ISLAMIC RELIEF PAKISTAN

Revised Technical Evaluation against 114 Latrine DIKhan Under DEC-||(PR #10001423)
S. No Item/Description & Specification Vendor Vendor Vendor Vendor Remarks
MC SC GA
WC

Vendor WC mentioned Flying/Lucky brand. IRP

|Accepted Lucky cement

Vendor MC mentioned Kohat/Lucky brand. IRP

Accepted Both.
1 Cement Fresh (Ordinary Portland (0PC) cement) 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5
Vendor SC mentioned Lucky/Kohat/Pioneer brand.
IRP Accepted Lucky/Kohat
Vendor GR mentioned Lucky brand. IRP Accepted
Lucky.

Vendor WC Submitted Revised Sample of Brick(

Brand I) and and IR accepted
Vendor MCSubmited 7G, AK brands and IR
Bricks A class bricks ((Dimension 9'X4.5"X3") with frong
Jaccepted both
and regular shape, sharp edges, metallic sound when 2,5 2.5 2.5 2.5
Vendor Sc Submitted 11, SK brands and IR accepted
two bricks strike together, uniform colour and texture). both
Vendor GR Submitted 33 Brand sample and IR
accented
in JAllthe physical submitted samples by vendor are
3
Pre-cast RCC slabs for latrine roof & septic tank (size 2.5 2.5 2.
2.5
1.5'x5'), slabs with bracing and no tray type accepted to IR
Pre-cast RCCslabs for Soakage Pit (size 2'x4'), Slabs with All the physical submitted samples by vendor are
2.5 2.5 2.9 2.5
|bracingand no tray type accepted to IR
Vendor WC Submitted Gold Alpha brand as sample
and accepted by IR
Vendor MCSubmitted Atlas Pipe brand as sample
and IR accepted
|Air vent pipe PVC(2"dia x 10ft (PVC SCH 26/SDR 41) 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5
Vendor SC Submitted HI Master brand as sample
and IR accepted
Vendor GR Submitted Sonex Brand as sample and IR
laccepted
Vendor WC Submitted Eleven Star brand as sample
Jand accepted by IR
Vendor MCSubmitted Aqua Fit brand as sample and
2.5
IR accepted
6 Fly Screen for air vent pipe (2" UPVC) 2.5 2.5
Vendor SC Submitted Diamond brand as sample and
|IRaccepted
Vendor GR Submitted Master PVC Fly screen which
is anpraved
Vendor WCSubmitted Burj brand as sample and
accepted by IR
|Vendor MC Submitted Atlas Pipe brand as sample
2.5 2.5 2.5
Jand IR accepted
7 PVC Elbow (2" Dia (UPVC) Vendor SC Submitted Sonex Fit brand as sample and
|IR accepted
Vendor GR Submitted Sonex Fit brand as sample
Jand lR accented
Vendor WC Submitted Speed brand as sample and
accepted by IR
|Vendor MC Submitted Ravised sample of Master
2.5 2.5 2.5
brand wich is approved
PVC TEE (4" x 2" x4" (UPVC) Vendor SC Submitted Low quality brand as sample
and IR rejected
|Vendor GR Submitted sample of Master Brand UPVC
IIee which is anoraved
 Revised Technical Evaluation against 114 Latrine DI Khan Under DEC-I| (PR # 10001423)
$.No Item/Description &Specification Vendor Vendor Vendor Vendor Remarks
WC MC GR
Vendor WCSubmitted Gold plast brand as sample
and accepted by IR
Vendor MC Subrnitted low quality sample and IR
PVCPipe 4" pipe from WC to septic tank &
9 drain, PVC rejected
SCH 26/SDR 41) 2.5 2.5 2.5
Vendor SCSubmitted HIMaster brand as sarnple
land IR accepted
Vendor GR Subrnitted Sonex Fit brand as sarnple
Jand lR WCSu
Vendor açGPRARtted Gald plast brand as sample
and accepted by IR
Vendor MC Submitted low quality sample and IR
10
PVC Pipe 3" pipe to drain out waste water from latrine, rejected
25 2.5 2.5
PVC SCH 26/SDR 41) Vendor SC Submitted HI Master brand as sarnple
and IR accepted
Vendor GR Submitted Sonex Fit brand as sample
andJR
Vendoraccented
WC Submítted Eleven Star brand as sample
and accepted by IR
Vendor MC Submitted Capital brand as sample and
|IR accepted
11 Indian WC Medium Size white colour 2.5 2.5 2.5 Vendor SC Submitted Eleven Star brand as sample
and IR accepted
Vendor GR Submitted Volks brand as sample and IR
accepted
Vendor WC Submitted Eleven Star brand as sample
Jand accepted by IR
Vendor MC Submitted PCI brand as sample and IR
accepted
12 P-Trap (4" ceramic) 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5 Vendor SC Submitted Eleven Star brand as sample
land IR accepted
Vendor GR Submitted Durr brand as sample and IR
ed
endor WC Submitted Popular brand as sample and
accepted by IR
Vendor MC Submitted Alpha brand as sample and IR
Jaccepted
13 Solution for PVC pipes 125 Gm 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5
Vendor ScSubmitted Alpha brand as sample and IR
accepted
Vendor GR Submitted Durr Kawsar as sample and IR
AwSubmitted
Vendor sample as per the specs &
standards and accepted by IR conditionally by
|Iron Door (Pre-Painted door Size 2.5'x6 sheet SWG 22, improving the weight, angle size and bracing
|Vendor MC Submitted sample as per the specs &
with 1.25" Angel Iron farm and double diagonal bracing standards and accepted by IR conditionally by
14 |SWG 16 approx. weight 16 kg, provided with handles 2.5 2.5 1 2.5
improving the finishing quality
Jand locking mechanism from both sides, provided with Vendor SC Submitted cut pieces of materials as
properly welded mesh (jaali) 4"on the top of door) sample (not complete door) and IR rejected
Vendor GR Submitted revised sample of Door having
Mietagp (90 kal whicbis annraved
|Vendor WC Submitted Steel made Floor Screen
which is approved
in
Vendor MC Submitted Nice brand as sample and IR
accepted
15 Floor Screen 3 inches (plastic or steel) 2.5 2.5 2.5 2.5
Vendor SC Submitted DGOS brand as sample and IR
accepted
|Vendor GR Submitted revised sample of floor
screen is Hame Stve Brand which is annraved
Total Marks 37.5 34.5 34.5 37.5

Name: Shah Hassan Khan/ Ghulam Muhammad

Senior WASH Officer/ Project Engineer
Date: April 24, 2024

Points Guide:
|As Per IR Requirement = 2.5 to 3
2 Below IR Requirement =1
3 Sample Not Submitted=0