Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Qualitative Research 11
Qualitative Research 11
Presented By:
Binghot, Harold Joey E.
Asilo, Ela Mae C.
Mascardo, Jessebel E.
Mesias, Lourd Vincent H.
Suya, Leame
Presented to:
Ms. Brenda R. Cantil
Table of Contents
TITLE PAGE.......................................................................................................................................................................1
Chapter 1.......................................................................................................................................................................3
Problem......................................................................................................................................................................3
Introduction:..........................................................................................................................................................3
Conceptual framework.........................................................................................................................................5
Theoretical framework.........................................................................................................................................6
Statement of the Problem:....................................................................................................................................7
Significance of the Study.......................................................................................................................................7
Scope and limitation of the Study.........................................................................................................................7
Definition of Terms................................................................................................................................................8
Chapter 2.......................................................................................................................................................................9
Methodology..............................................................................................................................................................9
Research Design:...................................................................................................................................................9
Research Environment:........................................................................................................................................9
Research Informants:..........................................................................................................................................10
Sampling Design:.................................................................................................................................................10
Research Instrument:..........................................................................................................................................11
Data Gathering Procedures:...............................................................................................................................11
Ethical Considerations:.......................................................................................................................................12
Chapter 3..................................................................................................................................................................... 12
Presentation, Analysis, and Interpretation of Data...............................................................................................12
Chapter 4..................................................................................................................................................................... 17
Summary of Findings, Conclusions, and Recommendations...............................................................................17
Summary of findings...........................................................................................................................................17
Conclusion:..........................................................................................................................................................17
Recommendations:..............................................................................................................................................18
Chapter 1
Problem
Introduction:
Improper waste management poses many hazards that vary in scope and severity.
In recent years, the global community has recognized the need for sustainable waste
segregation emerges as a critical strategy for reducing pollution. The urgency of addressing
waste management issues is highlighted by the escalating global waste crisis, characterized
by rapid urbanization and population growth. Waste and recycling management plans should
be developed for any construction project prior to the start of work in order to sustain
Waste segregation refers to the practice of separating wet waste from dry waste. It is a
process of dividing, identifying, classifying, and sorting garbage and waste products to
important for both the environment and human health (Graham, H. 2022). The practice of
Japan is a model for waste management due its integrated and effective approach. In
Japan in the 1950s and 1960s, high economic growth and rapid urbanization led to an
increase in waste volumes and worsening of the sanitation environment due to inappropriate
management of waste. In response, the government revised and made various laws for the
technologies were completed. Still there were difficulties in securing disposal facilities and
handling sposal volumes. To improve the situation, recycling laws were created during the
1990s and implemented for promotion of recovery of valuable materials which had been
incinerated previously i.e. Containers and Packaging Recycling Law, 1995;Home Appliance
Recycling Law. (Singh et al., 2015). Similarly, the country of Brazil is also one of the
country’s leading the way in recycling and waste management. Municipal solid waste
management in São Leopoldo, Brazil is held by the municipality, through the Municipal
Public Cleaning Office (SELIMP), created in August 2010. SELIMP [14] has 51 employees
operating directly on supporting of weeding, mowing, sweeping, and removal of debris. The
other operational activities relating to solid waste are outsourced, under contract with a
private company supervised by the municipal administration. (Ghesla et al., 2018). Also, the
system of collection and separation of municipal waste in Maienfeld is modern and eco-
friendly. It is confirmed by the high rates of collection of municipal waste (more than
50,00% in each scenario), and by waste sorting into four containers. In view of all that has
Philippines is among the top waste generators in Southeast Asia, and one of the top
contributors to plastic waste pollution in the seas. This is a result of various factors
including low recycling rates, issues in collection, and inconsistency in plastic packaging
segregation in many local government units (LGU). A continuous rise in the amount of
waste is expected in the succeeding years as the population also increases There is existing
law and framework on addressing waste problems but will only be possible if implemented
properly and strictly. Not only in the hands of the government will it be addressed but also
with the help of the citizens through active participation and whole hearted application of
segregation at the local wet market and fishing port is evident. This research aims to
examine the waste segregation practices of the local wet market vendors and nearby
residents of the fishing port. By conducting this study, we will be able to discover the waste
segregation strategies and what challenges the wet market vendors and nearby residents face
The researchers decided to study this topic as they would like to help in developing
cleaning programs by providing information as they have seen the need for proper waste
Conceptual framework
Level of
knowledge about
waste segregation
Independent variable:
Community engagement
and participation in waste
Waste management
segregation
practices
This study revolves around the waste segregation practices of the wet market vendors
and nearby fishing port residents. Waste segregation practices can be enhanced by developing
cleaning programs developed by the local officials of the municipality. The development of
the action programs can be affected by the community engagement and participation while
the effectiveness of it can be affected by the level of knowledge about waste segregation by
Theoretical framework
Resource Conservation Theory posits that segregating waste at the source allows for the
recovery and recycling of valuable resources embedded in waste streams. By separating materials
such as paper, plastic, glass, and metal, these resources can be diverted from landfills and
reintroduced into the production cycle, reducing the demand for virgin materials and conserving
natural resources.
Environmental justice theory: Waste segregation can also be viewed through the lens of
environmental justice, which emphasizes the fair distribution of environmental benefits and burdens
across society. In many cases, marginalized communities and low-income neighborhoods bear a
disproportionate burden of waste disposal facilities and pollution. By implementing effective waste
segregation practices, communities can mitigate the adverse environmental and health impacts
associated with improper waste management, promoting equity and social responsibility.
Lastly, Behavioral Change Theory states that waste segregation relies on modifying
individual and collective behavior to encourage responsible waste management practices. Behavioral
change theories emphasize the role of education, incentives, social norms, and feedback mechanisms
in influencing people’s attitudes and actions towards waste segregation, communities can foster a
This study will examine the segregation practices of the Market vendors and Nearby
2. What are the main challenges faced by wet market vendors and nearby
3. Based on the results of the study what action program can be designed?
Wet Market Vendors. The results of this study can help the vendors enhance their
segregation strategy, serve clean and safe foods for the people of the Municipality of
Margosatubig.
Margosanon: This study can help nearby residents of the fishing port in enhancing
LGU Officials: This research will guide the LGU officials of the Municipality of
Margosatubig in understanding the needs of the vendors and nearby residents of Wet
Market and Fishing Port Area in maintaining the cleanliness of the said place.
Future Researchers: This study will guide future researchers in their research
Margosatubig, Zamboanga Del Sur. The informants of this study are the wet market vendors
and nearby fishing port residents who answered the interview questions provided by the
researchers. We selected only a few participants who can serve as the representatives of the
population in providing us with the information needed as surveying all the wet market
Definition of Terms
miscommunication by providing clarity and ensuring that everyone interprets the terms in
Landfills: a system of trash and garbage disposal in which the waste is buried between
Nearby residents: Refers to the residents residing near the municipality’s fishing port.
Waste. Refers to a material that is not wanted; the unusable remains or byproducts of
something.
Waste generators: In this study, this term refers to refers to a place whose act or
Waste segregation: Refers to the sorting and separation of waste types to facilitate
Wet market Vendors: Refers to the vendors of the municipality’s local Agora Wet
Market.
Chapter 2
Methodology
introduction
Research Design:
The case study approach developed by (Yin 2003) is used in this qualitative study, enabling
the researcher to examine and analyze the data. He stated that case study contains data from
six potential sources: documents, archival records, first-hand observations and interviews,
and related things. In addition, as the study (Zainal, 2007) notes, the case study approach is
used to understand and research a variety of complex circumstances. Because of this, this
Research Environment
The research will be carried out within the Agora Public Market situated in Poblacion
Margosatubig, Zamboanga Del Sur, with a specific focus on the wet section, adjacent
residents, and vendors operating within the wet market area. Serving as the sole public
cleanliness within the market premises, attributed to the collective efforts of vendors and
residents who have begun actively maintaining the cleanliness of their surroundings. This
includes adopting responsible waste disposal practices, thereby mitigating the issue of
This study’s informants are the selected group of wet market vendors and nearby fishing
port residents from Poblacion Margosatubig, Zamboanga Del sur using the snowball
sampling.
Sampling Design:
This study uses the snowball sampling process. Snowball sampling, also known as chain-
participants help recruit future subjects for a study. Snowball sampling is often used
sampling procedure may be defined as snowball sampling when the researcher accesses
informants through contact information that is provided by other informants. This process is,
by necessity, repetitive: informants refer the researcher to other informants, who are
contacted by the researcher and then refer her or him to yet other informants, and so on.
(Noy, 2008)
Research Instrument:
The research instruments are the tools that the researcher uses to collect data. There are
different types of instruments based on the structure or format, purpose, nature, and
availability. (M Sathiyaseelan · 2015). The primary instruments of this study are the researchers
themselves with the guide questionnaires. A questionnaire is a research tool for conducting
from their point of view. The questionnaires need to be open-ended to make the participants
To conduct the study, the researchers will send a letter to the principal of the school
requesting permission to carry out the study. To administer the study, the researchers will
approach the adviser who work with Grade 11 Senior High School students in the target
school who specialize in STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics). After
receiving permission from the principal. The researchers will send a letter to the Barangay
Captain for approval to conduct a survey to Public Wet Market Vendors in order to
administer the study. The researcher distributes a questionnaire survey to the target
responder. However, before administering the test, the researchers will explain the goal of
the study to the respondents and the manner of answering the questionnaire.
Ethical Considerations:
In this study, researchers followed a few ethical guidelines and best practices. The
researchers acknowledged the participants' full and willing engagement. The latter, however,
is free to revoke their consent at any time and no longer participate in the study. Participant
written informed consent was obtained. In accordance with the Data Privacy Act of 2012,
the researchers took into account the participants' confidentiality and privacy. Aside from
that, the interview guide questionnaire did not contain any derogatory, offensive, or other
inappropriate language.
Chapter 3
Presentation, Analysis, and Interpretation of Data
This chapter reviews the results and analysis of the qualitative data on the waste
segregation strategies practiced by wet market vendors and nearby fishing port residents.
The researchers used thematic analysis in interpreting the data gathered by the study.
Waste segregation is the process of separating your waste into different types. Waste
management is a subject which should be a censorious issue for every citizen of the country.
It is not just up to the municipal authority to take care of the waste generated. (Anshuman,
P., & Pankaj, R. 2019). Based on the data gathered, there is 1 emerging theme which is:
Waste segregation is vital for efficient waste management, involving the separation
“Syempre nakay lain lain nga mga sako para sa mga mabulok ug dili mabulok
butngan nimo” [Of course, there are different bags for biodegradable and non-biodegradable
bago pa siya malata.” [We will make a garbage can to be segregated and throw something
“Naa lang mi cellophane, kana lain pareha ana oh lain mig cellophane, dayon wala
man mi malata diri kay puro man gyud ni cellophane amoa sa karnehan.” [We only have
biodegradable waste here because it’s all cellophane from the meat section.] P17
“Ilahi ang butanganan [sako] kada isa ka sako para sa malata, dili malata.”
[separate the garbage bags, each bag for biodegradable and nonbiodegradable]P12
“Ibutang jud sa sako I lahi lahi sya nga sako.” [We put them in separate bags.] P11
to country. (Freedman, B., Dorsey, W., Frazier, A., Kambhampati, M., Galiotos, J., &
Mukherjee, S. 2024). Based on the narratives, the wet market vendors and nearby fishing
separating the waste into separate garbage bags for biodegradable and non-biodegradable
materials.
challenges faced by wet market vendors and nearby residents in implementing effective
Waste segregation is the process of separating your waste into different types. Based
on the data gathered, there are 2 emerging theme which is: lack of cooperation from the
As the world’s population continues to expand over the years, irresponsible waste
disposal among residents in urban or rural communities has become one of the most serious
social issues that has affected not only public health but also the environment to a great
extent (Brennan, 1999; Edjabou et al., 2016; Han et al., 2016; Najam et al., 2015). This
Based on the narratives provided, one of the challenges wet market vendors and
nearby fishing port residence face is the hard-headedness of other residents/vendors towards
proper waste segregation. This is also true to the other countries such as India. According to
(Bhawal Mukherji et al., 2016), the primary problem regarding waste management in Delhi
is a lack of segregation at the source. This is inevitable, as most residents do not know the
appropriate medication disposal is largely positive. However, despite this favorable attitude,
the actual practice of the public remains unsatisfactory due to the limited understanding of
Unsegregated municipal solid waste has become a challenging issue for developing
countries. Challenges in this process vary across regions, urban-rural dynamics, and
constraints. (Shukla et al., 2021,). This theme is supported by the following narratives.
“Diha sauna pa jud nga wala bitaw gi segregate ang mga basura daghan jud kay
makuan diri sa mercado nga baho siya ang palibot maka langhap jud ka nga baho nga
sama anang isda kinahanglan jud to nimo siya i segregate, ang kuan nga baho para dili
bitaw makuan sa tawo, kay mao man to siyay usa sa malanghap ug sakit nimo.” [Before, the
garbage wasn’t really segregated, there were a lot piled up around the market, emitting
strong doors. You could smell it, like rotten fish. You really had to segregate it, especially
the fish waste, to control the smell and prevent people from getting sick, because that’s one
“Hago baya I bulag bulag pa ang malata sa dili malata pareha anang plastic.” [its
“. Ang ubang basura kay ipang ipon, dili ma segregate dayon dili kargahon sa
basurahan” [Waste are mixed together, and if not segregated then the garbage truck won’t
“. Ang kalisod syempre ang kanang mga nasagol na ang mga mabulok sa dili
mabulok ganon then imo pang kamuton syempre, kailangan magsuot ug gloves or
cellophane nalang para maka iwas pud sa sakit.” [The difficulty, of course is that those that
are mixed with the ones that are stained with those that are not stained, then you have to
clean them of course you have to wear gloves or cellophane to avoid getting sick] P20
“. Kanang kuan gang oy,kanang mga cellophane nga Ilahi lahi labi nang mga inana
diara, maglisod nya dili nimo ibulag kay dili puniton sa mga basurero” [The problem is
those cellophanes and other stuff, it’s difficult because if its not segregated then the garbage
Based on the narratives, the challenges that wet market vendors and nearby fishing
port residents find difficult when segregating waste are when biodegradable and non-
biodegradable waste combine. They find it difficult to segregate the waste because the
biodegradable waste generates a strong odor over time. They also stated that if their waste is
not properly segregated, the garbage collectors will not collect their garbage bag.
Chapter 4
Summary of Findings, Conclusions, and Recommendations
In this chapter, a brief summary of the research paper will be presented. The
recommendations that will serve as guidelines to improve the cleanliness of the Agora Wet
Summary of findings
This chapter presents the summary of findings, conclusions, and recommendations offered.
1. Waste segregation strategies practiced by wet market vendors and nearby fishing port
residents.
Based on the narratives, it is revealed that the wet market vendors and nearby fishing
port segregate their waste by separating the biodegradable waste and non-biodegradable
The study reveals that wet market vendors and nearby fishing port residents face 2
challenges in segregating their waste. One of said challenges is the hard-headedness of the
people, some residents/vendors does not follow the proper waste segregation resulting with
the garbage collectors not collecting the garbage bags that were not segregated. Another
biodegradable waste mix together, they find it hard to segregate because of the strong odor
Conclusion:
Based on the findings of this research, the researchers found out that wet market
vendors and nearby fishing port residents are facing challenges every day on how to segregate
hardheaded people violating the rules of the wet market and fishing port in properly
2. Researchers found out that not all the time, the wet market vendors and nearby residents
segregate their waste properly. They just put it in one garbage bag and let the garbage
3. Based on their answers, researchers can conclude that not all of the vendors and residents
of the wet market and fishing port are knowledgeable about properly segregating waste.
Even though the Municipality of Margosatubig has a "SILHIG" program with the goal of
Recommendations:
Conduct a gathering for both nearby residents and wet market vendors and address the
problem about the management of their waste, discuss about what will be the
Provide Proper Infrastructure, Ensure that there are enough bins and containers
hazardous materials, etc. Clearly label these bins with instructions to avoid confusion.
References:
1. Shukla, P., Sharma, P. K., Pandey, S., & Chintala, V. (2021). Unsegregated municipal solid waste in
India - Current scenario, challenges and way forward. Nature Environment and Pollution
Technology, 20(2). https://doi.org/10.46488/nept.2021.v20i02.048
2. Anshuman, P., & Pankaj, R. (2019). Status and challenges of waste segregation in
residential communities. International Journal of Human Capital in Urban
Management, 4(4), 303-310. DOI: 10.22034/IJHCUM.2019.04.06
3. Bhawal Mukherji, S., Sekiyama, M., Mino, T., & Chaturvedi, B. (2016). Resident knowledge and
willingness to engage in waste management in Delhi, India. Sustainability, 8(10),
1065. https://doi.org/10.3390/su8101065
4. Freedman, B., Dorsey, W., Frazier, A., Kambhampati, M., Galiotos, J., & Mukherjee, S. (2024). ~
Biodegradable and Non-biodegradable Waste. Environmental Science.
5. Demirbas, A. (2011). Waste management, waste resource facilities and waste conversion processes. Energy
Conversion and Management, 52(2), 1280-1287. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enconman.2010.09.025
6. Graham, H. (2022). Waste Management in Metro Manila Food Markets: Rapid assessments in Quezon City
and Pasay City.
7. Singh, R., Yabar, H., Nozaki, N., & Rakwal, R. (2015). Analyzing waste problems in developing countries:
Lessons for Kathmandu, Nepal through analysis of the waste system in Tsukuba city, Japan. Journal of
Scientific Research and Reports, 8(6), 1-13. https://doi.org/10.9734/jsrr/2015/20346
8. Coracero, E. E., Gallego, R. J., Frago, K. J., & Gonzales, R. J. (2021). A long-standing problem: A review on the
solid waste management in the Philippines. Indonesian Journal of Social and Environmental Issues
(IJSEI), 2(3), 213-220. https://doi.org/10.47540/ijsei.v2i3.144
9. Bardoel, E. A., & Drago, R. (2021). Acceptance and strategic resilience: An application of conservation of
resources theory. Group & Organization Management, 46(4), 657-
691. https://doi.org/10.1177/10596011211022488
10. Faber, D., Levy, B., & Schlegel, C. (2021). Not all people are polluted equally in capitalist society: An eco-
socialist commentary on liberal environmental justice theory. Capitalism Nature Socialism, 32(4), 1-
16. https://doi.org/10.1080/10455752.2021.2009640
11. Hu, J., Tang, K., Qian, X., Sun, F., & Zhou, W. (2021). Behavioral change in waste separation at source in an
international community: An application of the theory of planned behavior. Waste Management, 135, 397-
408. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wasman.2021.09.028
12. Hiew, S. Y., & Low, B. Y. (2024). The knowledge, attitude, and practice of the public regarding household
pharmaceutical waste disposal: A systematic review (2013–2023). International Journal of Pharmacy
Practice, 32(2), 120-132. https://doi.org/10.1093/ijpp/riae001
13. Sivaranjani S, Priyanka Sherllyn S, Deepaharshini G R, & Eunice J. (2024). Green symphony: A brief review of
waste segregation techniques. International Research Journal on Advanced Engineering Hub (IRJAEH), 2(03),
381-386. https://doi.org/10.47392/irjaeh.2024.0056
14. Bogoro Audu Gani, V. I., & Bwala, H. B. (2014, July). KNOWLEDGE, ATITTUDE AND PRACTICE OF SOLID
WASTE SEGREGATION IN BAUCHI METROPOLIS, NIGERIA. In Proceedings of the Multi-disciplinary
Academic Conference on Sustainable Development (Vol. 2, No. 3).
15. Noy, C. (2008). Sampling knowledge: The hermeneutics of snowball sampling in qualitative
research. International Journal of Social Research Methodology, 11(4), 327-
344. https://doi.org/10.1080/13645570701401305
Republic of the Philippines
Department of Education
Region IX, Zamboanga Peninsula
Division of Zamboanga del Sur
TORIBIO MINOR NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Gabay, Margosatubig Zamboanga del Sur
The undersigned students are asking for your permission to participate in a survey that
will be administered herein. The purpose of this study is to determine the waste segregation
strategy of the Wet Market vendors and nearby Fishing Port residents.
Results obtain herein can be beneficial for the municipality as it can help in
developing waste segregation programs that can help in maintaining the cleanliness of the
community. Your participation in the survey is completely voluntary. There will be no cost
or risk to you as a respondent.
During the course if this study, this will be conducted by Harold Joey E. Binghot,
Jessebel C. Mascardo, Ela Mae C. Asilo, Lourd Vincent H. Mesias, and Leame Suya who
are students-researchers currently enrolled in Science, Technology, Engineering, and
Mathematics {STEM} at Toribio Minor National High School, Gabay, Poblacion,
Margosatubig, Zamboanga del Sur.
Please check the box below if you want/do not want to participate in the study.
I have read this consent form and I understand what is being requested of me as a participant
in this study.
1. Confidentiality: I understand that the information I provided in this study may be utilized
for research purposes. I also understand that the personal information I gave may be
coded of which in unavoidable circumstances may eventually reveal my personal identity.
2. Voluntary Participation: I have read this consent form and I understand what is being
requested of me as a participant in this study. I freely consent to participate. I understand
the nature and purpose of there will be no penalty/ consequences of any kind that will be
charged against me.
3. Termination of Participation: My participation in this study may also be terminated if I
do not conform to the etiquette of this study and if in any part my involvement may lead
to unjustified risks.
4. Consent to Participation: I have read this consent form and I understand what is being
requested of me as a participant in this study. I freely consent to participate.
Republic of the Philippines
DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION
Region IX, Zamboanga Peninsula
Division of Zamboanga del Sur
TORIBIO MINOR NATIONAL HIGH SCHOOL
Gabay, Margosatubig Zamboanga del Sur
With utmost respect, the STEM 11 students of this Toribio Minor National Highschool would like to conduct
a study regarding the Waste Segregation Strategies of the Municipality’s local wemarket and fishing port.
Proper waste segregation and disposal are critical for maintaining the environment and public health. As
concerned members of our municipality, we believe that this initiative will greatly benefit our community in
maintaining a clean environment. Hoping to gain support for this educational task. Thank you very much
and God bless.
Noted by:
BRENDA R. CANTIL
Teacher III
Approved by:
Appendix C. Interview Guide Questions
Prefaratory Statement.
I would like to express my sincere gratitude for your participation in this study. I
would like to inform you that the primary purpose of this research is to gather valuable
information about the waste segregation management of the wet market vendors of the
Agora Public Market and nearby residents of the Fishing Port. You have nothing to worry
about because there is no wrong answer here. You may withdraw your participation in this
research if you have any doubts about it or should you feel your privacy is invaded.
This interview may take 20-30 minutes. You can be assured that all the information
you will share will remain confidential.
Now, would you allow me to open the “audio recorder” while we talk?
What are the What segregation How will you describe Does improper waste
main objectives of strategies do Wet the cleanliness of your segregation affect the
waste Market Vendors and surroundings? quality of the products?
segregation? nearby residents
utilize? How did you cope up How well informed are you
Why is waste with the challenges? about the importance of
segregation What are the waste segregation?
important for the challenges faced by Can you describe the
environment? Wet Market Vendors current waste What types of waste do
and nearby segregation practices you find difficult to manage
How do you think residents in among the wet market and dispose of?
waste segregation implementing vendors and nearby
impacts the effective waste residents?
environment and segregation
community health practices?
in Margosatubig?
Based on the study
results, what action
program can be
designed?
CATEGORY 12-15 points 8-11 points 4-7 points 0-3 points
Introduction/Topic Exceptional introduction Proficient introduction Basic introduction that Weak or no
that grabs interest of that is interesting and states topic but lacks introduction of
reader and states topic. states topic. interest. Thesis/topic is topic.
Thesis/topic is Thesis/topic is clear somewhat clear and Paper’s purpose is
exceptionally clear, and arguable arguable. unclear. Thesis/topic
well-developed, and a statement of position. is weak or missing.
definitive statement.
Statement of the Problem
5 4 3 2
Identification The problem is clearly The problem is clearly The problem is clearly The problem is
and and objectively and objectively and objectively identified and
Definition of identified with concise identified with identified and defined; defined in a manner
Problem language and defined concise language and some detail may be that is sometimes/
with consistent precision defined with some imprecise (general) or somewhat unclear
of detail. precision of detail. unelaborated. and/or may manifest
some subjectivity
Level of Who, what, when, Who, what, when, Who, what, when, Some answers to
Detail where, and how are where, and how are where, and how are who, what, when,
specifically addressed in addressed adequately. addressed but answers where, and/or how
substantial detail may be unclear are missing or are
inadequate.
Limits on The problem statement The problem The problem statement The problem
Solutions is worded to allow an statement is worded to is worded to allow a statement is worded
unlimited number of allow several possible few possible solutions. to allow only a
possible solutions solutions couple of possible
solutions.
Methodology Identifies appropriate Identifies appropriate Identifies appropriate The methodologies
methodologies and methodologies and methodologies and described are either
Sample research techniques research techniques research techniques not suited or poorly
(e.g., justifies the but some details are but many details are suited to test
Procedures sample, procedures, and missing or vague missing or vague. The hypotheses. The
Measures measures). Data analytic methodology is largely methodology is
incomplete. under-developed
and/or is not
feasible
9-10 7-8 5-6 4-3
Maintains The proposal is well The proposal has an The proposal is The document lacks
purpose/focus organized and has a tight organizational somewhat focused or focus or contains
and cohesive focus that structure and the focus has minor drifts in the major drifts in focus
is integrated throughout is clear throughout. focus.
the document
Supporting evidence Provides clearly Provides adequate Provides inappropriate Provides little or no
appropriate evidence to evidence to support or insufficient evidence to support
support position position evidence to support position
position
References and Citations
References and Properly and explicitly Properly cited. May The manuscript has The manuscript
citations cited. Reference list have a few instances several instances of lacks proper
matches citations in which proper improper use of citations or includes
citations are missing. citations. Contains no citations.
several statements
without appropriately
citing.
Grammar, clarity, The manuscript is well The manuscript The manuscript The manuscript is
and organization written and ideas are effectively communicates ideas poorly written and
well developed and communicates ideas. adequately. The confusing. Ideas are
explained. Sentences and The writing is manuscript contains not communicated
paragraphs are grammatically correct, some grammatical effectively.
grammatically correct. but some sections lack errors. Many sections
Uses subheadings clarity. lack clarity.
appropriately