19th BU Chemistry Colloquium on Student Researches

Scoring Sheet
Selection of “Best Oral Paper”

Agriculture, Aquatic, and Natural Resources (AANR)

Significance of Findings Manuscript/Write-Up Presentation
Creativity, originality, and quality of work Clarity of
Contribution to Relevance to Accuracy presentation,
Rationale,
new knowledge regional / Conceptual / of figures Clarity Cogency stage presence,
Code State-of-the-Art Total
on S&T national Objectives analytical and and style and logic voice
(to include
Advancement development (3) framework and language (3) (3) modulation, and
(analysis of the
(30) (30) methodology (10) (4) response to
problem) (7)
inquiries (10)

AANR1
AANR2
AANR3
AANR4
AANR5
AANR6
AANR7
AANR8

Name of Evaluator: Prof. Carlos V. Cortez, Jr.

 19th BU Chemistry Colloquium on Student Researches
Scoring Sheet
Selection of “Best Oral Paper”

Agriculture, Aquatic, and Natural Resources (AANR)

Significance of Findings Manuscript/Write-Up Presentation
Creativity, originality, and quality of work Clarity of
Contribution to Relevance to Accuracy presentation,
Rationale,
new knowledge regional / Conceptual / of figures Clarity Cogency stage presence,
Code State-of-the-Art Total
on S&T national Objectives analytical and and style and logic voice
(to include
Advancement development (3) framework and language (3) (3) modulation, and
(analysis of the
(30) (30) methodology (10) (4) response to
problem) (7)
inquiries (10)

AANR1
AANR2
AANR3
AANR4
AANR5
AANR6
AANR7
AANR8

Name of Evaluator: Prof. Jhunell A. Regala

 19th BU Chemistry Colloquium on Student Researches
Scoring Sheet
Selection of “Best Oral Paper”

Industry, Energy, and Emerging Technology (IEET)

Significance of Findings Manuscript/Write-Up Presentation
Creativity, originality, and quality of work Clarity of
Contribution to Relevance to Accuracy presentation,
Rationale,
new knowledge regional / Conceptual / of figures Clarity Cogency stage presence,
Code State-of-the-Art Total
on S&T national Objectives analytical and and style and logic voice
(to include
Advancement development (3) framework and language (3) (3) modulation, and
(analysis of the
(30) (30) methodology (10) (4) response to
problem) (7)
inquiries (10)

IEET1
IEET2
IEET3
IEET4
IEET5
IEET6
IEET7

Name of Evaluator: Dr. Al B. Besmonte

 19th BU Chemistry Colloquium on Student Researches
Scoring Sheet
Selection of “Best Oral Paper”

Industry, Energy, and Emerging Technology (IEET)

Significance of Findings Manuscript/Write-Up Presentation
Creativity, originality, and quality of work Clarity of
Contribution to Relevance to Accuracy presentation,
Rationale,
new knowledge regional / Conceptual / of figures Clarity Cogency stage presence,
Code State-of-the-Art Total
on S&T national Objectives analytical and and style and logic voice
(to include
Advancement development (3) framework and language (3) (3) modulation, and
(analysis of the
(30) (30) methodology (10) (4) response to
problem) (7)
inquiries (10)

IEET1
IEET2
IEET3
IEET4
IEET5
IEET6
IEET7

Name of Evaluator: Ms. Sherlyn M. Enovejas

 19th BU Chemistry Colloquium on Student Researches
Scoring Sheet
Selection of “Best Oral Paper”

Health & Health Systems Management (HHSM)

Significance of Findings Manuscript/Write-Up Presentation
Creativity, originality, and quality of work Clarity of
Contribution to Relevance to Accuracy presentation,
Rationale,
new knowledge regional / Conceptual / of figures Clarity Cogency stage presence,
Code State-of-the-Art Total
on S&T national Objectives analytical and and style and logic voice
(to include
Advancement development (3) framework and language (3) (3) modulation, and
(analysis of the
(30) (30) methodology (10) (4) response to
problem) (7)
inquiries (10)

HHSM1
HHSM2
HHSM3
HHSM4
HHSM5
HHSM6
HHSM7

Name of Evaluator: Dr. Charmaine A. Malonzo

 19th BU Chemistry Colloquium on Student Researches
Scoring Sheet
Selection of “Best Oral Paper”

Health & Health Systems Management (HHSM)

Significance of Findings Manuscript/Write-Up Presentation
Creativity, originality, and quality of work Clarity of
Contribution to Relevance to Accuracy presentation,
Rationale,
new knowledge regional / Conceptual / of figures Clarity Cogency stage presence,
Code State-of-the-Art Total
on S&T national Objectives analytical and and style and logic voice
(to include
Advancement development (3) framework and language (3) (3) modulation, and
(analysis of the
(30) (30) methodology (10) (4) response to
problem) (7)
inquiries (10)

HHSM1
HHSM2
HHSM3
HHSM4
HHSM5
HHSM6
HHSM7

Name of Evaluator: Prof. Daile Meek S. Membreve

 19th BU Chemistry Colloquium on Student Researches
Scoring Sheet
Evaluation for the “Best Student Poster Paper Award 2024”

Organization and Contribution to Online Response

Code Total**
Appeal (40) Knowledge (40) (20)*

AANR1

AANR2

AANR3

AANR4

AANR5

AANR6

AANR7

AANR8

IEET1

IEET2

IEET3

IEET4

IEET5

IEET6

IEET7

HHSM1

HHSM2

HHSM3

HHSM4

HHSM5

HHSM6

HHSM7

* to be filled out by the BU Chemical Science Society

** add the partial scores (a total of 80%)

Name of Evaluator: Prof. Dean Carlo F. Galias

 19th BU Chemistry Colloquium on Student Researches
Scoring Sheet
Evaluation for the “Best Student Poster Paper Award 2024”

Organization and Contribution to Online Response

Code Total**
Appeal (40) Knowledge (40) (20)*

AANR1

AANR2

AANR3

AANR4

AANR5

AANR6

AANR7

AANR8

IEET1

IEET2

IEET3

IEET4

IEET5

IEET6

IEET7

HHSM1

HHSM2

HHSM3

HHSM4

HHSM5

HHSM6

HHSM7

* to be filled out by the BU Chemical Science Society

** add the partial scores (a total of 80%)

Name of Evaluator: Prof. Johnor F. Bobiles