Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Architectural Conservation of The Rock-Hewn Church
Architectural Conservation of The Rock-Hewn Church
Architectural Conservation of The Rock-Hewn Church
DOI: https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2023.67.07.12
How to Cite:
Richard, F.N., & Golkarian, Sh. (2023). Architectural conservation of the rock-hewn churches of Lalibela, Ethiopia: A study on
preservation and socio-economic conservation. Amazonia Investiga, 12(67), 127-138. https://doi.org/10.34069/AI/2023.67.07.12
Written by:
F. Nonyelum Richard1
https://orcid.org/0009-0008-5810-6787
Sh. Golkarian2
https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1858-0133
Abstract Abstrait
The 11 monolithic structures that makeup Les 11 structures monolithiques qui composent les
Ethiopia's Rock-Hewn structures in Lalibela were structures éthiopiennes taillées dans la roche à
painstakingly cut out of solid rock in the 12th Lalibela ont été minutieusement découpées dans la
century. Currently, these churches are facing roche solide au 12ème siècle. Ces églises sont
various issues of deterioration such as exposure to actuellement confrontées à divers problèmes de
natural and human-caused harms. This article détérioration, tels que l'exposition aux éléments et les
critically evaluates the architectural conservation dommages naturels et causés par l'homme. Cet article
initiatives made to preserve these amazing évalue de manière critique les initiatives de
buildings, which are often recognized as some of conservation architecturale prises pour préserver ces
the most astounding architectural accomplishments bâtiments étonnants, qui sont souvent reconnus
in history. It carefully examines the preservation comme l'une des réalisations architecturales les plus
techniques used, highlighting their cultural étonnantes de l'histoire. Il examine attentivement les
relevance and the inherent values crucial for techniques de préservation utilisées, soulignant leur
maintaining the Lalibela rock-hewn churches. pertinence culturelle et les valeurs inhérentes
Through the socio-economical aspects, it draws cruciales pour le maintien des églises creusées dans
attention to the lack of funding and lack of technical le roc de Lalibela. A travers les aspects socio-
requirements. Also, sustainable conservation économiques, il attire l'attention sur le manque de
activities develop a sense of ownership and bring financement et le manque d'exigences techniques.
awareness to the value of protecting cultural L'étude utilise une méthodologie de recherche
heritage. The report suggests methods for qualitative axée sur des études de cas approfondies de
strengthening capability and creating a special Lalibela, d'autres structures taillées dans la roche et
conservation fund. The study uses a qualitative des travaux universitaires publiés. Nos recherches
research methodology focusing on in-depth case offrent des suggestions précieuses pour encourager
studies from Lalibela, other rock-cut structures, and des techniques de conservation efficaces. Enfin, ces
published academic works. As a result, this research observations contribuent à une meilleure
offers valuable suggestions to encourage efficient compréhension des défis de la préservation des
conservation techniques. Finally, these héritages architecturaux du monde en fournissant des
observations contribute to a greater comprehension références utiles pour des sites analogues confrontés
of the challenges in preserving the world's à des défis de conservation similaires.
architectural legacies by providing helpful
references for analogous sites facing similar Palabras clave: Patrimoine culturel, Conservation,
conservation challenges. Préservation, Éthiopie, Églises rupestres.
1
Department of Architecture, Near East University, Near East University, Near East Boulevard, Nicosia, Turkey.
Researcher ID: JDD-3692-2023
2
Department of Architecture, Near East University, Near East University, Near East Boulevard, Nicosia, Turkey.
Researcher ID: GZA-9671-2022
Introduction
One of the most outstanding instances of This study's objectives are to examine the
monolithic construction in the world is thought to difficulties in conserving the rock-hewn churches
be the rock-hewn churches of Lalibela, a of Lalibela, discuss current conservation
UNESCO World Heritage Site in northern techniques, and suggest upcoming preservation
Ethiopia. These churches, which were carved out plans. The purpose of the study is to shed light on
of solid rock and constructed in the 12th century, practical conservation measures that can
are works of art. However, the churches have guarantee the survival of rock-hewn churches for
been dealing with substantial conservation issues the coming generations.
because of both natural weathering and human
activity, therefore it is essential to design a The focus of this study is on the preservation of
thorough and long-term plan for their the rock-hewn buildings of Lalibela, a UNESCO
preservation and upkeep. Preserving the Lalibela World Heritage Site in northern Ethiopia. The
rock-hewn churches is crucial for Ethiopia and study's objectives are to examine the difficulties
the rest of the globe. To create successful in conserving historic churches, talk about
preservation plans, specialists in the field of present conservation techniques, and suggest
architectural conservation have been upcoming preservation plans. The scope of the
collaborating closely with local governments and study includes a look at how the churches'
communities. (UNESCO World Heritage Center, structural integrity is affected by human activity,
2021). natural weathering processes, and the role that
experts in architectural conservation play in
The study aims to shed light on practical creating long-term preservation plans. The main
conservation measures that can guarantee the objective of the project is to develop efficient
survival of the rock-hewn churches of Lalibela, conservation techniques that can guarantee the
Ethiopia, for the coming generations. With data survival of rock-hewn churches for future
and research gathered, using the qualitative generations (Janssens, 2017).
research approach, from published works, this
study reveals the dire need of the Lalibela rock- Theoretical Framework or Literature Review
hewn churches in conservation works to protect
their historical importance. The structural Architectural conservation
stability and integrity of the site are being
impacted by natural forces including weathering, The process of preserving, restoring, and
erosion, and geological instability as well as maintaining buildings or structures with
human-caused elements like tourism, architectural and historical significance is
urbanization, and vandalism. (Kumar et al., referred to as architectural conservation. Keeping
2020) Numerous conservation initiatives have these structures functioning and aesthetically
started because of these difficulties to guarantee pleasing while preserving their historical value
the site's preservation for future generations. The and character is the aim of architectural
natural weathering process is one of the biggest conservation. Architectural conservation is
obstacles to preserving the rock-hewn cathedrals described as "all actions aimed at safeguarding
of Lalibela, (Renzulli et al., 2011). The soft the value and integrity of the architecture, and the
volcanic tuff used to construct the churches is environment in which it was created, including
prone to deterioration from wind, water, and artistic, historical, cultural, social, and technical
other natural variables. Furthermore, the aspects" by the International Council on
churches' structural integrity has significantly Monuments and Sites (ICOMOS, 2010). The
deteriorated because they were exposed to the necessity to strike a balance between
elements for over 800 years, (Ebabey & Zeleke, preservation and transformation is one of the
2023). Experts in the field of architectural major topics of architectural conservation. To
conservation have been developing numerous prevent harming the structure's historic integrity
preservation solutions to deal with these issues. or that of the surrounding area, any alterations
These tactics include safeguarding the churches must be properly planned and carried out. This
from additional environmental harm, restoring calls for a thorough comprehension of the legacy
the original structural integrity of the buildings resource's historical, cultural, and social value as
using non-invasive methods, and fostering well as a team effort involving stakeholders,
sustainable tourism to support regional economic subject matter specialists, and the larger
growth while also preserving the site. community (Jokilehto, 2017). The use of
(Gebregziabher, 2020). appropriate materials and methods is an
important component of architectural
conservation. Feilden (2003) asserts that because architectural conservation initiatives across
they have stood the test of time and are better a variety of industries, including
suited to the original design and construction architecture, engineering, construction,
processes, older materials and construction historic preservation, and tourism. For
methods are frequently more compatible with restoration and conservation work, skilled
heritage structures and locations than modern labor and specialized knowledge are needed,
ones. Trillo et al., (2021) point out the use and which promotes job growth and the
role of digital technologies to replace preservation of traditional crafts and skills.
conventional methods, because they offer the − Tourism and cultural heritage: Historic
possibility to integrate multiple layers of structures that have been preserved and
information and to link across industries, cultural heritage sites are popular tourist
communities and higher education with a destinations. Through visitor spending on
flexibility and timelessness that traditional things like admission fees, guided tours,
techniques like paper-based could not trinkets, and hospitality services, this
demonstrate. In particular, HBIM offers the tourism potential brings in money for local
chance to connect a variety of information about economies. Architectural conservation
heritage assets and convey it to multidisciplinary supports cultural tourism, aids in the
professionals in the form of BIM models, protection and promotion of cultural assets,
embedding important characteristics of historic and fosters a sense of pride and identity
structures while allowing designers to easily among the local population
gather and reassemble information. These tools (Gražulevičiūtė–Vileniškė & Urbonas et al.,
can help with the planning and implementation 2011).
of conservation actions as well as offer new ways − Community development and revitalization:
to interact with cultural places. However, the Valuing cultural heritage can be done in
necessity to maintain the authenticity and various ways. One way is through the
integrity of the heritage resource must be emotional and aesthetic pleasure that people
balanced with the use of technology. Community get from visiting heritage sites. Another way
involvement and engagement is another is through the economic benefits that they
important aspect in architectural conservation. In bring, such as generating revenue, creating
order to ensure that local people' beliefs, jobs, and providing training opportunities.
opinions, and needs are taken into account, it is Preserving cultural heritage can also create
crucial to include them in the conservation economic benefits, such as city center
process. Community involvement can promote a revitalization, heritage tourism, an increase
sense of ownership and responsibility for cultural in property values, and small business
property as well as increase public awareness of incubation. The priority in economic
and support for conservation activities development is to create jobs and local
(Cameron, 2013). household income, which can be achieved
by rehabilitating historic buildings. This
Socio-economic aspects of conservation creates a substantial economic impact on
jobs and income since the labor required for
Several socioeconomic factors that are important building rehabilitation is high. Jobs in
to consider are included in architectural cultural heritage preservation are generally
conservation. These elements can be examined well-paid, and there is a shortage of the
from a variety of angles: required skills. The preservation of cultural
heritage also contributes to city center
− Economic Impact: The local and regional revitalization. Heritage tourism is another
economies are significantly impacted by economic benefit generated by cultural
architectural conservation. The creation of heritage, as it is becoming one of the leading
jobs and economic prosperity are frequently sectors in the post-industrial economy. The
brought about by preservation efforts. effect of cultural heritage on property values
Tourist spending on lodging, food, is significant. Research shows that there is a
transportation, and related services can statistically significant price premium
increase when historic buildings draw associated with the inclusion of a property in
visitors In addition to increasing property a historic district. Cultural heritage also
prices and luring businesses, conservation plays a role in small business incubation,
activities can also help the economy recover which is crucial for the local economy. The
(Donovan, 2008). adaptation of historic buildings to modern
− Job creation and skills preservation: needs without harming their physical
Employment possibilities are created by structure and architectural character is
terms in architectural conservation are shafts, and social areas. Jordan's Petra region is
conservation, restoration, preservation, and home to stunning rock-cut tombs, temples, and
rehabilitation. These terms are specified by facades that are sculpted from sandstone cliffs
worldwide charters, guidelines, and standards. that are rose in color.
Since ancient times, rock-hewn buildings have Cappadocia, located in central Turkey, is home
captured people's attention because they provide to a unique landscape of volcanic rock
a fascinating look at the architectural prowess of formations that have been shaped by erosion over
earlier civilizations. Around the world, rock-cut time. The area is particularly renowned for its
cathedrals provide evidence of the creativity and large network of cave settlements and
flexibility of past civilizations. They offer underground civilizations that were carved out of
insightful understandings of the architectural, the pliable volcanic tuff. Since the time of the
ecclesiastical, and cultural activities of their time. Hittites, Cappadocia's rock-hewn buildings have
There is magnificent architecture carved out of served a range of functions, including houses,
solid rock in addition to the churches of Lalibela. monasteries, and places of worship (Hazel &
Other places of the world, such as the Andus, 2006). The Göreme Open Air Museum, a
Cappadocia region of Turkey and the Petra site UNESCO World Heritage Site, is one of
in Jordan, have similar constructions and are two Cappadocia's most well-known examples of a
famous places renowned for their amazing rock- rock-hewn building. A collection of cave
cut architecture. Like the churches in Lalibela, churches and monasteries from the 10th and 11th
these structures present unique conservation and centuries are on display at the museum. These
management challenges. Known for its bizarre structures are painted with paintings that depict
terrain of cone-shaped rock formations and host scenes from the Bible. The site's conservation
to a vast network of underground cities, efforts have concentrated on preserving the
churches, and monasteries is the Cappadocia frescoes from light and moisture damage,
region of Turkey. These inventively constructed strengthening the rock walls, and restricting
buildings, which were carved into soft volcanic public access to lessen wear and strain on the
rocks, have elaborate tunnel systems, ventilation buildings.
Figure 3. Facade of the treasury (khazneh), photo obtained from: Burak, J. (2015 Oct 15).
Study area the nation's capital. The town is famed for its
monolithic churches that were carved out of rock
Background Information on Lalibela and were constructed in the 12th century under
the rule of King Lalibela.
Lalibela is a town in northern Ethiopia's Amhara
region, about 260 kilometers from Addis Ababa,
One of the world's greatest architectural wonders The Rock-Hewn Churches of Lalibela
is thought to be the churches of Lalibela, which
were hewn out of solid rock. There are a total of The village of Lalibela in northern Ethiopia is
11 churches, each with a distinctive architectural home to a collection of 11 monolithic churches
style and spiritual value. A network of tunnels known as the Rock-hewn churches of Lalibela.
and trenches that the priests and worshippers The churches, which were constructed in the 12th
utilized as a means of transportation connects the century under the rule of King Lalibela, are
churches. Lalibela's churches are viewed as a regarded as one of the seven wonders of the
representation of Ethiopia's extensive cultural world. Each church has a distinctive design and
and religious history. They also serve as a tribute a special religious meaning. They were cut out of
to the resourcefulness and inventiveness of the solid rock. A network of tunnels and trenches that
individuals who constructed them using only the priests and worshippers utilized as a means of
rudimentary equipment and their bare hands. The transportation connects the churches. (UNESCO,
churches of Lalibela were designated a UNESCO 2023).
World Heritage Site in 1978 in recognition of
their historical and cultural importance. • Some churches from the north cluster of
Lalibella
Figure 6. Bet Medhane Alem (House of the Saviour of the World), (Brilliant Ethiopia1, 2021)
Figure 7. Bet Maryam (House of Mary), photo obtained from: (Brilliant Ethiopia1, 2021)
Figure 8. Bet Golgotha and Mikael, photo obtained from: (Brilliant Ethiopia1, 2021)
The Lalibela rock-hewn churches are evidence of cultural importance. The churches are referred to
the ingenuity and inventiveness of those who as "a remarkable testimony to the architectural
constructed them. The only equipment and and engineering skills of the ancient Ethiopians"
methods used to build the churches were chisels by the UNESCO World Heritage Centre, who
and hammers. The architects of the cathedrals also says that they "are outstanding examples of
were able to cut beautiful architectural details a unique form of religious architecture."
from the rock that are still highly regarded today. (UNESCO, 2021) The Lalibela rock-hewn
Both religious and cultural values may be found chapels still draw tourists from all over the world
in the rock-hewn churches of Lalibela. For the today. The churches are well-liked tourist
Ethiopian Orthodox Church, the churches are a attractions, and tourists flock there to take in the
significant place of pilgrimage, and thousands of magnificent architecture and discover more
people travel there each year to participate in about Ethiopia's fascinating history and culture.
religious festivals and festivities. The churches The town of Lalibela has a strong tourist
are a source of national pride and a representation economy, with hotels, eateries, and gift shops
of Ethiopia's rich cultural heritage. (UNESCO, attracting tourists.
2023). The Lalibela rock-hewn churches were
designated a UNESCO World Heritage Site in • Some churches from the south cluster of
1978 in recognition of their historical and Lalibella
Figure 9. Bet Gabriel Raphael (House of Gabriel Raphael), obtained from: (Brilliant Ethiopia1, 2021)
Figure 10. Bet Abba Libanos (House of Abbot Libanos) and Bet Leham, obtained from: (Brilliant
Ethiopia1, 2021)
Figure 10. Bet Emanuel (house of Emmanuel), obtained from: (Brilliant Ethiopia1, 2021)
installation of protective barriers, and other − Religious value: The Lalibela rock-hewn
steps to lessen the impact of visitors on the churches are revered by the local populace
structures to reduce this damage. (UNESCO and are significant places of pilgrimage for
World Heritage Center, 2021) the Ethiopian Orthodox Church. Numerous
− The development of proper conservation pilgrims visit them annually as they are
rules and practices is another aspect of thought to be the earthly representation of
maintaining the Lalibela rock-hewn the New Jerusalem. The preservation of
churches. This could entail the creation of these buildings is crucial for upholding the
policies and rules for the administration and site's religious significance and its status as
preservation of the churches as well as the a place of worship.
creation of educational initiatives for both − Touristic value: The Rock-hewn churches
residents and professionals working in the of Lalibela are one of Ethiopia's most
field of conservation. It might also entail important tourist attractions and are visited
creating outreach and educational initiatives by thousands of people from around the
meant to spread knowledge about the value world each year. The conservation of these
of churches and their cultural relevance. structures is important for preserving their
(UNESCO World Heritage Center, 2021) tourism value and ensuring that they
− Involving local communities in continue to attract visitors and contribute to
conservation efforts is crucial to ensuring the the local economy.
long-term viability of conservation efforts.
This can be done by creating community- Cultural significance
based conservation initiatives that work with
residents to design, carry out, and monitor The rock-hewn chapels of Lalibela are highly
conservation efforts. This strategy can revered across Ethiopia and the rest of the world.
promote a sense of ownership and These cathedrals are regarded as UNESCO
responsibility for the preservation of the World Heritage sites and are among the most
churches as well as aid in increasing local significant historical and cultural monuments in
capacity for conservation activities. Ethiopia. The churches, which were built in the
(ICOMOS, 1983) 12th and 13th centuries, are renowned for their
distinctive architectural style, which includes
Significant Values for Their Conservation fine carvings and frescoes carved straight into the
live rock. The Rock-hewn churches of Lalibela
The religious, historical, and cultural should be preserved for their historical relevance
significance of Lalibela's rock-hewn churches in addition to their spiritual and religious
makes their preservation crucial. These values importance. The churches shed light on
consist of: Ethiopia's medieval religious and cultural
traditions as well as the period's engineering and
− Cultural value: The rock-hewn cathedrals architectural techniques. Therefore, preserving
of Lalibela are outstanding examples of these churches is crucial for the historical and
Ethiopia's architectural legacy, which has cultural heritage of Ethiopia, as well as for the
evolved over centuries and displays a special education and appreciation of coming
synthesis of indigenous and foreign generations. Beyond their religious and historical
influences. The elaborate carvings and significance, Lalibela's rock-hewn churches have
decorations on the churches, which represent a significant cultural impact. Additionally, these
the aesthetic and cultural heritage of the churches are a significant representation of
area, are highly noteworthy. For this cultural Ethiopia's history and culture. They stand for
treasure to be preserved for future inventiveness, creativity, steadfast faith, and
generations, these structures must be devotion to the cultural traditions of the people
conserved. who built them. Therefore, it is crucial that these
− Historical value: It is thought that King churches are preserved if Ethiopia's rich cultural
Lalibela ordered the construction of the heritage is to be recognized and respected both
rock-hewn churches in Lalibela in the 12th domestically and internationally.
century. They are important as a
representation of Ethiopia's medieval Conclusions
civilization as well as a tribute to the
creativity and technical know-how of the An interdisciplinary endeavor called
builders. The preservation of these buildings architectural conservation aims to sustain the
is crucial for maintaining this significant historical relevance, artistic value, and
portion of Ethiopia's heritage. functioning of existing structures. A unique