Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 7

Journal of Social Issues & Humanities, Volume 2, Issue 2, February 2014

ISSN 2345-2633

Survey of Farmanfarmaian's Both Historicist and


Modernist Attitudes on the Spatial Setting and
Visual Body of Carpet Museum
Koorosh Attarian, Kourosh Momeni Dehaghi, Ebrahim Heydari, Maral Rahmani

Abstract— Abdulaziz Farmanfarmaian historicist perspectives on spatial and physical structure of Carpet Museum have had various
effects. These effects coincided with modern architecture's beginning pioneered architects of the second generation’s acquaintance,
including Abdul Aziz Farmanfarmaian, with fundamental principles of this architectural style. The value of Iran's carpet craft and its high
position in the world, made a group of experts to offer the suggestion of establishing Carpet Museum of Iran to grant authorities. Tehran
Carpet Museum was started to construct in the northwest side of Laleh Park in 1961, on a land with area of 12,000 square meters, and
after a 15-year delay in construction, was opened in 1977. Abdul Aziz Farmanfarmaian, architect of this magnificent architectural
monument, was one of the second generation leading architects. These groups of architects influenced of west culture civilization, Iranian
historic heritage (with highlighted role of pre-Islam architecture) Data used in this study was obtained through librarical and field research.
Data analysis demonstrated that the architect of carpet museum, used historical perspective for designing the exterior framework of the
building, specifically in façade moldings and ornamentations but this idea is not included in the museum spatial layout. However it is
noticeable that the architect had given his modern attitude to this monumental museum objectively, which is the result of long history of
museums' function in west. The main purpose of this paper is to recognition the architectural characteristics of carpet museum and the
effect of architect's attitude on it.

Index Terms— Farmanfarmaian, Carpet Museum, Carpet Loom Historicity Introversion, Light, Modernist, Second Generation Pioneering
Architects.

——————————  ——————————

1 INTRODUCTION

C ARPET is one of the most dynamic discursive systems of


Iranian Art (Shaeiri, 69:1388). Iranian carpets have an im-
portant part in luxuries of royal life in history and for this
nology
These three were the most important reasons, which led au-
thorities to agree with establishment of Carpet museum. In
purpose, this craft attracted foreigner visitors and tourists in sixties Abdul Aziz Farmanfarmaian assigned to be the head of
centuries. From fifteenth AD centuries onwards, Iranian car- carpet museum building project. He was one of the French
pet craft adored and praised by western countries. Moreover, school of Bozar graduates, who started teaching at the College
Persian rugs were the most spectacular present that passen- of Fine Arts in Tehran University in the fifties. Farman-
gers could easily bring along. These handicrafts’ beauty and farmaiyan Office besides architectural design also worked in
glory as a presents from Iran, were revealed the insignificancy the urban design and planning fields. For instance, it can be
of western carpets (Pope, 2010: 8). mentioned Non-industrial consortium of Oil works, including
Due to The importance of Iranian carpets and its significant urban planning, building schools, building houses and build-
position in the world, which have mentioned above, a group ing offices in oil-rich regions in the years of 1967 – 1975 and
of experts and researchers of carpet in the early seventies pro- also urban planning and housing of Sarcheshmeh Copper
posed the establishment of Carpet Museum of Iran to authori- Company of Kerman, Karaj Khaneh Corporation, Isfahan
ties. The main primary reasons for the establishment of this Khane Corporation and Khane Corporation in East of Tehran
building can be mentioned as follows: City. But his most known urban project is Masterplan of Teh-
• the carpet factories establishment and commissioning and ran City with Victor Graven cooperation. Among his other
investors' profits architectural works, it can be point out the design of Tehran
• Eliminate cultural-artistic aspects of this industry Azadi Stadium, National Iranian Oil Company building, Vet-
• Adopting wrong policies towards the advancement of tech- erinary Medicine university, Mother Palace in Saadabad Pal-
ace Complex, part of Niavaran palace, office building of Radio
————————————————
and Television, Iran's pavilion in Montreal exhibition in 1976,
 Ph.D. Student of Architecture, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran.
Email Adderss: Attariank@gmail.com (Corresponding Author) and Arj company and nuclear reactor of Tehran University.
 Assistant Professor of Architecture and Urban Planning, Faculty of Carpet museum is one of his design projects, which is the
JondiShapur University of Technology, Dezful, Iran.Email Adderss: main subject of this study. The museum is located in North-
k_momeni@jsu.ac.ir
 Architecture Graduate Student of Architecture, JondiShapur University of west side of Tehran's Laleh Park on a land with the area of
Technology, Dezful, and Iran.Email Adderss: 12,000 square meters. The Architecture of this museum is a
Ebrahim.heidari.pgu@gmail.com Email Address combination of traditional and modern architecture. Carpet
 Undergraduate Degree of Architecture Technology, Azad Islamic Universi-
ty of Iran, Sepidan Branch, Sepidan, Iran. Email Address: Maralrahma-
museum complex of Iran, contains the most exquisite collec-
ni756@gmail.com tions of Iranian carpet from the fifteenth century AD till the
contemporary era.
209
Journal of Social Issues & Humanities, Volume 2, Issue 2, February 2014
ISSN 2345-2633

In this study, at first procedure of the museum architecture • Iranian heritage (with highlighted role of pre-Islam architec-
and dominant architectural concepts and ideologies of fifties ture).
been taken into consideration. Then architect's attitude regard- • The rise of architects from ventricle of these two.
ing the context of the project and its relationship with carpet In addition to addressing these group of contemporary archi-
museum has been studied. Therefore the main objective of this tects, it should also be noted that sixties and seventies ' Irani-
study is to clarify the effect of Farmanfarmaiyan Historicist an Intellectuals’ concerns, were kind of a tendency towards
and modernist views on the structural, functional and physical cultural ecologic. Aligned with these scholars, architects were
form of the museum. also searching for "kinsman Architecture ». What in the name
of "kinsman architecture" formed in this period, was nothing
less than modern architecture with ecological tendency. This
2 ARCHITECTURE AND URBANISM IN PAHLAVI II ERA
point must also be considered, that the second generation pio-
"From the late Qajar and early Pahlavi period, great political, neering architects' tendency towards historicity and ecology,
social and cultural changes had occurred in Iran. Constructing was not happened by, postmodern scholars' Theoretical In-
wide streets in the heart of the historical context, establishing structions such as Robert Venturi and Charlrz junks, But took
major governmental buildings and the emergence of a kind of place through implemented projects and works by architects
undervalued common architecture are characteristics of this such as Louis Kahn's , Alvar Aalto, James Sterling and Hassan
period. Although At the same time some buildings with an- Fathy's discussions mentioned in architecture book "Architec-
cients traditional appearance buildings were erected, But it ture for the poor" and his most important work in Qurna in
should be noted that this matter was happend under the spe- Egypt(see Fig. (2) ). What is worthy in this position is the ef-
cific program for placing pre-Islamic' past against Islam's past. forts of these architects to create an "Iranian architecture",
Thus such a superficial moves could not be considered for which can have an status in international Assemblies (Bani
making a strong support for identity, which can be based on it, Masoud., 2011:297).
renovate the character of Iran Contemporary architecture One reason for these architects confusion in finding their
"(Memarian, 2004:341). identity was the unclear ideology beneath this architecture. If
One category of these contemporary architects, were known as we truly master our time ideology, or in other words, we have
the second generation pioneering architects, which can be ex- a clear idea for our present time, perhaps it is easier for archi-
pressed in the domain of a cultural triangle: tect to restore his identity (Mirmiran, 2004:12).
• The impact of West culture and civilization.

the Tehran Fine Art University's studios under the chairman-


ship of Eng. Foroughi, along with Eng. AftanDlyan, Sihon and
Qyahy (Untitled, 2011).
3 ABDUL AZIZ FARMANFARMAIAN THEORETICAL
He could truly be named the father of " Consulting Engineers
PERSPECTIVE (1920-2013) of Iran, ". Farmanfarmaian is an architect who was contem-
"One of the Iranian influential architects whom his main con- plating to "build”, and this concern of his should not be con-
cern was architectural engineering, is Abdul Aziz Farman- sidered without social context and the technology of his time.
farmaian. He was born in 1920 in Tehran "(Bani Masoud An architectural design for him is a builed design. An archi-
2011:311). He is considered as one of the most important pio- tect’s success rate is valued with his built works. Accordingly,
neering architects of second generation of Iranian contempo- he believed that a serious attention towards requirements,
rary architecture, whom was one of the founders of modern facilities and constraints of time and place,is the most im-
engineering system. He studied at the School of Bozar in Paris portant condition for success in business. As his distinguish-
and graduated in April 1930 and then returned to Iran. At ing characteristics are the strong belief in the necessity of
first, he began to design for relatives and friends in his father’s proper function of building and high precision in executional
garage and then had been hired in Tehran University’s office. details, can be mentioned. He believes that each architectural
Shortly after his residence in Iran, he started teaching in one of opus must be able to do its desired propose properly and the
210
Journal of Social Issues & Humanities, Volume 2, Issue 2, February 2014
ISSN 2345-2633

proper use of his accessible materials is a principle (Farman- Masoud 2011:313).


farmaian 2006).
Abdul Aziz farmanFarmaian entered into the realm of Iran’s
4 INTRODUCTION OF THE EXISTING SPACE AROUND
Architecture, when the major parts of architecture works
THE BUILDING AND BUILDING LOCATIONS IN URBAN
were in the hands of foreign companies and engineers and
there was nothing like designing the architectural detailng. In CONTEXT
fact Farmanfarmaian’s time should be considered as the era of Carpet Museum is located on the north side of Laleh Park, in
revolution of construction technology from the traditional Fatemi Avenue. Existence of Waterfronts in nearby sidewalks
technology to a modern technology. With this understanding is separating the main area of museum from street space. (Fig.
he tried to find practical solutions and he could revise and 4). It should also be noted that in the area of museum's green
remedy this deficiency in the possible minimum time with space, there is a building with a specific shape and double-
help of foreign architects’ experiences and visiting important glazing and no roof, which the given usage to it, is chapel
project from around the world. So, major of his work has been function.
modeled on the work of modern architects. As he himself also Carpet Museum association with Contemporary Art Muse-
insist on this issue that he designed most of his works as an um: Contemporary Art Museum located on the north side of
extract of Richard Neutra, Franck Lloyd Wright, Le Corbusier Keshavarz Boulevard, Westside of Laleh Park and south of
and Bauhaus school’s instructions and the International style( carpet museum and has started its artistic and cultural activi-
Moghtader 2003:58). ties in 1977. It should also be noted that two museum build-
“As Farmanfarmaian’s Historicism works can point out Teh- ings were built nearly at the same time, so that architect of
ran university’s Mosque, Iran’s Pavilion in Montreal Interna- Contemporary Art Museum, Kamran Diba, also has designed
tional expo in 1967, and Carpet museum in 1977 AD .But also the chapel of contemporary art museum. Of course there is a
it should be mentioned that the concepts which he had ex- detailed description of these two buildings' form association
that is beyond the scope of this study.
pressed in giving the building an Iranian look, seems just to be
in the ostensible part of Iranian architecture concepts( Bani

Fig. 4. The right figure, the location of Carpet Museum in urban context. Figure 5: The left figure, relationship between the
contemporary art museum and the carpet Museum from form viewpoint.

as carpet Museum's agendas.


Initially, the museum began its work with displaying 275
carpet and then this number had increased with purchasing
5 CARPET MUSEUM from domestic and foreign resources and transfers from other
"This museum was incompletely built as Carpet Gallery in museums, including the Golestan Palace Museum, (Bassam,
1961 and remained abandoned for 15 years and then in the 1390). It should also be noted that in this building all types of
early 1976, its repairs and overall changes began and was offi- rugs and hand-woven carpets are kept considering their quali-
cially opened on 22 January of 1977 "(Bani Masood, 2011: 313- ty and their age and with regard to characteristics of Iranian
314). However, It also should be noted that researching in his- carpets in terms of color, design, pattern texture and diversity
tory, evolution and history quality of art and the carpet indus- of carpet weaving areas. The building has a displaying area of
try, particularly in Iran, collecting and purchasing a variety of 3400 square meters, which consists of two halls. These halls
hand-woven Iranian carpets and holding temporary exhibi- are used for displaying types of hand-woven carpets and rugs.
tions of Iranian and around the world’s carpet, are considered

211
Journal of Social Issues & Humanities, Volume 2, Issue 2, February 2014
ISSN 2345-2633

tion. Air conditioner device between the roof and Pseudo ceiling
does the Temperature and humidity control. These factors caused
Farmanfarmaian to have an introspective approach in museum
building. It should be conceded that the architect in his introspec-
tive attitude just considered formal point of view and did not use
introversion conceptual attitude.

6.2 The Revealed Ornaments as Carpet Loom


One of the physical characteristics of the museum's exterior
facade is its revealed ornaments, which is similar to Carpet
loom. These traditional and historicity elements have provid-
ed, the structural performance of the building and are made of
reinforced concrete. Ornaments have been made of series of
columns, which are connected together so that the entrance to
Fig. 6. Tehran Carpet Museum. Source: Jam News
the carpet museum occurs from under one of these openings.
These columns are a trace of architect’s historicity thoughts in
the museum. It must be acknowledged that the architect in
designing the building along with his modernist agendas has
given an Iranian form to the museum that he used revealed
ornaments to achieve this goal.

Fig. 7. Repeating rhythm in exterior facade.

6 CHARACTERISTICS OF BUILDING'S ARCHITECTURE


AND IMPACT OF ARCHITECT'S ATTITUDE ON THESE
INDICATORS
Carpet Museum of Iran has a beautiful and spectacular archi-
tecture that the building’s exterior ornaments are inspired
from black nomadic tents and Carpet looms. (Bassam, 2011,
Bonnie M., 2011: 314). Farmanfarmaian also had used Iranian
traditional elements in designing the carpet museum building.
However, the totality of museum's design is modern and it is a
reminder of international architecture style. In a general per-
spective, it can be stated that the scheme of the Carpet Muse- Fig. 8. Investigating the role of carpet loom in the carpet museum's
um is designed with a modern purpose, but the architect has structure as an attribute of architect’s thoughts in the building
tried to give the museum an Iranian theme behind the modern (Source: authors).
architecture (Bani Masoud, 2011: 313-314).

6.1 Introversion
Due to the carpet sensitivity to the direct sunlight the outer body 6.3 Light Shafts
of building has minimal contact with the outside environment. In To provide light in this museum, entering direct light is prevent-
other words, "architectural form of museum building has been ed as far as possible. The architectural style of the building is in a
selected in a manner that the displaying part of museum has the manner that the least of light is allowed into the gallery. For ex-
lowest correlation with outer space"(Bani Masoud, 2011: 314). ample, the overall consul of the building on the top of the win-
Also, to enhance security in this building, only one main door dows has provided many shades in order to prevent them from
and two emergency exit door have been used. In order to ventila- allowing the entrance of direct light as far as possible, due to the

212
Journal of Social Issues & Humanities, Volume 2, Issue 2, February 2014
ISSN 2345-2633

destructive effects of light on museum and carpets. Except the harmful rays. So to lighten gallery space, solar lamps with varia-
inside of the spring house (central hall), in the other parts of gal- ble radiation angle have been used in gallery space. Therefore,
lery the sunlight does not penetrate into the inner space. Also In solar lamps with variable radiation angle have been used in gal-
this part the light passes trough a suspended ceiling, which is lery space. The trace of Iranian architecture can bee seen in the
made of a special plastic. This layer acts like a filter and reduces roof lights and it is indicating the designer's visual perspective in
the intensity of sunlight and eliminates a considerable amount of making building more Iranian.

Fig. 9. Observing the location of artificial light shafts of Ceiling in the Museum (Source: authors).

French, English and German in the library. Also best books,


periodicals and researches related to Iranian carpet and in
6.4 Impact of Farmanfarmaian’s Historicity Attitude on general Eastern carpets and books in the fields of religion, art
The Building Spatial Setting and literature of Iran are available in the Museum Library.
The inner space of museum is built from two halls (permanent Next to the library, bookstore of museum is also working.
gallery and temporary gallery) and its ancillary spaces in or- Teahouse: in the right corner of complex's lobby, teahouse
der to display different types of carpets and rugs. Permanent with a convenient visual to the lobby is located. In fact it is a
gallery of museum is located on the ground floor and its area place for enthusiasts to relax and drink for a short time af-
is approximately 1500 square meters. In the permanent gal- ter visiting the exhibition.
lery, a space has been design in which there is a vertical carpet
weaving machine (known as Tabrizi) and a carpet-weaving
artist is showing various ways of carpet weaving. The sus-
pended ceiling of theater is made of metal and designed in the
shape of filled and empty squares. These squares that are lo-
cated in different levels next to each other, in addition to add-
ing beauty to the interior space, are a suitable cover for indoor
installations. In order for Visitors to take a short break while
visiting the exhibition, sitting spaces are embedded in the cer-
tain intervals that suit the inner theme of exhibition. Tempo-
rary exhibition of carpet museum is located on the second
floor of museum with the area of approximately 800 square
meters and is designed for seasonal exhibits for different parts
of Iran. For ancillary spaces of museum can mention services,
tearoom, library and administrative (Bani Masoud, 2011: 314-
315).
Library: there are almost 3500 books in Persian, Arabic,
213
Journal of Social Issues & Humanities, Volume 2, Issue 2, February 2014
ISSN 2345-2633

museum to deployment, which includes guards' resorts, kitch-


en, bathroom, dining, police dorm and chapel.

Fig. 10. Right figure: the lobby of complex and connectivity paths with
other parts of museum; Fig. 11. left figure: location of permanent
exhibition and the way of getting in and out of it (Source: authors).

Sector of Museum Office: As this section's most important


actions are, documentation of existing opus in the museum. It
Fig. 12. The location of different spaces in the plan (Source: authors).
should be noted, that what is important in introduction and
training section after the documentation, is troves’ presenta-
tion and display. Other tasks of this part of the museum is Farmanfarmaian has applied his historicist insights in the
researching which would be achieved through organizing var- shape and appearance and modern concepts has been applied
ious exhibitions and numerous lectures, translating special- in the structure of the building. However, we should point
ized books, data collection and presentation of different pa- out that the museum is an appendage of the modern world
pers. One of the peripheral exhibitions that are held in this and in our country does not have much history. So Farman-
museum recently, is temporary exhibition particularly for farmaian is satisfied with applying only historicist perspective
blinds. A number of museum’s opus which have exsert pat- on the physical of building.
terns, form this exhibition collection.
Restoration Section: for better maintenance of museum's 7 CONCLUSION
opus, they should be cleaned, treat and repair regularly. In
order to achieve this goal, museum office has a special section In the examination of Farmanfarmaian thoughts’ process we
called the Restoration Workshop. This part is located next to came to this conclusion that most of the built structures in the
the museum office and has a relatively proper connection to Second Pahlavi period were Integration of modern and tradition-
the complex's library. Acoustic matters have led to existence of al architecture. Therefore, Farmanfarmaian's time should be con-
this distance. sidered as the era of transition and transformation of the technol-
TABLE 1 ogy. Most of his works has been modeled after the work of mod-
THE LEVEL OF MUSEUM'S SPACES RELATION TO EACH OTHER ern architects. As he himself also emphasizes, he has designed
(SOURCE: AUTHORS) most portion of his projects with adaptation from Richard Neutra
and Frank Lloyd Wright and Le Corbusier the Bauhaus school's
Instructions and the International Style. Farmanfarmaian also has
used traditional Persian elements in the design of carpet museum
monument. However museum design has a modern totality and
it is a reminder of the international style of architecture. In a gen-
eral perspective, it can be stating that carpet museum design has
been designed with modern agendas, but the architect has tried
to give it an Iranian theme behind the modern architecture. One
of the Physical characteristics of the museum's exterior facade is
its revealed ornaments, which is similar to Carpet loom. These
traditional and historicity elements have provided, the structural
performance of the building and are made of reinforced concrete.
Architect's purpose of these elements is purely of historicist as-
pects. Farmanfarmaian applied his historicist approach only in
the body of building and in its spatial structure had used more of
modern concepts and had less attention to his historicist ap-
proach. In Skylights of this building Iranian architecture's visual
indications is evident and architect did not use Iranian light
Service Sector: this part is a location for service and guards of shaft's structure, but has given it An Iranian look with only an
214
Journal of Social Issues & Humanities, Volume 2, Issue 2, February 2014
ISSN 2345-2633

Iranian decorative cover. In general, in the design of carpet mu-


seum, Farmanfarmaian has applied his historicist approaches in
the physical of the building and has used his modernist ap-
proaches in the structure of the building and has tried to integrate
modern and traditional (historicist) architecture.

REFERENCES
[1] Bani Masoud Amir (2011) Iranian Contemporary Architecture: Struggle
between Tradition and Modernity (Fourth Edition) Tehran Art Century Ar-
chitecture Publishing.
[2] Bassam Sayed Jalaleddin (2011) Interactive Services of Iranian Carpet Science
Association and _ Museums, science-research Journal of Goljam, No. 18
Goljam Publication.
[3] Anonymous (2011) A Biography of Abdul Aziz Farmanfarmaian (1920-2013),
http://hamshahrionline.ir/ details/149425, analytical-News databases - of
Hamshahri online.
[4] Arthur Upham Pope (2010), the position of carpet in Iranian Art (Translation:
Mostafa Zakeri) Tourism bimonthly, No. 25 Journal of Tourism.
[5] Shaeiri Hamidreza (2009), Analysis of the signs - semiotic of discourse, Teh-
ran, Samt publishing.
[6] Farmanfarmaian Abdul Aziz (2006), Abdul Aziz Farmanfarmaian in the Film
of Interview with, Architect's Journal, No. 36.
[7] Moghtader, Mohammad Reza (2003) Mohammadreza Moghtader Discuss-
sion with AbdulAziz Farmanfarmaian, Architect Journal, No. 22 pp. 58.
[8] Memarian Gholamhossein (2004) Reviewing Theoretical Foundations of
Architecture, Tehran, Soroush Danesh Publication
[9] Mirmiran, Hadi (2004), The Search for National Identity in Today’s Architec-
ture, Architect Journal, No. 26.

215

You might also like