Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Content of Sodium in Aluminium During Electrol
The Content of Sodium in Aluminium During Electrol
net/publication/239165707
CITATIONS READS
9 1,689
4 authors:
V. Danielik J. Thonstad
Slovak University of Technology in Bratislava Norwegian University of Science and Technology
84 PUBLICATIONS 526 CITATIONS 255 PUBLICATIONS 3,473 CITATIONS
All content following this page was uploaded by M. Korenko on 15 December 2017.
Received 21 August 2003; received in revised form 13 November 2003; accepted 17 November 2003
Abstract
The content of sodium in molten aluminium during electrolysis of the molten system Na3 AlF6 –NaCl–Al2 O3 was investigated at the
temperatures 750, 890 and 1000 ◦ C. Simultaneously, the cathodic overvoltage was measured. It was found that the experimental data on the
cathodic overvoltage agree well with the values predicted on the basis of the concentrations of sodium in molten aluminium. Saturation of
molten aluminium with sodium was not achieved by electrolysis of a cryolite-based electrolyte.
To achieve saturation of sodium in liquid aluminium the eutectic mixture NaF–NaCl was used as electrolyte. The experiments were carried
out at the temperatures 710, 750, 800, 900 and 960 ◦ C, i.e. below and above the boiling temperature of sodium at atmospheric pressure. In
this case, saturation of the molten aluminium with sodium was reached. The obtained data are treated by a thermodynamic model.
© 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
0013-4686/$ – see front matter © 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.electacta.2003.11.011
1506 P. Fellner et al. / Electrochimica Acta 49 (2004) 1505–1511
discuss the relationship between the content of sodium in melt. Therefore, in a subsequent series of experiments, an
aluminium and the cathodic overvoltage by the electrolysis electrolyte consisting of the eutectic mixture NaF + NaCl
of NaF–AlF3 –NaCl–Al2 O3 melts. (26.4 wt.% NaF + 73.6 wt.% NaCl, teut = 680 ◦ C) was used.
Electrolysis was carried out at the temperatures 710, 750,
800, 900 and 960 ◦ C. The temperatures 710 and 750 ◦ C were
2. Experimental chosen because the difference in the solubility of sodium
in liquid aluminium between the classical literature data
A sketch of the experimental apparatus used for the elec- [23–25] and the results of Hansen and co-workers [21,22]
trodeposition of sodium into an aluminium cathode (or rather is high in that range. On the other extreme, the temperature
electrodeposition of sodium as well as aluminium) is shown 960 ◦ C is close to the temperature of electrowinning of
in Fig. 1. The inner diameter of the graphite cell with a sin- aluminium [1], and no data on the solubility of sodium in
tered alumina lining was 55 mm, height 60 mm. Fifty grams aluminium at this temperature is available in the literature.
of aluminium and 100 g of electrolyte were weighed-in. The electrolysis was carried out with cathodic current den-
When the cryolite-based electrolyte was used, the electrolyte sities (jc ) up to 0.625 A cm−2 . The cathode surface is curved.
was saturated with alumina at the beginning of the electrol- The real cathodic current densities were determined accord-
ysis. Aluminium of purity 99.9% was used in the beginning ing to Zoriæ et al. [28]. At jc = 0.25 A cm−2 , the electroly-
of the experiment. During the experiment, sodium was de- sis could be carried out for several hours. The Al–Na alloy
posited into the aluminium. However, because of the molyb- was sampled every 15 min. For sampling a quartz tube (inner
denum (or iron) plate at the bottom of the electrolytic cell, Ø 4 mm) equipped with an attached syringe was used. The
a small amount of molybdenum was observed in the alu- sample was quenched in water mixed with ice. The cooled
minium (less than 0.1%) at the end of the experiment. metal sample was cleaned mechanically, dissolved in HCl
The cathodic overvoltage, which is mainly concentration (diluted to 1:1) and analysed by AAS.
overvoltage [1], was determined by a method based on fast
current interruption (ca. 50 ns). The potential decay of the
cathode voltage was monitored on an oscilloscope. Extrapo- 3. Results and discussion
lation of the transient curves to zero time yielded the IR-free
cathode potential, referred to the aluminium reference elec- 3.1. Cathodic overvoltage
trode . The experimental details can be found in [27].
Saturation of aluminium with sodium could not be When the molten system NaF–AlF3 –NaCl–Al2 O3 is elec-
achieved by electrolysis of the NaF–AlF3 –NaCl–Al2 O3 trolysed, the primary cathode reaction is the reduction of
Al(III) species. The chemistry of cryolite-based electrolytes
is rather complex [2]. Schematically the cathode reaction
can be written as
NaF
AlF3
250
200
150
ηcat/ mV
100
50
Fig. 3. The cathodic overvoltage vs. current density in the melt Na3 AlF6 + 5 wt.% NaCl + Al2 O3 (sat.) at 1000 ◦ C. Filled triangles: electrochemical
measurement of the cathodic overvoltage; full curve: data on the cathodic overvalotage described by the least squares method; open squares: calculated
from the contents of sodium in the aluminium cathode.
We may assume that the concentration overvoltage equals anode reaction was the evolution of chlorine. In neither case
the emf of the following concentration cell: could current densities higher than ca. 1 A cm−2 be used,
because of the occurrence of anode effect [2]. It can be seen
Al(Na)|NaF(I), AlF3 (I), NaCl(I)||NaF(II), AlF3 (II), that Eq. (3) describes well the relationship between the con-
NaCl(II)|Al(Na) (2) tent of sodium in aluminium and the cathodic concentration
overvoltage, also in the case of the low melting electrolyte
Index II denotes the concentration of species at the containing a high concentration of NaCl. It also follows that
metal/electrolyte interface under cathodic polarization of saturation of aluminium with sodium was not achieved in
aluminium, while index I denotes the situation when no these experiments, and the primary cathode process was al-
current passes through the interface, i.e. the bulk compo- ways the electrodeposition of aluminium.
sition. On the basis of this model, and taking reaction (1) The results given in Figs. 4 and 5 show considerable
into account, the cathodic concentration overvoltage ηc scatter. It is assumed to be due to losses of sodium during
is related to the ratio of the concentrations of sodium in sampling and quenching.
non-polarized and polarized aluminium [1,27]. It holds:
RT c(Na, j = 0) 250
ηc = ln (3)
F c(Na, j)
200
In Fig. 3, the cathodic concentration overvoltage mea-
sured at the temperature of 1000 ◦ C in the melt Na3 AlF6 +
150
5 wt.%NaCl + Al2 O3 (sat.) is plotted as a function of the
-η cat/ mV
1200
1000
800 890 ˚C
x(Na)/ ppm
600
400
750 ˚C
200
3.2. Solubility of sodium in aluminium corundum crucibles, so a low content of alumina would be
present in the melt. The electrolysis was carried out at the
The value of the saturation of liquid aluminium with temperatures of 710, 750, 800, 900 and 960 ◦ C. This tem-
sodium is of both practical a theoretical interest, not only perature interval covers both the temperature of aluminium
for aluminum electrolysis but also for the refining and cast- electrolysis and the temperatures of refining and casting of
ing of aluminium. Recently published data by Hansen and aluminium.
co-workers [21,22] suggest that a revision of the literature The results are shown in Figs. 6–8. The cathode current
data on this subject [23–25] has to be made. In order to pre- density was 0.25 A cm−2 . When the current density was in-
pare saturated solution of sodium in liquid aluminium, we creased up to 0.625 A cm−2 , the maximum concentration of
electrolysed a melt consisting of 26.4 wt.% NaF +73.6 wt.% sodium in aluminium was not significantly different from
NaCl (eutectic mixture). The electrolysis was carried out in that obtained at a lower current density jc = 0.25 A cm−2
1800
1600
1400
1200
x(Na) / ppm
1000
800
600
400
200
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
τ / min
Fig. 6. The content of sodium in the liquid Al–Na cathode as a function of the duration of electrolysis at 710 ◦ C. Composition of the electrolyte:
26.4 wt.% NaF + 73.6 wt.% NaCl. Open squares: jc = 0.125 A cm−2 ; filled squares: jc = 0.25 A cm−2 .
P. Fellner et al. / Electrochimica Acta 49 (2004) 1505–1511 1509
1800
1600
800 ˚C
1400
750 ˚C
1200
x(Na) / ppm
1000
800
600
400
200
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
τ / min
Fig. 7. The content of sodium in the liquid Al–Na cathode as a function of the duration of electrolysis. Composition of the electrolyte: 26.4 wt.%
NaF + 73.6 wt.% NaCl. Open squares: jc = 0.25 A cm−2 ; t = 750 ◦ C; cross: jc = 0.625 A cm−2 ; t = 750 ◦ C; filled squares: jc = 0.25 A cm−2 ; t = 800 ◦ C.
Horizontal lines: values of the content of sodium in aluminium determined by the regression analysis.
(see Fig. 7). The same limiting concentration of sodium sodium. The time dependence of the concentration of sodium
in aluminium was achieved even when the cathode current in aluminium can be explained by slow mixing of the de-
density was lowered to 0.125 A cm−2 (see Fig. 6). At this posited sodium with aluminium. Because of possible losses
current density the electrolytic cell could be operated for of sodium during sampling and quenching, the highest con-
several hours without an anode effect. It can be seen that centrations of sodium in aluminium were considered to be
after a certain time of electrolysis the content of sodium in the most reliable. As shown in the following, the concentra-
the Al–Na alloy reached a constant value. The amount of tions of sodium in liquid aluminium saturated with sodium
deposited sodium was by two orders of magnitude higher agree reasonably well with the data published in the clas-
than that required for saturation of the Al–Na alloy with sical papers on this subject [23–25]. The high solubilities
1800
900 ˚C
1600
1400
1200
x(Na) / ppm
1000
800
960 ˚C
600
400
200
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400
τ / min
Fig. 8. The content of sodium in the liquid Al–Na alloy as a function of the duration of electrolysis in the melt, 26.4 wt.% NaF + 73.6 wt.% NaCl,
at jc = 0.25 A cm−2 . Filled squares: t = 960 ◦ C; open squares: t = 900 ◦ C. Horizontal lines: values of the content of sodium in aluminium that were
considered as most reliable.
1510 P. Fellner et al. / Electrochimica Acta 49 (2004) 1505–1511
of sodium in aluminium reported by Hansen [21] have not It follows that at 900 ◦ C kH (900 ◦ C) = 62.67 MPa; and at
been confirmed. 960 ◦ C kH (960 ◦ C) = 90.87 MPa.
The boiling point of pure sodium is 883 ◦ C. No experi- When we assume that the pressure of sodium vapour
mental data on the solubility of sodium in aluminium above over liquid Al–Na alloy saturated with sodium during
this temperature has been reported in the literature. From our electrolysis of the NaF–NaCl mixture equals 105 Pa, it
measurements it follows that at the temperature of 900 ◦ C follows from the thermodynamic model that the mole frac-
the solubility of sodium in aluminium reaches 1593 ± 80 tion of sodium in aluminium saturated with sodium at
ppm. At 960 ◦ C, the solubility of sodium in aluminium is 900 ◦ C is 1596 ppm, which is in excellent agreement with
700 ± 80 ppm. As liquid sodium does not exist at atmo- the experimental value of 1593 ± 80 ppm. At 960 ◦ C the
spheric pressure at these temperatures, the physical meaning calculated content of sodium in aluminium is 1000 ppm.
of this data has to be clarified. This can be done on the basis The experimental value obtained by the electrolysis is
of a thermodynamic model. 700 ppm. With respect to approximations made and the
risk of loss of sodium during sampling and quenching,
3.3. Thermodynamic model this can be considered as an acceptable agreement. (It
should be stressed that the calculations made above the
At temperatures lower than 883 ◦ C (the boiling point of boiling point of sodium (883 ◦ C) assume that the pres-
sodium), the chemical potential of sodium in Al–Na alloys sure of sodium equals 105 Pa, while at temperatures lower
saturated with sodium equals the chemical potential of pure than 883 ◦ C, the Al–Na alloy is in equilibrium with liquid
liquid sodium: sodium.)
The literature data on the content of sodium in liquid alu-
µ(Na in Al, satutared) = µ0 (Na, l) (4)
minium and the results obtained in this work are summarized
As the concentration of sodium in liquid aluminium is in Fig. 9. It follows that our results agree with the classical
rather low (thousands of ppm) the Henry law can be applied. literature data.
In Henry’s approximation, the pressure of sodium vapours
over the liquid Al–Na alloy is proportional to the mole frac-
tion of sodium in the liquid Al–Na alloy:
p(Na) = kH (Na) · x(Na in Al) (5) 1000
4. Conclusion [4] E.W. Dewing, M.J. Gilbert, in: C.J. McMinn (Ed.), Proceedings of
the 109th TMS Annual Meeting on the Light Metals, 1980, p. 221.
[5] E.W. Dewing, Met. Trans. B 18B (1987) 409.
Data on the cathodic overvoltage in the system Na3 AlF6 – [6] E.W. Dewing, E.Th. van der Kouwe, in: P.G. Campbell (Ed.), Pro-
NaCl–Al2 O3 are presented. It follows that the cathodic ceedings of the 118th TMS Annual Meeting on the Light Metals,
overvoltage has its origin in concentration polarisation 1989, p. 297.
at the aluminium cathode. The experimental data are in [7] E.W. Dewing, E.Th. van der Kouwe, Met. Trans. B 20B (1989) 671.
good agreement with theory. However, when using the [8] W.H. Tingle, J. Petit, W.B. Frank, Aluminium 57 (1981) 286.
[9] R.D. Peterson, A.T. Tabereaux, in: R.E. Miller (Ed.), Proceedings of
Na3 AlF6 –NaCl–Al2 O3 electrolyte, saturated solution of the 115th TMS Annual Meeting on the Light Metals, 1986, p. 491.
sodium in aluminium could not be obtained. [10] P. Fellner, Ž. Lubyová, Chem. Papers 40 (2) (1986) 145.
Al–Na alloys saturated with sodium at the temperatures [11] V. Danielik, P. Fellner, Chem. Papers 52 (4) (1998) 195.
710, 750, 800, 900 and 960 ◦ C were prepared by electroly- [12] J. Thonstad, S. Rolseth, Electrochim. Acta 23 (1978) 223.
sis of a NaF–NaCl eutectic melt. A thermodynamic model [13] M.M. Vetyukov, J.U.V. Borisoglebsky, Tsvetnyje Metally 47 (3)
(1974) 30.
describing the saturation of molten aluminium with sodium [14] P.V. Polyakov, V.M. Mozhaev, V.V. Burnakin, S.S. Romanchenko,
below and above the boiling point of sodium (883 ◦ C) is Electrochimiya 17 (1981) 1454.
presented. It is suggested that the data on saturation of alu- [15] P. Fellner, V. Danielik, in: Proceedings of the International Harald
minium with sodium presented by Hansen and co-workers A. Øye Symposium, Trondheim, Norway, 1995, p. 389.
[21,22] are not suitable for a thermodynamic treatment of [16] V. Danielik, P. Fellner, J. Thonstad, J. Appl. Electrochem. 28 (1998)
1265.
Al–Na liquid alloys. [17] V.N. Senin, A.A. Kostjukov, J.U.I. Dvinin, Tsvetnyje Metally 40 (5)
(1967) 53.
[18] A.T. Tabereaux, Light Metals, 1996, p. 319.
Acknowledgements [19] J. Thonstad, S. Rolseth, J. Rødseth, O. Lund, J. Tonheim, V. Danielik,
P. Fellner, J. Hı́veš, TMS-AIME Light Metals, 2001, p. 441.
[20] G.K. Sigworth, T.A. Engh, Scand. J. Met. 11 (1982) 143.
This work was supported by courtesy of the Slovak Grant [21] S.G. Hansen, Thermodynamics of Impurity Elements Na, K, Li,
Agency (VEGA 1/9426/02) and by Professor Geir Martin Ca in Liquid Aluminium Alloys, Ph.D. Thesis, NTNU, Trodheim,
Haarberg, The Norwegian University of Science and Tech- Norway, 2001.
nology. [22] S.G. Hansen, J.K. Tuset, G.M. Haarberg, Metall. Mater. Trans. B.
33B (2002) 577.
[23] E. Scheuer, Z. Metallkd. 27 (1935) 83.
[24] W.L. Fink, L.A. Willey, H.C. Stumpf, Trans. AIME 175 (1948) 364.
References [25] C.E. Ransley, H. Neufeld, J. Inst. Met. 78 (1950) 25.
[26] K. Motzfeldt, Metall. Mater. Trans. 34B (2003) 735.
[1] K. Grjotheim, C. Krohn, M. Malinovský, K. Matiašovský, J. Thon- [27] P. Fellner, J. Hı́veš, M. Korenko, J. Thonstad, Electrochim. Acta 46
stad, Aluminium Electrolysis, second ed., Verlag, Düsseldorf, 1982. (2001) 2379.
[2] J. Thonstad, P. Fellner, G.M. Haarberg, J. Hı́veš, H. Kvande, Å. [28] J. Zorić, I. Roušar, J. Thonstad, Light Metals, 1997, p. 449.
Sterten, Aluminium Electrolysis, third ed., Verlag, Düsseldorf, 2001. [29] I. Barin, O. Knacke, O. Kubascewski, Thermodynamical Properties
[3] E.W. Dewing, Met. Trans. 3 (2) (1972) 495. of Inorganic Substances, Suppl. 1977, Springer, Berlin, 1973.