Professional Documents
Culture Documents
EY Managing Complexity and Change in A New Landscape
EY Managing Complexity and Change in A New Landscape
EY Managing Complexity and Change in A New Landscape
FF For or ouror
ourourlatest
latest latest survey
survey
survey onon asset
onasset management
asset management
management investment • Investors,
investment •• Investors,
Investors, regulators,
regulators, boards
regulators, boards and andsenior
senior
boards management
management
and senior areare
operations,
operations, wewe contacted
contacted chiefchiefoperating
operating officers
officers demanding
demanding moremore transparency
transparency and andreporting,
reporting, including
including
investment
(COOs)
(COOs) and operations,
and heads
heads of ofinvestmentwe
investment contacted
operations
operations chief
at at new management
new approaches
approaches to to are
riskrisk demanding
management
management and and more
governance,
governance, as as
operating
traditional
traditional asset
assetofficers
managers.
managers. (COOs)
WeWe spoke
spokeand
with heads
with4040 leading of asset
leading asset atransparency
a result
resultof of
thethe rapidly
rapidly and
evolving reporting,
evolving global,
global, including
regional
regional and and
local
local
managers
managers in the
in the Americas
Americas and andEurope
Europe withwith
assets
assets under
under regulatory
regulatory and andmarket
market landscape.
landscape.
investment operations at traditional asset new approaches to risk management
management
management (AUM) (AUM) spanning
spanning US$5US$5 billion
billion
to to
moremore than
than
managers.
US$1US$1trillion,
trillion,
with We
with spoke
thethemajority
majority with
of of 40
respondents leading
respondents managingglobal
managing • and
Pressures
• Pressures governance,
to to
reduce
reduce costs
costs asand
and aimprove
result
improve of
margins theareare
margins
asset
between
between managers
US$50US$50 billion
billionheadquartered
and andUS$500
US$500 billion.
billion.inOur
Our the
survey
survey seeks causing
seeks causing
rapidlyfirmsfirms to tofocus
evolving focusonon operational
operational
global, efficiency
regional efficiency and
and and
local
to to
provide
provide insight
insight into intofour
fourprimary
primary questions:
questions: rationalize
rationalize theirtheirexisting
existing product
product suite
suiteand and asset
assetclasses.
classes.
Americas and Europe with assets under regulatory and market landscape.
• What
• What areare
management thethe marketmarket forces
(AUM) forces and and
spanningkeykey drivers
drivers
US$5causing
causing asset • Rapid
asset
billion
• Rapid technology
technology advancements
advancements fromfrom software
software vendors
vendors
managers
managers to to assess
assess and andalteraltertheir
their
existing
existingoperating
operating andandthird-party
third-party assetassetservicers
servicers have have enabled
enabled firms
firmsto to
tomodels,
more than US$1 trillion, with the majority • reduce
Pressures
reduce infrastructure
infrastructure to reduce
complexity
complexity costs
and and and
costcostbyimprove
by
rationalizing
rationalizing Alex
Alex
Alex
Birkin Birkin
Birkin lan
Alan
Alan
FishFish
Fish
models, operations
operations and andsupporting
supporting technologies?
technologies? Partner
Partner
andand
Global
Global
Wealth
Wealth
& & Partner
Partner
andand
Americas
Americas
Wealth
Wealth
& &
thethe
number
number of ofapplications,
applications, which
which hashas increased Partner and Partner and
of respondents managing between margins are causing firms toincreased
focusthe onthe Asset
Asset
Management
Management Advisory
Advisory Asset
Asset
Management
Management Advisory
Advisory
• What
• What arearethethe keykey areas
areas of offocus,
focus, including
including firmfirmpriorities
priorities opportunities
opportunities forfor outsourcing.
outsourcing. Global Wealth & Asset Americas
Leader,
Leader,
Ernst &Wealth
ErnstYoung & LLP
& Young
LLPAsset
US$50
and and billion and US$500 billion. Our
investments?
investments? operational efficiency and rationalize their Leader, Leader,
Ernst
Ernst
& Young
& Young
Management Advisory
LLP
LLP
Management Advisory
These
These complex
complex forces
forces require
require firms
firms to toimplement
implement enterprise-
enterprise-
survey
• What
• What areare
seeks
thethe
to provide
similarities
similarities and and
insightbetween
differences
differences
into
between
foursmall,
small,
existing product suite and asset classes. Leader, Ernst & Young LLP Leader, Ernst & Young LLP
wide
widetransformational
transformational change
change spanning
spanning people,
people, processes
processes
primary
medium
medium and questions:
andlarge large asset
assetmanagers,
managers, including
including geographic
geographic and and
controls,
controls, data,
data, and and
business
business applications.
applications. OurOur survey
survey
nuances?
nuances? • Rapid
indicates
indicates that
that technology
leading
leading asset
asset advancements
management
management firms
firmsarefrom
are
now now
implementing
implementing change
change at at
anan unprecedented
unprecedented rate.
rate.
• What
• What Whatleading arepractices
leading the market
practices contribute
contributeforces
to to and and
success,
success, key and drivers
what
what software vendors and third-party asset
doesdoesit look
it looklikelike today?
today?
causing asset managers to assess and alter COOs COOs servicers
andandmanagers
managers have of of enabled
leading
leading firms to
organizations
organizations arereduce
are
continually
continually
assessing
assessing their
theirglobal
global operating
operating model.
model. Standing
Standing stillstill
is not
is not
Varioustheir
Variousmarket existing
market forcesforces operating
and andpressures,
pressures, models,
fromfrom operations anan
increasing
increasing infrastructure
option.
option. Operating
Operating
complexity
models
models must
must evolve
and
evolve to to
cost
support
support
by
business
business
competition
competition to tosweeping
sweeping regulatory
regulatory change,
change, areareforcing
forcing
global
and
global
asset
supporting
asset management
management
technologies?
firmsfirms to toevaluate
evaluate and and
evolve
evolvetheir
rationalizing
their strategies,
strategies, safeguard
safeguard the
competitive number
competitive position of and
position applications,
and
control
control costs
costs
operating
operating models
models to tosupport
support theirtheirbusiness
business strategies:
strategies: in an
in anwhich
increasingly has
increasingly increased
complex
complex regulatorythe
regulatory opportunities
environment.
environment.
•• Competition
What are
• Competition the
is driving
is key
driving asset areas
asset managers of focus,
managers to to
focus including
focusonon brand EY’s
brand EY’s for
20132013 outsourcing.
survey
survey of of
assetassetmanagement
management operations
operations provides
provides
insights
insights onon how how leading
leading firms
firms arearetransforming
transforming their
their
firm priorities
management
management and andgrow and
growAUM AUMinvestments?
through
through innovative
innovative new new
products,
products, distribution
distribution channels
channels and and geographies.
geographies. organizations
organizations to toexecute
execute winning
winning business
business strategies.
strategies. WeWe
hopeThese
hopeyou you complex
findfindthis this
report forces
report interestingrequire
interesting and and firms
useful.
useful. to
If you
If youwould
would
•• The
• The What
changing areand
changing the
and similarities
increasingly
increasingly complex andglobal
complex differences
global regulatory implement
regulatory likeliketo to
discuss
discuss ourour enterprise-wide
findings
findings in greater
in greater transformational
detail,
detail,please
please contact
contact
environment
environment is requiring
is requiring assetassetmanagers
managers to to
invest
invest oneoneof of
thethemembers
members of ofourour team.
team.
between
significantly
significantly
small,
in people,
in people,
medium
infrastructure,
infrastructure,
and largesystems
process,
process,
asset
systems
change spanning people, processes and
and managers,
and
data.
data. including geographic nuances? controls, data, and business applications.
Our survey indicates that leading asset
1 1
• What leading practices contribute to management firms are now implementing
success, and what does it look like today? change at an unprecedented rate.
Various market forces and pressures, COOs and managers of leading organizations
from increasing competition to sweeping are continually assessing their global
regulatory change, are forcing global asset operating model. Standing still is not an
management firms to evaluate and evolve option. Operating models must evolve to
their operating models to support their support business strategies, safeguard
business strategies: competitive position and control costs
in an increasingly complex regulatory
• Competition is driving asset managers to environment.
focus on brand management and grow
AUM through innovative new products, EY’s 2013 survey of asset management
distribution channels and geographies. operations provides insights on how leading
firms are transforming their organizations to
• The changing and increasingly complex execute winning business strategies. We hope
global regulatory environment is requiring you find this report interesting and useful.
asset managers to invest significantly in If you would like to discuss our findings in
people, infrastructure, process, systems greater detail, please contact one of the
and data. members of our team.
2 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
Executive summary
Leaders of global asset management firms significantly in marketing and brand of business processes across the front-,
are driving their operations and technology awareness in Europe in an effort to increase middle- and back-office operations. Firms
organizations to transform business market share. are creating global centers of excellence
processes and technology infrastructures. in a more diverse set of low-cost locations,
Adopting a strategic approach to
To enable long-term competitiveness, balancing such trade-offs as proximity
complying with a dynamic regulatory
firms are redefining their global operating to senior management, cost of travel,
environment
models through: information security, depth and breadth
Global firms must comply with a changing of skilled resources, and political
• A global footprint that maximizes the use and complex regulatory environment that and environmental factors. While the
of the 24-hour clock for business processes places significant demands on not only majority (55%) of all responding firm
and technology development while the compliance organization’s people and indicated that their primary location
enabling trading across multiple time zones technology, but also on the core investment strategy was to maximize the uses of
operations infrastructure overseen by the near-shore locations, for smaller and
• The next generation of shared services COO. Leading firms are differentiating some midsized firms, nearshoring remains
organizations, outsourcing and data their capabilities and competitiveness by the more cost-effective approach.
management programs to promote holistically assessing and implementing
flexibility and responsiveness to changing strategic change programs to address a For US firms of all sizes, the tax advantages
investor and regulatory demands multitude of regulations by a multitude of the offshore locations are a primary
of regulators with all their overlaps and driver for diversifying from traditional
• Cost-management programs that include conflicts. While challenges and competitive financial enter hubs. Where scale supports
product rationalization, assessment of opportunities span business processes and the strategy, these firms are moving from
distribution channels, a critical review legacy applications, data management and function-specific relocations to taking a
and rationalization of global business its associated challenges of quality, timely cross-functional approach that effectively
applications, and ongoing strategic delivery, effective analytics, and reporting takes a critical mass of an organization,
assessment of the use of low-cost locations are paramount. Medium to large global from senior management on down, and
asset managers are implementing new and relocates to a lower-cost location. This
While specific areas of focus vary across enhanced compliance programs that require approach has the added benefit of providing
small, medium and large firms, a number changes to existing organizational structures, site diversification and enabling business
of common themes have emerged as firms functional alignment, processes, systems continuity planning.
reposition their global operating models in and data to manage global regulatory
Expanding the use of third-party
response to the convergence of long-term compliance. For individual firm, the cost of
outsourcing throughout the
downward pressure on management fees and compliance is substantial. For 44% of all firms
operating model
increased operating costs. globally, the cost of compliance represents
between 11-25% of their operations budget. Asset servicers are a fundamental
Driving asset growth by expanding global
component of an asset management firm’s
distribution channels and focusing on Defining and implementing the next
global operating model. With the exception
a premier client experience and brand generation of global location strategy
of a minority of firms, the question is no
management
Over the past decade, global expansion longer whether to outsource; instead, firms
In response to declining margins, firms has been heavily focused on technology are considering which functions can be
are focusing their corporate strategies on development and testing, as well as outsourced, the optimal number of providers
distribution and brand management for asset performing selected operational functions to use and how third-party providers can be
growth. Across all respondents, improving such as reconciliations. And this expansion integrated effectively to enable timely data
distributions channels is the number one has been traditionally concentrated in a few access by the enterprise.
driver in changes to the firm operating locations. As medium and large forward-
model. US managers are expanding their looking asset management firms evolve to Outsourcing has grown significantly in the
brands in Europe, while firms in all locations the next generation of offshoring, they are last few years as firms drive outsourcing
are assessing how to expand the direct-to- increasingly looking to leverage their global into the middle office and closer to the
consumer model. US firms rebounded from footprint by creating a global operating functions that traditionally interact with
the financial crisis more quickly than their model, where the technical and data the front-office investment team, such as
European counterparts and are investing infrastructure supports an increased number performance measurement and attribution.
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 3
Even firms that are unlikely to outsource firms are adopting process excellence and Rationalizing the number of business
a significant number of functions use efficiency methodologies that originated applications, adopting vendor solutions
third-party providers for selected products in manufacturing, such as lean process and driving toward simplicity throughout
such as exchange-traded funds (ETFs) or improvement, to drive efficiency, scale the systems infrastructure
Undertakings for Collective Investment in and cost savings in existing or new shared The ability of leading software providers to
Transferable Securities (UCITS). For example, services organizations. support the scale, scope and global footprint
68% of the responding firms describe their of top asset management firms, along with
Expanding and maturing data management
target operating model as a combination of the realization that technology is no longer
and information security programs
outsourcing and in-house operations, with a differentiator in many parts of the value
62% of firms employing an outsource model Operations and technology leadership in chain, has enabled asset management firms
that relies on one or two strategic partners. top-tier firms are driving their organizations to reduce infrastructure complexity and
to implement world-class data management cost. For example, they are rationalizing the
Identifying cost savings in existing shared
standards. While few firms have developed an number of applications and replacing legacy
services organizations
enterprise-wide data management platform custom applications with vendor-based
Establishing shared services can serve many with the exacting level of efficiency and solutions. In the front office, where large
purposes: streamlining operations prior quality standards demanded by stakeholders, firms have historically supported two, three
to outsourcing, preparing for relocating committing resources to data management or more platforms based on asset type, the
all or part of the organization, or simply is a priority. Data plays a significant role drive is to consolidate on a single trading and
reducing operating costs and increasing the in a firm’s ability to comply with global order management platform. Demonstrating
effectiveness of the control environment for regulations, establish a truly global footprint how slowly this shift takes place across large,
processes viewed as too mission-critical to and realize benefits from a wide array of complex infrastructures, participating firms
outsource. Centralizing and standardizing cost management programs across the indicated that strategic spend far outweighed
business processes, such as reconciliation organization. Not surprisingly, the top five maintenance at 65% of the budget for
or technology functions such as testing and priorities of all responding firms are data smaller firms, while legacy infrastructure and
data services, are mature practices across quality and accuracy, support for increasing greater complexity results in strategic spend
the industry. Seven in 10 firms surveyed regulatory demands, timely availability of outstripping maintenance by only 3%-4% in
maximize the use of shared services data, effective data governance, and support both medium and large firms.
organizations for functions performed in for enterprise reporting.
house. While there remain a few smaller For midsized firm, the move to vendor-
firm (under US$100 billion) that have yet Surveyed firms agree on the importance of based solutions or platform upgrades is
to maximize shared services organizations, data governance and management, but how being driven by software vendors that
the structure is fully adopted by 100% of the to accomplish the goal varies. Responding offer hosting solutions, thereby expanding
largest firms surveyed. firms are closely split regarding the degree of the service model’s flexibility and
data management standardization, with 50% functionality. Of firms participating in the
For leading firm, the next phase of shared having adopted common standards across survey, only 15% of midsized firms indicated
services organizations is focused on the firm, and 43% choosing a hybrid model a broad use of custom business applications
driving down costs through reassessing the with enterprise-level and local standards. rather than licensing industry-standard
location of the centers, as well as reviewing Not surprisingly, the percentage of firms third-party applications.
business functions that may have previously adopting a single, common standard declines
been considered too complex or close to as firm size increases, with 67% of small
the customer to be moved into a shared firms using a common standard, and 80% of
services organization. In addition, top-tier the largest firms choosing a hybrid model.
4 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
WhileWhile managers
managers across
across the globe
the globe face similar
face similar challenges,
challenges, Participant profile
somesome interesting
interesting regional
regional variations
variations are clear:
are clear:
The purpose of the survey was to gather insights from senior
• The US has recovered from the financial crisis and operations executives — COOs and heads of operations — on
• The US has recovered from the financial crisis an challenges and direction of investment operations, technology,
is squarely focused on growth, distribution of new
is squarely focused on growth, distribution of new outsourcing, location strategy and use of centers of
products and geographical expansion.
products and geographical expansion. excellence. We spoke with 40 operations professionals at asset
• Europe, meanwhile, is still focused on regulation and management organizations in North America, Europe and
costmeanwhile,
containment, resulting in on
implementation select Latin American markets. The respondents were both
• Europe, is still focused regulation of
global and regional traditional asset managers.
different
and cost operatingresulting
containment, models.in European-based
implementationfirms
spend more
of different thanmodels.
operating 50% of their operations budgets
European-based firm
Respondent profile
spendonmorecompliance-related
than 50% of their functions,
operationsas they must deal
budgets
Total 40
with local countryfunctions,
on compliance-related and EU regulations layered
as they must dealon top
of global
with local regulations.
country Global regulations
and EU regulations layerednow also
on top By geography # of participants
include
of global the reachGlobal
regulations. of theregulations
US Securitiesnowand Exchange
also Americas 21
includeCommission
the reach (SEC)
of theand Internal Revenue
US Securities Service (IRS).
and Exchange Europe 19
Commission (SEC) and Internal Revenue Service (IRS). By AUM
• Small and midsize firms seek a truly global operating
model to leverage the associated synergies, while Under US$100 billion 15
• Small and midsize firms seek a truly global operating
large firms realize that their business is too complex US$100 billion—US$500 billion 20
model to leverage the associated synergies, while
for a single operating model and take a more regional Over US$500 billion 5
large firms realize that their business is too complex
approach. Some firms have begun to ask, “Maybe By institutional type
for a single operating model and take a more regional
biggest isn’t best when it comes to margin?”
approach. Some firms have begun to ask, “Maybe Division of investment bank or diversified 18
financial services firm
• Outsourcing
biggest post-trade
isn’t best when it comesexecution functions is still a
to margin?”
continuing trend. Although service providers have Division of insurance company 10
• substantially
Outsourcing enhanced
post-trade their capabilities,
execution there
functions is still a are Independent asset management firm 12
still significant
continuing gaps in implementing
trend. Although service providers a truly
haveglobal
outsourced
substantially servicetheir
enhanced capability.
capabilities, there are AUM by product
still significant gaps in implementing a truly global
outsourced service capability.
6%
9% Mutual funds/collective
investment vehicles
9% Separately managed
accounts
50% Wealth management
accounts
ETFs
26% Alternatives
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 4
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 5
Improving distribution channels is key
driver for changes to operating model
COOs are focused on improving margins by a road map to implement the changes with
building infrastructure to support growth, discrete milestones. The road map identifies
creating new differentiated products and critical dependencies on programs and
developing new distribution channels — initiatives at the enterprise level, such as
while controlling costs through streamlining compliance and data strategies.
ons
y Improving
distribution 55% Improving distribution 81%
channels channels 26%
se
Enabling new Enabling new 43%
45%
products products 47%
ey
f Changing
Changing regulatory 19%
regulatory 42%
landscape 68%
landscape
Differentiation Differentiation 0%
through increased 10% through increased
value/lower cost 21%
value/lower cost
6 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
“ We’re always concerned that our application set can keep
up with changing front-office needs in terms of new product
development, globalization and more complicated security. From
a strategic perspective, that’s something that we want to stay
close to.”
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 7
Investment in enabling technologies and
infrastructure is a top priority
eir
Enhanced control
Enhanced control
environment to manage risk environment to manage risk 38%
and meet regulatory 38% and meet regulatory 37%
requirements requirements
8 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
Risk management is a driving force as
firms set their objectives for their target
operating model
Given high-profile past failures in oversight responded with heightened requirements for
and the ensuing regulatory response, it risk management, such as the Alternative
comes as no surprise that risk management Investment Fund Managers Directive (AIFMD)
is the primary objective of firms target and UCITS. These increased requirements
operating models. Stronger risk management are leading to demands for improved
is both a response to recent regulation and understanding and transparency of risk and
48%
Risk management 57%
s 37%
ed 40%
Increased 52%
ve quality/accuracy 26%
r 22%
Cost savings 14%
tter 32%
s
15%
Time-to-market 19%
11%
Investor 15%
confidence/confidentiality 24%
5%
12%
Capacity planning 19%
5%
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 8
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 9
Compliance with regulatory requirements
is the top industry challenge
What do you believe are the industry’s top three challenges for investment
operations over the next 12 months?
ns
d Top industry challenges
nt
Compliance with regulatory 82%
81%
requirements 84%
ope
30%
ue Cost pressure 14%
47%
ory 22%
lity Investment product innovations 19%
26%
18%
Technology innovations 14%
21%
U
Resource skills/talent 18%
10%
management 26%
10 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
Highest cost functions are
resource-oriented tasks
nt, Which three functions represent the highest costs to the firm, and for
which three functions do you see the greatest opportunity to reduce
operations costs?
Highest function costs and opportunity to reduce: total (40)
t
Investment/fund accounting 58% 35%
Performance measurement
28% 35%
nd and attribution
ore
Institutional client reporting
25% 32%
and fee billing
her
tax Trade processing 25% 22%
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 11
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 10
12 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
Firms plan to maximize the use of
nearshore and offshore locations to
manage costs
As firms define their target state, location the US, state and local tax considerations Not surprisingly, the larger the firm, the
strategy is a primary consideration that will and concessions are a significant factor in more likely it seeks to maximize nearshoring
influence the functional, data and application location strategy for new middle- and back- or offshoring strategies. Larger firms have
investment needs and priorities. office operations centers. the scale to benefit from these strategies,
whereas for smaller firms the benefits do not
nd
al 17%
r in
55%
ngly
d
e
20%
ks
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 12
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 13
Most firms prefer one or two strategic
outsource partners
Asset servicers have evolved their governance. However, these benefits Regardless of the number of outsourcing
operational skills, understanding of risk need to be weighed against the benefit of partners, fund managers are choosing
and compliance, investment in leading diversification in minimizing supplier risk, their administrator relationships with great
technology, and focus on client service — even though this arrangement might care because administrator errors can lead
all making the decision to outsource cost more. to regulatory compliance problems and
increasingly compelling. damage the fund manager’s reputation.
Although switching can be complex, risky Firms are even adopting periodic request for
[If outsource or combination] Which of following best describes your target for
ding
an outsourced operations infrastructure?
p
r,
his
dic
are
e 62%
vice
s
Over US$500b (5) 40% 60%
cess
Use multiple best-in-class providers Use one or two strategic partners Don’t know/uncertain
14 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
Firms are only beginning to realize the
opportunity in outsourcing more
complex processes
In general, asset managers globally are integration, improve business applications,
outsourcing functions for which service and enhance the knowledge and skills
providers have more established capabilities, required to deliver the consistent and high-
while early adopters — less than 10% of quality reporting required by the front office
respondents — are using third-party firms for for these functions, it is likely outsourcing will
middle-office functions, such as performance become more prevalent.
measurement and attribution, post-trade
• Mature service
provider
Valuations and pricing 33% 2% 65%
capabilities
ity Investment/
fund accounting 45% 2% 53%
re
Outsource to third party Offshore Nearshore Colocated internal resources Don’t know/uncertain
16 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
Most firms are leveraging shared services
for key “insourced” functions
Across asset management firms, the use of programs; communication and escalation operations, yet realizing cost savings is
shared services is becoming the norm. The protocols; and assessment of key controls an ongoing challenge as asset types and
next step forward is likely to be the alignment and control monitoring. Once established, reporting requirements continually evolve.
across functions of production versus shared services organizations provide a Data and technology must be well integrated
oversight skills and internal versus client- framework for peer benchmarking of both to enable cost savings and efficiency gains;
facing roles. efficiency and quality standards. otherwise, a shared services organization
risks being as inefficient as disparate teams.
s
changes: redesign of career paths, roles functions. Creating a shared services teams throughout the organization for
and responsibilities; definition of new organization is a strategic decision that is each separate functional area. Here, scale
oversight roles, service-level agreements and implemented across as many functions as and complexity to consolidate outweigh
operational metrics tracking and reporting; possible. The shared services organization the benefits.
enhanced training and development is a relatively mature concept in investment
ent
Performance measurement
nge and attribution (37)
27% 70%
No Yes
Note: Where numbers do not add up to 100%, some respondents were uncertain.
Managing
Managing complexity and complexity
change in and change
a new landscape in a survey
— Global new landscape
on asset—management
Global surveyinvestment
on asset management
operations |investment
16 operations | 17
Firms are facing many data
management challenges
The increasing complexity of business, the trade life cycle to product development engaged in data initiatives to achieve a
a more volatile macroeconomic and and distribution, where data drives single source of truth and using tools
political environment, changing investor profitability analyses that inform product to develop comprehensive metadata
expectations, a tapestry of global regulatory rationalization, product development and repositories to consolidate data and trace
requirements, the need for enhanced distribution effectiveness. lineage and quality.
reporting and transparency, and stakeholder
demands for stronger risk management have However, relatively few firms have Firms that make progress are establishing
all raised the bar for data management. implemented the data quality and efficiency the required governance frameworks
What are your top five challenges related to data and data management?
stor
s,
Top data challenges — total Top data challenges by AUM
e all
87%
Availability of data 60% Availability of data 45%
40%
e Changing business
38% Changing business 47%
requirements
30%
requirements 40%
Utilizing data
28% 40%
analytics Utilizing data
15%
analytics 40%
ific
Redundancy 20%
7%
Redundancy 20%
60%
Total (40)
Under US$100b (15) US$100b–US$500b (20)
Over US$500b (5)
18 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
“ Our first action is strengthening the whole data governance area.
Our key stakeholders are fully engaged; we set up a steering
group and sub-working groups where each owns its data.
Our focus is on strengthening this with the right governance.“
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 19
At most firms, the data management
strategy is defined by a centralized team
In order to support their data needs and to 3. Establish processes for data management “ We’ve created our own data
reduce costs of enterprise data management, group. We’ve formed “a senior
a sizeable majority of firms have chosen to 4. Define controls and monitoring and
centralize data management. establish quality metrics for such
data committee” that deals
standards as timeliness and frequency with any challenges or areas
Irrespective of a firm’s approach to of conflict and it meets on a
centralization, key steps to establish the 5. Establish repositories to consolidate data quarterly basis. We’re big on
ata management strategy is defined by a
framework for data governance and control
are the same:
and trace lineage and quality
investment in the data and on
the programming side as well.”
6. Improve the design and implementation
1. Identify ownership of new data solutions CFO, Americas
US$100b—US$500b AUM
2. Establish a single source of truth 7. Define an implementation plan based on
discrete, measureable data sets
cy Total (40)
78%
Defined by centralized data team in the enterprise Local to legal entity or functional area
No defined approach
20 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
A significant portion of technology budget
is allocated to strategic investment
The need to balance investment in strategic To optimize spending, it is important “Our focus is to make our
technology versus maintenance of current to review — at the line-item level in the
technology environment more
infrastructure is an ongoing challenge for technology budget — all maintenance spend
asset management firms. to identify initiatives that can be stopped or robust, trying to reduce the
rescaled to “self-fund” some of the needed number of applications we’re
For all but the smallest firms, the average strategic investments in data, applications using, while at the same time
proportion of IT budgets that are directed to or integration. The critical step is to do this
making our data consistent
of technology budget is allocated to strategic
strategic initiatives approaches 50%. review in the context of a strategic road map,
supported by the leadership in operations across the organization.”
This bellwether ratio is an important measure and technology to stop investments in
Director of Operations,
to consider for undertaking any strategic initiatives that are not aligned to the new
Europe US$100b—US$500b AUM
transformation program, and it is key to operating model.
allocating sufficient funds to investment.
e 65%
ed Under US$100b (11)
n 35%
ted
44% Total (30)
52%
56%
US$100b–US$500b (15)
48%
51%
pe
M Maintenance Strategic spend
Managing
Managing complexity and complexity
change in and change
a new landscape in a survey
— Global new landscape
on asset—management
Global survey on asset management
investment operations |investment
20 operations | 21
Firms are focused on deploying and
maintaining leading business applications
Firms require flexible and scalable technology providing a consolidated and granular view “ Our number one concern is
that supports a number of objectives of the entire enterprise, asset managers are the ability of our application
across the enterprise. They are focused on focusing on selecting the right applications
deploying the right business applications to support them over the next several years.
technology environment to
and establishing the data management keep up with the necessary
22 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
Steady progress is being made toward
implementing of follow-the-sun
24/7 operations
The need for investment operations and However, only half of the firms that indicated
technology to support the “follow-the- they have a follow-the-sun strategy have
sun” business model, one in which the actually fully implemented it, with another
investment team is engaged in active trading third still in progress.
24 hours a day, is an ongoing challenge
for firms as business models increase the
number of locations, trading volume and
/7 operations
support global trading. Only a few of the
smaller firms require such a strategy.
35%
50%
Total (40) 60%
Total (14) 36%
5%
, 14%
38%
50%
Americas (21) 52%
Americas (8) 38%
10%
12%
32%
50%
Europe (19) 68%
Europe (6) 33%
0%
17%
13%
50%
Under US$100b (15) 80%
Under US$100b (2) 0%
7%
50%
35%
43%
US$100b–US$500b (20) 60%
US$100b–US$500b (7) 43%
5%
14%
100%
60%
Over US$500b (5) 0%
Over US$500b (5) 40%
0%
0%
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 23
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 22
“Buy versus build” strategy varies across
investment operations functions
Unique requirements, complexity and product development is low, availability of The use of ubiquitous tools, such as MS
scale of resources make larger firms more internal technology and project management Access and Excel, offers the ability to
willing to assume the risk of internal custom resources are limited, and viable third-party manage large volumes of data and respond
For those functions your firm performs in house, please identify the
description(s) that reflects
For those functions theperforms
your firm technology environment
in house, please for eachthe
identify function.
. description(s) that reflects the technology environment for each function.
.
Technology environment for in-house functions
24 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
Few asset managers plan to replace
existing or current applications
New implementations are costly and are reporting. Before replacing applications,
disruptive in the short-term, requiring firms should assess the end-to-end process
resources from the business to ensure for both these functions to identify
successful implementation. opportunities for process, control and
►
More diverse market for
Post-trade compliance (31) 84% 10% 6%
vendor solutions
► Dependent on more complex
Institutional client reporting 61% 17% data and metadata
and fee billing (18) 22%
► Requires involvement
Retail client reporting and 64% 18% 18% and directly affects functions
fee billing (11) beyond investment
operations
Financial regulation, tax, management 87% 13%
and board reporting (15)
No Yes Uncertain
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 24
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 25
Conclusion
Which firms will emerge the winners from • Create flexibility within the operating
this new market environment? A few critical model, enabling rapid response to
success factors are becoming evident. client demands, market conditions and
Market leaders will be firms that can deliver regulatory change. Operating in the
on the following: global marketplace and expanding into
emerging markets, while maintaining
• Deliver customized and scalable solutions market share and margins in established
through effective data management markets, mean firms need to have
and sophisticated client reporting tools. organizational, technology and governance
The ability of firms to effectively govern models that can respond rapidly,
risk, drive process efficiencies, employ effectively and efficiently.
effective enabling technologies, integrate
global organizations, meet regulatory • Leverage external third-party service
requirements, drive product innovation and providers while increasing flexibility and
offer differential client experience depends speed to market. Third-party servicers are
on solving the increasingly complex data becoming a standard arrow in the quiver
management challenges. of leading firms. Whether asset managers
use providers for specific products,
• Think differently about new capabilities regions or broad-based outsourcing,
that can be enabled with big data and boards of directors and firm leadership
emerging data technology capabilities. are increasingly seeing the value in the
The volume, variety and velocity of data role service providers can play in a global
in asset management firms my be as operating model.
great as, if not greater than, any other
industry. The opportunity to ingrain
advanced analytics and data-driven
recommendations at the point of decision-
making across investment teams, risk
management, investment compliance and
operations is a challenge few, if any, firms
have mastered.
26 | Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations
EY Contacts
contacts
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset managemen
Managing complexity and change in a new landscape — Global survey on asset management investment operations | 27
EY | Assurance | Tax | Transactions | Advisory
About EY Ernst & Young LLP is a client-serving member firm of Ernst & Young Global
EY is a global leader in assurance, tax, transaction and advisory services. The Limited operating in the US.
insights and quality services we deliver help build trust and confidence in the
capital markets and in economies the world over. We develop outstanding © 2014 EYGM Limited.
leaders who team to deliver on our promises to all of our stakeholders. In so All Rights Reserved.
doing, we play a critical role in building a better working world for our people, SCORE no. EH0146
for our clients and for our communities. 1402-1202297 NY
EY refers to the global organization, and may refer to one or more, of the ED 0115
member firms of Ernst & Young Global Limited, each of which is a separate
legal entity. Ernst & Young Global Limited, a UK company limited by guarantee, This material has been prepared for general informational purposes only and is not intended to be relied
upon as accounting, tax, or other professional advice. Please refer to your advisors for specific advice.
does not provide services to clients. For more information about our
organization, please visit ey.com. ey.com