Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project Report
Project Report
Submitted By:
Supriya Thapa (078/MSEEB/019)
Submitted To:
Ar. Yam Prasad Rai
Project Supervisor
Tribhuvan University
Institute of Engineering
The comfort of pedestrians is substantially impacted by the pavement and sidewalk materials
used in urban areas. Dark substances absorb solar energy during the day and emit it again at
night. On the other hand, cool materials are frequently suggested for reducing UHI effects due to
their high albedo. Microclimatic advantages of light colored pavement are significantly high over
dark pavement materials. As a result, the thermal comfort of pedestrians can actually be affected.
This study quantifies and compares the local warming effects caused by the materials used in
Birgunj's hot and humid climate Street Canyon. It focuses on the impact of various materials on
outdoor thermal comfort in a prominent hot and humid climatic zone of Nepal. The study is
carried out in three phases of literature review, data collection and numerical validation at the
street level. In general, it was discovered that increasing the albedo by 0.1 resulted in a decrease
in surface temperature of close to 2.3°C. The study concludes that by increasing the albedo of
pavement material from 0.2 to 0.35 alone, a thermally comfortable street space could be created.
First and foremost, I would like to express my sincere gratitude to my project supervisor Ar.
Yam Prasad Rai and for providing me the opportunity of carrying out research in the context of
the pavement material for pedestrian comfort in Nepal. I am also grateful to Dr. Sanjaya Uprety
for the valuable comments and guidance during the research process. The making of this report
has been one of the significant challenges I have faced and without their constant support and
guidance, the task wouldn’t have been completed on the allocated time.
Also, I would also like to thank Department of Architecture, Pulchowk Campus for providing
this opportunity to help me devote time to this report. I are indebted to have this opportunity to
work on the report where I was encouraged and guided thoroughly and provided untiring,
preserving, and unflinching help by my respected teachers. This report also helped us to improve
my critical thinking ability and data analysis ability. I am also thankful to my friends and seniors
for guiding me and helping me directly or indirectly to complete this Project Report.
Table of Contents
1 Introduction............................................................................................................................1
1.1 Background.......................................................................................................................1
1.2 Need of the study..............................................................................................................2
1.3 Importance of the study.....................................................................................................4
1.4 Problem statement.............................................................................................................4
1.5 Objectives of the Research................................................................................................4
1.6 Methodology.....................................................................................................................5
1.7 Expected Outputs..............................................................................................................5
2 Literature Review..................................................................................................................6
2.1 Road Types in Nepal.........................................................................................................6
2.2 Outdoor thermal comfort..................................................................................................8
2.3 Variables determining the pavement surface temperature................................................9
2.3.1 Urban canyon, solar irradiance and microclimate.....................................................9
2.3.2 Urban canyon albedo...............................................................................................10
2.3.3 Albedo and surface temperature..............................................................................11
2.3.4 Cool pavements.......................................................................................................12
2.4 Research Findings...........................................................................................................13
2.5 Reflective Paints and Pavements....................................................................................18
3 Case Study............................................................................................................................20
3.1 A case of Phoenix, Arizona.............................................................................................20
3.2 A case of Nangal, Punjab................................................................................................22
4 Introduction to Case area...................................................................................................24
5 Climate Analysis..................................................................................................................25
5.1 Temperature....................................................................................................................25
5.2 Relative Humidity...........................................................................................................27
5.3 Rainfall and Precipitation................................................................................................28
5.4 Wind Speed.....................................................................................................................29
5.5 Psychrometric chart.........................................................................................................30
6 Site Study..............................................................................................................................31
6.1 Deep canyon Analysis.....................................................................................................32
6.2 Shallow canyon Analysis................................................................................................33
6.3 Surface temperature Analysis.........................................................................................34
7 Improvement Strategies......................................................................................................35
8 Numerical Validation..........................................................................................................36
9 Discussion and Conclusion..................................................................................................37
References......................................................................................................................................38
List of Figures
List of Tables
1.1 Background
The spaces around us in which we take shelter and those which we interact with are part of our
everyday social reality. Outdoor spaces are important to a sustainable city as they are the spaces
that link the public with the urban built context while accommodating daily pedestrian traffic and
various outdoor activities. Outdoor space is often referred to as a space among the building
entities where human and nature exchange information, materials and energy. It is as important
as the indoor living spaces as it allows the people to interact with nature through day to day
physical, socio- cultural or economic activities.
The inevitable linkage of the human to its outdoor environment is held by the comfort created
between one another. In the recent years, urbanization has taken over a huge portion of the land
along with the degradation of its environment. The changes in the micro climate is one of its
major effects where we can clearly feel the alteration in climatic factors like air temperature,
humidity and rainfall. Out of all the effects, the urban heat island still prevails as one of the most
prominent problems that we can see in the hot and humid streets in Nepal. Due to the
unavailability of the land, the building designs have taken the vertical expansion as a matter of
accommodation. The phenomenon of vertical residential design forms a building cliff called
urban canyon phenomenon (Firdausah & Wonorahardjo, 2018). An urban canyon (also known as
a street canyon) is a place where the street is flanked by buildings on either sides creating a
canyon-like environment. For larger areas of a city the thermal response is a function of the
aggregation of urban canyon units (Offerle, Eliasson, & Grimmond, 2007). 30% of solar thermal
energy is absorbed and stored by canyon material and released at night with the result increasing
the ambient temperature. The increasing of the air temperature in the urban at night and the
temperature difference between urban and peri urban is an indication of heat island phenomenon
(Nunez & Oke, 1977)).
(Santamouris, Papanikolaou, Koronaki, & Livada, 1999) found a high intensity of the heat island
with an increase in air temperature of 13°C around the canyon at night due to anthropogenic heat
1
and the use of heat absorbing material. The air temperature in urban area have been found to be
greater than their surrounding areas. The urban heat island is an urban area that is lot warmer
than the rural areas surrounding it, which is a reflection of the micro climatic changes brought on
by human modification to urban surface. Thus a biophilic and a bioclimatic planning approach
can help in mitigation of all the unfavorable outdoor climatic conditions. (Speak & Salbitano,
2022) mentioned local physical characteristics of the sites : Sky View Factor (SVF), tree shade,
ground surface cover, and canyon effect, can affect human exposure to potentially uncomfortable
thermal conditions during a typical summer. (Akbari, Kurn, Bretz, & W., 1997) reported that the
UHI measured at the canopy layer may exhibit high spatial and temporal variation as a result of
the variable thermal properties of the urban construction materials that in combination with the
three-dimensional geometry of built-up surfaces modifies neighboring air temperatures.
Out of the material properties, albedo is the most important with regards to how pavements
interact thermally with the environment when exposed to sunlight. Thermal emittance, thermal
conductivity, and specific heat capacity of the materials are second order factors (Li, Harvey,
Holland, & Kayhanian, 2013). The thermal behavior of pavements and other ground surfaces, as
well as the effects that this thermal behavior has on people and the environment, are significantly
influenced by albedo (or solar reflectance). The direction of sensible heat flux is upward when
the temperature of the ground surface is higher than that of the near-surface air above it, which
causes the temperature of the canopy layer air to rise. Contrary to many rural locations, where
vegetation cover and soil moisture evaporation may reduce the increase in surface temperature
that results from the absorption of solar radiation, a sizable component of urban regions is made
up of dry impermeable materials, such as pavement or buildings. Several researchers have
recommended that to reduce the heating of such surfaces, wherever possible, they should have a
high albedo.
Thermally comfortable streets promote walkability and sustainability. Urban forms significantly
affects urban climate, which has an impact on street-level outdoor thermal comfort. Thus, it is a
promising place for raising the temperature of the outdoors. In order to reduce discomfort from
2
heat at the pedestrian level, street design is a crucial factor in bioclimatic urban development. As
far as the ambient environment allows, it is necessary to keep urban streets comfortable in order
to build and maintain walkability. Street design is an important issue in bioclimatic urban
development to mitigate thermal discomfort in pedestrian level. Since, the temperature ranges
between 22°C to 41°C in Subtropical region of Nepal, it is difficult to carry out outdoor activities
during daytime.
In the context of Nepal, there are not many research done to reduce the surface temperature to
make the streets walkable in hot summer days. The pavement type selection process, as stated by
the Ministry of Physical Infrastructure and Transport Department of Roads, includes primary and
the secondary factors. The primary factors include the traffic, soil characteristics, weather,
construction considerations, recycling and the cost construction. Whereas the secondary factors
include the performance of the similar pavement in the area, adjacent existing pavement,
conservation of material and energy, availability of local materials, traffic safety, carrying out the
experiments, promotions of competition and preferences f local industries. Both the factors do
not cover the area of heat reflectance property of the pavement material and pedestrian level
thermal comfort. Thus it is of utmost importance to have a thorough study of the pavement
properties in order to create a thermally comfortable streets in the hot and humid climate of
Nepal.
3
Figure 1 Pavement type selection process
The research aims to find out the surface reflectance of various pavement materials for hot and
humid climate of Nepal and that will help to lower the thermal structure , both air and surface
temperature, during hot season. Hence, this research will help urban planner, energy efficient
planner, policy makers, and designers to create thermally comfortable streets in hot and humid
region of Nepal. This research will also help local authority to consider the pavement material
for the new urban development project. Ultimately, this research aims to help the common
people to walk and conduct business activities in a thermally comfortable street This research
will help urban planners, policy makers, designers to create framework for high performing
street in hot and humid region of Nepal.
Climate change is unavoidable and its effects will be higher in coming days. The most affected
area by climate change is urban outdoor areas as indoor spaces can be conditioned through
mechanical means. The amount and the intensity of outdoor activities are affected by the level of
the discomfort experienced by the inhabitants when they are exposed to the climatic conditions
in these outdoor spaces (E.Wilson, F.N.col, L.N.nayakkara, & A.U.berjahn-tritta, 2008).
During the summertime, elevated surface and air temperatures can have a number of undesirable
health and environmental impacts causing increased human and ecosystem discomfort, UHI
would exacerbate heat waves, which can lead to serious health issues. The UHI can worsen air
quality by promoting ground-level ozone formation. Despite the problem, designers are more
attracted to the impact of environmental forces on indoor climate of the buildings, design
strategies, and passive solar gains rather than outdoor thermal comfort (Shafaghat, Manteghi,
Keyvanfar, & Lamit, 2016).
4
1.5 Objectives of the Research
The major objective of the study is:
• To investigate the thermal structure (air and surface temperature) of various pavement on
regular street canyons and examine the pedestrian thermal comfort.
1.6 Methodology
The research will be carried out in three phases basically, starting from liter ature review which
includes a general description of street design and its relationship with albedo, microclimate,
aspect ratio and solar access. The second phase deals with the field study of including the
pavement material, Sky View Factor and aspect ratio calculation, pavement temperature and the
market availability of the pavement materials from existing urban configuration. The third phase
includes a numerical validation and the results will be evaluated and concluded.
5
• Cool pavement materials providing the maximum reflectance of the solar radiation.
• Strategies to improve thermal structure of streets by providing potential material
properties in future use in the urban development and urban planning processes.
2 Literature Review
2.1 Road Types in Nepal
According to Nepal Urban Road Standard 2076, the urban roads are classified as follows:
Sub-arterial Roads (Sadak): These are the roads of the somewhat lower levels of travel mobility
than the arterial roads.
Collector Roads (Marg): A collector road is one intended for collecting & distributing traffic to
and from local roads & also providing the access to arterial/sub-arterial roads.
Local Roads (Upa-Marg): A local road is one primarily intended for access to the residence,
business, and other abutting property.
6
7
A local road is one primarily intended for access to residence, business or other abutting
property. Such a road normally does not carry large volume of traffic. A local road may be
residential, commercial or industrial, depending upon the prominent use of the adjoining land.
Such roads are taken for the study which may pr may not have pedestrian sidewalks.
Thermal comfort is the condition of mind that expresses satisfaction with the thermal
environment and is assessed by subjective evaluation (ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 55). Thermal
comfort is a difficult notion to evaluate in either an indoor or outdoor setting since it
encompasses physical, physiological, or psychological factors.
Six main variables that directly affect thermal comfort can be divided into two categories:
personal variables, which are occupant characteristics, and environmental variables, which are
features of the thermal environment. Metabolic rate and level of clothing are the former two,
while air temperature, mean radiant temperature, air speed, and humidity are the latter two.
Standards typically relate to a constant state to study even if all of these variables may change
over time.
Figure 2 Relationship between the thermal comfort and surrounding environmental settings.
The urban canyons are flanked by the buildings on either sides and forms a canyon like
environment which in fact is a space of heat collection and dissipation. The amount of heat
absorbed in a canyon is directly related to the incident solar radiation on the surface and this
amount of solar radiation is determined by a factor called Sky View factor. The sky view factor
(SVF) is the ratio of the visible sky area of a point in space to the total sky area.
Figure 3 Illustration of Sky view factor in a street canyon Figure 4 Skyline graph and sky view factor
The higher the SVF the more solar radiation will potentially be received by a horizontal surface,
and studies have reported a positive correlation between moderate to high sky view factor (SVF)
values and land surface temperature (LST).
In a canyon with higher SVF, the ambient air remains heated up and the surface temperature of
the street along with the temperature of the building envelope material increases significantly
creating a hot and uncomfortable walking condition for the pedestrian in a hot summer day. On
the contrary, a canyon with a lower SVF will have a cool and comfortable thermal condition.
Thus a microclimate of an urban is a correlational to the solar radiance and its Sky View Factor.
The albedo quantifies the reflecting power of a surface on a scale from 0 to 1. In urban
climatology, the albedo can be quantified at different scales: at the local-urban scale for the
whole urban surface (i.e. urban fabric) or at the scale of individual facets (i.e. roads, façades,
roofs (Salvati A. , Kolokotroni, Watkins, & Richard, 2022). The reflecting power of individual
facets is expressed in terms of surface albedo – or solar reflectance (SR) – given by the ratio of
the reflected to the incident solar radiation over a horizontal plane. Measured SR can reach
values up to 0.95 for advanced ultra-white materials or be as low as 0.05 for dark materials such
as fresh asphalt (Salvati A. , Kolokotroni, Watkins, & Richard, 2022).
10
Figure 6 Interconnections between surface albedo, urban canyon albedo, outdoor thermal comfort and building indoor thermal
environment
Source: http://thebritishgeographer.weebly.com/urban-climates.html
11
The table 1 shows the albedo value of various pavement materials. This indicates that the albedo
increases on increasing the light coloured pigment on the materials.
2.3.4
Cool pavements
The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) defines cool pavement as paving materials
that reflect more solar energy, enhance water evaporation, or are otherwise modified to remain
cooler than conventional pavement to mitigate the UHI effect. Solar reflective "cool" pavements
stay cooler in the sun than conventional pavements. Existing pavements could be made "cool" by
many techniques.
12
cement blended with light color slag. Other reflective pavements using reflective coats on
already existing Pavements.
Figure 10 Working of Reflective coating on asphalt pavement Figure 11 Cool pavement and surface temperature reduction
Figure 10 shows the working of reflective coating on asphalt pavement where by the application
of high albedo dark colored paint coating on pavement surface has a high reflection of the infra-
red radiations. The traditional asphalt with a temperature of 121°C can be reduced as low as
106°C by the application of solar reflective cool pavement as shown in Figure 11.
(Erell E. , Pearlmutter, Kutiel, & Bar, 2013), did a simulation to find out the changes in the
ambient temperature with relation to the pavement albedo of canyons with various aspect ratios.
The simulation included the weather stations of four cities, Eilat, Singapore, Adelaide and
Goteborg in East- West and North- South orientation. On increasing the albedo from 0.2 to 0.7,
all the cities experienced a lowered air temperature on both orientation of the streets. This shows
that the surface and the air temperature reduction is not affected by the orientation of the street
13
but is affected by the albedo of the pavement surfaces. Also the albedo comes into effect for
cities with temperate to hot climates.
Figure 12 The difference between the predicted air temperature in each of the urban canyon scenarios and the measured
temperature at the respective reference weather stations, at 12:00 (Erell E. , Pearlmutter, Kutiel, & Bar, 2013)
The research papers of last thirty years were reviewed that discussed about the changes in
ambient temperature and pavement temperature on altering the albedo. (Kusuda, 1975), stated
that just by changing the albedo only by applying of white paint on dark asphalt, a reduction of
maximum daily surface temperature over 7°C could be done.
(Mattheos Santamouris & T. Karlessi, 2011) did a park renovation project in Athens, Greece,
implementing high-albedo paving that resulted in a decrease of 1.9 °C in peak temperatures. A
maximum temperature difference of 7.6 °C between conventional tiles and cool pavement’ on a
hot summer day was obtained. Also the authors concluded that the reduction of peak air
temperature is estimated at 0.57–2.3 °C for every 0.1 increase in urban albedo, equivalent to a
total effect of 1–3.5 °C.
14
The effect of changing albedo on the pedestrian thermal comfort was also studied. Studies
showed that the increment in the reflectance of the pavement materials can cause a discomfort
due to increased interreflections between surfaces. Use of high-albedo materials in canyon
surfaces may lower air temperature, the reduction is not enough to offset increased radiant loads.
As a result, pedestrian thermal comfort may in fact be compromised (Salvati A. , Kolokotroni,
Watkins, & Richard, 2022). The summarized research findings is shown in the tables below.
15
Table 2 Summary of Research findings
1. The effect of ground cover on earth (Kusuda, 1975) • Changing surface albedo alone, by application of
temperature. white paint to dark asphalt, was reported to have
resulted in a reduction of maximum daily surface
temperature of over 7°C.
2. Mitigation of urban heat islands: materials, (H. Rosenfeld, et al., • Application of practical changes in the albedo of
utility programs, updates. 1995) materials, could reduce summertime peak air
temperature by as much as 1.5 °C.
3. Development of a zero-dimensional meso (Bhardwaj & Golden, • Air temperature reductions could be achieved
scale thermal model for urban climate. 2009) ranging from 0.5 to 5°C, depending on assumptions
regarding the extent of high albedo surfaces.
4. Improving the microclimate in urban (Gaitani, Spanou, & • A potential air temperature reduction of 1–2 °C in a
areas: a case study in the centre of Athens Synnefa, 2011) public square through implementation of cool
paving.
16
S.N Title Author Findings
5. Environmental Design of Urban Buildings: (Santamouris M. , 2012) • Cool pavements reduced the peak ambient air
An Integrated Approach. Taylor & Francis temperature by up to 1.9 °C, and the ground surface
temperature was reduced by 12 °C.
6. Using advanced cool materials in the urban (Mattheos Santamouris & • A maximum temperature difference of 7.6 °C
built environment to mitigate heat islands T. Karlessi, 2011) between conventional tiles and cool pavement’ on a
and improve thermal comfort conditions hot summer day was obtained.
• A park renovation project in Athens, Greece,
implementing high-albedo paving resulted in a
decrease of 1.9 °C in peak temperatures.
• The reduction of peak air temperature is estimated
at 0.57–2.3 °C for every 0.1 increase in urban
albedo, equivalent to a total effect of 1–3.5 °C.
7. Heat mitigation strategies in winter and (Taleghani M. , • The air temperature was reduced by 1.3 °C
summer: field measurements in temperate Tenpierik, Sailor, & J., compared to a dark pavement (albedo of 0.37) in
climates. 2014) the temperate climate of Portland.
8. Comparing the effects of urban heat island (Wang & Akbari, 2016) • It would be possible to reduce the average air
mitigation strategies for Toronto, Canada temperature by up to 0.8 °C at mid-day and 0.6 °C
at mid-night during the hot summer days
17
9. Urban canyon albedo and its implication (Qin, 2015) • Reflective pavements can be used only if an urban
on the use of reflective cool pavements canyon has an aspect ratio no greater than 1.0.
10. Impact of reflective materials on urban (Salvati A. , Kolokotroni, • Increasing surface reflectance in urban canyons has
Watkins, & Richard,
canyon albedo, outdoor and indoor a detrimental impact on outdoor thermal comfort,
2022)
microclimates due to increased interreflections between surfaces.
11. Effect of high-albedo materials on (Erell E. , Pearlmutter, Kutiel, & • Use of high-albedo materials in canyon surfaces
Bar, 2013)
pedestrian heat stress in urban street may lower air temperature, the reduction is not
canyons enough to offset increased radiant loads. As a
result, pedestrian thermal comfort may in fact be
compromised.
12. The effect of pavement characteristics on (Berardi, 2021) • Although the increase of reflectivity of pavement
pedestrians' thermal comfort in Toronto reduces the air temperature, it reduces the thermal
comfort at the pedestrian level.
18
2.5 Reflective Paints and Pavements
The surfaces could be made cool by the application of reflective paints also called as cool paints.
Various cool pavement paints have been developed that has been successfully experimented and
shown to ave reduced the surface temperature. The summary of the temperature decrement is
summarized in the table below.
6. Solar Nanjing, China 8.5 °C–9.5 °C subtropical (Sha, Liu, & Li,
Reflective climate 2017)
pavement
(self
developed
paint)
19
Table 5 Summary of reflective pavements
Light aggregate Replacing with wasted 0.52 4.4°C (Guntor, Din, &
tiles, sand and epoxy Iwao, 2014)
resin
black asphalt Yellow, beige, green, 0.26, 9.0, 7.0, 5.0, (Synnefa,
and red asphalt 0.31, and 4.0°C Karlessi, &
0.10, Santamouris,
and 0.11 2014)
20
3 Case Study
Heat is absorbed and held in by asphalt throughout the day and released at night. Due to the heat
being trapped within the built environment, Phoenix is one of several cities that are experiencing
the urban heat island effect. According to data from the United States Environmental Protection
Agency, nighttime temperatures in heat island regions can vary by up to 22 degrees higher than
those observed outside the heat island. Increased energy demand, greenhouse gas emissions, air
pollution, and other negative impacts are brought on by higher nighttime temperatures.
With the use of cool pavement on neighborhood streets, Los Angeles has had succeeded in
lowering road surface temperatures. Phoenix aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of the cool
pavement technology and material in lowering temperatures in the city's desert environment. The
pilot program included the cool street pavement of eight different streets in a residential area in
Phoenix.
Source: https://www.phoenix.gov/streets/coolpavement
21
The findings from the one year observation of the program included the temperature and comfort
data which included the following:
22
3.2 A case of Nangal, Punjab
Nangal is a town in Rupnagar district in Punjab, sandwiched between sub-tropical hot climate of
Punjab and Cool temperate climate of Himachal Pradesh, India. The area has a humid subtropical
and dry winter climate. The summers are extreme hot and humid whereas the winters are mid to
moderately cold in winters. The temperature goes as high as 42 °C in summer and as low as 5 °C
in winters. The study area is closely related with the climatic area of the hot humid climate of
Nepal and has many resemblances in its climatic characters.
The Punjab Government has made use of the precast concrete slabs in the streets with residential
and commercial market areas in both urban as well as rural areas. Although the use of the
concrete slabs isn’t intended to reduce the surface temperature, it is used because of its
durability. The arterial streets which is asphalt paved also consists of market areas which is less
vibrant in daytime and people often prefer walking in the evening for commercial activities in
such streets. Whereas in the streets with concrete slabs, the place is quite chaotic and hectic even
in daytime as compared to the asphalt paved streets. This shows that the concrete having more
albedo than that of the asphalt has higher reflectance of the incoming solar radiation and thus
makes the streets thermally comfortable. The hectic nature of the concrete streets shows the
comfort of the pedestrian during daytime.
Figure 15 Concrete surface as cool pavement Figure 16 Concrete surface as cool pavement
23
The climate of the Nangal is hot and humid throughout the summer. According to Meteoblue,
the average annual maximum temperature is 33.58 °C and average annual minimum
temperature is 14.58 °C. Temperature remains more than 30°C from April to October and
above 35 °C from April to September which may exceed to above 40 °C during April to July.
Figure 17 shows the average temperature and precipitation and Figure 18 shows the
maximum temperatures in Nangal.
24
4 Introduction to Case area
Many existing streets are Asphalt blacktopped, concrete premix, earthen and
gravel topped. Very few streets have pedestrian sidewalks which have
concrete blocks. The streets play an important role in the daily commute of
the residents. The urban streets in Birgunj is classified into arterial and the
local ones. The streets taken for the study are the local streets which may or
may not have the pedestrian sidewalks but people use them for daily
commute and located in the residential and the commercial spaces. Streets
Figure 22 Asphalt street with concrete blocks in sidewalks Figure 23 Earthen street
Figures above show the various pavement materials in the streets of Birgunj.
5 Climate Analysis
Climate data for the Birgunj are acquired from a variety of sources. Secondary data sources
included the data from Climate consultant and Meteoblue, which are collected and analyzed. The
Department of Hydrology and Meteorology does not have data for 2014, 2015 and 2018 and also
present data is not enough for complete climate analysis. Climate has been analyzed on the basis
of its temperature, Relative Humidity, Precipitation and wind speed. The climate of Birgunj is
sub-tropical monsoon with a very hot and humid summer. People feel very warm and muggy
throughout the summer.
5.1 Temperature
26
According to Meteoblue, the average annual maximum temperature is 31.6 °C and average
annual minimum temperature is 17.9 °Temperature remains more than 30°C from July to
October and above 35 °C from April to June which may exceed to above 40 °C during April to
June. According to climate consultant, the average annual maximum temperature is 29 °C and
average annual minimum temperature is 14 °C.
Source: meteoblue
Source: meteoblue
27
Figure 26 shows the average temperature graph from meteoblue, Figure 27 shows the maximum
temperature graph obtained from meteoblue and Figure 28 shows the average temperature graph
obtained from climate consultant.
Source: meteoblue 29
Figure 32 Precipitation amount graph
Source: meteoblue
5.4 Wind Speed
30
Figure 35 Windrose diagram
Source: meteoblue
The bioclimatic chart is very effective tool for analyzing the comfort condition. The chart is used
to plot the average maximum and minimum temperature and the average maximum and
minimum relative humidity. Identifying a suitable strategy for a given location can be made
using bioclimatic charts based on the thermal comfort conditions of that particular location. The
Psychrometric chart was obtained from climate consultant and following data were obtained.
31
• Active cooling is required from May-August.
Figure 36 PsychrometricChart
The winter comfort ranges from 22 °C to 26 °C and the summer comfort range from 25 °C to
28 °C.
6 Site Study
The Streets were analyzed based on their aspect ratio and sky view factors. Different streets
canyons were taken for the study that had varying aspect ratios and Sky View factors. The aspect
ratio of canyons were calculated by the formula,
Aspect ratio of canyon= height of the building/ width between the buildings
Similarly the 2D sky view factor was calculated. From a 2D perspective the SVF from a point in
the street canyon is estimated as (DeWolff, 2008) .
32
6.1 Deep canyon Analysis
• Deep canyons (aspect ratio >1) have shadow effect that makes the streets cool.
• Sky view factor is less (<0.3) in deep canyons that allows less solar radiation on surface.
• High aspect ratio and less SVF allows the streets to have less surface temperature.
33
• Pedestrian feel thermally comfortable in such streets.
34
• Shallow to regular canyons (aspect ratio ≤ 1) have very less to no shadow effect that
makes the streets hot during daytime.
• Sky view factor is higher (>0.3) in shallow canyons that allows high solar radiation on
surface.
• Less aspect ratio and high SVF allows the streets to have greater surface temperature.
• Pedestrian feel thermally uncomfortable in such streets with no shades, either from
buildings or trees.
• Thus, improvement strategies for surface temperature reduction were needed to be made
for the streets with higher SVF and less Aspect ratio.
The surface temperatures of the above mentioned streets were measured and data were collected
and analyzed. The ambient and pavement surface temperature of all four types of streets were
measured. The data was taken on 9th march,2023 at 2:45 pm. There was a difference of 1.23°C
between asphalt and concrete pavement.
35
Asphalt shallow canyon absorbed more solar radiation. Highest recorded surface temperature
was 44.6°C. Highest ambient temperature recorded was 31.5°C. Concrete deep canyon absorbed
less solar radiation. Lowest recorded surface temperature was 37.7°C. Lowest recorded ambient
temperature was 30.27°C.
7 Improvement Strategies
Studies showed that Asphalt had the larger impact on the surface heating followed by concrete,
soil, and grass. The site study showed most of the streets in Birgunj are Asphalt. Thus the first
line of improvement is necessary for the asphalt streets. (Gong, Liu, Lv, & Wu, 2023) classified
the cool asphalt technologies that includes various measures to prevent heat from entering thr
pavement. Among them, the reflective technologies suit best in our context. Due to the
unavailability of the reflective paints, the improvement strategies incorporates the adoption of
various heat preventing technologies.
Thus the improvement strategies have been made on basis of the availability of the reflective
material technologies in Birgunj.
For existing pavements, pigment in coating layers such as Titanium dioxide (TiO2) increase
solar reflectance and reduce surface temperature by (10 ± 2.5) °C. The literature showed that the
36
TiO2 is the major constituent in cool paints so if only it could be used, there can be a significant
decrement in the pavement temperature. Similarly the other improvement technologies include
the following:
• Chip seals technology and sand seals technology: spraying asphalt cement or
emulsified asphalt on the surface of newly built asphalt pavement and embedding
aggregate.
• Colored asphalt technology: using colored asphalt, added color pigments to the asphalt
mixture to prepare thin asphalt layers of different colors.
8 Numerical Validation
To evaluate the possible improvement of thermal comfort in the considered area, the Cooling
Power Thermal Comfort Index was evaluated for the climatic conditions corresponding to the
area before and after the proposed intervention.
Where,
37
Base case with Asphalt pavement (albedo 0.2)
=2.23 m/s
= 3.01
Quite hot
t= (31.6-2.3)°C = 29.3°C
=6.70 m/s
= 7.22
Comfortable
Hence by changing the albedo from 0.2 to 0.35 alone can create a quite hot streets into thermally
comfortable streets.
38
reflective materials. About the pavement materials, the availability of concrete could help in cool
pavement constructions. Due to the unavailability of the reflective paints, Titanium dioxide could
be used in order to reflect maximum solar radiation. The study was carried out with the
numerical validation of key theories explained and its relation with the thermal comfort of
pedestrian was examined. Changing the albedo from 0.2 to 0.35 alone can create a thermally
comfortable streets.
References
Akbari, H., Kurn, D. M., Bretz, S. E., & W., H. a. (1997). Peak power and cooling energy
savings of shade trees. Elsevier, 139-148.
Aletba, S. R., Hassan, N. A., Jaya, R. P., Aminudin, E., Mahmud, M. Z., & Hussein, A. M.
(2021). Thermal performance of cooling strategies for asphalt pavement: A state-of-the-
art review. Science Direct, 356-373.
Berardi, M. T. (2021). The effect of pavement characteristics on pedestrians' thermal comfort in
Toronto. Elsevier.
Berg, R., & Quinn, W. (1978). Use of light colored surface to reduce seasonal thaw penetration
beneath embankments on permafrost.
Bhardwaj, R., & Golden, P. E. (2009). Development of a zero-dimensional meso scale thermal
model for urban climate. Researchgate .
Cena, M., & Wojcik, M. G. (1966). an attempt to determine through formulae computation of
biometeorological cooling power in Poland.
DeWolff, R. (2008). Developing an environmental fog potential map using a GIS.
Dirksen, M., Ronda, R., Theeuwes, N., & Pagani, G. (2019). Sky view factor calculations and its
application in urban heat island studies. Elsevier.
E.Wilson, F.N.col, L.N.nayakkara, & A.U.berjahn-tritta. (2008). Public Urban Open Space and
Human Thermal Comfort: The Implications of Alternative Climate Change and Socio-
economic Scenarios. Journal of Environmental Policy and Planning, 31-45.
Erell, E., Pearlmutter, D., & Kutiel, D. B. (2014). Effect of high-albedo materials on pedestrian
heat stress in urban street canyons. Elsevier, 367-386.
Erell, E., Pearlmutter, D., Kutiel, D., & Bar, B. a. (2013). Effect of high-albedo materials on
pedestrian heat stress in urban street canyons. Elsevier.
Firdausah, A. M., & Wonorahardjo, S. (2018). Typology Study of Urban Canyon in Residential.
Earth and Environmental Science. IOP Conference Series.
39
Gaitani, N., Spanou, A., & Synnefa, M. S. (2011). Improving the microclimate in urban areas: a
case study in the centre of Athens. BUILDING SERV ENG RES TECHNOL, 53–71.
Gong, X., Liu, Q., Lv, Y., & Wu, S. C. (2023). A systematic review on the strategies of reducing
asphalt pavement temperature. Elsevier.
Guntor, N. A., Din, M. F., & Iwao, M. P. (2014). Thermal Performance of Developed Coating
Material as Cool Pavement Material for Tropical Regions. JOURNAL OF MATERIALS
IN CIVIL ENGINEERING , 755-760.
H. Rosenfeld, A., Hashem Akbari, Sarah Bretz, Fishman, B. L., M. Kurn, D., & Haider Taha, D.
a. (1995). Mitigation of urban heat islands: materials, utility programs, updates. Elsevier,
255-265.
Kappou, S., Souliotis, M., Papaefthimiou, S., & Paravantis, G. P. (2022). Cool Pavements: State
of the Art and New Technologies. Sustainability.
Kusuda, T. (1975). The effect of ground cover on earth temperature.
Li, H., Harvey, J. T., Holland, T. J., & Kayhanian, M. (2013). The Use of Reflective and
Permeable Pavements as a Potential Practice for Heat Island Mitigation and Stormwater
Management. Environmental Research Letters.
Lin, T.-P., Tsai, K.-T., & Matzarakis, R.-L. H. (2012). Quantification of the effect of thermal
indices and sky view factor on park. Landscape and Urban Planning, 137–146.
Lu, Y., Rahman, M. A., & Golrokh, N. W. (2022). Lab-Controlled Experimental Evaluation of
Heat-Reflective Coatings by Increasing Surface Albedo for Cool Pavements inUrban
Areas.
Mat, K. G. (2018). Using reflective pavements to mitigate urban heat island in warm climates -
Results from a large scale urban mitigation project. Elsevier, 326-339.
Mattheos Santamouris, & T. Karlessi, A. a. (2011). Using advanced cool materials in the urban
built environment to mitigate heat islands and improve thermal comfort conditions.
Nunez, M., & Oke, T. R. (1977). The Energy Balance of an urban canyon.
Offerle, B., Eliasson, I., & Grimmond, C. S. (2007). Surface heating in relation to air
temperature, wind and turbulence in an urban street canyon. Researchgate, 122:273–292.
Park, C., & Lee, J. H. (2017). Association between Three-Dimensional Built Environment and
Urban Air Temperature: Seasonal and Temporal Differences. Researchgate .
Qin, Y. (2015). Urban canyon albedo and its implication on the use of reflective cool pavements.
Elsevier, 86-94.
Salvati, A., Kolokotroni, M., Watkins, A., & Richard, K. a. (2022). Impact of reflective materials
on urban canyon albedo, outdoor and indoor microclimates. Building and Environment.
40
Santamouris, L. D. (2004). Passive Cooling of Outdoor Urban Spaces. The Role of Materials.
Solar Energy .
Santamouris, M. (2012). Environmental Design of Urban Buildings: An Integrated Approach.
Routledge.
Santamouris, M., Papanikolaou, N., Koronaki, I. P., & Livada, I. a. (1999). Thermal and air flow
characteristics in a deep pedestrian canyon under hot weather conditions. Elsevier, 4503-
4521.
Sha, A., Liu, Z., & Li, K. T. (2017). Solar heating reflective coating layer (SHRCL) to cool the
asphalt pavement surface. Elsevier.
Shafaghat, A., Manteghi, G., Keyvanfar, A., & Lamit, H. (2016). Street Geometry Factors
Influence Urban Microclimate in Tropical Coastal . Researchgate , 61-75.
Speak, A. F., & Salbitano, F. (2022). Summer thermal comfort of pedestrians in diverse urban
settings: A mobile study. Elsevier.
Synnefa, A., Karlessi, h., & Santamouris, N. G. (2014). Measurement of Optical Properties and
Thermal Performance of Coloured Thin Layer Asphalt Samples and Evaluation of Their
Impact on The Urban Environment. Researchgate.
Taha, h., & Akbari, D. S. (1992). High Albedo Materials for Reducing Cooling Energy Use.
Taleghani, M., & Berardi, U. (2017). The effect of pavement characteristics on pedestrians'
thermal comfort in Toronto. Urban Climate.
Taleghani, M., Tenpierik, M., & Sailor, A. v. (2014). Heat mitigation strategies in winter and
summer: field measurements in temperate climates. Elsevier , 309-319.
Taleghani, M., Tenpierik, M., Sailor, A. v., & J., d. D. (2014). Heat mitigation strategies in
winter and summer: field measurements in temperate climates. Elsevier, 309-319.
Wai', K. M., & Tan, L. X. (2021). Improvement of the Outdoor Thermal Comfort by Water
Spraying in a High-Density Urban Environment under the Influence of a Future (2050)
Climate .
Wan, W. C., Hien, W. N., & Aloysius, a. P. (2014). A Study on the Effectiveness of Heat
Mitigating Pavement Coatings in Singapore. Research Gate .
Wang, Y., & Akbari, U. B. (2016). Comparing the effects of urban heat island mitigation
strategies for Toronto, Canada. Elsevier , 2-19.
Yi, Y., Jiang, Y., Li, Q., Deng, C., & Xue, X. J. (2019). Development of Super Road Heat-
Reflective Coating and Its Field Application. Coatings.
Zheng, N., Lei, J., Wang, S., & Chen, Z. L. (2020). Influence of Heat Reflective Coating on the
Cooling and Pavement Performance of Large Void Asphalt Pavement. coatings.
41
Zhu, S., & Mai, X. (2019). A review of using reflective pavement materials as mitigation tactics
to counter the effects of urban heat island. Springer.
42