Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Patient's Satisfaction With Rural Health Center
Patient's Satisfaction With Rural Health Center
On
Patient’s satisfaction with Rural health center as a health service provider at Fulchari Upazila In
Gaibandha District, Bangladesh
February, 2023
ABSTRACT
The present study is conducted to asses the patients satisfaction with the rural health canter as a
health service provider at Fulchari upazila in Gaibandha district. Data were collected through the
use of well structured area. when I collected data I used random sampling method. I took 50
respondent from this area. Data were also collected from interview method using well structured
questionnaire. Bangladesh is a developing country here 75% people are live in rural area.
Bangladesh health structured are not good at all specially rural area health center is also very poor
conditions. The objectives of the study to asses the socio economic condition of respondents, to
asses the rural people satisfaction and the constraints which face rural people. Here, rural areas
health conditions also related with NGO activities. This study also showed result from NGO
activities. The data are analyzed different statistical measure like pie chart, bar diagram, line graph
etc. To find out patient’s satisfaction this study also showed some determinants which influenced
patients satisfaction. This study showed most of the patients were female respondents almost 64%
female respondents are went to rural health center here only 36% male respondents went to rural
health center. All respondents lived in tin sheet house and their sources of drinking in tube well.
According to the objective, this study analyzed the patients satisfaction determinants which is
doctor behavior, spending time, distance from residence and medicine availability. 53.66% people
satisfied from rural health center and 36.58% people are medium satisfied and 9.76% people are
dissatisfied. In this study showed that here no specialist doctors, no nurse, and have no capacity
in bed. Only primary treatment is available in this rural health center.
Certification
This is to certify that ‘Lisha Akter' has carried out the research impersonated in the present
dissertation entitled” patients satisfactions with rural health center as a health service provider at
Fulchari upazila in Gaibandha district” under my supervision for the partial fulfillment of the
requirement of field work and report writing in economics at the Rajshahi University.
This is also that this dissertation is an independent work and does not constitute part of any material
submitted for any other degree here or elsewhere.
I, the undersigned, hereby declare that he complete work impersonated in the dissertation entitled
“patients satisfaction with rural health center as a health service provider at Fulchari upazila in
Gaibandha district “ has been carried out under the supervision of Professor Dr. Md. Atiqul Islam,
Department of Economics, University of Rajshahi is an original research work completed by me.
It has been submitted for the partial fulfillment of the course EC 409 Field work and Report
Writing. I further declare that the research paper which impersonated is original and has not been
submitted for any other degree or qualification here or elsewhere.
Signature of candidate
….................................
ID:1812042162
Session:2017-2018
Department of Economics
University of Rajshahi.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
At first I would like to express my appreciation and heartfelt obligations to my Almighty that he
can give me the power that I can able to do this work.
I would like to express my appreciation and heartfelt obligations to my beloved mother, father and
al my teachers and friends who always provided all the supports, encouragement, affection and
precious advice when it was necessary.
First of all, I would like to offer my Immense heartiest gratitude and thanks to my worth supervisor.
I have been very fortunate to have my supervision. His fruitful guidance and critical feedback had
been very useful in keeping me on the right track.
I am highly indebted to all respective teachers, Department of Economics, University of Rajshahi
for their advice and encouragement.
I also acknowledge the staff of the computer unit and all other employees of the Department of
Economics for their cordial help and co-operation during this research work.
Finally, I thanks to the fishermen who have given information and helped me for this research.
Contents
ABSTRACT …………………………………..……..................................................
CERTIFICATION
DECLARATION
CHAPTER ONE
1.1 Background of the study
1.2 Objective of the study
1.3 Scope of the study
1.4 Rational of the study
1.5 Layout
CHAPTER TWO
Literature review
2.1 Introduction
2.2 Relevant literature
2.3 Research gap
2.4 conclusion
CHAPTER THREE
3.1 introduction
3.2 Study area
3.3 Study population
3.4 Mosamari community clinic
3.5 Study design and sampling procedure
3.6 Methods of data collection
3.7 Tabulation of the data
3.8 Conclusion
CHAPTER FOUR
Findings and discussion
4.1 Introduction
4.2 socio economic characteristics of respondents
4.2.1 Analysis of data
4.2.2 Distribution of respondents by sample area
4.2.3 Distribution of Respondents by Gender
4.2.4 Distribution of respondents by occupation
4.2.5 Distribution of respondents by attending school and the class level
4.2.6 Distribution of respondents by family size
4.2.7 Distribution of respondents by structure of house and drinking source
4.2.8 Distribution of respondents by types of toilet
4.3.1 Disease suffer presently
4.3.2 Distribution of Respondents first choice
4.3.3 reason to go their preferable place
4.3.4 patient’s satisfaction with its determinants factor
4.4.1 behavior of doctors
4.4.2 Medicine availability
4.4.3 Spending time of doctors with each patient’s
4.4.4 Distance from residence
4.4.5 satisfaction from rural health center
4.5.1 NGO available in the study area
4.5.2 Distribution of facilities by NGOs
4.5.3 Satisfaction from NGO
4.6 Conclusion
CHAPTER FIVE
Conclusion and Recommendations
5.1 Introduction
5.2 Overview of the Chapter
5.3 Recommendations
5.4 Limitation of the study and direction of the future Research
Reference
Appendix 1: survey Questionnaire for the study
Appendix 2: My Experience in the Research
List of the table
Table:1 Distribution of Respondents by sample area
Table:2 Distribution of respondents by structure of house and drinking source
Table:3 Distribution of respondents by opinion of doctors getting medicine
Table:4 Available NGO in the study area
List of figure
Figure 1 : Distribution of respondents by gender
Figure :2 Distribution of respondents by occupation
Figure:3 Distribution of respondents by attending school and their class level
Figure:4 Distribution of respondents by family size
Figure:5 Distribution of Respondents by types of toilet
Figure :6 Distribution of respondents by presently suffer disease
Figure:7 Distribution of respondents by first choice
Figure:8 Reason to go their preferable place
Figure:9 Behaviour of doctors
Figure :10 Medicine availability
Figure:11 spending time of doctors with each patients
Figure:12 Distance from Residence
Figure:13 satisfaction from rural health center
Figure:14 Distribution of facilities by NGOs
Figure :15 satisfaction from NGO
CHAPTER ONE
Introduction
So for developing and improving the status and condition of Bangladesh, improvement of health
sector must be increased.in this case, reform in rural health sector is necessary. This study contends
that satisfaction can be increased by developing rural hospitals, providing qualified physicians,
nurses, availability of drugs in reasonable price, increasing more share of government in health
expenditure. This study also assesses that public health delivery facilities in rural areas can help to
improve the condition l people.
1.4 Layout
The layout of the report means as to what the research report should contain. A comprehensive
layout of the research report should comprise preliminary pages, the main text and the end matter.
This report included into five chapters; chapter one comprises an overview of the health sector
status in rural area. It also provides the objectives of the study and also comprised the scope of the
study and rational section.
Chapter two provides a review of the relevant literature to the study, research gap and conclusion
section. This chapter is an important chapter of research work. I have reviewed many literature
relevant to my study and found that most of the researcher found the delivery service and its
percentage but no one said about people’s satisfaction percentage.
Chapter three gives the research methods and procedures specifically looking at the data collection
and analysis procedures used. In chapter four the findings ae presented, interpreted and discussed.
Finally, chapter five outlines the summary and conclusions drawn from the empirical data and
policy implications.
CHAPTER TWO
Literature Review
2.1 Introduction
Literature review is an important part of every social research. Generally literature review refers
to previous or unpublished works related to current research. Such as any survey, authors,
quotation, books, articles related to the current research. A little research works has been carried
out in the context of the health care center as a health provider in rural area. This is the literature
review chapter. This is one of the main chapter in research work. This chapter has four section.
here are some related literature about health care service on rural area.
3.2Study Area
The selected area was fulchari upazila at gaibandha district of Bangladesh. Fulchari upazila area
306.53 sq km, located in between 25°06' and 25°23' north latitudes and in between 89°34' and
89°46' east longitudes. It is bounded by gaibandha sadar upazila on the north, shaghata and
islampur upazila on the south. Total area of this upazila is char land. Total population 137796
among them male are69816 and female are 67979. This upazila mainly water bodies and its contain
three rivers that are Brahmaputra, old Brahmaputra, and jamuna. Fulchari thana was formed on 25
February 1855 and it was into an upazila in 1984.Literacy rate and educational institution average
literacy 27.7%, male 33.2%, female 22.1%.Here educational institution college 3, secondary
school 8,primary school 69. Main occupation of that area in agriculture 75.15%,non agricultural.
Main crops paddy,wheat,sugarcane,maize,jute,onion,chilli,mustered,penut,vegetable.extint
barly,kaun,sweet potato. Communication facilities pucca road 27.61 km, mud road 163.56
km,railway 5 km ,waterway 59.40 nautical miles. Accesses to electricity all the unions of the
upazila are under rural electrification net work.However 5.01% of the dwelling households have
access to electricity. Sources of drinking water tube well 91,14%,tap 0.28% and others 8.14%.
sanitation 11.70% of dwelling households of the upazila use sanitary latrines and 39.39%.
•
Moshamari community clinic is e government hospital situated at a village area. Md Jahangir Alam
is a community clinic health facility head informer. This is no bedded system hospital. There is only
one rural doctor and no nurse. There is no sufficient availability of medicine. some common
medicines are provided from the clinic. Everyday about 30/50 patients come in the hospital who are
living most near or more far to the hospital for different normal treatment. There is no bed and no
nurse. Here serve only primary treatment like ANC, PNC, EP, family planning. In this clinic have
only one weight and height machine. Among the admitted patients most of the patients are female.
Here I found clinic some structure measure of this community clinic. I added some Question on this
survey Questions as follows as:
1. Capacity of the hospital : we found this study, this clinic had no bed
2. How many qualified doctors and Nurse have had in the hospital? : Here we found no nurse
no doctors
3. What kind of diseases they offer treatment normally? : we found result here only provided
primary treatment like ANC, PNC, EPI, HE, Family Planning, etc.
4. Is there any availability of medicine in the hospital?: head informer told that here provide
only 30 items
5. Do this basic infrastructure like weight machine?: they said here had only one weight machine
6. Is there any pathological center? They said no
7. How many patients have admitted in the hospital in a month? 800-1000
8. Among the admitted patients how many are male / female? They said maximum were female
1.ketkirhat 10
2.katadara 10
3.mosamari 10
4.dariarvita 10
5.kabilpur 10
3.6 Methods of data collection
Data were collected from face to face interview with a well structured questionnaire. There are
various methods of data collection. Such as interview schedule, observation study, rapid rural
appraisal participatory rural appraisal etc. I took interview schedule as a methods of data collection
in my study. Here both qualitative and quantitative questionnaire were there. The data were collected
keeping in mind the three objectives. The questionnaire consist of demographic structure. Social
structure which focused patients satisfaction level from hospital, different related questions for
identifying NGOs activities in the rural area.
We collect data on the basis of questionnaire may not present the actual view of variables. In such
case we may group our collected data in a precise way to know it at a glance. The summarization of
raw data into a group in a table is called tabulation of the data .In this section I will discuss about
different variable alone with their tabulation and also we present graphically. I used tabulation form
for presenting the data in my study.
3.8 Conclusion
In this chapter I have discussed data and methodology procedure. And I used interview schedule as
a methods of data collection in my study. This chapter contain 9 section and this is the most important
chapter for research work. It is called the life of research because a research is conducted based on
the specific methodology.
Chapter four
Findings and discussion
4.1 Introduction
Findings and discussion chapter is also one of the main chapter of research work. Its completely
my findings. The aim of my study was to determine the satisfaction of the patients or socio
economic condition and constraints to get Services. Total 50 respondent were interviewed and it
was reported that the socio economic composition of respondents using the survey like age
distribution, education status, housing types ,latrine types occupation, present disease, NGO
service. A detailed analysis is made on these parameters and presented in this section.
The above table shows that the total number of respondents is 50. The total respondents are
collected data randomly in this area on different point. From these respondents 80% respondents
are going to hospital and 20% are not going to hospital. Among 50 respondents, I was collected
10 in one point and that percentage is 20%.These data based on only one community clinic that is
mosamari community clinic.
Male
Female
Male Female
40
Fig: 4.4 Number and percentage of respondents by attending school and class
level
4.2.5 Distribution of respondents by family size
Determinants of socio economic status also depend on family size. Because in a large family
especially in rural area, family members can’t get all opportunity which are more available in a
small family. They have less availability in education, nutrition, health service access in large
family. In the above table, there are large parts of respondents who have large family size. We can
see that only 20% respondents have a family size up to 10.70% respondents have a family size
between 4-6. And 10% have large family that is more than 7 members. We can present it by
following diagram;
70
20
10
1 TO 3 4 TO 6 7 TO 10
Above this table we can see that 100% respondents use tube well and 100% people use tin sheet
housing. But no respondents use pond water for drinking purpose and no respondents use bricks
house. (https;//www.researchgate.net) groundwater fed irrigation and drinking water, in this study
showed that in Bangladesh approximately 97% of all drinking water supplies comes from ground
water via hand operated tube wells. Our analysis also showed that.
Percentage
44% Diseased
Their disease are so common so that they don’t need to visit specialist doctor. When they are sick
firstly they prefer rural doctor or nearby public hospital or go pharmacy. There are various reason
behind it. In the literature review M. A. Seddiky et.al. (2014) said that the poor and marginalized
people are the primary beneficiaries of the community clinic. Most of them illiterate and live hand
to mouth. Some rural people believe in the charismatic power of the kabiraz instead of modern
medicine. From the sample data we see that same condition, here 16% respondents first go public
hospital.60% respondents first go rural doctors and 24% of respondents go to pharmacy doctor.
There is no respondents who are go to first a specialist. As their disease are not more serious, so
they trust rural doctor and pharmacy doctor. And they also mentioned that these Common diseases
are cured them, they thought there is no need to go private clinic or specialist. This analysis we
can see by following line graph.
PHARMACY
24%
RURAL DOCTOR
60%
PUBLIC HOSPITAL
16%
Percentage
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Personal preference More distance Unawareness
Percentage
From the sample data, the study result shows that in total 41 respondents. 14.63% get all
medicine,82.93% of them get half or less than half medicine and 2.44% don’t get any medicine
bacause of unavailability of medicine. Now we can see that by a pie chart
Fig: 4.12 Distribution of respondents by opinion of doctors getting medicine
4.4.3 Spending time of doctors with each patients
Patients satisfaction also depends on doctors spending time.it present that doctors spends more
time to each patients and treat them attentively, patients satisfaction increases. From the study, we
can see that 34.15% people said that doctors give fast time.64.85% people said that doctors treats
the patients attentively and spend the time that is actually need to treat them fast. This result can
be shown pie chart.
From the sample data, we see that 100% respondents said that all the NGOS are available in this
study area. Here have a reason, NGOs are more emphasis on rural area to provide best Service in
this areas people. They provide various types of services like family planning, malnutrition, child
nutrition, education related etc.
4.5.2 Distribution of facilities by NGOs
NGOs provide various facilities to the rural People. The facilities are mostly child nutrition, family
planning, education, health awareness , and other facilities. Respondents give various opinion that
provided by different NGOs. Like SKS emphasis on rural peoples life standard and child nutrition.
we see that Majority of the respondent that means 60% respondents said that SHOWHARDO and
SKS gives child nutrition and maternity care. This service also called by pusti in this study area.
BRACK give only family planning service and 20% people are take this service among 100%
people. Here 20% Respondents said that they are serviced by health awareness from this NGOs.
This analysis we can present by a bar diagram.
4.6 Conclusion
This is the most important chapter in research work. In this chapter firstly I can try to see that about
socioeconomic conditions of the respondents and the end of the chapter I analyzed the patients
satisfaction from rural health center. most of the patients were satisfied some are dissatisfied.
Chapter Five
Conclusion and Recommendation
5.1 Introduction
This is the conclusions chapter of our report writing. This is one of the main chapter.From our
findings and discussion chapter, we see that socio economic condition of the respondent and
satisfaction with relative determinant in fulchari upazila. The aim of the study is to asses the
patients satisfaction from community clinic and non governmental organizations. Many of the
problem found in other governmental health service appeared here,shortages of drugs and
consumables, insufficient skills in some staff are not available when needed. At present community
clinics are Playing at most a limited role in public service sector.
Jane farmer, surah-anne munoz, Guinever threlked (2012).” Theory in rural health”, Australian j rural
health,20, 185-189
M Rahman, MM Islam, MR Islam, G sedhya, MA Latif(2011).” Disease pattern and health seeking
behavior in rural health”, Faridpur med coll.j. 5(1): 32-37
Maruf hasan Rumi, Niaz makhdum,Md Haruner Rashid,a Abdul muyeed (2021).” Patient’s satisfaction on
the service Quality of Upazila health complex in Bangladesh “, journal of patients experience, volume 8:1-
7
Mohammad Hamiduzzaman,.et.al.2021).”the world is not mine – Barriers to health care access for
Bangladesh rural elderly women”, journal of cross culture Gerontology, 36:69-89
Syed Saad Andaleeb, Nazlee siddqui, Sahjahan khandakar(2007).” Patient’s satisfaction with health service
in Bangladesh “, Health policy and planning, 22:263-273
Md. Assraf seddiky, Ms. Esmat Ara, Sabina Yasmin(2014).” Role of union Information and service center
(UISC) to promote health care facilities for the rural poor in Bangladesh”, American international Journal
of research in humanities, arts and social sciences.
Emmanuel kawme Darkwa,M.sophia Newman, Mahmud kawkab,Mahbub Elahi Chowdhury (2015).” A
qualatative study of fators influencing retention of doctors and nurses at rural health care facilities in
Bangladesh “, BMC Health services research 15:344
Ahmed, S.M (2018).”Frugal innovation in health care”, Bangladesh health scenario.
Khondkar Mohammad Zobaiar, Louis Sanzogni,Kuldeep Sandu (2020).” Telemedicine healthcare service
adoption Barriers in Rural Bangladesh “, Australian Journal of Information systems vol 24.Research article.
Anwar islam and Tuhin biswas (2014).” Health system in Bangladesh : challenges and opportunities “,
American journal of health research;2(6): 366-374.
APPENDICES
Appendix 1: Questionnaire
Survey Questionnaire for the Study
Patient’s satisfaction with rural health center as a health service
provider at Fulchari upazila in Gaibandha District
1.General Information
Respondent serial number
Date
Name of the respondent
Sex
Age
District
2.Demographic Information
a. Number of family member in HH?
b. how many children do you have?
1 How much time a doctor spends for each patient treatment? 1=fast
2=exactly
2 Does patients get all the medicine that the doctor prescribes? 1=all
2=half or less than half
3=no
This was the first Research work in my study life. I was very scared in the beginning. I didn’t know
what to do. Under the supervision of my respected honorable teacher. I was able to overcome my
research fears. He guided me very sincerely. I went home 1st October with his direction and best
wishes. I had gotten only 4 days to collect data. I selected five villages and 50 respondents for
my Research work. The first two days, I Couldn’t do anything. So I was so afraid that I would not
be able to finish the job in time. By the grace of Almighty, I was able to complete the work the
allotted me.
It was a great experience I started to I started to collect data from 5th October. that was there
wonderful day. On the 5th October after breakfast I went out for data collection with my father
through bike. At first we go to Ketkirhat village. My first respondent was my auntie. she is a
wonderful woman and housewife. She was very happy to see me and my father. she asked
everyone around to help with information. Respondent give me all information without hesitation.
From there I took 10 respondent.
After data collection I went to the neighborhood off moshamari community clinic from there. I
took 10 respondents from around the clinic. as soon as I left they arranged s chair for me. these
people. Among these people Someone came and objected to the clinic after finished my work.
There I and my father were offered breakfast and after breakfast we moved on to Katadara village.
There are many problems have to be faced during data collection. At that point female and male
did not want to give any information. Make respondent were disagreed to give any information
about this question. One of them literally asked me to leave the house. Then I Convinced them to
give me information. Then I went and explained them correctly and get 10 respondents. One male
Respondents said you bought a diabetic machine in here. In this community clinic here no diabetic
machine that’s why we can not test diabetic free of cost. In this place there is one offering tea and
chop.
From there I moved on to Dariarvita village. From this area I took 10 respondent also. Some of
my acquaintances were there and they started talking about my marriage about future plans. Many
offered lunch but it was time consuming so I went back home that day.
On the 6 the October, I went to my village Kabilpur. Here also I took 10 respondent. There I have
lunch and meet relatives. Everyone has cooperated by giving me information.
Picture of my data collection : on the 10th October, I moved Rajshahi and I finished the rest
of the work with data entry as directed by my esteemed teacher.