Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Composites World October 2022
Composites World October 2022
interiors:
COMPOSITES
ENABLE MODERN
ARCHITECTURE
OCTOBER 2022
Thermoplastic composites
welding advances for
sustainable airframes / 50
Plant tour: AvCarb, Lowell,
Mass., U.S. / 62
3D knitted hybrid
thermoplastic structures / 76
A property of Gardner Business Media VOL 8 No 10
KNOWLEDGE IS POWER
AND WE HAVE THE DEMOS THAT CAN HELP YOU ATTAIN IT.
LIVE at Booth L23 during CAMX 2022 – It’s the Composites One
and Closed Mold Alliance Demo Zone.
At LIVE demos in a single enclosed space on the CAMX Show floor, you’ll learn
innovative processes to kickstart your business. Talk to dependable experts
adept at the latest technologies. And gain tips and techniques
that can help you attain the results you need.
Get the power of knowledge from Composites One - LIVE - at Booth L23
during CAMX 2022 in Anaheim, CA, October 17-20.
Because knowledge is power. Only from Composites One and the Closed Mold Alliance.
Innovative. Dependable. Results.
Presented LIVE by Composites One, the Closed Mold Alliance and our industry partners.
CompositesManufacturing
The Official Magazine of the American Composites Manufacturers Association
TABLE OF CONTENTS
COLUMNS FEATURES
4 From the Editor 16 CAMX 2022 preview
The largest composites industry trade show in
6 Troubleshooter North America takes place Oct. 17-20 in
Louis Dorworth of Abaris Training 16 Anaheim, Calif., U.S. CW previews many of the
Resources outlines key considerations to exhibits and technologies that will be on
make when fabricating quality composite display.
molds to minimize risk of leakage under By Grace Nehls, Chris Pasion,
pressure or vacuum.
Katie Leesemann and Hannah Mason
10 Gardner Business Index
The GBI: Composites Fabricating ended 42 Composites enable epic
August with all component indices
continuing to show slowed rates of growth. interior for Museum of the
Future
For this one-of-a-kind lobby, AFI pioneered
42 digital, reconfigurable molds to achieve
organic-shaped, multifunctional panels and
stairwell cladding.
» DEPARTMENTS By Ginger Gardiner
12 Trends
72 Applications 50 Thermoplastic composite
74 Marketplace
welding advances for more
74 Showcase
sustainable airfames
Multiple demonstrators help various welding
80 Post Cure technologies approach TRL 6 in the quest for
50 lighter weight, lower cost.
By Ginger Gardiner
62
CompositesWorld (ISSN 2376-5232) is published Valley Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45244-3029. accurate. In applying recommendations, however, you should exercise care and normal MEMBERSHIPS:
monthly and copyright © 2022 by Gardner Business If undeliverable, send Form 3579. precautions to prevent personal injury and damage to facilities or products. In no case
Media Inc. 6915 Valley Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45244- CANADA POST: Canada Returns to be can the authors or the publisher accept responsibility for personal injury or damages
3029. Telephone: (513) 527-8800. Printed in U.S.A. sent to IMEX Global Solutions, PO Box which may occur in working with methods and/or materials presented herein, nor can
Periodicals postage paid at Cincinnati, OH and 25542, London, ON N6C 6B2 Canada. the publisher assume responsibility for the validity of claims or performance of items
additional mailing offices. All rights reserved. Publications Mail Agreement #40612608. appearing in editorial presentations or advertisements in this publication. Contact
POSTMASTER: Send address changes The information presented in this edition information is provided to enable interested parties to conduct further inquiry into
to CompositesWorld Magazine, 6915 of CompositesWorld is believed to be specific products or services.
CompositesWorld.com 1
@CompositesWrld
HEADQUARTERS
6915 Valley Ave., Cincinnati, OH 45244-3029
Phone 513-527-8800 Fax 513-527-8801
gardnerweb.com
subscribe@compositesworld.com
From the highly complex to the everyday, we provide custom solutions that provide
consistency, dependability, and value, from aerospace applications to automotive,
construction, marine, sporting goods, wind energy, and more. And we do so in a safe,
sustainable fashion with a broad range of advanced water-based products. Whether
it’s a cleaner, primer, sealer, release agent, or an entire system, we can deliver a
solution fit for your specific application.
» You have probably heard by now that CAMX 2022 is coming technologies they will feature in their booths. We heard from
up this month, Oct. 17-20 in Anaheim, Calif., U.S. CAMX is North exhibitors this year — a record. Looking through these “previews,”
America’s largest conference and a trade show targeted toward the it’s clear there are many new products and technologies being intro-
composites manufacturing industry. It can be difficult sometimes duced at the show. You can find some of the previews in this issue of
to justify to yourself, and those to whom you report, that attending CW, starting on p. . Others can be found in the September issue.
a trade event has value sufficient to offset the time and capital All can be found online at www.compositesworld.com/hashtag/
commitment. If you’re camx. But it’s best if you just go to the show and see for yourself.
struggling to do that for • Education. If you’re new — or relatively new — to the compos-
I hereby offer 10 CAMX , I hereby offer ites industry, CAMX offers myriad opportunities to get to know it
compelling reasons to these compelling reasons better. I already mentioned the conference programming, and you
attend CAMX 2022. to attend the show. can add to that Composites One’s Demo Zone. The Demo Zone is
• In-person connections. If a large, glass-enclosed space on the show floor (booth L) where
COVID taught us anything, it’s Composites One and the Closed Mold Alliance demonstrate manu-
the importance of in-person interactions. There is real value in the facture of composite parts using a variety of materials, tools and
composites industry gathering in one place to learn, share ideas, processes, including infusion, resin transfer molding, silicone bag
collaborate, network and just plain socialize. If that’s not enough... molding and prepreg and autoclave processing. Expert tip: The
• Conference. CAMX is a trade show and conference. The demos attract large crowds and are great for socializing.
conference is multi-faceted, offering a variety of topics in a variety • Meet a CW editor. CW’s entire editorial staff will be at CAMX.
of environments. Your options include technical papers focused We are pretty decent folks who are always happy to talk composites.
on original research and education sessions focused on case histo- Stop by CW’s booth (D), say hello and take a selfie with us.
ries. You’ll also find speaker panels and featured sessions that • CAMX Show Daily. CW publishes the CAMX Show Daily, a good
emphasize many of the topics that are shaping the industry. You old-fashioned daily newspaper that will keep you up to speed on
might also check out “Good Day, CAMX,” on Wednesday morning, show happenings. You will likely have a Show Daily thrust into your
which features a panel on next-gen thermoplastic composite aero- hands as you enter the show. This is a thrilling experience.
structures. And don’t forget the keynote speaker, Michael Steep. • CW, the magazine. If you love the feeling of receiving CW each
He’s talking Tuesday morning about supply chain challenges and month via mail or email, it’s even better in person. We’ll have the
opportunities. Expert tip: The conference offers great opportuni- September and October issues available at our booth. Stop by and
ties to meet and interact with subject matter experts, and you can’t pick one up.
have too many subject matter experts in your life. • Steps. If, like the rest of the world, you are now counting your
• Awards. CAMX offers two awards programs — the CAMX steps each day, CAMX offers a great opportunity to stay on target. You
Awards and the Awards in Composites Excellence (ACE). The should hit , steps with a full-day, robust tour of the exhibit hall.
CAMX Awards, given in two categories, will be announced at • Disneyland. CAMX is, literally, next door to Disneyland. Every
the General Session on Tuesday morning. The ACE winners, amusement park is chock full of composites. Consider it research.
presented in six categories, will be announced Tuesday afternoon Safe travels and we’ll see you in Anaheim.
on the show floor. Expert tip: The award winners tend to soak up a
lot of attention, but be sure to visit the exhibit areas for each award
program on the show floor. There are always interesting technolo-
gies and products among the non-winners.
• New products/technologies. Every year, CW asks CAMX
exhibitors to send us information about the products and JEFF SLOAN — Editor-In- Chief
Why does my
composite mold leak
under vacuum or
applied pressure?
» The biggest complaint I get about composite versus metal
molds is that they tend to leak over time. This is especially
true when making low-temperature cure, high-temperature
service laminated tooling. Sometimes they leak immediately
when tested for first article compliance, causing the fabricator
to desperately try to seal the leaks and (temporarily) fix the
problem to save their own investment, or worse, deliver it on
time to an unsuspecting customer. Regardless, fixing leaks after
fabrication is undesirable, and over time scrapped parts and
repeated repairs can prove costly.
What can be done up front to ensure that molded composite
tools do not leak in service? To answer this question, we need to
understand what factors contribute to leaking tools in the first
place. The following are some important points to consider.
Tool design
Adding flanges with large radii around the periphery of the
tool can minimize the potential for edge impact damage
during fabrication, demolding and in service. The bonus to FIG. 1 CFRP mold
this approach is increased stiffness in the tool laminate itself, Both the permanent pattern and the layup mold in these images have flanges with
allowing for minimal support structure (Fig. 1). Consideration generous radii outside of the part area, providing increased stiffness to the laminate
and protection from edge impact. Source | Ascent Aerospace
for flanges and other molded features occur at the model or
pattern design, enabling layup of these features along with the
tool laminate.
Sealant tape on
primary mold
flange
FIG. 3 Molded index features vs. tooling pins FIG. 4 Multi-piece tooling concept
Molded index concept for locating the molded part to subsequent trim and/or drilling This illustration demonstrates the idea of placing multiple pieces of a tool into a par-
jigs or fixtures. Molded indexes can also be used for locating and secondary bonding ent mold so that vacuum/pressure integrity can be maintained. Source | Abaris
mating parts. Source | Abaris
carbon fiber or < gsm for glass fiber be used to minimize the Microfracture of the matrix resin
problem. Note: HS fabrics require more scrutiny of warp face If the matrix resin is damaged, it’s most likely to occur during
orientation to acquire true symmetry (Reference August the demolding process when wedges are used to remove the tool
article, “Doing the twist: A look at dimensional issues in high- from the model or pattern. This is especially true with the exposed
temperature cured laminates”). edge (pancake) tool design, where the laminate is in-plane with
Multiple debulks are recommended for best results. The first the wedging surface. The force from the local impact and flex of
ply should always be compacted so that it is tight to the model the laminate during the demolding process causes severe micro-
or pattern prior to the layup of subsequent plies. The number cracking in a fan-like pattern at each wedge location. Thermal
of plies between debulks depends on the mold configuration. cycling (expansion and contraction) exacerbates the condition as
The more complex the mold, the more debulks are required. the microfracture network continues to grow in resin-rich areas
A final overnight debulk is recommended prior to cure if time within the laminate, ultimately causing loss of vacuum/pressure
(and materials) allow, to draw off moisture, volatiles and provide integrity. Thus, having a flange with a generous radius at the
laminate compaction prior to cure. wedge line will stiffen the structure and minimize the chance
for fracture.
Initial low-temperature cure
Highly reactive, low-temperature curing resins allow for good Cutting or machining edges
dimensional control between a model (or pattern) and the tool It is highly recommended not to use a reciprocating saw (jig saw
laminate by minimizing the thermal expan- or Sawzall) or high-speed abrasive
sion factor during cure. Many prepreg tooling cutting wheel to trim the sharp edges
systems initially cure at ~65°C for a number Remember the motto of a tool laminate. A reciprocating saw
of hours. Depending on the system, where will microfracture the edges and the
“prework instead of rework”
the temperature is measured and the heat cutting wheel can overheat the matrix
when fabricating
transfer coefficient of the model, this resin, making it more prone to fracture.
may not be enough time or temperature composite tooling. It is suggested that the edge be laid up
to push the resin to maturity. It may as close to net shape as possible, followed
appear to be cured, but it is not fully by hand or belt sanding running parallel to
crosslinked. The vitrified resin at this stage is highly susceptible the edge, rather than trimming. Afterward, cover the edge with
to fracture when impacted or flexed. Increasing the soak time at a rubber edge protector to safeguard edges from damage and
the initial process temperature or raising the temperature (after employees from injury (Fig. 2).
the initial cure) to ~80°C for a couple of hours can help push the
crosslinks further towards maturity prior to demolding. After- Holes, pins, bushings and penetrations in a
wards, a full post-cure above the intended service temperature is tool laminate
recommended before proceeding. Ask any toolmaker who does tool maintenance and they will
CompositesWorld.com 7
THE TROUBLESHOOTER
tell you that over time, tooling holes, pins, bushings and other Multi-piece tools
penetrations into or through the tool laminate will begin to leak. Instead of splitting a tool into separate pieces with a split-line to
When used cycle after cycle, stresses on pin locations, bushings accommodate negative draft configurations, consider designing
and metal vacuum plumbing/hardware locations all develop the mold with pieces that are inserted into a “parent” tool for
microcracking in the adjacent matrix resin that will eventually maintaining vacuum/pressure integrity across the split-line
link up with the microfracture (leak) network. It may be best to (Fig. 4, p. 7).
use molded features in the mold to provide indexing of the part
for subsequent tools used in trimming and drilling operations From hindsight to foresight
(Fig. 3, p. 7). There are many more good ideas for reducing or eliminating leaks
in a composite mold. For example, in the
1980s, I was part of a team that used a
Viton interleaf layer1 in the tool laminate
design to mitigate leaks in prepreg auto-
clave-cured tools. The Viton layer works
well at eliminating leaks but requires
extra consideration in the laminate design
to reduce thermal expansion effects. The
point is that with a little knowledge and
Options available:
• Wisconsin Oven Premium • Vacuum pump & ports • Pressure transducers
control system • Thermocouple jack panels • Motorized controlled
• DataSense™ Technologies • Digital programmable controller dampers
Industrial IoT System for • Process timer • Insulated floor
predictive maintenance to • Disconnect switch • Many other options
reduce unplanned downtime • Chart recorders/data acquisition available upon request
Louis Dorworth is the direct
services manager at Abaris
Training Resources Inc. (Reno,
Wisconsin Oven Corporation Nev., U.S.). Lou has been involved
WISOVEN.COM 2675 Main Street • PO Box 873 • East Troy, WI 53120 in the composites industry since
1978 and has experience in material and process
sales@wisoven.com Wisconsin Oven is a brand of (M&P) engineering, research and development
Thermal Product Solutions, LLC
262-642-3938 (R&D), tooling, manufacturing engineering, teaching
and troubleshooting. Lou is a coauthor of the
textbook titled “Essentials of Advanced Composite
Fabrication and Damage Repair,” second edition.
See us at Booth W2
www.thermwood.com
800-533-6901
GARDNER BUSINESS INDEX: COMPOSITES FABRICATING
PRESENTED BY
For decades, our highly toughened prepreg system has • In stock and ready to ship
been the material of choice for aerospace companies
seeking to manufacture lighter and stronger structures. • Flexible cure profiles for
efficient production systems
These prepreg materials are designed to meet primary
structure performance requirements, withstand • Uniform resin content and
demanding operating conditions, and enable no-bleed resin system
consistent part production. The robust performance of
our materials, coupled with publicly available design
data and digital design tools, helps customers achieve
streamlined development, cost advantages, and
optimum structural performance.
800.208.6729
www.toraycma.com
TRENDS
Denmark-based Isodan Engineering presents a mobile, dust-free mechanical processing
solution for on-site composites recycling, and Ontario-based CpK Interior Products
enters the composites battery enclosure market with a relatively fast, low-cost solution.
ENERGY
process, run by one operator. Large wind blade pieces are or used as a mobile plant with a separate power generator.
inserted into one end, where they enter a “pre-shredder” The first machine was developed for recycling company
station and are shredded into finer particles. They travel Global Fiberglass Solutions (Bothell, Wash., U.S.). According
by conveyor to a secondary “refiner” station for further to Christensen, Global Fiberglass Solutions was well-
processing to the specified size and length requirements. versed in crushing and granulating fiberglass wind turbine
Nielsen notes that this second step can be customized blades to produce reusable materials such as its “ecopoly”
as needed, and may be one simple grinding or shredding compounded pellets and panels for construction applica-
stage, or a multi-step process to produce the required tions, “however, that process was very dusty and therefore
material. The entire system operates under negative pres- hazardous.” Isodan was chosen for its self-contained, dust-
sure to eliminate the airborne dust that is a typical safety free technology, and delivered its first customer unit to
concern for fiberglass shredding or recycling. At the end Global Fiberglass Solutions in July 2018.
of the process, bags of shredded material can be collected Christensen notes that interest in Isodan’s systems has
straight from the system to be repurposed into new grown over the past year or so as more companies look for
applications. sustainability solutions — not just for EOL wind blades, but
According to Nielsen, the output depends on the size for fiberglass boat hulls in the marine industry. In addition,
of the unit and how refined the final product needs to be, he notes, fabricators are looking to repurpose fiberglass
though a 20-foot unit can process between 500 and 1,500 manufacturing scrap as well.
kilograms of material per hour. “It’s a rapidly growing part of our business,” Nielsen says.
“We offer a front-end solution for repurposing and However, one of the biggest challenges that still exists
granulating these composite materials into lengths that can within the industry, he adds, is that solutions still need to
then be repurposed into other useful products,” says Finn be matured for the reused material. “In early years, nobody
Christensen, export manager at Isodan Engineering ApS. wanted to talk much about the recycling process, but that
The systems are each custom-designed, built directly has changed a lot,” Nielsen observes. “I think we’d probably
into 20- or 40-foot shipping containers so that they can call ourselves an early bird in this market in terms of coming
be easily transported via truck, rail or boat. They can be up with a commercial solution, and we’re continuing to see
installed as stationary machines within a recycling facility a lot of interest.”
CompositesWorld.com 13
TRENDS
AEROSPACE
the company’s processing capabilities:
injection molding, resin transfer mold-
ing (RTM), thermoforming and more.
Parts are finished and assembled at the
Guelph, Ontario, facility prior to OEM
EMI SHIELDING delivery. And a fourth facility in Auburn
SURFACE FINISH Hills, Mich., serves as the design head-
quarters and includes product engineers
and program managers.
Now, the company is entering the
world of composite battery enclosures.
According to Dr. Gregory Farrar, head of
R&D at CpK Interior Products, “The elec-
tric vehicle [EV] battery supply chain
is growing in Ontario, with a need for
lightweight enclosures. We want to seize
this opportunity and become part of the
supply chain.”
In 2019, the CpK Interior Products
ADHESIVE FIRE PROTECTION team began by comparing the cycle
CARRIERS times, part quality, possible part
complexity and tooling cost for various
processing methods: wet compression
GALVANIC CORROSION BARRIER molding (WCM), high-pressure resin
transfer molding (HP-RTM) and prepreg
with autoclave cure.
HP-RTM and autoclave process-
HOW WILL OUR MATERIALS HELP YOU? ing produced high-quality and highly
complex parts, but at relatively high
cycle times and high tooling costs,
whereas WCM enabled production of
www.tfpglobal.com parts quickly with low tooling costs, but
with lower quality and complexity.
enquiries@tfpglobal.com • 1 518 280 8500 CpK Interior Products, therefore,
set out to develop a method for
manufacturing battery enclosures with the quality and continued running internal tests — on electromagnetic
complexity of autoclave or HP-RTM processing, but at the interference (EMI) shielding and other properties — to
shorter cycle time and lower tooling costs of WCM. produce a full data set on its capabilities.
The project, a collaboration with several industry partners, The ultimate goal, says Farrar, is to leverage each of CpK
involved materials development and process design. The Interior’s capabilities — R&D, design engineering, materials
resulting process, called UniFORM, “combines WCM with a development, fabrication and assembly — to fill the need
proprietary tool design, where we use a vacuum in the tool- for lightweight, high-quality composite
ing to enable us to produce high-quality parts with very low battery enclosures at a realistic price point
cycle time,” says Dr. Murali Reddy, lead for R&D and sustain- and cycle time for the automotive market.
ability at CpK Interior Products. Read the full article online at
He explains, “The way it works is we lay down the fabrics short.compositesworld.com/CkPInteriorP
into the tool, apply the liquid resin, close the tool. The tool
is held to the cure temperature of the
resin, and we pull the vacuum, and
the part is formed.” The process ends
up being a hybrid between vacuum-
assisted HP-RTM and WCM, with the
three key elements being vacuum-
assisted tooling, high-temperature cure
and snap-cure resins. Depending on
the complexity of the part design, the
process was demonstrated with or with-
out preforming needed.
Reddy notes that a variety of carbon
fiber types were tested and confirmed
for feasibility so far, and that cycles
time of less than a minute were
achieved for several materials. Recycled
and twill materials were tested as well,
resulting in longer cycle times of up to
3.5 minutes.
To put its new technology to the
test, in 2021 the company approached
a North American OEM focused on
battery enclosure design. The enclosure,
per the required specifications, featured
a carbon fiber/epoxy top and bottom
tray, and included metal and injection
molded plastic inner frame components.
On the composite trays, finite
element analysis (FEA) modeling was
used first to analyze properties such
as impact resistance, crush resistance
and structural stiffness versus steel or
aluminum. The CpK Interior Products
model passed each OEM requirement,
and a prototype was built and tested.
“We tested the possibility of produc-
ing the battery box without any
preforms, just raw materials,” says
Reddy. Each tray was produced in a
two-minute cycle time, with 50% fiber
volume. The resulting weight was 44
pounds per tray — an 86.4% weight
reduction versus the 324-pound steel
version and a 60% weight reduction
versus the 110-pound aluminum version.
And overall part thickness measured to
3 millimeters, sized 2,061 millimeters x
1,361 millimeters. CpK Interior Products
CompositesWorld.com 15
SHOW PREVIEW
preview
2022 Composites and
Advanced Materials
Expo (CAMX)
Who:
American Composites
Manufacturers Assn.
(ACMA, Arlington,
Va., U.S.); Society for
the Advancement of
Material and Process
Engineering (SAMPE,
Diamond Bar, Calif.,
U.S.)
When:
Oct. 17-20, 2022
Where:
Anaheim Convention
Center, Anaheim, Calif.,
U.S.
Source | CW
» CAMX 2022 is fast approaching, taking place Oct. 17-20 at Featured panelists include Miles Arnone, CEO of Re:Build Manu-
the Anaheim Convention Center in Anaheim, Calif., U.S. This facturing; Jay Wakenshaw, chief operation officer at Elroy Air; and
year’s show promises to provide an opportunity to make new Jonathan Sourkes, head of sales of Aero SBU, Victrex. Moderating
connections, learn about the composites industry and explore the panel is Marcy Offner from Composites One (Schaumburg, Ill.,
new technologies on display from more than 400 exhibitors. The U.S.). Attend the event to learn more.
event features more than 100 conference sessions, a variety of live
demonstrations and a general session keynote presentation about Exhibit previews
supply chain disruptions and new opportunities, presented by CAMX has always provided a platform for the introduction of innova-
author and business leader Michael Steep. CAMX also will cele- tive technologies and products. CW solicited all CAMX exhibitors for
brate new technologies and innovations through the presentation information about the software, materials, equipment and services to
of its CAMX Awards and Awards for Composites Excellence (ACE). be featured in their booths. We heard back from many of them — in
One new event this year is “Good Day, CAMX,” a panel discussion fact, CW received a record number of previews this year!
taking place at a.m. on Oct. . The discussion explores a collabora- To accommodate as many previews as possible, CW has split
tion led by Re:Build Manufacturing (Framington, Mass., U.S.), along them into two batches. The first report was published in the
with Elroy Air (South San Francisco, Calif., U.S.) and Victrex (Bristol, September issue of CW; what follows is the second report.
R.I., U.S.) to produce next-generation aerospace-certified structures Please visit compositesworld.com for the full list and to follow our
and lead the adoption of thermoplastic materials. coverage of CAMX during and after the show.
AFP, postprocessing
robotic solutions
Addcomposites (Espoo, Finland)
and IND Group (Sherbrooke,
Quebec, Canada) have teamed up
Source | Accudyne Systems
again this year to showcase upcoming
and existing products. As operating
Ultrasonic composite preform trimming partners providing the North American market
equipment with turnkey, off-the-shelf automated fiber place- Source | Addcomposites
Accudyne Systems (Newark, Del., U.S.) has developed ultrasonic trimming ment (AFP) and postprocessing robotic solutions, both companies are
solutions for a variety of thermoset composite preforms. co-exhibiting to show customers a more complete visual of the value
An ultrasonic generator uses high-frequency AC current to drive a proposition they offer.
piezoelectric crystal at the knife’s resonant frequency. The amplitude Specifically at the show, Addcomposites supplies the fiber placement
of this vibration is on the order of a few thousandths of an inch, but the head to IND Group, which is integrated into the Group’s cobot solution
sawing motion and energy added at the cutting point improve the ability platform known as Cobii. The Cobii family of products are temporarily
to cut individual fibers and resist the accumulation of resin. Trimming is available for training purposes, short-term repair jobs or for university
performed against a urethane cutting surface. Custom holding fixtures can instruction. The Cobii products include AFP, trimming, sanding, buffing
be molded, even in single quantities, through the use of 3D-printed molds. and other capabilities.
Both gantry and robotic solutions are controlled through a Siemens Also highlighted is the AFP-XS system, Addcomposites’ standard
(Munich, Germany) Sinumerik CNC controller using standard G-code. toolhead designed for various industrial robots, and AddPath, the
Accudyne has provided complimentary simulation and part-programming accompanying layup planning software.
solutions, importing machining paths from Catia V5 and automatically IND Group focuses on lean robotics to supply portable and flexible
generating collision-free robot programs. units that can be deployed and integrated in record time. A collaborative
Accudyne has also integrated ultrasonic cutting into pick-and-place, sanding unit is displayed at CAMX, giving the opportunity for attendees
lamination and AFP technologies. Accudyne Systems Inc., Booth S65, to experience easy programming functions while in teaching mode.
accudyne.com Addcomposites, Booth S55, addcomposites.com
Larger Compression
Molding Presses?
At Greenerd, we’re always up to your hydraulic
pressing challenges, especially the bigger,
complicated compression molding/ composites
projects. Our design, engineering, manufacturing,
automation and integration expertise has produced
huge successes in all major industry segments.
And we’re ready to bring you our 140 years of
experience today.
Compression
Molding
Machine
Complete
with Crane
System
Teflon Molding
Machine
Large Compression
Molding Machine
2-Sided Operation
FLY LIGHTER,
WITH LESS FUEL
collinsaerospace.com/thermoplastics
CompositesWorld.com 21
Untitled-2.25 x 9.125 CW Specs.indd 4 9/7/2021 9:35:08 AM
SHOW PREVIEW
• Compression
hardtop fabricated from a variety of materials
and manufactured using three different
• Thermoforming processes: LRTM, vacuum infusion and silicone
• Injection
bag molding. “You can see how the same part
• Press
can be made completely differently, depending
on what your needs are and how many parts
Automation
•
you want to produce each day,” says Offner.
Specialized “You’ll get a feel for all the different possibilities
Solutions of closed molding.”
In addition, along with partner Magnum
Venus Products (MVP, Knoxville, Tenn., U.S.),
Composites One is demonstrating a fast-flow,
LRTM process to show how processes can
be sped up to enable higher rate or higher
efficiency manufacture.
On the final day of CAMX, Thursday, Oct. 20,
the demo organizers will hold an open house in
the booth, offering attendees a chance to talk to
the technical team, ask questions about demos
seen during the week and see the demonstra-
tion parts up close. “This will be the first time
bringing the open house component back to
our CAMX demos since 2019,” says Offner.
“We’re excited to bring back more opportuni-
COMPOSITE PRESSES AND PRESS SYSTEMS
ties for in-person and hands-on learning.”
Composites One, Booth L23, compositesone.com
www.wickert-usa.com
CompositesWorld.com 23
Untitled-2.25 x 9.125 CW Specs.indd 5 9/7/2021 9:35:09 AM
SHOW PREVIEW
Graphene products
and applications,
networking resources
The Graphene Council (New Bern,
Source | Fives Machining Systems Inc.
N.C., U.S.) is a global community
of more than 30,000 materials
Automated tape laying, fiber placement professionals that produce and
machines use graphene to create the next
Source | Graphene Council
Fives Machining Systems Inc. (Hebron, Ky., U.S.) Composites & Automated generation of products and appli-
Solutions business line provides end-to-end composites manufacturing cations, including composites and
solutions from lamination to demolding and everything in between. plastics. Founded in 2013, it represents the interests of graphene experts
Fives supports customizable lamination, forming, inspection and curing and organizations, producers, researchers, application developers and
solutions for its customers. Above all, the company says it specializes in end users.
developing highly automated, end-to-end solutions that seek to increase Graphene Council seeks to help companies understand how to
productivity across the complete line. leverage 2D advanced materials, such as graphene, to improve products
This automation specialization led Fives to develop a range of across a range of characteristics. The material imparts multiple benefits
distinctive and customized automation solutions. Fives offers tape laying not only to composite parts, but is also being used to make tools
and fiber placement machines. Featured products include the Cincinnati perform better and to last longer, according to Graphene Council.
Robotic Viper, Cincinnati Supercharger and Fives In-Process Inspection. Graphene is a unique form of carbon that has distinctive properties at
Cincinnati Robotic Viper is an AFP machine designed for OEM or Tier the atomic scale. It is said to be the thinnest known material, — so thin it
1 capabilities and quality standards. The next-generation edition seeks is considered 2D — exhibits high strength and is highly conductive (heat
to automate hand-laid parts and includes machine configurations able and electricity). When in a single layer of carbon, graphene is almost
to accommodate many shape and size applications, including concave transparent.
and convex. It also possesses a dockable head for flexibility and an Some initiatives important to the Graphene Council include
in-process inspection capability. Development of International Standards, material characterization and
The Cincinnati SuperCharger is an automated tape lamination testing services and Verified Graphene Producers inspection programs.
machine. The Cincinnati SuperCharger features the choice of vertical Companies are able to join The Graphene Council to gain access to
travel, X-axis rails in incremental sections for flexibility in part length, the network and valuable resources. Member benefits include:
up to 25° counters and up to 60 m/min layup rate. It is also available as • The Graphene Report, an up-to-date and comprehensive global
a 9- or 10-axis machine. Machine height can be configured for specific resource on commercial graphene developments.
applications, with high-speed axis motion for high productivity and • Two free registrations to Graphene Council Member conferences.
choice of crossrail width. • Weekly graphene intelligence briefings including information from
Fives In-process Inspection (IPI) provides integrated measurement science journals, commercial news, applications and patents, and
technology for automated composite layup. A quality monitoring announcements of webinars, conferences and events.
solution, the Fives IPI features a custom design to seamlessly integrate Membership in the Graphene Council helps support the development
into an AFP machine. Optical coherence tomography (OCT) imaging of standards and the commercial adoption of this material.
technology creates 3D maps of composite surfaces. Real-time defect The Graphene Council, Booth Z42, thegraphenecouncil.org
measurement, and real-time tow placement measurement and control
are possible. Fives Machining Systems, Booth N54, fivesgroup.com
Broadband, infrared
heat technologies
Heraeus Noblelight (Cambridge,
U.K. and Gaithersburg, Md., U.S.) is
highlighting its broadband flashlamp
Source | Heraeus Noblelight heat source, the humm3, along
with infrared heat technologies for
increasing production rates and quality in composites processing and fabricating applications.
Humm3 technology is a high-power, safe, highly controllable broadband heat source for
AFP, automated tape laying (ATL), filament winding and other composites applications.
Heraeus Noblelight’s Humm3 technology delivers homogeneous, highly controllable heat to
the process area over a wide range of temperatures at rapid process rates. Its instantaneous
temperature ramp-up and cooldown is said to be ideally suited to process complex parts using
dry fiber and thermoplastic composite materials.
Humm3 reportedly delivers power previously only available from a laser, but without
cumbersome safety protocols and costs associated with a laser safety enclosure. The system
also offers scalable heated widths from 12.5-300 mm and beyond, with wider widths offering
the possibility to greatly improve material deposition and thus production rates.
Heraeus Noblelight’s infrared emitters, modules and systems cure thermosetting plastics
and heat thermoplastics prior to welding, molding or forming. Precise control and placement
of infrared radiation ensures a more efficient composite fabrication process. Example applica-
tions include prepreg layup, de-bulking prepreg carbon fiber tape layups, softening of multiply
prepreg material prior to molding and more. Heraeus Noblelight America LLC, Booth F54, DESIGN TO
heraeus.com
PRODUCTION
Corrosion-resistant resins
When it comes to corrosion-resistant fiber-
reinforced plastic (FRP) tanks, pipes, ducting, SIKA IS A
pultruded profiles and custom components,
Derakane resins by INEOS (Dublin, Ohio, U.S.)
PROVIDER AND
aim to bring trusted polymer performance. DEVELOPER OF
Derakane’s track record, INEOS says, is proven
through hundreds of cases that provide decades
HIGH QUALITY
of proof of chemical containment and transport
Source | INEOS PERFORMING
in a variety of applications, including chemical
processing, coatings and linings, power genera- RESIN SYSTEMS
tion, mineral processing, pulp and paper and wastewater treatment.
Embracing the best features of INEOS’ legacy resins, Derakane Signia is meant to deliver
& ADHESIVE
elevated results — less environmental impact, better quality and better efficiency — all SOLUTIONS
contained within an identifiable resin system. With high resistance to oxidizing acids, solvents
and caustic materials, Derakane offers reliability, low maintenance and extended service life.
FOR TOOLING AND
In the job shop, INEOS reports several benefits to Derakane Signia. Prepared with a distinc- COMPOSITES
tive styrene suppressant system to reduce emissions, extend permits and provide a low-odor
environment, Signia has low styrene emissions. Signia is also designed to assist with improved
shop efficiency through easy surface preparation, increased secondary bonding and reduced WWW.SIKAINDUSTRY.COM
gassing for faster consolidation and less process time. The resin also offers long shelf life to 800-688-7452
maintain its processing characteristics.
INEOS also reports benefits of using Derakane Signia in the field. It possesses a consistent
polymer backbone meant to deliver the same chemical resistance and mechanical properties
as its predecessors — all with better processing, according to the company. Signia also has
verifiable identification through a proprietary detection system to verify the integrity of a
customer’s design wherever corrosion-resistant FRP pipes and tanks are present. INEOS
Composites, Booth J42, ineos.com/composites
CompositesWorld.com 25
Untitled-2.25 x 9.125 CW Specs.indd 6 9/7/2021 9:35:14 AM
SHOW PREVIEW
Computer-
controlled filament
winding machine
Since 1961, McClean Anderson
(Schofield, Wis., U.S.) has
developed filament winding
Source | Magnum Venus Products
equipment. Since its first Source | McClean Anderson
THERMOPLASTIC SYSTEMS
calitzler.com
Features
■ Creels
■ Tow Spreading
■ Waterborne Resin Application
■ Oven for Pre-Melting Resin
■ Resin Consolidation Die Application
C. A. Litzler Co., Inc.
■ Profile Thickness Systems
4800 W. 160th Street
Cleveland, OH 44135 USA ■ Compaction Rolls
216-267-8020 ■ Winders
sales@calitzler.com ■ Controls & Automation
W yoming
to review beam bending calculations using
fixtures in stock,
ready to be shipped. a variety of boundary conditions and load
configurations, including:
T est
• Expert consultation
with Drs. Dan and • SS Ends – Center Load
Don Adams • SS Ends – 4-Point Bend
F ixtures
• Email or call today to • SS Ends – Uniform Loading
discuss your fixture and
• Clamped Ends – Center Load
custom design needs.
INC. • Clamped Ends – Uniform Load
• Cantilevered – End (tip) Load
• Cantilevered – Uniform Loading
CERAMIC FLEXURAL TEST FIXTURES Any composite material application with
requirements for critical performance and
safety must be verified through a mainstream
CERAMIC FLEXURAL
engineering and development approach, such
STRENGTH
TEST FIXTURES as final laminate testing through ISO/ASTM
MODEL: WTF-CF test standards, which Metyx says should be
ASTM C1161 used to complement this design tool. This is
also the case for core materials for sandwich
laminate constructions, include facing details
CONFIGURATIONS A, B, C AND A CUSTOM SMALL-SCALE FIXTURE ARE SHOWN such as grooves and perforations, in which
resin absorption is taken into consideration to
provide a more accurate result with respect to
overall laminate weight.
Metycalc is also said to help speed produc-
tion and reduce labor by showing how different
material selections can change the process,
as well as revealing cost-effective solutions to
optimize the number of layers needed to meet
design goals.
Free to use and user friendly, Metycalc can
CERAMIC FLEXURAL STRENGTH CERAMIC EQUIBIAXIAL FLEXURAL be accessed across platforms including PC,
THREE-AND FOUR-POINT LOADING TEST FIXTURE MAC, Android and Apple. Metyx Composites,
MODEL: WTF-CF MODEL: WTF-CB
Booth S11, metyx.com
ASTM C1161 ASTM C1499
CUSTOM MADE TO YOUR SPECIMEN SIZE
ASTM ASTM
D5379 D7078
WE HAVE OVER
ASTM 300 FIXTURES IN
C297
STOCK AND
READY TO SHIP
ASTM C273
BS 7260
CompositesWorld.com 33
NOVEMBER 15–17, 2022
H YAT T R E G E N C Y | G R E E N V I L L E , S C
PRESENTED BY:
Spe c i a l E v e n t s
coming to
Carbon Fiber 2022!
PRE-CONFERENCE TOUR
Tuesday, November 15
Clemson University’s International Center
for Automotive Research
This tour will break attendees into groups as you’re
guided throughout the facility. You’ll see various
items and processes in the lab including materials
testing, machinery, cutting tables and more.
This event is free but space is limited!
Celebr a te w i th u s ! m
Register by October 14 to claim the early bird rate and a
limited-edition Carbon Fiber 25th Anniversary lapel pin!
Learn more at
CarbonFiberEvent.com
SHOW PREVIEW
CompositesWorld.com 37
SHOW PREVIEW
Thermoset, thermo-
plastic composite
materials
With its Tenax carbon fibers and
composites, Teijin Carbon America
(Rockwood, Tenn., U.S.) offers solu-
Source | Saint-Gobain Vetrotex tions to the aerospace, automotive,
infrastructure industries and more.
Technical glass fiber textiles Tenax high-strength continuous
Vetrotex (Tlaxcala, Mexico) is a fiberglass manufacturer for technical filament fibers include a range of Source |Teijin Carbon America
textiles. The company operates globally with sales offices in Australia, the standard, intermediate (IM) and
Czech Republic, India, Japan, Korea, the U.S., France, China and Malaysia, high-modulus (HM) products and are available in tow sizes from 1K to 48K
with production facilities in Europe and North America. and suited for processes like prepregging, pultrusion, weaving, filament
The company’s aim is to serve its customers anywhere in the world winding and braiding. Tenax filament yarn is surface treated to improve
with its global presence while focusing on local service. Vetrotex strives fiber-to-resin interfacial bond strength, and fiber sizing is applied to
to be a true business partner to its customers in all aspects. Vetrotex protect the fiber and improve handling and wetout. A variety of available
says innovation is a major part of its constantly developing mindset, sizings make it fully compatible with thermoset matrix systems. Teijin says
encouraged across the company for the satisfaction of customers. its tailored thermoplastic sizing is compatible with thermoplastic matrix
With more than 80 years of experience in fiberglass manufacturing, systems like PEEK, PEI and PPS.
Vetrotex works in partnership with its customers, continuously investing Tenax short fibers, either milled or chopped, are designed to improve
in research and development (R&D) for improved technologies and properties in thermoset and thermoplastic applications. They come in
product solutions. It strives to offer a complete range of service and easy-to-handle bundle sizes and modifications that enable use in high-
products tailored and focused on customer needs. The company says temperature thermoplastics, and are available in a variety of sizes.
its clients enable it to position itself as a reputable provider of building, Pyromex is an oxidized PAN fiber (OPF) with non-flammable and
industrial and a wide spectrum of other applications requiring technical non-melting characteristics. Pyromex OPF is ideal for critical aerospace
textiles. applications thanks to its chemical purity and aerospace-grade production
Vetrotex’s parent company, Saint-Gobain, is a glass producer with standards. As a result, Teijin reports Pyromex is widely used in welding
more than 350 years of experience. With a large presence in the habitat blankets, fleece insulation and carbon/carbon brake applications.
and construction markets, it designs, manufactures and distributes Tenax ThermoPlastics, when combined with rapid production processes,
building materials and other industrial products, providing solutions reportedly enable fast processing, low scrap rates, good mechanical
to meet the growing demand for energy efficiency and environmental performance, chemical resistance and recyclability. Teijin offers three
protection. Because of this prestige, Vetrotex is able to use Saint- types of products: ThermoPlastics UniDirectional (TPUD), ThermoPlastics
Gobain’s vast resources to develop and manufacture distinctive glass Consolidated Laminate (TPCL) and ThermoPlastic Woven Fabric (TPWF).
fiber products. Vetrotex, Booth X56, vetrotextextiles.com Teijin Carbon America Inc., Booth X2, teijincarbon.com
LABOR $$$$$ $ - $$
FACILITIES $$$ $
CONSUMABLES $ - $$$ $ - $$
TOTAL COST $500 - $1000/lb $200 - $400/lb
LEARN MORE
www.HawthornComposites.com/Advantage
CompositesWorld.com 39
SHOW PREVIEW
Curved
calligraphy
panels, double
helix stairs
AFI supplied 7,700 square
meters of complex-curved,
glass fiber/epoxy panels
for the wall, ceiling and
spiral staircase cladding in
the Museum of the Future’s
lobby.
Source (all images) | Advanced
Fiberglass Industries
»The Museum of the Future (MOTF, Dubai, United Arab which extends up to the seventh floor. All told, the museum’s interior
Emirates) is one of the most complex and challenging projects in consumes a total of , square meters of composites.
modern architecture. Opened in February 2022, it is described as AFI also supplied oval light structures for the parking decks.
“the most beautiful building in the world” by His Highness Sheikh Like the exterior cladding, the interior panels feature Arabic callig-
Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, who conceived the museum raphy cutouts with inset LED lighting and also integrate sound
as an incubator for innovation and invention. dampening. They also are certified for fire resistance (FR) per ASTM
The museum features seven floors, each dedicated to a E- class A and EN regulations — a challenge in itself.
different exhibition space, as well as ongoing research and devel- Key elements in overcoming these challenges include the use of
opment (R&D) — for example, in sustainability, data science, Sicomin (Châteauneuf-les-Martigues, France) FR epoxy, Adapa’s
health and well-being, bioengineering and other technologies (Aalborg, Denmark) reusable, adaptive mold system (Learn More)
that are not yet fully conceptualized. and AFI’s long history of developing innovative, cost-effective
CW wrote about the museum’s multifunctional exterior in composite solutions for demanding projects.
(see Learn More), but its interior lobby is also iconic and
enabled by composites. DailyArt Magazine describes entering Innovation in GFRP
the spacious and impressive lobby as “an adventure.” This unique Specializing in design and construction of composite components,
experience is made possible by Dubai-based Advanced Fiber- AFI was established in Dubai in 1997 and has two production facili-
glass Industries (AFI), which was tasked with construction of ties of 55,000 and 15,000 square feet. “We can build to any specs
the complete lobby façade, including the calligraphy-embedded and design requirements,” says Majid Akram Chaudhry, general
ceiling and walls and cladding for its three spiral staircases, one of manager of AFI. The company’s facilities feature a climate-controlled
cleanroom, curing oven, paint booth, a CNC three-axis router and almost no shrinkage, making construction and installation of these
a KUKA (Augsburg, Germany) CNC seven-axis milling robot. The complex panels easier. However, the budget for the project was
company primarily manufactures with hand layup and vacuum based on much cheaper resins.” The increased cost was indeed an
bagging, but also has developed these techniques for use with the issue, admits Chaudhry, “but the epoxy also would enable cutting
Adapa mold system, discussed below. the weight of the panels by half. We also had ideas about how to
AFI’s operations are segmented into three specialties: military, save costs during manufacturing [see “Adaptive molds” p. 44]. So,
automotive and architecture. Its innovation comes from decades we proposed this new epoxy-based design to Killa Design, and they
of devising solutions for a range of composite components. For approved the change.” Killa Design is the local architecture studio
example, it has manufactured more than , glass fiber-rein- in Dubai responsible for the MOTF design, including oversight of
forced polymer (GFRP) hoods for Dubai-based NIMR Automo- construction details.
tive. “This is a -square-meter bonnet, which is bigger than that AFI applied two Sicomin epoxy systems, both using intumescent
for a Hummer,” says Chaudhry. “We work with NIMR to design technology as well as FR additives, though not based on aluminum
products such as fenders, dashboards and consoles for military trihydroxide. “The technology that we used allows much higher FR
vehicles.” AFI has also designed and built body panels, doors, content and performance in order to meet the requirements of the
dashboards, fenders and bumpers for concept and small-series ASTM E- and EN regulations demanded by this project,”
production cars, trucks and recreational vehicles. explains Denjean. “The main fire resistance was achieved by using
In architecture, AFI has built the -meter-diameter sphere SGi bio-based FR epoxy gel coat. The second tier of protection
atop the -story Ministry of Foreign Affairs building in Ashgabat, was SR FR hand-laminating resin, which has a low viscosity of
Turkmenistan, and , square meters of panels for the millipoise at °C — about half that of a conventional FR epoxy
-meter-high dome for the Center of Islamic Civilization in hand lamination resin.”
Tashkent, Uzbekistan. AFI has also constructed curved restau- AFI used this system with a laminating machine to wet out
rant interiors and spiral staircases, as well as unique structures -gsm glass fiber quadraxial fabric from Metyx Composites
such as the crushed granite gel-coated Evolutes sculpture by (Istanbul, Turkey) that was then applied to the Adapa molding
Karim Rashid, showcased in the Armani suite of the renowned system using a small team of laminators. For Sicomin, one chal-
Burj Khalifa hotel in Dubai (see p. Post Cure column in CW’s lenge was to modify the epoxy hardener formulation to be slow-
February issue). reacting for making such large panels.
“The laminators needed sufficient pot life before gelling, but then
Redesign with FR epoxy sometimes, the laminators needed to go faster for smaller panels,”
The original design for the MOTF interiors specified use of an FR notes Denjean. “So, we had to make a fast and a slow hardener for
vinyl ester resin, explains Chaudhry, “but that was too heavy.” the laminating resin and then also be able to mix these for an inter-
Marc Denjean, export manager for Sicomin, had met AFI during mediate gel time, in order to accommodate AFI’s production needs.
an architecture and construction show in Dubai. “We introduced We customized this for them, and it took some months to set up,
the idea of using an FR epoxy resin,” he says, “which also offers because we had to test these different systems, qualify them and
CompositesWorld.com 43
INSIDE MANUFACTURING
1 CNC-cut foam placeholders were laid onto the curved Adapa mold to 3 CNC-cut EPS foam supports were bonded onto the cured A surface
produce the panel’s A surface that visitors see. laminate and coated with a light GFRP laminate.
Silicone
beam
Custom
bracket
PVC connects
foam beams
edge
GFRP
Wood stapled to embedded
PVC provides extra into silicone
grip/stability beams
2 Close-up of the system used to mold flanges on all four panel edges. 4 The final B surface laminate was applied on day three and room-temp
cured, followed by a final heated post-cure.
fire-test them. After this was completed, however, production ran Affordability via adaptive molds
very quickly.” The project used roughly metric tonnes of resin, Because the cost of the panels using epoxy was so much greater
which Sicomin delivered in six months. than the original budget, the team at AFI needed a very efficient
“It’s a minimum -millimeter-thick laminate all over the lobby method to fabricate the 228 interior wall panels. Each panel was
because that was the criteria for the Class A fire rating certifica- unique due to the complex curved surfaces of the lobby’s walls
tion,” explains Chaudhry. and ceiling. “We had seen the Adapa mold system being used to
Denjean notes that fire resistance testing is always a big chal- produce glass fiber-reinforced concrete [GRC] panels for the Kuwait
lenge because requirements such as ASTM E- and EN are International Airport project,” says Chaudhry. “We got in touch with
so difficult to meet. “At Sicomin, we make our own test panels for the founder of Adapa, Christian Raun, and he came to Dubai to
the materials testing in fire test labs,” he says. “But our customers discuss our idea to use his system for molding the GFRP panels for
must build test parts just as they would for the project and also in the museum lobby.”
the factory where the actual parts will be produced. They then must Adapa’s adaptive mold system is based on multipoint forming,
get passing results on three consecutive tests.” Sicomin and Metyx a technology that basically works like the plastic toy that forms the
provided assistance to AFI throughout fire testing. The panels that shape of your hand when you press into its myriad pins. Instead
AFI prepared were tested at Thomas Bell-Wright Construction of plastic pins, Adapa uses a bed of actuated metal cylinders, each
Testing Laboratory in Dubai and passed all FR requirements. topped with a powerful magnet and controlled digitally using
6 Finished panels were bolted to each other and to the steel brackets
attached to the building structure.
CompositesWorld.com 45
INSIDE MANUFACTURING
panel — AFI would use three D .- x .-meter reconfigu- The silicone barriers — which appear as white beams in Step
rable Adapa molds. This approach not only enabled massive cost (p. ) — were held in place by eight to nine metallic L-brackets
savings, but also eliminated the need for large amounts of space via the magnets under the molding surface. For thicker panels
for mold storage and panel production. AFI was able to mold (in Zones and , explained below), explains Pullur, “we used a
all of the panels in a production room of less than square -millimeter-thick PVC foam core [green color] as an extension
meters. AFI was also the first company to use the Adapa system for because the silicone barrier height was insufficient to create the
molding GFRP panels in the Middle East (Learn More). flanges needed. Due to this PVC core’s taller height, we inserted
“We did make some customizations,” says Sooraj Pullur, AFI’s some rectangular pieces of GFRP into the silicone barriers to
head of engineering. “This included extra [actuator] rods so that serve as a guide.” The latter can be seen in Step (p. ), behind
we could avoid some minor waves that were occurring with our thin pieces of wood stapled to the PVC core to provide extra grip/
GFRP panels versus how it was designed for GRC — basically stability for this connection.
smoothing out the gaps between actuators. And we added more
magnets under the molding surface to solve some issues that we Challenging calligraphy
had with the silicone membrane rising during vacuum molding.” The calligraphy on the MOTF’s interior lobby is an integral part of
Additional actuators for higher resolution and stronger magnets its design, declaring His Highness Sheikh Mohammed’s vision and
for vacuum forming/molding are now standard within Adapa’s posing a challenge to all people everywhere: “We might not live
product family for composites. “The team also had to devise a for hundreds of years, but the products of our creativity can leave a
release agent system that worked with both the epoxy resin and legacy long after we are gone. The future belongs to those who can
the silicone membrane molding surface,” adds Denjean, “but the imagine it, design it and execute it. The future does not wait. The
Adapa system was robust and easy to use.” It also allowed AFI to future can be designed and built today.”
use epoxy resin and still meet the project’s budget. For AFI, these words posed a key challenge during design and
“We also worked with Adapa to develop silicone barriers for construction of the interior’s composite panels. “These Arabic
making the flanges on all four edges of each panel,” explains letters had to be very precise, including the dots [called diacritical
Pullur. These flanges were used to attach the panels to each other marks] and nothing could be changed,” explains Chaudhry, “with a
and were key to maintaining joint accuracy during installation. maximum tolerance of to millimeters.”
RENEGADEMATERIALS.COM
The depth of the letters also changed with the height of the of expanded polystyrene (EPS) foam were used as placeholders and
lobby, to remain legible to visitors, even as the walls and ceiling later removed.
extend further away. AFI divided this height and letter depth into After the A surface was laminated, a second set of CNC-cut EPS
four zones. Zone is up to . meters high, where the depth of the foam was bonded to it, providing the structure between the callig-
calligraphy letters is only millimeters. That depth increases to raphy cutouts and the required panel thickness for each zone. The B
millimeters in Zone , to millimeters in Zone and to surface was then laminated across these EPS foam supports, which
millimeters in Zone . “From Zone onwards, LED lights would were undersized from the A surface laminate to create a -milli-
be installed into the curves of the letters,” notes Pullur. “So, there meter-wide “cove” in which to install the LED lights. After the panels
had to be a cavity to install these, and we also had to incorporate were demolded, acoustic insulation was then installed (by a different
acoustic insulation to prevent echoing in the lobby, but without contractor) in the recesses created for the calligraphy letters.
affecting the smooth, curved design.” Pullur describes the manufacturing steps: “We used our CNC
AFI’s concept was to use two surfaces. The A surface would face machines to cut the foam placeholders and panel supports as per
out toward the building’s visitors and form the curvature of the the CAD model. On the first day, we used Adapa’s software to shape
lobby, while the B surface would attach to the building’s internal the mold surface, laid the foam placeholders and applied the FR
structure. The A surface was formed by a gel-coated GRFP skin gel coat. The lamination was then made in three stages. On the first
laid onto the silicone surface of a curved Adapa mold, but was day, we laminated the A surface. On the second day, we bonded the
omitted in certain areas to form a kind of negative space to repre- CNC-cut foam supports onto the A surface layer and then applied
sent the “cutout” calligraphy letters. In these areas, CNC-cut pieces a light laminate on top. On the last day, we applied the B surface
SIDEBAR
laminate.” The epoxy resin was room-temperature cured overnight after each lami-
nation, and then heaters were used to apply a final post-cure. AFI’s humidity- and
temperature-controlled laminating room was well-organized for this panel production,
which was completed in months.
“There was some trial and error to find the right methodology for the least time and
cost,” says Chaudhry. “It was basically one month of R&D with a lot of brainstorming.
But it allowed us to meet the design and budget requirements and win the job after
competing with several other competitors from around the world.” All of the panels
were manufactured at AFI’s production
facility and then transported to the MOTF
site for installation.
Read this article online |
“Installation was also a challenge,” says
short.compositesworld.
com/MOTFinterior AFI installation manager, Patrik Gajdosik.
Read about this museum’s “We wanted each and every joint between
composite exterior facade| panels to be seamless, so we came up with
short.compositesworld.com/MOTF an idea to form a small V section so there
See CW’s video of the Adapa system and would be no hairline joints visible. First,
Adapa’s image gallery |
we installed steel brackets to the build-
short.compositesworld.com/Adapavid and
short.compositesworld.com/Adapaimages ing’s wall and ceiling structure, and then
attached the panels to each other and to the
bracket system. Next, we filled the V gaps
using fire-retardant epoxy adhesive and overlaminated them, followed by grinding the
panel surface smooth and final painting. The lobby panels had to have a white matte
finish and a tolerance of only a few millimeters over a ,-square-meter surface.” AFI
achieved this — a D scan of the completed interior lobby showed the surface main-
tained a tolerance of ± millimeters. “When you go into the lobby now,” notes Gajdosik,
“it looks like one continuous structure.”
CompositesWorld.com 49
Thermoplastic
composites welding
advances for more
sustainable airframes
Multiple demonstrators help
various welding technologies
approach TRL 6 in the quest for
lighter weight, lower cost.
Welded stringers in
»Thermoplastic composites welding has lower half of MFFD
the potential to significantly improve the GKN Fokker conduction welds CF/
sustainability of commercial aircraft produc- LMPAEK stringers to the skin of the
tion. According to Tier 1 airframer Collins Multifunctional Fuselage Demonstrator
Aerospace (Charlotte, N.C., U.S.), more auto- (MFFD) lower half being assembled
mated, out-of-autoclave (OOA), weldable at SAM|XL as part of Clean Sky 2’s
STUNNING project. The 2.5-ton, induc-
thermoplastic structures have the potential tion heated, 1-meter-long conduction
to reduce manufacturing cycle time by up welding tool is housed within a rack and
to 80% and weight by up to 50% compared pinion-equipped hoisting fixture that
to previous metal and thermoset composite positions the welder over each stringer
assemblies. These previous assemblies use using the notches in the circumference
of the fuselage shell tool.
drilling and mechanical fasteners, requiring
Source | GKN Fokker, SAM|XL
up to nine manufacturing steps. “We believe
that for a new, A320-type single-aisle
aircraft in five to eight years, thermoplastic composites will be a were originally developed and produced by Fokker Aerostructures
game-changer, not only to enable higher production rates but also (Hoogeveen), now part of Tier airframer GKN Aerospace. For
best cost and weight,” says Cedric Eloy, deputy chief CTO, Tier 1 these structures, GKN Fokker uses KVE Composites’ (The Hague,
airframer Daher Aerospace (Paris, France). Netherlands) patented induction welding process. Induction,
Thermoplastic composite structures have been certified conduction and resistance welding are all defined and discussed
and flying for decades. These include resistance-welded main in CW’s feature article on thermoplastic composites welding
landing gear doors on the Fokker in , j-nose leading edge (see Learn More).
wing structures on the Airbus A and A in and , There have been numerous welding developments since
respectively, and induction-welded carbon fiber (CF)/polyphen- (see “Composites welding developments” sidebar, right), including
ylene sulfide (PPS) elevators and rudder on the Gulfstream G a move toward low-melt polyaryletherketone (LMPAEK)-based
business jet in . “There are more than G aircraft flying,” composites for potential lower temperature processing versus
notes Arnt Offringa, director of the GKN Aerospace (Solihull, U.K.) polyetherketoneketone (PEKK) and polyetheretherketone (PEEK),
Global Technology Centre Netherlands (GTC-NL, Hoogeveen). continued advancements in automation and simulation and an
“Gulfstream now has seven aircraft models using welded ther- increase in the size and complexity of demonstrators. Welding has
moplastic control surfaces, with production continuing, so it’s also become more common. Most Tier airframers have significant
become an established manufacturing method.” Offringa was a key welding R&D or established capabilities, many with technology
champion in the induction-welded structures listed above, which readiness levels (TRL) approaching -. And even though welded
structures have been certified since , there is debate in the U.S. (UD) tapes — versus the previous parts made with fabric — certi-
that certification of future welded structures should follow what’s fied and flying by .
been established for bonded structures. This is likely because
welding in the U.S. is not as mature as it is in Europe and details of MFFD lower half
previous certifications are not widely known. In any case, a good The most significant thermoplastic composites welding project
thermoplastic composite weld should show homogeneous material in progress is the Airbus-led Multifunctional Fuselage Demon-
through the thickness with no identifiable interface. In this way, strator (MFFD) project, funded by Clean Aviation (formerly Clean
welded structures are not at all like bonded structures. Sky 2). At 4 meters in diameter and 8 meters long, this A320-type
In Europe, emphasis is on advancing process control and fuselage section will be the world’s largest thermoplastic compos-
nondestructive testing (NDT) already used during production ites structure, once the upper and lower halves are welded
of certified structures, on demonstrating multiple welding tech- together. This assembly will be completed by Fraunhofer IFAM
niques via fabrication and testing of ever larger demonstrators, (Stade, Germany) before the assembled barrel is delivered to
and on having the first welded structures made with unidirectional Airbus (Hamburg, Germany) in 2023. Production of the lower half
CompositesWorld.com 51
FEATURE
is led by GKN Fokker in the STUNNING project, while the upper time, with a slight overlap of - centimeters, and then completes
half is managed by the DLR Center for Lightweight Production the second side. Two L-stringers were also welded to receive the
Technology (ZLP), which is part of the DLR Institute of Structure cabin floor (Fig. , opposite).
and Design in Augsburg, Germany. Components for both halves “Next, clips will be placed over these stringers and joined to the
have been made using Toray Advanced Composites TC1225 CF/ stringers and skin using spot ultrasonic welding,” says Van Rijswijk.
LMPAEK unitape. The MFFD project began in 2014 and aims to Although the dedicated ultrasonic welder used for this opera-
enable production of 70-100 fuselage shipsets per month, reduce tion has the same type of sonotrode as the tack welder (Fig. , p.
fuselage weight by 10% (1,000 kilograms) and reduce fuselage ), it is configured differently for this high-strength weld versus
costs by 20% (€1 million). tack welding. Later on, frames will be connected into the fuselage
The lower half is being assembled at SAM|XL (Delft, Neth- through these clips using the same ultrasonic spot-welding tech-
erlands) with planned delivery to Airbus by October . The nique, says Bram Jongbloed, materials and process engineer at
SAM|XL facility has multiple robotic arms and one large gantry- SAM|XL. “To make joints perpendicular to the skin, we have a
based robot for welding. As described in Fig. (p. ), the first step second welder turned at degrees,” he adds. This welder will
was to conduction weld omega stringers onto the curved fuselage press and weld the flat web of the frames to the omega-shaped flat
skin (Learn More). “The gantry robot end effector is equipped plate of the clips (Fig. ).
with suction cups to precisely place the stringers onto the skin,” “We have about clips to join with ultrasonic welding, and
says Kjelt van Rijswijk, CEO of SAM|XL. “It is also equipped with then the frames,” says Muijs. “After that, we will install the floor
an ultrasonic spot welder to tack the stringers in place.” grid, equipped with composite floor beams, metal seat rails and
GKN Fokker then welded the stringers with a -meter-long other systems. We will conduction weld where the floor beams
conduction welding tool. The metal tool is induction heated and meet the frames and also below, where the support struts meet the
this immediate, even heating is conducted through the stringer’s frames [Fig. ].”
foot laminate to melt the matrix at the stringer-skin weld inter- He notes lessons already learned with conduction welding in
face. “The tool includes a heat sink that controls temperature on STUNNING: “Welding the stringers took much longer than we
the stringer surface,” explains Leo Muijs, chief technologist at GKN expected and also resulted in some shape changes in the skin. This
Fokker. “It applies pressure and then completes the welding cycle.” is not something we have seen in previous conduction-welded
He notes that these omega stringers have a foot to be welded on demonstrators. So, we are studying that now. There are also some
both sides. The weld tool moves down one side, one meter at a joggles [changes in thickness] in the stringers that we cannot go
over well. The flat welding tool can deal with a certain slope, for FIG. 1 Multiple welding technologies demonstrated
example a : ply dropoff [e.g., one .-millimeter-thick ply The welding steps for fabricating the upper and lower halves of the 4- x 8-meter-
dropped every millimeters] causes no problems, but we cannot long MFFD fuselage are shown here, along with project leaders and partners.
weld a dropoff of :.” There is also an issue of length. “Our Lower half welds of floor grid to frames are shown as white hatched rectangles at
lower right. Completed halves will be shipped to Airbus Hamburg to be welded
smallest welding tool is roughly half a meter long, which is too
together in 2023.
long to weld a -centimeter stiffener, for example,” he says. Other
Source | Clean Aviation, DLR CC BY-NC-ND 3.0, GKN Aerospace, SAM|XL, compiled by CW
welding methods could be used for these short stringers, says
Muijs, “but they were not specified for this demonstrator, which is
our current task. So, now we document these issues and include welding, one of the major lessons we learned is to avoid ply
it in our final report to Airbus. When we make future designs, endings or runouts beneath the stringer feet,” says Fischer. “These
we can create guidelines for conduction welding that help, and ply drops within the skin affect the weld quality.”
we are already working on different end effectors to solve these Michael Kupke, vice director, Institute of Structures and Design
issues. The whole goal of this demonstrator is to find these chal- and head of department at ZLP, explains: “In continuous ultra-
lenges and advance the technology to address them.” sonic welding, heat is generated when there is damping of the
ultrasonic waves. Stiffer materials transmit the waves, while softer
MFFD upper half materials increase damping. A soft layer of unreinforced polymer
DLR expects to deliver the upper half of the MFFD in early 2023. — the same matrix as in the composite surfaces being welded
It, too, has amassed lessons learned, starting in July 2021 with — is placed at the weld interface to control the energy during
production of a 1-meter-long full-scale test shell to verify its tech- welding. This is called an energy director.” So, just as the amount
nology bricks, including continuous and spot ultrasonic welding of fiber changes stiffness and damping, which affects the weld,
and resistance welding (Learn More). “We used continuous ultra- so do changes in laminate thickness. “We have to understand the
sonic welding for the Z-stringers and resistance welding for the effect of such changes in the surfaces being welded and address
frames,” explains Frederic Fischer, technical lead for thermoplastic this in the process,” says Kupke.
composites production at the ZLP. “We had six frames for this “We will have different sets of parameters for thicker skins and
test shell. We welded the first three and then went into a lessons- thinner skins,” adds Fischer. “And this is the case also for joggles
learned session and did a bit of rebuilding and redesign of the in stringers to match buildups and dropoffs in the fuselage skin.
welding bridge. And then we finished the last three. This test shell We’re adapting the welding process parameters to the layup and
allowed us to test the process parameters and setup of the welding geometry of the parts being welded. We verified that we can weld
elements, study the results and finalize what we are using for the stringers to shallow ramps with a : ratio.”
final 8-meter upper shell, which we started last April.” Another lesson was learned during resistance welding of the
What had to be changed? “With the continuous ultrasonic frames. “We saw that the in-situ consolidated tape skin had a
CompositesWorld.com 53
FEATURE
comparatively high electrical conductivity. To rule out leakage DLR’s resistance welding bridge can be seen in Fig. (p. ),
[of ] currents through the fuselage skin during welding — which anchored to the test fuselage shell tool. The bridge grips a curved
becomes more likely if the weld faces have similar fiber orienta- fuselage frame and presses it down onto the skin. “Every foot along
tion — we added an insulating layer to the carbon fiber-based the frame has its own welding module with a pneumatic cylinder
welding elements.” to apply a pressure of about bar,” says Fischer. “Electric current is
COMPOSITES
CALL FOR
LMT ONSRUD
Visit www.onsrud.com
Honeycomb and composites materials have for more information
become the standards within the aerospace, 800-234-1560
medical, and transportation industries.
LMT Onsrud premium cutting tools increase
machining efficiencies, eliminate delamination,
and enhance part finishes. LMT Onsrud LP
1081 S. Northpoint Blvd
Trust LMT Onsrud to provide tools that meet Waukegan, IL 60085
your exacting standards! Phone 800 234 1560
BARRIERS Sports
LIVE DEMOS @
Medical
BOOTH Q11
Aerospace
Transportation
then run through the welding module [from the red to black wire in Premium Aerotec in Augsburg, Germany.) To support this, Clean
Fig. through the welding element positioned between the frame Sky 2 awarded the DEWTECOMP project to R&D lab CETMA
foot and the fuselage skin.” This welding element generates heat in (Brindisi, Italy), aiming to weld structural frames with reinforce-
the weldline, analogous to the energy director used in ultrasonic ment parts such as gussets, wedges and fittings to produce a DSS
welding. with at least 15% weight savings and up to 75% energy savings
In the past, it was a stainless steel mesh, “but we now use the versus a standard autoclave-cured thermoset structure.
same carbon fiber composite as in the skin and frames,” says Kupke. “Our strategy was to divide the entire structure into different
“Though metal has better electrical conductivity, we have elimi- subassemblies that can be welded with a very simple tool and
nated any foreign material in the weldline — it is a single homoge- linear weld path,” says Giuseppe Buccoliero, advance materials
neous material throughout.” and process development engineer at CETMA. “These welded
“During resistance welding, we run current until the matrix subassemblies are then joined to manufacture the door frame
reaches the required process temperature, which is above the structure. We first developed the induction welding process
crystalline melting temperature,” continues Fischer. “We then for the CF/LMPAEK unitape, and then we followed a building
reduce the voltage in two steps, while pressure is applied, until block approach — testing coupons, components and finally to
the weldline cools. Welding takes about two minutes.” After the the demonstrator level. We also developed a fully automated
frames, DLR again uses resistance welding to integrate cleats as induction welding cell where the robotic arm movement and the
shear ties between the Z-stringers and curved fuselage frames. welding head are fully integrated and controlled by a single PLC
“DLR developed a cobot-on-robot-based welding system for [programmable logic controller].”
this process because it requires perfect positioning of each cleat CETMA also developed simulation that can predict not only
between stringer and frame and must also allow for tolerance thermal behavior in the weld, but also mechanical behavior, such
compensation.” as microcracking. “This helped us to optimize the welding process
for each DSS component, taking into account the laminate design
MFFD door structure and part geometry,” says Buccoliero. CETMA verifed weld perfor-
Another part of the MFFD project is the door surround struc- mance through lap shear, compression and double cantilever
ture (DSS) for the lower fuselage half, to be fabricated by Tier 1 beam testing, the latter for fracture toughness and comparing test
airframer Aernnova Aerospace (Miñano, Spain) using induction data with simulation results. It then scaled up to weld the frame
welding. (Note, the DSS for the upper MFFD half was produced by subassemblies, completing the project in June .
CETMA is now working with its equipment partner SINERGO program will move quickly from coupons to the stiffened-skin
(Valdobbiadene, Italy) and Advantech Advisory (Lloret de Mar, panel element level, says Seneviratne. “We’ll do a comparison
Spain) to commercialize its patented induction welding tech- of bonded, bolted and welded joints in both in-plane and out-
nology, including gantry and robotic systems. of-plane loading for static strength, durability and damage toler-
ance. We’re doing this because we need to address the issues with
NIAR scaling these technologies. Fatigue testing is also key to under-
Wichita State University’s National Institute for Aviation Research stand long-term behavior. We have coupon-level fatigue data
(NIAR, Wichita, Kan., U.S.) is also developing resistance, ultra- showing our resistance welds can perform times better than
sonic and induction welding process specifications. In March 2021, bonded joints. But then we changed the quasi-isotropic ply at the
it announced the addition of robotic
induction welding equipment as part of
its Modeling for Affordable Sustainable
Composites (MASC) research program,
sponsored by the U.S. Air Force Research
Laboratory (AFRL, Dayton, Ohio). Its
resistance welding and ultrasonic welding
cells were added shortly after (Fig. 4),
and are quasi-static, meaning they aren’t
robot-based or continuous, but instead
produce piece-wise welds. NIAR’s resis- Composite Parts,
Assemblies
tance welding uses carbon fiber resistance
elements in the weld interface.
AND Tooling
“Under this AFRL research, we’ll pursue
process development and then building
block certification protocols for all three
welding technologies through a -foot-
long manufacturing demonstrator called
► Rapid Design and Build
Frankenstein (FS-),” says Waruna Sene-
virate, director of the Advanced Technolo- ► One-Off or High Volume
gies Lab for Aerospace Systems (ATLAS) at
► Large, Complex Shapes
NIAR. “This demonstrator will allow us to
validate the in-house developed welding ► High-Precision Machining
processes and certification protocols in ► Non-Destructive Testing (NDI)
scale and to work with different manu-
facturers to produce welded thermo-
plastic composite parts and make sure the www.janicki.com | 360.856.5143
processes are robust.”
The building block testing in this
CompositesWorld.com 57
FEATURE
CompositesWorld.com 59
FEATURE
began with flat panel testing on the KVE welding test setup at the University of South
Mix,
Carolina, which also helped to develop thermoplastic-coated optical fibers embedded
into the composite laminate and interrogated using Luna’s (Roanoke, Va., U.S.)
Meter, and
ODiSi eight-channel interrogator system.
RTRC also used force/torque sensors in its robotic induction welding head, an IR
camera and thermocouples to monitor pressure and temperature during welding.
Dispense Zhao acknowledged support provided by the Advanced Robotics for Manufac-
turing (ARM) Institute (Pittsburgh, Pa., U.S.), the GrayMatter Robotics team led
Materials by Dr. Ariyan Kakir and the University of South Carolina team, led by Dr. Wout De
Backer and by Dr. Michael van Tooren (technical fellow structures at Collins Aero-
with space, previously at Univ. of S.C.) regarding induction welding. “We have a follow-
on program to further improve welding quality by applying machine learning,”
Precision says Zhao. “As the technology matures, our aim is to transition to a large part
demonstration.”
Increase your in bonded primary structures, metal and composites, as well as the welded thermo-
plastic composite rudders and elevators that are flying, due to the failsafe require-
production ments of current certification protocols. “Eventually, I think we’ll have enough confi-
dence for welded composite primary structures without crack arrest features,” he says,
efficiency and but conditions this on first building years of history and data, “like we have done for
Booth #T11 and more than 20 years of experience in the composites industry.
ginger@compositesworld.com
breton.it
Plant tour: AvCarb, Lowell, Mass., U.S.
» For the vast majority of applications of carbon fiber-reinforced Carbon fibers for fuel cells
polymers (CFRP), performance metrics revolve around light- AvCarb traces its history back to the 1960s, when it was best known as AVCO,
weighting and structural properties, such as strength, stiffness, which developed AVCOAT, a well-known ablative material used in the thermal
durability, toughness, crack resistance, corrosion resistance, protection system for NASA’s Apollo space program. Since then, the company
evolved to develop carbon fiber/phenolic friction products and, now, specializes in
weatherability and more. These have been and always will be the
the complex manufacture of carbon fiber fabrics and papers for electrode applica-
hallmarks of CFRP performance. tions in fuel cells and battery systems. Source (all images) | CW
There is one application, however, where carbon fiber’s proper-
ties are deployed in a different, non-structural, but just as impor-
tant way — in which high-quality carbon fiber-based products help Fuel cells 101
maximize the power-generating capability, and material forms To understand AvCarb, its manufacturing processes and its
manage the reactants of an electrochemical fuel cell reaction. That products, one first has to have a basic understanding of a fuel cell
application is the hydrogen fuel cell, and the carbon fiber product — its components and operation. Fuel cells come in a variety of
it uses is the gas diffusion layer (GDL), a thin, highly-engineered sizes and types, providing electrical power in drivetrains in myriad
carbon fiber paper composite, and a critical component in the fast- vehicles, including passenger cars and trucks, buses, long-haul
growing and rapidly evolving effort to leverage hydrogen as a tool trucks, trains and ships. They also can be used to provide stationary
to decarbonize the world’s energy supply. As important as GDLs power to residential structures and commercial buildings.
are to fuel cells, there are only a few companies in the world that Regardless of the application, all fuel cells operate in the same
have the experience and chemical and manufacturing expertise fundamental way, consuming hydrogen and using an electrochem-
required to produce them at sufficient quality and quantity. One of ical reaction to separate electrons from protons in each hydrogen
those companies is AvCarb, located in Lowell, Mass., U.S., and the atom. Following this separation, electrons are routed through an
focus of this plant tour. external circuit to produce electricity, before being moved to the
end of the process and the cell, where they unite with the hydrogen was acquired by Textron and the AVCO name lived on, as did the
protons and oxygen to produce water. AvCarb brand.
It’s important to understand the specific components of a fuel Masse says AvCarb’s next big application came in when it was
cell to appreciate the role AvCarb’s products play. It might be easiest approached by General Motors, which was experiencing inconsis-
to think of a fuel cell as two nearly identical back-to-back halves, tent slippage fleetwide on its transmission torque converters. This
each of which uses the same materials to perform different func- slippage, by itself, was not necessarily a problem. What GM needed
tions (Fig. ). On one side — left side, in Fig. — is a flow field was a material that could provide the same, repeatable slippage over
plate through which hydrogen is channeled. After it exits the flow the life of the transmission, thus allowing the engine to operate most
field plate, the hydrogen passes through the carbon fiber GDL efficiently. Masse says AvCarb’s solution was a carbon fiber/phenolic
(which includes a microporous layer — MPL), a thin graphitic layer friction material that, eventually, demonstrated consistent % torque
that acts as a moisture control barrier as well as an electrode that converter slippage for more than , miles. This friction material
diffuses the hydrogen before it passes through the anode layer. The was so successful that GM specified it on all of its - and -speed
anode layer is coated with a catalyst, typically platinum, that sepa-
rates hydrogen electrons from hydrogen ions (protons). The protons
are allowed to pass through the electrolyte at the center of the fuel
cell and into the cathode. The electrons are channeled through an
external circuit, where they generate an electric current.
Meanwhile, on the right side of the cell is another flow field plate
through which air is channeled before it passes through its own
GDL/MPL and then a cathode. Inside the cathode, the disparate
particles and atoms meet — hydrogen protons from the electrolyte,
hydrogen electrons from the external circuit and oxygen from the
air — to produce water molecules, which are then expelled from the
fuel cell as waste.
The efficiency of a fuel cell depends on its ability to convert as
many hydrogen atoms to electricity as possible, and the GDL is a
big part of this effort. The GDL must consistently and effectively FIG. 1 Fuel cell structure
diffuse the hydrogen across its surface to maximize the effect of the
Fuel cells come in a variety of sizes and designs, but all follow the same basic prin-
titanium catalyst on the anode. And that’s where AvCarb comes in. ciple. Hydrogen enters the cell from the left via a flow field plate, passes through
the GDL/microporous layer (MPL), enters the cathode and reacts with a catalyst
From friction to fuel cells (usually titanium). The catalyst separates the hydrogen into electrons (e-) and
CW’s tour of AvCarb starts in the company’s conference room, where and ions (H+). Electrons travel through a circuit that creates electricity. Ions travel
through the central electrolyte membrane and enter the cathode, on the right.
we are met by Guy Ebbrell, president, and Roger Masse, CEO. If
Electrons, after creating electricity, enter the cathode with oxygen from external air
there is institutional memory at AvCarb, then it exists almost entirely delivered via another flow field plate on the right. The ions, electrons and oxygen
in the form of Masse, who has worked for the company for 47 years, come together in the cathode to form water, which is emitted from the fuel cell as
starting third shift doing basic production work and then gradually waste. AvCarb’s specialty is the manufacture of the carbon fiber GDL.
moving up the ladder to the leadership position he holds today. Source | Jasna Jankovic, Ph.D., Materials Science and Engineering Dept., University of Connecticut
Masse relates the company’s history, which goes back to the early
s, when AvCarb started life in Lowell as Aviation Corp., or AVCO.
AVCO is best known for having developed AVCOAT, an ablative
material used in the thermal protection system for NASA’s Apollo
space program. AVCOAT -G consisted of an epoxy-novalac
resin system reinforced with quartz fibers and phenolic microbal-
loons. It was injected into a glass fiber honeycomb core that was
bonded to the entire outer shell of an Apollo crew module. That
entire system — honeycomb core infused with AVCOAT — provided
critical thermal protection for astronauts in the crew module.
Eventually, AVCO spun off its boron fibers business with the
creation of Specialty Materials (Lowell), which still operates today
and produces boron and silicon carbide fiber products. AvCarb,
meanwhile, was developed as a brand within AVCO, consisting of
FIG. 2 Stretch-breaking fibers
carbon fiber composite structures fabricated for space, defense,
Bundles of oxidized carbon fibers are shown here being drawn out of red barrels
friction, textile and other applications, that benefited from the
and into one of two stretch-breaking machines that AvCarb operates. Each fiber
carbonization technology on which the company was founded. is pulled through a stretch-breaking machine twice in preparation for the yarn-
AVCO continued to market its heat shield material. In , AVCO spinning process.
CompositesWorld.com 63
PLANT TOUR
transmissions for the next years and eventually licensed it to Ford to be really conductive and let that current go around the external
Motor Co. circuit. And then, here you are generating all this water. The GDL
“That drove a -% fuel efficiency gain on million vehicles needs to be able to dispel that water without drying the membrane
produced,” Ebbrell says. “So that’s a significant innovation. And out because the membrane must stay wet — but not too wet. In all,
that’s the beginning of how we started to have a really positive it is a very complicated high-performance composite structure that
environmental impact.” AvCarb remains a global leader in friction is fully graphitized and unique in the industry.”
products today. As AVCO entered the fuel cell market with its graphitic carbon
Also in the s, AVCO started to look at carbon fiber’s poten- fiber fabrics and papers for GDL applications, Textron decided
tial in electrode technologies. “Although all the friction business to focus solely on defense work and sold the company to Ballard
kept going strong, we really started putting all our R&D efforts into Power Systems (Burnaby, B.C., Canada) in . The AVCO name
fuel cells,” Masse says. “It was certainly a new market, but it was a went away as the company became Ballard Material Products, but
fledgling market. It was very small. But it gave us an opportunity to the AvCarb brand survived. Ballard challenged AvCarb to deliver
start looking at different properties and technologies. It was gas flow a world-class gas diffusion system for Ballard’s fuel cell systems,
versus liquid. We were used to dealing with transmission fluids, a which AvCarb did.
much more viscous fluid. Now we’re dealing with water and gas and In , however, Ballard went through a divestment phase of
we needed to design porosity of a different type. So we were adding its own and sold the AvCarb brand and technology to the current
particles in. We were dealing with all different types of graphitic management team, backed by private investors. The AvCarb brand
materials. It was fun. I mean, it was a whole new type of composite thus became AvCarb the company, and for many years it focused
for us — really a lot more complicated. Everybody had a different on diversification of products and markets and expanding its GDL
fuel cell design.” expertise for the hydrogen markets. Then, in late , private
This led to work in crystal formations and carbon/carbon by equity firm Arsenal Capital Partners (ACP, New York, N.Y., U.S.),
certain types of heat treatment, porosity development for GDLs, recognizing the growing importance of fuel cells in general as
fabrics manufacture and more. “Our expertise was in managing part of its sustainability push in its growth fund, and recognizing
material thickness, porosity, crystal formation and heat treatment,” AvCarb’s unique capabilities in particular, acquired AvCarb with
Ebbrell says. “That was and is our sweet spot and fuel cells needed the promise of significant capital investment. Since ACP’s invest-
these properties. They were right up our alley.” ment in late , AvCarb has invested significantly in capacity,
That alley, however, was thick with onerous material require- R&D and customer service to support the anticipated rapid growth
ments. “We learned pretty quickly that the GDL is absolutely critical,” of AvCarb’s fuel cell and other energy material forms. By early ,
Masse says. “It has to be chemically inert. It has to compress the AvCarb will have installed and commissioned the world’s largest
right amount and not too much. It cannot physically degrade. It has asset base for servicing the GDL needs of a growing global customer
base, with even more investment planned. targeted toward vehicle transmission applications.
Today, AvCarb’s fuel cell products represent a large majority of The feedstock for most of AvCarb’s products takes two forms:
the company’s revenues and clearly are a significant demand driver oxidized polyacrylonitrile (PAN) yarn or nonwoven carbon fiber
for the future. Masse notes that fuel cell technology is evolving paper. The use of these raw materials is central to AvCarb’s manu-
quickly, with a variety of increasingly complex designs entering the facturing expertise as it gives the company complete control over
market — different shapes, sizes, principles of operation — that the heat treatment process, which is critical to the development of
demand different GDL features and performance attributes. the material properties demanded by fuel cell and similar energy
It’s become incumbent on AvCarb to meet those needs. Masse systems. The use of oxidized PAN and nonwoven carbon fiber paper,
points to AvCarb’s unique mix of electrochemists, material scien- combined with the nature of the end products, also means that
tists and design engineers who help the company stand out and AvCarb’s manufacturing floor looks very different than a typical
drive the innovation needed to keep it ahead of the fuel cell tech- composites fabrication operation.
nology curve. “Our goal is to be the number
one provider of engineered carbon-based
products in growth areas that are impactful
to the planet’s future,” Masse says. “To do
that, we have to stay ahead of the market
technically, with sufficient capacity, and be
ready to address our customers’ needs as
they seek higher performance and global
supply chains.”
CompositesWorld.com 65
PLANT TOUR
Mongoose solutions are designed, built, and tested at Ingersoll Machine Tools,
in Rockford, IL, the U.S. Headquarters of Camozzi Machine Tools.
simultaneously looks back with pride on almost 50 years of plans to add capacity there as well if and when it is needed.”
technology evolution, and ahead with hope that the fast-growing Says Ebbrell: “Aspirationally, we want to be the number one
hydrogen economy will drive the company’s growth for the next 50 supplier of these engineered carbon solutions for alternative energy
years. Until AvCarb was acquired in late 2021 by ACP, Masse says markets as we uphold our long-standing history in ICE engines. We
the company had been struggling to find the capital required to talked about fuel cell electrolyzers, flow batteries and other technolo-
expand capacity. The company’s unique capabilities, combined gies that are developing in the new energy markets, and how our
with its relatively small size, made it somewhat vulnerable. years of experience in material science positions us for success. We
“I think that’s what puts us at this exciting point right now,” always start with a customer problem. We dig into that with them
Masse notes. “We have all the pieces we and we try to get an understanding of how a material behaves in the
need to support this growing market, all system, what makes it work, and how we can improve that perfor-
Read this article of these decarbonization applications for mance. And that is the story behind all of our successes.”
online | short. products that fuel cells need. I think the Of course, “doing it this way” has evolved over half a century —
compositesworld.com/
AvCarbpt only piece we were missing was having the much of it guided by Masse’s long and personal experience with
resources.” AvCarb. Still, he admits he’s close to retirement and might soon let
ACP, says Masse, had been eyeing the next generation take over. But for the man who started on third
AvCarb for some time as it sought a shift and then spent the next years working nearly every job AVCO
position in the hydrogen market. The had to offer, leaving is bittersweet. I asked Masse what he would have
decision by ACP to secure that position said if, years ago, someone told him that he’d one day be CEO. He
has given AvCarb the resources to expand pauses to think: “I would have laughed,” he says. “That would have
capacity to meet increase in demand for its made no sense whatsoever. Impossible to imagine.”
fuel cell, battery and friction products. This makes Masse particu-
larly excited that AvCarb is fully capable of helping meet the needs
of the global decarbonization marketplace on a large scale. Meeting
those needs will include expansion of AvCarb’s global footprint.
Jeff Sloan is editor-in-chief of CompositesWorld, and has been
“We want to locate near the customer,” Masse says, “and we see a engaged in plastics- and composites-industry journalism for
lot of growth coming out of Europe, so we expect to expand there. 26 years. jeff@compositesworld.com
We also see growth coming out of Asia, so we have well developed
20
A N NIVE
RS
AR
Y
HPC
Charter
Advertiser
+1.775.827.6568
training@abaris.com
www.abaris.com
LAST CHANCE
To Source the Materials, Innovations, and
Connections that Drive Performance.
JOIN US IN ANAHEIM
REGISTER NOW
Sign up for CAMX Connection and follow CAMX on
social media at #CAMX2022 for live updates during
the event.
theCAMX.org/registration
MANUFACTURING SUPPLIERS
SHOWCASE
VACUUM BAG
SEALANT TAPE
General Sealants industry leading portfolio includes 37 unique
product formulations showcasing products designed for cure
cycles from room temperature up to 800ºF (22ºC to 426ºC).
www.GeneralSealants.com | Contact at Sales@GeneralSealants.com or 800-762-1144
Products distributed worldwide by Airtech Advanced Materials Group www.airtechonline.com
PRESENTER: RUSS POWERS, Industry Technical Manager, Composites & Aerospace |Chem-Trend
PRESENTERS: GABRIEL BENARROCH, Product Sales Engineer | Trelleborg Sealing Solutions Albany
JOHN MICHASIOW, Mechanical Design Engineer | Trelleborg Sealing Solutions Albany
Scan QR Code
to Register:
Composites vs steel
The MAPICC 3D project (2011-2016)
realized a process capable of
producing net-shape preforms from
topology-optimized, high-perfor-
mance structural 3D thermoplastic
textile composites. The final product, a
GF/PP Volvo truck seat reinforcement
plate, was made in one shot using a
knitting technique. At 1.3 kilograms, it
weighs 2.7 kilograms less than its steel
predecessor — a reduction of 67.5%.
Source | Institute of Textile Machinery and High
Performance Material Technology, Technische
Universität Dresden
» Heavy-duty vehicle (HDV) transport is the automotive sector’s trailer. In markets like Brazil and Australia, every kilogram above the
most prominent climate problem. To illustrate, in the European front axle weight threshold requires - kilograms off the payload.
Union (EU), HDVs account for 22% of road vehicle emissions, Composites provide a lightweighting opportunity for the
though they represent less than 5% of the vehicles on the road. HDV industry’s weight issues, especially if they are structur-
To combat their effect on climate change, emissions legislators ally optimized to the given set of loads, boundary conditions and
reduce the emissions targets for HDVs every few years, pushing constraints to maximize the system’s performance. A lightweight
manufacturers to develop cleaner technologies. The European truck chassis could accommodate new lower emission powertrain
Commission recently proposed a 15% CO2 reduction by 2025 solutions before it reaches a weight threshold. This could also
compared to 2019, and a 30% reduction by 2030. enable increased payload, so transport firms could haul more
It is a similar story in the U.S. The California Air Resources cargo, improve the transport economy and reduce the number of
Board recently finalized its HDV Low NOx Omnibus Regulation, required journeys.
which phases in more stringent emissions standards starting in
model year (MY) ; these standards will be updated again in MAPICC 3D project
MY to target a % reduction in NOx emissions by . The To help realize industrialized lightweight vehicle components,
U.S. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration and Environ- the European Commission backed a project called MAPICC 3D
mental Protection Agency, which have had emissions and fuel- (2011-2016). It sought to develop a process capable of producing
efficiency standards for HDVs across the U.S. for over a decade, net-shape, high-performance structural 3D thermoplastic textile
are poised to follow suit. composite preforms with topology-optimized fiber reinforcement
Lower emission powertrains such as hybrid and electric solu- orientation made in one shot using a knitting technique.
tions, and exhaust gas treatment technology, generally increase The project included the development of virtual tools capable of
vehicle weight. In addition, HDV gross weight and axle loads are modeling D composite structures and predicting their mechan-
limited by their class which further compounds the challenge of ical behavior according to textile architecture and resin choice,
implementing these technologies. For example, for HDVs in the allowing for customized end products and better accessibility to
EU that weigh , kilograms when laden, every kilogram on the SMEs/OEMs. It also saw the development of thermoplastic hybrid
front axle above this weight means kilograms must be taken off yarns comprising both matrix and reinforcing fibers. The resulting
the payload to provide safe counterbalancing of the truck and the manufacturing process can precisely steer the fibers in three
weft
› Development of virtual tools to model › Development of thermoplastic hybrid › A one-shot process that precisely steers the
3D composite structures and predict their yarns comprising the matrix and fibers in three dimensions, tailoring them to the
mechanical behavior according to textile reinforcement. component’s load paths and allowing integrated
architecture and resin choice. mechanisms with minimal waste.
dimensions, tailoring them to the component’s load paths with tons) to replace a steel plate. The resulting composite part was to
minimal raw material waste. match the steel version’s technical requirements, including the
Twenty partners from countries fulfilled the MAPICC D strength needed to pass the mandatory ECE R seat belt anchorage
project’s manufacturing chain from raw materials to completed test for the N class vehicle, and realize significant weight savings.
component testing and verification. Key partners included Volvo Philippe Lefort, lead engineer for Volvo Group Europe, explained
Group Europe (Gothenburg, Sweden), Steiger Participations the rationale for choosing the seat reinforcement plate for the
(Vionnaz, Switzerland), Rajasthan Technical University (RTU, lightweighting study: “We developed a formula associated with
Kota, India), Institute of Textile Machinery and High Perfor- the vehicle’s balance to identify the location of the most effective
mance Material Technology at the Technische Universität Dresden weight saving. It determined that the weight reduction should be as
(TUD, Germany), Ecole Nationale Supérieure des Arts et Indus- far forward on the truck as possible for the largest axle load reduc-
tries Textile (ENSAIT, Roubaix, France), virtual testing specialist tion. The seat reinforcement plate is close to the front, has signifi-
Reden (Hengelo, Netherlands), Toray Advanced Composites (TAC, cant high-performance design criteria and is reasonably heavy. As
Nijverdal, Netherlands) and resin suppliers Axson Technologies such, it was the right challenge for this study.”
(now Sika Advanced Resins, Baar, Switzerland) and Huntsman The composite seat reinforcement plate replicates the steel
(The Woodlands, Texas, U.S.). version’s design to avoid cabin modification. As a first step to
Volvo Group Europe used the MAPICC D project to develop making the composite version, RTU conducted finite element
and validate a thermoplastic textile composite seat reinforcement analysis (FEA) on the steel reinforcement plate using Ansys Shell
plate for its N class truck (axle weight between . and . metric (Canonsburg, Pa., U.S.). Next, VISUAL CRASH PAM (ESI Group,
CompositesWorld.com 77
77
FOCUS ON DESIGN
peak load the bolts would see during the seat belt anchorage test. anchorage test deemed the structure a successful replacement for
The test results showed that the composite reinforcement plate the steel version.
needed -millimeter steel inserts to achieve this. We chose this for
the final structure with nuts and captive washers in addition to the The future of 3D knitted preforms
steel inserts for extra support.” The final glass fiber-reinforced PP Volvo truck seat reinforcement
Sika Advanced Resins and Huntsman oversaw the adhesive plate weighs 1.3 kilograms, 2.7 kilograms less than its steel prede-
bonding for affixing the composite seat reinforcement plate to the cessor, for a total weight reduction of 67.5%. The MAPICC 3D tech-
truck’s steel cabin floor. The companies nology achieved its goals of producing complex, production-ready
tested several types of adhesives from 3D preforms with controlled three-directional fiber placement —
Read this article online |
various chemical families with different and with the potential to integrate third-party components — in
short.compositesworld. stiffness and behaviors. PP is difficult one shot. The technology’s high design flexibility and low manual
com/MAPICC3D to bond due to its low surface energy, operations make manufacturing composite structures using this
so surface activation was needed to technique as versatile as 3D printing is for isotropic material struc-
increase the adhesion. Flame treatment tures. The limitations associated with manufacturing preforms are
was selected for this as it performed significantly reduced and so, too, are the design limitations of the
best in shear and intersection bond structures.
strength. The chosen adhesive was “Through this project, D knitted preforms from thermoplastic
Sika’s ADEKIT AA. hybrid yarns consisting of the matrix and reinforcing components
Volvo Group Europe tested the MAPICC D composite seat becomes a tool of significant economic output for vehicle indus-
reinforcement plate in a truck cabin on a seven-actuator dynamic tries,” notes Pierre-Yves Bonvin, CEO of Steiger Participations,
shaker rig. Volvo bolted the seat to the reinforcement plate and which developed the knitting machine for the MAPICC D project.
loaded it with a total of kilograms across the seat’s shoulder “We can now accomplish hyper-specialized workshops and make
and lap sections. Cables connected to an actuator pulled the D knitting a competitive composite manufacturing solution
weights forward in the cab during the ECE R seat belt anchorage compared to other technologies that are slower, more expensive,
test. Here, the main load interacting with the composite struc- polluting and wasteful.”
ture is a horizontal drag force. The composite seat reinforcement
plate surpassed the required N class .-kilonewton load on
the upper and lower torso without rupture, achieved . kilonew-
tons on the upper torso load and . kilonew tons on the lower Stewart Mitchell is a Bristol, U.K.-based engineering journalist
torso load before observed failure. At that load, severe deforma- with experience covering technology in Formula 1, electric and
tion of the seat rails led to complete adhesive rupture on the front hybrid powertrain and autonomous systems. He has a degree
in motorsport engineering from Oxford Brookes University
of the composite seat base. The performance of the MAPICC (Oxford, U.K.), and is a member of The Institution of Mechanical
D composite seat reinforcement plate in the ECE R seat belt Engineers (London, U.K.). smitchell@compositesworld.com
CompositesWorld.com 79
POST CURE
Post Cure
Highlighting the behind-the-scenes
of composites manufacturing
Thermoplastic composite
rebar optimizes construction
logistics
Customization
Customized Fabrics Reduce Upfront Costs
and Eliminate Waste
A&P delivers the exact width, material type, and
architecture required to enable easy manufacture
An 11” wide hybrid fabric with fiberglass bias yarns and carbon axials
meets A&P’s customer’s cost and performance requirements and superior performance.
Automation
Cost and Production Time Reduced
Through Automation
A&P’s overbraiding equipment supports high
volume applications enabling exact placement of
fibers providing optimized architectures, efficient
use of material, and reduced manufacturing time.
Thermoplastics
A&P’s Thermoplastic Offerings Enable Rapid
Cycle Time for High Volume Production
24” diameter
slit tape sleeving
4595 East Tech Drive, Cincinnati, Ohio 45245 • 513-688-3200 • sales@braider.com • www.braider.com