Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 19

Case Study

The Complete
Playbook for Generative
AI in Fashion
By Marc Bain From ChatGPT to Midjourney to Runway, the emerging technology
June 2023
is already showing why it could be one of the most consequential in
decades for the fashion industry. Early adopters and experts unpack the
opportunities and challenges of putting gen AI to use to design products,
create campaigns and other content, and better connect with customers.
Executive Summary
In 2018, an artist named Robbie Barrat conceived an and interviews in spring 2023. That said, four key
entire fashion collection in the style of Balenciaga strategic areas have already emerged for fashion,
using artificial intelligence. Barrat had to train his enabling this case study to showcase the state of
own AI model on images of existing looks he gathered play in product design, visual content creation,
himself, and the output wasn’t perfect. Much of it copywriting, and shopping and customer experience.
appeared smudged and distorted. But it was enough To help build out the knowledge provided in this
to capture fashion’s attention, landing him an case study, brands and retailers such as Revolve,
interview with Ssense and a collaboration with Acne Casablanca Paris, Frame, Snipes, Levi’s and Zalando;
Studios. technology providers such as Salesforce, Amazon
and Shopify; and other AI-focused experts share real
Just a few years later, anyone with a computer can
examples of putting this emerging technology to use
essentially create a collection — with less work and
and what they have been learning in the process.
more photorealistic results than Barrat’s earlier
attempt — using new generative-AI tools. See page 17 for a glossary of key terms.
Generative AI, which describes machine learning
algorithms capable of creating new content, is set to
have a major impact on fashion brands. Trained on Exhibit 1: Money Magnets
a sufficient number of examples, these algorithms
Even as the tech industry faces a wider funding drought, generative AI’s big players
recognise the underlying patterns and structures in
are attracting high valuations.
data and create novel examples of their own. Some
tools, such as DALL-E 2, Midjourney and Stable
Valuations (May 2023)
Diffusion, can produce images. Others, such as
USD (billions)
ChatGPT, can generate text. Still others are capable
of making videos, like Runway. But all are able to
OpenAI
create their content from text prompts, promising a Foundation model
29.0
wide array of uses.
Anthropic
Though generative AI grabbed attention with the 4.4
Foundation model
deluge of user-generated memes it unleashed online,
Cohere
like a video reimagining the Harry Potter movies Foundation model
2.0
in the style of Balenciaga, its greatest impact could
be on businesses. Tech giants such as Microsoft Hugging Face
2.0
Foundation model
and Google are racing to incorporate it into their
core products, while industries from healthcare to Lightricks
1.8
finance are looking for ways to use it to lift labour Image/video

productivity and a wave of start-ups are building Runway


1.5
enterprise applications. Goldman Sachs analysts Image/video
estimate that, once generative AI is widely adopted, it
Jasper
could boost US productivity by 1.5 percentage points Text (copywriting)
1.5
per year for a decade, ultimately increasing S&P 500
profits 30 percent or more over that period. Replit
1.2
Text (code)
Fashion is set to experience generative AI-influenced Inflection
growth of its own. While the industry is just starting Natural language interface
1.2
to explore the technology’s potential, McKinsey &
Company estimates that in the next three to five Adept
1.0
Natural language interface
years it could add between $150 billion and $275
billion to the operating profits of the apparel, fashion Character.ai
1.0
Natural language interface
and luxury sectors. It is already beginning to shake
up areas such as design, marketing and customer Stability.ai
1.0
service. Foundation model

As various parts of the fashion industry value Glean


1.0
Natural language interface
chain test and adopt the technology, this case study
explores the opportunities, challenges and risks
for both brands and their employees. However, Source: CB Insights
the field is changing rapidly and use cases were
a work in progress as we conducted our research

Have you been sent this case study? Read more deep-dive analysis with a BoF Professional membership at businessoffashion.com/
memberships or contact professional@businessoffashion.com

businessoffashion.com 2
History and Context

Decades in the Making


Exhibit 2: The Rise of Generative AI

2019 February: GPT-2 comes out with 1.5 billion parameters


2012 Breakthroughs in deep learning allow for major
— a measure of the model’s size and complexity.
advances in fields like computer vision and natural
language processing.
March: China’s Baidu issues its counter to Google’s
BERT, called ERNIE, or Enhanced Representation
2013 Through Knowledge Integration.

July: Microsoft and OpenAI sign a multi-year


2014 Ian Goodfellow introduces generative adversarial partnership that includes a $1 billion investment by
networks, which use competition between two neural Microsoft.
networks to produce realistic imagery.
2020 May: GPT-3 goes live, boasting 175 billion parameters.
2015 March: Researchers invent the diffusion model, which
learns to produce imagery from noise and is the basis 2021 January: OpenAI releases its image generator, DALL-E.
of image generators such as DALL-E 2 and Stable
Diffusion.
2022 March: Midjourney, an AI image generator, goes live on
a Discord server.
June: Google launches Deep Dream, a model that
becomes popular online for its psychedelic imagery.
April: DALL-E 2 arrives. Google announces a
540-billion parameter transformer, called Pathways
December: OpenAI is founded as a non-profit research
Language Model.
lab. (It will drop the non-profit status in 2019.)
May: Meta releases its Open Pretrained Transformer
2016 language model. Google announces Imagen, an image-
generating diffusion model.
2017 June: Google creates the first transformer model, a
August: Stability.ai launches text-to-image model Stable
form of deep learning that takes raw text and learns the
Diffusion.
relationships between words, laying the foundation for
models like GPT.
September: Meta unveils Make-A-Video, which
generates video from text prompts.
2018 June: OpenAI releases GPT, which stands for
“generative pre-trained transformer.” November: OpenAI releases ChatGPT.

October: Google unveils BERT, or Bidirectional Encoder 2023 January: Microsoft announces $10 billion investment in
Representations for Transformers, a language model it OpenAI.
uses to better understand search intent.
May: Google unveils new experimental search
experience powered by generative AI.

What makes generative AI so promising code in World War II, was one of its computing power enabled advances.
for fashion is its capacity to quickly pioneers.) Because of the high costs and Around 2012, an inflection point arrived
produce high-quality content as well limited power of computers, progress as deep learning led to dramatic gains
as understand and recreate natural was slow, but over the years, and despite in AI fields like computer vision. AI has
language. While these capabilities are just occasional setbacks, researchers made continued to improve and become more
becoming widely accessible, they’re built breakthroughs that still underpin AI available to industries, letting fashion
on foundations that reach back decades. today. companies adopt it for purposes such as
demand forecasting, identifying their
The field of AI began gathering They developed neural networks, which
most valuable customers, managing
momentum in the 1950s, when scientists use sets of algorithms arranged in
markdowns more effectively and battling
and mathematicians, believing machines interconnected node layers to mimic
counterfeits.
could one day begin to learn and reason the workings of the human brain, and
on their own, laid the foundations of devised deep learning techniques that Generative AI is the next step in this
modern computer science. (Famed allow computers to better understand evolution, and the excitement around the
British mathematician Alan Turing, “unstructured” and complex data, technology and range of applications has
who helped crack Germany’s Enigma including text or images. Leaps in led to an influx of investment. Though

businessoffashion.com 3
History and Context

the total value of venture capital deals in


Exhibit 3: Generating Deals
generative AI globally fell from $5 billion
Microsoft’s $10 billion investment in OpenAI in 2023 pushed funding for generative AI in 2021 to $4 billion in 2022 as inflation,
to new heights after the market slowed in 2022 amid a broader downturn. rising interest rates and recession
concerns depressed the market, the
Generative AI global deals (2012–May 2023) Deal count number of deals still increased, according
Deal value (USD, billions) to Pitchbook, a funding database. Relative
to the broader technology landscape, it
has proved “resilient against the market
downturn,” noted Ali Javaheri, an
15 Includes OpenAI Microsoft 400
deal worth $10bn
associate analyst of emerging technology
at Pitchbook.
12.6
304 By May 2023, funding surged past
286 300 previous years — mostly because of
10
Microsoft’s $10 billion investment
in OpenAI, announced in January.
191 Companies like OpenAI that are building
200 what are called foundation models,
which are trained on huge volumes of
125 5.1
4.6
data and capable of being applied to an
5
array of tasks rather than just narrow,
83 118
100 tailored uses, are drawing the most
0.4
0.04 0.04 55 2.1 money, Javaheri said, while those making
0.1 1.6
15 24 30 specific text-based applications, such as
3 7 0.3 0.4 for copywriting, are also attracting a good
0.1
0 0 deal of interest.
2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023*
A variety of industries are trying to take
advantage of generative AI’s potential.
* YTD until May 25, 2023 The prestigious architecture firm
Zaha Hadid Architects is using image
Source: Pitchbook
generators to help produce building
designs, its head, Patrik Schumacher, said
in a roundtable discussion hosted by the
platform DigitalFutures in April 2023.
Lawyers are also exploring it as a way to
automate tedious work like reviewing
documents.
Exhibit 4: Big Backers
For fashion businesses, the technology
True to their reputation for tech investments, Silicon Valley-based companies are
presents a variety of possible uses
leading the global pack in funding generative AI deals.
and benefits. Based on moves already
publicly announced by brands, retailers
Largest investors in global generative AI by deal count (Jan 2012–May 2023)
and technology providers, as well as
conversations with companies and
Investor Deal Count Investor Type experts, BoF identifies four of the most
immediate opportunities generative AI
offers:
1 Y Combinator 43 Accelerator/Incubator
1. Enhance and support creativity
1. Enhance and support creativity
2 Andreessen Horowitz 34 Venture Capital 2. Augment and hyper-personalise
customer-facing content and services
2. Augment and hyper-personalise
3 Sequoia Capital 32 Venture Capital
3. Reduce costs or complexity
customer-facing ofservices
content and
ambitious projects
3. Reduce costs or complexity of
4. Automate manual tasks
4 Khosla Ventures 25 Venture Capital ambitious projects

4. Automate manual tasks


5 Bloomberg Beta 23 Corporate Venture Capital

Source: Pitchbook

businessoffashion.com 4
Market Opportunities and Challenges

Playing to Generative AI’s Strengths


Up and Down the Value Chain
Exhibit 5: How Generative AI Plugs into Fashion’s Value Chain
Generative AI can be used across the product lifecycle, reducing lead times, creating efficiencies and unlocking new ideas.

Streamline copywriting Provide more personalised


Generate design variations Produce visual content
and automate content- product suggestions and
and new ideas and marketing imagery
generating tasks customer service

Generative AI’s opportunities are present The ease with which a company An AI-generated image might feature
to varying degrees across use cases. integrates generative AI into its more revealing clothing on a woman than
Companies that leverage the technology operations will depend on how much a man, for example. It can also suffer from
in these areas stand to benefit on multiple it expects the technology to do and technical shortcomings, like ChatGPT’s
levels, while potentially bolstering how much customisation is needed. tendency to get facts wrong.
operating profits, as McKinsey noted. Uses incorporating customer data or
Companies using AI could face backlash
combining it with proprietary technology
“We’ve seen it a number of times also or even be drawn into legal challenges
can require more technical expertise, but
in more ‘classic’ data and IT projects,” by creatives who say their work was
for basic tasks, even lean start-ups can get
said Holger Harreis, a senior partner used to train AI systems. The situation
going quickly by using one of the growing
at McKinsey. By raising productivity, raises new legal questions around
number of AI tools on the market.
streamlining product development and intellectual property, like how much
reducing time to market, he noted, “what “In principle, you could [integrate protection a brand can expect on an
we’ve seen in the rearview mirror is generative AI] with a very small and AI-generated design. Although in the
actually the biggest impact contribution relatively low-sophistication IT team,” opinion of Anthony Lupo, an attorney
came from increasing revenues.” Harreis said, “because for many of those focused on fashion and technology at law
things, there are dedicated apps or firm ArentFox Schiff, it shouldn’t deter
For generative AI, the effects may not be
solutions as a service.” companies at this stage from exploring
equal across all parts of the value chain.
and experimenting with generative AI.
In supply chains, generative AI could
be used to summarise data or automate
Protecting People and Brands “You should be leaning into this, because
filling out paperwork, but uses that more The technology carries notable risks. if you aren’t, your competitor will be and
fundamentally shift how companies Chief among them is the effect on staff, you will be left in the dust,” Lupo said.
operate in the near term are less clear. who may need to learn new skills, such
To get started, companies should analyse
as how to prompt an AI tool to produce
The greatest opportunities are probably their entire value chain, determine the
the desired outcome, or take on new
in the areas that play directly to problems they want to solve or processes
roles, such as editing AI-generated text
generative AI’s strengths. These include they need to improve and consider where
rather than purely writing their own.
tasks related to design, marketing and generative AI can help with tasks or add
Others could be displaced, a possibility
customer interactions, such as generating value.
companies need to weigh seriously. AI can
design ideas, creating imagery for use
also replicate existing biases in any data
in campaigns or online, and powering
it uses, including racial and gender biases.
chatbots and clienteling tools.

businessoffashion.com 5
Strategy

Where Fashion Meets


Generative AI
01 — Design

Revolve created a capsule collection based on its AI-generated campaign with creative agency Maison Meta, but turning the AI designs into physical garments wasn’t always easy.
Revolve.

In April 2023, drivers heading towards see what the outcome might look like or
Opportunities Palm Springs on California’s Interstate explore entirely new ideas.
10 would have seen multiple billboards
It does come with challenges. AI-
Enhance and support creativity posted by online retailer Revolve
generated designs may still need manual
featuring models in trippy landscapes
Augment and hyper-personalise edits and integrating the process into
full of giant mushrooms or flowers.
customer-facing content and services existing workflows can be tricky because
The images, down to the models and
it doesn’t consider real-world factors
clothing, were AI-generated and created
Reduce costs or complexity of like fabrics and construction. But it
for Revolve by Maison Meta, a creative
ambitious projects nonetheless offers a potentially powerful
agency specialising in AI.
creative tool.
Automate manual tasks That month, Revolve’s first drop of a
“Product design is a prime opportunity,”
limited capsule collection with pieces
Harreis of McKinsey said. “I don’t think
from the campaign went live for pre-
we should believe that, right now, the
order, giving consumers the opportunity
machine could take over everything,
to buy clothes designed by generative AI.
but supporting that process is highly
Design is one of the clearest and enhancing.”
potentially most significant use cases
Designers can easily begin creating
for the technology, aligning neatly with
imagery with AI image generators such as
its ability to produce new content. It
Midjourney, Stable Diffusion or OpenAI’s
provides designers a means to quickly
DALL-E, starting from text prompts or
whip up countless variations of a concept,
images they upload. (Users should be
mash together a mix of inspirations and

businessoffashion.com 6
Strategy

aware that they may need to take steps sauce,” Cyril Foiret, Maison Meta’s Another wrinkle is that, for now, the
with tools like Midjourney if they don’t founder, told BoF. images are two-dimensional, so the
want their output to be publicly visible.) design may only show the front of an item,
Revolve, while exploring how it can use Design Approaches leaving the designer to create the rest of
the technology for its private labels, has the garment, like the back, themselves.
There are different approaches designers
found it can shorten the time involved But there are tech companies working on
can take to using generative AI. If they’re
in coming up with and visualising new 3D generative AI.
trying to get ideas for physical garments,
concepts.
they may want to start with broad Because AI can produce concepts that
“We were developing a bomber jacket descriptions. are difficult or impossible to construct,
and we were able to generate, in a matter companies may not be able to easily
“Best practice right now is you use AI to
of minutes, a lot of different variations, turn all their AI-generated concepts
go way wider than you would necessarily
versus — if someone was going to sketch into finished products. A physical
go before, just due to the manpower of
it — it would take hours,” said Michael leather jacket from Revolve’s capsule
sketching out that many ideas, and then
Mente, Revolve’s co-founder and co- collection with Maison Meta required
the role of the user becomes more than
chief executive. “We were able to put hand-painting to replicate the graphic
ever an editor,” said Andrew Wyatt,
together pieces and see different pocket detailing of the AI image. Pattern makers
co-founder and chief executive of Cala,
placements, different pocket details, and manufacturers may find themselves
an all-in-one platform for designing and
different collars. … Our buying team struggling to stay faithful to the original
producing clothes that has incorporated
could say, ‘The pocket size from this vision.
DALL-E via an API, or application
one. Take the collar from this one.’ Put it
programming interface, from OpenAI. “It is a potentially disrupting workflow,”
together, go and then send it up to develop
Mente said. Even so, he added that the
samples.” In Cala, users start from a template of
process of making the capsule collection
an item — it had about 40 as of spring
It still requires a human’s ideas, effort was overall “smooth, fun and enjoyable
2023, including clothing and accessories
and an understanding of how to prompt — and also with some important lessons
— and can insert adjectives like “edgy”
the AI to get good results, though. learned.”
or “minimalist,” describing the desired
Designers may find they need to be
design in one text field and details and A further area of caution brands should
as descriptive as possible about every
trims in another to generate designs. be aware of involves intellectual
feature of the garment, down to fabrics,
Wyatt said based on how many times property. Plaintiffs ranging from Getty
trims and specific design details. When
they’re pinging the DALL-E API, some Images to a group of artists have filed
Maison Meta in April 2023 organised
users are creating dozens of iterations of a lawsuits against AI companies alleging
an AI Fashion Week, which included a
design as they try to zero in on what they infringement of copyrighted work,
competition that will see Revolve produce
want. accusing the companies of training image
the collections of the three winners,
generators on their work without consent.
many designers were secretive about their Designers may find it difficult to produce
A number of cases are ongoing and yet to
prompts, treating them as their “secret concepts that match their established
be resolved.
visual language when using systems
trained on general internet imagery. Erik Lupo, the ArentFox Schiff attorney, said
Torstensson, co-founder and creative based on existing case law, the test has
director of fashion label Frame, said he’s been whether the ultimate product is an
been experimenting with training his infringement. That could continue to
own model using the tool Runway. He hold true, but AI is new territory and the
styled numerous looks on a model with courts may need to offer more guidance.
past Frame pieces and a few vintage McKinsey’s Roberts said brands should
items, fed those pictures into Runway and involve their legal teams as they explore
generated new designs bearing his “DNA,” opportunities and establish principles
as he put it. and guidelines.
Though Frame isn’t formally using Arguably the blurriest area is the extent
generative AI for clothing yet, to which brands can protect AI-generated
Torstensson has used the technology to designs. Historically, IP laws have existed
produce designs for furniture he said in part to ensure creators can benefit from
will be in Frame stores. Cala also offers the work they’ve put into a product or
templates for packaging. Roger Roberts, innovation, according to Lupo. If it takes
a technology expert at McKinsey, said just moments to create something, does it
physical spaces, like store interiors, are deserve the same protection? The safest
another area of opportunity in design. route as the field continues to develop may
be for brands to use generated designs as
Not a Magic Bullet a starting point and then edit them or add
original material themselves, Lupo said.
With any AI tool, designs still generally
require manual editing with separate
software. If a company wants to add
branding such as a logo, that would
need to be done manually, since AI tools
generally won’t recreate them. Changing
The leather jacket from Revolve’s capsule collection a colour or shortening sleeves without
with Maison Meta had to be hand painted to match the generating an entire new image also
AI-generated design. Revolve. typically means manual edits.

businessoffashion.com 7
Strategy

Example prompts and outputs from


Stable Diffusion’s DreamStudio

Prompt: “Black leather biker jacket”

Prompt: “Act like a fashion designer and


create a black leather biker jacket with an
asymmetrical collar, shoulder pads, distressed
detailing, narrow arms and extended length,
minimalist, geometric”

Prompt: “Black female model walking a


runway at Paris fashion week, white minidress
with colourblock details, Piet Mondrian,
chic, primary colours, white high heels, gold
earrings, asymmetrical”

Source: Stable Diffusion

businessoffashion.com 8
Strategy

02 — Visual Content

Opportunities
Enhance and support creativity

Augment and hyper-personalise


customer-facing content and services

Reduce costs or complexity of


ambitious projects

Automate manual tasks

Casablanca, which has typically opted to shoot its marketing images with film, used generative AI to expand its
creative boundaries for its Spring/Summer 2023 collection, partnering with photographer and artist Luke Nugent.
Casablanca.

Luxury fashion brand Casablanca entered timelines, since brands don’t necessarily
new territory in May 2023. Though have to scout locations, find models,
the Paris-based label has typically style them (including hair and makeup),
avoided even digital photography for its manage lighting and do all the other work
campaigns, preferring old-fashioned that goes into creating images.
film, it decided to use AI to produce the
Whether or not it speeds the process
campaign for its Spring/Summer 2023
may depend on how it’s used, however. It
collection, collaborating with Luke
can also be difficult with current tools to
Nugent, a British photographer and AI
accurately translate a brand’s products in
artist. They opted for stylised shots that
a generated image. Worth noting as well
were painterly and slightly surreal rather
is that using AI can mean the models and
than photorealistic.
creatives brands would have normally
Steve Grimes, Casablanca’s art director, hired might not be necessary in some
who along with junior art director instances.
Sid Oudainia Beaulieu was part of the
But for companies with limited resources
creative team involved, said even being
trying to keep up with the content
AI-generated, the outcome was consistent
demands of the internet, or just looking to
with the brand’s typical aesthetic and
explore new creative avenues, it can be a
imagery.
valuable tool.
“We love the result,” stated Charaf
“I would argue that’s the biggest challenge
Tajer, Casablanca’s founder and creative
in our business, that constant stream
director.
of newness,” said Edzard van der Wyck,
Visual content has emerged as another co-founder of Sheep Inc., a high-end
promising use of generative AI for fashion knitwear brand that used AI for a
brands, which are under ever-increasing campaign that went live on its website
pressure to churn out imagery for in May 2023. The brand can spend
marketing, social media and e-commerce large amounts of time and money on
sites. It has the potential to provide more photoshoots, which don’t always work as
creative freedom and shorten production well as hoped. With generative AI, Van

businessoffashion.com 9
Strategy

der Wyck said, Sheep Inc. can more easily models and is only using AI models to add including a stylist, set designer and
produce creative content that it can test to its range, critics attacked the company, lighting expert. With all the back-and-
and iterate on based on what’s resonating accusing it of using AI to cut costs at the forth refining the imagery, it ended
with its community. expense of human models. In a statement, up taking longer than a traditional
Levi’s said it’s “physically impossible photoshoot, according to Tajer.
There are sustainability benefits too,
to shoot every single product at every
according to Sheep Inc.’s other co- “There’s so much work and different
single size at the SKU level” and noted the
founder, Michael Wessely, since AI people’s expertise that go into composing
technology could allow it to offer “a more
eliminates the need for carbon-intensive those images and ideas to make
personal, relevant and potentially more
flights and reduces waste, such as sets that something finalised that looks to a certain
engaging shopping experience.”
get discarded after use and the multiple standard,” Grimes added. “It’s not just
samples the brand has to produce for pressing a button and spitting out an
shoots and can’t sell afterwards.
Differing Results image.”
The process used for creating imagery
Levi’s is turning to AI to increase the Maybe the biggest challenge brands face
has an influence on whether generative
diversity of models displaying its clothes is ensuring their products are accurately
AI proves more efficient. Sheep Inc. didn’t
on its e-commerce site, announcing plans depicted in their AI-generated images,
enlist outside help and made everything
at BoF’s technology-focused Professional since any product photos uploaded into
itself with Midjourney. Van der Wyck said
Summit in March 2023 to test AI- an image generator will be altered in the
while it would typically require about two
generated models created by the agency output. Casablanca went so far as to shoot
months to plan and execute a campaign
Lalaland.ai. products from its collection on models
shoot, it took about a week from start to
mimicking the poses in the AI images and
But Levi’s also faced backlash, finish using AI.
then insert them into the AI images.
underscoring the reputational risk of such
But Casablanca, whose images were
moves as fashion workers worry about “We have to take lots of images of a
much more elaborate, said it needed
lost jobs. Even though Levi’s emphasised product — doesn’t have to be a studio
about 10 people to create its AI campaign,
it will continue to hire diverse human shoot at all — and then train the AI so
the AI learns that product exactly,” said
Nima Abbasi, a partner at Maison Meta,
which has created campaigns for a variety
of brands. “Then we pull that into the
creation so that the imagery actually
represents whatever the consumer is
going to buy.”
One common refrain heard among early
adopters is that while AI can enable
creativity, it isn’t a substitute for it. For
Casablanca, the process of researching
locations, building a story and mood-
boarding was exactly as it would have
been for a traditional shoot.
Both Casablanca and Sheep Inc. also said
AI won’t replace photography for them.
It’s simply another tool at their disposal.
Brands using AI to produce visual content
will want to consider whether to add
disclaimers on the imagery, particularly
with photorealistic images, to ensure
customers feel they are being transparent.
Maison Meta suggests they do so at this
stage.
They’ll also want to assess how they may
be repeating harmful biases in their
imagery, since AI replicates any biases
in the data it’s trained on, which in the
case of large language models generally
means huge volumes of data scraped
off the internet. In DreamStudio, a
commercial interface for Stable Diffusion,
for instance, the prompt “model wearing
a black sweater” resulted in images
depicting thin, white women and men.
Decode, a technology and culture site,
found that Midjourney can similarly
default to a white male for many prompts.

Sheep Inc. created campaign images with generative AI, allowing it to do in a week what would normally take about
two months. Sheep Inc.

businessoffashion.com 10
Strategy

03 — Writing Copy

When Snipes used generative-AI copywriting tools, its writers were able to spend more time on high-value products. Pexels.

Towards the end of 2022, Snipes began Generative AI’s capacity for
Opportunities experimenting with generative-AI tools understanding and producing natural-
such as Jasper and Copy.ai to see how they sounding language makes writing one
Enhance and support creativity could help its copywriters. At any given of the tasks it’s especially well-suited to
moment, there are thousands of products handle. In addition to general-purpose
Augment and hyper-personalise live on the sneaker and streetwear software like ChatGPT, start-ups
customer-facing content and services retailer’s e-commerce site, with more including Jasper and Hypotenuse offer
frequently arriving, putting pressure on enterprise tools, while tech providers
Reduce costs or complexity of
the writers to keep up their output. Chief powering many fashion businesses such
ambitious projects digital officer Jenna Flateman Posner was as Shopify, Salesforce and Amazon are
apprehensive about how the copywriters adding generative copy options into
Automate manual tasks
would react. She braced herself when she their platforms. These tools aim to
met with one writer to get feedback. help companies streamline writing of
everything from marketing emails to
“It’s their craft. It’s their profession. So
product descriptions.
you would think that utilising generative
AI would feel a little bit like cheating,” At this stage, however, they need human
Flateman Posner said. “What she told oversight, and incorporating them can
me is that what the generative AI and the require changing established workflows.
dynamic copywriter have allowed her To make the most of their future
to do is really home in on the styles that potential, including hyper-personalised
bring value to the business.” copy, companies will also require strong
data capabilities. For now, though, AI
Now, for commodity products, the
copywriting tools can already automate
copywriter acts more like an editor,
laborious work.
reviewing the technology’s output for
accuracy and Snipes’ tone of voice. “We’re seeing a tonne of usage,” said
This frees the copywriter to focus Miqdad Jaffer, head of product at Shopify,
on the storytelling around styles which introduced a tool called Shopify
Snipes expects to be big sellers, have Magic for writing product descriptions in
marketing investments behind them early 2023. “It creates a way for [companies]
or have compelling backstories worth to get their products live faster and in the
highlighting, Flateman Posner said. hands of consumers sooner.”

businessoffashion.com 11
Strategy

New tools from technology providers such as Salesforce can enable customers to automate some copywriting work like generating product descriptions. Salesforce.

For a new product, users of Shopify’s let users create subject lines and body Honaman noted the excitement around
service enter a few keywords as well as copy for email campaigns based on what generative AI has led interest in AWS
any special instructions, like the name has performed well in the past. Michael to surge as companies worry their data
of the manufacturer, and then generate a Affronti, general manager of Salesforce’s capabilities could hold them back.
description, which they can edit. Shopify Commerce Cloud, foresees soon being
Workflows might need adjusting too.
has also updated the product to allow for able to dynamically personalise product
Affronti said instead of a writer creating
different tones of voice, like an expert descriptions for individual users.
several versions of a product description
tone or a playful tone.
If a customer in New York visits a site, for the company’s major markets, they
Flateman Posner said tools like Hypotenuse, for example, the copy describing a jacket could set up a generative interface that
which offers bulk writing and editing, might take a fashion angle, but if they’re allows them to write one or two versions
have helped with the workload tied to in Seattle, where it rains frequently, it and deploy them.
dropshipping, since it can inundate could emphasise its waterproofing. An
“They review it once, change maybe one
the copywriters with a large number image of a model wearing the product
word and hit save,” he said.
of products whose descriptions often could also dynamically change to show a
need rewriting. In one instance, Snipes’ cityscape or a forest. (Snipes, a Salesforce One point of tension for any company
copywriters completed about two weeks’ customer, is eager to begin testing involves deciding how much human
worth of writing in two hours, she said. these sorts of personalised experiences, oversight is needed and how much
Flateman Posner said.) autonomy to give the AI. While large
Tech providers say these capabilities
language models can be good at producing
are just the beginning. Amazon, which “Brands and I have been talking
conversational text, they can also
is rolling out generative-AI tools for its about generative [AI] as a way to bring
make factual and conceptual errors or
cloud platform, Amazon Web Services, personalisation even closer to the
reproduce information from sources
envisions a time when a content customer, because we can fundamentally
closely enough to raise plagiarism
marketing manager could use its AI do things that were impossible unless you
concerns. The wrong error directed at
service, Bedrock, to quickly generate had a million content writers writing a
a customer could lose a sale or, worse,
copy for social media posts, display ads million versions of a product description,”
damage the retailer’s reputation. If a
and websites by feeding it examples Affronti said.
company wants a person to review all
of past taglines and relevant product
copy before it’s live, that would slow the
descriptions. One-to-One Barriers workflow and could eliminate the opportunity
“It’s very feasible, if not now then in the But to tailor content to consumers at a to let AI personalise copy on the fly.
very near future,” said Justin Honaman, one-to-one level, brands and retailers will
Brands could mitigate these problems in
head of worldwide retail and consumer need more than just publicly available
various ways, like having templates that
packaged goods at AWS. “Over time, I information. They’ll have to connect their
the AI just fills in with certain keywords.
think that the models will be even more customer data to the AI model. That will
AI models are continuously improving, too.
powerful and the use cases will continue prove challenging for many businesses,
Even so, there’s always some inherent error
to expand.” especially those struggling to collect
rate in them. Brands will need to decide how
first-party data or structure it to be
Salesforce introduced new generative much human monitoring and intervention
usable. Companies will also want to make
tools for Einstein GPT, its AI product they’ll need to mitigate that risk.
sure the AI provider has data-privacy
for customer relationship management,
measures in place.
in June 2023, including templates that

businessoffashion.com 12
Strategy

04 — Shopping and Customer Service

With AI, chatbots such as Zalando’s can be genuinely conversational, rather than just offering a set of scripted responses, and provide tailored product suggestions. Zalando.

In customer interviews, Tian provide tailored product suggestions


Opportunities Su, Zalando’s vice president of rather than a generic list of links, like
personalisation and recommendation, conventional search. Importantly, they
Enhance and support creativity said she often hears that customers create an iterative experience in which
struggle to find the products they’re a shopper can respond to the results
Augment and hyper-personalise
looking for because they don’t know with feedback or additional questions,
customer-facing content and services the right search terms. A chatbot that narrowing the results or guiding the bot
Reduce costs or complexity of
can understand and respond to natural towards what they want.
language could greatly improve the
ambitious projects But while these bots understand and
situation in Su’s opinion, which is why the
respond to questions effectively, even
Automate manual tasks online fashion retailer is joining other
providing viable outfit suggestions, they
companies — such as Shopify, secondhand
have limitations. BoF testing in spring
marketplace Mercari, start-up ShopWith
2023 found their replies can sound
AI and KNXT, an experimental platform
automated and they may fail to surface
operated by Kering — in releasing an
satisfactory products. (The retailer’s
online shopping assistant that uses
inventory is a limiting factor.) Their
generative AI.
styling sense tends towards fairly generic
With these chatbots, searching for a suggestions as well. The expectation,
“summer top” might return a set of linen however, is that as they advance they’ll
shirts, even though the customer didn’t offer shoppers a new and effective way to
specify linen. They can also recommend search for and discover products.
full looks that consider contextual factors,
“The natural language interface allows
such as the type of event, location and
them to be able to be expressive in
weather if a customer asks what to wear to
whatever way they want and allows us to
an open-air concert in London in October.
determine what the right search criteria
Shopping and customer service are other is,” Shopify’s Jaffer said.
areas where the technology’s language
The interface is perhaps especially
abilities can play a role. Chatbots
useful for platforms and retailers like
bolstered by large language models can be
Shopify, Zalando and Mercari with a vast
genuinely conversational, unlike previous
inventory of thousands of products. For
generations that could only reply from a
shoppers, finding the right item can be
set of scripted responses. They can also

businessoffashion.com 13
Strategy

“Human ‘augmentation,’ a challenge, particularly if they aren’t


familiar with all the brands available. The
what the customer wants. The retailer
must then be able to find products
versus ‘automation,’ will bot can offer a variety of options that fit that match. To do that, it needs a deep
their search criteria. understanding of its inventory, meaning
be the watchword in A site with a limited assortment can be
each product needs rich information and
the retailer has to extract and interpret
luxury.” simpler to browse, and there are fewer
that information, according to Su.
options for the bot to draw from when the
— Roger Roberts shopper asks a question. Because KNXT Jaffer similarly pointed out that Shopify
only carries Kering brands and those in wants to improve the quality of the
which the holding company of the Pinault datasets it uses to suggest products to
family behind Kering owns a stake, for make it easier for customers to filter by
example, its Madeline bot doesn’t offer price or certain product attributes.
a wide range of items when asked for
A larger goal for many fashion players
recommendations. It suggests only one
is being able to use customer data to
product.
personalise a chatbot’s responses. The bot
On the other hand, luxury shoppers may could use the data to offer specific sizes
value the additional information and based on a customer’s preferences, for
storytelling Madeline offers, such as example. It’s an ambitious aim, though,
product details and occasions when an and requires brands and retailers to have
item could be worn. their customer data at hand and to be able
to map it to their inventory.
McKinsey’s Roberts believes generative
AI could enhance the in-store luxury “Getting to know the buyer information
experience, too, giving sales associates and then tying that to the merchant
“superpowers” through clienteling tools attribute information is one where we’re
that analyse client data, translate the going to have to spend a little more time
insights into plain language and generate for sure,” Jaffer said.
recommended actions.
Essentially, chat assistants are largely a
“Human ‘augmentation,’ versus work in progress or still in testing. Jaffer
‘automation,’ will be the watchword in said Shopify opened Shop.ai to users
luxury,” he said. “It will continue to be quickly to see how customers interact
super important for those frontline team with it and gather feedback. Kering said in
members to think critically about the a statement that KNXT, which introduced
recommendations here.” its Madeline chatbot in March, is a place
to “test innovative digital experiences.”
Not a Replacement For Search — Yet Zalando’s shopping assistant was in beta
testing as of the time of writing.
Jaffer pointed out that Shopify’s intent
isn’t to replace traditional search But all these companies expressed
with a generative-AI assistant but confidence that the language abilities of
to complement it. He compared it to generative AI will keep advancing and
shopping in a store. Some customers know that their shopping assistants would
exactly what they’re looking for and don’t steadily improve in tandem as they
need the help of a sales associate. Others receive more data and user feedback.
have questions or want suggestions and
Companies interested in exploring
would like to speak with someone who
generative-AI chatbots will need to be
can guide them. (Google has announced
clear about their customers’ needs and
it is testing generative AI in its Shopping
whether a bot can meet them. They
vertical, and while it won’t have a
should also consider whether they want
conversational bot, it similarly aims to
to launch quickly to see how customers
offer more guidance with new features.)
interact with the bot or whether it’s better
Building a generative-AI chatbot isn’t as to test privately to decide if the bot needs
simple as getting an API for ChatGPT. refining first.
Large language models, which are trained
on general information, aren’t fashion
specialists, and they can be vulnerable
to “hallucination,” meaning replies that
may be grammatically correct but are not
factual — or are just plain odd. Users have
found ways to get around protocols like
blocks on inappropriate content by asking
bots to act as a different persona.
“These AI [tools] are designed to hold a
good conversation. You have to actually
[specially train] it to give you more factual
information,” Su said.
Moreover, the AI just helps to understand

businessoffashion.com 14
Takeaways

Putting AI Into Practice


For many fashion businesses, it is The most ambitious uses of generative
relatively easy to start testing ways to AI could also require bigger shifts, like
Fashion and Generative AI:
put the technology to use with tools that in the case of personalised content or
A Starter Checklist
are free or low cost, such as many of the chat responses based on customer data.
Like with other tech rollouts, this checklist can image generators available, or enterprise Before companies can put AI to use for
help brands launching gen AI do so smoothly. tools for tasks such as copywriting. In those purposes, they need good data
some cases, they can enlist partners like that’s structured and accessible to the
Begin small with tools that are free creative agencies or artists with technical employees who need it. Many companies
or low cost expertise. may find they have to upgrade their data
Closely examine specific needs and capabilities first.
But before they make any major or costly
use cases
commitments, closely examining specific “If you cannot get access to your data, it’s
Factor in the impact on workforces needs is critical, as well as evaluating going to hold you back,” said Amazon’s
and workflows how much value generative AI can offer Honaman. “How can you run models
and what the impact will be on their against it?”
Ensure human input and oversight
workforce and workflows.
is available None of the experts BoF spoke with
“You need to have a broader aperture and suggested companies avoid generative
Have appropriate guard rails for
customer-facing tools not only think gen AI, but you really need AI because of any of the potential risks,
to come from a values point of view and but there are issues to be aware of. For
Test rigorously before deployment understand your business, understand text-based applications, particularly
the evolution of your business and where those where the AI is interacting directly
you’d like to drive it and understand with customers, companies should put in
the full value chain,” said McKinsey’s place appropriate guard rails to constrain
Harreis. “Once you understand the bot responses to customers’ queries.
opportunities, you would start thinking Open-ended bots can be led into making
about what’s the best approach to it that confusing or worrying statements,
gives the highest return on investment.” creating potential reputational risks for a
business.
Businesses should keep in mind that the
technology can help speed up processes With generative AI for design, the
and reduce manual work, but it requires technology could introduce new legal
human input and oversight. Designs questions around IP as well. The safest
often need manual editing and could route may be for brands to ensure they’re
prove difficult to manufacture in some adding their own elements to generated
instances. Visual content remains designs.
dependent on creative ideas and refining.
“The most practical approach is just
Copy needs editing and checking for
keeping humans armed with critical
accuracy. And chatbots require plenty of
thinking [and] in the loop on most aspects
human effort behind the scenes.
of deployment and adoption today,”
Roberts of McKinsey pointed out that Roberts said.
generative AI at this stage should be
Ultimately, companies should treat it as
regarded as a way to enhance human
any other new technology: Think of the
abilities rather than replace them,
use cases that make the most sense for
particularly when it comes to luxury,
the business, weigh the benefits and costs,
which remains rooted in personal
test before deploying widely and measure
customer service. To make the most of
results.
the technology, sales associates and other
staff may need to be trained in the best
ways to use AI applications.
The brands and retailers providing
input for this case study also commonly
emphasised that generative AI provides
another tool they can use and isn’t a
substitute for what they already have.
It might find a role in addition to, rather
than instead of, photography, for example.
Similarly, it can help designers produce
new ideas but won’t eliminate sketching.
At least for now, it’s being used to
supplement or support established tools
and processes.

businessoffashion.com 15
Looking Ahead

Generative AI’s
Fast-Changing Future
The progress happening in generative The expectation is that these advances and more of those scenarios happen
AI is swift and is making a meaningful will continue making AI tools more that involve doing things on behalf of a
difference in the tools fashion businesses effective and valuable to fashion. They customer faster and more cheaply.”
can use. OpenAI’s GPT-4 is leaps ahead could also unlock capabilities companies
These conditions make it hard to predict
of its predecessor, GPT-3.5 — the model haven’t yet imagined. Honaman said the
what the future holds. One warning from
underlying ChatGPT — surpassing it in use cases Amazon is working on have
experts is that as AI-generated content
advanced reasoning, accuracy and more. evolved over the course of just a few weeks
proliferates and becomes the input new
Sheep Inc.’s Van der Wyck said the release — and most people weren’t thinking about
models are trained on, the output will
of version five of Midjourney in March them at all several months previously.
decline in quality, like making a copy of
2023 marked the first time he felt the
And while one obstacle to progress is the a copy. But it is increasingly likely that
technology could produce usable visuals.
expense of training AI models, which generative AI will become embedded in
“Version six is on the horizon. I’m already can require hefty investments due to the fashion over time, just as earlier uses for
excited about what probably is going to processing power and hardware required, machine learning have. Large tech players
come next because it is already so good,” costs are falling. and start-ups alike will also keep trying to
he said. capitalise on the technology with services
The way Affronti at Salesforce put it is
and tools for businesses. Pitchbook
The abilities are only growing. In a that “as the technology itself gets better,
estimates the market for enterprise
spring 2023 paper, computer scientists as some of the work that we’re doing
applications of generative AI will reach
at Microsoft said an AI system seemed to in Einstein GPT gets more powerful
$42.9 billion in 2023 and grow to $98.5
show an intuitive understanding of the and, quite frankly, as the underlying
billion by 2026. Within that, it expects
physical world, solving a puzzle about how cost comes down for actually running
natural language interfaces to make up
to stack different objects, despite having all of this infrastructure — because
the largest portion because of “customer
no physical embodiment itself. it’s so expensive from a computation
service and sales automation use cases.”
perspective — I expect to see more
It’s still a big question whether generative
AI will live up to the potential its
proponents envision. In fashion, it could
Exhibit 6: Growth Mindset find a home in some narrow roles, appear
in customer feeds or on e-commerce
By 2026, the total market for generative AI is expected to more than double, with natural
sites every so often in ways they may or
language interfaces powering uses like customer service and sales.
may not recognise and be absorbed into
the industry’s infrastructure without
AI market size in generative-relevant categories (est.)
changing it.
USD (billions)
But if it does match the expectations
Natural language interfaces being put forward by many, it could
Tailored applications (e.g. biotech, coding) reshape how fashion businesses operate,
Foundational AI software and by extension have major effects on
2D/3D media and audio the industry’s workforce. Historically,
technology hasn’t resulted in a net loss of
1.99 jobs but it has changed work. As some jobs
22.08 are eliminated, new roles can be created,
requiring different training and abilities.
Revolve’s Mente pointed out that AI could
28.46 accelerate the move to digital tools, like
3D design programs.
“It’ll definitely shift skill sets,” he said.
0.77 Fashion companies will need to be
46.01
9.40 prepared for change, whatever form it
12.76 ultimately takes.
20.00

2023 2026 E

Source: Pitchbook Emerging Tech Research

businessoffashion.com 16
Glossary
• Artificial intelligence (AI): Technology • Neural network: A form of ML that
such as a computer program that uses a set of interconnected algorithms
mimics the human brain’s ability to structured in various node layers
perform tasks and learn and improve imitating the workings of the human
over time. brain.
• Deep learning: A form of neural • Transformer: A neural network that
network involving more than three uses sequences of data, like words in
node layers. These algorithms are a sentence, to identify relationships
more effective at processing and between data points that may be far
understanding unstructured data. apart from one another, allowing it to
understand context and predict new
• Diffusion model: A type of generative
sequences. Many language models like
model trained by adding “noise” to a set
OpenAI’s GPT models (GPT stands for
of training data and then reversing the
“generative pre-trained transformer”)
process to reconstruct the data. It can
are transformers trained on giant
use random noise to create new data by
amounts of data.
repeating the “denoising” process.
• Generative Adversarial Network
(GAN): A type of generative model
capable of producing realistic imagery
by employing two neural networks,
a generator and a discriminator. The
generator creates new content and
the discriminator tries to distinguish
if it’s real or fake. As each improves,
the output becomes increasingly more
difficult to identify as false.
• Generative AI: Deep learning
algorithms that with sufficient examples
of something can recognise the
underlying patterns and structures in
the data and produce new iterations,
including text, imagery, video and more.
• Machine learning (ML): A branch of AI
that involves algorithms which are able
to identify patterns in data and learn
from them without being explicitly
programmed.

businessoffashion.com 17
Further Reading
• UBS, US Retail & Internet: highlights from an expert call on Generative AI
• The Business of Fashion, How Generative AI Could Perpetuate Fashion’s Biases
• The Business of Fashion, Should Fashion Fear AI?
• McKinsey & Company, Generative AI: Unlocking the future of fashion
• The Business of Fashion, The BoF Podcast | How Generative AI Could Reshape Fashion
• Stephen Wolfram, What Is ChatGPT Doing…and Why Does It Work?
• Quartz, The data that transformed AI research—and possibly the world

businessoffashion.com 18
For press enquiries, please contact:

Jael Fowakes
Associate Director, Brand and Community
jael.fowakes@businessoffashion.com

Liam Johnson
Senior Account Director, Camron Global
liam.johnson@camronglobal.com

Copyright © 2023, The Business of Fashion Ltd. All rights reserved

All information contained herein is the sole property of The Business of Fashion Limited. The Business of Fashion Limited reserves
all rights regarding the use of this information. Any unauthorised use, such as distributing, copying, modifying, or reprinting, is
not permitted. Please contact professional@businessoffashion.com for more copies.

Design by Amy Vien


Edited by Janet Kersnar, Brian Baskin and Hannah Crump

Front cover image: Casablanca

Discover our complete online courses and learning resources at: businessoffashion.com/education

info@businessofashion.com

businessoffashion.com 19

You might also like