Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Motivating Students by Design
Motivating Students by Design
"Dr. Jones has provided a simple, practical, evidence-based handbook not just on
motivation, but on creating a more positive and effective classroom for both
students and teachers. This book should be on the desk or nightstand of every
teacher and professor. I intend to recommend it to all who will listen!"
-Jason W. Osborne, Ph.D., Associate Provost and Dean of the Graduate
School, Clemson University
The title of the book, Motivating Students by Design, was chosen b·ecause
the author explains how instructors can motivate students intentionally
through the design of their courses. The two primary purposes of this book
are to present a motivation model that can be used to design instruction
and to provide practical motivation strategies and examples that can be
by De.SIGN
strategies that motivate students. All of the strategies presented are
followed by several examples, which provide readers with over 100 ideas for
how the strategies can be implemented in courses. This book will be useful
to graduate students and beginning professors, as well as professors who
are more experienced and want to refine their instruction or try new
strategies.
www.theMUSICmodel.com
Brett D. Jones
Contents
Dedication
Introduction
x x
x x
x x
What are the purposes of this book?
x x
x x
What is motivation?
Figure 2.2. Individuals weigh the costs and benefits of different activities when
deciding in which activities to engage.
x x
Figure 2.4. The relationship between students’ MUSIC perceptions and their
motivation, engagement, and outcomes.
Figure 2.5. The process through which external variables, such as instructors’
teaching strategies, can affect students’ MUSIC perceptions, motivation,
engagement, and outcomes.
x x
x
x
How can you use the MUSIC model to design instruction?
x
x
x
Evaluating results
x
x x
MUSIC® Model of Academic Motivation Inventory Instructions for Scoring the MUSIC® Model of Academic Motivation
(Professor version, short-form ) Inventory (Professor version, short form)
1 2 3 4 5 6
Strongly Disagree Somewhat Somewhat Agree Strongly
disagree disagree agree agree Table 3.1. Table to Score the MUSIC Inventory Scales (Professor version)
x x
MUSIC® Model of Academic Motivation Inventory Open-Ended Questions Related to the MUSIC Model
(College Student version, short-form )
Table 3.2. The items for the MUSIC® Model of Academic Motivation Inventory
(College Student version, short-form)
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
Final Comments About Using the Assessment Tools
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x x
Figure 3.2. The MUSIC model design cycle Figure 3.3. Levels of a course
Table 3.3. A Brief Checklist to use at the End of Designing a Course or Activity
Questions to Help You Focus Your Redesign4
o
x x
Course Background
x x
6.0
5.2 5.3
5.1
5.0 4.9
4.6
4.3 4.2
4.0
x
3.0
2.0
1.0
Figure 3.4. Survey results near the end of the spring semester
x
Figure 3.6. Survey results near the end of the spring semester (darker shaded
bars, n = 47) and the end of the fall semester after redesign (lighter
shaded bars, n = 20)
x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x
x x
Problem
Solution
Overview of eMpowerment
x x
Empowerment Strategy 1
Relevant Theories Provide students with choices during class and within assignments.
x x
x
x x
Example M.1.12 – Using Games That Require Decisions Example M.1.13 – Giving Total Freedom on Assignments
x x
Empowerment Strategy 2
Incorporate learner-directed approaches.
x x
x
x
x
x
Empowerment Strategy 3
Explain to students the amount of control they have in the course.
Empowerment Strategy 4
Don’t give rewards that may be perceived as controlling.
x x
Empowerment Strategy 5
Avoid controlling language and allow students to talk more.
x x
Problem
Solution
Overview of Usefulness
x x
Relevant Theories
Usefulness Strategy 1
Explain how the content is useful to students’ lives.
x
x
x x
Figure 5.1. When students don’t perceive the course to be useful, you
can use the other components of the MUSIC model to
motivate students.
Usefulness Strategy 2
Ask students or someone else to share the reasons they find the course
content useful.
Example U.3.2 – Interviewing a Professional Example U.3.4 – Connecting Content to the Real-World
x
x
x
Example U.3.5 – Sharing Work with an Audience
x
x
x
x
Usefulness Strategy 4
Provide opportunities for students to set and reflect on their goals.
Problem
Solution
Overview of Success
x x
Figure 6.2. Students’ are motivated when challenge meet their ability level
(based on Csikszentmihalyi, 1990, p. 74)
Figure 6.1. Students’ success beliefs are affected by their past performances, by
observing others, by feedback from others, and by their emotional
reactions.
x x
Relevant Theories
x x
x
x x
Success Strategy 1
Help students believe they can succeed at course activities when they
put forth the required effort.
x x
Success Strategy 2
Create an environment that promotes and supports successful learning.
x
x x
Example S.2.13 – Administering a Collaborative Two-Stage Exam Example S.2.15 – Allowing Students to Share Experiences
x
x x
Success Strategy 3
Match the difficulty levels of class activities and assignments with the
abilities of the students.
x x
Success Strategy 4
Provide students with honest, specific feedback about their level of
competence at regular intervals.
x x
Success Strategy 5
Be explicit when describing your expectations and communicating to
students.
x x
─
x x
Problem
Solution
Overview of Interest
x x
Relevant Theories
x
x x
x
Figure 7.1. Oversimplified (but still helpful) diagram of how information can
enter memory or not
Interest Strategy 1
Design instruction that catches and holds students’ attention.
Example I.1.1 – Using Novelty
x x
x
x x
Interest Strategy 2
Use activities that pique students’ curiosity about the content.
Example I.2.2 – Providing Surprising Information Example I.2.5 – Teaching Concepts From Example to Definition
Example I.2.7 – Including Non-Typical Sources Example I.2.9 – Identifying Interesting Information
Interest Strategy 3
Stimulate emotional arousal in students to avoid boredom.
x x
Interest Strategy 4
Design curriculum with a consideration of students’ individual interests.
Problem
Solution
Overview of Caring
x x
Relevant Theories
x
x x
x
Example C.1.1 – Showing You’re Approachable
Caring Strategy 1
Be approachable and relatable to students.
x x
Caring Strategy 2
Ensure that students feel respected by you and the other students, both
online and face-to-face.
x
Caring Strategy 3
Show students that you care about whether or not they achieve the
course objectives.
Caring Strategy 5
Help students fit into the culture of the class, major, college, or
university.
Example C.5.1 – Making Connections to other Content Areas Example C.5.3 – Allowing Students to Share Their Knowledge
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
x
What is the MUSIC Model of Motivation Theory? What research has been conducted using the MUSIC model?
x x
Table 9.1. Studies in Higher Education That Use the MUSIC Model
Study Authors and Date School Level Courses/Subject Areas
x x
Table 9.3. Studies Examining Relationships Between the MUSIC Variables and
Domain identification
Study Authors and Date School Level Courses/Subject Areas
Table 9.2. Studies in Pre-K to 12 Schools That Use the MUSIC Model
Study Authors and Date School Level Courses/Subject Areas
Figure 9.1. Students’ course perceptions can affect the likelihood they choose a
career in that discipline.
Table 9.4. Studies Providing Validity Evidence for the MUSIC Inventory
MUSIC Inventory Country of
Study Authors and Date Version Language Participants
Afterword
References
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x x
x
APPENDICES
x x
APPENDIX A
Tips for Succeeding (see Example S.2.2)
This is an example of a “Tips for Succeeding” document. This isn’t a complete
document, but it’s intended to give you some ideas for what you can include.
x x
APPENDIX B
My Study Strategies in This Course assignment
(see Example S.2.9)
This is an example of an assignment that requires students to reflect on their study
strategies and to consider other possible strategies they could use to be more
effective learners.
x
x x
x
APPENDIX C
Retaking Tests (see Example S.2.12)
x
This is an example of an explanation as to why you’re allowing students to retake
tests.
x
x
x
x
x
x x
APPENDIX D APPENDIX E
Example Email to Students Doing Well (see Example S.2.15) Example Tables to Include in a Syllabus (see Example S.5.1)
This is an example of an email that can be sent to students who are doing well in your These two tables are examples of tables that can be included on your syllabus to help
course. This type of message can be sent to solicit their strategies, which can then be make course expectations explicit to students.
shared with the other students in the class.
APPENDIX F
Strategies to Learn Students’ Names (see Example C.1.1)
This appendix includes strategies that you can use to more effectively learn students’
names.
x
x
x
About the Author