Labs -
Sponsored by UNICEF, 2023. https://labs.theguardian.com/unicef-child-labour/
5
Ibid International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182)." (1999).
6
ILO. “Child Labour in Cotton: A Briefing; International Law and Policy Institute (2015) Child Labour in the Indian
Cottonseed Sector, 2016.”
Last Name4

the next and even from one industry to the next within a single nation 7. Slavery, separation from

families, exposure to dangerous risks and diseases, or abandonment on the streets of major

metropolitan areas at young ages are all examples of the most dangerous factors leading to child

labour. While there are many kinds of child labour, the worst forms must be eradicated as soon

as possible in accordance with Article 3 of ILO Convention No. 182 8. The use, procurement, or

exposing of a kid to sexual slavery for the making of sexually explicit content or sexually

explicit performances; the use, acquisition, or rendering of a pre-schooler for illegal purposes,

particularly for the fabrication and trafficking of narcotics and all other forms of forced labour or

operations resembling enslavement, such as buying and selling of kids, debt servitude and forced

labour, and compelled work are unlawful9.

Reasons Behind Use of Child Labour in Fast Fashion Industry

Children Provide Cheaper Labour

Despite being illegal in most nations, child labour is common in the planet's

impoverished communities. The International Labour Organization projects that 170 million

children are working, with many of them producing textiles and clothes to meet the demand of

customers in Europe, the United States, and elsewhere 10. People are seeing positive changes.

Although the ILO reports a 30% drop in child labour from 2000 to 2012, 11% of kids worldwide

are still living in conditions that prevent them from getting an education without interruption 11.

Most of these children are employed in the textile and clothing industry, where they help meet

7
Baland, J. & Robinson J. (2000) Is child labor inefficient? Journal of Political Economy,108, 663-679
8
International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182)." (1999).
9
Ravallion, M & Wodon, Q., “Does child labour displace schooling? Evidence on behavioural responses to an enrollment
subsidy. Economic Journal, 110, C158-C175, 2000”.
10
Ibid Moulds, Josephine. “Child Labour in the Fashion Supply Chain Where, Why and What Can Be Done.” The Guardian
Labs - Sponsored by UNICEF, 2023. https://labs.theguardian.com/unicef-child-labour/
11
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
Last Name5

the high demand from shoppers in the West 12. With the rise of fast fashion, businesses have been

compelled to look for lower and cheaper ways to staff their factories 13. Many of the nations

where textiles and clothing are manufactured have abundant supplies of low-cost labour. Stop

Child Labour's worldwide campaign organizer, Sofie Ovaa, claims that many young women in

developing nations like India and Bangladesh are excited to work for little money and may be

easily lured into exploitative sectors like garment manufacturing and domestic servitude by the

promise of higher pay.

Poor Children Have no Options to Pursue

Hiring managers in southern India persuade families in poor countryside regions to bring

their children to textile factories by promising them a high salary, decent living conditions, three

complete meals daily, the chance to further their education, and a one-time payment after three

years. This is according to a new study published by the Centre for Research on Multinational

Corporations (SOMO) and the India Committee of the Netherlands (ICN) 14. The results of their

investigations in the real world prove that the children are, in fact, subjected to working

circumstances that are inhumane, even by the standards of contemporary servitude and the

lowest standards of child labour15. Since a significant portion of the fashion industry's supply

chain relies on low-skilled personnel, and some of these jobs are more appropriate for kids than

for older individuals, child labour is a serious problem in the industry 16. Companies favour hiring

youngsters for harvesting cotton since their little fingers cause less damage to the plant.

12
Ibid International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182)." (1999).
13
Ibid Baland, J. & Robinson J. (2000) Is child labor inefficient? Journal of Political Economy,108, 663-679
14
Ibid Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations (SOMO). “Branded Childhood: How garment brands contribute to
low wages, long working hours, school dropout and child labour in Bangladesh, 2017.”
15
Nifong, C. “No Sweat Pact to Cut Garment Worker Abuse. New York, The Christian Science Monitor, 1997.”
16
Ibid Moulds, Josephine. “Child Labour in the Fashion Supply Chain Where, Why and What Can Be Done.” The Guardian
Labs - Sponsored by UNICEF, 2023. https://labs.theguardian.com/unicef-child-labour/
Last Name6

Teenagers are viewed as compliant employees because they are able to operate beneath the

spotlight.

Children Have no Voice over Supervisors

The lack of labour organizations and other forms of societal authority, according to Ovaa,

makes it difficult for workers to negotiate for better workplace conditions. These individuals are

inadequately skilled and powerless in the workplace 17. Because of the enormous complexity of

the fashion logistical network, companies are able to get away with child labour. As a result,

major companies and customers will not know that youngsters are working for them 18. From the

cultivation of cotton kernels in Benin to its extraction in Uzbekistan, starting with the milling of

fibre in India to its final assembly in Bangladeshi manufacturing facilities, children are involved

in every step of the clothing sector's supply chain19.

Exploitation of Children in Fast Fashion Sector

Exploitation of Children in Cotton Farms

To move pollen grains from one crop to another, the cotton cultivation sector frequently

uses children. They frequently are paid less than the minimum wages, perform for extended

periods, and are frequently exposed to harmful chemicals. Children are reportedly working for

extended periods planting cotton in the springtime and gardening throughout the summer in

underdeveloped nations where cotton is one of the principal crops 20. Child labour is widespread

in every stage of the process, at the knitting and churning factories. Sixty percent of employees at

the factories SOMO studied in India were below the age of eighteen at the time they were hired,

17
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
18
Ibid Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations (SOMO). “Branded Childhood: How garment brands contribute to
low wages, long working hours, school dropout and child labour in Bangladesh, 2017.”
19
Ibid Moulds, Josephine. “Child Labour in the Fashion Supply Chain Where, Why and What Can Be Done.” The Guardian
Labs - Sponsored by UNICEF, 2023. https://labs.theguardian.com/unicef-child-labour/
20
Ibid International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182)." (1999).
Last Name7

with the youngest employee being only fifteen years old 21. The "cut-make-trim" step, in which

garments are assembled, also employs children22. Children work in clothing factories doing

everything from dying clothes to stitching on buttons to trimming and clipping strands to folding,

transporting, and packaging23. Children are forced to embellish, sequin, and smock (make pleats)

at tiny workplaces and residential settings.

Taking Advantage of the Supply Chain Complexity

The complicated nature of the fashion industry's logistics network is one of the main

obstacles to eliminating child labour in the industry. Although many companies have restrictions

for their suppliers, it is common practice for work to be assigned to other manufacturers,

frequently without the knowledge of the customer. Ovaa claims that the corporations in the US

and EU that buy their fabrics have no idea where they are made 24. Perhaps they are familiar with

their initial source, and perhaps there are even norms of behaviour in place; yet, as the chain

progresses down its lowest layers, it becomes increasingly impossible to trace the origin of the

cotton. The fact that child labour is really a symptom of deeper issues only adds to the difficulty

of addressing it25. When there is a lack of money, there will be youngsters who are eager to

labour for less, making them easy prey for exploitative employers. According to Lotte

Schuurman of the Fair Wear Foundation, if guardians do not go to school, they are more likely to

take low-paying jobs, which in turn forces their children to work when they should be in school,

preventing them from breaking the cycle of poverty that keeps them there.

21
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
22
Uzbek-German Forum for Human Rights. “Forced Labor in Uzbekistan’s Cotton Sector, 2016”.
23
Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations (SOMO). “Branded Childhood: How garment brands contribute to low
wages, long working hours, school dropout and child labour in Bangladesh, 2017.”
24
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
25
Ibid Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations (SOMO). “Branded Childhood: How garment brands contribute to
low wages, long working hours, school dropout and child labour in Bangladesh, 2017.”
Last Name8

Despite the widespread notion that child labour is no longer an issue in the fashion

industry and sweatshops, many outsiders disagree 26. Child labour is a major social issue

everywhere, including in the fast fashion sector. The fashion industry in numerous nations is

plagued by issues related to the use of child labour. Beadwork, T-shirt embroidery, accessory

creation, and many more are only some of the various fashion-related tasks that these folks

perform in the cotton plantations, ginnery, and high-street clothing business27. According to

studies, the low pay children get in apparel manufacturing (around a third of the salaries that

adults earn for identical or equivalent work) is a key contributor to the prevalence of child labour

in this sector. Consumers' insistence on low prices and little overhead contributes to this

problem, as does the drive of businesses to maximise profits. Child work has been linked to

economic practises that leave families without the means to provide for their children. In such a

situation, kids might have to work long hours to help out with the groceries.

Given that many nations are reluctant to disclose information regarding the number of

children in their populations who are deemed to be subjected to inappropriate labour

circumstances, it may be challenging to provide an exact estimate of the proportion of children

who are working for a livelihood28. However, projections suggest that almost 200 million

youngsters between the ages of 4 and 14 and another 140 million between the ages of 15 and 17

are engaged in hazardous financial activities throughout the globe29. About half of these kids are

forced to labour in potentially dangerous conditions. Several countries have invested much in the

creation of a wide range of programmes to combat the prevalence of child labour in the fast

26
Wilson, D. “Fashion Industry Forum. Economic Journal, 101, C138-C155, 1997.”
27
Ibid Wilson, D. “Fashion Industry Forum. Economic Journal, 101, C138-C155, 1997.”
28
ILO. “Child Labour in Cotton: A Briefing; International Law and Policy Institute (2015) Child Labour in the Indian
Cottonseed Sector, 2016.”
29
Bhukuth, A. “Defining child labour: a controversial debate. Development in Practice, 18, 385-394, 2008.”
Last Name9

fashion business30. Many third-world nations, for instance, have implemented programmes to get

kids out of factories and back into classrooms, all while spreading the word that child labour is

wrong and that kids deserve an enjoyable childhood, too31.

Famous Fast Fashion Brands Using Child Labour

BBC's investigation into UK clothing retailer Primark revealed some of the company's

most alarming behaviours. The Primark affiliates employed underage labour and paid illegal

immigrants minimal salaries to keep them in the UK, according to the investigation 32. Firestone

faced allegations of exploiting its employees in Liberia by forcing them to bring young people to

work if they did not meet output quotas or risk having their pay reduced in half 33. Because of this

information, the Firestone Company was targeted by protesters all around the globe 34. State law

forbids anyone below the age of 18 from being employed in such manufacturing plants. Still, in

2008, Iowa's Labour Commissioner David Neil asserted the Ministry of labour discovered that

farmland merchandise processing enterprises had hired approximately sixty minors, starting at 14

years old, for positions in the production plants.

Primark's cheap apparel is made in labour camps. A wave of customer boycotts has hit

Primark, but the company continues to grow. Primark has a chequered past when it comes to

allegations of child labour and other forms of modern slavery. This firm does not exercise

sufficient control over its supplier base to avert civil rights breaches, such as the exploitation of

child labour. They are not forthcoming enough about their efforts to make their factories safer for

workers. Because of their history of employing underage labour, Uniqlo is included on this

30
Ibid Nifong, C. “No Sweat Pact to Cut Garment Worker Abuse. New York, The Christian Science Monitor, 1997.”
31
Knoebel, E., “The Modern World. Orlando, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1988”.
32
Assoune, Alex. “13 Fashion Brands That Still Use Sweatshops in 2023.” Panaprium. Panaprium, March 15, 2020.
https://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/fashion-brands-that-still-use-sweatshops
33
Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
34
Ibid Bhukuth, A. “Defining child labour: a controversial debate. Development in Practice, 18, 385-394, 2008.”
Last Name10

shameful list. They currently produce their wares in emerging Asian nations by use of forced

labour35. The corporation relies on exploitative child labour in the developing economies of

Bangladesh, Indonesia, and China36. Uniqlo lacks concern in the slightest that the United Nations

has guidelines for businesses to avoid, confront, and redress civil rights abuses perpetrated in its

supply networks.

ASOS employs children to work in its factories in Turkey and uses assembly lines

reminiscent of those found in sweatshops. The audits that ASOS performs to combat forced

labour are not nearly thorough enough. ASOS does not provide any information on its primary

suppliers and has made minimal advancement in paying its workers a fair salary 37. Forever 21, a

Los Angeles-based fast-fashion shop, is embroiled in yet another controversy. Forever 21 has

received widespread backlash from consumers due to the company's exploitation of sweatshops.

One-third of Forever 21's apparel is produced domestically 38. However, they are presently being

criticised for running factories that resemble sweatshops, paying employees below minimum

wage, and not compensating employees for overtime. In Uzbekistan, youngsters work for

Forever 21 in cotton fields. When kids are forced to labour on farms instead of attending school,

their education suffers.

It is well known that GAP formerly employed children as factory workers. Manufacturers

in Bangladesh, Cambodia, India, Indonesia, and Sri Lanka are still using sweatshop conditions to

produce GAP brand goods. Although GAP is becoming more open, reports of brutal abuse

towards employees continue to surface. Since workers at GAP have no organisation privileges,

35
Ibid Assoune, Alex. “13 Fashion Brands That Still Use Sweatshops in 2023.” Panaprium. Panaprium, March 15, 2020.
https://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/fashion-brands-that-still-use-sweatshops
36
Ibid International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182)." (1999).
37
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
38
Ibid Assoune, Alex. “13 Fashion Brands That Still Use Sweatshops in 2023.” Panaprium. Panaprium, March 15, 2020.
https://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/fashion-brands-that-still-use-sweatshops
Last Name11

work over sixteen hours daily, and are paid less than half the hourly rate in India, they keep

fighting the company. Unfortunately, sexual and physical assault of young women continues to

occur at GAP workplaces. H&M continues to manufacture its goods under sweatshop conditions.

Despite the company's best efforts, H&M is still not able to provide its workers with a decent

wage. The company has also been involved in a number of controversies. Bangladeshi garment

production facility employees are subjected to abusive working conditions in order to produce

H&M products. And younger people in Myanmar still serve as their labour force.

Similarly, it has been discovered that Nike, a global American company that creates,

produces, and sells sneakers, garments, equipment, and peripherals globally, still tolerates child

labour, in violation of the employment law. Throughout decades, Nike has been condemned

repeatedly for using underage labour. They are the most successful active-wear company in the

world, but they got there by engaging in several immoral practises 39. Labour rights specialists do

not conduct random audits of many Nike manufacturing facilities. Nike does not value their

employees very well. Nike's continued promotion of sexism and mistreatment in the workplace

is really troubling. They do not feel accountable for the daily constitutional breaches that occur

in their workplaces.

Urban Outfitters and Zara are two more brands exposed as current or former users of

child labour. The facility where Urban Outfitters' clothes are made is run like a typical

sweatshop. In order to increase their profitability, they continue to pay their employees

low wages and provide unsafe workplace conditions40. There have been other historical cases of

controversy with Urban Outfitters and child labour. Urban Outfitters continues to engage in

39
Ibid Assoune, Alex. “13 Fashion Brands That Still Use Sweatshops in 2023.” Panaprium. Panaprium, March 15, 2020.
https://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/fashion-brands-that-still-use-sweatshops
40
Ibid Assoune, Alex. “13 Fashion Brands That Still Use Sweatshops in 2023.” Panaprium. Panaprium, March 15, 2020.
https://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/fashion-brands-that-still-use-sweatshops
Last Name12

wasteful practises and provide insufficient data to back up its claims on its positive economic

and ecological effect. Urban Outfitters cotton plantations and processing facilities have been

accused of allowing child labour, sexual exploitation, and physical violence 41. In the past, Zara

operated slavery-like plants in Istanbul, Turkey, where individuals were exploited and often not

compensated. There have been reports of contemporary servitude and child exploitation at Zara

plants in Brazil42. With increased openness and worker development programmes, Zara is

showing it is concerned about its suppliers. However, the company does not provide a decent

salary for workers in any of its supply chains.

Solutions to Child Labour in Fast Fashion

Introduction to the IPEC

The International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) remains at the

forefront of the fight to end child labour in every segment of the economy. IPEC's mission is to

end the worst kinds of child labour throughout the globe as soon as possible. IPEC has been

working towards this goal since its inception in 1992 43. It does this by engaging in public

education and mobilisation aimed at transforming public perceptions and promoting acceptance

and successful execution of the ILO child labour Protocols, as well as using country-based

initiatives that foster legislative change, establish institutional ability, and put into effect practical

steps that eliminate child labour44. Numerous thousands of kids have been pulled out of labour

and either reformed or banned from ever working again courtesy of these initiatives 45. In-depth

41
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
42
Ibid Assoune, Alex. “13 Fashion Brands That Still Use Sweatshops in 2023.” Panaprium. Panaprium, March 15, 2020.
https://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/fashion-brands-that-still-use-sweatshops
43
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
44
ILO. “International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) >What Is Child Labour > Action against Child
Labour.” International Labour Organization, 2020. https://www.ilo.org/ipec/facts/lang--en/index.htm
45
Ibid International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182)." (1999).
Last Name13

quantitative and qualitative research, regulation and legal reviews, programme assessment, and

tracking of juvenile labour have complemented this advocacy effort at all times, allowing for the

build-up of an extensive repository of statistical findings and approaches, topical experiments,

good practices, standards, and educational resources.

Child Labour Monitoring

Routine inspections of potential workplaces where underage girls and boys may be

employed are an effective measure for combating child labour. The approach of implementing

and effectively coordinating this surveillance of child labour is known as child labour monitoring

(CLM)46. The overarching goal is to guarantee that underage and legitimate young employees are

protected from mistreatment and unsafe working conditions. A referral mechanism that connects

former child workers with the necessary assistance facilitates active monitoring of child

employment on a local level47. In practice, CLM entails the creation of a synchronised multi-

sector inspection and reporting procedure that seeks to serve all children in a specific

geographical region in order to identify, refer, safeguard, and ward off kids from working 48. Its

primary functions include conducting personal inspections on kids, working regularly to discover

them and the potential hazards to which they are subjected, referring them to solutions,

confirming that they were successfully removed, and following up with them to ensure they have

adequate choices.

Industrial Labour Inspections

To combat the exploitation of children, IPEC strengthens the capabilities of labour

inspection organisations and other regulatory bodies to address issues, including child labour in
46
Ibid ILO. “International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) >What Is Child Labour > Action against
Child Labour.” International Labour Organization, 2020. https://www.ilo.org/ipec/facts/lang--en/index.htm
47
Venkateswarlu, D. “Stop Child Labour Coalition and India Committee of the Netherlands Cotton’s Forgotten Children,
2015.”
48
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
Last Name14

dangerous conditions and child exploitation tracking 49. The auditors of working conditions have

historically played an important role in the fight against child labour. The emergence of new

legal frameworks, like the ILO Convention 182 on Worst instances of child labour, has given

their job further scope and significance. In order to combat unsafe child labour, auditors can

provide details and advice to both companies and employees50. They can also utilise their

statutory enforcement authority to remove minors from potentially dangerous industries and

recommend them to the rightful authorities so that they can enrol for educational programmes or

get vocational education. Workers under the age of whatever is the legal working age in that

nation are also fully safeguarded from harm in the workplace 51. Enhancements to occupational

health and safety as a whole and the elimination of potentially dangerous occupations for

children are necessary to guarantee their safety.

Significance of CLM and Labour Inspection

Child Labour Monitoring (CLM) is a dynamic field that is intricately connected to the

implementation of domestic child labour laws. The primary objective of community-based

oversight is to facilitate the engagement and education of the public in the surveillance of child

work practises while establishing a connection between this surveillance endeavour and

municipal governments and official regulatory bodies, particularly labour inspections. This

linkage ensures that the information gathered on instances of child labour is utilised in a manner

that maximises its effectiveness. In order to effectively carry out their responsibilities, the

monitors must be endowed with a distinct mandate and the requisite power, despite the fact that a

49
Ibid ILO. “International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) >What Is Child Labour > Action against
Child Labour.” International Labour Organization, 2020. https://www.ilo.org/ipec/facts/lang--en/index.htm
50
ILO. “Baselines to Achieve SDG Target 8.7 2017 Global Estimates of Modern Slavery and Child Labour.” International
Labour Organization, March 15, 2017. https://www.ilo.org/global/topics/forced-labour/publications/WCMS_547398/lang--en/
index.htm
51
Ibid Venkateswarlu, D. “Stop Child Labour Coalition and India Committee of the Netherlands Cotton’s Forgotten Children,
2015.”
Last Name15

significant portion of their function entails altering perspectives rather than executing legal

measures. The concept of CLM entails the establishment of an integrated and comprehensive

system for monitoring and referring children across several sectors. The primary objective is to

ensure the inclusion of all children residing within a certain geographic location 52. The primary

endeavours of this organisation encompass the systematic and recurrent undertaking of direct

observations in order to detect instances of child labour and assess the associated hazards to

which such kids are subjected53. Additionally, the organisation facilitates the transfer of these

minors to appropriate services, verifies their successful removal from exploitative situations, and,

after that, monitors their progress to ensure their well-being.

Community-based juvenile labour surveillance councils are commonly comprised of

individuals who hold positions of authority within the community, such as neighbourhood

leaders, educational professionals, healthcare advocates, as well as delegates from households

directly affected by child labour54. In certain cases, young people who have been removed from

work may also be included in these teams55. Inspection visits are conducted at various

companies. Return trips are frequently undertaken in tandem with formal inspections by

workplace auditors. In order to offer guidance to companies and employees, implement social

and labour policies, and oversee and uphold labour rules and regulations, the establishment of

efficient national workplace inspection mechanisms is needed. Labour examination is a

governmental obligation that serves as a public service. It is most effectively structured as a

comprehensive system operating within the framework of a broader administrative framework.

52
Ibid Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June 21, 2017.
https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/
53
World Vision. “Forced and Child Labour in the Cotton Industry, 2012”.
54
Ibid Moulds, Josephine. “Child Labour in the Fashion Supply Chain Where, Why and What Can Be Done.” The Guardian
Labs - Sponsored by UNICEF, 2023. https://labs.theguardian.com/unicef-child-labour/
55
Ibid Assoune, Alex. “13 Fashion Brands That Still Use Sweatshops in 2023.” Panaprium. Panaprium, March 15, 2020.
https://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/fashion-brands-that-still-use-sweatshops
Last Name16

This approach aligns with the principles outlined in the ILO Conventions on workforce

evaluation, namely Convention No. 81 from 1947 and Convention No. 129 from 1969, which

specifically addresses workforce assessment in the agricultural industry.

Recognizing if a Brand is Using Child Labour

Unfortunately, and inadvertent to many, child labour is pervasive in the fast fashion

business. Traceability is difficult to achieve due to the complex nature of contemporary supply

chains. The rapid fashion model negatively impacts workplace conditions. Since this forces

businesses to look for cheaper and cheaper workers, it is no surprise that child labour is an issue

in the fast fashion industry56. The apparel and fabric business employs children throughout the

whole production process. Everything from picking cotton to making yarn to cutting, sewing,

and finishing garments57. Children enter the workforce to meet the need for cheap, low-

expertise labour in worldwide supply networks, which is fuelled by the low costs of the fast

fashion sector. When adult workers make too little, they are unable to provide for their families,

and children are forced to work 58. The likelihood that a particular firm employs children is

directly proportional to whether or not its workers are paid reasonable salaries.

Inadequate compliance with employment and education rules, as well as an inadequate

level of educational opportunity, also play a role 59. It is conceivable that a business with

operations there is taking advantage of low-wage kid labourers. The complex nature of the

suppliers, sub-suppliers, and producers involved in the fast fashion industry makes for a lengthy

distribution network. Responsible apparel companies can more easily keep tabs on their primary
56
Ibid ILO. “Baselines to Achieve SDG Target 8.7 2017 Global Estimates of Modern Slavery and Child Labour.” International
Labour Organization, March 15, 2017. https://www.ilo.org/global/topics/forced-labour/publications/WCMS_547398/lang--en/
index.htm
57
Bell, jenny. “Help End Child Labour: 23 Brands Committed to Child Labour Free Clothing.” Good Maker Tales, 2021.
https://goodmakertales.com/child-labour-free-clothing/#:~:text=Full%20Transparency%20and%20Traceability,right%20back
%20to%20material%20production
58
Ibid International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No. 182)." (1999).
59
Ibid Baland, J. & Robinson J. (2000) Is child labor inefficient? Journal of Political Economy,108, 663-679
Last Name17

vendors. But sometimes manufacturers do work for companies without their knowledge 60. Child

work is much more of a problem deeper in the supply chain, in textile factories and cotton

plantations. A Code of Ethics is essential for every open and fast-fashion business. It is expected

that this will protect each of the ILO's Four Fundamental Freedoms 61. This involves ending child

labour as well as contemporary forms of slavery and compelled labour. Firms that make suitable

clothes should have an open inspection strategy that covers the entire supply chain, and the

findings of such inspections should be made public. Companies and their suppliers can both

benefit from having their actions and claims independently verified by a third party 62. Companies

lacking a public code of conduct, publicly available inspections, and independent auditors or

oversight are more likely to be seen as exploiting the low wages of children living in poverty.

Conclusion

The global fast fashion business is a major offender in the cycle of child labour because it

takes advantage of the poverty-stricken youth it employs at every point in the production

process. The need for low-cost labour, the absence of monitoring and transparency in supply

chains, and the difficult socioeconomic situations faced by families in low-income countries all

contribute to the emergence of this complicated problem. Children are frequently denied an

education and fundamental rights, making them a vulnerable and exploitable workforce. There is

a clear need for more openness and accountability in the fast fashion sector after some well-

known businesses were accused of using child labour. There is an immediate need for

60
Ibid Moulds, Josephine. “Child Labour in the Fashion Supply Chain Where, Why and What Can Be Done.” The Guardian
Labs - Sponsored by UNICEF, 2023. https://labs.theguardian.com/unicef-child-labour/
61
Ibid ILO. “International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) >What Is Child Labour > Action against
Child Labour.” International Labour Organization, 2020. https://www.ilo.org/ipec/facts/lang--en/index.htm
62
Ibid Bell, jenny. “Help End Child Labour: 23 Brands Committed to Child Labour Free Clothing.” Good Maker Tales, 2021.
https://goodmakertales.com/child-labour-free-clothing/#:~:text=Full%20Transparency%20and%20Traceability,right%20back
%20to%20material%20production
Last Name18

comprehensive, effective measures to end child labour in the fast fashion industry as a result of

these disclosures.

The International Programme for the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) is only one of

several organisations that has made it its mission to end child labour via education, legislation,

and oversight. Key instruments for tracking and combating the exploitation of children in the

fashion industry include child labour monitoring, labour inspections, and community-based

surveillance committees. In addition, shoppers play a key role by buying from companies they

know using fair employment practises and promoting open communication. Companies'

adherence to International Labour Organisation norms and the elimination of child labour in

supply chains rely heavily on codes of conduct, public inspection techniques, and third-party

audits.
Last Name19

Bibliography

Assoune, Alex. “13 Fashion Brands That Still Use Sweatshops in 2023.” Panaprium. Panaprium,

March 15, 2020. https://www.panaprium.com/blogs/i/fashion-brands-that-still-use-

sweatshops

Baland, J. & Robinson J. (2000) Is child labor inefficient? Journal of Political Economy,108,

663-679.

Bell, jenny. “Help End Child Labour: 23 Brands Committed to Child Labour Free Clothing.”

Good Maker Tales, 2021.

https://goodmakertales.com/child-labour-free-clothing/#:~:text=Full%20Transparency

%20and%20Traceability,right%20back%20to%20material%20production

Bhukuth, A. “Defining child labour: a controversial debate. Development in Practice, 18, 385-

394, 2008.”

Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations (SOMO). “Branded Childhood: How

garment brands contribute to low wages, long working hours, school dropout and child

labour in Bangladesh, 2017.”

ILO. “Baselines to Achieve SDG Target 8.7 2017 Global Estimates of Modern Slavery and Child

Labour.” International Labour Organization, March 15, 2017.

https://www.ilo.org/global/topics/forced-labour/publications/WCMS_547398/lang--en/

index.htm

ILO. “Child Labour in Cotton: A Briefing; International Law and Policy Institute (2015) Child

Labour in the Indian Cottonseed Sector, 2016.”


Last Name20

ILO. “International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) >What Is Child

Labour > Action against Child Labour.” International Labour Organization, 2020.

https://www.ilo.org/ipec/facts/lang--en/index.htm

International Labour Organization. "C182–Worst Forms of Child Labour Convention, 1999 (No.

182)." (1999).

Knoebel, E., “The Modern World. Orlando, Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, 1988”.

Moulds, Josephine. “Child Labour in the Fashion Supply Chain Where, Why and What Can Be

Done.” The Guardian Labs - Sponsored by UNICEF, 2023.

https://labs.theguardian.com/unicef-child-labour/

Nifong, C. “No Sweat Pact to Cut Garment Worker Abuse. New York, The Christian Science

Monitor, 1997.”

Ravallion, M & Wodon, Q., “Does child labour displace schooling? Evidence on behavioural

responses to an enrollment subsidy. Economic Journal, 110, C158-C175, 2000”.

Reddy, Krishna. “Top 28 Companies That Use Child Labor Still! - Wisestep.” Wisestep, June

21, 2017. https://content.wisestep.com/companies-use-child-labor/

Somani, Vishakha. “5 Common Problems Faced by the Fashion Industry.” World Fashion

Exchange (WFX.com), March 25, 2022. https://www.worldfashionexchange.com/blog/5-

common-problems-faced-by-the-fashion-industry-with-solutions/

Uzbek-German Forum for Human Rights. “Forced Labor in Uzbekistan’s Cotton Sector, 2016”.

Venkateswarlu, D. “Stop Child Labour Coalition and India Committee of the Netherlands

Cotton’s Forgotten Children, 2015.”

Wilson, D. “Fashion Industry Forum. Economic Journal, 101, C138-C155, 1997.”

World Vision. “Forced and Child Labour in the Cotton Industry, 2012”.

You might also like