Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Tracing Collapsing Structures in Uganda-1
Tracing Collapsing Structures in Uganda-1
BACKGROUND
Globally, crises such as insecurity, disasters, ill-health and environmental degradation have continued
to pose a significant challenge to the human race. Disasters, both man-made and natural, have
hindered the attainment of Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) in most countries (Ede, 2021) .
He further explains that the impact is mostly felt in under-developed and developing nations where
capacities to manage such is lacking. Also, the world’s population continues to grow, in 2021, the
global population reached seven billion mark, and in November 2022 it reached 8 billion (UNEP,
2023). The population is increasingly becoming urban (Aliyu & Amadu, 2017). Today more than 400
cities have a population of a million or more, about 70% of them are found in developing countries
(Aliyu & Amadu, 2017). Due to increased population, the demand for services and needs like shelter
is also on an increase. Shelter is the first thing humans need for living in this world even before food
(Amadi, 2012; Hamma-Adama & Kouider, 2017).
Population is increasing in Urban areas yet land where buildings are founded is fixed. The solution to
this, is to shift from horizontal development to vertical development. However vertical development
solves a problem of space shortage (Kigguddu, 2017), it has been evidenced with negative effects like
failure of structures commonly known as building collapse. In last three years (2020-2023) over 394
lives were lost in countries like China, Cambodia, Canada, Italy, Thailand, South Korea, Belgium,
Israel, USA, Spain, Nigeria, Iran, Germany, Indonesia and France. With USA registering highest
number of fatalities of 98 in 2021 when Champlain towers in Surlfide Florida collapsed (Wikipedia
2023).
Recently, there has been widespread concern among the public regarding the poor quality of
infrastructure being built across the country. The frequent issues include the failure of bridges, road
surfaces, and building collapses during construction, capturing public attention. The government
allocates a substantial portion of the national budget to infrastructure development. Failures in these
projects not only result in a direct financial loss but also pose risks to lives. Rebuilding collapsed
structures increases the overall cost and diminishes the monetary value of the initial investment
(Alinaitwe & Ekolu, 2014).
Building is described as an enclosure for spaces designed for specific use, meant to control local
climate, distribute services, and evacuate waste (Fadamiro, 2012). Buildings are structural objects that
may secure themselves by transferring weights to the earth. Furthermore, according to Odulami
(2011), buildings are structures for human activities, which must be safe for the occupants. Building
construction involves a series of processes, including architectural design, engineering analysis,
obtaining permits, site preparation, foundation construction, framing, installation of building systems
(such as electrical, plumbing, and HVAC), interior finishing, and exterior cladding (Carpenter et al.,
1997).(Caleb et al., 2023)
LITERATURE REVIEW
In the construction of tall buildings, adherence to specific design specifications is crucial (Peansupap
& Ly, 2015). Notably, in Kampala, Uganda, Alinaitwe and Ekolu (2014) documented 54 fatalities and
122 injuries from building collapses within a four-year period (2004-2008)(Alinaitwe & Ekolu,
2014). The frequency of such failures in Kampala has prompted scholarly investigations to identify
their causes. Design specifications, detailed requirements for a construction project, must be
rigorously followed for the successful completion of high-rise buildings (Mugabi, 2022a). These
specifications, typically prepared by the client after thorough research, play a vital role in ensuring the
sustainability of such structures. Neglecting to adhere to design specifications results in design errors,
encompassing mistakes, omissions, and conflicts in the design (Mugabi, 2022a; Okeke et al., 2020).
Design mistakes, arising from human errors, may include lapses or slips, especially when applied
incorrectly by inexperienced designers. Omissions occur when a part of the system is unintentionally
overlooked in the design process, while conflicts involve overlapping elements that cannot be
constructed simultaneously. Despite ongoing discussions, the role of design errors remains
inconclusive, yet they are considered significant contributors to building failures and collapses in
various contexts, including Uganda (Okeke et al., 2020; Waziri, 2016).
Alinaitwe & Ekolu (2014) highlighted key causes of structure failures during construction in East
Africa. Issues included poor materials and workmanship, design errors, absence of professional
supervision leading to overlooked problems, and wrong implementation of construction methods.
Neglect of design approval procedures and secondary factors like cost-cutting attempts and influence
peddling were also identified (Alinaitwe & Ekolu, 2014). Several studies have pinpointed causes such
as negligence, deficient foundations, faulty steel reinforcement, hurried construction, greed, lack of
soil tests, poor supervision, and non-compliance with building codes and design errors (B\laszczyński
& Sielicki, 2019; Kobielak et al., 2015; Mugabi, 2022a; Peansupap & Ly, 2015).
Mugabi (2022) clarifies that building collapses are primarily due to structural, not architectural,
issues. Approved designs with a registered engineer's stamp should prevent such failures, but a
common problem arises when clients deviate from these designs during construction. He suggests that
strict adherence to building regulations would involve monitoring construction sites to ensure
engineers oversee the process. However, he acknowledges the challenges authorities face, such as
staff shortages, and emphasizes the importance of responsible supervision by technicians, especially
foremen, during construction (Mugabi, 2022b).
METHODOLOGY
The study employed a mixed-methods approach, combining site surveys, interviews, and data
collection from local news media and the Kampala Capital City Authority (KCCA). Site surveys
involved physically visiting locations of collapsed structures to gather firsthand information and
assess the extent of damage. Interviews were conducted with relevant stakeholders, including
construction professionals, government officials, and local residents, to gather insights into the causes
and consequences of building collapses.
To geographically locate collapsed structures, GPS coordinates were collected during site surveys and
interviews. These coordinates were essential for mapping the temporal and spatial distribution of
collapsed structures using Geographic Information Systems (GIS). GIS software, specifically
ArcMap, was utilized to import and analyse spatial data, allowing for the visualization of patterns and
trends over time.
Data analysis was conducted using Excel, where information on collapsed structures was organized
and analyzed to identify patterns, trends, and key factors contributing to building collapses. Graphs
were generated to visually represent the trends in collapsing buildings, providing insights into the
frequency and severity of incidents over the study period.
Building collapses in Uganda have been recurrent issues since as far back as records go. These collapses are often attributed to a combination of
factors, ranging from poor construction practices to natural disasters. One significant cause is poor construction quality, where substandard
materials and inadequate workmanship result in structurally weak buildings. Additionally, the lack of supervision from qualified professionals
during construction exacerbates these issues. Design flaws also play a role, with buildings suffering from inadequate structural designs that
compromise their stability. Furthermore, natural disasters such as storms, floods, and earthquakes further weaken already vulnerable structures.
Foundation problems, including issues with soil stability and construction methods, contribute to collapses as well. Illegal construction without
proper permits or adherence to regulations adds to the risks. Maintenance neglect also plays a part, as deteriorating structures are more prone to
collapse over time. Accidents, such as collisions with vehicles or machinery, can also trigger collapses. Addressing these multifaceted issues
requires comprehensive efforts, including better regulations, professional oversight, and public education on construction safety.
Figure 1: A map of Uganda showing collapsed structures.
Figure 2: Map showing Spatial Distribution of Collapsed Structures
Table 2: Number of collapsed structures, Deaths and Injured Persons in the following year
Table 2 provides a comprehensive overview of collapsed structures, fatalities, and injuries in Uganda
from 1997 to 2023. The data reveals fluctuations in the occurrences of collapsed structures, deaths, and
injuries over the years. Some years saw no collapsed structures, while others experienced spikes in
incidents, notably in 2006 and 2020. Conversely, years like 2005, 2003, 2002, 2001, and 1998 had no
reported collapses, indicating varying stability in construction practices. The data highlights the
unpredictable nature of building collapses, influenced by factors like building regulations, economic
conditions, and urban development. Years with more collapses tend to have higher fatalities and injuries,
underscoring their impact on public safety. While recent years show fewer collapses, ongoing vigilance
and enforcement of safety standards are crucial.
Efforts to enhance construction safety measures are essential, especially in years with spikes in collapses,
deaths, and injuries. Analysing past incidents can inform preventive measures to create safer
environments. Stakeholders must work together to mitigate risks and protect communities in Uganda.
140
120
100
Numbers
80
60
40
20
0
23 22 21 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 09 08 07 06 05 04 03 02 01 00 99 98 97
20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 20 19 19 19
Year
Table 3: Number of collapsed structures, Deaths and Injured Persons in the following periods
1 2023-2019 94 103 41
2 2018-2014 19 71 12
3 2013-2009 18 69 13
5 2003-1999 15 0 6
6 1998-1994 4 2 2
Sum 262 464 89
This table presents a breakdown of collapsed structure incidents in Uganda, categorized by five-year
periods, along with the corresponding number of deaths and injuries. From 2019 to 2023, there were 94
deaths and 103 injuries recorded in 41 incidents. The period from 2014 to 2018 saw 19 deaths and 71
injuries in 12 incidents. In the span of 2009 to 2013, there were 18 deaths and 69 injuries reported across
13 incidents. The period from 2004 to 2008 recorded the highest numbers, with 112 deaths and 219
injuries in 15 incidents. Notably, from 1999 to 2003, there were 15 deaths reported but no injuries,
spanning six incidents. Finally, from 1994 to 1998, four deaths and two injuries were documented in two
incidents. Overall, across the entire dataset, there were 262 deaths, 464 injuries, and a total of 89 incidents
recorded.
DEATH
120
112
100 94
80
Number of Deaths
60
40
19 18
20 15
4
0
2023-2019 2018-2014 2013-2009 2008-2004 2003-1999 1998-1994
Period
219
200
Number of the Injured
150
103
100
71 69
50
0 2
0
2023-2019 2018-2014 2013-2009 2008-2004 2003-1999 1998-1994
Period
45
41
Frequency of collapsed structures
40
35
30
25
20
15
15 12 13
10
6
5 2
0
2023-2019 2018-2014 2013-2009 2008-2004 2003-1999 1998-1994
Periods
CONCLUSION
The data highlights the recurring problem of building collapses in Uganda, leading to deaths and injuries.
Factors like poor construction practices, design flaws, natural disasters, and neglect contribute to these
incidents. While the frequency of collapses varies over time, the need for consistent efforts to address the
root causes remains clear. Strict building regulations, professional oversight during construction, and
public education on safety are crucial. Analysing incidents by periods reveals trends, emphasizing the
need for ongoing monitoring and intervention. It is also discovered that Most incidences occurred in
Central and Makindye divisions in Kampala District. Collaboration among authorities, industry
stakeholders, and the public is essential to create safer environments and protect lives in Uganda.
RECOMMENDATIONS.
Research should be carried out to ascertain why in period of 2023-2019 many buildings collapsed.
I. From fig 1, map of collapsed buildings, it shows that most collapsed buildings were in Kampala
district. Research should be also conducted to find out the causes, reasons and possible solutions.
REFERENCES
Alinaitwe, H. M., & Ekolu, S. (2014). Failure of structure in East Africa with focus on the causes of
failures in the construction phase. Construction Materials and Structures–Proceedings of the
First International Conference on Construction Materials and Structures, 1, 76–85.
https://books.google.com/books?
hl=en&lr=&id=Qj8oBgAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PA76&dq=Alinaitwe,+H.M.,+%26+Ekolu,+S.
+(2014).+
%22Failure+of+structure+in+East+Africa+with+focus+on+the+causes+of+failures+in+the+const
ruction+phase.%22+In+Construction+Materials+and+Structures:
+Proceedings+of+the+First+International+Conference+on+Construction+Materials+and+Structu
res+(pp.+76-85).+IOS+Press.&ots=aYQ5J2yKOd&sig=mqhoiy7SPzF_wQYzqbyorWR6z1s
Ede, .. I. (2021). The trend of collapse of buildings in concrete materials in Lagos , Nigeria. Earth and
Environmental Science.
Iyu, A., & Amadu, L. (2017). Urbanization, cities, and health: The challenges to Nigeria – A review.
Annals of African Medicine, 16(4), 149. https://doi.org/10.4103/aam.aam_1_17
Amadi, L. (2012). Africa: Beyond the new dependency: A political economy. African Journal of Political
B\laszczyński, T. Z., & Sielicki, P. W. (2019). The influence of design and contractor errors on the failure
Caleb, M., Olonade, K. A., & Lawan, M. M. (2023). Evaluating The Causes of Building Collapse in
https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Mwesigwa-Caleb/publication/378366547_Evaluating_The_
Causes_of_Building_Collapse_in_Kampala_District_Uganda/links/
65d66973adc608480ade799b/Evaluating-The-Causes-of-Building-Collapse-in-Kampala-District-
Uganda.pdf
Hamma-Adama, M., & Kouider, T. (2017). Causes of building failure and collapse in Nigeria:
repository.worktribe.com/247029/1/HAMMA-ADAMA%202017%20Causes%20of%20building
%20failure
Kobielak, S., Hutnik, E., & Zamiar, Z. (2015). Failures of building constructions caused by design errors.
https://yadda.icm.edu.pl/baztech/element/bwmeta1.element.baztech-b51d4a44-a7d1-45df-8719-
6af4d46bfd81/c/07_kobielak_hutnik_zamiar_ZNWSOWL_4_2015.pdf
Mugabi, S. (2022a). Assessment of variations in design specifications and their impact on building failure
http://dissertations.mak.ac.ug/handle/20.500.12281/11613
Mugabi, S. (2022b). Assessment of variations in design specifications and their impact on building failure
http://dissertations.mak.ac.ug/handle/20.500.12281/11613
Okeke, F. O., Sam-Amobi, C. G., & Okeke, F. I. (2020). Role of local town planning authorities in
https://www.cell.com/heliyon/pdf/S2405-8440(20)31205-6.pdf
Peansupap, V., & Ly, R. (2015). Evaluating the impact level of design errors in structural and other
370–378.
%2C+2023%29.+&form=ANNTH1&refig=c3814a43afb249c38e4f087b165b00cd&pc=U531
Waziri, B. S. (2016). Design and construction defects influencing residential building maintenance in
304631106_Design_and_Construction_Defects_Influencing_Residential_Building_Maintenance
_in_Nigeria/links/59034660a6fdccd580cfd825/Design-and-Construction-Defects-Influencing-
Residential-Building-Maintenance-in-Nigeria.pdf