Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Extinction Project (Precious)
Extinction Project (Precious)
Extinction Project (Precious)
TOPIC:
SUBMITTED TO:
DR. SHOBOLA
Extinction is a critical tool used in behavior modification to decrease undesirable behaviors and
increase desirable behaviors. It involves removing the reinforcement that is maintaining a
behavior, which can be either positive reinforcement (adding something desirable) or negative
reinforcement (removing something aversive).
Also, extinction could refer to the gradual reduction and eventual elimination of a previously
learned behavior by withholding the reinforcement that originally maintained it i.e when a
behavior is reinforced, meaning it is followed by a positive outcome or reward, it tends to
increase in frequency. However, when reinforcement is consistently removed or withheld, the
behavior is no longer reinforced and its occurrence decreases over time. This process is known
as extinction e.g nail-biting, interrupting, stealing, whining etc.
Punishment refers to the application of aversive consequences following a behavior with the
intention of reducing the likelihood of that behavior occurring again in the future. It involves
the use of negative consequences or the removal of positive stimuli to discourage unwanted
behavior.
Punishment aims to create a strong association between the behavior and the negative
outcome, which is intended to deter the individual from repeating the behavior. It can also be
positive or negative. It is positive when a stimulus is given or added to decrease a behavior and
it is negative when a stimulus is withdrawn to decrease a behavior.
ORIGIN OF EXTINCTION.
Extinction is a key concept in behavior modification that refers to the process of eliminating or
reducing a behavior by withholding reinforcement. Several theories have been proposed to
explain the phenomenon of extinction in behavior modification. Here are three prominent
theories with references to further explore each theory:
Operant conditioning, developed by B.F. Skinner, focuses on how behavior is shaped and
modified by consequences. According to this theory, extinction occurs when a previously
reinforced behavior is no longer followed by a reinforcing consequence, resulting in a decrease
in the frequency or strength of that behavior.
Operant conditioning is a psychological theory that explores how behavior is influenced by its
consequences. According to operant conditioning, behaviors that are followed by positive
consequences are more likely to be repeated, while behaviors followed by negative
consequences are less likely to be repeated. Extinction is a process within operant conditioning
where a previously reinforced behavior gradually decreases or disappears when reinforcement
is no longer provided for that behavior.
Extinction occurs when the reinforcer that maintained a behavior is no longer delivered, leading
to a decline in the frequency of that behavior. The process of extinction involves the weakening
of the association between the behavior and its consequences, resulting in a decrease in the
occurrence of the behavior over time.
To illustrate the concept of extinction, let's consider a case study involving a dog being trained
to sit using positive reinforcement. The trainer initially rewards the dog with a treat every time
it successfully sits on command. As a result, the dog learns that sitting leads to a positive
outcome (the treat) and is more likely to sit when commanded.
However, during the extinction phase, the trainer stops providing treats when the dog sits.
Initially, the dog may still exhibit the behavior, hoping to receive a treat. When the treat is
consistently withheld, the dog's behavior of sitting will gradually decrease in frequency. If
extinction continues, the dog may eventually stop sitting altogether, as the association between
sitting and receiving a treat weakens.
Several factors can affect the speed and effectiveness of extinction. These include the strength
of the previous association between the behavior and its consequences, the consistency of
withholding reinforcement, and the presence of any other reinforcing stimuli in the
environment.
The behavioral excess theory suggests that extinction can occur when a behavior has been
excessively reinforced, leading to satiation or a reduction in the reinforcing value of the
consequence. In other words, if a behavior has been frequently and consistently reinforced, the
absence of reinforcement during extinction may result in a decrease in the behavior.
Behavioral Excess Theory is a theoretical framework within behavior analysis that seeks to
explain the occurrence and persistence of problem behaviors. According to this theory,
problem behaviors such as aggression, self-injury, or disruptive behaviors may be considered
excessive responses to environmental factors. These behaviors are thought to be maintained by
social reinforcement, where the individual engages in the behavior because it has previously
resulted in attention, escape from aversive situations, or access to preferred items or activities.
Extinction is a behavioral procedure commonly used to decrease or eliminate problem
behaviors. It involves withholding the reinforcement that maintains the problem behavior,
thereby reducing its occurrence over time. In the context of Behavioral Excess Theory,
extinction is implemented to disrupt the pattern of social reinforcement that supports the
problem behavior.
Let's consider a case study to illustrate the application of Behavioral Excess Theory and
extinction:
Case Study:
Child: Sarah
Sarah, a 4-year-old child, engages in frequent tantrums when her parents are occupied with
other activities. These tantrums often involve screaming, crying, and throwing objects. Sarah's
parents typically respond to her tantrums by giving her attention, hoping to calm her down.
This attention serves as a positive reinforcement for the tantrum behavior, leading to its
persistence.
To address this problem behavior using Behavioral Excess Theory and extinction, Sarah's
parents decide to implement an extinction procedure. They make a plan to ignore Sarah's
tantrums completely, ensuring that no attention is provided during these episodes.
Initially, when the extinction procedure is implemented, Sarah's tantrums may escalate in
intensity and frequency. This is known as an extinction burst, where the individual increases
their behavior to regain the previously effective reinforcement. However, Sarah's parents
remain consistent in ignoring the tantrums, providing no attention or reinforcement.
Over time, as the tantrums no longer result in attention, Sarah's behavior starts to decrease.
She learns that tantrums no longer produce the desired response from her parents, making the
behavior less effective in achieving her goal of obtaining attention. As a result, the tantrums
gradually diminish in frequency and intensity until they eventually cease.
The extinction burst theory proposes that during the initial stages of extinction, there is often
an increase in the frequency, intensity, or duration of the behavior being extinguished. This
phenomenon is known as an extinction burst. The theory suggests that the burst occurs due to
an individual's attempt to regain the previously reinforced consequence, and if the behavior is
not reinforced, it eventually diminishes.
The Extinction Burst Theory is a concept used to explain the phenomenon of extinction in
behavior analysis. It suggests that when a previously reinforced behavior is no longer rewarded,
there is a temporary increase in the frequency, intensity, or duration of the behavior before it
eventually decreases and goes extinct. This burst of activity occurs because the organism is
trying to obtain the reward that it previously associated with the behavior.
During the extinction process, an individual or animal learns that a specific behavior no longer
produces the desired outcome. For example, if a dog has been trained to sit in exchange for a
treat, but suddenly the treats stop being given after sitting, the dog might exhibit an extinction
burst. The dog might bark, jump, or paw at the person in an attempt to obtain the treat it used
to receive. However, if the person remains consistent and does not provide the treat, the dog
will eventually stop displaying the unwanted behaviors.
Case Study:
Let's consider a case study involving a child and their bedtime routine. Previously, the child was
allowed to stay up an extra half hour if they repeatedly asked their parents for more time.
However, the parents decide to change the routine and enforce a strict bedtime without any
additional negotiation. Initially, the child may exhibit an extinction burst by throwing a tantrum,
crying, or persistently asking for more time to stay awake. The child's behavior intensifies in an
attempt to regain the previously reinforced outcome of staying up later. However, if the
parents consistently follow through with the new bedtime routine and do not give in to the
child's demands, the extinction burst will eventually subside, and the child will adapt to the new
routine.
BEHAVIOR MODIFICATION.
The concept of behavior modification, also known as applied behavior analysis (ABA) or
behavior therapy, is a systematic approach to understanding and changing behavior. It is based
on the principles of behaviorism, which emphasize the role of environmental factors in shaping
behavior. Behavior modification techniques have been widely used in various fields, including
psychology, education, and clinical practice, to address a range of behavioral issues and
promote positive change.
Extinction, within the context of behavior modification or applied behavior analysis (ABA),
refers to the process of eliminating a previously reinforced behavior by discontinuing the
delivery of the reinforcing consequences that maintained that behavior. It involves withholding
the reinforcement that previously followed a particular behavior, with the aim of reducing or
eliminating that behavior over time. Extinction is a fundamental principle in behavior
modification and has been applied successfully in various settings to address unwanted
behaviors.
When implementing extinction, it is crucial to be consistent and ensure that the reinforcer is
completely removed. Inconsistently or intermittently providing reinforcement during extinction
can lead to an increase in the behavior, as it may intermittently be reinforced and persist
longer. Extinction can be challenging initially, as individuals may exhibit an increase in the
frequency, intensity, or duration of the behavior in what is called an extinction burst. However,
if reinforcement is consistently withheld, the behavior will eventually decrease and may go
extinct.
The principles of extinction in behavior modification are based on the concept of removing or
withholding reinforcement to reduce or eliminate a target behavior. Here are the key principles
involved in the process of extinction:
3. Extinction Burst: When reinforcement is initially removed, it is common for the behavior to
temporarily increase in frequency, intensity, or duration. This is known as an extinction burst.
The individual may engage in the behavior more frequently or more intensely in an attempt to
obtain the previously experienced reinforcement. It is important to remain consistent during
this phase and not provide any accidental reinforcement, as the extinction burst will eventually
subside.
4. Spontaneous Recovery: Even after a behavior has been extinguished, it is possible for it to
reappear temporarily. This is referred to as spontaneous recovery. The behavior may resurface
after a period of time, but it is usually weaker and less persistent than before. Consistency in
maintaining the extinction procedure can help address any spontaneous recovery that may
occur.
5. Extinction of All Reinforcers: Extinction should be applied to all reinforcers that maintain the
target behavior. If the behavior is reinforced by multiple sources, all of them should be
addressed to ensure comprehensive extinction. If reinforcement is still available from some
sources, the behavior may persist.
The process of extinction involves several key steps and processes to effectively reduce or
eliminate a target behavior. Here are the main processes involved in the extinction of a
behavior:
1. Identify the Target Behavior: The first step is to clearly define and identify the specific
behavior that is targeted for extinction. It is essential to have a precise understanding of the
behavior to be able to apply the extinction procedure effectively.
2. Analyze the Reinforcement: Determine the type of reinforcement that is maintaining the
target behavior. This could be positive reinforcement (receiving something desirable) or
negative reinforcement (escaping or avoiding something aversive). Understanding the nature of
the reinforcement is crucial for designing an effective extinction plan.
3. Withhold Reinforcement: Once the reinforcement maintaining the behavior has been
identified, the next step is to deliberately and consistently withhold that reinforcement. This
means ensuring that the behavior no longer leads to the desired outcome or consequence that
previously reinforced it.
4. Consistency and Persistence: Consistency is key in the process of extinction. Reinforcement
must be withheld every time the target behavior occurs to prevent any accidental or
intermittent reinforcement, which could prolong the extinction process. Persistence is also
important, as it may take time for the behavior to diminish.
5. Ignore the Behavior: In many cases, the best approach during extinction is to ignore the
target behavior completely. This means refraining from any verbal or nonverbal attention,
reaction, or response to the behavior. By removing attention or social reinforcement, the
behavior becomes less likely to occur over time.
6. Monitor for Extinction Burst: During the early stages of extinction, it is common for the target
behavior to temporarily increase in frequency, intensity, or duration. This is known as an
extinction burst. It is crucial to expect and anticipate this burst and remain consistent in
withholding reinforcement, as the behavior will eventually decrease.
7. Prevent Spontaneous Recovery: Even after a behavior has been extinguished, there is a
possibility of it reappearing temporarily. This is known as spontaneous recovery. To prevent
this, it is important to continue the extinction procedure consistently, even after the behavior
has seemingly diminished.
9. Generalization and Maintenance: Once the target behavior has significantly decreased or
been eliminated, it is crucial to reinforce and maintain the desired alternative behavior
consistently across different settings and situations. This helps ensure that the behavior change
is lasting and generalizes beyond the initial context.
10. Evaluate and Adjust: Regularly assess the progress and effectiveness of the extinction
process. If necessary, modify the extinction plan based on the individual's responses and
behavior patterns to ensure the best possible outcome.
In this case, the target behavior is nail-biting, where an individual habitually bites their nails.
Examine the factors that reinforce nail-biting. It could be driven by various factors such as
anxiety reduction, sensory stimulation, or habitual patterns.
Identify the specific reinforcers maintaining the behavior, such as attention from others or
sensory satisfaction. Develop a plan to withhold these reinforcers.
Ensure consistent implementation of the extinction procedure. For example, everyone involved
should be aware of the plan and committed to not providing any attention or reaction when the
individual engages in nail-biting.
When the individual starts nail-biting, those around them should completely ignore the
behavior. They should avoid any verbal or nonverbal reactions, refraining from giving attention
or providing any form of reinforcement.
Step 6: Monitor for Extinction Burst
Expect an initial increase in nail-biting behavior during the early stages of extinction, known as
an extinction burst. Despite the increase, it is crucial to remain consistent and continue ignoring
the behavior, as it will eventually decrease.
Even after nail-biting behavior has significantly decreased or stopped, be prepared for
occasional instances of spontaneous recovery. Maintain the extinction procedure to prevent
the behavior from resurfacing.
Simultaneously with the extinction process, encourage and reinforce alternative behaviors that
are incompatible with nail-biting. For instance, provide the individual with stress-relief toys or
alternative coping strategies to redirect their focus away from nail-biting.
Ensure that the individual generalizes the alternative behaviors and practices them consistently
across various situations and settings. Reinforce and praise the individual for engaging in the
desired alternative behavior.
Regularly assess the progress and effectiveness of the extinction procedure. If needed, modify
the plan based on individual responses and behavior patterns. Adjust the reinforcement
strategies to best support the individual in maintaining the desired behavior change.
By following these processes and principles, behavior modification practitioners can effectively
implement extinction as a technique to reduce or eliminate undesirable behaviors and promote
positive behavior change.
WHEN CAN EXTINCTION BE USED IN MODIFYING A BEHAVIOR?
Extinction can be a useful technique for modifying a behavior in various contexts and situations.
Here are some situations in which extinction can be used to modify a behavior:
2. Breaking Bad Habits: Habits are behaviors that are regularly repeated and reinforced over
time. Extinction can be used to break bad habits by removing the reinforcement or reward
associated with the behavior.
4. Improving Social Skills: Extinction can be used to teach individuals new, appropriate social
behaviors by withholding reinforcement for inappropriate behaviors and reinforcing desirable
alternative behaviors.
5. Encouraging Good Habits: Extinction can also be used to encourage good habits and
behaviors, such as praising individuals for engaging in positive behaviors and refraining from
providing reinforcement for negative behaviors.
5. Monitoring and Data Collection: Regular monitoring and data collection are beneficial to
track progress and assess the effectiveness of extinction. Keeping records of the target
behavior's frequency, intensity, and duration helps evaluate the impact of the intervention and
make any necessary adjustments. It also provides objective data to measure changes and
improvements.
6. Addressing Extinction Bursts: Anticipating and addressing extinction bursts is important for
maintaining consistency and avoiding unintended reinforcement. Extinction bursts involve an
initial increase in the target behavior as the individual tries harder to obtain the previously
experienced reinforcement. Being prepared for this temporary increase and continuing to
withhold reinforcement will help the behavior eventually decrease.
7. Support and Collaboration: Collaboration and support from all individuals involved in the
individual's environment are crucial for successful extinction. This includes family members,
caregivers, teachers, or colleagues. Consistent implementation of the extinction procedure and
reinforcing alternative behaviors require teamwork and a shared understanding of the goals
and strategies.
8. Individualized Approach: Recognize that each individual is unique, and the effectiveness of
extinction may vary. Factors such as age, cognitive abilities, and individual differences can
influence the response to extinction. A personalized approach that considers these factors and
tailors the extinction procedure accordingly can enhance its effectiveness.
By optimizing these factors and implementing extinction with care, practitioners can increase
the likelihood of successful behavior modification and promote positive behavior change.
4. Can Be Used in Various Settings: Extinction can be applied in a wide range of settings,
including homes, schools, workplaces, and therapeutic settings. It can be used with both
humans and animals, making it a versatile technique in behavior modification.
1. Initial Increase in Behavior: When implementing extinction, there is often an initial increase
in the frequency or intensity of the targeted behavior. This is known as an extinction burst and
can be challenging for practitioners and caregivers to manage. It requires consistency and
persistence to withstand the temporary escalation before the behavior decreases.
2. Potential for Emotional Response: During the extinction process, individuals may exhibit
emotional responses, such as frustration, anger, or heightened agitation. This can be
uncomfortable for both the individual and those implementing extinction. Careful monitoring
and support are necessary to address these emotional reactions.
3. Extinction Resistance: Some behaviors may be resistant to extinction, especially if they have
been strongly reinforced in the past or if alternative sources of reinforcement are available. The
effectiveness of extinction can vary depending on the individual, the behavior, and the context
in which it occurs.
4. Requires Consistency and Collaboration: Extinction requires consistent implementation
across all individuals involved in the individual's environment. This can be challenging if
different people respond differently to the behavior or inadvertently reinforce it. Collaboration
and communication are essential to ensure everyone is on the same page and consistently
applying extinction.
5. Ethical Considerations: There are ethical considerations when using extinction, particularly
when it involves withholding reinforcement or attention. Practitioners should carefully consider
the potential impact on the individual's well-being and ensure that alternative, more adaptive
behaviors are reinforced during the process.
CONCLUSION.
It is important to note that extinction should be implemented under the guidance of qualified
professionals who can assess the appropriateness of the technique for specific behaviors and
individuals. They can also help address any challenges or limitations associated with extinction
and provide support throughout the process.
Extinction should be used in conjunction with other behavior modification techniques and
should be implemented with care and caution. In some cases, it may not be appropriate or
effective, and other techniques may need to be considered. It is best to consult with a qualified
behavior modification practitioner or therapist before using extinction or any other behavior
modification technique.
REFERENCES
American Psychological Association. (2013). Guidelines for the Evaluation and Treatment of
Autism Spectrum Disorder in Adults. https://www.apa.org/autism-guidelines
Baer, D. M., Wolf, M. M., & Risley, T. R. (1968). Some current dimensions of applied behavior
analysis. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 1(1), 91-97.
Carr, E. G., & Durand, V. M. (1985). Reducing behavior problems through functional
communication training. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 18(2), 111-126.
Cooper, J.O., Heron, T.E., & Heward, W.L. (2007). Applied behavior analysis (2nd ed.). Pearson.
Cooper, J. O., Heron, T. E., & Heward, W. L. (2020). Applied Behavior Analysis (3rd ed.). Pearson.
Iwata, B. A., Dorsey, M. F., Slifer, K. J., Bauman, K. E., & Richman, G. S. (1982). Toward a
functional analysis of self-injury. Analysis and Intervention in Developmental Disabilities, 2(1-2),
3-20.
Iwata, B. A., Dorsey, M. F., Slifer, K. J., Bauman, K. E., & Richman, G. S. (1994). Toward a
functional analysis of self-injury. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 27(2), 197-209.
Kazdin, A. E. (2018). Behavior Modification in Applied Settings (9th ed.). Cengage Learning.
Lerman, D. C., & Iwata, B. A. (1996). Developing a technology for the use of operant extinction
in clinical settings: An examination of basic and applied research. Journal of Applied Behavior
Analysis, 29(3), 345-382.
Lerman, D. C., Iwata, B. A., & Wallace, M. D. (1999). Side effects of extinction: prevalence of
bursting and aggression during the treatment of self-injurious behavior. Journal of Applied
Behavior Analysis, 32(1), 1-8
Lerman, D. C., & Vorndran, C. M. (2002). On the status of knowledge for using punishment:
Implications for treating behavior disorders. Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, 35(4), 431-
464.
Mazur, J.E. (2006). Learning and behavior (6th ed.). Prentice Hall.
Miltenberger, R. G. (2016). Behavior Modification: Principles and Procedures (6th ed.). Cengage
Learning.
Skinner, B. F. (1938). The behavior of organisms: An experimental analysis. Appleton-Century-
Crofts.
Vollmer, T. R., & Iwata, B. A. (1991). Differential reinforcement as treatment for behavior
disorders: Procedural and functional variations. Research in Developmental Disabilities, 12(4),
297-319.