Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 12

Page 1

June 2014 Issue 145

Adili
Public procurement in Kenya
Cash cow for the corrupt or enabler for public service
delivery?

By Debra Gichio in secrecy, inefficiency, corruption and


undercutting which resulted or will result
In this issue... What do major government projects
like the Anglo Leasing, National
in huge amounts of resources going to
waste.
Social Security Fund (NSSF) funded
‘Uwajibikaji Pamoja’: Giving voice to Tassia II estate project, Independent It is estimated that weaknesses in public
Turkana residents - Page 6 and 7 Electoral and Boundaries Commission procurement, including vulnerability to
(IEBC) Biometric voter register/ voter corruption, are a global problem with
identification kit, Laptop Project and approximately $400 billion (Kshs 34.9
Advocacy and Legal Advisory Centre Standard Gauge Railway have in trillion) reported as being lost to bribery
helps Kwale residents recover common? They have all been in the and corruption in procurement globally.
community land - Page 8 limelight for all the wrong reasons.
In 2007 the Public Procurement
All the mentioned procurement Oversight Authority (PPOA) estimated
Gift giving to public officers as a processes were either marred by huge that procuring entities were buying at
catalyst for corruption - Page 9 variations between the price announced an average of 60% above the prevailing
at opening of the tender and the price at market price, an indicator that public
which the tender was awarded or failure procurement in Kenya does not receive
Public inquiry into the Anglo Leasing to ensure due diligence in the tendering the benefit of competitive procurement.
scandal long overdue - Page 10 process. Simply put, the procurement
process in all instances was shrouded Story continued on page 2 and 3


Page 2

What is public procurement? A brief history of public


procurement in Kenya
By definition, public procurement
is the acquisition of any type of Accountability in the public
works, assets, services and goods procurement system in Kenya in
by purchase, rental, lease, license, the past decade, has undergone
tenancy, franchise, or by any other significant changes.
contractual means1.
From a system with no regulations
Procurement is a key economic in the 1960s, to a system regulated
activity of any government that by Treasury Circulars in the 1970s,
significantly impacts how taxpayers’ 1980s and 1990s, and finally the
money is spent and is a function introduction of the Public Procurement
that remains most vulnerable to and Disposal Act (PPDA) of 2005
corruption. and the Procurement Regulations of
The Public 2006 setting new standards for public
Ordinarily, the Kenya Government procurement in Kenya .
Procurement does not use state-owned enterprises
Oversight Authority to manufacture goods and services A brief history of public
that public authorities require to procurement in Kenya
(PPOA) and the Public perform their duties. The government
therefore has to purchase various Accountability in the public
Procurement Review goods and services from the supply procurement system in Kenya in
Board (PPRB) market. the past decade, has undergone
significant changes.
This purchasing process is
The Public Procurement and regulated by the procurement law From a system with no regulations
Disposal Act further provides for and regulations that provide for the in the 1960s, to a system regulated
the establishment of the two key conclusion of contracts between by Treasury Circulars in the 1970s,
institutions in the procurement system: public entities and the providers 1980s and 1990s, and finally the
The Public Procurement Oversight of goods, works and services that introduction of the Public Procurement
Authority (PPOA) and the Public set out required standards and and Disposal Act (PPDA) of 2005
Procurement Complaints Review and procedures, oversight transparency and the Procurement Regulations of
Appeals Board (PPRB). and accountability mechanisms. 2006 setting new standards for public
procurement in Kenya3.
The Public Procurement Oversight Control mechanisms in
Authority’s key functions include: public procurement in Kenya The Public Procurement and
Disposal Act, 2005
• To provide oversight on public To ensure transparency and
procurement in Kenya. accountability the integrity and The purpose of the Public Procurement
• To report on and facilitate the transparency of a public procurement and Disposal Act as set out in the
implementation of the Public system is premised on a number legislation is to establish procedures
Procurement and Disposal Act of control mechanisms. These for procurement
• To build capacity and advice mechanisms include an effective
procuring entities on public control and audit system, an and the disposal of unserviceable,
procurement. efficient appeals mechanism, a obsolete or surplus stores and
comprehensive information sharing equipment by public entities to achieve
The Public Procurement Complaints system enabling civil society and the following objectives4:
Review and Appeal Board on the interested stakeholders to conduct
other hand has the role of reviewing social audits, and effective ethics and • To maximise economy and
procurement disputes as may arise anti-corruption measures. Without efficiency;
from time to time. such control mechanisms, flaws in
the procurement system may not be
detected and addressed2.
1 Section 3(1) of Public Procurement and
Disposal Act, 2005 3 Assessment of the Procurement
2 Assessment of the Procurement System in Kenya, OECD and Public Procure-
System in Kenya, OECD and Public Procure- ment Oversight Authority, October 2007pg 3
ment Oversight Authority, October 2007 pg18 4 PPPDA, Section 2
Page 3
Page 3

• To promote competition and Cases of procurement malpractice Further, the procurement Act must be
ensure that competitors are including Anglo Leasing, the National amended to conform to the Constitu-
treated fairly; Hospital Insurance Fund civil servants’ tion (Article 227) which states “When
• To promote the integrity and medical cover scheme, IEBC BVR a State organ or any other public entity
fairness of those procedures; kits, the NSSF Tassia estate scandal, contracts for goods or services, it shall
• To increase transparency and the standard gauge railway are among do so in accordance with a system that
accountability in those procedures; those that have dominated the media is fair, equitable, transparent, competi-
• To increase public confidence in and public discourse. tive and cost-effective’ and provides
those procedures; and for preference in the allocation of con-
• To facilitate the promotion of local These scandals among others point tracts.”
industry and economic development. to inherent weaknesses in the law
that that must be addressed through The writer is the Governance
the amendment of the law that allows and Policy Programme
However despite the enactment of the corruption to thrive and defeat the Coordinator
Public Procurement and Disposal Act, objectives of procurement.
2005 and operationalisation of various
regulations , public procurement in Ke-
nya continues to be marred by corrup-
tion scandals and losses amounting to Public procurement in Kenya: An infograph
billions of shillings.
Page 4

Public participation and civilian


oversight: The key to improving integrity in
public procurement
By Ivy Muriungi

Evidence shows that an effective


procurement system could save the
government approximately 25% of
its expenditure. This is a significant
amount considering the fact that public
procurement accounts for 11% of the
GDP1.

Public procurement in Kenya is guided


by several laws enacted to weed out
inefficiencies in the procurement process,
remove patterns of abuse, and the failure
of the public purchaser to obtain adequate procurement is responsive to their needs, Integrity pacts
value in return for the expenditure of make suggestions for improvement or Integrity pacts are another tool used to
public funds. Such laws include the objections and enhance transparency in facilitate public oversight in procurement.
Public Procurement and Disposal Act, the process. Integrity pacts are a form of contract
2005, Public Finance Management Act, signed between an authority and the
2012, the Public Officers’ Ethics Act, 2003 Access to information bidding candidates. The pact binds the
among others. The objective of having However, public participation can only be parties to put in place reciprocal controls
these laws has never been fully achieved effective when the public has access to to prevent any form of corruption between
in practice. relevant information in order to objectively the parties.
evaluate procurement. Information should
Beyond being a constitutional requirement, be made available in a simple and easily The pact also creates measures for
public participation and civilian oversight understandable manner. In countries grievance redress which can be used
remains one of the most powerful tools in with advanced use of ICT, e-procurement by the bidders or citizens. The overall
demanding for increasing transparency, systems have been used to publicly effect of the pact is that it allows citizens,
accountability and efficiency in public disclose information and users can businesses and civil society to monitor the
procurement. compare prices and terms. procurement process and evaluate the
performance of the contract.
The procurement cycle In Kenya, the tenders website http://
There is opportunity for public participation www.tenders.go.ke/ can be expanded The integrity pact concept has been
in the entire procurement cycle. The to provide additional information. Local tested in public procurement in Rwanda
cycle typically involves a planning and solutions such as notice boards, local between 2012 and 2013, and findings
preparation stage, advertisement, radio stations and community forums indicated that indeed the integrity pact
evaluation, award and post-contracting can be used to increase reach of such improved transparency and accountability
evaluation. Citizens can detect, prevent information. in procurement and contract performance.
and reduce wastage and corruption in It also provided room for citizens
public procurement by getting involved Further, in order for citizens to optimally to participate in the process, which
throughout the whole cycle. use the information they acquire, they stakeholders felt ought to be expanded.
would require a medium to report
Public hearings grievances be it at the authority itself or The writer is a former intern at the
Public hearings are one way of other responsible agencies such as the Governance and Policy Programme,
encouraging citizen participation. Citizens Public Procurement Oversight Authority TI-Kenya.
and experts can discuss the planned (PPOA). It naturally follows that such
procurement, assess the needs of the agencies should be easily accessible and
intended beneficiaries to ensure that have a clear and user friendly process
with subsequent feedback.
1 Bernard H. and Simon E. 2005.
International Cooperation and the Reform
of Public Procurement Policies. World Bank
Policy Research Working Paper 3720
Page 5

Weaknesses in the present public


procurement regime in Kenya and
what needs to be improved
By Elijah Ambasa and Disposal Act, 2005 lacks in these provisions on access to justice, fair trial
principles comprehensively as well as its and judicial independence. In ensuring
Nearly all grand corruption scandals in enforcement. access to justice, it is necessary to
Kenya had a public procurement and amend the law to provide for a reasonable
disposal of assets component. The legal framework to guide procurement application of fees and the removal of
at both levels of government must also non-monetary barriers to access. The
It is estimated that 25% of public comply with the constitutional provision of law also ought to ensure the procedures
expenditure could be saved through the non-interference in financial management. of the Public Procurement Complaints
proper implementation of procurement This principle has been recognised by the Review and Appeals Board conform to
and disposal of assets laws. A reform of the Public Finance Management Act, 2012. the principles of fair trial as espoused
legal framework for public procurement is by Article 50 of the Constitution where
indeed long overdue. The need therefore, is not to realign the applicable.
Public Procurement and Disposal Act,
Article 227 of the Constitution 2005 by making amendments to include Some procurement procedures also need
of Kenya 2010 county governments but to realign the to conform to the constitutional requirement
The Constitution of Kenya 2010 sets new procurement framework to be in line with for fair administrative action. Beyond the
standards with regard to procurement. the Constitution of Kenya 2010 and post- Constitutional push for reforms in the
Article 227 requires public procurement promulgation legislation such as the Public procurement law, there are real legislative
systems to be fair, equitable, transparent, Finance Management Act 2012 which gaps that need to be addressed to provide
competitive and cost effective. Article also provides guidance on the running of mechanisms for emergency procurement.
227 also requires Parliament to pass county and national governments. Such gaps increase the time spent in
procurement regulations that will provide responding to emergencies; particularly in
for preferential allotment of contracts, Affirmative action for youth, pharmaceutical procurement and disaster
protection of disadvantaged categories women and people living with response.
of persons and sanctions against non- disabilities
performing contractors, and those guilty The requirement to protect disadvantaged Stronger enforcement
of corrupt practices, tax violations and groups is affirmed by Article 21 of the mechanisms
labour laws. Constitution of Kenya. This article calls The Public Procurement and Disposal
for affirmative action for vulnerable Act, 2005 also fails to provide strong
New realities people who may not meet the competitive enforcement mechanisms, resulting
Above and beyond the provisions of standards of procurement regimes for to non-compliance with the laws. This
Article 227, the procurement law needs various reasons. This includes the youth, would necessitate restructuring of the
to conform to other realities such as the women and people living with disabilities regulatory arm of the Public Procurement
devolved system of governance. This who are entitled to 30% of government Oversight Authority. While it is suggested
should be done not just through devolution procurement. that restructuring of the entire system
of the functions of oversight authorities to separate the policy making and
but also through creating a framework for Such a significant decision ought not to be regulatory arms is necessary, participants
procurement at the county level. made without a legal framework to guide at discussion forums organised by
the process. Additionally, there must be Transparency International Kenya on the
The principles enshrined in Article 227 of a balance between affirmative action amendment of the Public Procurement
the Constitution have been absent under and protection of consumer rights which and Disposal Act 2005 felt that such a
the regime of the Public Procurement and are enshrined in the Bill of Rights. This restructuring should not be used as an
Disposal Act, 2005. Article 227 provides implies some capacity building initiatives avenue to increase bureaucracy.
for a procurement regime that is fair, by oversight bodies. This would in turn It is evident that there is a need to amend
equitable, transparent, and competitive require an expansion of the mandate of the procurement laws to ensure efficiency
and cost effective. It also provides for the such oversight by law. and effectiveness in public spending.
protection or advancement of persons,
categories of persons or groups previously The procurement appeals board The writer is the Programme
disadvantaged by unfair competition or The quasi-judicial function of the Officer, Governance and Policy,
discrimination. The Public Procurement procurement appeals board is subject to TI-Kenya.
Page 6

‘Uwajibikaji Pamoja’: Giving

‘Uwajibikaji Pamoja’ brings toget


Transparency International Kenya and 13 those who attended the event. numerous aid and service delivery instituti
government and non-governmental partners in Turkana County. These include the Cou
launched a complaints referral service dubbed The creation of ‘Uwajibikaji Pamoja’ was one Government of Turkana, National Drou
‘Uwajibikaji Pamoja’ in Lodwar town, Turkana of the recommendations TI-Kenya’s 2012 Management Authority (NDMA), Ke
County in April 2014. Food Assistance Integrity Study (FAIS), National Commission on Human Rig
which identified the lack of accountability (KNCHR), Adeso – African Developm
‘Uwajibikaji Pamoja’ will enable members of mechanisms to people affected by calamities Solutions, Catholic Diocese of Lodw
the public to submit complaints or feedback such as the 2011 drought as a key challenge Helpage International, OXFAM, Internatio
concerning aid and service delivery through in humanitarian operations. This project will be Rescue Committee (IRC), Lokichog
three channels: a toll-free SMS line, a web- rolled out in Wajir and West Pokot counties in Oropoi Kakuma Development Organisa
based portal, or by filling out paper forms. the coming months. (LOKADO), Save The Children Internatio
People with no access to a mobile phone Turkana Development Organisations’ For
or internet can visit the nearest office of (TUDOF), Turkana Women Advocacy a
a participating organisation to lodge their
complaints.
“‘Uwajibikaji Development Organisation (TWADO), Wor
Vision, and Transparency International Ken
Pamoja’
The walk-in option will also allow people who will enable
cannot read or write to report their cases.
The launch was marked by a procession in members of
Lodwar town followed by a football match at the public
the prisons grounds.
to submit
The launch was preceded by a high-level complaints Turkana based football
consultative forum to showcase the initiative or feedback teams battle it out for the
top prize during a football
and give stakeholders an opportunity to
understand the system. Turkana Deputy concerning aid match organised as part of
the launch of ‘Uwajibikaji
Governor Peter Ekai Lokoel, the Chief and service Pamoja’
Executive Officer of the National Drought
Management Authority James Oduor, TI-
delivery” PHOTO/TI-Kenya
Kenya Board Member Ikal Angelei and
Executive Director Samuel Kimeu are among
Page 7 Page 7

g voice to Turkana residents


Member of TI-Kenya
Board of Directors Ms.
Ikal Angelei delivers a
speech during the ‘Uwa-
jibikaji Pamoja’ launch
ceremony

PHOTO/TI-KENYA TI-Kenya Executive


Director signs the memo-
randum of understanding
Workshop participants at during the ‘Uwajibikaji
the ‘Uwajibikaji Pamoja’ Pamoja’ launch ceremony
pre-launch stakeholders’
workshop PHOTO/TI-Kenya

PHOTO/TI-Kenya

ther
ions
unty
ught
enya
ghts
ment
war,
onal
ggio
ation
onal,
rum
and
rld
nya.

‘Uwajibikaji Pamoja’
stakeholders and members
of the public from Lodwar
town hold a procession to
mark the launch of ‘Uwa-
jibikaji Pamoja’

PHOTO/TI-Kenya
Page 8

An Advocacy and Legal


Advisory Centre Officer at a
past public forum

PHOTO /TI-Kenya

Advocacy and Legal Advisory Centre helps


Kwale residents recover community land
In 2011/2012, the community in the Shika The defunct Kwale Municipal Council also The community presented the petition
Adabu area in Kwale County suffered a allocated land that was adjacent to the to the then newly established County
double loss. They lost a community centre community centre to a private developer. Government of Kwale and local
as well as the piece of land the centre was The developer intended to build a petrol Constituency Development Fund (CDF)
built on. station on that plot in the Shika Adabu committee.
area.
The Shika Adabu area in the defunct The CDF committee which had been newly
County Council of Kwale is not Even though the community tried to installed directed that the community
demarcated. It is unalienated public engage the area Member of Parliament centre be handed over to the residents of
land and therefore no individual titles and the defunct Kwale Municipal Council the area, to be managed by the community
have been issued for it. The residents to address the issue its queries went and all the proceeds of the centre would
of this area have openly, peacefully and unattended until April 2013 when TI- be used to maintain the centre and bring
uninterruptedly lived on the land since Kenya’s Advocacy and Legal Advisory development to the community.
the 1950s and have constructed both Centre (ALAC) in Mombasa organised
permanent and semi-permanent makuti a training forum in the area on civilian The county government also revoked
houses. oversight. the allocation of the land to the private
developer. With the assistance of the
About two years ago, the area MP Following the public forum, members of provincial administration, the developer
through the Constituency Development the local community got interested in the was requested to move his equipment.
Fund made a call to build a community civilian oversight concept and requested The land remains free to date while the
centre with a fire station and community ALAC to support them in drawing up a community still manages the centre.
hall. The project was completed without petition to be submitted to the county
the approval and/or the knowledge of the government and the Constituency However there is need to secure the two
community. Development Fund committee. public amenities by securing titles for them
as community land. The ALAC Mombasa
The centre was later left unattended Through ALAC Mombasa, TI- Kenya office has so far helped the community
and thereafter handed over to the son assisted the community to develop a to develop and present a petition to the
of a former politician from the area petition. It was drafted by an advocate in National Land Commission seeking
under unclear circumstances. The said Mombasa as a hybrid petition that could formal allocation of the land as community
individual was supposed to manage it and be presented as an administrative petition land. However, the process is hindered as
earn resultant income, actions which were or as a constitutional petition before the the Community Land Bill has not yet been
a clear affront to the rights of the local High Court of Kenya. enacted to provide a legal framework for
community. the process.
Page 9

By Juliet Mule

Mr. David* has been working as a village Gift giving to public


officers as a catalyst
elder in Njiiru District, Nairobi County for
over 5 years. He understands that as a
public officer, the services rendered to
the people within his village which he
administers are given for free, and has
served the people as such.
for corruption
therefore demand for them. Public officers Gift giving borders on a thin line between
However according to him, being given should serve citizens freely, and in cases rewarding with pure intentions and being
a gift by the citizens after serving them where there are payments to be made in a catalyst for corruption, and with the laws
diligently has been a welcome gesture, order to be served, the payments should being clear on this practice, it should not
and he sees nothing wrong with that. His be receipted. be encouraged.
argument is that as long as he does not
request for the gifts after serving them A sustained culture of gift giving results One of the causes of corruption is a
well; and it is done in their own volition, it in poor service delivery, and exacerbates ‘corruption opportunity’ which arises to
is well acceptable. corruption as some of the public officers persons who have ‘inclination’ towards
develop unwillingness to serve the citizens corruption. Through giving gifts, some
However, after attending a public forum unless their palms are ‘oiled’. In other public officers may exploit it and thus an
organised by the Advocacy and Legal instances, citizens give ‘gifts’ to public act of corruption occurs. Citizens have a
Advisory Centre (ALAC) Nairobi at Njiiru in officers with the expectation that they will responsibility to ensure that they do not
March, 2014, he learnt that the Constitution always be favoured in terms of service provide an opportunity for public officers
of Kenya in Article 76 provides that any CAPTION: sumquunt adi
gift given to a state officer on a public or aut aut atis quiscia pro ini-
mos que di dus conecuptas
official occasion should be surrendered as maximo que n quiscia
to the State. He admitted that he was not
aware of that provision and that he has
been gladly receiving the gifts for his own
benefit.

David resolved publicly that he would no


longer accept any gifts from citizens while
on official duty because these gifts could
be interpreted as attempts to influence
vested interests. Some of the individuals delivery either by being served faster than to be corrupt. They should refrain from
who have given him gifts in the past have other citizens, or creating acquaintances ‘rewarding’ public officers who serve them
resurfaced to demand for favours from his for future engagements for personal gain. in their official capacity, as a strategy of
office. Participants at the forum also got fighting corruption.
to understand that giving gifts can be a The wisdom behind Article 76 of the
catalyst to corruption whether knowingly Constitution is to deter the concept of gift There are other public officers who could
or unknowingly. giving with expectation for future favours. be unaware and several citizens are not
The Article provides that in a case where conversant with the provisions of the
The concept of giving gifts is regarded as the gift is given, the same should be Law, hence the need for more awareness
part of the African culture of appreciating delivered to the State. Section 11 2(a) creation to enlighten and empower
visitors and rewarding people who perform of the Public Officers Ethics Act also them. The government should take the
well or give support to members of their prohibits public officers from receiving or initiative to ensure that its officers are well
communities. It has been perceived as a requesting for gifts from the public, and conversant with the provisions governing
gesture of respect. where such a gift is given, the same is public conduct and ethical behavior.
deemed to be a donation to the office. The
Many Kenyans have thus been socialised proviso to this is in section 11(4) of the said *Name has been changed to protect
to give gifts to public officers as a gesture Act which allows a public officer to receive identity.
of respect and appreciation for services gifts either from a friend or relative where
rendered. They do not realise that these such a gift is given on a special occasion The writer is TI-Kenya’s Advocacy and
services offered by public officers are recognised by custom. Legal Advisory Centre (ALAC) Officer,
well within their rights and they should Nairobi.
Page 10

President Uhuru must institute a public inquiry


on Anglo Leasing now Responsibility must be apportioned to
individuals who should be punished in
accordance with the law. Costs incurred
in Anglo Leasing related awards and
legal costs should be recovered from the
individuals. The Government should not
fall back to public coffers to honour such
payments.

We must also question the process


used in making the payments to the
Anglo Leasing firms so far. The Principal
Secretary, National Treasury has admitted
that he conducted the transaction without
written authorization from the President,
contrary to Article 135 of The Constitution.
By Samuel Kimeu This is a blatant breach of the Constitution
and Parliament must censure the Principal
Questions abound on the handling of the procurement process in breach of Secretary and other officials concerned.
Anglo Leasing cases that have cost Kenya Kenyan laws and regulations were either The way this transaction was executed
billions of shillings, the latest being the improperly ventilated or unjustifiably raises reasonable suspicion that these
payment of Kshs 1.4 Billion. As Kenyans abandoned. But most important is shady deals that were conceived and
face a claim of an additional Ksh 3.5 Billion that despite all the reports pointing to nurtured under the KANU regime and
by the same recipients of the last payout, corruption and other illegalities in the blossomed under the Narc administration,
there is urgency in closing the floodgates procurement of these contracts, no may have found new patrons in the Jubilee
and holding public officials accountable action has been taken against those administration. Only decisive, immediate
for these losses with the same speed that suspected of involvement to date, except and conclusive action to punish those
the last payment was made. the conviction and a slap in the wrist for a behind the scandals can effectively rebut
former Permanent Secretary. this suspicion.
There have been serious questions
on the way the State Law Office To gain the confidence of Kenyans, the Moving forward, the following actions
defended the suits by First Mercantile President must immediately institute a are critical. The Attorney General must
Securities Corporation and Universal public inquiry to probe the entire Anglo inform Kenyans how much of their money
Satspace. The quality of the defense, Leasing scam including an audit of the has been spent to date on the 18 Anglo
the professionalism in the handling of legal processes that led to the payment Leasing type contracts and in related
the suits and the timeliness of action this week. Although the Ethics and Anti- payments including legal fees and awards.
are seriously in doubt. Were the officers Corruption Commission is currently Together with the National Treasury, he
responsible for the defense deliberately investigating the scandal, it has rolled on must present to the public an assessment
offhand in their treatment of the cases for far too long, and a public inquiry whose of the status of all Anglo Leasing contracts
to bequeath the awards to the Anglo proceedings all Kenyans can monitor, and their potential financial exposure. The
Leasing companies? It has come to light might be our best bet to assail this matter AG must in addition make all records of
that Kenya was not represented at crucial and unravel the identities of the principles the case, including all the Anglo Leasing
times of the proceedings. There were in these cases. In addition, an audit of contracts, court and arbitration awards
also serious delays in replying to crucial the legal process is an important first and various reports of inquiry public. All
legal communication. In addition, the step in closing the floodgates of claims information related to the latest claim
Honorable Solicitor General was assigned that the payment has opened. It is also should be in the public domain. Kenyans
to represent Kenya in foreign courts yet urgent in order to respond adequately to have the right to know all these information
he did not hold a certificate to practice in other claims, including the current one for to enable them engage in this matter from
those courts. Did all these occur under additional payment of Kshs. 3.5 Billion a position of knowledge.
the Attorney General’s watch? in respect of another Anglo Leasing type
contract, to avoid costly errors in the legal The writer is the Executive
It is also clear that the defenses of strategy. Director, Transparency
corruption and manipulation of the International Kenya.

Just Another Newsletter Title


Page 11
Connect with us:
www.tikenya.org

@TIKenya

TI-Kenya

ADVOCACY & LEGAL ADVISORY CENTRE


ALAC IS A WALK-IN, CALL-IN OR MAIL-IN CENTRE WHERE A
CITIZEN CAN GET FREE & CONFIDENTIAL ADVICE ON
CORRUPTION RELATED CASES

CALL TOLL-FREE 0800 720 721 OR SMS 22129


www.tikenya.org facebook.com/TransparencyKenya twitter.com/TIKenya

‘Adili’ is a news letter produced by TI-Kenya’s Communications Programme. The views and opinions expressed in this issue are not necessarily those of TI-Kenya. The
editor welcomes contributions, suggestions and feedback from readers.
Transparency International, 3rd Floor, Wing D, ACK Garden House, 1st Ngong Avenue. PO Box 198-00200, City Square,
Nairobi, Kenya. Tel.: 254-020-2727763/5, 0733-834659, 0722-296589; Fax: 254-020-2729530.

You might also like