Software Engineering Evaluation Form – Team # _______

Please rate the following on a scale of 1(poor) to 5 (outstanding) and provide feedback as
appropriate. Fractional points (4.5, for example) are appropriate.

1. Was the business opportunity/problem sufficiently analyzed ______

1. No business opportunity. 2. 3. Business Opportunity 4. 5. Business
No analysis performed Identified. Analysis is Opportunity clear.
limited. Analysis is detailed.
Comments:

2. Did the solution successfully satisfy the business opportunity/problem ______

1. Business opportunity 2.
poorly identified or
solution no appropriate for
business opportunity.
Comments:
3. Solution was a 4. 5. Very successful
satisfactory solution to solution to all business
business opportunity. Or opportunities
was a good solution to identified.
some of the opportunity.

3. Was the solution sufficiently planned to ensure success ______

1. No planning evident. 2. 3. Planning occurred, 4.
but not all risks
identified, creating
some risk of failure.
Comments:
5. Excellent planning,
risks identified and
planned for. Prospect
of success ensured by
planning.

4. Were the project variables(costs, schedule, scope) managed appropriately ______

1. No understanding of 2. 3. Project variables 4. 5. Good management
project variables observed. identified. Management of all important project
was minimal or good variables.
management of only
some variables.
Comments:
5. Was success achieved via effective team involvement _______
1. No teamwork observed. 2. 3. Team works well 4. 5. Well-oiled machine.
Team does not interact together with some Team clearly works
effectively. Lack of conflict. Team problems effectively..
teamwork probably led to did not derail project.
project failure
Comments:

6. Please rate the overall quality of the product ______

1. Product poorly
implemented. Instructions
difficult to understand.
Does not work properly.
Comments:
2. 3. Good quality product 4. 5. High quality
with clear areas for product, which can be
further improvement. used immediately.

7. Please rate the overall quality of the presentation ______

1. No evidence of planning 2. 3. Presentation is clearly 4. 5. Polished, prepared
or practice. prepared, but flow is presentation.
uneven in places.
Comments:

8. Please rate the degree to which the team made appropriate use of current technology ____
1. Little use of technology. 2. 3. Good use of 4. 5. Excellent use of
Tech used is not current. technology. Technology technology. Tech is
is relatively current. current.
Comments: