Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Debating in Higher Level
Debating in Higher Level
First, I put them in pairs and asked them to discuss if they were a dog or a cat person. What
are the advantages and disadvantages of having a dog/cat? What are the most common
misconceptions about having these pets?
Afterwards, I ask them to take a sheet of paper and a pen. Now tell students they’re going to
watch an informal debate about dogs vs. cats. They watch the video and write down the
arguments and useful phrases that the two people give to support their animal and to
introduce their ideas. You can brainstorm some ideas before playing the video.
The debate is long, so I only play it once. Go through the sentences they managed to write
down and ask if they express the same ideas as the students - when they were in pairs.
Present the handout with useful phrases, go through it with them.
You can either ask the students to vote (as I did) or pick a topic for the debate. Here are
some ideas for an informal debate. (Feel free to add more formal ones):
Divide the students into 3 groups: moderators, topic 1 and topic 2. Give them some minutes
to prepare their arguments, highlight that they must use the phrases to present their
arguments. The role of the moderators is to keep track of time, control the discussion and
also ask following questions to the groups. Plus, they must choose a winner based on best
arguments, who used more useful phrases and most of the team participated in the debate.
And pre-teach the vocabularies for debate (opening/closing statement, cross examination,
examination