Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 4

DOI: 10.1111/exd.

12393
www.wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/EXD
Review

The maximal cumulative solar UVB dose allowed to maintain


healthy and young skin and prevent premature photoaging
Masamitsu Ichihashi1,2 and Hideya Ando3
1
Sun Care Institute, Osaka, Japan; 2Saiseimirai Clinic Kobe, Kobe, Japan; 3Department of Applied Chemistry and Biotechnology, Okayama
University of Science, Okayama, Japan
Correspondence: Masamitsu Ichihashi, Saiseimirai Clinic Kobe, Kobe Commerce, Industry and Trade Center Building 23F, 5-1-14 Hamabedori
Chuo-ku, Kobe 651-0083, Japan, Tel.: 81-78-862-1101, Fax: 81-78-862-1102, e-mail: mm_ichihashi@hotmail.com

Abstract: The young facial skin of children with a smooth healthy occupies 60% of the total daily UV dose, to obtain the maximal
appearance changes over time to photoaged skin having mottled UVB per hour in a day, and calculated the maximal daily UV
pigmentation, solar lentigines, wrinkles, dry and rough skin, exposure time that would delay the onset of solar lentigines until
leathery texture, and benign and malignant tumors after exposure 60 or 80 years of age. The mean daily sun exposure time to
to chronic, repeated solar radiation. The first sign of photoaging maintain healthy skin until 80 years of age in the summer was
in Japanese subjects is usually solar lentigines appearing around calculated to be 2.54 min (0.14 MED) for unprotected skin and
20 years of age on the face. Fine wrinkles can then appear after 127 min with the use of a sunscreen of SPF (sun protection
30 years of age, and benign skin tumors, seborrhoeic keratoses, factor) of 50. In this study, we did not evaluate the photoaging
can occur after 35 years of age in sun-exposed skin. We effect of UVA radiation, but findings of the adverse effects of
theoretically calculated the maximal daily exposure time to solar UVA radiation on the skin have accumulated in the last decade.
radiation, which could prevent the development of photoaged Therefore, it will be important to estimate the maximal dose of
skin until 60 and 80 years of age, based on published data of solar UV radiation to retard the onset of photoaging based on an
personal solar UVB doses in sun-exposed skin. One MED evaluation of both solar UVB and UVA in the future. Finally, we
(minimal erythema dose) was determined to be 20 mJ/cm2, and expect that this study may contribute to keeping Japanese and
200 MED was used as the average yearly dose of Japanese other types of skin young and healthy by limiting the exposure of
children. Further, we hypothesized that the annual dose of the skin to solar radiation outdoors during the day.
Japanese adults is the same as that of the children. The cumulative
Key words: cumulative dose – minimal erythema dose – photoaging –
UVB dose at 20 years of age was thus calculated to be 4000 MED,
solar lentigine – solar ultraviolet light – ultraviolet light protection
and 22 MED was used as the maximal daily UVB dose based on
data measured in Kobe, located in the central area of Japan. We Accepted for publication 24 March 2014
used the solar UVB dose from 10:00 a.m. to 14:00 p.m. which

Introduction lation in many countries. It is ideal for aged persons to work


The ageing of human skin is caused by genetic and environmental healthily and actively among young people with young skin and
factors, which disturb the functions and structure of epidermal and contribute to the public as active citizens as long as possible. The
dermal cells and extracellular matrix components. Among environ- first sign of photoaging of the skin develops around 20 years of
mental factors, solar ultraviolet (UV) B radiation (290–320 nm) age in Japanese, with a slight earlier trend of photoaging skin in
and UVA radiation (320–400 nm) are the most harmful ones, as people who live in southern parts where annual sunlight is higher
chronic exposure to solar radiation is known to induce skin photo- than in northern parts of Japan (9). The first signs of photoaging
aging. Skin photoaging is characterized by the development of pig- in Japanese are usually pigmented spots, particularly in Asians
mentary disorders, such as solar lentigines, as well as and wrinkles having moderate melanin contents in the epidermis. Secondly,
and benign, premalignant and malignant skin tumors on sun- fine wrinkles appear after 30 years of age. Benign skin tumors,
exposed skin (1–6). These skin alterations due to repeated chronic seborrhoeic keratosis, usually occur after 35 years of age among
solar UV exposure are mostly caused by solar UV-induced DNA Japanese.
damage of epidermal cells in each exposure. Most DNA damage is We aimed to theoretically calculate the maximal daily and
repaired by functional repair systems of cells, but only about 50% of yearly solar UVB dose acceptable that would prevent and retard
cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers produced by a single UVB irradia- the onset of photoaging until 60 and 80 years of age, based on
tion is repaired during the first 24 h (7). Therefore, the mutation published data reporting the daily and yearly solar UV doses, mea-
rate may increase in some cells after repeated exposure to high doses sured for a limited term or calculated from the outdoor activity
of UV, possibly due to ‘The rule of A’ operating in DNA synthesis at information, to which children, teenagers and adults are exposed
the sites where DNA damage remains unrepaired (8). (10). We calculated the daily and yearly cumulative dose as mini-
Life-span is extending steadily in developed countries, and aged mal erythema dose (MED). Further, we propose a maximal expo-
individuals over 70 years of age now occupy 20–30% of the popu- sure time per day and per year to solar radiation, with and

ª 2014 John Wiley & Sons A/S. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd
Experimental Dermatology, 2014, 23 (Suppl.1), 43–46 43
16000625, 2014, s1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/exd.12393 by CAPES, Wiley Online Library on [22/05/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
Ichihashi and Ando

without the use of high SPF- and PA-sunscreens to retard the first p.m. These were extremely high compared with other data in each
sign of photoaging until the age of 80. year of the same term at different Japanese locations. The maximal
Determination of one MED, and cumulative solar MED/day in Tsukuba (located nearest to Tokyo among the four
UV dose until the first onset of photoaging stations) was 30.83 KJ/m2, equal to 15.4 MED, recorded in July
In the beginning, we calculated the lifetime cumulative solar UV 2001. Further, the maximal daily UVB dose measured in Kobe
dose of Japanese subjects, based on the results reported by Ono between 1991 and 2001, using a Burger Meter was 22.0 MED in
et al. (10), because it is well recognized that the personal solar UV July, 1994. Considering these data, we used 22 MED as the maxi-
exposure dose directly measured by chemical, physical or biologi- mal daily UVB dose in this study as Kobe is located nearly in the
cal procedures is the best way to evaluate UV effects on human central area of Japan.
skin in relevance to dose response. We determined 200 MED to Proposal of recommended maximal yearly and
be the average yearly dose of Japanese, based on the results of daily UVB dose to retard the onset of photoaging
Ono et al. Further, we used 20 mJ/cm2 as one MED, based on a Recommended maximal yearly doses to retard the onset of solar
few reasons: firstly, one MED of Japanese is distributed from 20 lentigines until 60 and 80 years of age were calculated as follows:
to 60 mJ/cm2 (15–50 min exposure at midday in the summer) 4000 MED  60 years = 66.7 MED (until 60 years of age) and
depending on the Japanese skin phototype (11); secondly, Ono 4000 MED  80 years = 50 MED (until 80 years of age).
et al. estimated one MED for Japanese, based on their measure- The maximal daily MED to keep young and healthy skin with-
ment, to be 20 mJ/cm2. out solar lentigines until 60 and 80 years of age was then calcu-
Ono et al. (10). measured the solar UVB dose of Japanese chil- lated as follows:
dren aged 11 and 12 years using UV colouring labels attached on 66.7 MED/year  365 days = 0.18 MED for 60 years, and 50
their shirts at the upper arm in the morning for the entire day for MED/year  365 days = 0.14 MED for 80 years of age.
seven consecutive days at each of the four seasons. They then esti- Next, the MED was converted to the daily exposure time subjects
mated the yearly UV dose using outdoor activity records of chil- were allowed to spend outdoors in midday in clear summer radiat-
dren and UV irradiance at monitoring stations. Further, we used a ing the strongest solar UVB flux. As around 60% of the daily maxi-
report by Thieden et al. (12). showing that there are no significant mal dose of 22 MED is delivered during the 4 h from 10:00 to 14:00,
differences in UV dose among the age groups of children, teenag- we can calculate the UVB dose/ hr as follows; 22 MED 9 0.6 
ers and adults in Danish volunteers. There is a high variation of 4 = 3.3 MED. Therefore, the outdoor life time (9) allowed (OLTA)
annual UV radiation between Japan and Holland, and the daily during a day near noon in the summer is calculated as follows: 3.3
life style of Japanese adults exposing their skin to sunlight may MED: 0.18 MED = 60 min: 9, 9 = 3.27 min (60 years of age) and
not be exactly the same as that of Danish people. We hypothesized 3.3 MED: 0.14 MED = 60 min: 9, 9 = 2.54 min (80 years of age).
that Japanese adults receive an annual solar UV dose at the same In the spring (March and April) and autumn (October and Novem-
rate throughout their lifetime, and calculated the cumulative dose ber) season, the daily maximal dose is fixed as 1/2 of the summer
until 20, 60 and 80 years of age. Based on these assumptions, a season; therefore, the OLTA during a day is calculated to be
cumulative solar UVB dose estimated at 20 years of age when the 3.3 min 9 2 = 6.6 min (60 years) and 2.54 9 2 = 5.8 min
first solar lentigine usually develops was as follows; 200 MED/ (80 years), and in the winter season (December, January, February),
year 9 20 years = 4000 MED. the OLTA per day is calculated to be 3.27 min 9 5 = 16.3 min
Further, we determined the maximal cumulative solar UVB (60 years) and 2.54 min 9 5 = 12.7 min (80 years) (Table 1).
dose needed to maintain young skin until an older age based on Sunscreen can change our outdoor lifestyle in
two hypotheses as follows: A linear regression line obtained in an sunny midday
epidemiological study on the effect of solar radiation on the The mean daily sun exposure time allowed to keep young skin
development of photoaging, pigmented spots and wrinkles, which until 80 years was calculated to be from 2.54 min in the summer
was seen on the face of females who live in Kagoshima city and 12.7 min in the winter, which is too short to spend a com-
(located in the southern part of Japan) and Akita city (located in fortable outdoor life even in the winter. Therefore, we estimated
the northern part of Japan) where annual solar radiation is the time for outdoor life when people use a sunscreen with a
around 60% that of Kagoshima city, indicated that pigmented high SPF. When people use a sunscreen with an SPF of 50, they
spots usually first appear around 20 years of age in both cities. will be able to work and play outdoors for nearly 2 h, even in
Pigmented spots seem to develop earlier in Kagoshima, but a the middle of clear summer days near noon, as shown in the
detailed analysis of the age of first appearance of pigmented spots following:
was not carried out in that study (2). Further, based on our clini- The maximal UV exposure time/day is 3.27 min for keeping
cal observations of patients who visited our clinic with a com- young skin until 60 years of age, is extended to 163 min/day
plaint of pigmentary disorders, we speculated that the first sign of (3.27 min 9 50 = 163 min), and for people who want to delay
photoaging is solar lentigines that appear around 20 years of age the onset of solar lentigines until 80 years of age, the 2.54 min is
in Japanese females. extended to 127 min/day (2.54 MED 9 50 = 127 min). 163 and
Determination of maximal daily UV dose 127 min exposure may be long enough for Japanese outdoor
Next, we determined the maximal daily UVB dose based on data sports, such as football or beach volleyball, even though these are
measured among four locations in Japan from 1996 to 2009 by times allowed at the time of the strongest UVB flux. Therefore,
the Japan Meteorological Agency (13). The maximal daily dose our results suggest that we are able to spend more than 2 or 3 h
was 7 KJ/m2 recorded in Kagoshima in June, 1996, which is calcu- outdoors even on clear days in the summer in Japan with the use
lated as 35 MED/day and 5.25 MED/h from 10:00 a.m. to 14:00 of sunscreens having a high SPF.

ª 2014 John Wiley & Sons A/S. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd
44 Experimental Dermatology, 2014, 23 (Suppl. 1), 43–46
16000625, 2014, s1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/exd.12393 by CAPES, Wiley Online Library on [22/05/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
Maximal cumulative UVB dose to prevent photoaging

Table 1. Recommended daily solar UVB dose and time delay to the onset of solar lentigine with age

Solar UVB dose/year Solar UVB dose/day Time/day around noon (min)

Onset of solar With


lentigine Without sunscreen
2 2
(year of age) J/m MED J/m MED sunscreen of SPF 50

20 40 000 200 109.6 0.55 10.16 508


60 13 333 66.7 36 0.18 3.27 163.5
80 5000 50 28 0.14 2.54 127

Daily time recommended for keeping skin without solar lentigines, the first sign of photoaging of the skin among Japanese females, was calculated based on the 200
MED and solar UVB dose of 40 000 J/m2 which were accumulated till 20 years of age when the first solar lentigine appears. 200 MED and 40 000 J/m2 were used as
the minimal dose to produce solar lentigines, and the daily allowed exposure time till 60 and 80 years of age between 10:00 a.m. and 14:00 p.m. was calculated and is
2.54 and 3.27 min, respectively.

Importance of anti-ageing on the appearance of phosphate) oxidase, which stimulates PGE2 (prostaglandin E2)
facial and other sun-exposed skin synthesis, leading to skin inflammation (16). UVA occupies more
The average lifespan of Japanese is 86.39 years of age for females than 90% of solar UV radiation that reaches the surface of the
and 79.64 years of age for males, according to a national survey in earth and has been shown to produce DNA damage in the form
2012, and is expected to extend to an older age in the near future, of cyclobutane pyrimidine dimers (CPD) and oxidized bases,
possibly due to the ideal health insurance system of Japan that which may also contribute to the development of pigment spots
covers the entire Japanese population. The aged are expected to and skin tumors (17,18). In addition, UVA is thought to be highly
live by themselves without any help from others, as long as possi- immunosuppressive and has been shown to have interactive effects
ble, but at present, they need some help from others during the on the immune system with UVB radiation (19,20), because the
last 7 years before their death, due to their inability to conduct UVA dose at the surface of the earth is 20–50 times higher than
their own activities required for their daily lives, including cook- that of UVB, and it penetrates window glass and skin, even if a
ing, washing, cleaning and visiting hospitals for their medical care. high SPF sunscreen is applied. In addition, melanin bound with
Anti-ageing medicine is well recognized in Japan to be essential to lipid peroxides becomes darker, and keratinocytes with melanin-
allow the aged population to live healthily and happily as active oxidized lipid complexes are reported to detach more slowly from
members of society. Anti-ageing medicine also aims to make peo- the basal layer, leading to delayed epidermal turnover, which
ple keep young and healthy skin without photoaging until they results in increased levels of melanin pigment formation. There-
are older (14). In this study, we propose a maximal exposure time fore, the maximal dose of solar radiation necessary to retard the
allowed for outdoor life per day and per year to keep young and onset of photoaging and skin cancer development based on the
healthy skin without pigmented spots, wrinkles and skin tumors detailed evaluation of both UVB and UVA needs to be determined
until 60 and 80 years of age, based on assumptions and data in the future.
reported by other research groups and our own data. The time Wrinkle formation is understood to be caused by the acceler-
allowed for exposure per day to retard the onset of the first ated degradation and resulting decrease in collagen and elastic
photoaging skin sign, solar lentigines, until 80 years of age is fibres due to increased protease activities of matrix metallopro-
2.54 min around noon, in the summer, which is extremely short teinases (MMPs), which are triggered by reactive oxygen species
for comfortable outdoor life and sports. However, we are able to produced by solar UVB and UVA radiation (21,22). DNA damage
extend the time that can be spent outdoors playing sports and is reported to be involved in the upregulation of MMP mRNA
working more than one hr, even around noon time in the middle levels (23), but the precise role of DNA damage in the control of
of the summer by simply applying a sunscreen with a high SPF. MMPs is not yet clear.
In the winter, as average daily UV dose decreases roughly to 1/4– Recently, infrared A radiation was shown to be one factor that
1/5 that of the summer, so people are able to spend several hr induces wrinkles by increasing mRNA and protein levels of MMPs
outside in the sunshine if they use a proper sunscreen. Even in following the generation of reactive oxygen species (24,25). In the
the summer, we can spend a few hours under sunlight before 10 future, the role of infrared A radiation on the development of
a.m. and after 2 p.m., when the UV flux is low compared with the solar lentigines has to evaluated, because it occupies more than
time in the middle of the day. 59% of the solar radiation that reaches the earth’s surface.
Future study: determination of maximal daily Proposal of the mechanism of solar lentigine
exposure time to solar radiation evaluating the development
UVA and infrared radiation effects on photoaging We propose that pigmented spots are possibly caused by gene
In this study, we did not evaluate the role of solar UVA radiation mutations related to melanogenesis, as patients with xeroderma
in photoaging, but UVA has been shown to induce human skin pigmentosum (XP) (14) who have mutations in genes essential to
darkening by polymerization of monomer melanin, such as di- repair CPD, the most common type of DNA damage produced by
hydroxy-indole carboxylic acid (DHICA), by H2O2 produced UV, develop solar lentigines around 5 months of age after a few
within 24 h after exposure to UVA (15). Further, UVA has been sunburns caused by exposing the skin only several min for each
reported to induce reactive oxygen species in human keratinocytes sunbathing, and benign tumors develop on the face around 1 year
by the activation of NADPH (nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide of age, but no wrinkles develop during childhood (Fig. 1). In

ª 2014 John Wiley & Sons A/S. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd
Experimental Dermatology, 2014, 23 (Suppl. 1), 43–46 45
16000625, 2014, s1, Downloaded from https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/exd.12393 by CAPES, Wiley Online Library on [22/05/2024]. See the Terms and Conditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; OA articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License
Ichihashi and Ando

KC of normal UVB KC of solar lentigine

ET-1
ET-1
N N
Keratinocyte
SCF Keratinocyte
SCF
KGF/KGFR
αMSH

Melanocyte

Figure 2. Mechanisms of solar lentigine formation in skin chronically exposed to


Figure 1. A 6-month-old baby with xeroderma pigmentosum (XP) having a solar radiation. A stem cell of epidermal keratinocytes may have a mutation in the
number of pigmented spots on the face after a few sunbathing exposures. The promoter regions of genes that affect melanogenesis, such as stem cell factor
patient was diagnosed clinically with XP, as the baby developed a severe sunburn (SCF), endothelin-1 (ET-1) and a-MSH (a-melanocyte stimulating factor), after
each time after a short sun exposure, and was confirmed to have a mutation in his chronic solar UV exposure. This may result in a cell that produces an increased
XPA gene. level of one or more of these factors even after a single solar UV radiation. The
mutated stem cell proliferates and produces transit amplifying cells, which have the
same mutation as the stem cell, and may induce abnormally high levels of gene
healthy subjects, on the other hand, solar lentigines develop expression, stimulating melanocytes to produce abundant amounts of melanin,
around 20 years of age as mentioned previously (9). Aoki et al. resulting in large amounts of melanosome transfer to surrounding keratinocytes,
making pigmented spots called solar lentigines.
(26) showed the upregulation of tyrosinase related protein-1
(TRP-1) at the basal layer of solar lentigo skin of healthy Japanese, (including the skin) continues to increase in number to about
but they did not clarify the mechanism of the continued hyper- 6 billion cells in an adult.
melanosis in solar lentigines due to TRP-1 upregulation. Further, In the present study, we did not evaluate the effects of UVB
to prove our hypothesis that solar lentigines are caused by gene and UVA in photoaging during childhood, particularly in children
mutations of keratinocytes and /or melanocytes, we must demon- under 10 years of age, as we have no reliable data of the daily and
strate mutations of genes relevant to melanogenesis in cells, possi- yearly sun exposure dose of Japanese children under 10 years of
bly keratinocytes, which are located in the pigmented spots age.
(Fig. 2). Conclusions
Contribution of DNA damage during childhood to Finally, we expect that the present study, which proposes a maxi-
photoaging mal exposure dose and time to solar radiation per day and per
In addition, high dose exposure to sunlight during childhood year, may contribute to Japanese and other types of skin having a
under 10 years of age has been shown to increase the incidence of similar melanogenic activity to provide information to public edu-
skin cancer in Caucasians (27). Further, the rate of gene mutations cation campaigns to try to change behaviour and reduce exposure
in cells undergoing DNA synthesis is shown to increase by the rule to UV to maintain young and healthy skin as we age.
of ‘A’, substitution of C to T, after two divisions (8). The rule of Conflict of interest
‘A’ must take place more frequently in cells of children in whom The authors have no conflicts of interest that are directly relevant to the
DNA synthesis occurs more frequently than in adult cells, since content of this article.
about 0.3 billion cells, the total cell number of a baby at birth

References
1 Monestier S, Gaudy C, Gouvernet J et al. Br J 12 Thieden E, Philipsen P A, Standy-Moller J et al. J 20 Poon T S, Barnetson R S, Halliday G M. J Invest
Dermatol 2006: 154: 438–444. Invest Dermatol 2004: 123: 1147–1150. Dermatol 2005: 125: 840–846.
2 Akiba S, Shinkura R, Miyamoto K et al. J 13 Annual Report of Ozone Layer Monitoring. 21 Kang S, Fisher G J, Voorhees J J. Clin Geriatr
Epidemiol 1999: 9 (Suppl.): S136–S142. 2008. Japan Meteorological Agency March Med 2001: 17: 643–659.
3 Ueda M, Matsunaga T, Bito T et al. Photoderma- 2009. Maximal daily cumulative UVB dose and 22 Fisher G J, Kang S, Varani J et al. Arch Dermatol
tol Photoimmunol Photomed 1996: 12: 22–26. monthly mean daily UVB dose at Sapporo, Tsu- 2002: 138: 1462–1470.
4 Warren R, Gartstein V, Kligman A M et al. J Am kuba, Kagoshima, Naha and Syowa Station, 23 Dong K K, Damaghi N, Picart S D et al. Exp
Acad Dermatol 1991: 25: 751–760. Antarctica. Dermatol 2008: 17: 1037–1044.
5 Fisher G J, Wang Z Q, Datta S C et al. N Engl J 14 Ichihashi M, Ando H, Yoshida M et al. Anti- 24 Kim M S, Kim Y K, Cho K H et al. Mech Ageing
Med 1997: 337: 1419–1428. Aging Med 2009: 6: 46–59. Dev 2006: 127: 875–882.
6 Ichihashi M, Ueda M, Budiyanto A et al. Toxicol- 15 Maeda K, Hatao M. J Invest Dermatol 2004: 25 Schroeder P, Lademann J, Darvin M E et al. J
ogy 2003: 189: 21–39. 122: 503–509. Invest Dermatol 2008: 128: 2491–2497.
7 Young A R, Orchard G E, Harrison G I et al. J 16 Valencia A, Kochevar I E. J Invest Dermatol 26 Aoki H, Moro O, Tagami H et al. Br J Dermatol
Invest Dermatol 2007: 127: 975–978. 2008: 128: 214–222. 2007: 156: 1214–1223.
8 Taylor J S. Mutat Res 2002: 510: 55–70. 17 Rochette P J, Therrien J P, Drouin R et al. 27 Kricker A, Armstrong B K, English D R. Cancer
9 Hillebrand G G, Miyamoto K, Schnell B et al. J Nucleic Acids Res 2003: 31: 2786–2794. Causes Control 1994: 5: 367–392.
Dermatol Sci 2001: 27 (Suppl. 1): S42–S52. 18 Ikehata H, Kawai K, Komura J I, et al. J Invest
10 Ono M, Munakata N, Watanabe S. Photochem Dermatol 2008: 128: 2289–2296.
Photobiol 2005: 81: 437–445. 19 Stapelburg M P F, Williams R B H, Byrne S N
11 Kawada A. Photodermatol 1986: 3: 327–333. et al. J Invest Dermatol 2009: 129: 2694–2701.

ª 2014 John Wiley & Sons A/S. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd
46 Experimental Dermatology, 2014, 23 (Suppl. 1), 43–46

You might also like