Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2013 Dochangesinspheno EJPD
2013 Dochangesinspheno EJPD
net/publication/236226447
CITATIONS READS
16 545
4 authors, including:
Alessandro Ugolini
Università degli Studi di Genova
68 PUBLICATIONS 1,162 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by Armando Silvestrini-Biavati on 15 November 2014.
Do changes in Introduction
spheno-occipital Rapid maxillary expansion (RME) is indicated in
the treatment of maxillary transverse deficiency and
synchondrosis after unilateral or bilateral crossbite. RME is used in order to
widen the midpalatal suture and to correct maxillary
rapid maxillary and dental transverse discrepancies. The maxilla is
connected with several bones in the head through
expansion affect sutures: frontomaxillary, frontonasal, frontozygomatic,
nasomaxillary, zygomaticomaxillary, temporozygomatic,
the maxillomandibular pterygomaxillary, internasal. When orthopedic forces
are applied from RME activation to the maxillary basal
complex? bone, they may be transmitted on closed facial bones.
Therefore RME may affect structures directly or indirectly
related to the maxilla [Ballanti et al., 2010; Christie et al.,
2010; Sun et al., 2011; Martina et al., 2012; Farronato et
al., 2012]. Baydas et al. [2006], Cordasco et al. [2012],
abstract Leonardi et al. [2012] included the nasal cavity, the
pharyngeal structures, the temporomandibular joints and
Aim This was to evaluate changes in spheno-occipital the pterygoid process of the sphenoid bone; Leonardi et
synchondrosis one year after rapid maxillary expansion al. [2010], reported indirect effects of RME even on the
(RME), in order to assess the influence that any spheno-occipital synchondrosis. The effect of orthopedic
change might have on sagittal and vertical skeletal forces on the craniomaxillary sutures have been studied
cephalometric variables. [Ghoneima et al., 2011]: animal-based research found
Materials and methods Patients were selected histologic changes in suture tissue after orthopedic forces
consecutively and grouped into: Group 1 comprised were applied, such as stretching of sutural connective
30 Caucasian patients (13 m; 17 f) undergoing RME tissue fibers and new bone deposition along the
therapy; after active expansion therapy, the Haas stretched fibers. Not all studies agree about the suture
expander was worn as passive retainer for an average and bones involved during RME therapy. Gardner and
of 7 months. Group 2 as control included 14 untreated Kronman [1971] found changes in lambdoid, parietal,
subjects (6 m, 8 f), matched by age, sex and vertebral and midsagittal sutures in rhesus monkeys; Kudlick
skeletal maturity (CVM method, stages 1-3). Six [1973] postulated the involvement of all craniofacial
cephalometric variables concerning spheno-occipital bones adjacent to the maxilla, except the sphenoid
synchondrosis were studied: N-S-Ba°; SOS-Ba; SOS-S; bones. Wertz and Dreskin [1977] found that the maxilla
S-Ba; Ba-N; S-N; nine skeletal variables for sagittal and moved downward and forward during midpalatal suture
vertical evaluation were also checked. T-test was used opening; conversely, Timms [1980] showed that the
for comparing the 2 groups data. maxilla and palatine bones moved apart, along with the
Results A statistically-significant opening of the pterygoid processes of the sphenoid bone. Leonardi et
spheno-occipital synchondrosis and increase of the al. [2010] reported the opening of zygomaticomaxillary,
posterior cranial base length (Ba-SOS) were found frontomaxillary and internasal sutures.
between group 1 and 2. After 1 year, these modifications Suture changes after RME therapy have been
in spheno-occipital syncondrosis produced no change suggested to induce changes in the craniofacial complex
in the anteroposterior or vertical skeletal parameters growth. In particular, it has been hypothesised that the
examined. cranial base is a guide for the development of the maxilla,
midface, and lower facial complex, and its modification
could affect the maxillomandibular complex [Proff et al., after a minimum of 6 months of removable palatal plate
2008]. To asses this hypothesis, the effects of RME on wear (1.1±0.4 years, at T2). For all patients, crossbite was
the cranial base and the spheno-occipital synchondrosis corrected at the end of active expansion.
have been investigated [Iseri et al., 1998; Jafari et al., The control group (group 2) comprised 14 subjects (6
2003; Baydas et al., 2006; Holberg and Rudzki-Janson, m, 8 f; mean age 7.6±1.7 years, at T1) with untreated
2006; Rukkulchon and Wong, 2008; Cendekiawan et al., cross-bite, matched by age, sex and skeletal maturity.
2008; Leonardi et al.,2010]. Some of these studies have Control subjects presented Angle Class I (n=8) or Class
hypothesised that opening of the synchondrosis could II, division 1 (n=6) malocclusions and transverse maxillary
account for the forward and downward displacement deficiency with posterior unilateral crossbite; they had
of the maxilla. Some studies report a downward and postponed orthodontic treatment for economic reasons.
forward movement of the maxilla when the midpalatal
suture opens, due to displacement of the maxillocranial Cephalometric analysis
sutures [Garib et al., 2005]. Some of these studies are Cephalograms were traced digitally, by a single
limited to short-term evaluation; some lack control examiner, using Ceph Basic v.1.0.4 software (Image
groups, and others are based on animal or experimental Instruments GmbH, Chemnitz Germany). Landmark
models, such as finite element analyses. location and accuracy of the anatomic outlines was
The aim of this controlled study is to evaluate changes verified by a second senior clinician (ASB). Cephalometric
in cranial base features one year after RPE therapy, in points selected are showed in figures 1 and 2. Six cranial
order to assess the influence such changes may have on base measurements [N-S-Ba°; SOS-Ba(mm); SOS-S(mm);
sagittal and vertical skeletal cephalometric variables. S-Ba(mm), S-N(mm) and Ba-N(mm)] and eight skeletal
variables (SNA°; SNB°, AFH/PFH(mm), Jarabak’s Sum S°,
S-N/Go-Me°, N-S-Ar°, S-Go(mm) and Ar-Go-Me°) were
Materials and methods determined. To analyse method error, five randomly-
selected lateral cephalometric radiographs were digitally
Subjects were treated from 2008 to 2011 at the retraced. A combined error of landmark location, tracing,
Department of Orthodontics, Faculty of Dentistry, Genoa and measurement was determined. Intraclass correlation
University; they were selected consecutively, according coefficients (ICC) were used to determine intra- and
to skeletal maturity as evaluated by means of the CVM inter-rater agreement for each cephalometric variable.
method [Baccetti et al., 2006]. All subjects presented Correlation coefficients for the skeletal measures were
cervical vertebral stages 1-3 (CVS 1–3) evaluated on greater than 0.95. Linear measurement errors averaged
lateral cephalograms, at T1. Exclusion criteria were: 0.4 mm (SD 0.6 mm), and angular measurement errors
previous orthodontic treatment, hypodontia in any averaged 0.5° (SD 0.5°).
quadrant (excluding third molars), hormonal imbalance,
temporomandibular joint symptoms, craniofacial Statistical analysis
abnormalities, arthritis, inadequate radiographs (poor Descriptive statistics were calculated for each variable.
quality at the cranial base area or unknown magnification The Shapiro-Wilks test demonstrated the normal
factor). distribution of data, thus parametric statistics could be
Thirty patients matched with inclusion criteria (13 m, 17 applied. Patients’ data were compared with data from
f; mean age 8.0±1.5 years, at T1). Subjects’ characteristics the control group using parametric t-tests. Probabilities
were: Class I or Class II division 1 malocclusion (18 and 12 of <0.05 were accepted as significant in all statistical
patients, respectively) with transverse maxillary deficiency analyses. The power of the study was adequate (>0.83),
and posterior unilateral crossbite at treatment onset (T1). calculated a priori using the mean values and standard
The records available included dental casts, panoramic deviations of N-S-Ba° reported by Maestripieri et al.
radiographs and lateral cephalometric head films at pre- [(2002] at an alpha of 0.05.
treatment stage (T1) and one year after the end of active
expansion (T2). The study group (group 1) underwent
tooth-tissue supported (Haas type) RME, expanded by Results
2 turns a day (0.20 mm per turn). When the desired
overcorrection for each patient had been achieved, the There were no significant differences between the two
appliance was stabilised. Expansion was considered groups regarding age and skeletal maturity. No significant
adequate when the occlusal aspect of the maxillary differences in any of the variables used in the study were
lingual cusp of maxillary first molars contacted the found between genders, thus data concerning the two
occlusal aspect of the facial cusp of the mandibular lower genders were pooled for analysis. Baseline (T1) and follow-
first molars. The Haas expander remained on the teeth up (T2) cephalometric measurements are summarised in
as passive retainer for an average of 7 (SD ±2) months, Table 1. During the treatment period (T1 to T2), study and
after which a removable palatal plate, with Adams clasp control groups showed significant changes in all cranial
on the first maxillary molars, was worn full-time. T2 was base variables, except for N-S-Ba (°) and BA-SOS (mm)
RME group were similar in value to those of the control modifications. It is widely reported that, immediately after
group, throughout the study period (Table 1) and that they expansion, there is a downward maxillary displacement
did not show any significant correlation with cranial base and an extrusion of the supporting teeth, leading to