Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Systems Work of Social Change How To Harness Connection Context and Power To Cultivate Deep and Enduring Change Cynthia Rayner Full Chapter PDF
The Systems Work of Social Change How To Harness Connection Context and Power To Cultivate Deep and Enduring Change Cynthia Rayner Full Chapter PDF
The Systems Work of Social Change How To Harness Connection Context and Power To Cultivate Deep and Enduring Change Cynthia Rayner Full Chapter PDF
https://ebookmass.com/product/persuasive-writing-how-to-harness-
the-power-of-words-frederick/
https://ebookmass.com/product/lead-through-anything-harness-
purpose-vitality-and-agility-to-thrive-in-the-face-of-
unrelenting-change-dustin-seale/
https://ebookmass.com/product/expressive-arts-for-social-work-
and-social-change-1st-edition-tuula-heinonen/
https://ebookmass.com/product/work-better-together-how-to-
cultivate-strong-relationships-to-maximize-well-being-and-boost-
bottom-lines-jen-fisher/
Escaping Nature: How to Survive Global Climate Change
Orrin H Pilkey
https://ebookmass.com/product/escaping-nature-how-to-survive-
global-climate-change-orrin-h-pilkey/
https://ebookmass.com/product/effective-implementation-of-
transformation-strategies-how-to-navigate-the-strategy-and-
change-interface-successfully-angelina-zubac/
https://ebookmass.com/product/change-proof-leveraging-the-power-
of-uncertainty-to-build-long-term-resilience-adam-markel/
https://ebookmass.com/product/heat-exposure-and-human-health-in-
the-context-of-climate-change-yuming-guo/
https://ebookmass.com/product/change-your-thinking-to-change-
your-life-kate-james/
The Systems Work of Social Change
“With special attention to the role of context and power, this book is a
roadmap for deep change in tackling today’s multiple crises around
the world.”
—Julie Battilana, Alan L. Gleitsman Professor of Social
Innovation, Harvard Kennedy School; Founder and
Faculty Chair of the Social Innovation and
Change Initiative at HKS.
“Social change should now more aptly be referred to as “The Systems
Work of Social Change.”
—Frank Beadle de Palomo, President and
Chief Executive Officer, mothers2mothers
“It will set you thinking differently . . .”
—Jeroo Billimoria, Founder and Serial Social Entrepreneur,
Catalyst 2030 & One Family Foundation
“Addressing inequalities and deep-rooted injustices in our society
requires a clear vision of the world we want and a process to get
there. A must read for those who believe that together we can build a
better world!”
—Winnie Byanyima, Executive Director, UNAIDS
“It will guide those who work in and think about systems change for a
generation. A breakthrough book.”
—Stephan Chambers, Director, Marshall Institute,
London School of Economics and Political Science
“Lucidly written and cogently argued book putting forward the case
for a systemic approach to social change.”
—Mirai Chatterjee, Chairperson, Self-Employed Women’s
Association Cooperative Federation
1
1
Great Clarendon Street, Oxford, OX2 6DP,
United Kingdom
Oxford University Press is a department of the University of Oxford.
It furthers the University’s objective of excellence in research, scholarship,
and education by publishing worldwide. Oxford is a registered trade mark of
Oxford University Press in the UK and in certain other countries
© Cynthia Rayner and François Bonnici 2021
The moral rights of the authors have been asserted
First Edition published in 2021
Impression: 1
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in
a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the
prior permission in writing of Oxford University Press, or as expressly permitted
by law, by licence or under terms agreed with the appropriate reprographics
rights organization. Enquiries concerning reproduction outside the scope of the
above should be sent to the Rights Department, Oxford University Press, at the
address above
You must not circulate this work in any other form
and you must impose this same condition on any acquirer
Published in the United States of America by Oxford University Press
198 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, United States of America
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
Data available
Library of Congress Control Number: 2021909382
ISBN 978–0–19–885745–7
Printed and bound in the UK by
TJ Books Limited
Links to third party websites are provided by Oxford in good faith and
for information only. Oxford disclaims any responsibility for the materials
contained in any third party website referenced in this work.
Foreword
Mirai Chatterjee, Chairperson, Self-Employed Women’s
Association (SEWA) Cooperative Federation
The COVID-19 pandemic has touched the very lives and livelihoods
of all of us on our planet, leading to reflection and reimagination of our
approaches to life and living. Cynthia Rayner and François Bonnici’s
book, The Systems Work of Social Change, is a timely and welcome
addition to the debates and discussions taking place in our homes,
societies, nations and—importantly—the millions of organizations
across the globe who are committed to a world that works for all.
Given their position both as practitioners and academics with a
deep belief in the need for social change, they are uniquely positioned
to share their own experiences and those of the many social change
organizations with whom they have worked. By analysing their own
experiences with candour, and reflecting on the experiences of others,
what emerges is a lucidly written and cogently argued book putting
forward the case for a systemic approach to social change. They argue
that a fundamental restructuring of social and environmental sys-
tems is necessary to undo the deep inequalities and multi-level injust
ices of our social and global environmental crises.
This insightful book emphasizes the need for systems work: cre-
ating systems that are responsive to changing realities and more
inclusive and representative of all. They have attempted to answer
several important questions that face us today, and most import
antly, how organizations can create systemic change. Their focus is
on civil society organizations —non-governmental organizations,
social enterprises, self-help groups, and people’s organizations. The
authors have drawn from eight such organizations on almost
every continent, organizations that have worked deeply, diligently,
sincerely and with commitment to improve the living and working
conditions of millions in every corner of the globe.
viii Foreword
careers with a strong faith in the type of social change that got us to
where we are today. As a medical doctor, François was trained to
think that the answers to society’s greatest challenges had already
been worked out by unprecedented scientific advancement.
However, as a junior medical officer in Namibia, he discovered that
the biomedical approach alone was inadequate. Working at the
height of the HIV/AIDS pandemic, amongst casualties of war
returning from the Democratic Republic of Congo, he was struck
by how poverty, the history of colonialism, and the legacy of apart-
heid undermined many attempts to fundamentally improve peo-
ple’s lives.
Cynthia’s work in social change began when, fresh out of busi-
ness school, she launched into a nonprofit fundraising role for a
South African non-governmental organization (NGO) in New York
City. As a former management consultant with a corporate career,
Cynthia thought her background, based on the principles of effi-
ciency and efficacy, primed her to make positive change. Yet when
she arrived in South Africa and became immersed in the organiza
tions she had been funding, these principles seemed to raise more
problems than solutions.
As our careers progressed, an unsettling realization came to us
slowly—too slowly for our own liking. The truth was that we, and
the institutions in which we were positioned, were messing up a
lot of the time. We were failing the communities with whom we
worked and forming part of the very problems we were trying to
solve. We saw issues with our approaches: strategies developed
with superficial input from “beneficiaries,” project plans written
by officials or consultants with little appreciation for ground-level
dynamics, funding that ran out just as we were making headway.
Communities at times seemed to resent “interventions,” while
the discussions we had with funders and policymakers felt
increasingly disconnected from reality. The deeper we got into
our work, the more questions bubbled to the surface. Truth be
told, we got scared. Was this how it was supposed to go? Why
didn’t it feel like anything was getting better, despite the signifi-
cant investment and effort on the part of so many organizations
and individuals?
xiv Preface
prove, and fund. For these reasons, we think they have been over-
looked by well-intentioned practitioners, funders, and researchers
like ourselves. We have come to believe that if we can bring these
practices to light, and give them credence among funders and pol
icymakers, we will have far more success in our collective efforts to
achieve just and enduring social and environmental change.
This book has been a five-year endeavor, and we have been hum-
bled by the many individuals and institutions who have shared this
journey with us.
This book, at its core, is a tribute to social change practitioners
whose systems work provides the inspiration and empirical basis for
our analysis. The case studies in this book involved many interviews,
conversations, and observations in person and over phone and
email. We are grateful for the gift and privilege of sharing their sto-
ries through the lens of systems work. We want to extend a sincere
thank you to Jos de Blok from Buurtzorg; Jeroo Billimoria, Bram van
Eijk, Lubna Shaban, Jared Penner, Bianca Isaincu, Rob Becker, and
Koen Vermeltfoort from Child & Youth Finance International
(CYFI); Mauricio Lim Miller and Jesús Garena from Community
Independence Initiative (CII) and Family Independence Initiative
(FII); Vicky Colbert, Clarita Arboleda, Heriberto Castro, and Luz
Dary Rojas from Fundación Escuela Nueva (FEN); Frank Beadle de
Palomo, Mitch Besser, and David Torres from mothers2mothers
(m2m); Arbind Singh, Rakesh Tripathi and Ratnish Verma from
Nidan; Marlon Parker and Rene Parker from RLabs; and Sheela
Patel, Nancy MacPherson and Ariana Karamallis from Slum Dwellers
International (SDI). All these organizations have been active in the
networks of Ashoka, Skoll Foundation and Schwab Foundation and
thus we are grateful to each of those organizations for highlighting
their work allowing us to build our knowledge collectively. We also
learned extensively from those representing the supporting case
studies in the book, including Kisimbi Thomas from AMP Health;
Alice Evans from Lankelly Chase; Andrew Darnton and Andrew
Harrison from Revaluation, and Anand Arkalgud from Socion.
Unfortunately, any book has its limitations as to how many sto-
ries and organizations can be profiled. A long list of practitioners
xviii Acknowledgments
and organizations were generous with their time and thinking, even if
we were unable to profile their work as we sincerely would have liked—
to them, we are beholden. We would like to thank Ruth Bechtel,
Aida Coehlo, Jessica Crawford, Anisa Draboo, Ashifi Gogo, Danielle
Goldschneider, Pinaki Halder, Katia Hamida, Tim Hanstad, Gregorio
Janeiro, Chris Jochnick, Jordan Kassalow, Margarida Matsinhe, Anand
Mehta, Luvuyo Rani, Evan Simpson, Elizabeth Smith, Hien Tran, and
Allen Wilcox for the conversations which advanced our thinking in so
many ways.
This book could not have been written without Tony Tabatznik
and Laura Horwitz from the Bertha Foundation, who graciously
provided the ongoing support, provocation, and encouragement to
make all this work possible through their partnership with the
University of Cape Town Graduate School of Business and the
Bertha Centre for Social Innovation. We also wish to thank Hilde
and Klaus Schwab, Katherine Milligan, Mirjam Schoening, Goy
Phumtim, Pavitra Raja, Carolien de Bruin, Maria Inés Martin,
Gabriela Henchoz, Shiv Verkaran and the Schwab Foundation for
Social Entrepreneurship who commissioned the research that
formed the backbone of the manuscript, and in particular Precious
Moloi-Motsepe and the Motsepe Foundation, who provided the
funding for the research. Geraldine Reymenants and Katrien
Vanderplaudutse and the Government of Flanders, with their sup-
port for research and development of case studies and teaching
materials on this topic at the Bertha Centre, also made this work
possible. These individuals and organizations have been more than
funders—they have been true thought partners in every sense of
the term.
We are also indebted to the talents and energy of several people
who worked closely with us to turn our ideas into words: Sarah
Boyd, originally a research assistant who quickly segued into co-
writer, editor, and true collaborator; Jane Notten, who skillfully put
much of our thinking into readable prose; and Michael Schellenberg,
who patiently gave us editorial support when we needed a profes-
sional and experienced hand. Gayle Northrop read several drafts of
this work and improved it considerably with her clear thinking,
encouraging guidance, and substantial expertise. Camilla Thorogood
Acknowledgments xix
Endnotes 197
Index 239
We have arrived at a point in our human evolution where
we know a lot, but we understand very little. Our chosen
navigation has been piloted by reason, leading to the port
of knowledge. As such it has been an overwhelmingly
successful. We have never, in all of our existence, accumu-
lated more knowledge than during the last 100 years. We
are celebrating the apotheosis of reason, but in the midst of
celebration we suddenly have the feeling that something
is missing . . . Perhaps the moment to pause and reflect has
arrived.
―Chilean economist Manfred A. Max-Neef, What Next?
Introduction
Working in Systems
One would think that these successes would boost our shared
confidence considerably. And yet, they have not. In survey after
survey, respondents around the world indicate that they believe the
world is getting worse off.7 Our own informal polls among students
in the classrooms where we teach bear these statistics out. Even in
our conversations with those who are courageous enough to devote
their life’s work to improve the world—the nonprofit leaders, activ-
ists, environmentalists, community organizers, social innovators
and entrepreneurs whom we refer to collectively as social change
practitioners—we sense a growing unease.
It was from this practical need that the Schwab Foundation asked
us to conduct research on systems change for their community
of social entrepreneurs. We were excited about the opportunity,
thinking that the project might help us create a definition of sys-
tems change that encompassed the real practices we were seeing in
the examples around us. During our workshops, short courses, and
planning sessions with social change practitioners at the Bertha
Centre, we had seen glimmers of the work that one might call sys-
tems change, and we already had a sense of the values and activities
this work required. However, if pressed to explain what exactly
these practitioners were doing differently, we could not readily
articulate it. So we set out to examine more closely a group of
organizations that embodied the different approaches to systems
change as we understood it.
Through the networks we had built with the Bertha Foundation
and the Schwab Foundation, we spent the next five years exploring
and studying dozens of social change organizations in greater depth
than we ever had previously. We sought out local luminaries,
revisited standouts from our past work, searched databases, and
discovered new groups from the recommendations of colleagues,
friends, and beyond. This work took us on an exceptional journey
across five continents to conduct conversations with hundreds of
individuals. Along the way, we spoke with social change practi
tioners in boardrooms and hotel conference rooms, as well as under
highway overpasses, on bumpy car rides, in classrooms, and even,
on one occasion, on a funicular which took us 10,000 feet above sea
level. Like any good journey, our final destination ended up being
quite far from where we set out to go.
Two Approaches
technical systems change that we had read about in books and art
icles, and it corresponded with many of the conversations we had
with practitioners and funders.
Alternatively, we were also on the lookout for transformational
systems change, such as influencing policy at the local, national, or
international level or forcing political change through community
organizing and large- scale protest action. We spent time with
groups with long histories of advocacy and activism, generating sig-
nificant political wins at the local, national, and international levels.
Still others were excellent at mobilizing and building collaborative
networks, one of them spanning a hundred plus countries and tens
of thousands of partners, and another linking up governments and
the private sector to spread their models to countless beneficiaries.
What we didn’t anticipate was something far deeper—a set of val-
ues and beliefs toward the process of change that was as important
as the change itself. While the accomplishments and achievements
were instrumental to achieving change, they were ultimately not
the qualities that intrigued us most. We began to realize that the
two approaches—technical and transformational—are necessary
but not sufficient to create systems that are enduring and just. With
these organizations, we eventually journeyed to a deeper set of
principles which we came to call systems work.27
Buurtzorg
(35 countries)
Family
Independence
Initiative
(USA)
Nidan
(India)
Child and Youth Finance
(175 countries)
RLabs mothers2mothers
(23 countries) (10 countries)
Fig. 0.1 Eight organizations practicing systems work around the world
Source: Authors.
xxxviii Introduction
PRACTICES PRINCIPLES
EQUIP DISRUPT
CULTIVATE PROMOTE
PROBLEM- POLICIES AND
COLLECTIVES PLATFORMS
SOLVERS PATTERNS
PART I
PRINCIPLES OF SYSTEMS WORK
These lines seem to explain how these islands were sprung from Ma keia mele e
Wakea and Papa, according to the knowledge or belief held by Pakui, hoomaopopo ai i ka laha
the composer of these songs. He was a priest and a historian ana o keia mau aina e
belonging to the board of historians and genealogist of the order of the Wakea laua me Papa, e
priesthood. But in looking at Chapter I of this story the ideas of the like me ka ike a Pakui ka
historian are very similar in regard to the birth or appearance of these mea nana i haku i keia
islands. Also in the song composed by Pakui in his capacity as a mele, he kahuna ia, he
prophet and historian, as seen in this chapter, but it will be well to note kakaolelo no loko mai o
the setting of the genealogy from the time of Wakea, as shown in the ka papa mookuauhau o
following chapter. na kahuna nui o ka
oihanakahuna. Aka ma
ka nana ana i ka Mokuna
I o keia moolelo, ua
aneane like ka manao o
na kakaolelo ma ka loaa
ana o keia mau aina. A
ma ke mele i hakuia e
Pakui ma kona ano kaula
a kakaolelo hoi e like me
ka hoike ana ma keia
mokuna o keia moolelo;
aka e pono e nana i ka
hoonoho ana o ka
mookuauhau mai a
Wakea mai e like me ka
hoike ana ma ka mokuna
malalo iho.
In this chapter it seems it was the heavens that was first created and Ma keia mokuna, ua
the earth afterwards, and thus read the lines of the song composed by manaoia ma ka
Pakui in Chapter III: hoomaopopo ana, mehe
mea la o ka lewa ka mua,
o ka lani, alaila o ka
honua mai, a penei ka
heluhelu ana i na lalani
mua o ke mele i hakuia e
Pakui ma ka Mokuna III.
“Wakea was the old one of Luamea, and Papa giving birth to islands “O Wakea Kahiko
was the wife. Luamea, o Papa hanau
Tahiti-ku of the rising sun and Tahiti-moe of the setting sun was born, moku ka wahine.
The foundation stones were born Hanau Tahiti-ku, Tahiti-
And also the stones of heaven.” 45 moe,
Hanau Keapapanui.
Hanau Keapapalani.”
Therefore these were the first products of the union of Wakea and A nolaila o na mea mua
Papa; Hawaii was born afterwards, as told here below: keia i loaa i loko o ko
Wakea mau la laua o
Papa, a mahope o Hawaii
ka hanau ana e like me
malalo iho.
“Wakea lived with Papa and five children were born to them: “O Wakea ka i noho aku
First, Tahiti-ku (standing or rising Tahiti); ia Papa hanau elima
Second, Tahiti-moe (setting or lying down Tahiti); keiki:
Third, the foundation stones; O Tahiti-ku, Tahiti-moe,
Fourth, the stones of heaven; Keapapanui,
Fifth, Hawaii. [18] Keapapalani,
Wakea was the husband, Papa the wife, } Hawaii. [19]
Kane was the husband, Walinuu the wife, } of Maui. O Wakea ke kane a Papa
Wakea lived with Papa; offsprings were Kane and Kanaloa.” (w) }
O Kane ke kane a
Walinuu (w) } o Maui.
O Wakea kai noho ia
Papa; hanau o Kane, o
Kanaloa.”
After the birth of these different children Papa went back to Tahiti and Mahope iho o ko Papa
Wakea lived wifeless. Therefore Wakea took unto himself Kaulawahine hanau ana i keia mau
who as a result gave birth to Lanai Kaula. Lanai was afterwards keiki, hoi aku la o Papa i
adopted. And thus runs the genealogy: Tahiti, noho wahine ole o
Wakea. Nolaila, lawe ae
Husband. Wife. Child. o Wakea ia Kaulawahine,
Wakea the husband of Kaulawahine, Lanai was the child. hanau o Lanai Kaula, a
Wakea the husband of Hina, Molokai was the child. mahope laweia ua o
Lanai i keiki hookama. A
penei ka hoonohonoho
ana o ka mookuauhau.
Thus Wakea had two island children with his new wives. On Papa’s Alua mau keiki moku a
return from Tahiti she heard of Wakea’s escapades with the new wives Wakea me na wahine
and got jealous of them and was also angry at her husband, Wakea. hou. Hoi mai o Papa mai
Therefore Papa took Lua for a husband and they had for a child Oahu, Tahiti mai, lohe ua lilo o
known as Oahualua. Papa went back to her first husband Wakea, and Wakea ia Kaulawahine
gave birth to Kamawaelualanimoku, Niihau, Kaula, and also Lehua. laua me Hina; a nolaila
They had four children after their reconciliation, and the genealogy huhu o Papa i na
reads as follows, according to Pakui’s chant, Chapter III: punalua, a huhu pu no
hoi i kana kane ia Wakea.
Nolaila, lawe ae o Papa
ia Lua i kane nana, loaa
ka laua keiki o Oahu
(Oahualua). Hoi hou aku
o Papa me kane mua me
Wakea, hanau o
Kamawaelualanimoku, o
Niihau, o Kaula, o Lehua.
Aha mau keiki a laua ma
ko laua manawa i hoi hou
ae ai. A penei hoi e
heluhelu ai i ka moolelo
ma ke mele i hakuia e
Pakui i hoikeia ma ka
Mokuna III.
And this is the way the genealogy should be set of the children Papa A penei hoi ka
had with Wakea after the reconciliation: Wakea lived again with Papa, hoonohonoho ana o ka
and was born to them Kauai, Kamawaelualanimoku, Niihau, Lehua, moolelo o ka hanau ana
and Kaula. With these children Papa ceased giving birth to islands o Papa i na keiki muli ia
according to the previous historian; but according to the accounts of laua i hoi ae ai me
Kamahualele, another great prophet and historian, he gives the Wakea. Noho hou o
following version: Moikeha left Tahiti and came here on account of Wakea ia Papa, o Kauai,
Luukia, his concubine, [20]becoming crazy on account of Mua’s false Kamawaelualanimoku,
tale of Moikeha’s unfaithfulness. When Moikeha heard that wrong had Niihau, Lehua, Kaula. O
been done him he left Tahiti and sailed to Hawaii, and as his canoes keia mau keiki a Papa,
approached the beach at Hilo Kamahualele stood up on the cross- pau kana hanau moku
boards of the canoe and chanted the following mele in honor of his ana. Aka hoi ma ka ike o
chief: kekahi kaula nui, he
kakaolelo, o Kamahualele
kona inoa: I ka manawa i
holo mai ai o Moikeha
mai Tahiti mai, mamuli o
ka hoaaia i kana wahine
[21]manuahi ia Luukia, no
ko Mua olelo hoopunipuni
ana ia Luukia no ka hewa
i hana oleia e Moikeha,
aka ma kela lohe ana o
Moikeha ua hana pono
ole ia oia, nolaila, haalele
oia ia Tahiti, holo mai oia i
Hawaii nei, a i ka
hookokoke ana mai o na
waa e pae i Hilo, ia
manawa, ku mai o
Kamahualele i luna o ka
pola o na waa, a kahea
mai:
According to this chant of Kamahualele, Wakea and his wife were not Aia i loko o keia mele a
the original progenitors of Hawaii nei, and here is this also: it seems Kamahualele, aole o
from this account that the people came from Tahiti to people these Wakea a me kana wahine
islands as stated in the mele chanted by Kamahualele from the cross- na kumu mua o Hawaii
board of the canoe recited above. nei. A eia kekahi; ma ka
nana ana a me ka
hoomaopopo ana, no
Tahiti mai na kanaka i
laha ai keia mau moku, e
like me ke mele a
Kamahualele i hea mai ai
i luna o ka pola o na waa,
e like me ke mele maluna
ae.
CHAPTER V. MOKUNA V.
It is told in the genealogy of Opuukahonua that they were the royal Ua oleloia ma ka moolelo
parents or ancestors of these islands, and that there were ninety-five o Opuukahonua o laua
generations from him to Kamehameha the Great. And they were found na kupuna alii o keia mau
or obtained by the fishing of Kapuheeuanui, and thus runs the tale: aina, he
When Kapuheeuanui let down his fishing line into the sea from kanaiwakumamaiwa
Kapaahu his line caught something that he thought was a fish and hanauna mai laila mai a
drew the line onto the canoe when, behold, it was a piece of coral. The hiki ia Kamehameha. A o
priest Laulialamakua came along as Kapuheeuanui was disentangling ka loaa ana o keia mau
his line from the coral and preparing to throw it away. Then the priest aina, i lawaia ia e
spoke to him, “Eh! Don’t throw away that piece of coral, for that is a Kapuheeuanui. A penei
chief, a foreteller of events. Go thou and look for a pig and appease the ke kaao ana: I ka wa i
god, and after prayer call its name Hawaiiloa, then throw it back into kuu aku ai o
the sea, and it will grow up into an island.” Kapuheeuanui obeyed the Kapuheeuanui i kana aho
instructions of the priest. The next day Kapuheeuanui went fishing i loko o ke kai mai
again and his line was again caught by a coral. This time he bethought Kapaahu mai, ia
himself of what the priest had said and took the coral to him, and the manawa, mau ana kana
priest said to him, “That is a man, a chief; call his name Mauiloa.” He aho lawaia, a manao ae
did so and then threw the coral back into the sea. On the third day of la oia he ia keia mea e
Kapuheeuanui’s fishing [22]his line was again entangled on a coral, mau nei, alaila, huki ae la
making the third piece of coral brought to the surface by his line, and, oia i kana aho, a i ke kau
as he had done before after freeing it from his line, took it to the priest. ana ae i ka waa, eia ka
The latter on beholding this coral exclaimed, “That is a man, a wohi, a he akoakoa. Ia manawa
chief from the sacred air; call his name Oahunuialaa.” 48 Kapuheeuanui hele mai ke kahuna o
continued fishing and always took to the priest the corals he caught on Laulialaamakua, e
his line, who named them and ordered him to go through the same hoomakaukau ana o
process of deifying them, or rather offering sacrifices to them, until all Kapuheeuanui e wehe ae
the islands now comprising the group were successively raised as i ke akoakoa a kiola aku,
corals. And thus, according to this tale, the islands of this group grew ia manawa, olelo aku ke
up from pieces of coral. But then, this is only a tale, and this is how one kahuna. “E! Mai kiola oe i
can ascertain the truth that these islands of Hawaii nei really did grow na akoakoa, he alii na, he
from corals. hai kanaka, hulia i puaa,
a hoomalielie i ke akua,
alaila pule a pau, alaila
kapa aku oe i kona inoa o
Hawaiiloa, alaila kiola aku
oe i loko o ke kai, e ulu
mai auanei na he moku.”
Alaila, hoolohe aku la o
Kapuheeuanui e like me
ka olelo a ke kahuna. I
kekahi la ae lawaia hou
no o Kapuheeuanui, hei
hou no ke akoakoa,
[23]alaila hoomanao ua
lawaia nei i ke kahuna,
lawe hou aku no i ke
akoakoa, i mai ke
kahuna, “He kanaka, he
alii, e kapa aku oe i ka
inoa o Mauiloa,” alaila
kiola aku la ua lawaia nei
i ka moana. I ka ekolu o
ka la lawaia o
Kapuheeuanui, hei hou
no he akoakoa, o ke kolu
ia o ka akoakoa; e like
me ka hana mau a ua
lawaia nei, a pela no oia i
hana aku ai. A ike mai la
ke hahuna i keia koa: “He
kanaka keia he wohi, he
alii no ka ea kapu, e kapa
aku i kona inoa o
Oahunuialaa.” Pela mau
ka hana mau a ua o
Kapuheeuanui, a pela no
hoi ka ke kahuna olelo i
ua lawaia nei. Ua kapaia
na inoa o keia mau aina
mamuli o ka olelo a ke
kahuna. A ma keia kaao
no Hawaii nei, he
akoakoa keia mau
mokupuni, ua ulu mai
loko ae o ke kai; aka, he
kaao wale no ia. A penei
hoi ka hoomaopopo ana i
ka oiaio ana, he akoakoa
io o Hawaii nei.
This is how the song runs that Makuakaumana 49 chanted at Tahiti, Penei ke mele a
when he and Paao went to get a new chief for Hawaii nei, because all Makuakaumana i oli aku
the old chiefs of Hawaii had sinned, Kapawa 50 being the king of Hawaii ai i Tahiti, ia laua me
at that time, he being of the fortieth generation from the time of Paao i holo ai i alii hou no
Opuukahonua. When Makuakaumana and company were nearing the Hawaii, no ka mea, ua
beach in the harbor of Moaulanuiakea 51 then Makuakaumana chanted pau na alii mua o Hawaii
to Lonokaeho, the priest of that place: nei i ka hewa, o Kapawa
ke alii o Hawaii nei ia
manawa, i ke kanaha o
na hanauna alii mai a
Opuukahonua mai a ia
Kapawa. A ia
Makuakaumana ma i
aneane aku ai e kau i ke
awa o Moaulanuiakea ia
manawa i oli aku ai o
Makuakaumana ia
Lonokaeho ke kahuna:
O Lono, O Lono, listen, O Lonokaeho! E Lono, e Lono - e-! E
Lonokulani, 52 chief of Kauluonana, 53 Lonokaeho!
Here are the canoes, get on board, Lonokulani alii o
Come along and dwell in Hawaii-with-the-green-back, 54 Kauluonana.
A land that was found in the ocean, Eia na waa kau mai,
That was thrown up from the sea, E hoi e noho ia
From the very depths of Kanaloa, Hawaiikuauli,
The white coral in the watery caves He aina loaa i ka moana,
That was caught on the hook of the fisherman; I hoea mai loko o ka ale;
The great fisherman of Kapaahu, I ka halehale poi pu a
The great fisherman Kapuheeuanui. Kanaloa;
The canoes touch the shore, come on board, He koakea i halelo i ka
Sail to Hawaii, an island, wai,
An island is Hawaii; I lou i ka makau a ka
An island is Hawaii for Lonokaeho to dwell on. lawaia,
A ka lawaia nui o
Kapaahu
A ka lawaia nui o
Kapuheeuanui - la
A pae na waa, kau mai,
E holo ai i Hawaii, he
moku;
He moku Hawaii,
He moku Hawaii na
Lonokaeho e noho.
When the canoes were beached, Paao told Lonokaeho he was wanted A pae na waa i uka, olelo
to go to Hawaii to be its ruler. When Lonokaeho heard this from Paao aku o Paao ia Lonokaeho
he said to him, “I will not go there, but I will send Pili and he shall eat of e hoi i alii no Hawaii. A
Hawaii. He shall be the chief to go together with you, and you must be lohe o Lonokaeho i keia
the priest.” And that is how Pili came to come here. It is so told in the olelo a Paao, alaila, olelo
history of Paao. But we must also examine the genealogy of chiefs aku la o Lonokaeho ia
from Opuukahonua to Wakea as is set forth in Chapter VI. Paao, “Aole wau e holo,
aka, e hoouna aku wau ia
Pili nana e ai o Hawaii,
oia ke alii e holo pu me
olua; a o oe no ke
kahuna.” A nolaila oia ka
hiki o Pili ia Hawaii nei.
(Pela i oleloia ma ka
moolelo o Paao). Aka, e
pono ke nana i ka
hoonohonoho ana o ka
mookuauhau alii mai a
Opuukahonua mai a hiki
ia Wakea, e like me ka
hoonohonoho ana ma
kela aoao Mokuna VI.
In the genealogical tree of Opuukahonua it is not stated who his Ma ka hoonohonoho ana
parents were, but, it is stated in the genealogy of Kualii, that i ka mookuauhau mai a
Opuukahonua came from Tahiti to live in Hawaii when these islands Opuukahonua mai, aole i
were inhabited by human beings. Opuukahonua came with his two ikeia ko Opuukahonua
younger brothers Lolomu and Mihi and one woman, Lana, and they mau makua, aka, o ka
became the progenitors of the people of Hawaii nei, and this is how mea i oleloia i loko o ka
they increased: [24] moolelo o Kualii, mai
Tahiti mai o
The Genealogy of Opuukahonua. Opuukahonua o ka hele
ana mai a noho i Hawaii
HUSBAND. KANE. WIFE. WAHINE. CHILD. KEIKI. nei, i ka manawa, aole he
Opuukahonua. Kanananuikumamao (k). kanaka ma keia mau
aina. Holo mai o
Lolomu. Lana. Ohikimakaloa (w). Opuukahonua me kona
mau kaikaina elua, o
Mihi. Hekilikaaka (k).
Lolomu a me Mihi,
Nakolowailani (k).
hookahi wahine o Lana, a
Hekilikaaka. Ohikimakaloa. o lakou na kupuna mua o
Ahulukaaala (w). Hawaii nei. A penei ka
laha ana: [27]
Mihi. Ahulukaaala. Kapuaululana.
Kapuaululana. Holani. Kekamaluahaku.
Kekamaluahaku. Laamea. Lanipipili.
Laakeakapu. Lanioaka.
Lanipipili.
Hinaimanau. Laakealaakona.
Kanehoalani. Kaiwilaniolua.
Kaihikapualamea. Kukonalaa.
Makakailenuiaola. Kahiko.
Kahakauakoko.
Papa. Hoohokukalani.
Wakea.
Hoohokukalani. Haloa.
Ulu.
Kii. Hinakoula.
Nanaulu.
Nana.
Nanaiea.
Mauimua.
Mauihope.
Akalana. Hinakawea.
Mauikiikii.
Mauiakalana.
Aikane. Hinahanaiakamalama.
Hema.
Kapoea. Paumakua.
Huanuiikalalailai.
Molehai. Kuhelani.
Hanalaanui.
Palena. Hikawainui.
Hanalaaiki.
Hualani. Kalahumoku.
Kanipahu.
Alaikaaukoko. Kalapana.
Kahoukapu.
Manauea.
Pinea. Hakau.
Liloa.
Akahiakuleana. Umi.
Kulamea. Kapunanahuanuiaumi.
Makaalua. Nohowaaumi.
Kealiiokalaloa.
Kapulani.
Kapukini.
Umi. Keawenuiaumi.
Aihakoko.
Piikea.
Kumalae.
Kaikilani.
Kukailani. Kaohukiokalani.
Makakaualii.
Keakealanikane.
Kalanioumi.
Keeumoku.
Keawe. Kalanikauleleiaiwi.
Kekela.
According to the genealogical table or tree from the time of Ma ka papa kuauhau i
Opuukahonua to Kamehameha there are ninety-nine generations, and hoonohonohoia mai a
that is the royal line of this race. But there were many chiefly branches Opuukahonua mai a hiki
from this royal line and many descendants, but no attention can now ia Kamehameha, he
be paid to them in a genealogical order. kanaiwakumamaiwa
hanauna ka nui, o lakou
ka hanauna alii o keia
lahui. Aka, ua puka mai
he mau lala ohana alii ma
keia mookuauhau, a ua
ulu a lehulehu lakou, aka,
aole e hiki ke
hoomaopopo i ka
hoonohonoho ana o na
lala ohana alii e ae, ma
na lalani like e like me ka
hoonohonoho ana i
hoikeia ma ka papa
kuauhau mai a
Opuukahonua mai.
It is well to divide those times into periods from the time of He mea pono ke
Opuukahonua until the reign of Kamehameha, and to credit each reign maheleia i mau wa mai a
with the works or happenings during its time as the story associates Opuukahonua a hiki ia
each king or chief with them. Kamehameha e like me
ka noho aupuni ana, a e
hoakaka pololei ia ka
hana i loko o na wa a me
na hana ano nui a keia
alii keia alii i loko o ko
lakou kaao ana.
The Earliest Times. From Opuukahonua to Kukonalaa, elder brother of Wa Mua. Mai a
Kapawa, was sixteen generations. That was when Pili arrived from Opuukahonua a hiki ia
Tahiti and Kapawa was the reigning sovereign, and there were several Kukonalaa ko Kapawa
battles as a consequence. kaikuaana, he
umikumamaono ia
hanauna, ia manawa hiki
mai o Pili mai Tahiti mai,
oia ke alii o Hawaii nei ia
manawa, aka, he mau
hoouka kaua ma ia
manawa.
Second Epoch. From Pili’s time to Kahiko there were eight Wa Elua. Mai ia Pili a hiki
generations, and there were several great undertakings during that ia Kahiko, ewalu ia
period, and Pili’s was a time of peace and prosperity, for he was wise. hanauna, he wa maikai
ia, a he mau hana
naauao no ka Pili ia
manawa.
Third Epoch. From Wakea to Waia there were four generations. There Wa Ekolu. Mai ia Wakea
were also several important works during that time. a hiki ia Waia, eha ia
hanauna, he mau hana
nui i loko oia manawa.
Fourth Epoch. From Waia to Liloa were fifty-seven generations. There Wa Eha. Mai a Waia a
were several happenings during this interval and many wars. hiki ia Liloa he
kanalimakumamahiku
hanauna, he nui na ano
oia wa, a me na hoouka
kaua ia wa.
Fifth Epoch. From Liloa to Kamehameha were fourteen generations. Wa Elima. Mai ia Liloa a
These divisions of time are not supposed to be strictly correct as there hiki ia Kamehameha, he
had been no one to definitely define the limits of each epoch. But it is umikumamaha hanauna.
settled on in this manner. These several divisions of time were known Ma keia mahele ana i na
to later generations by the legends and tales referring to them, and wa, aole ma ka pololei
made plainer by the prayer of Kukailani, a great priest who lived and maoli, aole no he mea
was of the seventy-ninth generation from the time of Opuukahonua. nana i hoomaopopo mai
ka mahele ana i na wa.
Aka, penei nae: Aia iloko
o keia mau wa i
maheleia, ua akaka ma
ko lakou kaao ana, a ua
akaka ma ka pule ana a
kekahi kahuna, o
Kukailani kona inoa, oia
paha ke
kanahikukumamaiwa o
ka hanauna mai a
Opuukahonua mai.
O thou Ku, and Uli, and Kama, it is flown. 1 E Ku, e Uli, e Kama, lele
Kalani the languishing chief of Kaiwa. wale. 1
Iwikauikaua in straight line from the depths; O Kalani ke ’lii kaahea o
From the Tahitian stem of the earth’s foundation, Kaiwa.
Whose royal lineage is so old and well established Iwikauikaua haulili mai
From the sacred ancestry of Kukonalaa. lalo;
The kapu was put on Makalii. Mai kumu kahiki ka
This is the first prayer; it is flown. honua ua kele,
The kapu of the island has flown. 2 Ua nao ua pela i ke kapu
The kapus of the islands are in a row; alii
The kapus of the islands are enjoined, I ka pela alii kapu o
The kapu of the island has come forth, Kukonalaa.
It has rested on the sacredness of the island, Ua kau ke kapu i Makalii.
Pili was the one that enjoyed that sanctity; Akahi -a- aha; lele wale.
The island of Hawaii-of-the-green-back. Lele mai ke kapu o ka
This is the second prayer. It has flown; moku. 2
The kapu has flown backwards to Wakea. [28] Lalani ke kapu o ka
Wakea was the priest, the chief 3 moku;
Who was born loaded and covered deep with kapu; Kui mai ke kapu o ka
It was Wakea who broke the kapu of the island. moku,
The kapu was divided to surround the islands, Pii mai ke kapu o ka
The kapu flew backwards to Waia 55 the king. moku,
This is the fourth, the fourth resting of the kapu; 56 Ili aku, kau aku ke kapu o
It was Liloa who enjoyed that kapu. ka moku,
The island is kapued for Liloa, 4 Na Pili e noho ia kapu,
The kapu had grown and flourished in Tahiti, Ka moku i Hawaiikuauli.
By Liloa of Umi was the kapu broken, Alua-a aha, lele wale;
The powers of the kapu were divided; Lele aku ke kapu ia
It is Iwiaulana Iwikauikaua. Wakea. [29]
A kamahele branch that is inclining downwards, 57 O Wakea ke kahuna, ke
That is weighed down by the kapus of Iwikauikaua. alii, 3
Let the bones pay 58 for the kapus of the island; Ke alii i kumu, i nua, i
Iwikauikaua was the wrong one; makolu i ke kapu;
The one who sulked in the waters of Haunaka. Ia Wakea naha ke kapu o
ka moku,
Mahae ke kapu i kiope na
moku,
Lele aku ke kapu o Waia
ke alii.
Aha -aha- ka ilina o ke
kapu,
Na Liloa e noho ia kapu.
Ua kapu ka moku ia
Liloa, 4
Ua kapu kawao i Tahiti,
Liloa o Umi ke kapu i
nahae,
Nahae na mana o ke
kapu,
O Iwiaulana Iwikauikaua.
Lola kamahele i kikiwi,
I pipio i ke kapu o
Iwikauikaua.
Na ka iwi e pani ke kapu
o ka moku;
Iwikauikaua ke kalohe;
Ka hoololohe wai i
Haunaka.
This is the prayer that is referred to in the genealogy of Kamalalawalu. O keia ka pule i oleloia i
And it is shown by the construction of this poetical prayer that time loko o ka molelo o
should be divided into epochs. Because it is only on the reigning kings Kamalalawalu. A ma keia
that the kapu of the islands are conferred, and it would seem time and mele pule i maopopo ai
epochs were divided as shown by the division of the chant referred to he pono ke mahele i mau
above. wa. No ka mea, aia wale
no ma na ’lii aimoku e ili
ai ke kapu moku. A mehe
mea la, ua
hoomaopopoia na wa ma
ia mau ano e like me na
pauku mele pule maluna
ae.
It is told in the history of Hawaii that was printed at Lahainaluna, and Ua oleloia ma ka moolelo
also in the history revised by Pogue of Lahainaluna, that a vessel of o Hawaii nei, i paiia ma
some kind had arrived at Hawaii long ago, and that was the first Lahainaluna, a me ka
knowledge the people of this race had of foreigners; but in the history moolelo i hooponopono
of Kualii, one of the former kings of Hawaii nei and a famous one for hou ia e Mr. Pokuea o
his strength and valor in battle, it is said that he was the first one to visit Lahainaluna, ua ku mua
Tahiti, and that he was the one that first knew or met foreigners in the mai kekahi moku ma
olden times. This is how that is recognized by his prayer in the middle Hawaii nei i ka wa kahiko,
of his history as recited below: a oia ka hoomaka mua
ana o keia lahui e ike i na
haole. Aka hoi, ma ka
moolelo o Kualii kekahi
alii kahiko o Hawaii nei,
ke alii kaulana no ka
ikaika i ke kaua; ua
oleloia, nana i ike mua o
Tahiti, a oia ka mea i ike
mua i na haole i ka wa
kahiko, a penei ka
hoomaopopo ana ma
kona pule, ma ka hapa
waena o kona moolelo e
like me malalo iho: