Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Dokumen - Tips LDD PT Olam
Dokumen - Tips LDD PT Olam
DILIGENCE
REPORT
PT DHARMAPALA USAHA
SUKSES [*]
(2015[Issuing Year])
(1)
Company Formation.................................................................................13
(2)
Replacement or Appointment of Board Members; Share Transfers; and
Amendment of Articles..............................................................................13
(3) Company Officers.....................................................................................14
(4) Articles of Association...............................................................................15
2.2 PT Olam Indonesia[*]..........................................................................................15
i
ii
CONFIDENTIAL
[*], 2015
Dear Sirs,
This legal due diligence report ("Report") has been prepared at the request of PT
Dharmapala Usaha Sukses Indonesia [*] (“ OAMDUS[*]”) in relation to the proposed
acquisition of PT [*] (“[*][*]”).
2.1 Budiarto Law Partnership has been instructed by PT DUS[*] to conduct the following
legal due diligence investigations:
(2) Licensing, to confirm that PT DUS[*] hold all required material licenses from
the government and those licenses are valid;
(3) Assets, Liabilities and Labors, to confirm the nature and validity of the
Assets, Labors and Liabilities owned by the PT DUS[*]; and
2.2 The documents which were obtained by us during the course of our legal due diligence
investigations are listed in Attachment 1: List of Documents Received to this Report.
2.3 This Report is based on information obtained prior to – JuneFebruary 115, 20153.
2.4 This Report is based on the laws of the Republic of Indonesia as of the date of the
Report.
3.3 Assumptions
1
3.1 This Report has been prepared based on the following assumptions:
(1) that where we have been provided with copies of documents, that copy is an
exact and complete reproduction of, and conforms with, the original of the
document and the original of the document still exists;
(3) that all signatories, dates of and any stamp duty or other marking on all
documents provided to us (whether copies or originals) are authentic;
(4) that where a document was provided to us in draft form, it was executed or will
be executed in the form of that draft;
(5) except as specifically stated in this Report, all documents provided to us are
within the capacity and power of, and have been or will be validly authorized,
executed and delivered by party, and constitute valid and binding obligations of
party under all applicable laws;
(6) except as specifically stated in this Report, each document provided to us,
which is a contract or agreement, is enforceable in accordance with its terms;
(8) all material information and documentation has been provided to us and is true
and complete and not misleading in any way.
3.2 This Report is based on the laws of the Republic of Indonesia. Any opinions expressed
with respect to matters which may be subject to or governed by the law of any other
jurisdiction should be verified and confirmed by lawyers competent to advice in those
jurisdictions.
This Report is exclusively addressed to PT DUS[*], and may not be disclosed to any party
outside of PT DUSOLAM[*], without the prior written consent of Budiarto Law Partnership.
Sincerely yours,
BUDIARTO LAW PARTNERSHIP
WIDJOJO BUDIARTO
NIA 92.10155
2
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This Report, which summarizes the results of our legal due diligence review in relation to the
Project, should be read in full. However, we believe that the matters set out in this Executive
Summary may be of particular concern or interest to the addressee.
NO SUMMARY ISSUE/ANALYSIS
CORPORATE
1. Deed No. 32No. 54, was made on July The date of Deed of Establishment
19, 1996May 11, 1994 (“Deed of stated on Minister of Justice approval
Establishment”), before Ny. is different from the original deed.
Rukmasanti Hardjasatya S.H., Linda Note:
Ibrahim, S.H., then a Notary in Central re not provided with the documents
Jakarta. evidencing the announcement of
Deed of Establishment in the State
the Deed of Establishment has been Gazette and documents evidencing
approved by the MOLHR Minister of the registration of the Deed of
Justice on NovemberJuly 297, 19968 Establishment in the Company
pursuant to Decree No.C2- Registrar maintained by Company
10.700HT.01.01.Th.96No. C2-9686 Registrar Office.We wetration with
HT.01.01.TH.98, and also been company registrar and the ed of
registered with the Company Registrar Establishmene. -
on June 12, 1997, with registration No.
8112/BH.09.05/VI/97January 31, 2001,
with registration No. 095/BH
09.01/5/2001.
Note:
Note:
5. The authorized and paid-up capital of We were not provided with any
PT OLAM[*] pursuant to Deed No. documents evidencing payment of
32/200317/2006. capital contribution from Olam
International LtdWardono Asnim and
There is an enlargement of authorized Sunny G VergheseTjong Nelly
capital from Rp 1,628,900,000.- Permatasari, in respect of the
Rp250,000,000.- to Rp 2,559,700,000.- increase of authorized and paid up
Rp40,000,000,000.- and paid-up capital of PT OLAM[*] pursuant to
capital from Rp 1,628,900,000.- Deed No. 32/200317/2006.
Rp100,000,000.- to Rp
2,559,700,000.-.Rp10,000,000,000.-
LICENSING
5
30, 2007 valid until October 30,
2008;
6
on April 30, 2009 valid until
January 15, 2013;
3. PT DUS [*] holds several Tax File We were not provided with Taxpayer
Number (Nomor Pokok Wajib Pajak or Registration (Surat Keterangan
“NPWP”) and relating documents as Terdaftar or “SKT”)-
follows:
7
[*] folows :
8
Taxation on June 24, 2011; is
registered as Taxable
Entrepreneur on February 20,
2012.
9
371/B.3/A.9/2008 issued by
Investment Coordinating Board
(BKPM) dated August 19, 2008
10
Trade dated April 28, 2004;
11
(r) Recommendation Letter for Raw
Sugar Importer Producer No.
27/IAK/IV/2005 issued by
Directorate General of Chemical
and Agro Industry dated April 25,
2005
12
(bb) Acknowledgement of Importer
Producer for Raw Sugar No.
32/DAGLU/IP/1/2007 dated
January 11, 2007;
13
04.IP-04.14.0004 dated March 10,
2014
14
Temporary Coffee Exporter (Eksportir
Kopi Sementara or “EKS”) No.
44/DAGLU/EKS/8/ 2013 dated 1 August
2013 issued by Directorate General of
Foreign Trade;
15
8. [*] holds Fishery Business License The address of [*] stated in the IUP is
(Surat Izin Usaha Perikanan or “IUP”) inconsistent with its address in the
No. 01.02.01.0198.0897, issued on Letter of Domicile. Pursuant to the
January 19, 2012 in the name of PT Letter of Domicile, the current
Karya Cipta Buana Sentosa. domicile of [*] is at Jl. Cilincing Raya
11 RT. 012 RW. 002, Kel. Lagoa,
Kec. Koja, Jakarta Utara.
(a)
PT OLAM holds business licenses of
foreign investment as follows:
1. SIPI No.
523.37/48/KPPTSP/2012,
dated March 05, 2012, issued
by One Stop Licenses
Application Service Office of
Nusa Tenggara Timur Province
(Kantor Pelayanan Perizinan
Satu Pintu Provinsi Nusa
Tenggara Timur or “KPPTSP”);
2.
3. erading Bucense
No.RDAGANGA/ated 6ary
16;BKPM Approval No.
16
583/T/PERDAGANGAN/1999
on Permanent Business
License and Business
Expansion dated 22 October
1999 valid until April 2029;
10. Fish Transporter Vessel License (Surat We were not provided with any SIKPI
Izin Kapal Pengangkut Ikan or “SIKPI”). license of [*].
15. Licenses of [*]’DUS branch and/or We were not provided with any
representative’s office. regular licenses which are required by
governing laws and regulations for [*]
to set up a branch and/or
[*DUS Branch Office ] holds Nuisance representative’s office in Maumere
Permit (Surat Izin Gangguan) No: Cilacap such as SKDP Cabang,
KPPT.503.c/55/PB/11/2011 issued by Laporan Pembukaan Cabang, TDP
One Stop Licenses Application Service Cabang, and NPWP Cabang.
Office of Sikka Regency on February
21, 2011 503/011/I/27/2004 issued by
Cilacap Local Government dated
January 27, 2004
18
; and
AGREEMENT
ASSETS
Our search on this section is based on Other than stated on this section, we
the List of Assets in Maumere [*] were not provided with any more
provided by [*] to us. documents evidencing the ownership
of moveable assets of [*] in Maumere.
Based on the List, [*] owns several
assets such as Office Buildings, We were also not provided with list of
Dormitories, Warehouse, Vessels, Cars, assets in Jakarta and Larantuka.
Machineries, Office Stationaries, and
other moveable assets, with the details
as elaborated below:
LIABILITIES
LABORS
LITIGATION
Impending Litigation. -
20
1. DEFINITIONS
Unless otherwise defined, all and any words or terms used in this Report shall have the
following meanings:
Deed No. 127/1996 Deed of Amendment of Article of Association No. 127 made
on September 23, 1996, as defined in page 27
Deed No. 338/2008 Deed of Amendment of Article of Association No. 338 made
on August 22, 2008, as defined in page Error: Reference
source not found
[*]
Law No. 03/1982 means Law No. 03 Year 1982 concerning Company
21
Registration Obligation
Law No. 13/2003 means Law No. 13 Year 2003 concerning Employment
Law No. 32/2009 means Law No. 32 Year 2009 concerning Environment
Protection and Management
NPWP Cabang means Nomor Pokok Wajib Pajak Cabang or Branch’s Tax
File Number as defined in page Error: Reference source not
found
SPPT PBB means Notification on Tax Due of Land and Building Tax
(Surat Pemberitahuan Pajak Terhutang Pajak Bumi dan
Bangunan)
22
TDP Cabang means Tanda Daftar Perusahaan Cabang or Certificate of
Branch’s Company Registration as required in Article 11
paragraph (1) point (d) Law No. 3 of 1982 regarding
Company Registration (Wajib Daftar Perusahaan)
23
2. CORPORATE STRUCTURE
PT DUS is n Indonesian Foreign Capital Investment Company (PMA) and all of the
shares in its share capital are held and owned by foreign legal entity and Indonesia
legal entities [or Indonesian individual].
[*] is an Indonesian limited company and all of the shares in its share capital
are held and owned by Indonesia legal entities.
A company obtained its status as legal person under the Company Law
once its deed of incorporation is approved by the MOLHR.
24
All actions done by its founders on behalf of a company prior to its
establishment shall bind the Company upon the Company obtaining its
legal person status if such actions are accepted or taken over by the first
General Meeting of Shareholders (the “GMOS”). The GMOS must be
convened within 60 days after the company obtaining its legal person
status, attended by all shareholders of [*]. The resolution passed in this
GMOS has to be voted for by all shareholders of [*]. Failing this, the
founders who entered into the contract shall be personally, jointly and
severally liable for the performed actions and all their consequences.
In the case of share transfers, the transferor and transferee will sign Deeds
of Transfer (Akta Pemindahan Hak) either under hand or before a Notary.
The Company Law, following the Dutch Civil Law tradition, adopts a two-
tier management structure, comprising:
25
(i) Direksi and common law executive directors; and
A company must have at least one director and one commissioner. In the
event there is more than one director, one of the directors may be
appointed as President Director, who generally has the authority to bind a
company under agreements with third parties. In the event there is more
than one commissioner, one of the commissioners can be appointed as
President Commissioner.
(i) the shareholders approve the change to the members of the Board
of Directors and/or Board of Commissioners, with such
shareholders' resolution being restated in a Notarial deed form;
(ii) the change to the members of the Board of Directors and/or the
Board of Commissioners is reported to MOLHR; and
(iii) the change to the members of the Board of Directors and/or the
Board of Commissioners is reported to DT. Indonesian companies
are not required to maintain a Register of Directors or Register of
Commissioners. Rather, evidence of the current composition of the
Board of Directors and Board of Commissioners is in the form of
Shareholders' Resolutions appointing the directors and
commissioners of the company, which follow steps (i) to (iii) above.
2.2 PT DUS[*]
(a) Background
26
a) Tthe Deed of Establishment has been approved by
the Minister of Justice (“MOJ”)OLHR on November
29, 1996[*] pursuant to Decree No. C2-
10.700.HT.01.01.Th.96No. [*];
b) Note:
c)
d) The approval of this Deed of Establishment was
given together with the approval of Deed No. [*].
e)
f) Tthe Deed of Establishment has also been
registered with the Company Registrar on June
12, 1997[*], with registration No. 095/BH
09.01/5/20018112/BH.09.05/VI/97;
g)
h) The Deed of Establishment had later been
announced in the State Gazette No. 104;
Supplement of State Gazette No. 7645 dated
December 29, 1998.State Gazette No. [*];
Supplement of State Gazette No. [*] dated [*].
Note:
- [the approval of shareholders to accept the resignation of [*] and [*] from [*],
therefore [*] shall be managed by [*] and [*]];
Note:
Note:
28
The announcement of Deed No. 3/1999[was
stated togehe State Gazette No. 74, Supplement
of State Gazette No. 5727 dated September 14,
1999.
Note:
29
the announcement of Deed No. [*] was stated together with the Deed of Establishment in
the State Gazette No. [*], Supplement of State Gazette No.[*] dated [*].
g) Deed of Minutes of Extraordinary General Meetings of Shareholders No. 23 ("Deed
No. 23/1999"), made on June 25, 1999, before Ny. Rukmasanti Hardjasatya S.H., then a
Notary in Central Jakarta, concerning:
- The approval of the amendment of the article of association of PT OLAM in
accordance with the change of composition of Board of Directors of PT OLAM.
Deed No. 23/1999 has been approved by MOJ No. [*] on [*] and [*] had been registered
with the Company Registrar on [*], with registration No. [*];
the announcement of Deed No. [*] was stated together with the Deed of Establishment in
the State Gazette No. [*], Supplement of State Gazette No.[*] dated [*].
h) Deed of Minutes of Extraordinary General Meetings of Shareholders No. 12 ("Deed
No. 12/1999"), made on November 12, 1999, before Ny. Rukmasanti Hardjasatya S.H.,
then a Notary in Central Jakarta, concerning:
- The approval regarding the change of composition of Board of Directors of PT
OLAM.
-
Note:
the announcement of Deed No. [*] was stated together with the Deed of Establishment in
the State Gazette No. [*], Supplement of State Gazette No.[*] dated [*].
i) Deed of Minutes of Extraordinary General Meetings of Shareholders No. 26 ("Deed
No. 26/2000"), made on April 27, 2000, before Ny. Rukmasanti Hardjasatya S.H., then a
Notary in Central Jakarta, concerning:
- The approval regarding the change of composition of Board of Directors of PT
OLAM.
-
Note:
the announcement of Deed No. [*] was stated together with the Deed of Establishment in
the State Gazette No. [*], Supplement of State Gazette No.[*] dated [*].
Note:
30
We were not provided with the documents
evidencing the announcement of Deed No.
12/2001 in the State Gazette and documents
evidencing the registration of the Deed No.
12/2001 in the Company Registrar maintained by
Company Registrar Office.
k) Deed of Minutes of Extraordinary General Meetings of Shareholders No. 23 ("Deed
No. 23/1999"), made on June 25, 1999, before Ny. Rukmasanti Hardjasatya S.H., then a
Notary in Central Jakarta, concerning:
- The approval of the amendment of the article of association of PT OLAM in
accordance with the change of composition of Board of Directors of PT OLAM.
Deed No. 23/1999 has been approved by MOJ No. [*] on [*] and [*] had been registered
with the Company Registrar on [*], with registration No. [*];
the announcement of Deed No. [*] was stated together with the Deed of Establishment in
the State Gazette No. [*], Supplement of State Gazette No.[*] dated [*].
the announcement of Deed No. 29/1996 was stated together with the Deed of
Establishment in the State Gazette No. 104; Supplement of State Gazette No. 7645 dated
December 29, 1998.
Note:
We were not provided with the
announcementMOLHR approval of Deed No.
29/1996 21/2008was stated together with the
Deed of Establishment in the State Gazette No.
104; Supplement of State Gazette No. 7645 dated
December 29, 1998.
Note:
33
The main features of PT OLAM[*] as set out in the documents
referred to in section 2.2 (1) above may be summarized as follows.
(iii) Shareholders
Sunny G 65 1,512,550.- 1
Verghese
Amount
Shareholders Shares %
(Rp)
Olam International 29,935 696,587,450.- 99.78
Ltd
Sunny G 65 1,512,550.- 0.22
Verghese
34
Shareholders Shares Amount (Rp) %
Olam 39,935 929,287,450.- 99.
International 84
Ltd
Sunny G 65 1,512,550.- 0.1
Verghese 6
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Appoint
ment
Position Name Effective
Date
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Note:
tmentEffe
ctive Date
tmentEffe
ctive Date
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Note:
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Note:
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
38
Anup Kumar
Commissioner Jagdish A Parihar March 14,
2001
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Note:
We were not provided with the Indonesian
language version of Deed No. 18/2003 as well as
notification from MOLHR regarding data change
thereof.
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Note:
We were not provided with the Indonesian
language version of Deed No. 17/2004 as well as
notification from MOJ regarding data change
thereof.
39
l) Pursuant to Deed of Statement of Shareholders
No. 1 ("Deed No. 1/2005"), made on November
14, 2005, before Ny. Rukmasanti Hardjasatya
S.H., then a Notary in Central Jakarta, the
composition of the Board of Directors and the
Board of Commissioners was as follows:
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
tmentEffe
ctive Date
41
q) Pursuant to Deed of Restatement of Meeting
Resolution No. 02 ("Deed No. 02/2010"), made on
June 3, 2010, before Ashoya Ratam, SH., MKn,
then a Notary in Bekasi, the composition of the
Board of Directors and the Board of
Commissioners was as follows:
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
Appointm
ent
Position Name Effective
Date
[Agricultural activities:
43
accessories, lubricants, fuel, water and ice.as importer and
main distributor, as well as undertake export trading
business of agricultural/plantation products, including
activities of drying, cleansing, selection, and classification
of the quality of agricultural products.
This Letter of Domicile was valid until January [*].has expired since
April 15, 2015 We wre not provided with a letter of dimicile of
OlamDUat has been extended.
44
Number (Nomor Pokok Wajib Pajak or “NPWP”). The details of PT
DUS[*]’s SKT and NPWP are as follows:
- Taxpayer Registration:
Type : [*]
Date of issue : September 30, 2003 [*]
Number : 02.062.239.5-073.000[*]
Issuing authority : Directorate General of Taxation of
Minister of Finance
45
The Company Law requires the Board of Directors to maintain a Register
of Shareholders (Daftar Pemegang Saham), setting out, amongst other
things:
(ii) the amount, number and date of acquisition of the shares owned
by the shareholders and, if more than one class of shares is
issued, each class of shares issued;
(iii) the name and the address of any individual or legal body which
holds rights under a pledge of the shares and the date of obtaining
such rights of pledge; and
(iv) information with respect to shares paid in a form other than cash.
(ii) whether any security has been granted over the shares.
Note:
Note:
(b) Must submit a report on its business activities to BKPM every six
months (Laporan Kegiatan Penanaman Modal or "LKPM").
47
Note:
Note:
We have reviewed copies of the following BKPM licenses and related approvals in
respect of PT DUS[*]:
Authority : BKPM
Number : 1145/1/IP/PMA/2014
Date of Issue : April 14, 20145
Content : Foreign Investment Principle License regarding Deed
16/2015[*] ofer of shares
Number : 285/1/IP-PL/PMA/2014
Content : Expansion of Foreign Investment Principle
License
49
In accordance with President Approval No. B-374/Pres/5/1996
dated 20 May 1996.
[*]
[*] holds the Distributor of Medical Equipment License with the following details:
Company : [*]
Address : [*]
Number : [*]
Issue date : [*].
Activities : [*]
Pursuant to article 13(1) PM.30/2012, IUP is valid as long as the company performs fishery
business activities.
[*]
[*]
Name : PT DUS
Date of issue : February 13, 2015
Number : 2.09.0971.04.00408
Expiry date : February 12, 2020
Issuing authority: Minister of Trade
Name : PT DUS
Date of issue : May 7, 2014
Number : 2.09.05.07.95704
Expiry date : May 6, 2019
Issuing authority: Minister of Trade
Name : PT DUS
Date of issue : October 11, 2012
Number : 01.011339
Issuing authority : Directorate General of Customs and
Excise, Minister of Finance
51
PT OLAM[*] holds other relevant licenses as follows:
(1) Background
In conformity with Law No. 32 Year 2009 (“Law No. 32/2009”) concerning
Environment Protection and Management and the new Government
Regulation No. 27 Year 2012 on Environmental License (“GR.27/2012”)
which is effective as of February 23, 2012, in performing its business
activities, [*] shall obtain Approval of Environmental Management Attempt
(Upaya Pengelolaan Lingkungan or “UKL”) and Environmental Supervision
Attempt (Upaya Pemantauan Lingkungan or “UPL”) and Environmental
License (Izin Lingkungan) at the project site approved by the local
authority. However, it is also stated in the GR 27/2012 that every
environmental document approved prior to the enactment of the regulation
remains valid and shall serve as Environmental License.
Note:
52
Under the provision of Article 109 of Law No. 32/2009, any person who
performs business activities without having an Environmental License,
shall be punished by 1 (one) year up to 3 (three) years custody and by a
fine with nominal value of Rp1, 000,000,000,- (one billion Rupiah) up to
Rp3,000,000,000,- (three billion Rupiah).
4. AGREEMENTS
[*]
1.1[5.1] Assets
(1) Land
(a) Background
53
A Right of Lease confers a right upon the lessee to utilize
the land owned by another party by paying compensation.
[*] has a Right to Build over a piece of land, with the following
details:
1.2[5.2] Labors
Note:
54
Branch Manager 1. Field Division 1.
2.
Human 1. 3.
Resources
4.
Finance 1. 5.
2.
3. Workshop 1.
Division
4. 2.
3.
Production Head 1. 4.
5.
Quality Control 1.
2. Cold Storage 1.
Division
3. 2.
4. 3.
4.
Processing 1.
2. Logistic and 1.
Legal
Division
3. 2.
4.
5. Compression 1.
Division
6. 2.
7. 3.
8. 4.
9. 5.
10.
11. Driver 1.
12. 2.
13. 3.
14. 4.
15. 5.
16. 6.
17. 7.
18.
19. Security 1.
20. 2.
21. 3.
22. 4.
23. 5.
24.
25. Canteen and 1.
Dormitory
(2) Licenses
Note:
55
We were not provided with any mandatory documents in employment such as
Manpower Report Obligation (Wajib Lapor Tenaga Kerja/WLTK), Provident Fund
Participation Certificate (Sertifikat Kepersertaan Jamsostek), and evidence of the
provident fund program payment (Bukti Pembayaran Jamsostek), Utlization Plan
of Foreign Eemployment (Rencana Penggunaan Tenaga Kerja Asing/RPTKA), and
Employing Permits of Foreign Workers (Izin Mempekerjakan Tenaga Kerja
Asing/IMTA)..
Sanctions:
Under the provision of Article 4 paragraph (1) and (2) jo. Article 17 Law No.
3 Year 1992 concerning Provident Fund Program, any negligence by a
person or a management of the company to participate all of his/her/its
employees to provident fund program, shall be punished by for not more
than 6 (six) months custody or by affine of not more than Rp50,000,000,-
(fifty million Rupiah).
Under the provision of Article 42 paragraph (1) of Law No. 13 Year 2003
concerning Labour, every employer who employs foreign worker (Tenaga
Kerja Asing or “TKA”) must have written permission from the Minister or a
designated official (IMTA). Furthermore according to Article 6 jo. Article 30
of Regulation of the Minister of Manpower and Transmigration No. 12 Year
2013 concerning Procedures for Use of Foreign Workers, approval of
RPTKA is required in order to obtain such license (IMTA). Any negligence
by a person or a management of the company to fulfill the IMTA obligation,
shall be punished by revocation/refusal of working permit of the foreign
workers thereof.
This Section is based upon inquiries made to: the District Court of North Jakarta,
the National Arbitration Council of Indonesia, the Industrial Relation Court of
Jakarta, the Administrative Court of Jakarta, the Commercial Court of Central
Jakarta, Tax Court, the District Court of Maumere, the District Court of Larantuka,
the Industrial Relation Court of Kupang, and the Administrative Court of Kupang,
which are the courts having jurisdictions over [*].
56
A. any civil or criminal proceedings in the District Court of [*] Jakarta since [*]
up to [*] pursuant to Statement Letter No. [*] issued by the Registrar of
District Court of [*] Jakarta on [*];
D. any tax proceedings in the Tax Court up to [*] pursuant to Statement Letter
No. [*] issued by the Tax Court Secretary on [*];
57
CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
1. Corporate Documents
2. Licensing
4. Labors
58
Attachment 1: List of Documents Received
60
Appendix 1: Statement Letters
61
62