Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2024-01-27 17021-M2 21x36 D103-19 ASCE705 ACI318-19
2024-01-27 17021-M2 21x36 D103-19 ASCE705 ACI318-19
2024-01-27 17021-M2 21x36 D103-19 ASCE705 ACI318-19
for
DP Watering SAS
Nominal 98,000 Gallon Bolted Steel Water Tank
Medellin, Colombia
Job No.17021-M2
Client: DP Watering SAS Location Medellin, Colombia
Page 1 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Shell Heights
Height of Fifth Ring : = 4.10 ft
Height of Fourth Ring : = 8.00 ft
Height of Third Ring : = 8.00 ft
Height of Second Ring : = 8.00 ft
Height of Bottom Ring : = 8.10 ft
Shell Thickness[AWWA D103 Section 5.4]
treq = Shell Thickness Required for Net Tensile Stress = 2.6HDsG/(Ft(s-dbh)) [AWWA D103 5-4]
Ft =Allowable Tensile Stress = Min(0.6Fy(1.0-0.9r+3rdbolt/s),0.6Fy,0.4Fu) [AWWA D103 5-7 & 5-8]
H = Height of Liquid = 35.000 ft
D = Tank Diameter = 21.542 ft
No. Staves = 14
γ = Density of liquid = 62.4 lb/ft3
s = Bolt Spacing = 2 in
G = Specific Gravity = 1.00
dbh = Bolt Hole Diameter = 0.563 in
dbolt = Bolt Diameter, dbolt = 0.50 in
r = Force Transmitted By Bolt(s) Divided by Tensile Force [AWWA D103 Section 5.5.3]
N = Bolt Rows
t = Shell Thickness
Shell Shell Ht
Bolt Rows treq (in) t (in) Material Fy (ksi) Fu (ksi) r Ft (ksi)
Thickness (Ft)
Fifth Ring: 12 gauge 1 0.0111 4.10 0.1046 A-1011-40 40 55 1 20.4
Fourth Ring: 12 gauge 1 0.042 8.00 0.1046 A-1011-40 40 55 1 20.4
Third Ring : 10 gauge 1 0.072 8.00 0.1345 A-1011-40 40 55 1 20.4
Second Ring: 7/32" 1 0.114 8.00 0.2188 A-36 36 58 1 18.4
Bottom Ring: 1/4" 1 0.149 8.10 0.2500 A-36 36 58 1 18.4
Bolt Design[AWWA D103 Section 5.5]
Vertical Stave Lap Bolt Loading
Hf = Hoop Force = HγD/2
P = Bolt Force = Hf/(12/S)
an = Net Section Distance = min(s-dbh, 0.85s) = 1.438
Pallow,t = Allowable Tension on Net Section = Ftant
Pallow,b = Bolt Allowable Bearing Force= 1.35FydbolttN
Pallow,s =Bolt Allowable Shear = fvAtsN = 0.6(0.9)/2.2FuAtsN < 0.25FuAtsN
Fu,bolt = Ultimate Tensile Stress Bolt = 120,000 psi SAE Grade 5
n = Number of Bolt Threads Per Inch = 13 threads/in
2
Ats =0.78584(d-0.9743/n) = 0.142 in2
smin = Minimum Edge Distance = (P/N)/(0.6Fyt)[D103 Eq 5-6]
se = Edge Distance = 0.75 in
Tension on Min
Hoop Bolt Net Bearing Shear Edge
Shell Force Force, Section , Pallow,b Pallow Dist.
Thickness Bolt Grade H (ft) (lb/ft) Pbolt (lb) Pallow,t (lb) (lb) (lb) (in)
Fifth Ring: 0.1046 5 2.896 1,946 324 3,067 2,824 4,182 0.13 OK
Fourth Ring: 0.1046 5 10.896 7,323 1,221 3,067 2,824 4,182 0.49 OK
Third Ring : 0.1345 5 18.896 12,700 2,117 3,944 3,632 4,182 0.66 OK
Second Ring: 0.2188 5 26.896 18,077 3,013 5,775 5,317 4,182 0.64 OK
Bottom Ring: 0.25 5 35 23,524 3,921 6,598 6,075 4,182 0.73 OK
Page 2 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Page 3 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
wr
L
Rafter Design
Try Rafter Member C3x4.1
Section Properties
d = Rafter Depth 3 inch Channel wr = Rafter Weight 4.1 lb/ft
Fy (ASTM A36) 36 ksi Sx = Section Modulus 1.10 in3
ry = Radius of Gyration 0.40 in Ix = Moment of Inertia 1.66 in4
Zx = Plastic Section Modulus 1.32 in3 Iy = Moment of Inertia 0.19 in5
ho = Flange Centroid Dist. 2.73 in Cw = Warping Constant 0.31 in6
4 r
J = Torsional Constant 0.03 in ts = Eff. Radius of Gyration 0.469 in
c = ho/2√(Iy/Cw) 1.08 E= 29,000 ksi
Roof Configuration & Loading
No. Rafters = 14
Roof Slope = 1 :12
θ = arctan(rise/run) = 4.764 °
L = Design Rafter Length = 9.920 ft
La = Actual Rafter Length = 9.982 ft
lt = Max Tributary Width to Rafter = 4.83 ft
wD = (D)*lt =Max Tributary Dead Load to Rafter = 25.98 lb/ft
wLr = (Lr)*lt =Max Tributary Live Load to Rafter = 120.85 lb/ft
Design Moment
LC 1 (D+Lr)
x = Distance Along Beam to Point of Maximum Moment = 5.69 ft
2 2 2
Mu = W/(3L )(L -x )+wrx/2(L-x) = 11.7 k-in
Yielding Limit State [AISC 14th Edition Section F2.1]
Mn = Mp = FyZx = 47.52 k-in
Lateral-Torsional Buckling Limit State [AISC 14th Edition Section F2.2]
Lb =Unbraced Length = 0.000 in
Lp = 1.76ry√(E/Fy) [AISC 13th ED. Eq. F2-5] = 19.881 in > 0.00 in
L b < L p , thus limit state of Lateral Torsional Buckling Does not Apply
Design Flexural Strength
Mn = = 47.52 k-in
Ωb (ASD) = = 1.67
Mn/Ωb = = 28.46 k-in > 11.7 k-in
OK
Mu/(Mn/Ωb) = = 0.412
Use 14-C3x4.1 Rafters
Max. Rafter Spacing [AWWA D103 Eq. 5-12]
trp = Roof Plate Thickness = 0.1046 in
Fy = Yield Strength of Roof Material = 36,000 psi
W D+Lr = Dead Load and Live Load on Roof Surface = 29.375 psf
Lmax = ((300Fytrp2)/(W D+Lr))0.5 <= 60 inches = 60.0 in
Rafter Spacing = 58.0 in < 60.0 OK
Page 4 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
W r0
Mrb
b
a
Page 5 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
6" Gravel m
tg
Dc
Dg
Grade
d = Column width = = 8.625 in
Allowable Soil Bearing = = 1,500 psf
Ht. Above Grade = = 6 in
Act. Col. Load = = 4,846 lb
Area Req'd at Grade = = 3.23ft2
Diameter (Dc) at Base of Column = = 18in
Diameter (Dg) at Grade = = 30in
Area at Grade = = 4.91 sq ft > 3.23 sq ft
OK
fb = P/A = 19.04 psi (Ref: Roark, Table 24, 2L)
Fb = = 24,000 psi b/a = 0.521
b = = 4.688 in Km Factor (K) = 0.161
a = = 9 in K m = K x f b x a2 = 249 in-lb
tp = (6Km/Fb)0.5 = 0.25 in < 0.375 in, OK
Page 6 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
SD1 = USM1 (Eq 14-4) = 0.465 g (Design Acceleration, 5% damped, at 1.0 sec period)
Convective Acceleration
Sac = Design spectral response acceleration for the convective component, 0.5 percent damped,
at the first mode sloshing wave period Tc
Tc = First mode sloshing wave period
Tc = 2Pi x (D / 3.68g x tanh(3.68H/D))1/2 = 2.679 Seconds
K = Damping scaling factor to convert spectrum = 1.5
from 5 percent to 0.5 percent damping
For Tc ≤ TL [Eq. 14-12]
Sac = KSD1/Tc ≤ SDS = 0.260 g
For Tc > TL [Eq. 14-13]
Sac = KTLSD1/Tc2 = N/A
Ac = λESacIE/Rc [Eq. 14-17] = 0.122 g
Page 7 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Shell Weight
Shell - Fifth Ring Wt. = 1,326 lb
Shell - Fourth Ring Wt. = 2,489 lb
Shell - Third Ring Wt. = 3,201 lb
Shell - Second Ring Wt. = 5,207 lb
Shell - Bottom Ring Wt. = 6,024 lb
W s = Total Shell Wt. = 18,247 lb
Roof Structure Weight
Roof Wt. = 1,595 lb
Total Rafter Wt. = 573 lb
W r =Total Roof & Rafter Wt. = 2,168 lb
Freeboard
Table 6 Minimum Freeboard Requirements
Risk Category
SDS I&II III IV
SDS < 0.33g None None d
SDS ≥ 0.33g None 0.7d d
Summary of Design Seismic Loads
D/H = 0.62
Ai = Impulsive design acceleration = 0.1839 g
Ac = Convective Design Acceleration = 0.1215 g
W s = Total Weight of Tank Shell = 18,247 lb
W T = Weight of Tank Contents (Eq 14-19) = 796,003 lb
W c /W T = 0.230D/H*tanh(3.67H/D) (Eq 14-18) = 0.143
W c = Effective Convective Weight = 113,510 lb
W i/W t = 1.0-.218(D/H) (Eq 14-17) = 0.865
W i = Effective Impulsive Weight = 688,383 lb
W r = Weight of Roof and Rafters = 2,168 lb
Xs = Height from Bottom of Shell to Center of Gravity of Shell = 14.58 ft
Ht = Total Height of the Shell = 36.208 ft
Xi/H = 0.5-0.094(D/H) [Eq. 14-21] = 0.4417
Xi = Height from Bottom of Shell to Centroid of Lateral Seismic = 15.46 ft
Force Applied to Impulsive Weight W i
Xc/H = (1.0-(cosh(3.67H/D)-1)/(3.67H/Dsinh(3.67H/D))[Eq. 14-22] = 0.8332
Xc = Height from Bottom of Shell to Centroid of Lateral Seismic = 29.16 ft
Force Applied to Convective Weight W c
W f = Weight of Tank Bottom = 2,002 lb
Design Overturning Moment and Base Shear at Bottom of the Shell
Ms = √[(Ai)(W sXs+W rHt+W iXi)2+(AcW cXc)2] [D103 Eq. 14-15] = 2,059,774 ft-lb
2 2
Vf = √[(Ai)(W s+W r+W i+W f) +(AcW c) ] [D103 Eq. 14-23] = 131,418 lb
tb init = 0.1345 in
wL init = 7.9tb√FyHG ≤ 1.28HDG [D103 Eq. 14-29] = 1,257 plf
wL max = 1.28HDG = 965 plf
wrs = 2/3(W r) + 1/2(W rftr) = 1,350 lb
wt = (W s + wrs)/(πD) [Eq. 14-33] = 289.58 plf
Page 8 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Overturning Ratio
J Anchorage Ratio Criteria
J ≤ 0.785 No calculated uplift under design seismic overturning moment. Tank is self-anchored.
0.785<J≤1.54 Uplift occurs but tank is stable for the design load providing shell compression
requirements are satisfied. Tank is self-anchored.
J > 1.54 Tank is not stable and cannot be self-anchored for the design load. Modify the
annular plate if L < 0.035D is not controlling or add mechanical anchorage.
Av(1) = 0.48SDS [D103 14.3.4.3 limited by buckling] = 0.378 g
Av(2) = 0.19SDS [D103 14.3.4.3 not limited by buckling] = 0.15 g
2
J = Ms/(D (wt(1-0.4Av(2))+wL)) [D103 Eq. 14-28] = 3.587 Anchorage
Required!
Seismic Sliding Stability Check
Vallow = 0.4[W s+W r+W i+W c)(1.0-0.4Av(2)) [D103 Eq. 14-44] = Allowable = 312,392 lb
Lateral Shear
Vf = Design Shear Due to Horizontal Design Acceleration = 131,418 lb < 312,392 lb,
No Seismic
Sliding
Page 9 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Second Ring:
t = 0.2188 in
Y = 26.896 ft > 0.75D
D/H >= 1.333
Ni = (4.5Ai(GDH)(Y/H -.5((Y/H)2))(TANH(.866(D/H)))[D103 Eq. 14-35] = 144.0 lb/in
D/H < 1.333 and Y < 0.75D:
Ni = (2.77AiGD2)(Y/0.75D -.5((Y/0.75D)2)))[D103 Eq. 14-36] = 66.0 lb/in
D/H < 1.333 and Y >= 0.75D:
Ni = 1.39AiGD2 [D103 Eq. 14-37] = 118.6 lb/in←Governs
2 = 0.59 lb/in
Nc = 0.98AcGD (cosh(3.68(H-Y)/D)/COSH(3.68(H/D)))[Eq. 14-38]
Nh = 2.6YDG = 1,506 lb/in
av = Vertical Acceleration = 0.38 g
σs = √(Ni2 + 2 2
Nc + (Nh x Av) ))/ts [D103 Eq. 14-34] = 2,658 psi
σh = Nh/ts = 6,885 psi
σ t = σ s + σh = 9,543 psi
Fallow = 1.333Ft = 24,474 psi > 9,543 psi
OK
Third Ring:
t = 0.1345
Y = 18.896 ft > 0.75D
D/H >= 1.333
Ni = (4.5Ai(GDH)(Y/H -.5((Y/H)2))(TANH(.866(D/H)))[D103 Eq. 14-35] = 119.9 lb/in
D/H < 1.333 and Y < 0.75D:
Ni = (2.77AiGD2)(Y/0.75D -.5((Y/0.75D)2)))[D103 Eq. 14-36] = 114.8 lb/in
D/H < 1.333 and Y >= 0.75D:
Ni = 1.39AiGD2 [D103 Eq. 14-37] = 118.6 lb/in ←Governs
2 = 2.20 lb/in
Nc = 0.98AcGD (cosh(3.68(H-Y)/D)/COSH(3.68(H/D)))[Eq. 14-38]
Nh = 2.6YDG = 1,058.3 lb/in
av = Vertical Acceleration = 0.38 g
σs = √(Ni2 + 2 2
Nc + (Nh x Av) ))/ts [D103 Eq. 14-34] = 3,102 psi
σh = Nh/ts = 7,868 psi
σ t = σ s + σh = 10,971 psi
Fallow = 1.333Ft = 27,193 psi > 10,971 psi
OK
Fourth Ring:
t = 0.1046
Y = 10.896 ft <0.75D
D/H >= 1.333
Ni = (4.5Ai(GDH)(Y/H -.5((Y/H)2))(TANH(.866(D/H)))[D103 Eq. 14-35] = 80.0 lb/in
D/H < 1.333 and Y < 0.75D:
Ni = (2.77AiGD2)(Y/0.75D -.5((Y/0.75D)2)))[D103 Eq. 14-36] = 105.7 lb/in
D/H < 1.333 and Y >= 0.75D:
Ni = 1.39AiGD2 [D103 Eq. 14-37] = 118.6 lb/in ←Governs
2
Nc = 0.98AcGD (cosh(3.68(H-Y)/D)/COSH(3.68(H/D)))[Eq. 14-38] = 8.59 lb/in
Nh = 2.6YDG = 610.3 lb/in
av = Vertical Acceleration = 0.38 g
σs = √(Ni2 + 2 2
Nc + (Nh x Av) ))/ts [D103 Eq. 14-34] = 2,427 psi
σh = Nh/ts = 5,835 psi
σ t = σ s + σh = 8,262 psi
Fallow = 1.333Ft = 27,193 psi > 8,262 psi
OK
Page 10 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Fifth Ring:
t = 0.1046
Y = 2.896 ft <0.75D
D/H >= 1.333
Ni = (4.5Ai(GDH)(Y/H -.5((Y/H)2))(TANH(.866(D/H)))[D103 Eq. 14-35] = 24.1 lb/in
D/H < 1.333 and Y < 0.75D:
Ni = (2.77AiGD2)(Y/0.75D -.5((Y/0.75D)2)))[D103 Eq. 14-36] = 38.6 lb/in
D/H < 1.333 and Y >= 0.75D:
Ni = 1.39AiGD2 [D103 Eq. 14-37] = 118.6 lb/in ←Governs
Nc = 0.98AcGD2(cosh(3.68(H-Y)/D)/COSH(3.68(H/D)))[Eq. 14-38] = 33.69 lb/in
Nh = 2.6YDG = 162.2 lb/in
av = Vertical Acceleration = 0.38 g
σs = √(Ni2 + Nc2 + (Nh x Av)2))/ts [D103 Eq. 14-34] = 764 psi
σh = Nh/ts = 1550.7 psi
σ t = σ s + σh = 2,314 psi
Fallow = 1.333Ft = 27,193 psi > 2,314 psi
OK
Page 11 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Foundation Properties
f'c = Design Concrete Compressive Strength = 3,000 psi
Rebar: A.S.T.M. A-615, Grade 60
Ft : = 24,000 psi
Seismic Uplift
N = No. of Anchor Bolts = 14 ea
Ms = = 2,060 ft-k
W' = W s + (1/2W rftr +2/3W roof) = 19,597 lb
Dac = Diameter of Anchor Circle = 22.21 ft
Ps = 4Ms/(0.7NDac) - 0.9(1-0.4Av)W/N [D103 Eq. 5-14, ASCE 7-05 = 36,671 lb > 4,205 lb,
Strength Design Load Combination 7. 0.9D + 1.0E] Seismic Uplift
Governs
Wind Uplift
Mw = (See Page 3) = 254,884 ft-lb
Pw = 4Mw/(0.6Ndac)-0.9W/N [D103 Eq. 5-13, ASCE 7-05 Strength = 4,205 lb
Design Load 5: 0.9D+1.0W] = Uplift Per Bolt
Page 12 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Seismic Shear
Vf = √[(Ai)(W s+W r+W i+W f)2+(AcW c)2] [D103 Eq. 14-23] = 131,418 lb
Vallow = 0.4[W s+W r+W i+W c)(1.0-0.4Av) [D103 Eq. 14-44] = = 312,392 lb
Allowable Lateral Shear
Vnet(E) = Vf/0.7 - 0.9Vallow [ASCE 7-16 Strength Design Load = 0 lb
Combination 7. 0.9D + 1.0E]
veq = Vnet(E)/N = Shear Per Anchor = 0 lb < 807 lb
Wind Shear
Vw = Pw*HshellD = 14,079 lb
VALLOW = 0.4W tot = Resisting Friction Force [D103 Eq. 15-3] = 13,515 lb
Vnet(W) = Vw/0.6- 0.9Vallow [ASCE 7-16 Strength Design Load = 11,301 lb
Combination 5. 0.9D + 1.0W]
vwind = Vnet(W)/N = Shear Per Anchor = 807 lb
Page 13 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Thus, Use: 1.250 in Diameter Anchor Bolts, Embed 21 3/8 in, Project 24 in above foundation
with 4.0 in. Diameter x 3/8 in thick Anchor Plate
Page 14 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Anchorage Summary
4"
14 - 1 1/4'' Dia. Anchor Bolts
21.542 Ft Tank Diameter
6"
24" 21 3/8"
F1
F2
F3 d1
e d2
F4
d4 d3
Page 15 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Page 16 of 17
Superior Tank Company, Inc. | 17021-M2 January 27, 2024
Bending Capacity:
L = (4")√2 = 5.66 in
M = P/2*L = 98,678 in-lb
2
Zx = th /4 = Plastic Section Modulus = 10.522 in3
2
Sx = th /6 = Section Modulus = 7.014 in3
My = FySx = Yield Moment = 280,576 lb-in
Mn = Mp = FyZx ≤ 1.6My [AISC 360 F11-1] = 448,922 lb-in
Ωc (ASD) = = 1.67
Mn/Ωb = = 268,815 lb-in > 98,678 lb-in
OK
Page 17 of 17