Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 23

Journal of Product & Brand Management

Brand logo design: examining consumer response t o nat uralness:


Joana Cesar Machado Leonor Vacas de Carvalho Anna Torres Patrício Costa
Article information:
To cite this document:
Joana Cesar Machado Leonor Vacas de Carvalho Anna Torres Patrício Costa , (2015),"Brand logo design: examining
consumer response to naturalness", Journal of Product & Brand Management, Vol. 24 Iss 1 pp. -
Permanent link t o t his document :
http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/JPBM-05-2014-0609
Downloaded on: 09 February 2015, At : 04: 56 (PT)
Ref erences: t his document cont ains ref erences t o 0 ot her document s.
To copy t his document : permissions@emeraldinsight . com
The f ullt ext of t his document has been downloaded 22 t imes since 2015*
Users who downloaded this article also downloaded:
Laurence Dessart, Cleopatra Veloutsou, Anna Morgan-Thomas, Francisco Guzman, (2015),"Consumer engagement in
online brand communities: A social media perspective", Journal of Product & Brand Management, Vol. 24 Iss 1 pp. -
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

Michael F. Walsh, Karen Page Winterich, Vikas Mittal, (2010),"Do logo redesigns help or hurt your brand?
The role of brand commitment", Journal of Product & Brand Management, Vol. 19 Iss 2 pp. 76-84 http://
dx.doi.org/10.1108/10610421011033421
Sebastian Ullrich, Christian Boris Brunner, Francisco Guzman, (2015),"Negative online consumer reviews: Effects of different
responses", Journal of Product & Brand Management, Vol. 24 Iss 1 pp. -

Access t o t his document was grant ed t hrough an Emerald subscript ion provided by 268629 [ ]
For Authors
If you would like t o writ e f or t his, or any ot her Emerald publicat ion, t hen please use our Emerald f or Aut hors service
inf ormat ion about how t o choose which publicat ion t o writ e f or and submission guidelines are available f or all. Please
visit www. emeraldinsight . com/ aut hors f or more inf ormat ion.
About Emerald www.emeraldinsight.com
Emerald is a global publisher linking research and pract ice t o t he benef it of societ y. The company manages a port f olio of
more t han 290 j ournals and over 2, 350 books and book series volumes, as well as providing an ext ensive range of online
product s and addit ional cust omer resources and services.
Emerald is both COUNTER 4 and TRANSFER compliant. The organization is a partner of the Committee on Publication
Ethics (COPE) and also works with Portico and the LOCKSS initiative for digital archive preservation.

*Relat ed cont ent and download inf ormat ion correct at t ime of download.
! !

! " !
# $ ! %&& $ " $ " ''
! ( ) *
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

%& + ,
- ) *
! %& +! .& / ! 0 ( %&&1 !
2 ! * 3
4 1. ! ( !

5 !
5 ! 67 5 ! .7 ( ! ! *
!
!
* 8 ! %& +7
! %&&97 : * "! %&&.7 0 ! %& &7 ( ; ! %& + !
* <

< !
!
/ < =

; <!

1
! ! !

/ ! !
= ! * " *! = !
* 5 ! .7 > ! %&&+ ! *
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

, -

( !
? < ! 5 .
!
) %&&' <
! ! !
> %& & %& <

4 6
8 %&&6
! *
3

: !

5 ! .7 ( ! + ? ! = !
4 !
&7 $ ! +

4 < (
@ *! ! 5
*! %&& !

2
A A !
< < !
3 B ) ! %&& 7 ) / !
%&&9 C > %&&9 *
A ! A B *

A !

/ *
( ( ! '! <
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

)
( + " A
5 .
A "
/
!
< A / !
! A B
/ B

/ ! ! !
A
* 7 !
8 5 D! + ? A
$ ! '

3
? !
5 ! .7 ) ! %&&' !

< A ! >
!
! !
, A -! ! A
! ! ! ! ! ! !
, A - ! !
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

* 5 ! ! A
! ! ! A ! ! $
! ! ! A
" 5 ! .7 $ ! '
: ! !
@ ! 1 7; ! ' 7( ! %

*
!# " B
! =
< !
3 * # " ! ;
< ! <

4 ! <
> <
A
A 5 ! .7 $ ! '7 $ ! . / !
5 . %&&+ * !
* !
"

4
*
! <

/ ! A
" 7 A
! "
$ ! '

!
! .17 ) *! .9 !
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

! .1 ( !
* !
: * "! %&&. !
"

> !

/ < =
0 !
* * ! !
* ! ! !
%&&'7 0 ! 6 0 E C !
%&&'
! !
! "

/ " !
= $ =
) $ ! %& &7 $ =) ! %&&6 !
* = / !

5
!
5 ! %&&. ! A =*
! !
=*
; A ! = =
* ! *
! "
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

> * ! =*
F

5 ! . ! !
B : * "! %&&. ! =
* 3 !
* @ $ ! %&&1 ! < =*
!
! =*

$ ! ! A
B ! %&&

$ * =2 ! !/ !
4 " ! 5 ! 5 ! F ( / !
" 2 !
/ !
*! !
*

6
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

/
*

"
! 3

!
!G

!
"

!
*

=
!

!
<

!
!

!
/

A
A

!
!
"

!
>

!
<

!
2<

/
!

!
#
*

!
!
9&1

!
!

!
!
=*

7
$ %

& %
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

< ! !
! *
" !

> +% F
3 < 2
1& ! 96 * 6 6
=* 6 / B *!
3 , - !
3 1& 9.

1 = $ % * 9.
! = 2 *
&&
! !

> = A ! !
2 +1 * % =*
! %

'! ; * <
" #
$ % 9 9 9 %
& % % % % +1

8
1 1 1 9.

0 * * !
* " !
3 ! !

? ! !
/ . "
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

&& ! >
=
! * H * 7
H @ ! .7 ! '7 ) * ! 1 !
= ! ? !
* * H * ! =
/ !
* =*
! A ; !
% ! !
A >
3 !
" (
!

5 B / (
/;:#/
>
" 5 B 3 η% ? ! )
/
& &6

9
? < ! !
A F ) / %%&

+ * &'
+ G
! " 2
3 * B
> ! !
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

* )
!

( I5 = 3 ! χ% J 6 '! J& &+&! ) B ) J


& 6+K ! A
8 !
!
" 7 !

7 !

I ' J = .1!
J& &19! 5 B J =& %6 I
= H 7 χ% L ! J & 996! ) B ) J & &1+K
! . 1% J +9 '! (G J 1!
. '+ J +' 1! (G J % ' B !
A % .' 1M7
.+ %M

(! ( "
) )'
* *
+ 1. 1& % 9. 99
96 + . 6 66

10
, - . '/0 +% %. + +6 +% '
,(1 . (/0 96 + . %& .'
,21 . 2/0 %' %+ +9 + .
,31 40 .& . 1.
5 9 %9 . 1.
& 91 9& ' 6 66 %
6 7 " ++ % % %+ % 6
8 %& '' ' 16

4 !
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

5 B / &6 %
* & 9% *
& '&
5 B / ! .!
! ? !
< !

9 9 99

: A <
!
" !
/;:#/
η%
= %! J1+ +7 L& && 7 J& 6+7
%
πN& 7 = %! &6 J99 .7 L& && 7 J& 917 N& /
B L & &67
9 ! %
? !
= J+ .! G)J & '6&7 B L& && 7 =
J+ + ! G)J & ' 17 B L& &6= 4 B A

11
< !
B !

<
%
!

2! /

) : ; ) % : ; : 9; < = > ?=
"++ @" + . & '6 ++ & '% % . J=% &.7 J& &+
"++ @ + 6& &' + '. & '' % . J=% '17 J& &&1
"++ @ # +' & .% + .. &' % . J=& .17 J& +
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

"++ @$@" + '1 & .6 9 &6 & .' % . J=% 9'7 J& & 9
"++ @$@ 9 % &. 9 6& & .+ % . J=+ +.7 J& &&
"++ @$@ # 9 && 9 +& & .6 % . J=& .17 J& +.
"++ @&@" % & .% + . & '1 % . J= .97 J& &1.
"++ @&@ +% & '. + 6% & .9 % . J=% &+7 J& &99
"++ @&@ # + 16 & .. + '9 & .6 % . J=& '67 J& 96+
"++ @& $ #A 9 &% & '' 9 %. & '+ % . J=% 6%7 J& & %

<
! 0
< 9!
! !

> =* * ! !
=* = /??25 O@;:>; J9 &%! G)/??25 O@;:>;J & ''+7
/??25 O@;:>; J9 %.! G)/??25 O@;:>;J & '++
* = /??25 OF;@;:>; J+ + ! G)/??25 OF;@;:>;J & '1 7 % J & 1!
L& && 7 = /??25 OF;@;:>; J+ 9'! G)/??25 OF;@;:>;J& '+ 7 &1 J 1 +!
L& &&

9 9 B = 99

12
< !

! < * 6 ?
J=& +. *
! + !
* !
<
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

3! /
) )'
+ : 9; < = > + : 9; < = >
: ; : ; ?= : ; : ; ?=
+ . + . + +' + 9&
"++ @" J& &17 J& 6 &6 J=& 7 J& .6
& 1' & .+ & '% & '%
+ 61 + 9% + '' +'
"++ @ J & 7 J& +% &6 J=& 67 J& ..
& 1' & '. & '1 &'
+ .% + '+ +. + 9
"++ @ # J& 6 7 J& 61 &6 J=& . 7 J& +.
& .% & .% & '+ & .+
+ 16 + + + 9 1
"++ @$@" J= '%7 J& & &6 J= 917 J& 6
& .+ & .1 & & & .9
9 &1 9% 9 9% 9 61
"++ @$@ ' . J=& .'7 J& +. &6 J=& ..7 J& +.
& '9 & % & .+ & .9
9 &+ 9 9% 9 ' 99
"++ @$@ # J=% &67 J& &9 &6 J= 9+7 J& 1
&& & . & .% & .'
+ &+ % % +% + 1
"++ @&@" J& 117 J& 6 &6 J& %.7 J& '.
& '9 & + & '1 & ''
++ + 1 + 6+ +6
"++ @&@ J 617 J& % &6 J& +7 J& &
& '+ & .9 & .% & .1
+ '6 + 6& + 1. +'
"++ @&@ # J 6 7 J& 9 &6 J=& 1%7 J& 69
& .6 & &. &.
++ + + 91 + 9.
"++ @& $ #A J +97 J& &6 J=& & 7 J& +
& '% & .9 & '% & '6
+ % 9 9 1 9 +'
"++ @$ #A J= .+7 J& &' &6 J= 9'7 J& 6
& '9 &. & '& & '1

13
/??25 O/4( P * * 7 /??25 O;5 P 7
/??25 O;: P 7 /??25 OO@O/4( P * 7 /??25 O@O;5 P
* 7 /??25 OFO/4( P * 7 /??25 OFO;5 P
* 7 /??25 OFO;: P * 7 /??25 OF;@;:>;=
* ! 7 /??25 O@;:>;= *

! (

/82 /??25 O/4( J & 7 J& &97 /82 /??25 O;5 J & %! J& &97 /82 /??25 O;:
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

J & %+7 J& &% *


/82 /??25 OFO/4( J & % 7 J& &+7 /82 /??25 OFO;: J & %97 J& & 7
/82 /??25 OF;@;:>; J & %%7 J& &% / !
* /82 /??25 O@O;5 J & %97 J& & !
!
!
!
* /82 /??25 O@O;: J =& %'! J& &&6 !
9 !

> ( =
H !
!

5 ! .7 ( ! + :
! !

14
< ! < !

)
!

! 8 5 D! +7
5 ! . # " ! +
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

!
/
! !
A

/ ! * =*
! !

! ! 3
@ ! + ! =

: !
! * !
* =
!
!

? !
! 3 !
19M J & 19
< =

15
2
! <
!
=* $ =) $ ! %& &7 $ =
) ! %&&6 0
! !

! A
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

!
! !
A ! %&& 7 0 ! 67 E C ! %&&' !
* /

H ! <
! <

" ! < =
!
! ! !
<

9 =

? !
! 3 " ( !
* H * !
! ! !
*
* ! A

16
? < !
!

"

Q $ %&&'
= * < ?
! ) !
( ;
! .& 2<
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

) ; ! (
? < ! F / < F/ ! ; 6+!
( .1 ) &9 <
!4 * " ! %&

> " " F/ ! .&


* H " /
! < * F/

< < !
< !

< !
<
< !
< !

< !
" 0 !
%& &7 ( ! %&&6

9
4 !Q 1. ! !" !8 !)

17
4 !) 6 ! ,( * -! # $% &
' %( )! # 6 ; +! 1=%

4 * " !$Q!G !(/ ! / %& ! ,( * =


< < -! # $% & *% $+
, ' ) !# %. ; %! %&9=% '

5 ! / *! 4 %&& ! , 5
-! # $% & ' %( )! # 16 ; %!
. = +

5 ! 5! $ ! 8! G ! /! 2 ! Q! 8 ! /! $ =) ! 0! ! 2!
; ! ) ! 2 %&&. ! ,G *
-! ' %( ) % !# ; +=9! +66=+16
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

5 ! />! > ! Q ; ! 52 6 ! ,( / B
-! # $% & ' %( %+
+ !# +'! 9&6=9 6

8 ! / %&&6 ! , / -! 8 4 $ G 2 ! - $ )
. / + 0 ) ; C *! ;C! %66=%11

8 /Q 5 D! Q + 0 1$ 2 3 + % 0 - 0 %
) ) ( D !)

8 ! 4! 8 ! Q$! ) * ! G %& + ,F
-! # $% & 4% ' ) !# %& ;
6! +. =9&+
! Q?Q ! / !02! !0$ 4 *! > 5 . ! '$ % 3 /
6 2 !) !F ( 0 ! ;Q

!) > 5 !Q/ . ! ,8 -! # $%
& ' %( ) # 1% ; % 9=+&

! )>! 5 ! Q/! $ !( ( ! 4 %&&+ ! ,4


/ < " -! , %
# $% & ' %( ) %+ # %& ; 9! % '=+ +

! )>! 8 ! Q$ 5 ! Q / %&&9 ! ,
-! # $% & ' %( )! # 1. ; 9! 1&='%

!8 .& ! $ $% 1$ + , % 3 && % + 5 %( % 6 $ !
( !4 ! 5/

! >G 4 ! () & ! ,2 !
= -! # $% & $ % %+ ! # ' ; %! 9 = 9

18
! ; %&& ! ,5 / -! # $% &
4% ' ) !# 1 ; .! 696=666

A ! !/ * ! :! !? / ! C %&& ! ,( < B
-! % 4 %!
# 9& ; %! = &9

Q ! Q> $ ! =( %&&' ! ,5 -!
, % ' %( ) 7! # %9 ; 9! 9'9=9

@ ! @ =$ + ! ,5 " ! = 3 -!
# $% & ' %( )! # 6' ; ! =%%

@ ! @ =$ $ ! G 0 %&&1 ! ,4
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

-! ' %( ) + + ! # %6 ; 1! '9&='6

@ !Q!$ Q =( 4 ! .!,
-! # $% & /+ & ' %( ) + + !# %1 ; %!
9+= 6%

@ !? 1 ! ,# = <
-! !: 2 !> G5

$ =) !0 $ ! 8 %& & ! ,> R


-! # $% & ' %( )! # '9 ; 6!
&9= %

$ =) ! 0! $ ! 8 $ ! 2 %&&6 ! ,0
-! # $% &
' %( )! # 1 ; %! '= +

$ !Q . !, * -! % % 4$ 7! # '1 ; %! 1=%&

$ !) ' ! ,$B 3 ! D *
3 ! D -! !F D5 3
$ !$ = =;

$ !( + ! ,5 * ! =
-! # $% & $ %* + ) !# % ; %! 1%='9

$ "! @ / $ "! 0 Q '' ! ,2


-! # $% & /.. * + ) !# 1% ; 9! 9 +=9 .

! GQ! ( ! ( ! 8 ! ,2
-! / + $ % %+ # %1 ; ! 1& =1&.

19
! >! ! @ ! 4 ! Q0! 8 ! G .! , R
-! '$ % 4 %
%+ ! # ++ ; %! . =%%&

!> .1 ! ' + * %+ . , $ % 3 ) !( # !$

! ( Q ! ) *! 5 > 5 ! ( '! , *
< -! # $% &
$ %* + ) !# 1 ; %! = 9&

8! ! 5 ; ! ; %&&'! ,2 -!
# $% & 4% ' ) !# 9 ; 9! + +=+%+

; ! @2 ' ! , = * -!
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

* + + + + !# %6 ; 1! +91=9.

: ! F0 * "! @ %&&. ! , *
-! # $% & ' %( )! # '% ; +! +6= 99

) *! # .9 ! 3 ) & % 5 % !# ; !; C *! ;C

) *! 5 > ! 2 ! /4! ) ! 8 ) *! Q > %& + ! ,


-! # $% & 4$ %+ ! # 11 ; %! .&= .'

) *! 5 > Q !(C ( * !/G 1 ! ,5


< * -! # $% & ' %( ) %+ ! # ++ ; 9! 96+=
911

) ! !5 !Q 4!) A !Q > 8 G %&& ! ,/


A -! # $% & $ % %+ ! # %. ; %! 1'=
..

) ! / ! %&&9 ! ,
-! # $% & $ % %+ ! # +& ; 9! 6&+=6 .

) ! ;! 2 ! Q ! 5 %&&' ! ,/ <
-! , % ' %( ) 7! # %9
; 9! 96'=9'+

0 !8 4 ( ! ? %&&1 ! ,/
*-! , $ % %. % ) !# 6 ; 1! +'P 1+!

0 ! ! S * * ! Q! ; ! 5! 4 ! > ! 4 %& & ! ,/


* ! -! # $% &
$ %* + ) !# %& ; 9! 9+ =99

20
0 ! ) $ 6 ! ,8 * ! * R -!
' % & ! # '! +'=9&

( ! / +! , -! 3 )
' ) # $% # 9; ! ++=+

( ! (( @ *! $ $ ! $ %4 %! ) !2 5 !
;Q

( !4 ( !/ ' ! ' %( )/ +! ? ) !; C *! ;C

( ! $( % ! ,) -! # $% & 8 %
* + ) # ; +! %' =%.'
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

( !(/ ; !Q %& + ! ,>


-! # $% & $ % %+ ! # + ; 1! %&%=
% .

( !4!4 !/!$ ! !/ !Q!4 !Q! G ! $! !/! !4!( !/


8 ! ( Q %&&6 ! ,G -! ' %( ) % # 1 ; +=9!
+'6=+.1

( ! ! ,) -! /+% 4 % # +1 ; %! %+=%

# $ ! 0! 5 ! Q/! 5 ! 5/! $ ! ( ! ( ! /! ! )>!


4 !5 !4 !)/!G !Q0!? * !/! !Q!0 !
4 ( !4 %&& ! ,5 = =
! ' %( ) + + ! # %. ; 6! 1.= .6
# " ! 0> + ! ,/
-! / + $ % %+ ! # %& ; ! %%9=%%.

# " !0> ! ,/ <


-! # $% &* + ) 9 ' %( )! # 1 ; 1! 9 '=6%%

> ! ?!> !@) ! # %& & ! ,G R


-! # $% & *% $+ 4% ' ) !# ; %!
'1=.9

> ! ?!> !@) ! # %& !, =


= -! # $% &
*% $+ 4% ' ) !# %. ; 1! 9+.=99'

> ! / %&&+ ! 3 ) ) 4% , / . 8$ % ) 4$ )
' ) % ) 4% ! * !; Q ! ;Q

E ! $ C ! 5 5 %&&' ! , P -!
, % # $% &3 ) !# ; +! =%'
21
C !5> > 0 ( %&&9 ! ,/ ! A -! # $% &
$ % %+ ! # + ; %! 9 %=9%9

" C

Q 5D / ) * G ( 2
F 5 T ) ! ) !) ( 5282 (
! *
!
(5 2 4 ( !
< ( = * ,; * -
* ,: $ - 4 4 *! * )
Downloaded by CATOLICA PORTO At 04:56 09 February 2015 (PT)

4 " ( A
Q 5D A U

$ # 5 / ) 4 G V F !
) ! * ! *
( (5 2 4 ( !) (5 2 4 (
) F
< ! 3 A (
A

/ / ) 4 2 G F )
? ! 4 !( * ! =
/ A

) W 5 / ) ( ( F
? ) 2 ( )
F ? ) (
( ( 5 F (
* A
( G G: )! *

22

You might also like