Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Evaluating SSC English Syllabus in The Light of CLT
Evaluating SSC English Syllabus in The Light of CLT
A Project Report
Supervised By:
Md. Abdullah Bhuiyan
Lecturer
Department of English
Submitted By:
Department of English
ISHAKHA INTERNATIONAL UNIVERSITY, BANGLADESH
DECLARATION
Student’s Signature
Date:
This is to certify that I have read this report and that in my opinion it is fully adequate,
in scope and quality, as a report for the Bachelor degree of Arts (Hons) in English.
Supervisor’s Signature
Date:
iii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
First of all, I would like to express my deepest gratitude to the Almighty Allah for
giving me the courage and determination to complete the research within scheduled time. I
am grateful to my supervisor Md. Abdullah Bhuiyan whose supervision and guidance
throughout all stages of research has enabled me to complete the paper successfully. I would
also like to thank to the respected teachers of different schools who gave me their valuable
ideas. Their thoughts, ideas, suggestions and experiences made it possible for me to conduct
my study.
Lastly, my warmest gratitude goes to my parents for being there &supporting me at every
aspect of my life.
iv
ABSTRACT
Table of Contents
Contents PageNumber
Declaration………………………………………………………………………… ii
Acknowledgement………………………………………………………………… iii
Abstract…………………………………………………………………………… iv
1.7:ResearchQuestions…………………………………………………… 04
CHAPTER 2:LiteratureReview……………………….………….…………… 05
3.3: Instruments……………………………………………………………. 07
3.4: Sampling of the Study…………………………………………………. 08
3.5:Data Analysis………………….……………………………… 09
vi
CHAPTER 4: FindingsandAnalysis…………………………………… 10
Recommendations……………………………………………………… 15
References………………………………………………………………………… 17
Appendix -I………………………………………………………………………. 18
Appendix- II………………………………………………………………………. 18
Appendix- III……………………………………………………………………… 18
1
Chapter 1
Introduction:
2. Another feature of CLT is the use of authentic materials. Whenever possible authentic
language as it is used in a real context should be introduced.
3. Activities in CLT are often carried out by students in small groups.
2
However, CLT is not accepted cordially by the teachers in Bangladesh and it is not practiced in
the schools in true sense. In the starting, CLT was opposed by the traditional English teachers as
they were not ready for something which was wholly new to them.
According to the researcher’s identification, the functional curriculum has been implemented
partly which can be considered as a possible reason of the current state of failure of the CLT
approach in Bangladesh. It is thought that the education administration failed to involve some
vital issues including teacher preparation for implementing education policy and teste formation
at the introduction of CLT method in Bangladesh.
As a consequence, the imposition of CLT has affected language teaching and learning adversely.
It is now generally believed that the CLT approach has not come into force to bring the
anticipated changes in the existing English teaching and learning situation. Studies found that the
teachers are still using the same ancient process of English learning by the way they were taught
while they are teaching their students. Earning mark is the most important issue for all. Even the
teacher’s goal is to prepare the students for the impending test so that students can achieve higher
score in the examination. It seems that even after more than two decades of the arrival of CLT,
the English teachers are not conscious of the objectives of English curriculum. The innovation in
English language teaching curriculum was obscure to most of the teachers. Undoubtedly the
3
policymakers of Bangladesh were mostly reliable to this teaching and testing of English. In could
hardly be denied that ground realities were not duly considered while CLT introduced at
secondary level education in Bangladesh.
2. Communicative approach makes a secondary language available to the students and it also
creates the interest to adept the language among the students. Meaningful language is
always more easily possessed by learners.
3. Seeks to use genuine reasons and students get much interest and become motivated to learn
a secondary language.
4. In order to speak students, acquire grammar rules which is more proficient and efficient.
1. Through CLT method teaching and learning may hamper as it merely pays heed
to these contexts.
3. The CLT approach focuses on fluency but not accuracy. It is pointed out as a
disadvantage of the method. The method does not focus on error reduction.
Instead of it, the process creates such a situation where the learners are left using
their own devices to solve their communication problems. Through this way, they
may produce incoherent and they may do much grammatically incorrect
sentences.
4
1. What are the English language teacher’s attitudes towards the applying of CLT?
2. Does CLT help the students to develop communicative competence?
3. How much CLT is effective for language learning?
4. How much the present SSC Syllabus can help to implement CLT in Secondary level
The study will Evaluate the SSC English syllabus in the light of
Communication Language Teaching (CLT) method and will justify its effectiveness in achieving
communicative competence. The researcher provided relevant materials to find out their
motivations. As Communicative Language Teaching approach had been implemented in our
secondary level syllabus with an expectation that students will able to acquire communicative
competence in English as it is second or official language in Bangladesh, but since 1995 to
present, CLT approach has failed to achieve the expected goal at secondary level of Bangladesh.
In the meantime, several surveys and studies have been done to find out the problem. And
according to the results of these studies many editions and corrections have been done to provide
a standard syllabus based on CLT approach among the secondary level students. This study will
be a useful to evaluate the current secondary syllabus and will able to justify how much this
syllabus is effective in motivating the students to acquire communicative competence. The
author of the study thinks that it is a step for future researcher in this field.
5
Chapter-2
Literature Review
• Hossain in 2012 made an elaborate study on the present CLT based SSC syllabus and
observed that this syllabus includes some items that may help the students practice reading
and writing skills, yet students are not able to communicate in English. He pointed out some
possible causes behind this inability of students, such as untrained teachers, uninteresting
contents of English syllabus and text book, student’s poor performance, lacking in the
teacher student’s interaction and above all.
• Tahmina Sultana Saima says in her study in 2018 based on the effectiveness of SSC
English syllabus plays a very insignificant role in motivating to achieve communicative
competence, instead of practicing, the students are still found to memorize selected answers.
And another findingfrom her study says that students are more motivated to get a good Grade
Point Average (GPA) in exam than achieving competence. She also gives some possible
recommendations which may help to motivate students to achieve communicative
competence.
• Md. Miraz Hossain had made an evaluation on SSC English Syllabus which was published
on a group project of BANGLADESH RESEARCH FOUDATION JOURNAL on 2012,
where in his study Md. Miraz Hossain tries to point out the merits and drawbacks of CLT
based SSC English syllabus. He collected data by following questionnaire and interviewing
method. He collected some samples and statements by interviewing a few students and
teachers. Whatever in his study he confirms that the current CLT approached SSC syllabus is
appropriate in acquiring competency in English andis more successful both in the public
exam and in the real life situation than any other syllabus in the past. The main drawbacks
which are responsible for the incapability of acquiring competency in English are mainly
lack of teachers, lack of teacher’s appreciation on approaching CLT to the students. However
,Md. Miraz Hossain suggested a few recommendation regarding this crisis which can help
to overcome this problem.
• M.A.K Ruman elaborately evaluated the SSC syllabus based on CLT approach to find out
its merits that how much it is helpful in teaching and learning communicating English. He
6
tried to find out the causes behind the inability of achieving expected result. He made an
investigation among the teachers and students by collecting samples and statements,
following questionnaire and interview methods. Through his evaluation and investigation, the
findings of the study say that lacking of untrained teachers, student’s poor performance,
failure of implementing the syllabus properly are the major problem behind the failure of
achieving communicative competence on secondary level in Bangladesh.
• Mohammad Humayun Kabir, Farhad Jamila, Nahida Sultana has made a study on the
implementation of CLT principles at the SSC level in Bangladesh. In order to find out the
loopholes the have chosen two methods regarding classroom observation, and practicing
teacher’s interviews. Problems like lack of efficient and trained teachers, class size, present
testing system, lack of student’s language proficiency and deficiency in students and
teacher’s interaction have been pointed out in the way of CLT method as hindrances. They
have also added some recommendations to address this issue. Implementation of CLT in the
educational institutions, alignment of teaching and testing of English, following curricular
guidelines and so on can be the resolution of the cited crisis.
7
Chapter-3
The purpose of the study is to investigate and evaluate teachers’ and students’ perception,
attitudes and response towards the applying of Communicative Language Teaching in language
classroom according to their syllabus.
3.3 Instruments:
In this study, researcher used two survey instruments-questionnaire and
interview. The questionnaire designed for the students. Researcher also interviewed six English
teachers teaching at SSC level by following a structured interview so that they can “expand on
answers that are particularly important. The interviewed teachers have been coded as T1, T2, T3,
T4, T5 and T6.
The researcher has to browse a number of articles for preparing checklist. He followed Methela
Rahman (2013), Hussain (2010). She selected 8 questions for checklist. The checklist was used
while the researcher observed classes. The researcher conducted two classes in two different
schools following the checklist to find out student’s perceptions, attitudes and their response of
using authentic materials.
8
In ‘Arjat Atarjan High School’ the researcher selected 25 students among 40 students randomly. The
researcher informed the respondents about the present study and its significance in first class. They
are requested to attend next class. He conducted a class with 40 students using Communicative text
and task. Newspaper, literary extracts, you-tube videos, intelligence test, multimedia presentation
about CLT approach, Google etc. are used by the researcher. The researcher tried to find out their
negative and positive response towards the CLT approach on their SSC syllabus.
Next in ‘Hashmot Uddin High School’ the researcher conducted the survey among 16 students
out of 25 students randomly. 16 students and 1 teacher took part to the questionnaire survey and
interview.
Next in ‘Haybatnagar A.U Kamil Madrasah’ the researcher conducted the survey among 10
students out of 19 students randomly. 10 students and 1 teacher took part to the questionnaire
survey and interview.
In ‘Kishoreganj Girls High School’ the researcher conducted questionnaire survey among 19
students of class 9.Here 1 teacher also took part to the interview.
9
In ‘Gundhar High School’ questionnaire was provided among 10 students. Researcher also took
interview of one English teacher.
Next in ‘Kapasia Pilot High School’ the researcher conducted a class using CLT methods. The
researcher observed the class and after finishing the class the students filled up questionnaire
sheets. Here 1 teacher also participated in interview.
The teachers are cooperative and share their valuable opinion and suggestion about the present
study.
Teachers act like they preferred teach according to CLT in classroom. The researcher finds out
their motivations towards CLT approach. The result of data analysis and findings are presented
in next chapter.
10
Chapter-4
In the table no 01, the researcher has asked four question to the students in a questionnaire
method. Researcher wants to the ratio of student’s activities. The result shows that a large
number of students (46%) cannot speak English either. A few number of students only practice
English speaking as a part of teacher student’s interaction. However, a large number of student
do not feel comfortable in speaking English though they are following CLT based English
syllabus.
Then researcher attempted to know how the secondary level students are practicing to improve
their writing skills as it is one of the four major language skills. The students were gone through
another questionnaire, where they were asked how they participates on paragraph writings,
completing stories, fill in the gap and etc. the ratio of their activities has been designed to show
clearly:
Table 2: How Student’s practice on writing paragraph, completing stories and fill in the gaps
students write paragraphs by- memorizing practicing understanding conducting
strategies
64.8% 18.3% 12% 4.9%
11
100
90
80
70 64.8
60
50
40
30
18.3
20
12
10 4.9
0
by memorizing By practising in classroom by undrestanding by conducting learning
and at home strategies
In this chart the investigation shows that only 4.9% students are trying to utilize special learning
strategies where a huge number of students are basically following reading and memorizing
process. Basically the students who are on the alarming 64.8 rate are more worried about their
GPA that is way they are following the short cut process, which is clearly opposite to the goal of
the present CLT based syllabus.
In an another student
ent questionnaire
questionnaire the researcher wanted to find that why the students are
learning English? The researcher attempted to find if students are focused on achieving
communicative competence or not. As CLT focuses on the language skill development, they
should be motivated to achieve masters on language communicating. Therefore researcher
collected data from the students in questionnaire method where He asked questions with multiple
choices. The questions are- why are you learning English? There have been given four choices
from which students should pick one.
Statistics from this questionnaire says that 38% students are learning English as a communicative
method. They want to achieve communicative skills in English. But ddue ue to the lacking of well
management and enough appreciation they are not doing well in achieving communicative
competence. The statistics shows:
12
Series 1
universit
to
I don’t y
Language a subject a topic to pass communi for a job
know admissio
cate
n
Series 1 30 63 0.5 6.5 5 27 3 65
Although CLT is a language teaching method, this statistics shows that a massive number of
students are accepting English as a subject, though they are being taught on the basis of CLT
based syllabus. It signifies that students are merely focused on achieving communicative
competence rather they are more conscious about their grades which leads them to accept
English as a subject.
Though some students are found in this study who are trying to develop English as their second
language but this rate is too poor to count.
Researcher has made another questionnaire among the students who are trying to acquire
communicative competence to find out the way they are practicing whether it is based on CLT or
not. The researcher asked some question regarding to their goal and found how they practice
speaking English as a secondary language:
Among the students who are interested in achieving good communication skill in English have
been separated into four past on the basis of their participation. Only 3% of those students are
trying to practice both speaking and listening in home and classrooms. Among the 60% have
claimed that they practice with family and often with friends but in classroom they do not. They
feel the lacking of proper atmosphere on the classroom and less appreciation comes from
teachers which makes them uncomforting while speaking English on the classroom.
13
T2 claims that when she tries to make her students practice some communicative activities, they
do not show any interests. According to her, students are mostly seen “to memorize everything
without understanding anything to get good marks.”
T3 shared her experience of 20years and said that students are mostly motivated “to memorize
and copy from their friends in the examination.” she also expressed that when she tries “to make
the classroom environment appropriate for practicing communicative activities, students’
reaction is not co-operative. Though a few students respond but rest of others feels shy and many
of them cannot even understand the class and losses their interest to participate on class.
T4 said that students are not motivated to develop their communicative skills. They only want to
secure a good GPA in the examination.
T5 remarked that her students are not motivated enough to achieve communicative skills. When
she tries to make them practice communicative activities in the classroom, “they do not show any
interest, and want to memorize only those activities that have the probability to appear in the
examination.” Besides they do not have enough materials and guidelines which can make the
more professional in applying Communicative approach in the classroom.
14
T6 claims that students are always scared and aware about public examination. It is not their
fault, the system has made them to follow touch and pass process. They don’t want to take risk
on trying a new method as it may become a lengthy process to reach at the top point where
memorizing and reading guides can help them to acquire a good result in a short time. So, it is
clear that, all teachers agree to a point that most of the students’ purpose of learning English is to
achieve a good GPA in the examination. When they were asked about the students’ purpose of
learning English, they replied: “It has become a practical tendency of students to achieve a
greater GPA in examination.”
objectives of present CLT-based SSC English syllabus is to enable students “to acquire
necessary grammar competence in English language” (National Curriculum, 2012: 74). But some
of them are made to memorize grammatical rules, which are not expected at all.
It is clear that students are not participating on their classrooms and are not following the proper
guideline which is provided by current SSC syllabus. They are motivated in a wrong way. By
investigating the co-relation between the books students are following and the provided syllabus
this study has found that the conventional guide books are not following CLT curriculum at all.
These books are basically composed for helping teachers as it contains lots of seen/unseen
comprehensions, complete question patterns, fill in the gaps and many items according to the
testing curriculum. The teachers are mostly interested in picking up one of them applying those
in the question papers which is not acceptable on CLT curriculum. Again these books are
randomly being provided to the students and making them motivated that the question will be
among of these provided patterns, which leads them to memorizing these readymade books for
their examination.
Another major finding that is responsible for the failure of CLT approach in Bangladesh is
teacher student interaction. Most of the teachers are commonly not interested to adapt a new
curriculum for teaching English. They like to teach the way they had been taught when they were
students. They randomly mixed CLT method with the previous Grammar Translation Method.
They follow guides for testing 1st paper English as it is completely comprehensive and
communicative and for testing 2nd paper English they mixed it with Grammar Translation
Method where they emphasize on grammatical accuracy instead of emphasizing on the proper
applying of these grammatical items. As a result most of the students can achieve accuracy in
solving grammatical problems but they are not able to apply them in real life communications,
which were the major demerits of GTM (Grammar Translation Method).
16
Chapter-5
1. A new testing method may be provided where each four language skill will be at priority.
2. Classroom atmosphere may be transformed as language friendly.
3. Number of well trained teachers should be increased.
4. Guide books may be prevented and teachers should motivate students to practice
communicative English in real file activities.
5. Classroom facilities may need to be increased.
6. Syllabus curriculum Board needs to emphasize on English 2nd paper study plans. There
need to add some additions like writing paragraph from statistic charts or completing
stories from a picture etc.
17
References
[1] Kabir, Mohammed Humayun, Forhad Jamila, and Nahida Sultana. "Impediments to the
Implementation of CLT Principles at the SSC Level in Bangladesh: A Case Study." (2020).
[3] Sima, T.S., 2021. The effectiveness of SSC English syllabus in motivating students to
achieve communicative competence: A case study.
[4] Nuby, M.H.M., Rashid, R.A., Rahman, A.R.M.M. and Hasan, M.R., 2020. Communicative
Language Teaching in Bangladeshi Rural School. Universal Journal of Educational
Research, 8(2), pp.622-630.
[5] Ruman, Abdul Karim. (2014). "English Syllabus at the SSC Level in Bangladesh: An
Evaluation".
[6] https://www.scirp.org/journal/ce
[7] Samimy, K.K. and Kobayashi, C., 2004. Toward the development of intercultural
communicative competence: Theoretical and pedagogical implications for Japanese English
teachers. Jalt Journal, 26(2), pp.245-261.
[8] Kabir, M.H., 2015. Managing curricular innovation and teacher training: Bangladesh
perspective.
[9] Haque, M., 2011. Problems of CLT in Secondary Level: Urban Context (Doctoral
18
[10] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/316171560
[11] https://online.ulm.edu/articles/education/communicative-language-approach-in-esl.aspx
[12] https://tesol-lessonplan.blogpost.com/p/communicative-language-teaching-clt.htm]
[13] Long, C., Ming, Z., & Chen, L. (2013). The study of student motivation on English learning
in junior middle school-A case study of no.5 Middle School in Gejiu. English Language
Teaching, 6(9), 136-143.
doi:10.5539/elt.v6n9p136
[14] Larsen-Freeman, D. (2000). Techniques and principles in language teaching. New York:
Oxford University Press
[16] Gardner, R. (1985). Social psychology and second language learning: The role of attitude
and motivation. London: Edward Arnold\
[17] Gardner. R., & W. Lambert. (1972). Attitudes and motivation in second language learning.
Rowley Mass: Newbury House.
[18] Begum, M., & Farooqui, S. (2008). School Based Assessment: Will It Really Change the
Education Scenario in Bangladesh? International Education Studies, 1, 45-53.
https://doi.org/10.5539/ies.v1n2p45
[19] Billah, M. (2015). Language and Education Inside and Beyond the Classroom, Murdhonno,
Dhaka, Bangladesh.