Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Working Conditions and Common Mental Disorders in Prison
Working Conditions and Common Mental Disorders in Prison
10042022EN 4559
article
officers in the inland region of the state of São Paulo, Brazil
tools and approaches on the subject so that the ological differences, cultural particularities, and
frequency of CMDs in equivalent populations the structuring of the prison system in different
ranges from 15.2% to 59.6%21. The studies mainly countries prevent us from adequately comparing
focused on identifying post-traumatic stress dis- the prevalence rates in those countries vis-à-vis
order, depression19,21, and anxiety21. The method- those found in our study.
Table 1. Characteristics of prison security agents by sociodemographic, health condition, and common mental
disorder (CMD) variables. State of São Paulo, 2019.
With a
Total sign of
PR (95%CI; p-value)
CMD
n (%) n (%)
Age group (n=326)
27-39 years 87 (26.7) 35 (40.2) 1.15 (0.91-1.45; 0.250)
40-49 years 134 (41.1) 39 (29.1) 1.06 (0.84-1.33; 0.641)
50-59 years 96 (29.4) 33 (34.4) 1.09 (0.87-1.39; 0.426)
60 years and over 9 (2.8) 2 (22.2) 1.00
Ethnicity/skin color (n=329)
Nonwhite 80 (24.3) 21 (26.3) 0.93 (0.85-1.01; 0.093)
White 249 (75.7) 90 (36.1) 1.00
Marital status (n=329)
Single, separated/divorced, widowed 54 (16.4) 12 (22.2) 0.89 (0.81-0.99; 0.036)
Married, living with a partner 275 (83.6) 99 (36.0) 1.00
Schooling level (n=328)
High school 190 (58.0) 56 (29.5) 0.93 (0.86-1.00; 0.049)
Higher education, postgraduate 138 (42.0) 55 (39.9) 1.00
Monthly household income (n=328)
Up to R$ 5,000 181 (55.2) 62 (34.3) 1.01 (0.94-1.09; 0.760)
Above R$ 5,000 147 (44.8) 48 (32.7) 1.00
Self-perceived health (n=316)
Excellent/good 189 (59.8) 38 (35.8) 1.00
Fair/poor/very poor 127 (40.2) 68 (64.2) 1.28 (1.19-1.38; <0.001)
Physical activity (≥once/week) (n=328)
Yes 192 (58.5) 52 (27.1) 1.00
No 136 (41.5) 58 (42.6) 1.12 (1.04-1.21; 0.003)
Arthritis/Arthrosis/Rheumatism (n=325)
Yes 48 (14.8) 24 (50.0) 1.15 (1.04-1.28; 0.007)
No 277 (85.2) 84 (30.3) 1.00
Chronic pain (n=318)
Yes 155 (48.7) 70 (45.2) 1.19 (1.11-1.29; <0.001)
No 163 (51.3) 35 (21.5) 1.00
BMI (n=325)
Obese 125 (38.5) 40 (32.0) 1.04 (0.93-1.17; 0.473)
Overweight 151 (46.5) 55 (36.4) 1.08 (0.96-1.21; 0.191)
Normal/Eutrophic 49 (15.1) 13 (26.5) 1.00
PSQI (n=245)
Worse sleep quality 140 (57.1) 72 (51.4) 1.42 (1.32-1.52; <0.001)
Better sleep quality 105 (42.9) 7 (6.7) 1.00
PR: Prevalence ratio, IC95%: 95% confidence interval. BMI: Body Mass Index. PSQI: Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index.
Source: Authors.
4563
Source: Authors.
4564
Bravo DS et al.
When evaluating the prevalence of CMDs to it12. The fear of violence can trigger insecurity
concerning the Brazilian reality, values similar to and emotional fragility, leading to professional
those found in studies carried out in Rio Grande exhaustion, mental illness, and lack of work mo-
do Norte (23.6%)14 and Bahia (30.7%)11 can be tivation26.
observed. However, studies with ASPs conducted Violence in the work environment is a pub-
in Sergipe and São Paulo showed a considerably lic health problem27, and its occurrence is more
higher prevalence of CMDs, between 68.0%6 and common in some professions, such as health or
83.3%13, respectively. These differences are pos- education professionals and prison officers, since
sibly due to the low number of participants6,13 the intrinsic peculiarities of these professional
included in these studies and the peculiar place categories contribute to workers being more ex-
of work analyzed. For example, in one of them, posed to these events28. Therefore, physical, psy-
ASPs were workers at a Hospital for Custody and chological, and sexual violence negatively affect
Psychiatric Treatment13, an institution that shel- the health conditions of ASPs and compromise
ters people deprived of their liberty who are con- their work process27.
sidered incapable; that is, they have committed The association between this type of mental
some type of crime but are unable to recognize violence is supported by a meta-analysis showing
or pay for their crimes due to their psychic con- that exposure to bullying is associated with men-
ditions. tal health problems, burnout, and lower job sat-
Physical inactivity was also associated with isfaction29, with an impact on job satisfaction30,31,
CMDs, which is corroborated by other studies generating work stress30,31, organizational endan-
with prison officers11,22,23. Physical activity re- germent30, demotivation, dissatisfaction with the
duces tensions, often arising from the work en- position, anxiety, and emotional exhaustion31.
vironment23, and provides significant benefits to The association between sexual violence and
the physical and mental health of the population, CMDs is well reported for the female population32
thus contributing to the promotion of health and or in other professions33, with no reports on ASPs.
quality of life24. Possible limitations of this study are the use
Concerning aspects inherent to the physical of self-reported information (which may contain
structure of prisons, working conditions were memory bias); because it is a self-completed tool
associated with CMDs. The Brazilian prison en- (which can generate doubts about the questions);
vironment is generally characterized by build- the convenience sampling of the penitentiaries,
ings surrounded by walls and wires, guarded at not allowing the extrapolation of data to all ASPs
all times by heavily armed men, and extensive in the western region or the entire state of São
and damp galleries and corridors8. These physi- Paulo; the lack of more information about the
cal conditions, inherent to prison, can influence losses, which hinders the assessment of a possi-
their physical health and psychological distress6. ble selective loss of individuals most affected by
The unhealthy work environment can change the CMDs; and the small sample size, which, while
feeling of exertion, making the profession even representative for the population under analy-
more laborious25 and increasing stress and the sis, may have compromised the accuracy of the
likelihood of developing mental disorders6. association measures studied. However, using a
We found that having suffered some type of validated tool to identify CMDs in the research
violence in the last 12 months, such as insults or population has strengths, in addition to working
embarrassing situations, moral harassment, and with a population that is difficult to access, giv-
sexual harassment, was significantly associated en that the research was developed within prison
with CMDs in the adjusted analysis. A study in units. Moreover, ensuring absolute confidential-
other population segments found multiple fac- ity concerning ASP responses can minimize the
tors associated with CMDs, including exposure risk of withholding information about their men-
to violence. The risk of violence inside and out- tal health and working conditions.
side the prison environment is typical of any ac- In summary, this study proved that working
tivity related to prison security. Violence was also conditions, violence, insults, and demands inside
demonstrated in another study conducted with prison are associated with CMD signs. Therefore,
ASPs in Avaré-SP, in which 200 (66.4%) of the it would be relevant to conduct longitudinal stud-
301 prison workers reported having suffered at ies on the subject, especially those assessing the
least one verbal or physical abuse event at work, development of CMDs throughout the exercise
and 108 (35.8%) reported having suffered at least of the profession. The results can support actions
one abuse event outside of work, however, related aimed at improving physical spaces within the
4565
Collaborations References
DS Bravo: design, conception, methodology, data 1. American Psychiatric Association. Diagnostic and
Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fifth Edition
collection, data analysis, writing - initial version
(DSM-V). Arlington: American Psychiatric Associa-
and editing, and final approval of the manuscript. tion; 2013.
SG Gonçalves: design, conception, methodology, 2. World Health Organization (WHO). Depression and
data collection, data analysis, and final approv- other common mental disorders: Global estimates [In-
al of the manuscript. E Girotto: writing - review ternet]. Geneva: WHO; 2017 [cited 2022 jun 8]. Avai-
lable from: http://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/hand-
and editing and final approval of the manuscript.
le/10665/254610/WHOMSD?sequence=1.
AD González: writing - review and editing and 3. Goldberg DP, Huxley P. Common mental disorders:
final approval of the manuscript. FN Melanda: a bio-social model. New York: Tavistock/Routledge;
writing - review and editing and final approval of 1992.
the manuscript. R Rodrigues: design, conception, 4. Stansfeld SA, Fuhrer R, Head J. Impact of common
mental disorders on sickness absence in an occupatio-
methodology, data analysis, writing - review and
nal cohort study. Occup Environ Med 2011; 68(6):408-
editing, and final approval of the manuscript. AE 413.
Mesas: design, conception, methodology, data 5. Santos GBV, Alves MCGP, Goldbaum M, Cesar CLG,
analysis, writing - review and editing, final ap- Gianini RJ. Prevalência de transtornos mentais co-
proval of the manuscript, and supervision. muns e fatores associados em moradores da área ur-
bana de São Paulo, Brasil. Cad Saude Publica 2019;
35(11):e00236318.
6. Albuquerque DR, Araújo MRM. Precarização do Tra-
balho e Prevalência de Transtornos Mentais em Agen-
tes Penitenciários do Estado de Sergipe. Rev Psicol
Saude 2018; 10(1):19-30.
7. Bezerra CM, Assis SG, Constantino P. Sofrimento
psíquico e estresse no trabalho de agentes penitenciá-
rios: Uma revisão da literatura. Cien Saude Colet 2016;
21(7):2135-2146.
8. Lourenço AS. O espaço de vida do agente de seguran-
ça penitenciária no cárcere: entre gaiolas, ratoeiras e
aquários [tese]. São Paulo: Universidade de São Paulo;
2010.
9. Jaskowiak CR, Fontana RT. O trabalho no cárcere: re-
flexões acerca da saúde do agente penitenciário. Rev
Bras Enferm 2015; 68(2):235-243.
10. Steel Z, Marnane C, Iranpour C, Chey T, Jackson JW,
Patel V, Silove D. The global prevalence of common
mental disorders: A systematic review and meta-a-
nalysis 1980-2013. Int J Epidemiol 2014; 43(2):476-
493.
11. Fernandes RCP, Silvany Neto AM, Sena GM, Leal AS,
Carneiro CAP, Costa FPM. Trabalho e cárcere: um
estudo com agentes penitenciários da Região Metro-
politana de Salvador, Brasil. Cad Saude Publica 2002;
18(3):807-816.
12. Alves V. Condições de trabalho de funcionários pe-
nitenciários de Avaré-SP e ocorrência de transtornos
mentais comuns [dissertação]. Botucatu: Universidade
Estadual Paulista; 2009.
13. Santos DC, Dias JS, Pereira MBM, Moreira TA, Barros
DM, Serafim AP. Prevalência de transtornos mentais
comuns em agentes penitenciários. Rev Bras Med do
Trab 2010; 8(1):33-38.
14. Lima AIO, Dimenstein M, Figueiró R, Leite J, Dantas
C. Prevalence of common mental disorders and al-
cohol and substance abse among correctional officers.
Psicol Teor Pesqui 2019; 35:e3555.
4567
CC BY This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License