Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IEEE Line - Surge - Arresters - Monitoring - System
IEEE Line - Surge - Arresters - Monitoring - System
Abstract— Power system reliability is often threatened by inter-cloud lightning), and 2D statistical error has contributed
lightning discharges causing the outages of the overhead lines. to the recent improvement of the understanding of lightning.
Surge arresters installed on high-voltage overhead transmission Still, there are many areas that require further research since
lines can improve their lightning performance. Studying the parameters which are useful for insulation coordination
lightning is a challenging task due to its stochastic nature and studies, such as the front and tail times of the lightning current
complex discharge mechanism. Lightning data based on waveform, are not recordable by LLS. In accordance with IEC
lightning location systems has contributed to the recent 61400-24:2019, there are four parameters which are
improved understanding of lightning but there are still areas characteristics of lightning current: amplitude (I), rise rate or
that require further research such as the parameters of the
slope (di/dt), transferred charge (Q) and specific energy (W/R)
lightning current waveform. This paper describes the proposed
line surge arresters' monitoring system for measuring lightning
[6].
and line surge arrester currents as well as temperature and The most significant information in lightning research for
humidity. The proposed system is based on state-of-the-art engineering applications is derived from the waveform
measuring sensors, communication and information analysis of lightning currents that have been directly
technologies. Software and hardware components of the system measured. Several systems for measuring lightning current
are described, including laboratory tests and results. waveforms have been developed, most of them are installed
on high towers, like telecom towers [7] - [12].
Keywords—surge arrester, lightning current, waveshape,
measurement, monitoring A real time measurement system for measuring lightning
transient currents was developed and installed on two towers
I. INTRODUCTION equipped with line surge arresters (LSAs) on a 110 kV
Lightning is caused by strong electric fields that occur overhead line in the Croatian transmission network [13]. Due
between clouds and the ground or between clouds, as well as to the aging and obsolescence the measurement system in
within clouds. As a result of large potential differences, a question is no longer operational.
discharge occurs in the air with the length of an electric arc
This paper presents a system whose aim is to measure the
measured in kilometers and accompanied by a large current,
lightning current which circulates through the line surge
which can range from a few kiloamperes to tens or hundreds
arresters of an overhead transmission line. The new system is
of kiloamperes.
based on the state-of-the-art in terms of measuring sensors,
Studying lightning is a challenging task due to its communication, and information technologies. It is also
stochastic nature and complex discharge mechanism. Most of crucial to choose the measuring system's components
the lightning strikes (about three-quarters) do not involve the according to the parameters of the lightning current that are
ground, but are discharges between or within clouds. measured.
Discharges between clouds and the ground are relevant for the
The choice of a location with active lightning is a very
protection of power systems, because such lightning can strike
important step in the installation of such measurement device,
power system facilities and threaten the reliability of the
to obtain a sufficient number of measurement results. The
power supply [1].
selection of areas with high lightning activity should be made
Surge arresters installed on high-voltage overhead using modern lightning location technologies.
transmission lines can improve their lightning protection [2] -
The paper is organized as follows. Section II presents line
[5].
surge arresters’ application experience of the Croatian
Lightning data based on lightning location systems (LLS) transmission system operator. Section III describes the line
such as time and date of the lightning stroke, GPS coordinates surge arrester’s transient current measurement and monitoring
(2D), lightning current amplitude, lightning type, height (for system. Section IV depicts the laboratory tests and the
nsed use limited to: ELECTRICAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION - Mr. Anil Khopkar (269505). Downloaded on December 28,2023 at 11:06:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Res
experimental results. Finally, the conclusion is presented in outage rate. EMT simulations with different line surge
section V. arresters’ configurations were performed to determine the
placement (towers and phases) of the line surge arresters [14].
II. LINE SURGE ARRESTERS APPLICATION Data on the overhead line parameters, towers’ footing
There is increasing number of line surge arresters’ (LSA) resistance, and the most frequent locations, type and duration
application to the overhead lines in order to improve the of the failures were used as the input for the simulations,
lightning performance of the lines by reducing the outage rate Lightning statistics data obtained from the LLS were used
due to the lightning. It is the case in particular for the overhead in order to evaluate the efficiency of the LSA configuration in
lines located in the specific environments where it is not relation to the lightning activities in the observed area. Time
possible to apply other methods which improve overvoltage and spatial correlation of the relay protection system data and
performance of the overhead lines or their application are LLS data was performed to determine the number of outages
insufficient. caused by lightning. For example, correlations of the overhead
The Croatian transmission system operator has started to line outages with the lightning activities confirmed by the LLS
use LSAs in 2007 and after a first satisfactory experience in application are marked with red labels in Fig. 1. Analyses
reducing the number of outages of a line equipped, it has showed that the number of outages of the observed overhead
continued to apply LSAs to overhead lines which are exposed lines in relation to the recorded lightning activities decreased
to significant lightning activity [13]. after the LSAs were installed and the overvoltage protection
performance of the overhead lines improved significantly
The installation of LSAs on the 110 kV overhead lines on [15]. Other analyses showed that some improvements of the
the island of Brač is an example of this application, since this LSAs configuration are still possible [16, 17] for which further
zone has had many lightning related outages during the past research would be needed including a deeper understanding of
decades. These outages can often be transient failures cleared the lightning phenomena influence on the overhead lines’
by the auto-reclosure function of the overhead line relay operation. Therefore, LSA monitoring system with possibility
protection, but in some cases they can cause interruption of to measure the transient currents could be used.
electricity supply and significant damage of the primary or
secondary substation equipment. III. TRANSIENT CURRENT MEASUREMENT SYSTEM
The 110 kV overhead lines on the island of Brač are A better understanding of lightning parameters, methods
located in the coastal area which is exposed to specific climate for calculating the flashover rate of OHL (as well as the
conditions with high lightning activity, particularly during the validation of EMT software programs Erro! Fonte de
summer period of the year. The surrounding terrain is mostly referência não encontrada.), and the specification of the
rocky and of very high soil resistivity which aggravates the lightning impulse discharge capabilities of arresters could all
overvoltage protection performance of the overhead lines. be achieved by measuring the lightning current flowing
through the LSA and through the tower [19].
An example of the lightning activity tracked during a 1-
hour time period recorded by a LLS is shown in Fig. 1. When During its operation, an old version of the measurement
performing computations of lightning performance in the system provided data useful for performing correlations with
observed area a keraunic level of 40 lightning days per year is LLS data, as well as with data recorded by the overhead line’s
commonly used. relay protection device as it is shown in Fig. 2 [20].
nsed use limited to: ELECTRICAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION - Mr. Anil Khopkar (269505). Downloaded on December 28,2023 at 11:06:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Res
designed real time measurement system for lightning transient accuracy, which is the result of direct processing of the
currents monitoring [20] - [23]. received GPS signals and transformation of this data into GPS
precise time.
nsed use limited to: ELECTRICAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION - Mr. Anil Khopkar (269505). Downloaded on December 28,2023 at 11:06:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Res
In addition to the lightning current measuring system IoT x Recording and sending data.
(Internet of Things) based system is added to monitor
environment temperature and humidity. As it is previously It also enables the system to send data periodically from
mentioned lightning current measuring system will be the computer to the cloud, for instance once per day (or as set
installed on a transmission line tower and it is, as for every by the user). The sent data are automatically removed to free
other technical system, important and useful to have up space in the computer's memory, which may be in a remote
information on operational ambient conditions, in particular location. The program is launched automatically as soon as the
temperature and humidity. Also, this system represents computer is powered on due to the potential distant location
beginning of the development of IoT based devices’ of the system.
application in high voltage measurement systems. IV. EXPERIMENTAL MEASUREMENT SYSTEM TESTING
When performing insulation coordination studies or The Experimental Measurement System was tested with a
maintain insulation it is beneficial to have information about: large number of pulse currents of various waveforms in order
x temperature, to identify the optimal performance of the individual system’s
components and of the system itself.
x air pressure,
The scheme of the setup for the experimental measurement
x humidity, system testing in the high voltage laboratory is shown in Fig.
4 and consists of following equipment:
x air pollution,
x Impulse current generator;
x solar irradiation,
x Surge Protection Device (SPD)
x wind speed and direction, etc.
x Conventional laboratory measurement system;
The developed device records temperature and humidity
and sends the data in real time via the internet to a server. x Developed system (the system that was tested);
Although data is measured and provided once per 15 minutes,
the user can optionally set a sampling rate and data delivery x Power supply for developed system;
time frame. x Internet connection.
The device is built around a Wi-Fi LoRa (Long Range) 32 The impulse generator can generate surge currents up to
V2 device (number 8 in Fig.4) and a simple temperature and 10 kA peak values of both polarities of standard waveform
humidity sensor (number 7 in Fig.4 DHT12 sensor) that is 8/20 μs (or some other wave-shape).
connected to the Wi-Fi LoRa 32 V2 device. Micro Python @
[26] is used for programming a microcontroller which The SPD was used as the object through which current is
measures temperature and humidity and sends the data to a measured. Characteristics of the SPD are given in table I.
server. The Wi-Fi LoRa 32 V2 device can communicate (for
data sending) via Wi-Fi or LoRa network. In this case 4G TABLE I. CHARACTERISTICS OF DISTRIBUTION SURGE ARRESTER
(SPD)
network is available and device uses it. In the case that the
LoRa infrastructure (gateways) is available, it can also be used Maximum discharge current 40 kA
for the communication. The device is equipped with OLED Nominal discharge current 15 kA
Voltage protection level 1.2 kV
display on which temperature and humidity can be shown.
Maximum continuous voltage 275 V
The device is low consumption, and it can be supplied by U – I Characteristic
the battery for a long term i.e. for months. Voltage [V] Current [A]
344 0.001
B. Software and Data Storage in the Cloud 402 0.01
459 0.1
The lightning current measuring system is equipped with 517 1
a custom developed software which performs the following 575 10
operations: 632 100
690 1000
x Downloading the data by the measuring card, i.e. from 1100 10000
the measuring device (in this case Rogowski coil), all
the way to the computer, via USB 3.0 interface; The currents measured with the experimental system were
x Processing the data, i.e. recording on the controller simultaneously compared to the ones observed with a
disk; conventional laboratory measurement system consisting of an
oscilloscope with a sampling rate of 50 MSa/s. Voltage is
x Sending the processed data to the cloud, via a network measured at low inductive resistance R = 31.8 mΩ as it is
communication (LAN, WiFi, 4G). illustrated in Fig. 4. The current is obtained via this voltage
The software enables manual execution of the following drop.
commands: Lightning First Stroke Test is the preliminary test which is
x Trigger, performed to check that the laboratory set-up was operational,
and that the equipment met the desired requirements. It
x PPS signal, consists of the single 8/20 μs current impulse. The low current
amplitude of the first impulse is used to check the accuracy of
x GPS and the selected thresholds.
nsed use limited to: ELECTRICAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION - Mr. Anil Khopkar (269505). Downloaded on December 28,2023 at 11:06:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Res
The second experiment consisted of the generation of is no noise in recorded signal due to existing of enclosure on
several current shapes with different peaks to make sure that the laboratory oscilloscope.
the monitoring system acquire all of the impulses and send
them to the server over the mobile network.
About 90% of all cloud-to-ground lightning are downward
negative lightning discharges. The used testing current shapes
is similar to the directly measured lightning current shape as
shown in Fig. 5. It was recorded with measurement system
installed on the broadcasting tower on the mountain Lovćen,
Montenegro.
Fig. 7. Directly measured surge currents with the peak value I Ĭ 8,3 kA
Fig. 6. Measured current with the peak value I Ĭ 8,3 kA The difference between the simulated results and the
recorded data is due to the modelling of spark gap and SPD.
It can be observed that there is some noise in the recorded The spark gap has a non-linear characteristic and, together
signal due to the spark gap reaction in the laboratory current with the SPD, stops conducting current when the voltage
generator. Later in the data analyses stage this noise can be drops below a certain value. This behaviour has not been taken
removed using appropriate filtering techniques such as: the into account in model and it is not included in the simulations
Fourier transformation, the short Fourier transformation performed in MATLAB and EMTP.
(STFT), the wavelet transformation (WT), etc. Also, this noise
Experimental measurements of temperature and humidity
was observed to be significantly reduced once the measuring
with simple sensor was performed in laboratory for three
system was encapsulated in a metal box.
consecutive days as shown in Fig. 9. All acquired data was
The directly measured surge current with the peak value I successfully transferred to the cloud server.
Ĭ 8,3 kA is shown in Fig. 7. and it can be observed that there
nsed use limited to: ELECTRICAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION - Mr. Anil Khopkar (269505). Downloaded on December 28,2023 at 11:06:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Res
Arrester Installation”, Colloquium on Lightning and Power Systems,
Kuala Lumpur, 2010., (pp. 16-19).
[5] A. R. Hileman, Insulation coordination for power systems, CRC Press,
2018.
[6] IEC 61400-24, “Wind energy generation systems – Part 24: Lightning
protection”, 2019
[7] N. Watanabe, A. Nag, G. Diendorfer, H. Pichler, W. Schulz, V. A.
Rakov, and H. K. Rassoul, “Characteristics of Currents in Upward
Lightning Flashes Initiated From the Gaisberg Tower”, IEEE
Transactions on Electromagnetic Compatibility, vol. 61, no. 3, pp. 705-
718, Jun. 2019.
[8] F. H. Heidler, and C. Paul, “High-Speed Video Observation, Currents,
and EM-Fields From Four Negative Upward Lightning to the
Peissenberg Tower, Germany”, IEEE Transactions on Electromagnetic
Compatibility, vol. 63, no. 3, pp. 803-810, Jun. 2021.
[9] M. Azadifar, M. Rubinstein, F. Rachidi, V. A. Rakov, G. Diendorfer,
W. Schulz, and D. Pavanell, “A Study of a Large Bipolar Lightning
Event Observed at the Säntis Tower, ” IEEE Transactions on
Fig. 9. Example of temperature and humidity measurement in laboratory Electromagnetic Compatibility, vol. 61, no. 3, pp. 796-806, Jun. 2019.
[10] S. Kazazi, A. M. Hussein, and P. Liatos, "Evaluation of the
V. CONCLUSIONS performance characteristics of the North American Lightning
Detection Network based on recent CN Tower lightning data”, 2015
The most significant information in lightning research for International Symposium on Lightning Protection (XIII SIPDA), pp.
engineering applications is derived from the waveform 327-333, Sept. 2015.
analysis of lightning currents that have been directly [11] https://www.aldis.at/en/lightning-research/lightning-research-at-
measured. gaisberg/general/?ADMCMD_view=542
[12] C. Romero, A. Rubinstein, M. Paolone, F. Rachidi, M. Rubinstein, P.
Measuring the lightning current flowing through the LSA Zweiacker and B. Daout, “Instrumentation of the Säntis Tower in
and through the tower of the overhead line contributes to the Switzerland for Lightning Current Measurements”, International
better understanding of lightning parameters, methods for Journal of Plasma Environmental Science & Technology, Vol.4, No.1,
2010.
calculating the flashover rate of OHL (as well as the validation
of EMT software programs), and the specification of the [13] G. Levačić, L. Ćurin, S. Piliškić, D. Škarica, I. Ivanković and M. Mesić,
“Overview of the Line Surge Arresters Application in Croatian
lightning impulse discharge capabilities of surge arresters. Transmission Network”, CIGRE SEERC Colloquium, Vienna, 2022.
A real time LSAs' monitoring system was developed for [14] M. Puharić, M. Mesić, S. Piliškić and M. Mijoč, “The Overvoltage
measuring lightning and line surge arrester currents as well as Protection of the 110 kV Overhead Lines of the Island of Brač by the
Line Surge Arresters Application”, CIGRE Colloquium on Lightning
temperature and humidity. A special attention was given to and Power Systems, Lyon, France, 2014.
selection of the measuring system's components, taking into [15] M. Mesić, S. Piliškić, L. Ćurin, I. Uglešić, and B. Franc, “Application
account the parameters of the lightning current that are and Performance of the Line Surge Arresters of the 110 kV Overhead
measured. The most up-to-date state-of-the-art in measuring Lines of the Croatian Transmission System”, International Colloquium
sensors, communication and information technologies were on Lightning and Power Systems, Ljubljana, 2017.
implemented. [16] M. Mesić, I. Uglešić, B. Filipović-Grčić, S. Piliškić, M. Mijoč and B.
Franc, “Overvoltage Protection Performance of the 110 kV Overhead
Laboratory tests have shown good matching in amplitude Lines after the Line Surge Arresters Implementation”, IPST, Cavtat,
and shape of current recorded by the developed system and Croatia, 2015.
compared to the results provided by conventional laboratory [17] M. Mesić, S. Piliškić, I. Uglešić, B. Filipović-Grčić and B. Franc,
measurement equipment. Comparisons were also made with “Performance of the Line Surge Arresters of the 110 kV Overhead
Lines on the island Brač”, ICLPS, Bologna, Italy, 2016.
numerical simulation results conducted on models developed
[18] B. Badrzadeh, Z. Emin, E. Hillberg, D. Jacobson, L. Kocewiak, G.
in MATLAB and EMTP. Communication tests and tests for Lietz, F.F. Da Silva, and M. Val Escudero, "The need for enhanced
data transfer to cloud were successful and proved that it is power system modelling techniques and simulation tools", CIGRE
possible to install the measurement system on site. Science & Engineering, Vol N°17, February 2020.
[19] IEC 60099.4: 2014, Surge arresters – Part 4: Metal-oxide surge
In order to obtain relevant measurement results, it is arresters without gaps for a.c. systems.
recommended to use modern lightning location systems to [20] S. Sadovic, T. Sadovic, A. Xemard, M. Mesic and D. Marin, “Five
select the overhead line located in the area with active years of experience of Ston - Komolac transmission line lightning
lightning to which the system will be installed. measurement”, ICLPS, Bologna, Italy, 2016.
[21] T. Sadović, “Real-time remote monitoring of high voltage surge
REFERENCES arresters”, Graz University of Technology: Graz, Austria. 2010.
[1] A. Atputharajah., and T. K. Saha, “Power system blackouts-literature [22] M. Muhr and T. Sadovic, “Real-Time Remote Monitoring of Line
review”. In 2009 International Conference on Industrial and Surge Arresters”, CIGRE Colloquium, Cavtat, Croatia, 2008.
Information Systems (ICIIS) (pp. 460-465). IEEE, December 2009. [23] A. Balota, S. Grebović and T. Sadović, “Lightning Activity Monitoring
[2] Effectiveness of line surge arresters for lightning protection of System in Real Time”, MECO 2016 - 5th Mediterranean Conference
overhead transmission lines, CIGRE Brochure 855, December 2021. on Embedded Computing, Bar, Montenegro, 2016.
[3] IEC 62305-1: (2010), Protection against lightning –Part 1: General [24] https://www.digikey.com/en/products/detail/pomona-
principles. electronics/4108-20DB/736744
[4] M. Mesić, J. Radovanović, D. Škarica, and S. Sadović, “Improving of [25] https://www.welectron.com/mediafiles/datasheets/tiepie/TiePie-
Reliability Overhead Line 110 kV Ston–Komolac by Line Surge Handyscope-HS6-DIFF-Datasheet.pdf
[26] https://micropython.org/
nsed use limited to: ELECTRICAL RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT ASSOCIATION - Mr. Anil Khopkar (269505). Downloaded on December 28,2023 at 11:06:09 UTC from IEEE Xplore. Res