Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(Download PDF) Jews in Ancient and Medieval Armenia First Century Bce Fourteenth Century Ce Michael E Stone 2 Full Chapter PDF
(Download PDF) Jews in Ancient and Medieval Armenia First Century Bce Fourteenth Century Ce Michael E Stone 2 Full Chapter PDF
https://ebookmass.com/product/jews-in-ancient-and-medieval-
armenia-first-century-bce-fourteenth-century-ce-michael-e-stone/
https://ebookmass.com/product/the-thirteenth-century-animal-turn-
medieval-and-twenty-first-century-perspectives-1st-ed-edition-
nigel-harris/
https://ebookmass.com/product/medieval-arms-and-armour-a-
sourcebook-volume-i-the-fourteenth-century-ralph-moffat/
https://ebookmass.com/product/anglo-papal-relations-in-the-early-
fourteenth-century-a-study-in-medieval-diplomacy-barbara-bombi/
Medicine, Health, and Healing in the Ancient
Mediterranean (500 BCE–600 CE): A Sourcebook 1st
Edition Kristi Upson-Saia
https://ebookmass.com/product/medicine-health-and-healing-in-the-
ancient-mediterranean-500-bce-600-ce-a-sourcebook-1st-edition-
kristi-upson-saia/
https://ebookmass.com/product/englands-jews-finance-violence-and-
the-crown-in-the-thirteenth-century-john-tolan/
https://ebookmass.com/product/humanism-and-empire-the-imperial-
ideal-in-fourteenth-century-italy-alexander-lee/
https://ebookmass.com/product/governing-california-in-the-twenty-
first-century-seventh-edition/
https://ebookmass.com/product/a-history-of-ancient-and-early-
medieval-india-from-the-stone-age-to-the-12th-century-upinder-
singh/
Jews in Ancient and Medieval Armenia
Jews in Ancient and Medieval
Armenia
First Century bce to Fourteenth Century ce
MICHAEL E. STONE AND ARAM TOPCHYAN
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford. It furthers the
University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship, and education by publishing
worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of Oxford University Press in the UK and
certain other countries.
Published in the United States of America by Oxford University Press
198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America.
© Oxford University Press 2022
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval
system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission in writing
of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted by law, by license, or under terms
agreed with the appropriate reproduction rights organization. Inquiries concerning
reproduction outside the scope of the above should be sent to the Rights Department,
Oxford University Press, at the address above.
You must not circulate this work in any other form and you must impose this same condition
on any acquirer.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Stone, Michael E., 1938- author. | Topchyan, Aram, author.
Title: Jews in ancient and medieval Armenia : first century BCE
to fourteenth century CE / Michael E. Stone and Aram Topchyan.
Description: New York : Oxford University Press, [2022] |
Includes bibliographical references and index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2021058954 (print) | LCCN 2021058955 (ebook) |
ISBN 9780197582077 (hardback) | ISBN 9780197582091 (epub)
Subjects: LCSH: Jews—Armenia (Republic)—History.
Classification: LCC DS135.A83 S76 2022 (print) | LCC DS135.A83 (ebook) |
DDC 947.560492/4—dc23/eng/20220210
LC record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021058954
LC ebook record available at https://lccn.loc.gov/2021058955
DOI: 10.1093/oso/9780197582077.001.0001
Contents
Preface
Acknowledgments
Introduction
Abbreviations
Notes
Bibliography
Index of Personal, Ethnic, and Geographical Names
Preface
Uel propinquam sororem fas esse non alienam sicut fili noe post transactum
cataclysmum respexerunt / 290 / sibi loca in qua aedificarent sibi civitates,
nuncupantes eas in nomine uxorum suarum, quorum similitudinem et isti
iugati consumant.
Now, it is not lawful for a closely related sister to be estranged: just as the
sons of Noah, after the passing of the flood, sought out places for themselves
in which they could build cities for themselves, naming them in the name of
their wives, so that those married to their sister also use the sameness of the
places’ [names].52
2. In an Armenian apocryphal retelling of the early history of humankind, we
read that Masis was the mountain upon which the Ark rested. “55 And Noah,
after receiving God’s blessing, descended the mountain and dwelt in Akoṙi.
56 When his seed multiplied, they went down to Iǰewan and 57 they filled the
first dwelling [nax iǰewan], and in such a way they filled the earth. 58 And the
name of the place was called Naxiǰewan, and that is Noah’s tomb. 58 Such it
is until today.”53 Here, biblical events are connected with Armenian
geography; Armenian names are used and distinct onomastic etiologies are
invoked. Thus, the name Իջեւան Iǰewan is connected with the Armenian
word իջանեմ “to descend” combined with avan “village” or even with
ōt‘ewan “lodgings,” meaning “dwelling of descent,” while Naxiǰewan, a
different place, is understood to embody նախ “first,” and so “dwelling of the
first descent.”54 Moreover, the place of their initial descent is identified as a
site in Armenia called Akoṙi, at the foot of Mount Ararat. According to the
Armenian tradition, thence they moved to Naxiǰewan, which city actually still
exists. So, though the immediate building of a city is not mentioned explicitly,
a well-known city is said to be the first place in which Noah’s family dwelled
permanently upon leaving the Ark, which idea is buttressed by a popular
etymology.55
When he was suffered to escape after his attempt upon Brant’s life
in the private room at Elitch’s, James Harding tarried in Denver only
so long as the leaving time of the first westward bound train
constrained him. Nevertheless, he went as one driven, and with
black rage in his heart, adding yet another tally to the score of his
account against the man who had banished him.
But, like Noah’s dove, he was destined to find no rest for the sole of
his foot. Having very painstakingly worn out his welcome in the
larger mining camps, he was minded to go to Silverette, hoping to
pick a living out of the frequenters of Gaynard’s. Unluckily, he was
known also in Silverette; and unluckily again, word of his coming
preceded him from Carbonado, the railway station nearest to the
isolated camp at the foot of Jack Mountain. Harding walked up from
Carbonado, was met at a sharp turn in the wagon road by a
committee from the camp above, and was persuaded by arguments
in which levelled rifles played a silent but convincing part to retrace
his steps.
Returning to Carbonado, his shrift was but a hand’s breadth longer.
On the second day, when he was but barely beginning to draw
breath of respite, he was recognised as the slayer of one William
Johnson, was seized, dragged into the street, and after an
exceedingly trying half hour was escorted out of camp and across
the range by a guard of honour with drawn weapons.
Under such discouragements he promptly determined to face the ills
he knew, drank deeply at the well of desperation, and, making a
forced march to the nearest railway station, boarded the first train for
Denver. It was a hazardous thing to do. Brant was a man of his word,
and the banished one had known him to go to extremities upon
slighter provocation. But, on the other hand, Denver was a
considerable city, and their ways might easily lie apart in it.
Moreover, if the worst should come, it was but man to man, with
plenty of old scores to speed the bullet of self-defence.
So reasoning, Harding stepped from the train at the Denver Union
Station in the gray dawn of an October morning, Argus-eyed, and
with his hand deep buried in the pocket of his ulster. The time was
auspicious, and he reached a near-by lodging house without mishap.
Through one long day he remained in hiding, but after dark, when
the prowling instinct got the better of prudence, he ventured out. In a
kennel some degrees lower in the scale descending than Draco’s he
met a man of his own kidney whom he had once known in the
camps, and who was but now fresh from the Aspen district and from
an outpost therein known as Taggett’s Gulch.
This man drank with Harding, and when his tongue was a little
loosened by the liquor grew reminiscent. Did the Professor recall the
killing of a man in the Gulch a year or so back—a man named
Benton, or Brinton? Harding had good cause to remember it, and he
went gray with fear and listened with a thuggish demon of
suffocation waylaying his breath. Assuredly, everybody remembered.
What of it? Nothing much, save that the brother of the murdered man
was in Colorado with the avowed intention of finding and hanging the
murderer, if money and an inflexible purpose might contribute to that
end.
That was the gist of the matter, and when Harding had pumped his
informant dry, he shook the man off and went out to tramp the streets
until he had fairly taken the measure of the revived danger. Summed
up, it came to this: sooner or later the avenger of blood would hear of
Brant, and after that the end would come swiftly and the carpenters
might safely begin to build the gallows for the slayer of Henry
Brinton. Harding had a vivid and disquieting picture of the swift
sequence of events. The brother would find Brant, and the latter
would speedily clear up the mystery and give the avenger the proofs.
Then the detective machinery would be set in motion, and thereafter
the murderer would find no lurking place secret enough to hide him.
Clearly something must be done, and that quickly. Concealment was
the first necessity; James Harding must disappear at once and
effectually. That preliminary safely got over, two sharp corners
remained to be turned at whatever cost. The incriminating evidence
now in Brant’s hands must be secured and destroyed, and Brant
himself must be silenced before the avenger of blood should find and
question him.
The disguise was a simple matter. At one time in his somewhat
checkered career Harding had been a supernumerary in a Leadville
variety theatre. Hence, the smooth-shaven, well-dressed man who
paid his bill at the Blake Street lodging house at ten o’clock that night
bore small likeness to the bearded and rather rustic-looking person
who engaged a room a few minutes later at a German Gasthaus in
West Denver. The metamorphosis wrought out in artistic detail,
Harding put it at once to the severest test. Going out again, he
sought and found the man from Taggett’s Gulch, and was
unrecognised. Introducing himself as a farmer from Iowa, he
persuaded the man to pilot him through the mazes of the Denver
underworld, and when he had met and talked with a dozen others
who knew the Professor rather better than he knew himself, he went
back to the West Side Gasthaus with a comforting abatement of the
symptoms of strangulation.
Having thus purchased temporary safety, the castaway began
presently to look about him for the means to the more important end.
Night after night he haunted the purlieus, hoping that a lucky chance
might reveal Brant’s whereabouts. But inasmuch as Brant was yet
walking straitly, nothing came of this, and in his new character
Harding could not consistently ask questions. Twice he met William
Langford face to face, and, knowing that the boy could probably give
him Brant’s street and number, he was about to risk an interview with
his protégé in his proper person when the god of evil-doers gave him
a tool exactly fitted to his hand.
It was on the Sunday evening of Brant’s relapse. Harding had been
making his usual round, and at Draco’s he met a man whose face he
recognised despite its gauntness and the change wrought by the
razor. A drink or two broke the ice of unfamiliarity, and then Harding
led the way to a card room in the rear on the pretext of seeking a
quiet place where they might drink more to their better acquaintance.
In the place of withdrawal Harding kept up the fiction of bucolic
simplicity only while the waiter was bringing a bottle and glasses.
Then he said: “I reckon you’d be willing to swear you had never seen
me before, wouldn’t you, Gasset?”
The big man gone thin was in the act of pouring himself another
drink, but he put the bottle down and gave evidence of a guilty
conscience by starting from his chair, ready for flight or fight as the
occasion might require.
“Who the blazes are you, anyway?” he demanded, measuring the
distance to the door in a swift glance aside.
Harding pulled off the wig and beard and leered across at him. “Does
that help you out any?”
Gasset sprang to his feet with a terror-oath choking him and
retreated backward to the door, hand on weapon.
“Don’t you do it, Jim!” he gasped. “Don’t, I say. I never meant to hurt
her—any of ’em will swear to that!”
Harding struck a match and relighted his cigar. He did it with leisurely
thoroughness, turning the match this way and that and ignoring his
quarry much as a cat ignores a mouse which can by no means
escape. Gasset stood as one fascinated, watching every movement
of the slim fingers and feeling blindly behind him for the knob of the
door. Whereat Harding laughed mockingly and pointed to the bottle
on the table.
“You had better come back here and take a little more of the same to
stiffen your nerve, Ike. You couldn’t hit the broad side of a barn just
now.”
Gasset found the doorknob finally and breathed freer when it yielded
under his hand. “Give me a show for my life, Jim!” he begged,
widening the opening behind him by stealthy half inches. “It ain’t
worth much, but, by God, I want it for a little while yet!”
Harding laughed again. “What is the matter with you? You would
have been a dead man long ago if I had wanted to drop you. Come
back here and finish your drink.”
Having more than once set his life over against his thirst, Gasset did
it once again, filling his glass with hands that shook, and swallowing
the drunkard’s portion at a gulp. The liquor steadied him a little and
he sat down.
“Then you ain’t out gunning for me?” he ventured.
“No; what made you think I was?”
Gasset scratched his head and tilted the bottle again. “I don’t know, if
you don’t. But it appears like to me, if anybody had killed a sister of
mine I’d want to get square. And I reckon I wouldn’t split any hairs
about his being drunk or sober at the time, nor yet about whether he
went for to do it meaningly or just did it by happen-so.”
Harding ignored the implied reproach and went on to the more
important matter:
“Damn that! It is enough for me to know that you were trying to kill
George Brant,” he said coolly. “Do you still feel that way?”
Gasset rose unsteadily and the dull eyes of him glowed in their
sockets. “Look at me now, Jim, and then recollect, if you can, what-
all I used to be. You know what that was; not any man in the camp
could put me on my back unless I was drunk. And now look at me—
a poor, miser’ble, broke-up wrack, just out o’ the horspital! He done it
—filled me plum full of lead when I was too crazy drunk to see
single; that’s what he done!”
“Then I suppose you wouldn’t be sorry if you had the chance to even
up with him,” said Harding, hastily building up a plan which would
enable him to make use of this opportune ally.
“Now you are talking! Say, Jim, I’m hanging on to what little scrap of
life he has left me for just nothing else. Understand?”
“Good; that is business,” quoth Harding. “I am with you to stay. Find
him for me, and I’ll help you square the deal.”
“Find him?” echoed Gasset. “Why, man alive, he is right out yonder
at the faro table! You rubbed up against him coming in here!”
“The devil you say!” Harding hastily resumed the wig and the false
beard, with a word explanatory. “He mustn’t recognise me, or the
game will be up before it begins. Pull up your chair and we’ll talk this
thing over.”
Half an hour later the two conspirators left the card room and made
their way singly through the crowd in the game room to meet at the
bar. Gasset had lingered a moment at Brant’s elbow, and, having
seen the winnings, incautiously spoke of them to Harding in Tom
Deverney’s hearing. Harding shook his head, and dragged his
companion out to the sidewalk.
“You will have to look out for Deverney—the barkeeper,” he said. “He
is Brant’s friend. The first thing is to find out where he sleeps. We’ll
go over to the other corner and wait for him till he comes out.”
CHAPTER XVI
THE GOODLY COMPANY OF MISERY
Having gone so far astray on the Sunday, it was inevitable that Brant
should awake repentant and remorseful on the Monday. He slept
late, and when he had breakfasted like a monk and had gone
downtown to face another day of enforced idleness in his office,
conscience rose up and began to ply its many-thonged whip.
What a thrice-accursed fool he had made of himself, and how
completely he had justified Mrs. Langford’s opinion of him! How
infinitely unworthy the love of any good woman he was, and how
painstakingly he had put his future beyond the hope of redemption! If
Colonel Bowran would only come back and leave him free to go and
bury himself in some unheard-of corner of the world! This was the
burden of each fresh outburst of self-recrimination.
So much by way of remorse, but when he thought of Dorothy,
something like a measure of dubious gratitude was mingled
therewith—a certain thankfulness that the trial of his good
resolutions had come before he had been given the possible chance
of free speech with her—a chance which might have involved her
happiness as well as his own peace of mind.
“Good Lord!” he groaned, flinging himself into a chair and tossing his
half-burned cigar out of the window. “I ought to be glad that I found
myself out before I had time to pull her into it. If they had let me go
on, and she would have listened to me, I should have married her
out of hand—married an angel, and I with a whole nest of devils
asleep in me waiting only for a chance to come alive! God help me!
I’m worse than I thought I was—infinitely worse.—Come in!” This last
to some one at the door.
It was only the postman, and Brant took the letters eagerly, hoping to
find one from Hobart. He was disappointed, but there was another
note from the end-of-track on the Condorra Extension, setting forth
that the chief engineer’s home-coming would be delayed yet other
days.
Brant read the colonel’s scrawl, and what was left of his endurance
took flight in an explosion of bad language. A minute later he burst
into Antrim’s office.
“Where is Mr. Craig?” he demanded.
“He has gone to Ogden,” said Antrim, wondering what had happened
to disturb the serenity of the self-contained draughtsman.
“The devil he has! When will he be back?”
“I don’t know—the last of the week, maybe.”
“Damn!”
Antrim laughed. “What ails you this morning? You look as if you’d
had a bad night. Come inside and sit down—if you’re not too busy.”
Brant let himself in at the wicket in the counter-railing and drew up a
chair.
“I am not busy enough—that is one of the miseries. And I want you
to help me out, Harry. You have full swing here when the old man is
away, haven’t you?”
“Why—yes, after a fashion. What has broke loose?”
Brant looked askance at the stenographer, and the chief clerk rightly
interpreted the glance.
“O John,” he said, “I wish you would take these letters down and put
them on No. 3. Hand them to the baggageman yourself, and then
you’ll be sure they have gone.” And when the door closed behind the
young man he turned back to Brant. “Was that what you wanted?”
“Yes, but I don’t know as it was necessary. There is nothing
particularly private about what I want to say. You see, it is this way:
Colonel Bowran is out on the Extension, and Grotter is with him. I am
alone here in the office, and I’ve got to leave town suddenly. What I
want you to do is to put somebody in there to keep house till the
colonel returns.”
The chief clerk smiled. “It must be something pretty serious to rattle
you that way,” was his comment. “You are a good enough railroad
man to know that my department has nothing to do with yours,
except to ask questions of it. And that reminds me: here is a letter
from the general manager asking if we have a late map of the
Denver yards. The president is coming west in a day or two, and
there is a plan on foot for extensions, I believe.”
“Well?” said Brant.
“It isn’t well—it’s ill. We haven’t any such map, and I don’t see but
what you will have to stay and make one.”
Now, to a man in Brant’s peculiar frame of mind employment was
only one degree less welcome than immediate release. Wherefore
he caught at the suggestion so readily that Antrim was puzzled.
“I thought you had to go away, whether or no,” he said curiously.
“Oh, I suppose I can put it off if I have to,” Brant rejoined, trying to
hedge.
“Which is another way of telling me to mind my own business,”
retorted Antrim good-naturedly. “That’s all right; only, if you have
struck a bone, you can comfort yourself with the idea that you have
plenty of good company. No one of us has a monopoly of all the
trouble in the world.”
“No, I suppose not.” Brant said so much, and then got far enough
away from his own trouble to notice that the chief clerk was looking
haggard and seedy.
“You look as if you had been taking a turn at the windlass yourself,
Harry. Have you?”
“Yes, something of that sort,” replied Antrim, but he turned quickly to
the papers on his desk.
“Nothing that I can help you figure out, is it?”
“No,” said the chief clerk, so savagely that Brant smiled.