Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 s2.0 S0146280622000482 Main
1 s2.0 S0146280622000482 Main
1 s2.0 S0146280622000482 Main
TagedEnConflict of Interest: The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal
relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper. This is an open access
article under the CC BY-NC-ND license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/)
Curr Probl Cardiol 2023;48:101151
0146-2806/$ see front matter
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpcardiol.2022.101151
&
F
amilial hypercholesterolemia (FH) is an autosomal dominant
hereditary disorder that is increasingly emerging as a global public
health concern.1 Based on dominant genetic characteristics, FH
are classified into homozygous familial hypercholesterolemia (HoFH) and
heterozygous hypercholesterolemia (HeFH). In the Lebanese FH family,
Khachadurian was the first description of the heritability of FH in 1964.2
The global incidence of FH is about 1 of 250 of the general population,
with roughly 14-34 million people having FH.3 FH is characterized by a
significant increase in plasma low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-C)
at birth.3 Clinically associated with elevated cholesterol levels, gluten-like
xanthoma, and a family history of premature coronary artery disease
(CAD), the phenotype of HoFH is much more severe than that of HeFH.4
TagedPFH is a single-gene disease that is mainly caused by low density lipo-
protein cholesterol receptor (LDLR) or apolipoprotein B (Apo B) gene
function loss mutations or proprotein convertase subtilisin/kexin-9
(PCSK9) gene function gain mutations.5 Less common causes include
gene variants encoding apolipoprotein E (Apo E) and signal transduction
adapter family member 1 (STAP1).6 LDLR is mainly localized in liver
cells, the main sites for LDL metabolism. Over 95% of FH cases are
attributed to mutations in the LDLR gene. The Apo B molecule is synthe-
sized in hepatocytes and secreted in very low-density lipoprotein
(VLDL). After the transformation of VLDL into LDL, it plays a role as
an LDLR ligand. The binding of Apo B to LDLR leads to intracellular
internalization and lysosomal degradation of LDL particles.7 Similarly,
the mutation encoded by the Apo B gene reduces LDL clearance, result-
ing in family defective apolipoprotein B-100.8 PCSK9 is a member of the
mammalian serine preprotein invertase family. It is responsible for the
proteolytic maturation of secreted proteins, including neuropeptides, hor-
mones, cytokines, growth factors, receptors, serum, and cell surface pro-
teins.9 PCSK9 can bind and degrade LDL receptors, reducing LDL
receptor clearance on serum low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-
C).10 The under diagnosis of FH in the general population is an emerging
concern. Only 1% of potentially FH patients have been detected.11 There-
fore, correct identification of the causes of dyslipidemia is very important
to inform patient management.12 For many FH patients, the primary clini-
cal manifestation is acute coronary syndrome (ACS).13 Cascade screen-
ing (family testing based on relatives of affected individuals) has
improved FH diagnosis.14 Through reverse cascade screening of children
and their parents during immunization visits, early diagnosis of young
TagedH1MethodsTagedEn
TagedH2Data CollectionTagedEn
The following search terms were used to retrieve literature from WoSCC:
Topic = (“Familial Hypercholesterolemia” OR “familial hyperlipidemia” OR
“familial dyslipidemias”). The search period was between January 1, 2011
and September 26, 2021. There were no restrictions on language or docu-
ment type. A total of 1 617 records, comprising 11 types of documents were
obtained. Notably, 834 original research papers accounted for 51.74% of
total records (Table 1). Review papers ranked second (333 reviews),
accounting for 20.47% of the total records. The other 8 document types
were conference abstracts (313 articles), editorial materials (103 articles), let-
ters (25 articles), book chapters (7 articles), online publications (6 articles),
TagedH2Data AnalysisTagedEn
The Microsoft Office Excel 2019, VOSviewer (v.1.6.17), and CiteSpace
(v.5.8.R2) were used to analyze all 1 617 documents. Because of its out-
standing feature of strong graphic abilities and suitability in processing
large-scale data, VOSviewer (a bibliometric software) was used to construct
relational networks and for data visualization.29 CiteSpace (a web-based
Java application) is a document visualization analysis software gradually
developed for bibliometrics analyses and data visualization. CiteSpace was
used to visually display the basic knowledge and hotspots of the FH research
field and to predict its evolutionary paths as well as research frontiers.30
Microsoft Office Excel 2019 was used to analyze temporal distributions and
to identify highly cited FH-associated studies in the past 10 years. VOS-
viewer was used to draw visual knowledge maps for distributions of: coun-
try/regions, authors, and research institutions, as well as disciplines.
CiteSpace was to evaluate the research hotspots and frontiers.
TagedH1ResultsTagedEn
FIG 1. Trends in the growth of publications and the number of cited articles worldwide from
2010 to 2021 (Color version of figure is available online).TagedEn
TagedH2Country/Region DistributionTagedEn
As shown in Table 2, the largest number of published literatures were
from England, USA, and Australia, respectively accounting for 20.27%,
19.35%, and 11.06% of the total reports. The total number of studies
from the 3 countries accounted for more than half of the total reports,
implying that the 3 countries have a high interest in research in the FH
field. Studies from Canada (96.86), Germany (86.67), and the Nether-
lands (79.04) had the highest average citations per item (ACI), indicating
that the 3 countries started research on FH earlier, and their results are rel-
atively mature.
TagedPThe VOSviewer parameters were set as: Method (Linlog/modularity),
minimum number of documents of a country: 5. The obtained results
were from 81 countries, with 48 meeting the thresholds. Based on co-
occurrence analysis, VOSviewer classifies countries into different clus-
ters and colors them according to the time course in which they appear,
Rank Country Region Quantity Proportion/% ACI H-index Total link strength
1 England Western Europe 328 20.27 32.99 43 492
2 USA North America 313 19.35 52.59 56 444
3 Australia Oceania 179 11.06 38.24 32 293
4 Italy Southern Europe 138 8.53 59.21 34 231
5 Netherlands Western Europe 138 8.53 79.04 44 348
6 Spain Southern Europe 121 7.48 66.99 32 282
7 Greece Southeast Europe 85 5.25 37.36 16 97
8 China East Asia 83 5.13 15.05 17 98
9 Germany Central Europe 81 5.01 86.67 24 228
10 Canada North America 78 4.82 96.86 37 179
ACI average citations per item; Here includes the automatically calculated total link strength by VOSviewer.
Curr Probl Cardiol, July 2023
TagedEn TagedFiur
TagedEnCurr Probl Cardiol, July 2023
appeared. The bluer the color, the earlier the institution appeared, and the
redder the color, the later the institution appeared. As shown in
Figure 3B, the University of Western Australia, Curtin University, Fiona
Stanley Hospital, University of Melbourne, University of Sydney, Royal
Perth Hospital, and Royal Prince Alfred Hospital closely collaborated.
University of Amsterdam, McGill University, University of Palermo,
University of Pennsylvania, Sapienza University of Rome, University of
S~ao Paulo, University of Witwatersrand, Western University, Amgen Inc,
University of Cape Town, University of Helsinki and Imperial College
London, Polytechnic University of Milan closely collaborated. Oslo Uni-
versity Hospital, Universidade de Lisboa, University of Oslo, University
of Zaragoza, Hospital Clinic Barcelona, Fundacion Hypercholesterolemia
Familiar, and Hospital Universitario Miguel Servet closely collaborated.
University College London, University of Oxford, Cardiff University,
University of Teknol MARA, Imperial College London, University of
Manchester, and University of Nottingham closely collaborated.TagedEn
FIG 3. VOSviewer visualization map of authors and institutions in the studies of FH. (A) Cooperation map of authors. (B) Cooperation map of institutions
(Color version of figure is available online.)TagedEn
Curr Probl Cardiol, July 2023
TagedEnTABLE 4. Top 10 institutions in the studies of FH
TABLE 7. (continued)
FIG 4. Analysis of references. (A) References co-citation network. (B) Top 20 References with the Strongest Citation Bursts (Color version of figure is available
online.)TagedEn
Curr Probl Cardiol, July 2023
TagedEnCurr Probl Cardiol, July 2023
TABLE 8. (continued)
Rank Keywords Occurrences Total link strength Rank Keywords Occurrences Total link strength
1 Familial hypercholesterolemia 680 3 732 11 Prevalence 103 656
2 Cardiovascular disease 588 6 371 12 PCSK9 97 677
3 Hyperlipidemia 334 1 859 13 Children 97 603
4 Risk 243 1 531 14 LDL cholesterol 94 669
5 Cholesterol 209 1 234 15 Heterozygous familial hypercholesterolemia 93 705
6 Atherosclerosis 192 1 111 16 Efficacy 90 706
7 Density-lipoprotein cholesterol 163 1 166 17 Double-blind 90 698
8 Diagnosis 150 975 18 Stain therapy 90 683
9 Low-density-lipoprotein 120 662 19 Guidelines 77 581
10 Management 118 822 20 Monoclonal antibody 76 600
Here includes the automatically calculated total link strength by VOSviewer.
21
TagedEn TagedFiur
TagedEn22
Curr Probl Cardiol, July 2023
FIG 5. Map of keyword clustering in the studies of FH (Color version of figure is available online.)TagedEn
TagedEn TagedFiur
FIG 6. Top 15 keywords with the strongest citation bursts (Color version of figure is available online.)TagedEn
TagedH1DiscussionTagedEn
TagedH2General InformationTagedEn
Given the number of FH publications, research on FH is at a stable
stage. The number of publications in 2016 was the largest, and this could
TagedPNew Lipid-lowering DrugsTagedEn. The blue cluster mainly involves new lipid-
lowering drugs. Three new lipid-lowering drugs, including microsomal
TagedH2LimitationsTagedEn
This study has some limitations. First, the analysis of this study is
based on articles from the WoSCC database, which is the most well-
known database of scientific publications on many research topics, how-
ever, other databases such as PubMed, Scopus may provide a broader
coverage. Second, CiteSpace and VOSviewer cannot completely replace
system retrieval. For instance, the obtained documents are from 2011 to
2021. However, with continuous updating of WoSCC documents, the
number of obtained studies are different from the actual number of docu-
ments, and citations as well as h-index will accordingly change. Third,
we included all literatures on FH in the WoSCC database, however, due
to differences in quality among the studies, credibility of the analysis
may be low. Visual analysis based on literatures lays a foundation for
understanding the research topics, research hotspots and development
trends in in the field of FH.
TagedH1SummaryTagedEn
The manuscript summarizes the latest progress, hotspots as well as
frontiers, future research development trends and references in this field.
TagedH1Authors ContributionTagedEn
Namin Wei and Guoxiu Liu designed the study. Siyu Li, Guozhen
Yuan, and Xintian Shou collected the data. Xuesong Zhang re-examined
the data. Namin Wei, Guoxiu Liu, and Jingjing Shi analyzed the data.
Namin Wei wrote the manuscript. Yuanhui Hu and Huaqiang Zhai
reviewed and revised the manuscript. All authors contributed to the arti-
cle, approved the submitted version, and agree to be held responsible for
all aspects of the work.
TagedH1FundingTagedEn
The manuscript did not receive any specific grant from funding agen-
cies in the public, commercial, or not-for-profit sectors.
TagedH1AcknowledgmentsTagedEn
The authors acknowledge Home for Researchers editorial team (www.
home-for researchers.com) for language editing service.
Yuanhui Hu, MD, doctoral tutor, has been engaged in basic and clinical research of cardiovascular
diseases in Guang’anmen Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences for more than
30 years.
Guoxiu Liu is a PhD student at Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, her main research direction
is Chinese Medical Standardization.
Siyu Li is a PhD student at Beijing University of Chinese Medicine, her main research direction is
Chinese Medical Standardization.
Guozhen Yuan is PhD student in Guang’anmen Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Scien-
ces, her main research direction is the basic and clinical research of cardiovascular diseases.
Xintian Shou is a PhD student in Guang’anmen Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Scien-
ces, his main research direction is the basic and clinical research of cardiovascular diseases.
Xuesong Zhang is a PhD student in Guang’anmen Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical
Sciences, her main research direction is the basic and clinical research of cardiovascular diseases.
Jingjing Shi, MD, works in Guang’anmen Hospital, China Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences,
mainly engaged in basic and clinical research of cardiovascular for 8 years.
Huaqiang Zhai, MD, doctoral tutor, works in Beijing University of Chinese Medicine for more than
20 years. His main research direction is the prevention and treatment of respiratory diseases with Chi-
nese medicine, and is very interested in the basic and clinical research of cardiovascular diseases.