Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Adventure Tourism Environmental Impacts and Management 1St Ed 2020 Edition David Huddart Full Chapter PDF
Adventure Tourism Environmental Impacts and Management 1St Ed 2020 Edition David Huddart Full Chapter PDF
https://ebookmass.com/product/dark-tourism-in-the-american-
west-1st-ed-2020-edition-jennifer-dawes/
https://ebookmass.com/product/labour-policies-language-use-and-
the-new-economy-the-case-of-adventure-tourism-1st-ed-edition-
kellie-goncalves/
https://ebookmass.com/product/environmental-sustainability-in-a-
time-of-change-1st-ed-2020-edition-robert-brinkmann/
https://ebookmass.com/product/transformation-of-sydneys-
industrial-historic-waterfront-the-production-of-tourism-for-
consumption-1st-ed-2020-edition-ece-kaya/
Shale Gas. Exploration and Environmental and Economic
Impacts 1st Edition Edition Anurodh Mohan Dayal And
Devleena Mani (Eds.)
https://ebookmass.com/product/shale-gas-exploration-and-
environmental-and-economic-impacts-1st-edition-edition-anurodh-
mohan-dayal-and-devleena-mani-eds/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-calculus-story-a-mathematical-
adventure-1st-edition-david-acheson/
https://ebookmass.com/product/marketing-tourism-and-hospitality-
concepts-and-cases-1st-ed-2021-edition-richard-george/
https://ebookmass.com/product/food-waste-management-solving-the-
wicked-problem-1st-ed-2020-edition-elina-narvanen/
https://ebookmass.com/product/sustainability-management-in-
heritage-and-tourism-the-concept-and-practice-of-mottainai-in-
japan-takamitsu-jimura/
DAVID HUDDART & TIM STOTT
Adventure
Tourism
Environmental
Impacts and
Management
Adventure Tourism
David Huddart • Tim Stott
Adventure Tourism
Environmental Impacts and
Management
David Huddart Tim Stott
Liverpool John Moores University Liverpool John Moores University
Liverpool, UK Liverpool, UK
© The Editor(s) (if applicable) and The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Nature
Switzerland AG 2020
This work is subject to copyright. All rights are solely and exclusively licensed by the Publisher,
whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation,
reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilms or in any
other physical way, and transmission or information storage and retrieval, electronic adaptation,
computer software, or by similar or dissimilar methodology now known or hereafter developed.
The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, service marks, etc. in this
publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are
exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use.
The publisher, the authors and the editors are safe to assume that the advice and information in
this book are believed to be true and accurate at the date of publication. Neither the publisher nor
the authors or the editors give a warranty, express or implied, with respect to the material
contained herein or for any errors or omissions that may have been made. The publisher remains
neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature
Switzerland AG.
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Acknowledgements
The authors would like to thank their wives, Silvia and Debbie for their
patience and tolerance for understanding that it takes many hours to compile
a book such as this. Over many years the Outdoor Education students of
Liverpool John Moores University have provided an inspiration for the
authors in many ways. David Huddart would like to thank Emeritus Professor
Michael Hambrey; Verena Starke of the Geophysical Laboratory, Carnegie
Institution of Washington; Soffia Kristin Jonsdottir of Visit Myvatn; Thomas
Olsen of North Safari Outfitters, Kangerlussuaq and Ralf Rolestshek for per-
mission to use some of their visual material to considerably enhance the text.
Tim Stott would like to thank his son Ewan Stott for providing a significant
number of the photographs used in the chapters on the Andes and Australia.
v
Contents
vii
viii Contents
xix
xx List of Figures
Fig. 6.10 Ringed Seal (Pusa hispida,) The smallest of the Arctic
seals which is common in the Hudson BayN�������������������� 165
Fig. 6.11 Pingos near Tuktoyoyaktuk������������������������������������������������ 167
Fig. 6.12 The view from the top of Montana Mountain,
Carcross����������������������������������������������������������������������� 171
Fig. 6.13 Annual Counts of recorded Pleasure Craft in the
Canadian Arctic, Vessel Count 1990–2012. From
NORDREG Data���������������������������������������������������������������� 172
Fig. 6.14 Beechey Island graves of crewman from the 1845
Franklin Northwest passage expedition ���������������������������� 176
Fig. 7.1A Malaspina Glacier in south-east Alaska���������������������������� 184
Fig. 7.1B Agassiz glacier, Libby glacier and Agassiz Lakes ������������ 184
Fig. 7.2 Augustine Volcano, view from the west, January
12th 2006 �������������������������������������������������������������������������� 185
Fig. 7.3 Black Bear�������������������������������������������������������������������������� 188
Fig. 7.4 Brown Bears at Brooks Falls, Katmai National Park,
Alaska�������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 194
Fig. 7.5 Dall Sheep lambs on Alaskan clif�������������������������������������� 196
Fig. 7.6 Caribou on Tundra ������������������������������������������������������������ 200
Fig. 7.7 Bald Eagle (Haliaeetus leucocephalus) feeding on whale
carcase�������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 203
Fig. 7.8A Marbled Murrelet (Brachyramphus marmoratus) at Auke
Bay marina, near Juneau���������������������������������������������������� 206
Fig. 7.8B Juvenile Kittletz’s Murrelet (Brachyramphus breviros-
tris), Kachemak Bay, Alaska���������������������������������������������� 206
Fig. 7.9 Killer Whales off the south side of Unimak Island,
eastern Aleutian Islands, Alaska���������������������������������������� 210
Fig. 7.10 Arctic National Wildlife Refuge, Brook Range, with
tundra shrub willow ���������������������������������������������������������� 217
Fig. 7.11 Impacts of Off-Road vehicles on the study segment of
the Tanada Lake Trail (Wrangell-St. Elias National
Park and Preserve, Alaska). a) Partly vegetated trail
unvegetated trail on mineral soil b) Unvegetated trail
on organic soils with ponding c) Trail stream crossing
and channel initiation point with mineral soil d) Trail
stream crossing and channel initiation point with
organic soil and underlain by shallow permafrost ���������� 225
Fig. 7.12 Mt. McKinley, North America’s highest mountain������������ 231
Fig. 8.1 Himalayas�������������������������������������������������������������������������� 242
Fig. 8.2 K2. Photo by Vittorio Sella on the 1909 Italian
expedition ������������������������������������������������������������������� 243
Fig. 8.3A Everest from the Rongbuk valley in 1921. Photo by
George Mallory������������������������������������������������������������������ 244
Fig. 8.3B Everest from the Rongbuk glacier, 9th November
2005 ��������������������������������������������������������������������������� 244
Fig. 8.4 Himalayas mosaic. Taken from the International Space
Station, 28th January 2004������������������������������������������������ 245
xxii List of Figures
Fig. 10.7E Safari vehicles in the Maasai Mara keep in touch with
each other by radio. When a good sighting is made by
one vehicle (in this case it was a cheetah), the others in
the area are called in, thus concentrating damage to soil
and vegetation and causing additional stress to the
animal�������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 346
Fig. 11.1A Physical map of Australia�������������������������������������������������� 357
Fig. 11.1B Political map showing the countries of Australia which
has six states—New South Wales (NSW), Queensland
(QLD), South Australia (SA), Tasmania (TAS), Victoria
(VIC) and Western Australia (WA)—and two major
mainland territories—the Australian Capital Territory
(ACT) and the Northern Territory (NT)���������������������������� 357
Fig. 11.2A The kangaroo is a marsupial from the family
Macropodidae (macropods, meaning “large foot”)����������� 360
Fig. 11.2B The koala (Phascolarctos cinereus) is an arboreal
herbivorous marsupial native to Australia�������������������������� 360
Fig. 11.2C Kookaburras are terrestrial tree kingfishers native to
Australia and New Guinea, found in habitats ranging
from humid forest to arid savanna, as well as in subur-
ban areas with tall trees or near running water������������������ 360
Fig. 11.2D The grey-headed flying fox (Pteropus poliocephalus) is
a megabat native to Australia �������������������������������������������� 360
Fig. 11.3A Physical features map of New Zealand������������������������������ 362
Fig. 11.3B Map of New Zealand regions (coloured) with territorial
authorities delineated by black lines���������������������������������� 362
Fig. 11.3C The Lady Knox Geyser in Wai-O-Tapu Thermal area in
New Zealand’s Taupo Volcanic Zone, 27 km south of
Rotorua������������������������������������������������������������������������������ 362
Fig. 11.3D The Hooker Valley in Aoraki/Mount Cook National Park
contains a popular walking track which is 5 km long�������� 362
Fig. 11.3E Milford Sound is a fiord in the SW of New Zealand’s
South Island within Fiordland National Park, Milford
Sound Marine Reserve, and the Te Wahipounamu World
Heritage site ���������������������������������������������������������������������� 362
Fig. 11.3F Abel Tasman National Park is a New Zealand national
park located between Golden Bay and Tasman Bay at
the north end of the South Island �������������������������������������� 362
Fig. 11.4 Sydney Harbour Bridge, where tourists are guided to the
134 m “summit”���������������������������������������������������������������� 368
Fig. 11.5A Fraser Island is considered to be the largest sand island
in the world������������������������������������������������������������������������ 369
Fig. 11.5B Fraser Icon Tours 4WD bus taking tourists along its west
coast beach ������������������������������������������������������������������������ 369
Fig. 11.5C Fraser Island’s sandy tracks require 4WD vehicles to get
around�������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 369
Fig. 11.5D Sand Island Safaris – a typical adventure tourism
company on Fraser Island�������������������������������������������������� 369
List of Figures xxv
Fig. 11.5E Fraser Island dingoes are reputedly some of the last
remaining pure dingoes in Eastern Australia �������������������� 369
Fig. 11.6 Falls Creek Alpine Resort is an alpine ski resort in north
eastern Victoria, catering mainly for beginner/intermedi-
ate skiers and boarders ������������������������������������������������������ 372
Fig. 11.7 Shark cage diving from Port Lincoln off South
Australia������������������������������������������������������������������������� 372
Fig. 11.8A Uluru, also known as Ayers Rock, is one of Australia’s
most recognisable natural landmarks, great cultural
significance for the Aṉangu people������������������������������������ 374
Fig. 11.8B Kata Tjuta, also known as The Olgas, are rock forma-
tions 25km west of Uluru which has great cultural
significance for the Aṉangu people������������������������������������ 374
Fig. 11.8C Formerly it was popular to climb to the top of Uluru as
can be seen by the light coloured erosion mark in this
photo���������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 374
Fig. 11.8D Today visitors are respectfully requested not to climb the
rock to respect the wishes of the Anangu people�������������� 374
Fig. 11.9 Sky dive over Mission Beach, Queensland������������������������ 375
Fig. 11.10A A typical day cruise to the Great Barrier Reef (from
Cairns). This cruiser has a glass bottom and some have a
glass tank which allows guests to have a semi-submarine
experience�������������������������������������������������������������������������� 376
Fig. 11.10B Scuba divers prepare for their dive onto the coral reef���������376
Fig. 11.11A White water rafting is one of New Zealand’s top
attractions�������������������������������������������������������������������������� 376
Fig. 11.11B Jet boats on the Shotover River near Queenstown…. one
of the area’s top attractions������������������������������������������������ 376
Fig. 11.11C Whale watching cruise setting off from Kaikoura, 180
km north of Christchurch �������������������������������������������������� 376
Fig. 11.11D Sperm whale spotted off Kaikoura������������������������������������ 376
Fig. 11.11E A guided sea kayak tour in the Marlborough Sound,
Abel Tasman National Park ���������������������������������������������� 376
Fig. 11.11F Zorbing (globe-riding or orbing), seen here at Rotorua,
NZ, is the recreation or sport of rolling downhill inside
an orb, generally made of transparent plastic�������������������� 376
Fig. 11.11G Fox Glacier sign���������������������������������������������������������������� 376
Fig. 11.11H Fox Glacier was one of the few glaciers in the world to
be advancing between 1985 and 2009. In 2006 the
average rate of advance was about a metre a week. Since
then there has been a significant retreat ���������������������������� 376
Fig. 11.11I Sign for the AJ Hackett Ledge Swing above
Queenstown, NZ���������������������������������������������������������������� 376
Fig. 11.11J The AJ Hackett Kawarau Bridge Bungee Jump,
Queenstown NZ ���������������������������������������������������������������� 376
Fig. 11.11K Paragliding over Queenstown, NZ ������������������������������������ 376
Fig. 11.12A Dolphins Up Close vessel in Akaroa Harbour ������������������ 379
xxvi List of Figures
xxix
xxx List of Tables
tion would lose its competitiveness and tourists nue from a trip goes to airlines, hotels and other
would go somewhere else. international companies. In contrast, in adven-
ture travel 70–80% of the revenue goes to local
communities; while 65.5% of total travel expen-
1.2 lobal Figures for Tourism
G diture per adventure travel remains in the desti-
and the Adventure Sector nations or destination the traveller has visited.
accommodation component as part of the pack- 1. some real or perceived risk related to a physi-
age. Buckley (2006) identifies four component cal activity, remoteness or unfamiliar
types: independent travel, which involves at location;
least some commercial transport and accommo- 2. occurring in a natural environment that is rela-
dation but includes some activity that the travel- tively unexplored and with minimal or no
ler treats as adventurous; fully packaged, guided urban influences;
commercial adventure tours, departing on 3. a physical activity that tests both mental and
defined dates from specified gateways; fixed-site physical endurance;
adventure activities available to both tourists and 4. cultural immersion;
the local population, but where tourists make up 5. a minimalism that supports eco-, responsible
a significant percentage of the clientele, as in ski and sustainable tourism and discourages
resorts; and finally all the ancillary businesses mindless consumerism, although some of the
and economic sectors linked to adventure tour- luxury cruises that occur do not support this
ism through recreational equipment, adventure- element.
branded clothing and a significant proportion of
the amenity-migrant property market (where Adventure is not about how wild, high or
people move to an area to live or purchase a sec- extreme an activity is. It is primarily a mental
ond home, especially to take part in adventurous attitude to travel that shapes the values that visi-
activities). Buckley (2010) suggests that on a tors bring with them on their holiday. In other
global scale the outdoor and adventure tourism words, adventure is a subjective concept that
subsectors of the tourism market make up around revolves around how individual travellers like to
one-fifth of the global tourism market and travel shape their own experiences. The key for adven-
sector, and one that as we have noted continues ture travel is that the holiday should be based on
to expand. ATTA created a definition of adven- experiences, and that added value comes from
ture tourism and the adventure tourist. Such a really getting to know a destination through
tourist is one who includes at least two of the physical activity, cultural encounters and experi-
three following elements in his or her leisure encing the natural environment. Activities like
travel: physical activity, engagement with nature, these allow individual travellers to extend their
and cultural interaction and learning. Through own boundaries culturally, physically and geo-
this definition, it is seen that most tourists can be graphically, and these boundaries vary from per-
considered adventurers. The challenge for tour- son to person. Regardless of how tourism
ism will therefore always be to stimulate eco- professionals organise or categorise adventure
nomic and social development in a way that travel, adventure will always be a subjective term
factors in nature, culture and the environment. for travellers, because it is related to individual
Adventure travel addresses all these chal- experience. Adventure to one traveller may seem
lenges in a way that provides opportunities for routine or mundane to another. Adventure tour-
local communities to develop, and it takes ists push their own cultural, physical and geo-
account of the tourists’ diverse understanding of graphic comfort limits, and those limits differ for
what a responsible and sustainable adventure- each person. Rantala et al. (2018) suggest that the
based holiday involves. Hence adventure travel is boundaries between adventurous activities and
a form of travel where visitors interact with the tourism are blurred, and they explore the diffuse
environment and nature, take part in physical use of concepts such as wilderness, nature guid-
activities and are part of a cultural exchange that ing and adventurous activities. Nevertheless,
combines at least two of these elements. There adventure tourism has been widely studied, and
could also be an extra element of self exploration the literature review of 2119 references in Rantala
and connecting with self. It is possible therefore et al. (2018) indicates that the work was dispersed
to define adventure tourism as having some of the amongst many different subject disciplines and
following five elements: academic journals; their conclusion is that a
4 1 What Is Adventure Tourism?
reconceptualisation of adventure tourism is Table 1.1 Types of activity and categorisation as hard or
soft adventure
required. Cheng et al. (2018) find a total of 114
publications on adventure tourism that revealed Activity Type
three broad areas of foci in adventure tourism Archaeological expedition Soft
Attending local festival/fairs Other
research. These are adventure tourism experi-
Backpacking Soft
ence; destination planning and adventure tourism Birdwatching Soft
operators. Studies examining non-Western tour- Camping Soft
ists in their own geographical contexts and non- Canoeing Soft
Western tourists in Western geographical contexts Caving Hard
are under-represented. We hope to show in this Climbing (mountain/rock/ice) Hard
book that there are important environmental Cruise Other
Cultural activities Other
impacts caused by adventure tourism that need to
Eco-tourism Soft
be managed, and that education of participants Educational programs Soft
and company operators is necessary for the sus- Environmentally sustainable activities Soft
tainable use of the environments in which adven- Fishing/fly-fishing Soft
ture tourism takes place. Getting to know the locals Other
There are two main categories of adventure Hiking Soft
activities, hard and soft adventure, and vigorous Horseback riding Soft
Hunting Soft
debate often surrounds which activities belong in
Kayaking/sea/whitewater Soft
each category (see Table 1.1). The easiest way to Learning a new language Other
identify an adventure trip as hard or soft adven- Orienteering Soft
ture is by its primary activity. Rafting Soft
Both hard and soft adventures are highly Research expeditions Soft
lucrative segments of the adventure tourism sec- Safaris Soft
tor. The cost of the permit to access the summit of Sailing Soft
Scuba diving Soft
Mount Everest, a hard adventure activity, was
Snorkelling Soft
estimated to be US$11,000 per person in 2015. Skiing/snowboarding Soft
When all of the other factors are added in, such as Surfing Soft
training, gear, airfare and tour guides, the average Trekking Hard
total cost is about US$48,000 per person. Walking tours Other
Commercial adventure travel tour operators Visiting friends/family Other
offering soft adventure activities charged an aver- Visiting historical sites Other
Volunteer tourism Soft
age of US$308 per day in 2012. With an average
trip length of 8.8 days, the average total cost of a Source: Adapted from Adventure Tourism Development
Index 2016 Report
soft adventure trip was US$2710 per person, not
including flights. In addition to hard or soft
adventure activities, there are also different types average of one extra day. They spend more money
of adventure tourists. For example, adventure on equipment and gear, because they value brands
enthusiasts, such as avid kayakers, cyclists or that fit their highly specialised needs, and they
birdwatchers, become progressively more skilled seek out locations that are difficult to access or
at a specific outdoor or athletic activity. These are newly emerging but not yet popular. On the
enthusiasts are described as passionate about a other hand, extreme adventurers, such as base
certain sport or activity, tending to pursue the jumpers, those who cross the Greenland Ice Cap
same activity trip after trip, and seeking new and or runners of 100 km races, are not so much tour-
exciting destinations in the process. ists as independent travellers and thrill-seekers.
Although enthusiasts’ spending is on a par Extreme adventurers spend less money, because
with other types of adventure traveller, their more they have their own equipment, may not seek
frequent international trips typically last an commercial support to practise the activity, seek
1.4 Adventure Tourism 5
out locations that are difficult to access, and often In the adventure tourism sector, the trend has
camp or provide their own transport. been towards the removal of the middle man, tour
Extreme adventurers constitute a very small operator or travel agent, who has traditionally
segment of the sector. Thus, although they can connected the consumer in the source market to
have public relations and marketing value for a the provider or ground handler in the destination
destination or company, they do not typically market. As the traveller can access information
require attention from tourism development pol- and trusted consumer reviews online, he is now
icy makers and land managers. more likely to go straight to the provider. The
AdventurePulse: USA Adventure Traveller
Profiles, a study of the US adventure travel mar-
1.4.1 Growth in Demand ket, indicates that 71% of US adventure travellers
are making arrangements solely on their own.
In 2012, global tourism arrivals passed the 1 bil- While emerging economies are slowly outpac-
lion mark. As one of the fastest growing seg- ing developed economies for departures and
ments, adventure tourism arrivals naturally spending, the UNWTO predicts that by 2015,
increased as well. In 2010, the first global adven- arrivals in emerging economies will have
ture tourism market sizing study was conducted exceeded those in advanced economies; and by
by ATTA, the George Washington University and 2030, 57% of arrivals will be in emerging econo-
Xola Consulting. It found that the global value of mies. To accommodate this surge in demand,
adventure tourism was US$89 billion. The study supply is expected to increase. The makeup of the
was repeated in 2013 and found that 42% of trav- sector is predominantly small, owner-operated
ellers departed on adventure trips, making the businesses. In fact, in 2013 the average size of
sector worth US$263 billion, an increase of ATTA’s member companies was forty-four
195% in two years. This remarkable growth was employees.
attributed to an increase in international depar- Destinations around the world are focusing on
tures, an increase in travellers going on adventure adventure as a key niche segment, because of its
trips and an increase in average spending. economic and sustainability benefits. They are
Overall, 69% of international departures origi- working to provide professional education for
nated in Europe, North America or South adventure travel companies to support local peo-
America; the same was true of adventure tour- ple in participating in the tourism economy.
ism. Between 2009 and 2010, South America’s Increasingly, destinations are recognising that
hard adventure travel population grew from 1.4% travellers are seeking more authentic products.
of all departures to 8%. The same time period Around the world, destinations are gearing their
saw a 5% increase in the soft adventure popula- advertising and branding to appeal to adventure
tion. In fact, the UNWTO Tourism Highlights of travellers. For example, Norway capitalises on its
2014 notes that ‘with rising levels of disposable towering fjords and glaciers with the slogan
income, many emerging economies have shown ‘Powered by Nature’; Greenland emphasises its
fast growth over recent years, especially in mar- ruggedness with ‘Greenland, Be a Pioneer’; New
kets in Asia, Central and Eastern Europe, the Zealand touts its culture, mountains, wildlife and
Middle East and Africa.’ Additionally, the report hiking with ‘100% Pure New Zealand’; Nepal’s
notes that Chinese travellers are the top spenders Naturally Nepal logo includes a stylised high
while on vacation, and that developed economies peak and a tagline “Once is not enough”;
will benefit from the favourable exchange rate for Kyrgyzstan, surrounded by glaciers, emphasises
Russian and Chinese travellers via inbound tour- its mountainous assets in its adventure tourism
ism. Widespread increases of projected arrivals marketing with the tagline “Something New,
from Russian, Chinese, and Latin American trav- Something Different”; and Slovenia beckons
ellers will change the shape of tourism demo- with hiking, mountains and caves in its ‘I Feel
graphics in the years to come. Slovenia’ campaign.
6 1 What Is Adventure Tourism?
The trend is far-reaching. In 2011, 79% of of local communities, or to foster respect for dif-
tourism boards reported that the adventure tour- ferent cultures and for human rights. Since the
ism private sector had begun to emerge and/or 1980s, ecotourism has been considered a critical
grow in their destination. endeavour by environmentalists, so that future
In 2010, Greenland shifted its marketing to generations may experience destinations rela-
focus exclusively on the adventure sector. Its tively untouched by human intervention.
messaging and imagery were designed to capture Generally, ecotourism involves interaction with
the imaginations of tourists who sought off-the- biotic components of the natural environments. It
beaten track adventures and authentic cultural focuses on socially responsible travel, personal
interactions. Greenland’s marketing focused growth and environmental sustainability, and
equally on cultural, and especially culinary, typically involves travel to destinations where
activities through its ‘Taste of Greenland’ pro- flora, fauna and cultural heritage are the primary
gramme, and emphasised adventure activities attractions. It intends to offer tourists an insight
with the launch of a blog entitled ‘99% into the impact of human beings on the environ-
Backcountry’. This portrayed a modern ment and to foster a greater appreciation of our
Greenland, where girls in traditional costumes natural habitats. Responsible ecotourism pro-
ride scooters, the message resonating with how grammes include those that minimise the nega-
locals saw themselves. tive aspects of conventional tourism on the
UNWTO predicts that there will be 1.8 billion environment and enhance the cultural integrity of
arrivals globally by 2030, and that growth of local people. Therefore, in addition to evaluating
international tourism arrivals in emerging econo- environmental and cultural factors, an integral
mies will grow at double the pace of developed part of ecotourism is the promotion of recycling,
nations. Developed nations will see arrivals from energy efficiency, water conservation and cre-
emerging economies fuelling their growth; but as ation of economic opportunities for local com-
knowledge of adventure tourism options in these munities. For these reasons, ecotourism often
destinations is currently limited, there is a need to appeals to advocates of environmental and social
invest in building their markets—and this is cur- responsibility. It has three central principles: it is
rently happening. non-consumptive/non-extractive, it creates an
ecological conscience and it holds ecocentric
values and ethics in relation to nature. Lane
1.5 Ecotourism (2013) outlines the related types of niche tour-
ism. He defines adventure tourism as physical
Much of ecotourism is commercial outdoor rec- outdoor activities such as snorkelling, diving or
reation, and this has been discussed in much skydiving, where operators may not necessarily
detail by Buckley (2004, 2006, 2010). Ecotourism be operating in a sustainable manner or provid-
is a form of tourism that involves visiting fragile, ing education. Cultural tourism relates to the dis-
pristine and relatively undisturbed natural areas, covery of the cultural heritage of the destination,
intended as a low-impact and often small-scale such as learning from a local artist, and the focus
alternative to standard commercial mass tourism. is not on nature or wildlife. Green tourism applies
It is defined as responsible travel to natural areas to any tourism activity or facility operating in an
that conserves the environment, sustains the environmentally friendly way, incorporating
well- being of the local people, and involves renewable energy use or composting. Lodges
interpretation and education (TIES 2015, www. may be owned by a large corporation or lack a
ecotourism.org/news/ties-announces-ecotour- focus on conservation and education. Nature
ism-principles-revision). Its purpose may be to tourism is where wildlife is viewed in its natural
educate the traveller, to provide funds for eco- habitat, such as from jungle lodges in the Amazon
logical conservation, to directly benefit the eco- or cruise-only ships in Antarctica. These trips
nomic development and political empowerment may not have an educational component and are
1.6 Other Popular Forms of Tourism that Share Characteristics with Adventure Tourism 7
make the conservation of natural resources ben- a US$263 billion global market. In 2014, tour
eficial to local people. Alternatively, ecotourism operators noted that the top four trends in adven-
is travelling to relatively undisturbed or uncon- ture tourism were the softening of adventure
taminated natural areas with the specific objec- travel, customisation of trip experiences, multi-
tive of studying, admiring and enjoying the generational groups and cultural experiences. In
scenery and its wild plants and animals, as well other words, the trends indicate the broadening of
as any existing cultural manifestations (both past adventure as a choice of travel by the larger mar-
and present) found in these areas (Ceballos- ket. This data came from more than 300 compa-
Lascurain 1996). nies in sixty-nine countries. Governments
Geotourism is defined as tourism that sus- acknowledge this trend as well. Before 2007,
tains or enhances the geographical character of a 52% of tourism boards surveyed (ninety-one in
place: its environment, culture, aesthetics, heri- total) noted that they did not recognise adventure
tage and the well-being of its residents. tourism as a stand-alone sector in their destina-
Nature-based tourism is the segment in the tion. That number sharply decreased to a mere
tourism market in which people travel with the 8% in 2011 out of the same group of tourism
primary purpose of visiting a natural destination boards/ministries.
(Kuenzin and McNeeley 2008).
Nature tourism is travel to unspoiled places
to experience and enjoy nature (Christ et al. 1.7 Concluding Remarks
2003).
Wildlife tourism is based on encounters with The main aim of this book is to discuss how a
non-domesticated (non-human) animals in either wide range of recreational adventure activities
the animals’ natural environment or in captivity. can have an impact on the environment and how
It includes activities historically classified as the activities are associated with an important
‘non-consumptive’ as well as those that involve and growing branch of the tourist industry, adven-
killing or capturing animals (Higginbottom ture tourism. Environmental impacts are identi-
2004). Swarbrooke et al. (2003) provide a fied and possible management and education
detailed chapter on this topic as one aspect of approaches to minimise these impacts are dis-
adventure tourism. cussed in a series of chapters from various world
There are also some obscure forms of adven- regions, ranging from the polar Antarctic, through
ture tourism, including disaster and ghetto tour- the Arctic islands of Svalbard, Iceland, Greenland
ism, spiritual tourism and even ethno-tourism, and the Franz Josef Land archipelago to the
where indigenous peoples are observed. The lat- North American Arctic region of Alaska, the
ter is controversial because it can bring indige- Canadian Arctic and the Russian continental
nous peoples into contact with diseases to which Arctic, which includes the Kamchatka peninsula.
they have no immunity, and there is always the Adventure tourism in the world’s high mountain
possible degradation or destruction of a unique regions is considered in relation to the Himalayas,
culture or language. the Andes and some of the East African mountain
It is important to note that none of these types ranges, whilst we complete our world survey by
of tourism, which can be included in a broad dis- including a chapter on Australia and New Zealand
cussion of adventure tourism, is mutually exclu- and on Scotland. These are world regions that are
sive, and definitions can be overlapping. These important in the adventure tourism industry, and
‘brands’ all have a specific or even niche market where the authors have research experience and
value, because they resonate with a particular have travelled extensively. This detailed regional
segment of consumers. approach to the environmental impacts of adven-
Adventure tourism used to be a relatively ture tourism on a world scale is a major and up-
fringe or small niche of the overall tourism sec- to-date contribution to the literature. For example,
tor, but today it has become more mainstream as in Swarbrooke et al. (2003) there is only a brief
References 9
Fig. 2.1 Antarctica from NASA’s Blue Marble dataset. Source: Blue Marble dataset, https://visibleearth.nasa.gov/
view_cat.php?category1D=1484. (Photo: Dave Pape)
Fig. 2.2 Ocean Endeavour in Paradise Harbour, a wide embayment behind Lemaire and Byde Islands, indenting the
west coast of Graham Land. (Photo: Copyright M. J. Hambrey)
Since the inception of the IAATO in 1991, since 1989. About fifty of these sites have received
records of tour itineraries and site visits have more than 100 visitors in any one season and
been continually maintained. In recent years about the same number have been visited just
these expeditions have largely been conducted once. A cursory examination of the tour data indi-
using vessels carrying from six to 500 passengers cates that visits are concentrated at fewer than
(Fig. 2.2). The ships sail primarily to the Antarctic thirty-five sites. Fewer than ten sites receive
Peninsula region. Some itineraries also include around 10,000 visitors each season. The Peninsula
South Georgia and the Falkland Islands. These is an appealing destination as it is close to South
voyages generally depart from Ushuaia America, has a relatively mild climate and little
(Argentina), Port Stanley (Falkland Islands) and, sea ice, hosts multiple scientific stations and con-
to a lesser extent, from Punta Arenas (Chile), tains a diverse array of wildlife and scenery
Buenos Aires (Argentina) or Puerto Madryn (Farreny et al. 2011). From 2003–2009, the
(Argentina). Committee for Environmental Protection (CEP)’s
By far the most visited area of Antarctica is the tourism study noted that the top twenty most vis-
Antarctic Peninsula (see Fig. 2.4A for the main ited Antarctic landing sites were all in the Antarctic
locations in Antarctica and major bases). Molenaar Peninsula (2012). Activity is highly concentrated:
(2005) puts the figure at 95%. According to among these top twenty sites, 54% of visitor land-
IAATO records (IAATO website), approximately ings occurred at just seven of them. The top five
200 sites, including twenty research stations, have visited sites were: Whalers Bay, Port Lockroy,
been visited in the Antarctic Peninsula region Half Moon Island, Neko Harbor and Cuverville
Fig. 2.3 (a) Overall change in vessel traffic from Island, (6) Petermann Island, (7) Brown Station,
the 1993–1994 season to the 2012–2013 season, (8) Jougla Point, (9) Danco Island, (10) Brown
and (b) overall change in vessel traffic from the Bluff, (11) Vernadsky Station, (12) Telefon Bay,
2008–2009 season to the 2012–2013 season (the (13) Barrientos Island, Aitcho Islands, (14) Orne
five seasons following the Lynch et al. 2010 analy- Harbour, (15) Yankee Harbour, (16) Mikkelsen
sis). For orientation, the top twenty-five most pop- Harbour, (17) Damoy Point/Dorian Bay, (18)
ular landing sites (in the 2013–2014 season) are Paradise Bay, (19) Pléneau Island, (20) Hannah
indicated by numbers (in order of rank): (1) Neko Point, (21) Port Charcot, (22) Great Wall Station,
Harbour, (2) Cuverville Island, (3) Goudier Island, (23) Yalour Islands, (24) Waterboat Point/Gonzalez
(4) Half Moon Island, (5) Whalers Bay, Deception Videla Station, (25) Bellingshausen Station
2.2 Definition of Antarctic Tourism 15
Fig. 2.4 (A) Emperor penguins, the only animals to Gentoo penguin. (From: www.dreamstime.com/publ-
breed on Antarctica. (Author: Guiseppe Zibordi, NOAA domain-image-frees) (D) Adélie penguins and tourist
Corps Collection). (B) Adélie penguin. (Photo: Penny Zodiac at Bourdin Island. (Photo: Copyright M. J.
Scott (PDP) http://publicdomainphotography.com). (C) Hambrey)
16 2 Adventure Tourism in Antarctica
Island, each of which averaged more than 10,000 desire to visit as a tourist, to see the wildlife and
visitors per season during 2003–2009. In contrast, dramatic scenery, and to experience (arguably)
the most heavily visited site in the Ross Sea, Cape Earth’s last remaining wilderness (Bowerman
Royds, averaged 320 tourists per season from 2012). Modern Antarctic ecotourism has
2005–2011. It appears that tourists have visited increased rapidly since its beginning in the
over 300 sites since records began, and 100–200 1960s. Between 1992 and 2002, the annual
sites are visited regularly each season (Tin et al. number of tourists more than doubled. In the
2008), which may serve to destroy the very wil- Antarctic summer of 2000–2001, approximately
derness that many tourists to Antarctica are hop- 12,250 people walked on the Antarctic conti-
ing to experience. However, Naveen and Lynch nent, and in 2006 this number reached 35,000.
(2011) have produced a detailed documentation of The 2007–2008 season showed huge growth
sites visited by tourists to assist in the implemen- and marked the busiest season to date, with
tation of the 1991 Protocol on Environmental 46,265 reported tourists visiting Antarctica.
Protection to the Antarctic Treaty, which is an Actual numbers of visitors may be higher, as
excellent compendium for the start of manage- reported numbers come from members of
ment by tour companies of their visitors and by IAATO only. The reported numbers decreased
the countries that administer these locations. after that season, concurrent with the global
financial crisis and the ban on heavy fuel car-
riage by ships in Antarctic waters, impacting the
2.3 Growing Numbers 2011–2012 season, but numbers have been ris-
ing again since. Of the estimated 44,000
In recent decades, tourism has increased signifi- Antarctic tourists in the 2016–2017 season,
cantly in Antarctica. It is no longer only science 12,400 were expected to be involved in site
and exploration that draw people to visit, but a landings.
2.4 A Summary of IAATO Member Antarctic Tourism Trends 17
Each person landing on Antarctica has some Most tourism is ship-based, but in recent years
form of impact on the environment, such as the new market segments have come online, such as
inadvertent dispersal of seeds of non-native, or airborne and land-based tourism. The Antarctic
alien, species, disruption to wildlife and foot- Treaty System (ATS) and the Antarctic Treaty
prints. The number of tourists in the Antarctic Consultative Parties (ATCPs) formally regulate
Treaty area is estimated at three times the num- tourism, and the 1991 Environmental Protocol,
ber of National Antarctic Program (NAP) per- known as the Madrid Protocol, provides the regu-
sonnel during the 2016–2017 summer season. latory framework for human activities in the
There is some degree of overlap between tourist region, including tourism. ATCP decisions are
activity and personnel involved in NAPs, such implemented through national legislation of flag
as scientists taking part in recreational activities states. IAATO handles day-to-day management
while on the continent. In turn, some NAPs sup- of tourism, working alongside the ATCPs and
port the tourist industry through the accommo- other organisations. Maritime law also guides
dation of tourists and the establishment of some activity, given the ship-based nature of the
tourist facilities, visitor centres and souvenir majority of tourism (Jabour 2014).
shops on the Antarctic continent (Bastmeijer The main Antarctic tourist markets, histori-
et al. 2008). All forms of transport into the cally found in North America, Europe and
Antarctic Treaty area also impact the environ- Australia, are evolving as well. Not surprisingly,
ment and have the potential to cause catastro- considering the costs involved in Antarctic tour-
phe. The majority of travel for tourism is by ism, these regions represent some of the wealthi-
ship, which has a significantly lower carbon est countries in the world. It is believed that
footprint than air travel. Antarctic tour companies will continue to merge
One recent study suggests a conservative or may be taken over/bought out by larger travel
projection of growth to 120,000–160,000 visi- companies which have access to more extensive
tors to Antarctica annually by 2060 (Woehler resources for marketing Antarctic itineraries
et al. 2014). Considering the historical increase (Lamers et al. 2008). Demand for global tourism
in Antarctic tourism, recovery to nearly double products is already expanding considerably in
the previous peak over the next fifty years seems China, Russia, India and other growing econo-
a reasonable forecast. An increase in the number mies, and this trend is expected to continue. The
of vessels travelling to the area is also likely, 2013–2014 season saw an increase in the number
particularly large vessels, as well as increased of Chinese visitors, making up a total of 9% of all
numbers of tourist flights, to more areas, and visitors, while ten years prior, this population
over greater periods of time each year (Woehler represented only 0.2% of all visitors. This puts
et al. 2014). Thus, demand for Antarctic tourism China just behind the USA (33%) and Australia
is expected to increase in the coming years. This (11%), and ahead of Germany (8%) and the UK
is anticipated in traditional markets especially, (8%) (IAATO 2014).
as a result of growing media attention, greater
affluence, increased spare time, urbanisation,
ageing populations, and the growing global 2.4 Summary of IAATO
A
interest in ecotourism and adventure tourism Member Antarctic Tourism
(Lonely Planet 2013). The popularity of the Trends
region can be seen in the more mainstream
travel media, which is likely to contribute to The total number of tourists in the Antarctic
even greater interest. Lonely Planet listed Treaty area has followed an overall increasing
Antarctica as number two of the ten best desti- trend driven mainly by a recent sharp increase in
nations for travel in 2014. Referred to as the ship-to-shore landings. With more people present
adventure of a lifetime, Lonely Planet describes in the area, the sense of remoteness could be
Antarctica as a pristine continent with abundant compromised. Due to a lack of studies carried out
wildlife and majestic landscapes. on the impacts of landings, their cumulative
18 2 Adventure Tourism in Antarctica
effects, such as the introduction of invasive spe- the tourists visiting the Antarctic Treaty area are
cies via mechanisms such as ship fouling and doing so because they care about the environment
wastewater discharge, and the continued distur- (Vereda 2016), so they would likely choose opera-
bance to penguin nesting sites, are not fully quan- tors endorsed by IAATO for their safe, low-impact
tified. The need for data on these impacts will and environmental sustainability measures.
become more important as we face the possibility
of increased numbers, especially in high traffic
areas such as the Antarctic Peninsula (Haase 2.5 Types of Tourism
et al. 2009). It would be appropriate for tour
operators to be levied to provide funding for 2.5.1 Cruise Ship Tourism
research to be carried out, providing data and the
analysis of that data, on the impact of their indus- Currently the cruise ship industry is managed
try on the Antarctic Treaty area. through the ATS, non-governmental organisa-
Looking over a longer term at the number of tions (NGOs) (self-regulation), guidelines, vari-
passenger landings, there has been an overall ous treaties and a series of international laws
increase from 1995 in the past twenty years, (Bauer and Dowling 2006). There is a difference
although there was a decline between 1999 and of opinion within the academic community on
2003, and again between 2007 and 2010, the latter whether the Antarctic cruise ship industry is
being the result of the economic recession and a working well not only to meet the needs of the
ban on heavy fuel use by the International Maritime cruise ship operators and their clients, but for the
Organization (IMO). The potential for further greater wellbeing of the continent as a whole and
increase is limited by IAATO regulations in terms the rest of the world, and whether it is being man-
of the number of landings per site, the sites used aged sustainably for future generations. It appears
and the protocol that must be followed when visit- from the literature reviewed that this difference
ing sites designated as Antarctic Specially of opinion depends on what discipline the writers
Protected Areas (ASPAs) and/or Antarctic come from. As a broad generalisation, it appears
Specially Managed Areas (ASMAs). The growth that the tourism/science-based authors, such as
in tourist numbers and in the variety of their activi- Liggett et al. (2011) and Bauer and Dowling
ties raises concerns of potential overuse and (2006), believe strongly in self-regulation,
increases the threat of impact on wildlife, the natu- namely by the IAATO, and have confidence in
ral environment and even cultural heritage. the self-imposed management of Antarctica
Since 2004, 98.8% of Antarctic tourists have through the ATS. Although they acknowledge
travelled to the area via ship (IAATO 2017). The that more regulations will be required in the
trend of increasing numbers of operators in the future, there is not much discussion about the
market has the potential to create tension in the cur- realities of which laws are working or not work-
rent IAATO member system. Haase et al. (2009) ing and the validity of these laws within the inter-
discussed a recent case in which a group of opera- national community.
tors with ships of carrying capacity greater than In contrast, Molenaar (2005) and Wright
500 wanted to become members of IAATO. Initially, (2008), who are more legally or politically moti-
IAATO declined the request, but then reversed its vated, appear to think that it is only as a result of
decision after the operators threatened to create luck, or a lack of evidence to the contrary, that the
their own self-organised group. IAATO felt it was region remains largely free of the negative
more important to maintain a united membership impacts of tourism. These authors are often criti-
to prevent becoming fractured over less important cal of other authors, preferring to plan for the
issues. There is always the potential for operators expected disaster than wait for it to happen and
to work outside of any regulating body, but it is clean up the mess afterwards. There are also a
hoped that market demands for safety and sustain- growing number of knowledgeable authors who
ability would not support such ventures. Many of are taking a more moderate approach in their
2.5 Types of Tourism 19
writing, such as Haase et al. (2009), who are of once the fee for the flag has been paid. It is also
the opinion that a middle road between the laxity the case that in this context of self-regulation, all
of self-regulation and strictly codified regulation parties must trust the morals and truthfulness of
needs to be found as the best answer to the sover- the cruise ship operators when told that there
eignty issue. have been no significant incidents or accidents in
Wright (2008) highlights the seriousness of the Southern Ocean.
legal issues arising from the Antarctic cruise Vessels registered with flags of convenience
industry and points out that most of the interna- states account for more than 50% of all tourism
tional treaties, regulations and laws that are appli- vessels visiting Antarctica. Flags of convenience
cable to the sea are not applicable to Antarctic countries are notorious for their lack of interest in
waters. This is because the region does not fit the enforcing international conventions obligations
definition of areas governed by such treaties, reg- upon oceangoing commercial ships. Critics feel
ulations and laws since it does not fall under the these nations are not only reluctant to discipline
jurisdiction of a single sovereign state. This is major contributors to their economies; but even
compounded by sovereignty disputes and the more alarming, they simply may not have the
very real fact that many of the world’s states do resources to effectively enforce regulations or
not recognise sovereignty claims by other states. even punish polluters (Wright 2008). It would
States that do not recognise Antarctic claims to seem an appropriate time to ask whether an oper-
sovereignty treat the Antarctic waters as part of ator that is flying a flag of convenience should be
the high seas. This creates further legal complexi- considered as trustworthy as an operator that has
ties. Molenaar (2005) also shares Wright’s con- a flag from a country which actively involves
cerns in this area. Wright (2008) further highlights itself in matters in the Southern Ocean and
that despite sovereignty claims, much of the Antarctica. Molenaar (2005) highlights that in
Southern Ocean is beyond any of the claimant legal terms this situation is in many ways similar
states’ jurisdiction. Included in this are the land to that of the law of the high seas, whose regime
and maritime zones beyond the coastal state relies on the freedom of the high seas and the
jurisdiction of Africa, Australia and South primacy of flag state jurisdiction. He believes that
America, and claims on the Antarctic continent. regulation of human activities in Antarctica and
This is in addition to the areas adjacent to its surrounding waters is weakened by the
unclaimed portions of the Antarctic continent. In absence of undisputed sovereignty over the
these areas the flag state of a cruise ship has Antarctic continent.
exclusive jurisdiction (Wright 2008). She also The issue at the core of all these authors’ con-
highlights that when a commercial cruise ship cerns is that of legal liability when there is an
navigates international waters, it must be regis- accident in Antarctica. The issue of liability in the
tered with a country and have that state confer Antarctic Treaty System has been debated for
nationality on the ship. While on the high seas, years and has not as yet been comprehensively
the flag state retains exclusive legislative and addressed, further highlighting the inability of
enforcement jurisdiction. the ATS to regulate these very serious issues and
The cruise industry tends to flag its ships with respond in a timely manner?
states allowing open registries, called ‘flags of
convenience’ (Wright 2008). These are usually 2.5.1.1 Industry Self-Regulation
flagged in developing third world countries. Industry self-regulation has played an important
Non-US flag registries dominate the cruise regis- role in the management of the Antarctic cruise
try, as US laws are considered to be some of the industry to date. Recognising the potential envi-
most restrictive and punitive in the world. This ronmental impacts that increasing rate of tourism
causes further concern as states that issue cruise could cause, seven private tour operators joined
ships with a ‘flag of convenience’ often have no together in 1991 to form the International
further interest in the activities of the operator(s) Association of Antarctica Tour Operators. There
Another random document with
no related content on Scribd:
The Project Gutenberg eBook of The Southern
Literary Messenger, Vol. II., No. 3, February, 1836
This ebook is for the use of anyone anywhere in the United States
and most other parts of the world at no cost and with almost no
restrictions whatsoever. You may copy it, give it away or re-use it
under the terms of the Project Gutenberg License included with this
ebook or online at www.gutenberg.org. If you are not located in the
United States, you will have to check the laws of the country where
you are located before using this eBook.
Author: Various
Language: English
EVERY DEPARTMENT OF
RICHMOND:
T. W. WHITE, PUBLISHER AND PROPRIETOR.
1835-6.
BALLAD: by W. M. R.
THE COUSIN OF THE MARRIED, and the Cousin of the Dead: from the
French
THE ILIAD
PALÆSTINE: by P.
MARTORELLI
NEW TESTAMENT
SONG: by M. M.
LIBERIAN LITERATURE
STATIUS
LIONEL GRANBY, Chapter VIII: by Theta
GREECE: by Eliza
CRITICAL NOTICES
PAUL ULRIC, or the Adventures of an Enthusiast: by Morris
Mattson, Esq.
MARTIN'S GAZETTEER: by Joseph Martin
ROSE-HILL: by a Virginian
CHIEF JUSTICE MARSHALL
An Eulogy on the Life and Character of John Marshall: by
Horace Binney
A Discourse on the Life, &c. of John Marshall, L.L.D.: by Joseph
Story, L.L.D.
An Oration on the Life and Character of John Marshall: by
Edgar Snowden
THE CONFESSIONS OF EMILIA HARRINGTON: by Lambert A. Wilmer
THE AMERICAN IN ENGLAND by Lieutenant Slidell
CONTI THE DISCARDED: with Other Tales and Fancies: by Henry F.
Chorley
NOBLE DEEDS OF WOMAN
RIENZI, THE LAST OF THE TRIBUNES: by Edward Lytton Bulwer
ANIMAL AND VEGETABLE PHYSIOLOGY, considered with reference to
Natural Theology: by Peter Mark Roget, M.D.
CAREY'S AUTOBIOGRAPHY
AUTOGRAPHY
SOUTHERN LITERARY MESSENGER.
SELECTION IN READING.
"'It requires courage indeed' (as Helvetius has remarked,) 'to remain
ignorant of those useless subjects which are generally valued:' but it
is a courage necessary to men who either love the truth, or aspire to
establish a permanent reputation."2
2 Philosophy of the Human Mind, Vol. I.
NO. X.—(Continued.)
A few days after, the same proposition was conveyed more distinctly
to the Dey through the Sardinian Consul, with an assurance on the
part of the Admiral, that his Government no longer expected apology
or reparation, but wished merely to place affairs between the two
nations on their former footing. Hussein however remained firm in his
refusal to make any advances, only telling the Consul, that after
Peace had been signed at Algiers, he might perhaps to please the
Ministers, send them an Ambassador. The French Government
finding its recommendations thus treated, authorized the Sardinian
Consul to inform the Dey, that no farther overtures would be made
by it towards reconciliation, and that measures would be soon taken
to obtain complete satisfaction for the injury committed against
France. Hussein coolly answered, that he had men and ammunition
in abundance, and that he preferred the fortune of war to making or
seeming to make any apology.
The destruction of three Algerine feluccas of six guns each, was the
next event worthy of note in the history of the war. These vessels
were returning from a successful cruise and endeavoring to enter the
harbor of Algiers on the 1st of October 1828, when they were
discovered and chased into the adjacent Bay of Sidi Ferruch. The
prize was soon recaptured; the other vessels took refuge close to the
shore, under a small and ruinous battery mounting twelve guns,
where they were attacked by the whole of the blockading squadron.
After the first fire, the feluccas and the battery were abandoned;
boats were then sent by the Admiral to destroy the vessels, which
having been effected the fire was continued on the battery until it
was nearly demolished. The loss on the side of the Algerines is
believed to have been very small; the French had six men killed and
seventeen wounded, by the bursting of a gun on board the Admiral's
ship the Provence. This trifling affair was made the subject of a
special report by the Minister of the Marine to the King of France,
which may be found at length in the Moniteur of the 17th of October;
it was so far important, as it enabled His Majesty to say in his
Address to the Legislative Chambers in January following, that
—"most striking examples had already taught the Algerines, that it
was neither easy nor safe to brave the vigilance of his ships."
The Dey had several times expressed to the Sardinian Consul, his
admiration of the form and sailings of a brig called the Alerte
belonging to the blockading squadron; something in his manner at
length induced the Consul to inform M. de la Bretonniere, that
possibly His Highness might be inclined to negotiate for peace, in the
manner desired by the French Government, if it were understood
that the brig would be presented to him after the signature of the
treaty. The Admiral eagerly accepted this overture as he considered
it, and authorized the Consul to say in general terms, that he had no
doubt the Government of France would willingly accede to the Dey's
wishes in this particular, if an arrangement of the difficulties between
the two countries could be effected. Hussein's reply was
encouraging, and the Admiral in consequence sailed for France to
receive in person the instructions of his Government. He found the
Ministers anxious to have the affair peaceably adjusted; they were
ready to treat with the Dey provided it could be made to appear that
he had himself proposed the negotiation, and were willing to promise
the brig in return for the mission of an Algerine Ambassador to Paris.
The Admiral was accordingly instructed to assure the Dey, that if he
would comply with this formality, peace would be immediately signed
and the brig would be presented to him; but in order that no proofs
might exist of the advances made by the French Ministry, the whole
negotiation at Algiers was to be conducted verbally, through an
interpreter chosen for the purpose from the School of Oriental
Languages at Paris.
In the mean time the French Ministry had taken a most serious
determination. The insult offered by the Dey in firing upon M. de la
Bretonniere, was concealed from the public as completely as
possible; no mention of it was made in the Moniteur, yet it finally
became known, and the opposition press of Paris eagerly seized the
opportunity, to vilify the hated Ministry of Polignac for delaying to
avenge the insulted honor of France. In this condition of things it
became absolutely necessary for the Government to take some
decisive step towards a conclusion of the war, in order to relieve
itself from a heavy and increasing burthen of popular odium on this
account. To effect this purpose, two plans were proposed in the
Ministerial Council. Count de Bourmont the bold and active chief of
the War Department, was in favor of an expedition sent directly from
France, against the capital city of the offending Sovereign. Prince
Polignac the head of the Ministry, was doubtful of the propriety of