Professional Documents
Culture Documents
3.2.2.1 The Photoelectric Effect 4 4576
3.2.2.1 The Photoelectric Effect 4 4576
3.2.2.1 The Photoelectric Effect 4 4576
Date: ________________________
Comments:
An excited hydrogen atom can emit photons of certain discrete frequencies. Three possible
transitions are shown in the diagram.
(a) The transitions shown in the diagram result in photons being emitted in the ultraviolet,
visible and infrared regions of the electromagnetic spectrum.
(1)
Explain why, for a particular transition, the photon must have an exact amount of energy
whereas the free electron only needs a minimum amount of kinetic energy.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(c) The surface of a sample of caesium is exposed to photons emitted in each of the three
transitions shown in the diagram.
Determine whether any of these transitions would produce photons that would cause
electrons to be emitted from the surface of caesium.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
The graph shows how the maximum kinetic energy Ek of photoelectrons emitted from a metal
2.
surface varies with the reciprocal of the wavelength λ of the incident radiation.
A c
B h
C hc
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
When light of a certain frequency greater than the threshold frequency of a metal is directed at
4. the metal, photoelectrons are emitted from the surface.
The power of the light incident on the metal surface is doubled.
Which row shows the effect on the maximum kinetic energy and the number of photoelectrons
emitted per second?
D doubles doubles
(Total 1 mark)
Which graph shows the results for a metal Y that has a higher work function than X?
(Total 1 mark)
A Increases Unchanged
B Decreases Increases
C Increases Decreases
D Decreases Unchanged
(Total 1 mark)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Deduce whether light of this wavelength can cause the photoelectric effect when incident
on the potassium surface.
(4)
(c) The photoelectric effect provides evidence for light possessing particle properties.
State and explain one piece of evidence that suggests that light also possesses wave
properties.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 8 marks)
hf = ϕ + Ek,
where h is the Planck constant and f is the frequency of the incident radiation.
___________________________________________________________________
Ek _________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) In a typical experiment to investigate the photoelectric effect, Ek was measured for photons
of different wavelengths, λ ,and the values in the table were obtained.
(i) By rearranging the photoelectric equation, show that a graph of Ek (y-axis) plotted
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(ii) Use the above data to plot this graph on the grid provided and use your graph to
determine values for ϕ, in eV, and the Planck constant, h.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(c) Using the same axes, sketch the graph which you would expect to obtain if the experiment
were repeated with a metal having a larger value of ϕ.
(2)
(d) In a simple demonstration of the photoelectric effect, a metal plate is given a negative
charge and illuminated with, in turn,
The ultraviolet lamp causes the plate to lose charge but the laser has no effect. Explain
why this is so.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 15 marks)
In an experiment to demonstrate the photoelectric effect, a charged metal plate is illuminated with
9. light from different sources. The plate loses its charge when an ultraviolet light source is used but
not when a red light source is used.
(Total 1 mark)
(Total 1 mark)
(a) Explain why, when ultraviolet light is shone on a positively charged plate, no charge is lost
by the plate.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) Threshold frequency and work function are important ideas in the study of the photoelectric
effect.
Tables 1 and 2 summarise the work functions of three metals and photon energies of three
UV light sources.
Table 1
Zinc 4.3
Iron 4.5
Copper 4.7
Table 2
1 4.0
2 4.4
3 5.0
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(6)
(c) Calculate the maximum kinetic energy, in J, of the electrons emitted from a zinc plate when
illuminated with ultraviolet light.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
(Total 12 marks)
(Total 1 mark)
Monochromatic radiation from a source of light (source A) is shone on to a metallic surface and
13. electrons are emitted from the surface. When a second source (source B) is used no electrons
are emitted from the metallic surface. Which property of the radiation from source A must be
greater than that from source B?
A amplitude
B frequency
C intensity
D wavelength
(Total 1 mark)
In a photoelectric experiment, light is incident on the metal surface of a photocell. Increasing the
14. intensity of the illumination at the surface leads to an increase in the
A work function
(Total 1 mark)
Figure 1
Explain why there is a current only if the frequency of the electromagnetic radiation is
above a certain value.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(b) State and explain the effect on the current when the intensity of the electromagnetic
radiation is increased.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
Figure 2
The photoemissive surface has a work function of 2.1 eV. The frequency of the
electromagnetic radiation the student uses is 7.23 × 1014 Hz.
Calculate the maximum kinetic energy, in J, of the electrons emitted from the
photoemissive surface.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 12 marks)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(ii) Show that the work function of the metal is approximately 4 × 10−19 J.
(3)
wavelength ____________________ m
(3)
(Total 8 marks)
Sodium metal has a work function of 2.28 eV. An atom of sodium has an ionisation energy of
17. 5.15 eV.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) Show that the minimum frequency of electromagnetic radiation needed for a photon to
ionise an atom of sodium is about 1.2 × 1015 Hz.
(2)
Calculate the maximum possible kinetic energy of an electron that is emitted when a
photon of this radiation is incident on the surface.
Give your answer to an appropriate number of significant figures.
(d) Calculate the speed of an electron that has the same de Broglie wavelength as the
electromagnetic radiation in part (b).
When ultraviolet light of frequency 3.0 × 1015 Hz is incident on the surface of a metal,electrons of
18.
maximum kinetic energy 1.7 × 10–18 J are emitted.
(a) Explain why the emitted electrons have a range of kinetic energies up to a maximum value.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(3)
(ii) Calculate the threshold frequency of the metal. Give your answer to an appropriate
number of significant figures.
threshold frequency____________________Hz
(3)
(c) (i) State and explain the effect on the emitted electrons of decreasing the frequency of
the incident radiation whilst keeping the intensity constant.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(ii) State and explain the effect on the emitted electrons of doubling the intensity of the
incident radiation whilst keeping the frequency constant.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 13 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(a) When monochromatic light is shone on a clean cadmium surface, electrons with a range of
20.
kinetic energies up to a maximum of 3.51 × 10–20 J are released. The work function of
cadmium is 4.07 eV.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(ii) Explain why the emitted electrons have a range of kinetic energies up to a maximum
value.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(4)
Archbishop Beck Catholic Sports College Page 22 of 73
(iii) Calculate the frequency of the light. Give your answer to an appropriate number of
significant figures.
answer = ____________________ Hz
(4)
(b) In order to explain the photoelectric effect the wave model of electromagnetic radiation was
replaced by the photon model. Explain what must happen in order for an existing scientific
theory to be modified or replaced with a new theory.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 12 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 8 marks)
When a clean metal surface in a vacuum is irradiated with ultraviolet radiation of a certain
22. frequency, electrons are emitted from the metal.
(a) (i) Explain why the kinetic energy of the emitted electrons has a maximum value.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(ii) Explain with reference to the work function why, if the frequency of the radiation is
below a certain value, electrons are not emitted.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
______________________________________________________________
(1)
(b) Light energy is incident on each square millimetre of the surface at a rate of
3.0 × 10–10 J s–1. The frequency of the light is 1.5 × 1015 Hz.
answer = ______________________ J
(2)
(ii) Calculate the number of photons incident per second on each square millimetre of the
metal surface.
answer = ______________________
(2)
(c) In the wave theory model of light, electrons on the surface of a metal absorb energy from a
small area of the surface.
(i) The light striking the surface delivers energy to this small area at a rate of
3.0 × 10–22 J s–1.
The minimum energy required to liberate the electron is 6.8 × 10–19 J.
Calculate the minimum time it would take an electron to absorb this amount of
energy.
answer = ______________________ s
(1)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 12 marks)
(a) When illuminated with electromagnetic waves, a metal surface can exhibit the photoelectric
23. effect. The maximum wavelength that causes the emission of photoelectrons with zero
kinetic energy is 6.8 × 10–7 m.
(i) Show that the threshold frequency for the surface is approximately 4.4 × 1014 Hz.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(ii) Show that the work function for the surface is approximately 2.9 × 10–19 J.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(b) Explain why the photoelectric effect cannot be explained by the wave theory of light.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(Total 8 marks)
When monochromatic light is shone on a clean metal surface, electrons are emitted from the
24. surface due to the photoelectric effect.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) The wave model was once an accepted explanation for the nature of light. It was rejected
when validated evidence was used to support a particle model of the nature of light.
Explain what is meant by validated evidence.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
answer ____________________
(3)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
answer ____________________ J
(3)
(Total 12 marks)
When light of a certain frequency is shone on a particular metal surface, electrons are emitted
25. with a range of kinetic energies.
(a) Explain
• in terms of photons why electrons are released from the metal surface, and
• why the kinetic energy of the emitted electrons varies upto a maximum value.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(6)
(i) On the graph mark the threshold frequency and label it f0.
(1)
(ii) On the graph draw a line for a metal which has a higher threshold frequency.
(2)
______________________________________________________________
(1)
(c) The threshold frequency of a particular metal surface is 5.6 × 1014 Hz. Calculate the
maximum kinetic energy of emitted electrons if the frequency of the light striking the metal
surface is double the threshold frequency.
answer = ____________________ J
(3)
(Total 13 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) A clear sheet of glass, placed between the radiation sources and the zinc plate, absorbs
some of the radiation.
______________________________________________________________
(1)
(ii) Explain why this effect stops the gold leaf from falling further.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(1)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(1)
(d) Calculate the maximum speed of electrons emitted when radiation of wavelength 320 nm is
shone onto a caesium plate.
(i) Calculate the longest wavelength of electromagnetic radiation that will cause photoelectric
27. emission at a clean lithium surface.
work function for lithium φ = 4.6 × 10–19 J
The apparatus shown in the figure below can be used to demonstrate the photoelectric effect.
28. Photoelectrons are emitted from the metal cathode when it is illuminated with white light which
has passed through a blue filter.
You may be awarded additional marks to those shown in brackets for the quality of written
communication in your answers to parts (a) and (b).
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(b) Explain why no photoelectrons are emitted when the blue filter is replaced by a red filter.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(c) When a metal of work function 2.30 × 10–19 J is illuminated with ultraviolet radiation of
wavelength 200 nm, photoelectrons are emitted.
Calculate
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(5)
(Total 11 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) In an experiment on the photoelectric effect, the maximum kinetic energy of the emitted
photoelectrons is measured over a range of incident light frequencies. The results obtained
are shown in the figure below.
(i) A metal of work function Φ is illuminated with light of frequency f. Write down the
equation giving the maximum kinetic energy, EK, of the photoelectrons emitted in
terms of Φ and f.
EK =
(ii) Use the data in the figure to determine the work function of the metal.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(iii) Determine the maximum kinetic energy of the photoelectrons when the frequency of
the incident radiation is 2.5 × 1015 Hz.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(6)
(c) The experiment is repeated but with the light incident on a metal of lower work function.
Draw a new line on the figure that results from this change.
(2)
(Total 10 marks)
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(2)
(b) A metal plate is illuminated with electromagnetic radiation of wavelength 190 nm.
The metal has a work function of 7.9 × 10–19 J.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(ii) Show that the metal plate will emit photoelectrons when illuminated with radiation of
this wavelength.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
You may be awarded marks for the quality of written communication in your answer.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(6)
(Total 8 marks)
(a) Calculate the work function of X, given that each photon in the incident radiation has
3.2 × 10–19 J of energy.
The maximum kinetic energy possessed by a single photoelectron is 2.1 × 10–19 J.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(b) The source of the incident radiation is replaced with a new source. The wavelength of the
radiation from the new source is half the wavelength of the original radiation.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
(Total 6 marks)
Explain
(i) why the maximum kinetic energy of the emitted electrons does not change,
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(3)
(b) A potassium metal plate is illuminated with incident light of wavelength 5.10 × 10–7 m. The
work function of potassium is 3.58 × 10–19 J.
(i) Show that the frequency of the incident light is approximately 6 × 1014 Hz.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
caesium 3.04
silver 7.57
sodium 3.94
tungsten 7.33
Which of these metals would emit electrons when illuminated with light of wavelength
5.10 × 10–7 m?
______________________________________________________________
(7)
(Total 10 marks)
(a) When monochromatic light is incident on a metal plate, electrons are emitted only when the
33. frequency of the light exceeds a certain threshold frequency. Explain, in terms of energy,
why this threshold frequency exists.
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(3)
Calculate
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(7)
(Total 10 marks)
(a) (i) State what is meant by the wave-particle duality of electromagnetic radiation.
34.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(ii) Which aspect of the dual nature of electromagnetic radiation is demonstrated by the
photoelectric effect?
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(2)
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(ii) The radiation is maintained at the same frequency but the intensity is doubled. State
what changes, if any, occur to the number of electrons released per second and to
the maximum kinetic energy of these electrons.
(iii) The metal plate is replaced by another metal plate of different material. When
illuminated by radiation of the same frequency no electrons are liberated. Explain
why this happens and what can be deduced about the work function of the new
metal.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(8)
(Total 10 marks)
Name the following terms and explain their significance in this equation.
Φ _________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________
(5)
(b) In the photoelectric apparatus shown, the incident ultraviolet radiation has a wavelength of
220 nm and the current is 2.0 μA.
(i) Give the value of the current when the intensity of the incident radiation is doubled
whilst keeping the wavelength constant.
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(ii) The wave length of the incident radiation is now increased and at 350 nm the current
falls to zero. Calculate the threshold frequency and Φ.
______________________________________________________________
Φ ____________________________________________________________
______________________________________________________________
(5)
(Total 10 marks)
(b) EITHER
energy needed for electron to move to higher level/orbital ✔
OR
for a transition/excitation/change of levels an exact amount of energy is needed ✔
all the photon’s energy absorbed( in 1 to 1 interaction) ✔
electron can transfer part of its energy (to cause a transition/excitation)/ continues moving/
lower kinetic energy/ lower speed ✔
Any implication of photoelectric effect max 1
Accept one energy level to another
1
1
1
C
2.
[1]
3rd box
3.
(Electrons produe dark rings in diffraction experiments) ✔
[1]
C
4.
[1]
A
5.
[1]
C
6.
[1]
(a) Photons of light incident on the metal surface cause the emission of electrons ✔
7.
The electrons emitted are those near the surface of the metal✔
2
5.2 × 10−19J✔
OR
interference patterns (light and dark fringes) using two slits or diffraction grating✔
(b) (i) Ek = hf – ϕ
f= ∴ Ek = hc – ϕ (1)
cf y = mx + c (1)
(ii)
[alternative (d)
ultraviolet [red light] photon energy is high [low] (1)
above [below] work function (1)]
(2)
[15]
D
9.
[1]
10. D
[1]
(a) The process involves the ejection of electrons which are negatively charged. ✓
11. 1
Any electrons ejected will only make the positive charge greater. ✓
1
(d) The work function is the minimum amount of energy needed to remove the electron
from the zinc surface ✓
Alternative
Reference to max ke corresponding to emission of surface
electrons whilst electrons from deeper in the metal will be emitted
with smaller ke
1
[12]
D
12.
[1]
B
13.
[1]
C
14.
[1]
f= ✓= 1.24 × 1015(Hz)
λ= = 2.42 × 10-7✓
B1
2
C1
Condone minus sign here on energy or
charge
Use of hf = ȹ0
C1
A1
3
[5]
B1
1
C1
C1
A1
3
M1
A1
2
B1
B1
2
[8]
A1
2
(ii) Φ = hf
C1
A1
2
C1
A1
2
B1
B1
2
[8]
because there are now more photons striking the metal surface
(per second) (1)
4
(b) (i)
B1
2
B1
B1
2
B1
1
C1
C1
C1
C1
4
[9]
(ii) (1)
(7.645 × 10–19(J))
(allow C.E for value of f from (i))
5
[11]
(a) (i) the energy of a photon does not depend on the intensity (1)
32. so electron gains no extra energy
[or the energy is dependent on the wavelength / frequency] (1)
(ii) the intensity of the light determines the number of photons per second (1)
one photon interacts with one electron
[or hence more interactions with electrons] (1)
3
(a) the energy of each photon/the light increases with frequency (1)
33. electrons need a minimum amount of energy to leave the metal (1)
this amount of energy is equal to the work function (1)
3
(iii) (all) electrons have insufficient energy to leave the (new) metal (1)
the work function of the (new) metal is greater than hf
[or the work function of the (new) metal is greater than
that of the original metal] (1)
The Quality of Written Communication marks were awarded primarily for the
quality of answers to this part.
(8)
[10]
(Φ = hf0 gives) Φ = 6.6(3) × 10–34 × 8.57 × 1014 (allow e.c.f. for f0)
(a) This objective question was correctly answered by the majority of students (66%).
(b) This question produced very good discrimination. Many students were able to explain
satisfactorily that an exact amount of energy was needed to excite an electron to a higher
energy level. Linking this to why the photon needed an exact amount of energy, whereas
the free electron only needed a minimum, was more challenging. The idea that all the
photon’s energy was absorbed was better understood than the reason why the incident
electron only needed a minimum energy. It was common to see answers that made correct
statements but then went on to include a discussion of the photoelectric effect. Nearly 40%
of students gained no credit.
(c) This question was well done with nearly half the students scoring full marks.
(d) Performance in this multi-step calculation was disappointing, with over half the students
failing to score any marks. The photoelectric equation did seem well known but substitution
was a real issue for many. Students had to extract data from different sources and this
clearly caused them problems. A common error was a failure to convert the photon energy
to joule.
Most students (67.8%) were able to relate this gradient to the hc.
2.
Students should be reminded to make it clear which answer they have chosen, and to avoid
3. putting marks in more than one box. It was very accessible, with over 70% obtaining the mark.
The most frequently selected distractor was B, accounting for 30% of the responses. It would
4. benefit students to emphasise that the maximum kinetic energy depends only on the frequency
of the incident radiation and the work function of the metal surface. Increasing the power, without
changing the frequency, will only increase the number of photons incident on the surface every
second, and will not increase the energy each photon carries. It would have had to have been
clearly stated that the frequency had been doubled as a means of doubling the power for
distractor B to have been the answer.
This question was little more than recall of the features of the graph of maximum kinetic energy
5. against frequency of incident radiation. Over 60% of students correctly selected the correct
answer.
Many candidates found part (a) to be straightforward and did it well. Those candidates who failed
8.
usually omitted the words ‘minimum’ and ‘maximum’. A few candidates thought that Ek was the
maximum energy of a photon.
In general, part (b)(i) was answered well, but several candidates failed because they omitted the
speed of light from the relationship between frequency and wavelength. Most candidates
calculated the 1 / λ values correctly in part (b)(ii), but some (including those who used dot
notation to indicate recurring figures) lost a mark for incorrect use of significant figures. Other
incorrect notations included × 10–3 and × 10–3. Graphs were usually plotted reasonably
Answers given to this question on the photoelectric effect provided evidence of the tendency of
15. some students to not present full arguments when applying physics principles. In part (a) most
students identified that electrons needed to leave the surface but the linking of this to the
frequency of the radiation was quite vague. Responses that failed to mention photons were
common and many did not emphasise the importance of the work function. It was not unusual to
see discussions that confused the photoelectric effect with the excitation and ionisation of
electrons in individual atoms. It was a similar story in (b) where the majority of students realised
that the current would increase but then failed to explain why in terms of the increased number of
photons striking the metal surface per second. The calculation in part (c) was generally well done
with nearly three-quarters of students scoring full marks. Surprisingly, far fewer were then able to
use their correct answer from (c) to calculate the stopping potential in (d). Part (e) was another
example of incomplete arguments. The majority did appreciate that the stopping potential would
increase but were unable to give complete explanations for this effect. Better responses did link
this increase to maximum kinetic energy but it was very rare to see answers explaining that this
was due to greater energy transfer by photons.
(a) (i) Most appreciated that the work function was the energy to remove an electron. Fewer
16. went on to explain that work function was the minimum energy required and that it
refers to electrons at the surface.
(ii) This was generally well done with a high proportion of correct answers. Incorrect read
offs from the graph and incorrect powers of 10 were the main causes of failure to
complete this part successfully.
(b) Fewer students used the approach of calculating the energy in J, converting to eV and then
reading from the graph than the second approach in the marking scheme. Those who used
either approach often lost marks due to mixing up energies in J and eV and/or having
problems handling powers of 10.
This question on quantum phenomena linked the photoelectric effect with ionisation, two topics
17. which often cause confusion to students. The first parts of the question required students to
explain work function and ionization energy. Good explanations were commonly seen but there is
still the tendency for students to link work function to electrons escaping from individual atoms.
The remainder of the questions were quantitative and the majority of the calculations involved
proved to be accessible. The conversion of electron volts to joules was widely understood and a
high proportion of students were able to show that the frequency of radiation required for
ionisation was about 1.2 × 1015 Hz. The calculation of the maximum kinetic energy of the
electrons emitted had a similar high facility. In this calculation however, students were required to
quote their answer to an appropriate number of significant figure. This did present a problem to
some as although three significant figures are warranted from the data, if they used 1.2 × 1015 Hz
rather than their calculated value, only two should be quoted.
The final calculation of the de Broglie wavelength presented much more of a challenge and only
the more able students were able to do this correctly. Weaker students attempted to use the
equation for kinetic energy or to use the frequency of the photon instead of calculating the
wavelength.
Part (a) was not well answered and only about 5% of candidates scored full marks. In a
significant proportion of scripts confusion with excitation was apparent and this restricted
candidates to the first mark. Another common error was to assume that the photons had a range
of energies and this led to a range of kinetic energies.
Part (b) was more quantitative in nature and as has been the case in the past, candidates
performed better with a much higher proportion of candidates scoring full marks.
Part (c) was less well done and only the more able candidates were able to explain convincingly
the effects of decreasing frequency and increasing intensity on electron emission. It was
common to see answers which discussed threshold frequency rather than giving more general
answers which covered the reduction in frequency above this limit.
(a) Performance of candidates in this question exemplifies performance across the paper as a
19. whole.
The better candidates were able to produce a well-structured definition of the meaning of
the work function. Others had a limited recall of the definition often omitting that it was the
minimum energy or that it was a surface phenomenon.
Of those who did make a start most achieved at least one mark. The most common error
here was a failure to realise that 2.8eV had to be converted into joules. Correct answers
were well-laid out with little to no spurious calculations seen.
Students have found questions on the photoelectric effect quite challenging in previous series. In
20. view of this it was pleasing to see more confident answers this time around. The explanation of
work function and the calculation were well answered by a significant proportion of students.
Explanations of the range of kinetic energies were less sound and as has been the case in the
past there was frequent confusion between the photoelectric effect and excitation of electrons
from discrete energy levels. The idea of validated evidence which was required in part (b), seems
now to be well understood.
Many candidates were unable to answer part (a) with sufficient detail. Often these candidates did
21. not include that this is a surface phenomenon and were penalised.
The calculation in part (b) (i) was performed well with most candidates achieving full credit. The
most common error made by those who attempted the calculation was an incorrect conversion of
the wavelength for nm to m.
In part (b) (ii), many candidates were unable to correctly convert 2.3 eV into joules or made no
attempt to convert the work function but then compared 5.2(3) × 10–19 J with 2.3 eV.
Part (c) was answered poorly, with many candidates stating that there were no electrons left or
that the photoelectric effect can only occur when the emitting surface is negative. Very few
candidates were able to explain the lack of photoelectrons from an energy perspective.
Parts (b) and (c) proved much more accessible and candidates used the various relevant
equations confidently. Full marks for calculations were quite common. Part (c) (ii), which
assessed How Science Works, did confuse some candidates. When this happened, candidates
tended to explain the significance of validated evidence in general terms, rather than how it was
used to develop the particle model of light.
Many candidates found the calculations in part (a) to be accessible. However, candidates should
23. be aware that simply getting the correct answer in not sufficient when they have been asked to
‘show that’. In these cases they must be clear with their selection of equations, manipulation,
substitution and in dealing with powers of ten. They should also quote their answer to a greater
degree of provision than number mentioned in the question in order to demonstrate that they
have performed the calculation completely. There were a surprising number of candidates that
did not attempt this part of the question.
Answers to part (b) were poor. It seems that candidates were familiar with the effect but they
were not able to articulate the logic of why it demonstrates that light, in this case, is not acting as
a wave.
Part (a) was answered reasonably well and candidates seemed to appreciate the effects of
24. changing the frequency and changing the intensity of the incident light. In the legacy
specification, this topic has often confused candidates and it was pleasing to see many confident
responses. A minority of less able candidates did confuse the meaning of frequency, taking it to
mean the rate of photon arrival rather than the frequency of individual photons.
Part (b) (iv) assessed How Science Works and candidates answered this question well,
demonstrating that the idea of validated evidence is well understood.
The calculation in part (c) was, for the most part, done well and identifying the unit for the work
function did not really cause many problems. The only common error occurred in part (c) (ii)
when the maximum kinetic energy was calculated by equating it to the photon energy and
ignoring the work function in spite of the fact that this had been successfully calculated in part (c)
(i).
This question assessed quality of written communication and it was clear that most candidates
appreciated that their answers needed a logical structure. However, few candidates were able to
give a coherent and comprehensive answer.
Part (b) generated better answers although a significant minority of candidates did not appreciate
the fact that the gradient of the maximum kinetic energy against frequency graph is the Planck
constant.
Part (c) proved more difficult than expected and a number of candidates calculated the energy of
the photon using the threshold frequency and failed to calculate the work function.
The question was well answered by a good number of candidates. Few however, explained
26. clearly that the energy of the uv photons exceeded the work function of the zinc plate ejecting
one electron per photon. Several candidates suggested that the leaf and stem would end up
being positively charged which would mean that the leaf fell. A number of candidates appeared
to believe that photons carry charge.
In part (b) (i), most candidates realised that it was the ultraviolet radiation being absorbed. Along
with more common incorrect responses of ‘visible’, ‘photons’ or ‘electromagnetic’, a small
minority of candidates suggested that it was alpha, beta or gamma radiation that was absorbed
by the glass.
There were many good answers to part (b) (ii) which explained that the visible light photons had
insufficient energy to overcome the metal’s work function. Other answers indicated that the
candidates may have understood the mechanism but did not explain it in sufficient detail to
convince the examiners of their understanding: typically candidates giving this type of answer
said little more than that it was ultraviolet which was causing the photoelectric effect.
Few candidates gave answers which demonstrated that they fully understood the concepts in
part (c). Many felt that although the plate was positively charged the leaf was negatively charged,
others that the positive charge meant that there was an excess of protons rather than a deficit of
electrons. A common belief was that all the electrons had been emitted in causing the plate to
become positively charged thus there were no electrons available for emission.
Part (d) was either well answered very, with candidates getting all the way through to the final
answer, or else very poorly answered, with hardly any attempt made to use the photoelectric
equation. Too often final answers were quoted to an unrealistic number of significant figures but,
in this instance, there were no mark penalties applied for this.
Part (b) produced better marks. The change in the frequency or wavelength was known to most
candidates and about 50% of them referred to the work function or threshold frequency. Less
able candidates just wrote about the wavelength being different, which was not acceptable.
Overall, candidates did not seem to be as knowledgeable in distinguishing between the effects of
intensity and frequency of the source as in previous examinations. Part (c) caused a few
problems for less able candidates because they were often confused between f0 and/
In defining work function in part (a), most candidates wrote about the energy required to eject an
29. electron from a metal, rather than referring to a minimum energy requirement.
More than 50% of the candidates tackled part (b) in a sensible way and chose the correct
frequency to use in each part. There was, however, plenty of scope for errors in powers of 10,
significant figures and units. Many candidates failed to realise that the threshold frequency was
0.5 × 1015 Hz from the graph. There were also a significant number of candidates who could not
attempt these calculations. In part (c), about 50% of the candidates drew the graph with
confidence, while the remainder simply made a guess.
Less able candidates gave the answer to part (a) as simply as ‘kinetic energy’. They obviously
30. had not responded to the two available marks. Apart from this it was quite common to see only
one mark being awarded because candidates would omit referring to it as the maximum kinetic
energy or as the kinetic energy of the emitted electrons. Some candidates even referred to
‘energy needed’, which showed a misunderstanding of the given equation.
Parts (b) (i) and (ii) proved difficult for the weaker candidates. Several tried to use the
photoelectric equation to determine the frequency and consequently became very confused. The
majority of candidates, however, knew how to tackle this question and showed that the kinetic
energy of the electron was positive. A minority of candidates took the alternative approach and
showed the incident frequency was greater than the threshold frequency. The explanation
required in part (b) (iii) used to be the type of question that produced wrong answers from the
majority of candidates, because very often they could not distinguish between the role of the
incident electromagnetic frequency and the role of the incident intensity. It is pleasing to report
that in this examination it was only the weaker candidates who showed this uncertainty. This was
one of the reasons for assuming that the present cohort of candidates were slightly better than
average.
Part (a) caused problems for a significant number of candidates. It was common to find the
31. frequency of the incident radiation being calculated and then the value substituted back into the
photoelectric equation in order to calculate the energy. The unit of work function was often
incorrect, resulting in a lost mark.
Part (b) discriminated very well, even in the top ability range. For those candidates who failed on
this part, some of the more common errors were: taking the energy to be proportional to the
wavelength, doubling the value of the work function instead of doubling the incident energy of
each photon and basing the energy of the photon on the photoelectron energy.
The calculations in part (b) were generally well done and caused problems only for the weaker
candidates. Many candidates however, in parts (b)(ii) and (b)(iii), used the approximate value for
the frequency, given in part (b)(i), rather than the more accurate calculated value. This incurred a
penalty. There was also considerable incorrect use of significant figures at this point. Although
the calculations were generally correct the interpretation of the data obtained, which was
necessary for (b)(iv), was not of the same standard.
Traditionally, calculations connected with the photoelectric effect perform better than written
33. descriptions of the effect. Describing the event proved to be a skill not acquired by many of the
present candidates. There appeared to be a general lack of basic understanding of the
photoelectric effect which could not be attributed simply to a lack of communication skills. In part
(a) most candidates elected to repeat the information given in the question by continually
referring to the frequency of the photon rather than discussing the energy of the photon. It was
also clear that at least half the candidates could not distinguish between the process of emission
of an electron from a metal surface and ionisation of an atom.
The calculations in part (b) were, on the whole, performed well but some of the problems which
appeared were omitting the units in part (i) and weaker candidates wrongly converting J to eV in
part (iv) through multiplying rather than dividing by the charge e. There were a number of
significant figure errors in this part of the question.
Overall, the candidates had a sound understanding of the photoelectric effect and there was a
34. good response to part (a). The most common error was for candidates to refer to the
wave-particle duality of electrons rather than of electromagnetic radiation.
The calculation in part (b)(i) was carried out correctly by most candidates but a large number of
answers were presented without units. Good candidates had no difficulty with part (ii) but many
simply stated that “the number of electrons released per second increases”, rather than “the
number doubles”. Answers to part (iii) indicated that candidates seemed to have a much better
understanding of the photoelectric effect than those who sat the examination in January.
Pleasingly few candidates referred to electrons in shells, ionisation or the electronic bond with a
single atom. The weaker candidates often lost marks because they expressed ideas in an
unclear fashion, for example, “the work function needs to be higher in the new metal” was a
statement commonly seen.
Many candidates produced good, precise answers to part (a). However, a basic error was in
35. thinking that the photoelectron was removed from the atom rather than it being a free electron
near the surface of the metal. Part (b)(1) was the only section that was not answered well by the
majority of candidates. An answer of 2.0 μA for the current appeared as frequently as the correct
answer of 4.0 μA. The explanations offered were either vague and of the form ‘it is obvious they
are proportional’ or else were very confused in mixing up the properties of intensity and
frequency. Units were sometimes omitted in the answers to part (b)(ii).