Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Steward 1972
Steward 1972
I N SOILS
J. H. STEWARD AND J. M. OADES
(Department of Agricultural Biochemistry and Soil Science, Waite Agricultural
Research Institute, Glen Onnond, South Australia, 5064)
Summary
A method for extraction and determination of organic phosphorus based on a
pretreatment with I M HCl followed by ultrasonic vibration in 0 . 5 NaOH
~ is
proposed and shown to be generally superior to two commonly used procedures
in terms of efficiency and speed. Determination of organic phosphorus by the
proposed technique showed that almost a third of the phosphorus applied to a
red-brown earth growing a mixed legume-grass pasture has been incorporated
into organic molecules.
Introduction
ORGANIC phosphorus in soils is estimated by either of two indirect
procedures, ignition or extraction.
In the ignition procedure, organic phosphorus (Po)corresponds to the
increase in the inorganic phosphorus (Pi) which can be extracted from
soil by acid following the destruction of organic materials by ignition.
Usually untreated and ignited samples are extracted separately and
= pi extracted from ignited sample -pi extracted from untreated sample.
Black and Goring ( I 53) discussed the problems associated with the use
8
of this approach, an numerous publications have since emphasized the
existence of various factors which may each affect the final Po figure
(e.g. Williams et ul.,. 1970).
Using the extraction method, Po is the difference between the total
Pt) and the Pi in an extract of a soil. The Pi is measured
oxidative destruction of organic materials in the extract
and
= pi after destruction of organic materials -pi before drstruction of organic mabrialw.
Usually only an aliquot of the extract is destroyed (by acid digestion or
Na,CO, fusion) for the determination and it is thus possible to obtain
both quantitative and qualitative information from the same extract (cf.
the total destruction of the sample b ignition).
terms, the most eftyective method of extracting Po is
the highest amount of Po. This does not mean that
of the organic moiety attached to the phosphate has
not occurred.
NaOH is the most effective extracting agent of Po from soil, but yields
are usually greater when pol valent cations are first removed (Jackman
and Black, 1951;Black and Loring, 1953; Mehta et al., 1954; Saunders
and Williams, 1955; Anderson, 1960). The main differences between
these methods are in the pretreatments-whereas some workers used a
rather concentrated acid for the pretreatment (Mehta et al., 1954; Kaila
Journal of So11 Sclence, Vol. 23. No. 1, 1973
DETERMINATION OF ORGANIC PHOSPHORUS IN SOILS 39
and Virtaanen, 1955; Kaila, 1962; Greb and Olsen, 1967), Saunders and
Williams (1955) and Saunders (1959) used dilute acid. Other workers
were concerned with avoiding hydrolysis of acid-labile phosphates
(Anderson, 1960; Harra , 1963; Dormaar and Webster, 1963).
B
Among other metho s of extraction that have been proposed are
extraction with 8-hydroxyquinoline (Boswall and De Long, 1959),
sodium bicarbonate (Maclean, I 65a), acetylacetone and ultrasonic
dispersion (Halstead et al., 19667 and chelating resin (Thomas and
Bowman, 1966). These methods do not ap ear to have any proven
8
advantage or increased effectiveness over Na H extraction.
Distinct limitations of the published procedures are the long times of
extraction and the large solution-to-soil ratios which are used. These
make routine analyses tedious and qualitative investigations on the
extract are rarely possible. Furthermore, none of the methods is con-
sistently superior to any other in extracting Po from soils and, in the
absence of a ‘standard’ method, comparison of results in the literature
is not strictly valid where different extraction methods have been used
(Dormaar, 1964, 1967; Maclean, 19653; Bornemisza and Igue, 1967).
Ultrasonic vibration has been shown to be an effective means of
(Olmstead, 1931; Edwards and Bremner, 196 ,
.4
the rapid extraction of organic materials from so1 s
1964; Swincer et al., 1968; Ford et al., 1969) and
rock fragments (McIver, I 962). The following sections describe the
application of ultrasonic vibration to the extraction of Pofrom soils using
sodium hydroxide.
Materials and methods
Soils were obtained from two sources :
Uwbraefine sandy loam. Six plots from the CI permanent rotation
trial at the Waite Institute (Waite Institute Annual Report, 1966-7) were
sampled to a depth of 6.5 cm in the summer of 1967. Fifty cores were
taken from each plot using the zigzag attern recommended by Jackson
P
(1958). The air-dry soils were gent y crushed (< 2 mm) and sub-
samp es were ground to fine powder in a Sieb-teknik mill. The soils
were stored at room temperature in sealed plastic jars.
Eastern Australian soils. Seven soils were kindly su plied b Dr. C. H.
Williams, CSIRO, Division of Plant Industry, Cangerra. $our of the
soils were the same as those used by Williams and Anderson (1968), viz.
2-37, 250, 253, and 315; the other three were closely related to soils used
by the same authors, viz. ROB-same site as 53 I , 350-same site as 3 8,
CH-same paddock as 641. The soils were also ground to fine pow er
and stored at room temperature.
2
General methods. Total carbon was determined using a Fisher Carbon
Induction furnace (Young and Lindbeck, 1964). Carbon figures for soils
250 and 350 were corrected for carbonate content. P, in the soils was
determined by X-ray fluorescence spectrography using pressed borate
discs (Norrish and Hutton, 1964). Total N was determined by a
Kjeldahl procedure. The soil pH was measured 10 min after shaking
the soil in a I : 5 (w/v) suspension of soil in I M CaC1,.
40 J. H. STEWARD A N D J. M. OADES
Pt in the extracts was measured after perchloric acid digestion by
Usher's adaptation (Usher, 1963) of the method of Bartlett (1959).
Inorganic P was determined by the method of John (1970) after the
humic materials in the extract had been precipitated in O - O O ~ MH,SO,
at H z for 10-20 min (Anderson, 1961).
$he difference between P, and Pi in the extract was called Po;all
P values are quoted as pprn P on an air-dry soil basis. Differences of
less than 20 pprn P between soils were considered to be not significant.
Ultrasonic vibration was performed with a Branson S-75 ultrasonic
generator operating with a power output of 75 watts and a frequency of
20 kc/sec at the probe tip. The tip was placed 5-10 mm below the liquid
surface and all samples were exposed to the vibrations for 3 min. All
extracts were centrifuged and the supernatant solutions retained for
analysis.
For the quantitative analyses quoted in Tables 3 and 4, where no
pre-treatment was used to extract Po,the calculations included an adjust-
ment for that material remaining entrained in the soil residue after
decanting the supernatant extract. The weight of solution entrained
was measured and its Poconcentration was considered to be identical
to the Po in the supernatant extract. The adjustment was calculated
assuming a density of 1-0g/cc for the extract.
In the extractions involving a pre-treatment, the residue after extrac-
tion with 0 . 5 ~NaOH was washed twice with O - I M NaOH and the
pre-treatment, extract, and washings were combined for analysis
70"
198
I20 113
85
9
w
44 J. H. STEWARD AND J. M. OADES
a-
In
2
0
z
n
In
0
r
n
.-0
m
C
e
0
1"NaOH
Pretreatmentm ZdNaOH extract
FIG. I . Organic phosphorus extracted from soils by the methods of Mehta et af.
( I 954) and Harrap ( I 963).
TABLE 3
Comparison of phosphorus (ppm) extracted by the HC1-NaOH-ultrasonic
vibration procedure with methoh of Mehta et sl.
I I
Method of extraci
HC
Mehta
-
- PO PO
tirrbrae fsl
UI 62 70
u5 314 249 242 65 75
UI5 12.5 I33
U16 123 I 26
u17 348 258 303 II0 107
U 29 I79 183
Eastern Australian
roils
2 50
CH
' 183
223
130
131
53
92
104
230
48
111
73
I 26
237 2553 2257 296 I495 507 600
315 1225 567 658 1362 992 1512 I 087
253 2064 1636 428 1038 435 460
ROB 1719 985 734 1385 804 916
350 7038 6257 781 1954
-464 569
s
(ii) Omit ste 4 from the proposed rocedure. Instead, the Po in the
P
entraine solution is accounted or by weighing. This assumption
results in an error of less than 5 per cent.
The method can be adapted to deal with large uantities of soil by
using the flow cell for the ultrasonic probe descri ed by Ford et al. 'b
( 1969).
46 J. H. STEWARD A N D J. M. OADES
Urrbrae fsl
TABLE 5
Characteristics of Urrbraefsl(0--10 cm) r m n g natural pasture
bejiie and after fertilization wit superphosphate B
Total P added
Soil Year of in superphosphate
--
code sampling (kglb)
U61 I927 Nil
u57 1927 58.3 1'00
U618 1947 4506 ~~ ~ ~~~
(U57, U618) showed C :Po ratios close to the range of C :P, ratios for
other fertilized plots on the same soil, as shown in Table 4.
The last column of Table 4 indicates that, as the fertility increases,
as assessed by carbon and nitrogen contents, a greater proportion of the
P, is incorporated into organic molecules.
The proportion of the phosphorus added to the Urrbrae fsl as super-
phosphate which has been incorporated into organic compounds in the
soil was determined using annual reports of the Waite Agricultural
Research Institute and the current results. For the soils growin natural
pasture this was 16-18 per cent. Table 6 shows that a mixed egume- K
TABLE
6
Accumulation of organic phosphorus in Urrbrae fsl
under dagermt rotations
Phosphorus added as
superphosphate since I929
% added P
Plot ppm Po accumulated
number Rotation kg/ha accumulated+ as P,,
UI WF 289 I97 12 6
WPF 402 275 I7 6
5:: WWPPPP 482 330 75 23
U16 PPPPWW 482 330 68 21
U17 W 603 41 1 49 I2
U29 P 603 41 1 125 30
Acknowledgements
J. H. S. is grateful for the award of a Commonwealth Postgraduate
Research Fellowship.
REFERENCES
ANDERSON, G. 1960. Factors affecting the estimation of phosphate. J. Sci. Food
Agric. 11, 497~503.
-1961. A partial fractionation of alkali-soluble soil organic phosphate. J. Soil
Sci. 12, 276-85.
BARTLETT, G. R. 1959. Phosphorus assay in column chromatography. J. Biol. Chem.
234,466-7 I.
BLACK, C. A., and GORINGC. A. I. 1953. Organic Phosphorus in Soils, in Soil and
Fertilizer Phosphorus (eds. W. H. Pierre and A. G. Norman). Agronomy 4,
123-52.
BORNEMISZA, E., and IGUE,K. 1967. Comparison of three methods for determining
organic phosphorus in Costa Rican soils. Soil Sci. 103, 347-53.
BOSWALL, G. W., and DBLONG, W. A. 1959. The use of 8-hydroxyquinoline (oxine)
in the extraction of soil organic phosphorus. Canad. J. Soil Sci. 39, 20-6.
DORMAAR, J. F. 1964. Evaluation of methods for determination of total organic
phosphorus in chernozemic soils of southern Alberta. Ibid. 44, 265-71.
-1967. Distribution of inositol phosphates in some chemozemic soils of southern
Alberta. Soil Sci. 104, 17-24.
-1968. Extraction of organic phosphorus in chernozemic soils. Plant and Soil
28, 268-79.
-and WEBSTER, G. R. 1963. Determination of total organic phosphorus in soils
by extraction methods. Canad. J. Soil Sci. 43, 35-43.
EDWARDS, A. P., and BREMNER, J. M. 1964. Use of sonic vibration for separation of
soil particles. Ibid. 44, 366.
--1967. Dispersion of soil particles by sonic vibration. J. Soil Sci. 18,4743.
FORD,G. W., GREENLAND, D. J., and OADES,J. M. 1969. Separation of the light
fraction from soils by ultrasonic dispersion in halogenated hydrocarbons con-
taining a surfactant. Ibid. 20, 291-6.
GREB,B. W., and OLSEN,S. R. 1967. Organic phosphorus in calcareous Colorado
soils. Soil Sci. SOC.Amer. Proc. 31, 85-9.
GREENLAND, D. J., and FORD, G. W. 1964. Separation of partially humified organic
materials from soil by ultrasonic dispersion. Trans. 8th Int. Congr. Soil Sci. 3,
137-48.
HALSTEAD, R. L., and ANDERSON, G. 1970. Chromatographic fractionation of organic
phosphates from alkali, acid and aqueous acetylacetone extracts of soils. Canad.
J. Soil Sci. 50, 111-19.
--and SCOTT, N. M. 1966. Extraction of organic matter from soils by means
of ultrasonic dispersion in aqueous acetylacetone. Nature, Lond. 21 1, 1430-1.
HANCE, R. J., and ANDERSON, G. 1962. A comparative study of methods of investi-
gating soil organic phosphorus. J. Soil Sci. 13, 225-30.
HARRAP, F. E. G. 1963. Use of sodium EDTA in the determination of soil organic
phosphorus. Ibid. 14, 8 2 7 .
JACKMAN, R. H., and BLACK,C. A. 1951. Solubility of iron, aluminium, calcium and
magnesium inositol phosphates at different pH values. Soil Sci. 72, 179-86.
JACKSON, M. L. 1958. Soil chemical analysis. Constable and Co. Ltd. London.
JOHN,M. K. 1970. Colorimetric determination of phosphorus in soil and plant
materials with ascorbic acid. Soil Sci. 109, 214-20.
DETERMINATION OF ORGANIC PHOSPHORUS I N SOILS 49
KAILA,A. 1962. Determination of total organic phosphorus in samples of mineral
soils. J. Sci. Agr. SOC.Finland, 34, 187-96.
-and VIRTAANEN, 0. 1955. Determination of organic phosphorus in samples of
peat soils. Ibid. 27, 104-15.
MACLEAN, A. A. 1 9 6 5 ~ .Extraction of organic phosphorus from soils with sodium
bicarbonate. Canad. J. Soil Sci. 45, 165-70.
-1965b. Organic phosphorus in some New Brunswick soils. Ibid. 183-8.
MARTIN, J. K. 1964. Soil organic phosphorus. I. Methods for the extraction and
partial fractionation of soil organic phosphorus. N.Z. J. Agric. Res. 7, 723-49.
MCIVER,R. D. 1962. Ultrasonics-a rapid method for removing soluble organic
matter from sediments. Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta, 26, 343-5.
MEHTA, N. C., LECG,J. O., GORING, C. A. I., and BLACK, C. A. 1954. Determina-
- -
tion of oreanic DhosDhorus in soils. I. Extraction method. Soil Sci. SOC.
Amer.
Proc. 15,&3+.
NORRISH, K., and HUTTON, J. T. 1964. Preparation of samples for analysis by X-ray
fluorescent spectroeraphv. CSIRO Division of Soils. Divisional Report 3/64.
OLMSTEAD, L. B.- 1931: Dispersion of soils by a supersonic method. J: Agric. Res.
42,841-52.
SAUNDERS, W. M. H. 1959. Effect of phosphate topdressing on a soil from andesite
volcanic ash. I. Forms of soil phosphorus and a method for their determination.
N.Z. J. Agric. Res. 2, 427-44.
-and WtLLIms, E. G. 1955. Observations on the determination of total organic
phosphorus in soils. J. Soil Sci. 6, 254-67.
SAWYER, D. T. 1964. Metal gluconate complexes. Chem. Rev. 64, 633-43.
SWINCER, G. D., OADES,J. M., and GREENLAND, D. J. 1968. Studies on soil poly-
saccharides. I. The isolation of polysaccharides from soil. 11. The composition
and properties of polysaccharides in soils under pasture and under a fallow-wheat
rotation. Austral. J. Soil Res. 6, 225-35.
THOMAS, R. L., and BOWMAN, B. T. 1966. The occurrence of high molecular weight
organic phosphorus compounds in soil. Soil Sci. SOC.Amer. Proc. 30,799-801.
USHER, D. A. 1963. Estimation of phosphorus on paper chromatograms. J. Chroma-
tog. 12, 262-3.
WILLIAMS, C. H., and ANDERSON, G. 1968. Inositol phosphates in some Australian
soils. Austral. J. Soil Res. 6, 121-30.
WILLIAMS, J. D. H., SYERS, J. K., WALKER, T. W., and REX, R. W. 1970. A com-
parison of methods for the determination of soil organic phosphorus. Soil Sci.
110, 13-18.
YOUNG, J. L.,and LINDBECK, M. R. 1964. Carbon determination in soils and organic
materials with a high-frequency induction furnace. Soil Sci. SOC.Amer. Proc.
28, 377-81.
(Received 24 March Ig7I)
6113.1 E