Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mousavi Et Al., 2011.mercury in Natural Waters. A Menu Review
Mousavi Et Al., 2011.mercury in Natural Waters. A Menu Review
Mousavi Et Al., 2011.mercury in Natural Waters. A Menu Review
Environmental Forensics
Publication details, including instructions for authors and subscription information:
http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/uenf20
To cite this article: Aliyar Mousavi, Rose D. Chávez, Abdul-Mehdi S. Ali & Stephen E. Cabaniss (2011): Mercury in Natural
Waters: A Mini-Review, Environmental Forensics, 12:1, 14-18
This article may be used for research, teaching and private study purposes. Any substantial or systematic
reproduction, re-distribution, re-selling, loan, sub-licensing, systematic supply or distribution in any form to
anyone is expressly forbidden.
The publisher does not give any warranty express or implied or make any representation that the contents
will be complete or accurate or up to date. The accuracy of any instructions, formulae and drug doses should
be independently verified with primary sources. The publisher shall not be liable for any loss, actions, claims,
proceedings, demand or costs or damages whatsoever or howsoever caused arising directly or indirectly in
connection with or arising out of the use of this material.
Environmental Forensics, 12:14–18, 2011
Copyright
C Taylor & Francis Group, LLC
Mini-Review
Mercury in fish is a concern as for human health. Understanding mercury toxicity, however, requires an understanding of mercury
speciation. Monomethylmercury is known to be the most concerning mercury species. This mini-review first covers an introductory
Downloaded by [Universite de Montreal] at 09:28 18 July 2011
toxicology of mercury. As human exposure to monomethylmercury is mainly through fish and as monomethylmercury concentrations
in fish are related to inorganic mercury loads, health and environmental preventive regulations concerning mercury in natural waters
are addressed. Further, mercury geochemistry in natural waters is briefly reviewed, and the biogeochemical processes which affect
mercury toxicity in natural waters are discussed.
The symbol of mercury, Hg, is derived from the Latin word hy- another environmental concern: Consumption of contaminated
drargyrum meaning “liquid silver” (Greenwood and Earnshaw, fish products, fish, and wildlife that are at the top of aquatic
1994). The symbol refers to the fact that mercury in elemen- food chains is almost entirely what causes human exposure
tal form exists as a liquid at room temperature (Holleman & to monomethylmercury (United States Geological Survey [US
Wiberg, 2001). Inorganic compounds of Hg, with the excep- GS], 2000; Fitzgerald, 2003), and monomethylmercury is the
tion of derivatives of Hg2+2 ion, involve Hg(II) (Greenwood principal mercury-related human health concern today (Fitzger-
and Earnshaw, 1994). However, in addition to existing in ele- ald, 2003).
mental form and in inorganic compounds, Hg also occurs in Monomethylmercury is a neurotoxic species, and its poi-
organometallic compounds (Greenwood and Earnshaw, 1994), soning is known as Minamata disease, named after Minamata,
of which monomethylmercury (Hg CH+ 3 ) and dimethylmercury Japan, where industrially related mass poisonings, debilita-
(Hg(CH3 )2 ) are of special environmental importance. With all tion, and deaths occurred between 1950 and 1975. The poi-
the forms of mercury being variously toxic to aquatic biota and sonings resulted from consumption of locally caught fish and
humans, mercury in natural waters is an issue. In light of address- seafood that had been contaminated by monomethylmercury.
ing the toxicological concerns of mercury in aquatic ecosystems The monomethylmercury had originated from wastewater from
and in light of the preventive regulations to which those con- factories (Fitzgerald, 2003). It is important to note that children
cerns have given rise, this work discusses the occurrence and and infants, who may be exposed to monomethylmercury di-
speciation of mercury in natural waters. rectly by eating contaminated fish, are especially vulnerable to
the effects of ingesting it (European Environment and Health
Toxicity Information System [ENHIS], 2007).
Although the only form of mercury that accumulates
Mercury can be toxic to both aquatic plants and fish. Aquatic appreciably in fish is monomethylmercury (US GS, 2000;
plants are affected by mercury in water at 1 mg/L of inorganic Ravichandran, 2004), human exposure to monomethylmercury-
mercury and at much lower concentrations of organic mercury contaminated fish is also a possible cause of breast milk being
(Boening, 2000). Hg can also cause poisoning leading to de- a potential source of exposure to inorganic mercury (Risher
crease in the ability of fish to survive (Moore and Ramamoorthy, and De Rosa, 2007). Autoimmune effects have been reported
1984; Vieira et al., 2009). However, mercury in fish is also of in humans following prolonged exposure to inorganic mercury,
and long-term exposure to both high and low amounts of in-
organic mercury can cause renal damage (Risher and De Rosa,
Received 22 May 2010; 14 October 2010.
Address correspondence to Aliyar Mousavi, Mathematics and Sci-
2007). Still organomercury compounds are more dangerous than
ences Department, Nashua Community College, 505 Amherst Street, inorganic mercury compounds because of their greater perme-
Nashua, NH 03063, USA. E-mail: aliyarm@hotmail.com ability of biomembranes. They are more readily absorbed in the
14
Mercury in Natural Waters 15
gastrointestinal tract and, acting by binding to the –SH groups disease from ingested Hg (WHO, 2007). In 2003, the Joint
in proteins, have a more immediate and permanent effect on the FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA) es-
brain and central nervous system (Greenwood and Earnshaw, tablished a tolerable intake of 1.6 µg/kg bodyweight per week
1994). for monomethylmercury in order to protect the developing fetus
from neurotoxic effects (JECFA, 2004). In 2006, JECFA noted
Preventive Regulations Concerning Hg that life-stages other than the embryo and fetus may be less
in Natural Waters sensitive to the adverse effects of monomethylmercury (JECFA,
Food sources other than fish and seafood products may contain 2007).
mercury, although often in the less toxic form of inorganic mer- Although no legally binding international treaty on mercury
cury (ENHIS 2007). In the early 1970s, a monomethylmercury- pollution is presently in effect, more than 140 countries have
poisoning catastrophe occurred in Iraq after substantial amounts agreed to begin negotiations on a global treaty to control mer-
of wheat that was treated using a monomethylmercury fungicide cury (Hogue, 2009). The US EPA has set required mercury crite-
and was intended for planting were used to prepare bread (Tollef- ria for the United States for fresh waters and salt waters, unless a
son and Cordle, 1986; Clarkson and Strain, 2003). Currently state has its own criteria that meet the US EPA mercury criteria.
the use of both monomethylmercury and ethylmercury as fungi- The US EPA mercury criteria (maximum contaminant level) are
cides on seeds used for growing crops is cancelled in the United 2.1 µg/L for fresh waters and 1.8 µg/L for salt waters (ECFR).
States, subject to severe regulatory restriction worldwide, and
Downloaded by [Universite de Montreal] at 09:28 18 July 2011
discouraged worldwide by the World Health Organization (US Occurrence and Release
EPA).
Fish and shellfish both contain essential nutrients that help Mercury occurs naturally in the earth’s crust, principally as min-
maintain a healthy diet (He, 2009). Specifically, they are sources eral cinnabar (HgS) found along lines of previous volcanic ac-
of high-quality protein, are low in saturated fat, and contain tivity. The most famous and extensive deposits of cinnabar are
omega-3 fatty acids (He, 2009). However, concerns about mer- at Almaden in Spain and have been worked since Roman times.
cury levels in fish have caused some experts to rethink the Some of other deposits of cinnabar are situated in Algeria, Mex-
role of fish in a well-balanced diet (World Health Organiza- ico, and Italy. While the deposits at Almaden contain up to 6%–
tion [WHO], 2007). Nearly all fish and shellfish contain some 7% Hg, other deposits usually contain <1% Hg (Greenwood
traces of mercury (Mozaffarian, 2009), and the amount of mer- and Earnshaw, 1994).
cury in fish depends on their diet, lifespan and trophic level Mercury is released into the environment by both natural and
(Mozaffarian, 2009). Monomethylmercury in the aquatic food anthropogenic processes. Natural processes, such as volcanic
chain reaches highest concentration in top predators like tuna activity, release Hg primarily in the form of Hg0 (g) into the
and sharks (Clarkson et al., 2003). With fish consumption dom- air (Risher and De Rosa, 2007). Anthropogenic inputs of Hg to
inating the pathway for exposure to monomethylmercury for the environment are numerous and widespread. The most prob-
most human populations, many governments around the world lematic are atmospheric, principally coal and municipal waste
provide recommendations or legal limits for the maximum al- burning (Fitzgerald, 2003). Mining of gold is another important
lowable amount of mercury and/or monomethylmercury in fish anthropogenic source (US GS, 2000; Risher and De Rosa, 2007).
to be sold on the market (WHO-United Nations Environment Hg was used in the Mediterranean world for extracting metals by
Programme [UNEP], 2008). amalgamation as early as 500 BC (Greenwood and Earnshaw,
In the United States, the Food and Drug Administration (US 1994), and starting with the period of industrial revolution it
FDA) and the Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) ad- was used in gold extraction (Petrisor, 2006). Using mercury in
vise women who might become pregnant, women who are preg- gold mining and reprocessing is still in practice today (Petrisor,
nant, nursing mothers, and young children (US FDA-US EPA, 2006). The use of mercury in the chloralkali industry, where
2004) to avoid eating shark, swordfish, king mackerel, or tile- mercury is used as an electrode in the electrochemical pro-
fish. This population is also advised to eat up to 12 ounces (two cess of manufacturing chlorine, is a major source (Järup, 2003).
average meals) a week of a variety of fish and shellfish that Mercury is used today in paints and tattoo inks. Some other ex-
are low in Hg (e.g., shrimp, salmon, and pollock) (US FDA-US amples of anthropogenic sources of nonoccupational exposure
EPA, 2004). However, some experts have questioned the sound- to mercury are dental amalgams (still used for filling teeth in
ness of this advice, arguing that it ignores the benefits associated some countries), barometers, instruments for measuring blood
with consuming fish and potentially decreases fish consumption pressure, gas regulators, fluorescent bulbs, wall light switches,
among women of childbearing age (Arnold et al., 2005). camera batteries, thermostats, and thermometers (Järup, 2003;
The World Health Organization (WHO) has prepared a guid- Risher and De Rosa, 2007).
ance document for risk managers that uses national exposure
assessments to determine the appropriate risk management op-
Speciation and Geochemistry
tions, bearing in mind the nutritional benefits of fish consump-
tion. In addition, WHO launched an initiative to estimate the Greater than 95% of the mercury found in the atmosphere is gas-
global burden of food borne disease, including the burden of phase elemental mercury, while the mercury in precipitation is
16 A. Mousavi et al.
Rudd, 1990; Fitzgerald, 2003). The elemental mercury formed constants from hypothetical structures of NOM molecules
in aquatic environments can be volatilized to the atmosphere (Cabaniss, 2009). NOM is remarkably heterogeneous in
(Winfrey and Rudd, 1990; US GS, 2000; Fitzgerald, 2003). structure and exact structural information is unavailable
Figure 1 is a pictorial representation of the biogeochemical (Schmitt-Kopplin, 2003). Consequently, any QSPR which is to
cycling of mercury in freshwater lakes. The Figure and the num- be useful for predicting Hg(II) binding by NOM should require
bers corresponding to the percentages of the various mercury minimal information- preferably constitutional descriptors such
species show that only a small amount of the total mercury is ac- as functional group and elemental composition. One QSPR
tually transformed to monomethylmercury species (Fitzgerald, useful for predicting Hg(II) binding equilibrium constants
2003). has, to our knowledge, been developed. The developed QSPR
Other than methylation, demethylation, and reduction, two is for predicting equilibrium constants of Hg(II) binding by
sets of reactions are important in the biogeochemical cycling small organic molecules similar in ligand group composition to
of mercury in fresh waters. In the presence of hydrogen sulfide, NOM. The equilibrium constants are related to elemental and
Hg2+ precipitates as HgS. This precipitation has generally been functional group composition of the molecules without relying
assumed to inhibit the availability of mercury for methylation on stereochemistry or even overall connectivity (Mousavi,
and is believed to do so (Winfrey and Rudd, 1990; Fitzgerald, 2010). The QSPR is then interfaced with a dynamic, agent-
2003). The second is the set of reactions in which Hg2+ binds or based model of NOM for predicting Hg(II) complexation in
adsorbs to natural organic matter (NOM) (Winfrey and Rudd, different environments (Cabaniss, 2009).
Downloaded by [Universite de Montreal] at 09:28 18 July 2011
Cabaniss, S. E. 2009. Forward modeling of metal complexation by NOM: I. Mousavi, A., Bensalem, A., and Gee, B. 2010. Low–temperature synthesis
A prori prediction of conditional constants and speciation. Environmental of a green material for lithium–ion batteries cathode. Green Chemistry
Science & Technology 43:2838–2844. Letters and Reviews 3:135–142.
Choi, S. C., Chase, T. Jr., and Bartha, R. 1994. Enzymatic catalysis of Mozaffarian, D. 2009. Fish, mercury, selenium and cardiovascular risk:
mercury methylation by Desulfovibrio desulfuricans LS. Applied and current evidence and unanswered questions. International Journal of En-
Environmental Microbiology 60:1342–1346. vironmental Research and Public Health 6:1894–1916.
Clarkson, T. W., Magos, L., and Myers, G. J. 2003. The toxicology of Munthe, J., Bodaly, R. A., Branfireun, B. A., Driscoll, C. T., Gilmour, C.
mercury—-current exposures and clinical manifestations. New England C., Harris, R., et al. 2007. Recovery of mercury-contaminated fisheries.
Journal of Medicine 349:1731–1737. Ambio 36:33–44.
Clarkson, T. W., and Strain, J. J. 2003. Nutritional factors may modify Orihel, D. M., Paterson, M. J., Blanchfield, P. J., Bodaly, R. A., and
the toxic action of methyl mercury in fish-eating populations. Journal of Hintelmann, H. 2007. Experimental evidence of a linear relation-
Nutrition 133:1539S–1543S. ship between inorganic mercury loading and methylmercury accumu-
Eisler, R. 2006. Mercury Hazards to Living Organisms. CRC Press, New lation by aquatic biota. Environmental Science & Technology 41:4952–
York, NY, pp 47–57. 4958.
Ekstrom, E. B., and Morel, F. M. 2008. Cobalt limitation of growth and Panel on Mercury of the Coordinating Committee for Scientific and Tech-
mercury methylation in sulfate–reducing bacteria. Environmental Science nical Assessments of Environmental Pollutants.1978. An Assessment of
& Technology 42:93–99. Mercury in the Environment. Washington, DC: National Academy of
Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (ECFR). Title 40: Protection of Sciences, 30–39.
Environment, Part 131–Water Quality Standards, Subpart D–Federally Perdue, E. M., and Parrish, R. S. 1987. Fitting multisite binding equilibria
Promulgated Water Quality Standards. to statistical Distribution models: Turbo Pascal program for Gaussian
European Environment and Health Information System (ENHIS). 2007. models. Computers & Geosciences 13:587–601.
Exposure of Children to Chemical Hazards in Food. Copenhagen: World Petrisor, I. G. 2006. Mercury: Hazards and forensic perspectives. Environ-
Downloaded by [Universite de Montreal] at 09:28 18 July 2011