Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 147

UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G.

TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY


Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

THE LIVED EXPERIENCES OF PATIENTS THAT USED


TELEMEDICINE DURING THE
COVID-19 PANDEMIC

An Undergraduate Study Presented to The


Faculty of the College of Nursing
University of Perpetual Help
System Laguna

In Partial
Fulfillment of the
Requirement for the degree of
BACHELOR OF SCIENCE IN NURSING

By:
Dela Cruz, Aivee A.
De Leon, Danielle Anne G.
De Leon, Joanna Bren B.
Desquitado, Ireneo D.
Dominguez, Aira M.

January 2024
2
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

RECOMMENDATION FOR ORAL EXAMINATION

This undergraduate thesis entitled: “THE LIVED EXPERIENCES OF


PATIENTS THAT USED TELEMEDICINE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC,”
prepared and submitted by Aivee A. Dela Cruz, Danielle Anne G. De Leon, Joanna
Bren B. De Leon, Ireneo D. Desquitado, and Aira M. Dominguez in partial fulfillment
of the requirements for the degree Bachelor of Science in Nursing, has been
examined and hereby recommended for acceptance and approval for ORAL
EXAMINATION.

______________________________
Mona Liza U. Avelino, RN, MAN, PhD

Adviser

APPROVAL BY THE PANEL OF EXAMINERS

Approved by the committee on Oral Examinations with a grade of


__________________________.

______________________________
First Name M.I. Last Name, Title
Chairman

____________________________ ____________________________
First Name M.I. Last Name, Title First Name M.I. Last Name, Title
Panelist Panelist

Accepted and approved in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the


degree Bachelor of Science in Nursing.

____________ ____________________________________
Date Dean Estrella A. San Juan, RN, MAN, PhD
3
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The researchers would like to express their heartfelt appreciation to the

following individuals for their guidance and support in accomplishing this scholarly

endeavor:

First and foremost, ...


4
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

THESIS ABSTRACT

Title : “THE LIVED EXPERIENCES OF PATIENTS THAT USED


TELEMEDICINE DURING THE COVID-19 PANDEMIC”
Authors : Aivee A. Dela Cruz, Danielle Anne G. De Leon, Joanna
Bren B. De Leon, Ireneo D. Desquitado, and Aira M.
Dominguez
Degree : Bachelor of Science in Nursing
School : University of Perpetual Help – Dr. Jose G. Tamayo Medical
University
Academic Year : 2022 – 2023
Adviser : First Name M.I. Last Name, Title
Number of Pages :

Patients play a crucial role in the realm of telemedicine as the recipients of

care. Their firsthand encounters significantly shape the delivery of telehealth and

telemedicine services. Therefore, comprehending their lived experiences becomes

paramount for the continued development and enhancement of services that align

with optimal healthcare. Telemedicine emerged as the most convenient and

accessible avenue for seeking consultations amid the challenges posed by the

COVID-19 pandemic. Based on the result of the study, the following conclusion

were drawn: (1) This study delves into the positive experiences of patients utilizing

telemedicine during the Covid-19 pandemic. Participants express a favorable

perception of telemedicine, citing its accessibility, convenience, and contribution to

their overall wellbeing. The decision to choose telemedicine is rooted in its utility

and positive impact on the healthcare consultation process, providing insights into

the transformative role of telemedicine in enhancing patient health. (2) Alongside


5
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

the positive experiences, participants share challenges encountered during

telemedicine consultations. Notable issues include limitations on physical

examinations or procedures, reflecting the constraints of remote healthcare

assessments. Additionally, challenges related to the lack of internet connection and

delayed responses from healthcare providers are identified. These challenges

underscore the existing limitations of telemedicine, contributing valuable insights

into areas that may require improvement. (3) Benefits of Telemedicine during the

Pandemic: Despite the challenges, the study highlights significant benefits

associated with telemedicine in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic. These

advantages encompass enhanced safety measures, cost-effectiveness, effective

communication channels between patients and healthcare providers, and the

elimination of travel time. The identification of these benefits positioned

telemedicine as a promising avenue for improving healthcare delivery, particularly

in times of crisis, emphasizing its potential to address key healthcare concerns and

enhance overall patient experiences.

TABLE OF CONTENTS
6
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Page
TITLE PAGE
i
RECOMMENDATION FOR ORAL EXAMINATION
ii
APPROVAL SHEET
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
iii
THESIS ABSTRACT
iv
TABLE OF CONTENTS
v
LIST OF TABLES
viii
LIST OF FIGURES
ix
Chapter

1 THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND

Introduction 1

Theoretical Framework 3

Operational Framework 5

Statement of the Problem 7

Assumption of the Study 7

Scope and Delimitations 8

Significance of the Study 9

Definition of Terms 11

2 REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

The Great Demand for Telehealth and Telemedicine 13


7
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Telehealth: Defining the 21st Century Care 15

The Various Types of Telehealth Services 16

The Primary Role of Telemedicine in COVID-19 Pandemic 17

Telemedicine Status in Different Countries 18

The Emergence of Telehealth in the Philippines 20

The Role of Telemedicine in the Philippines 21

Synthesis of the Reviewed Literature 22

Gaps that the Present Study will Bridge 26

3 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Research Design 27

Sources of Data 28

Participants of the Study 28

Instrumentation and Validation 29

Data-Gathering Procedure 30

Data Analysis 31

Ethical Consideration 33

4 RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

I. The Experiences of Patients in Using Telemedicine during the 35


8
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Covid-19 Pandemic

II. Challenges Experienced by the Patient during the Consultation 49

III. Benefit of Telemedicine during the Covid-19 Pandemic 56

5 SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Summary 64

Conclusions 65

Recommendations 66

REFERENCES 69

APPENDIX A (Research Instrument)

APPENDIX B (Letter to the Dean of the College of Nursing)

APPENDIX C (Thematic Anaylsis)

APPENDIX D (Interview Transcript)

CURRICULUM VITAE

LIST OF TABLES

Table Page

1 Perception on Telemedicine 35

2 Choosing Telemedicine Service Among Others 39

3 Problems Encountered during the Consultation 49

4 Advantages of Telemedicine during Consultation 56


9
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure Page

1 Dorothea Orem’s Model of Self-Care Theory 4

2 Operational Framework 6

3 Colaizzi's Method of Data Analysis 32

CHAPTER 1

THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND

Introduction
10
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The emergence of the Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) in 2020 prompted a

global health crisis, with the World Health Organization declaring it a pandemic

(Mayo Clinic, 2022). The infectious nature of the disease, coupled with a lack of

effective treatments or vaccines at the time, necessitated rapid adaptations in

healthcare delivery. In response, the utilization of telemedicine, a digital health

technology, became paramount in managing and mitigating the impact of the

pandemic.

Governments worldwide implemented containment and mitigation measures,

including surveillance, testing, contact tracing, and strict quarantine. Digitally

advanced countries effectively employed telemedicine to curb the spread of COVID-

19 and ensure early detection for prompt management, as well as the continuous

care of individuals with multiple chronic diseases (Whitelaw et al., 2020; Latifi &

Doarn, 2020).

While telemedicine gained prevalence during this critical period, challenges

persisted in terms of varied solutions and infrastructure quality, hindering optimal

implementation (Omboni et al., 2022). In Southeast Asia, some countries, unlike

the Philippines, had already developed guidelines for telemedicine. Notably, the

Philippines addressed this gap on November 17, 2021, by passing House Bill No.

10245, known as the "eHealth System and Services Act" (Cervantes, 2021). This

bill aimed to institutionalize a comprehensive system providing accessible and


11
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

quality health information and services through information and communications

technology (ICT). Particularly focused on medically underserved areas, the

proposed Act aimed to benefit marginalized populations, aligning processes,

ensuring data availability, and promoting safe and effective service provision of

telemedicine in the country.

This study delves into the lived experiences of patients who embraced

telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic. By exploring these experiences, the

research seeks to contribute valuable insights to the ongoing evolution of

telemedicine, especially in the Philippines, where the proposed eHealth Act is

subject to refinement. The narratives shared by participants may be of use for the

refinement of the guidelines and shaping the future landscape of telemedicine use

in the country.

Theoretical Framework

Dorothea Orem's Model of Self-Care, a foundational nursing concept, proves

crucial in understanding how individuals experienced telemedicine during the

COVID-19 pandemic. This theory, rooted in the belief that nursing interventions
12
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

should empower individuals in self-management for life, health, and well-being,

aligns seamlessly with the fundamental principles of telemedicine (Hellqvist, 2021).

The essence of the Self-Care Nursing Theory emphasizes that individuals

naturally possess the desire and capability to care for themselves. Traditionally

applied in rehabilitation and primary care, this theory takes on a transformative role

in the virtual care landscape, acknowledging that individuals actively turn to

telemedicine platforms to address their perceived healthcare needs.

Orem's theory highlights the collaborative role of healthcare professionals in

developing specialized technologies, especially in telemedicine where

communication is adapted to factors like age and health status (King, 2007). The

core assumption of the theory, focusing on individuals' continual interaction with

their environment, extends to the use of digital devices within the telemedicine

framework. Individuals actively contribute to their well-being and potentially the

well-being of others through these proactive engagements.

As the study delves into the experiences of patients using telemedicine

during the pandemic, Orem's Self-Care Theory provides a theoretical foundation. It

underscores the importance of individuals actively participating in their healthcare,

even in the virtual realm. This framework enables an in-depth exploration of how

patients, through digital interactions, address their healthcare needs, making a


13
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

proactive choice to engage in their healthcare journey amid the evolving landscape

of telemedicine.

Figure 1. Dorothea Orem’s Model of Self-Care Theory

Operational Framework

This study employs a phenomenological approach to delve into the lived

experiences of patients who embraced telemedicine as a healthcare alternative

during the Covid-19 pandemic. The research is structured around three key distinct
14
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

research questions. First, the investigation seeks to uncover the comprehensive

range of patient experiences in utilizing telemedicine, exploring facets such as

accessibility, convenience, and overall satisfaction. The second research question

focuses on understanding how these experiences shape patients' perspectives

regarding telemedicine, particularly concerning perceived challenges associated

with this mode of healthcare delivery. Simultaneously, the third question delves

into the influence of patient experiences on their perspectives but with a focus on

the perceived benefits of telemedicine. This multifaceted approach aims to unravel

the intricate interplay between patient encounters, challenges, and benefits within

the realm of telemedicine during a global health crisis. The "Lived Experiences of

Patients that used telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic," encapsulates the

diverse array of encounters and perceptions, offering a nuanced understanding of

the patient journey in the context of telehealth services.


15
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Figure 2. Operational Framework

Statement of the Problem

This research aims to explore the lived experiences of patients who used

telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic. Specifically, this research will seek to

answer the following questions:

1. What are the experiences of patients in using telemedicine during the Covid-

19 pandemic?

2. How does these experiences influence the perspective of patients regarding

telemedicine based on its perceived challenges?


16
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

3. How does these experiences influence the perspective of patients regarding

telemedicine based on its perceived benefits?

Assumption of the Study

In conducting this research, the researchers aim to derive meaningful

insights. The study operates under certain assumptions:

1. Participants have gained enhanced knowledge concerning their health and

well-being through telemedicine.

2. Participants did not encounter challenges in utilizing telemedicine.

3. Participants perceive telemedicine as a provider of quality care, and they

express a willingness to recommend its usage to others.

Scope and Delimitations

This research focuses on investigating the lived experiences of individuals

who engaged with telemedicine services amid the COVID-19 pandemic. The study

involves ten (10) participants selected from the areas of Binan and Sta. Rosa,

Laguna, providing a localized perspective on telemedicine utilization. The research

duration spans from April 2023 to May 2023, capturing a specific timeframe during

the ongoing pandemic. Face-to-face interviews were chosen as the primary method

for data collection.


17
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The individuals included in this study will be patients with prior experience in

utilizing telemedicine services. According to Cresswell (2013), an optimal range for

participants in a qualitative study is between five and twenty-five (5–25). To

maximize efficiency within the specified timeframe, the researchers intend to

involve ten (10) participants in the study.

To ensure a focused participant selection, the researchers employed

Purposive and Snowball Sampling techniques. Purposive Sampling allowed

intentional selection based on predefined criteria relevant to telemedicine

experiences, while Snowball Sampling facilitated participant recruitment through

referrals.

Significance of the Study

In the context of the evolving healthcare landscape influenced by the COVID-

19 pandemic, this study addresses the practical significance of understanding

individuals' direct experiences with telemedicine. The research aims to provide

concrete insights with potential applications in patient care, healthcare practices,

and policy development.

Patients. This study will benefit the patients by acquiring in-depth knowledge

about telemedicine, empowering them to make well-informed decisions regarding

its merits and challenges. Their experiences may help in guiding future telemedicine

services in the country for optimal use.


18
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Healthcare Professionals. This research will offer insights into patients'

encounters with telehealth services, potentially enhancing the flexibility between

patients and nurses. Armed with crucial knowledge about patients' experiences,

healthcare workers can adapt and improve their healthcare practices, aligning them

with the patients' perspectives. Ultimately, this adjustment has the potential to

optimize the delivery of healthcare services.

Department of Health. This knowledge equips the Department of Health

with data-driven considerations to refine and optimize the integration of telehealth

services within the broader healthcare framework. By aligning policies and practices

with the uncovered experiences, the department stands to enhance the quality and

accessibility of healthcare services, particularly in the context of telemedicine,

contributing to more effective public health initiatives.

Future researchers. Future researchers can utilize this study as a reference,

providing a starting point for further research aimed at improving healthcare on a

macro level. Contributing to the collective knowledge related to Telehealth and

Telemedicine, this research offers an initial understanding of the subject,

encouraging future exploration of related topics for ongoing improvements in

healthcare practices.

Definition of Terms
19
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The following terms have been defined conceptually and operationally

according to how they are used in this study.

Electronic health or eHealth refers to the use of cost-effective and secure

information communication technology (ICT) for health. Also known as telehealth.

Geographically Isolated and Disadvantaged Areas (GIDAs) refer to

communities with marginalized populations physically and socio-economically

separated from the mainstream society and characterized by: a. Physical factors

such as those isolated due to distance, weather conditions, and transportation

difficulties; and b. Socio-economic factors such as high poverty incidence, presence

of vulnerable sectors, and communities

in or recovering from situations of crisis or armed conflict (“Philippine eHealth

Systems and Services Act,” 2021).

Information and Communications Technology (ICT) refers to the

following:

1. Compressed digital interactive video, audio, or data transmission;

2. Real-time synchronous video or web-conferencing communications;

3. Secure web-based communication;

4. Still image capture or asynchronous store and forward; and


20
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

5. Modern smart medical device are used for diagnosis and health care services

(“Philippine eHealth Systems and Services Act,” 2021).

Telehealth is the use of medical information exchanged from one site to

another via information and communication technologies (ICT) to improve the

patient’s health status. It encompasses preventive, promotive, curative, and

palliative aspects.

Telemedicine is the technology used to transmit electronic medical data

about clients to individuals at distant locations. It focuses more on the

curative/treatment aspect. Telehealth is often used interchangeably

with telemedicine, with telemedicine often being associated with direct client clinical

services, whereas telehealth has a broader definition of remote healthcare services

(Institute of Medicine, 2012, p. 134).

CHAPTER 2
21
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE

This chapter presents the related literature to support and validate the

findings of this study. To give a detailed discussion of the subject, the researchers

anchored this comprehensive analysis to several ideas and perspectives. This study

will include literature and other studies. This section also included a synthesis of the

reviewed related literature as well as a description of the gaps to be bridged by the

study.

The Great Demand for Telehealth and Telemedicine

With over 250 million cases globally and infections still continually rising in

most countries (Abraham & Biswas, 2020), COVID-19 has threatened human lives,

disrupted livelihoods, created societal and economic disorder of unparalleled

magnitude, and putting the global health care sector to a crisis. (Rasul, et al.,

2021)

Firstly, healthcare workers continually experienced higher workload,

psychological distress, shortage of personal protective equipment (PPE), lack of

incentives, and exclusion (Razu et al., 2021). Whereas, frontline workers globally

are shouldering the burden of treating the global pandemic while continuously

providing essential health services. (Braimoh et al., 2021).


22
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

In order to mitigate further burden to the different affected sectors: social

distancing was implemented (Pearce, 2020). ‘Social Distancing’ in application to

COVID-19 is defined as "remaining out of congregate settings, avoiding mass

gatherings, and maintaining distance (approximately 6 feet or 2 meters) from

others when possible." (CDC, 2020). However, Smith et al, (2020) emphasized

that continuance of care for those people without COVID-19 but suffering from

diseases should still be provided with care without the risk of exposure to hospital

congestion or hospital waiting rooms.

In relation to the aforementioned studies, Chuo, et al. (2020) emphasized

that as a response to the implementation of ‘Social Distancing’ the health-care

system was led to adapt in the time of crisis, especially as it faces the COVID-19

pandemic. To avoid the catastrophic consequences of "doing business as usual,"

the health care system has shifted toward providing care through telehealth

platforms, specifically telemedicine, making telehealth a leading modality of health

care delivery.

Exploring this case, Thomas et, al. (2020) claims that telemedicine offers

clients convenient access to consultations without the risk of exposure to the virus,

significantly decreasing person-to-person contact. Notably, telehealth avoids new

hospital visits that can potentially free up hospital beds and equipment for patients

who needs them most. (Hoffman, 2020) For this reason, telemedicine became the
23
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

most secure interactive system between patients and clinicians amidst the

pandemic. (Galiero, et al. 2020)

Telehealth: Defining the 21st Century Care

Telehealth is defined as the usage of medical information exchanged from

one site to another through electronic and digital means such as computers and

mobile devices with the goal of improving patients’ health (MFMER, 2022). It

allows individuals and healthcare providers to communicate effectively about

health-related topics when in-person care is not possible or necessary. (Tuckson et

al., 2017)

For the past years, the consistent usage of Telehealth has been consistently

regarded as a safe quality care modality and a convenient option for both patients

and clinicians. Moreover, it also increases the accessibility of rural communities,

vulnerable patient populations, and patients unable to secure in-person care for

safe, effective, and appropriate care when and where they require it (ATA, 2022).

Additionally, the goals of Telehealth encompass the following: accessible

health care, readily available health services, alternative consultation modality,

easier access to medical specialists, improved communication and coordination of

care, and support for self-management of health care (Persaud et al, 2017).
24
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The Various Types of Telehealth Services

To elaborate on the concept of Telehealth further, MFMER (2022) highlights

four main categories of Telehealth in the current medical industry. The benefits of

each category may vary depending on the scope of the patient’s health needs.

Live Videoconferencing (Telemedicine) is the most notable type of

technology-based healthcare service in telehealth, it is also known as Online

Consultation or Telemedicine. It involves a live, two-way video-based based

conference between the client and medical practitioner in real-time, or live. It is

typically done via interactive software such as Zoom and Google Meet housed in

hardware such as desktop computers, laptops, tablets, and smartphones.

The process of Telemedicine according to Saini and Jaiya (2022), starts with:

Firstly, the pre-consultation phase wherein the client will book a schedule with the

physician. Secondly, the consultation phase where the client and physician will have

a discourse about the health concern. Lastly, the sendoff phase wherein the

physician will provide an e-prescription or a follow-up schedule sent to the client.

In contrast with the aforementioned, the second category is Mobile Health

(mHealth). It is defined as the involvement of hardware devices such as

smartphones, tablets, smart wearables like iWatch, and other technologies to

monitor a variety of factors such as pulse rate, heart rate, and vital signs. Mobile
25
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Applications can be suggested by the physician to help clients manage health

conditions (Telehealth Org., 2020).

Similar to Mobile Health, the third category: Remote Patient Monitoring

(RPM) also allows healthcare providers to record and monitor patients’ health from

a distance. It uses web-based or mobile applications, wearable devices, and home

monitoring devices for uploading health-related information. (Chiron Health, 2022)

Different from all categories, Asynchronous Telehealth (Store-and-Forward

Telemedicine) involves a cloud-based platform that allows the clients’ data to be

collected and stored securely and later retrieved by professionals for analysis. This

type of telehealth is beneficial in rural settings where accessibility to specialists is

limited. Furthermore, it allows health providers in the area to electronically send

clients’ data to other geographic areas for consultation and analysis. (HIPAA, 2022)

The Primary Role of Telemedicine in the COVID-19 Pandemic

The rise of Telemedicine expanded as one of the management responses to

the COVID-19 crisis (Bahl et al. 2020). Due to the increased vulnerability and risk

of exposure to the virus, telemedicine has been applied more broadly across the

healthcare industry. Its use facilitates early patient access to health and social

services (Tahan, 2020). Moreover, video conferencing and similar systems were

also utilized to provide health care programs for people who are hospitalized and in
26
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

quarantine to reduce the risk of spread and exposure to others and employees.

(Smith et al. 2020)

Additionally, physicians under quarantine utilized telemedicine to employ

their services remotely (Hollander and Carr, 2020). This addresses the challenge of

the lack of workforce, enabling physicians, although infected, to resume their duties

through telemedicine (Shaw, et al. 2020). A further point, Tahan (2020) also

mentioned that telemedicine enabled other healthcare providers such as nurse

practitioners, clinical psychologists, and licensed clinical social workers to be

reimbursed for services in providing healthcare to their patients via telemedicine.

Telemedicine Status in Different Countries

The aforementioned related literature emphasizes that the pandemic

challenged health care systems across the globe. However, despite various

attempts to reform the health care system in the Middle East, its progress has been

slow. Factors including cultural, financial, technological, legal, and regulatory

challenges were found to prevent telemedicine from being fully utilized. Moreover,

patients' and doctors’ resistance to the usage of telemedicine is rooted in its low-

quality system implementation, lack of infrastructure, funding, and lack of

information technology training. (Hosam, 2020)

In comparison, the prolonged COVID-19 outbreak the Ministry of Health and

Welfare in South Korea agreed that teleconsultation is a helpful modality in avoiding


27
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

hospital visits that can lead to transmission of the virus. Despite this, unprepared

telemedicine implementation can cause detrimental effects such as confusion for

the medical staff and patients therefore it is not a permanent modality for

consultation, only temporary. (Kim, 2021).

Similarly, Price (2020) emphasized that telemedicine has proven to be an

extremely effective and necessary tool in the fight against COVID-19. It's likely to

remain but there is still room for improvement just as there is room for health care

providers to adapt to changing technology.

Even more so, the surge in usage and demand of Telemedicine in countries

like the USA (Hyder, 2020), the UK (Browne, 2020), and China (Cui, et al., 2020)

and countries in Latin America (Pierce, et al. 2021), by contrast, a technologically

advance country like Japan experience little usage of Telemedicine. An average of

2,400 initial online doctor appointments were conducted per month accounting for

less than 0.1% of the total doctor appointments in the country (Seki, 2021).

Moreover, Noto (2021) emphasized that the Japanese Medical Association

had shown skepticism and reluctance toward telemedicine, concerned that doctors

might be sued for misdiagnosis or footage of appointments could be leaked by

patients. Therefore, online consultation has struggled to increase.

The Emergence of Telehealth in the Philippines


28
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Telehealth and telemedicine are not new concepts in the Philippines. The

National eHealth Systems and Services Act (HB 10245), which delivers health

services through cost-effective, secure information, and communications technology

(ICT), was approved by the Philippine House Committee on Health. This approved

measure now specifies that Republic 10532 or the “Philippine National Health

Research System Act of 2013” shall ensure the development of new eHealth

solutions, services, and innovations.

The aforementioned law brought about the pioneers of telemedicine locally,

which includes KonsultaMD, a 24/7 health hotline service manned by skilled and

licensed Filipino doctors, and AIDE, a mobile app marketplace that connects

patients with doctors that were both established in 2015. Like in other countries,

the adaption of telemedicine in the Philippines was sluggish, hampered by

consumers' unwillingness to try this modality for medical consultations and

clinicians' general reluctance to change their current practices and learn a new way

of providing medical care (Lugtu, 2021).

Despite this reluctance, the genesis of the COVID-19 pandemic forced the

Philippine Health Care System to adapt to the challenges. In the words of Portia

Marcelo, a project leader of the National Telehealth System, ‘Telehealth was really

born out of the need for access to better care because of the geographic and social

challenges.’ (SIHI, 2020).


29
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The Role of Telemedicine in the Philippines

In addition to the aforementioned literature and studies, the Department of

Health (DOH) and the National Privacy Commission (NPC) released a framework for

telemedicine services to improve access to health services during the Enhanced

Community Quarantine amidst the pandemic. In the joint memorandum,

Telemedicine services were strengthened and offered for free, this allows physicians

to give medical consultations over the phone, chat, short messaging services

(SMS), and other audio-visual-conferencing platforms. To enhance it further,

medical practitioners are allowed to issue electronic case reports and prescriptions

(DOH, 2020).

With the vast array of services provided through online platforms due to the

many Filipinos diligently following health protocols, telehealth has stepped up in

expanding its services (Plantado, et al. 2020). In addition, this led to the rise of

Telemedicine in the country. Most of the online medical consultation services

provide 24/7 access to their users and/or subscribers, some require a certain

application to be downloaded on the user’s mobile phone or computer and provide

either monetary registration or free service. (Publico, 2022)

Likewise, another mode of availing telemedicine was through the DOH

COVID-19 hotline and via the website or downloadable mobile applications such as

SeeYouDoc, CloudPx, HealthnowPH, TelAventusMD, MedCheck, Telimed by


30
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Medgate, KonsultaMD, CareSpan, BizBox, and TsekApp to name a few. (DOH,

2020).

A further point, a surge of teleconsultations came after the country’s health

department allowed access to Telemedicine in lieu of the COVID-19 outbreak.

Telemedicine provider Medgate reported 170% increase in teleconsultation in

Philippines in 2020 and an 80% resolution rate. This service resulted in easing

hospital occupancy and preventing the spread of the outbreak (Gunasegaran,

2021).

Telemedicine is practically the future of the Philippines' healthcare industry,

and the Philippines government will need to regard it as a crucial component of

universal health coverage (Hani, et al., 2021). Additionally, the Philippines has a

low doctor-to-patient ratio (Balinbin, 2021). Using technology like telemedicine to

deliver healthcare is critical to improving the country's healthcare system.

Synthesis of the Reviewed Literature

Telehealth was defined as electronic and digital means to exchange medical

information from one site to another. It is a safe and secure digital environment

where effective communication about health-related topics is discussed via video

conference and remote monitoring tools. It provides access to health care,

especially to rural communities and vulnerable patient populations. (MFMER, 2022;

Tuckson, et al., 2017; Saini & Jaiya (2020); ATA, 2022; Persaud, et al. 2017)
31
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

In addition to the aforementioned, MFMER, (2022); Telehealth Org., (2020);

Chiron Health, (2022); and HIPAA, (2022); defined the various types of Telehealth

services available in the medical industry. They all agreed that Live

Videoconferencing or Telemedicine is the most notable, especially during the time

of the pandemic.

With the continuous rise of COVID-19 infections around the globe various

detrimental effects have been observed. It disrupted the socio-economic order,

and day-to-day living, and put the global healthcare sector in a crisis. (Rasul, et al,

2021; Razu, et al. 2021; Braimoh, et al. 2021)

Furthermore, social distancing was implemented to break the exponential

curve, banning mass gatherings and promoting distancing. However, people with

illnesses other than COVID-19 still require medical attention. Due to this reason,

Telemedicine has become the most secure interactive system for patients and

clinicians. (CDC, 2020; Smith, et al. 2020; Galiero, et al. 2020)

The claim above was supported by the study of Chuo, et al. (2020). They

emphasized the shift of treatment from the standard through a new modality, can

leads to the prevention of severe consequences. Moreover, Thomas, et al. (2020),

also emphasized that Telemedicine not only guarantees safety but also provides

convenient access to health care.


32
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Likewise, Bahl, et al. (2022) agreed that Telemedicine is one of the

management approaches to the COVID-19 crisis. This was supported by Tahan

(2022); Smith, et al. (2020); and Hollander & Carr, (2020) by mentioning that it

facilitates early patient access to health and services and reduces exposure to

COVID-19. It also re-employs physicians and other medical workers infected by

COVID-19 to resume their duties via digital means.

Though telemedicine had been considerably regarded as helpful by most

nations, in contrast, each country had their way of handling the COVID-19

pandemic, various countries had implemented Telemedicine. Additionally, the USA,

UK, China, and countries in Latin America have shown a significant surge in its

usage. (Hyder, 2020; Browne, 2020; Cui, et al., 2020; Pierce, et al., 2021)

An exception in regions like the Middle East, the progress of Telemedicine

has been slow and doctors and patients alike shown resistance to its usage (Hosam,

2020). Likewise in Japan, the use of Telemedicine consists of less than 0.1% of the

total medical appointments, thereby Noto (2021) emphasized that usage of

telemedicine struggled to increase in Japan.

Similarly, Kim (2021) emphasized that Korea utilizes telemedicine but it

would not be the basis of treatment permanently, only temporarily. There is still

room for improvement in Telemedicine according to a study by Price (2020).


33
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

According to Lugtu (2021), Telehealth was established in the Philippines as

early as 2015. It is not a new concept; however, it is unpopular or not well known.

In contrast, the study of SIHI (2020) highlights the shift of the modality of

consultation from traditional to digital via telemedicine as a response to the

challenge of the COVID-19 pandemic.

To support the claim above, the Department of Health and the National

Privacy Commission released a framework for telemedicine services to be

implemented and strengthened during the Enhanced Community Quarantine (DOH,

2020). This was supported by the study of Plantado, et al. (2021), who mentioned

that telemedicine services were offered for free and conducted 24/7. This is due to

the compliance of R.A 11223 to provide equitable access to quality and affordable

health care and services.

Moreover, DOH (2020) and Publico (2022) emphasized the use of

applications to fully utilize Telemedicine services in the Philippines that promote

accessibility to telemedicine. In relation, Gunasegaran (2021) reported that there

was a 170% increase in the usage of Telemedicine in the Philippines in 2020. This

was supported by Hani, et al. (2021), by mentioning that almost 70,000 virtual

services had been provided during the COVID-19 outbreak.

Gaps that the Present Study Will Bridge


34
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Whilst various published related literature discussed about definition, usage,

and need for telemedicine, a knowledge gap persists for understanding the

experiences of patients related to the use of telemedicine.

This study will be comparable with the related studies. The aforementioned

related literature and article focuses on telemedicine at a macro level: it discusses

concepts related to telemedicine and its application to the community and the

country. This study will explore the same concepts of telemedicine however, this

study will focus on the micro level: the participants and their experiences.

CHAPTER 3

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
35
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

This chapter discusses the research design, the selection of the participants

as well as the data-gathering procedures, the treatment and analysis of data, and

ethical considerations.

Research Design

For the purpose of understanding the participants’ lived experiences,

researchers in this research study employed a qualitative research method,

specifically, phenomenological research design since the result of the study will

explore the lived experiences of patients who used telemedicine during the COVID-

19 pandemic. Phenomenological research is an approach to qualitative research

that aims to comprehend and articulate the fundamental essence of a phenomenon

in a universal manner. This technique examines the daily encounters of individuals

while refraining from the researchers' preexisting views regarding the phenomenon.

Phenomenological research aims to explore the subjective experiences of

individuals in order to obtain a more profound understanding of their interpretations

and comprehension of events. This methodology is widely employed for the

examination of lived experiences, facilitating a more profound comprehension of

human cognition, and enhancing a researcher's grasp of a particular event. The

phenomenological research design necessitates the researcher to suspend any

preconceived assumptions they may hold regarding the experience or phenomena

(Ho, 2022).
36
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Sources of Data

Most of the data will be collected by conducting numerous in-depth face-to-

face interviews with people who have used telemedicine during the COVID-19

pandemic at the age of 18 years old and above and who live in Biñan to Sta. Rosa

City Laguna. Creswell (2007) suggested that for qualitative studies, researchers

interview 5 to 25 people who have all encountered the phenomenon. In order to

provide in-depth background and meaningful answers to the research questions,

the researchers consulted and cited books, journals, publications, and articles

through the process of reviewing related literature.

Participants of the Study

The participants of this study were composed of ten adults, aged 18 years old

and above from Biñan to Sta. Rosa, Laguna who used telemedicine during the

COVID-19 pandemic that is sourced via online screening through social media

applications and the web. According to Cresswell (2007), for a qualitative study five

(5) to twenty-five (25) participants are optimal. In accordance, the total number of

participants expected to participate in the study will be ten (10) in order to reach

data saturation. From this population, the sample that would be involved in the

study should be patients or clients who have had an experience with the use of

telemedicine for medical consultation during the COVID-19 pandemic.


37
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

In selecting the participants for the study, the researchers were guided by

two sampling techniques namely: Purposive Sampling and Snowball Sampling.

Purposive Sampling refers to a collection of non-probability sampling procedures

where participants are chosen because they possess criteria that the study needs,

while Snowball Sampling facilitates participant recruitment through referrals. These

are the methods of selection to find participants who can offer comprehensive and

in-depth information about the phenomena being studied. In order to identify the

study population, the researchers included inclusion criteria in which the

participants should be 18-22 years old, male/female, experienced or have had an

experience with the use of telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic, in Biñan or

Sta. Rosa, Laguna.

Instrumentation and Validation

The researchers used semi-structured one-on-one interviews which may be

conducted online or in person. The online interview will be considered through a

Google Meeting. The researchers used open-ended self-made interview guide

questions for the participants which are relevant to complement the primary source

of the data and to explore experiences, views, and opinions on specific areas in the

study. As a method for collecting information relevant to the study. This was used

because interviews offer an in-depth and personal view of the experience of the

patients than other methods.


38
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Data-Gathering Procedure

The research instrument was validated, and the approved questionnaires

would be the primary tool for data gathering for the questions contained in the

inquiry that would be asked of the participants of the research. The selected

participants will be given a full discourse about the study and will be oriented about

the premise of the research, they will also be asked to sign an informed consent

about the study and set their chosen schedule for the interview. Moreover, the

researchers would also provide a brief yet concise background for the research to

fully inform the participants about the study both verbally and in writing/text.

The use of guide questions was also utilized during the interview. To answer

the first statement of the problem of the study the researchers prepared the

following questions such as: Based on your experience, what are your views on

telemedicine? Why did you choose this telemedicine service among others? Can you

tell me about your experience with telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic?,

Based on your experience, what are the struggles you encountered during the

consultation?, During your consultation, what would you consider the advantages of

telemedicine?

Data Analysis
39
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The researchers used Colaizzi’s Method of Data Analysis. In the initial phase of

familiarization, the researchers immersed themselves in the data by repeatedly

reading the participants’ verbatim transcripts to develop a sense of familiarity.

Subsequently, the focus shifted to Identifying Significant Statements, where the

researchers pinpointed statements directly relevant to the investigated

phenomenon. During the stage of Formulating Meanings, careful consideration of

these significant statements led to the identification of meanings associated with

the phenomenon, accompanied by the crucial step of ‘bracketing’ to suspend any

preconceived notions and align closely with the participants’ experiences. It’s

important to note that, according to Colaizzi, achieving complete bracketing is

acknowledged as an unattainable goal.

Moving on to Clustering Themes, the researchers grouped the identified

meanings into common themes across all accounts, maintaining the application of

bracketing to prevent potential bias. This was followed by Developing an Exhaustive

Description, where all themes generated in the clustering phase were incorporated

into a comprehensive portrayal of the phenomenon. The next step, Fundamental

Structure, involved condensing the exhaustive description into a concise, dense

statement encapsulating the essential aspects of the phenomenon’s structure.

The final stage, Seeking Verification of the Fundamental Structure, entailed

presenting the fundamental structure statements to all participants to confirm if it


40
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

accurately reflected their experiences, aiming for congruence with their lived

reality. Importantly, the researchers adjusted earlier analysis steps based on the

feedback received from participants during this verification process.

Familiarization

Seeking
Identifying
Verification of the
Significant
Fundamental
Statements
Structure

Producing the
Formulating
Fundamental
Meanings
Structure

Developing
Exhaustive Clustering Themes
Description

Figure 3. Colaizzi’s Method of Data Analysis

Ethical Consideration
41
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Throughout the study, the researchers conscientiously adhered to ethical

considerations, with a particular focus on safeguarding the confidentiality of the

participants. Prior to the interviews, participants were sought for permission to

partake in the study, and their informed consent was obtained. Additionally, oral

consent was verbally secured from each participant before commencing the

interview, serving as tangible proof of their voluntary involvement in the research.

To uphold participant anonymity, every individual involved was assured that

their names would not be disclosed in the study's findings. The researchers

prioritized the well-being of the research participants, ensuring that they were not

exposed to any harm during the interview process. Throughout the interviews, the

dignity of the research participants was upheld, underscoring the researchers'

commitment to ethical conduct. Consequently, the confidentiality of the data

collected from the participants during the interviews was meticulously safeguarded.
42
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

CHAPTER 4

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

This chapter presents how the researchers completed the process of

bracketing, horizontalization, theme clustering, writing the overall essence, and

verification of the lived experiences of the participants who had used telemedicine

during the COVID-19 Pandemic.

Theme clustering was utilized after horizontalization by analyzing, outlining,

and grouping significant statements into meaningful units to sub-themes. The

researchers were able to derive four themes that contribute to answering the

questions of the study namely: What are the experiences of patients in using

telemedicine during the Covid-19 pandemic?; How do these experiences influence

the perspective of patients regarding telemedicine based on its perceived

challenges?; How does these experiences influence the perspective of patients

regarding telemedicine based on its perceived benefits?


43
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The following tables presented the groupings of clustered themes and sub-

themes based on the significant statements and their relative ideas.

I. The Experiences of Patients in Using Telemedicine during the Covid-19

Pandemic

Theme 1: Perception on Telemedicine

Sub-themes: Positive Experience, Usefulness in Consultation

SUB-THEMES THEME

Positive Experience Perception on Telemedicine

Useful for Consultation

Table 1. Perception of Telemedicine

The first overarching theme is the Perception of Telemedicine, which includes

the subthemes of Positive Experience and Useful for Consultation. Most of the

participants who had utilized telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic had
44
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

positive perceptions regarding telemedicine. By sharing their feedback, they

conveyed the efficiency with which their healthcare providers, utilizing telemedicine,

promptly and effortlessly attended to their health-related issues. They received

comprehensive information that facilitated clear and effective communication

between patients and doctors, contributing to the patient's recovery from the

disease and fostering overall well-being.

Sub-theme 1.1: Positive Experience

Participant 1 verbalized, “My views regarding Telemedicine have been

positive experience.”

Moreover, Participant 8 elaborated on how Telemedicine proves highly

advantageous as it obviates the necessity for physical presence outside the

residence, offering a streamlined and user-friendly interface. Through a

straightforward process involving minimal interactions, users can efficiently respond

to inquiries posed by their healthcare providers regarding their specific medical

concerns.

This technological modality thereby optimizes healthcare accessibility while

ensuring convenience and ease of use, contributing to an enhanced patient

experience, “Napakalaking tulong sakin ng telemedicine kase nga di na ko

kailangan lumabas pa ng bahay tapos napakadali nya lang gamitin, click click ka
45
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

lang and then, sagutan mo lang yung mga tanong sayo ng doctor mo kung ano

yung masakit sayo.”

Furthermore, Participant 10 also explicates that Telemedicine stands out as a

time-saving, exhibiting exceptional utility and user-friendliness. This modality,

characterized by its efficiency, not only mitigates the temporal constraints

associated with traditional healthcare approaches but also offers a seamless and

accessible platform for medical interactions. The streamlined nature of

telemedicine not only expedites the healthcare process but also contributes to a

more convenient and user-centric experience, “Mas nakaka save ako ng time, super

helpful at napakadali nya lang gamitin.”

Our study revealed highly positive participant experiences with Telemedicine,

particularly in terms of its effectiveness in knowledge acquisition. These favorable

outcomes resonate with findings from other studies, including Dario et al. (2016),

where participants expressed high satisfaction with telemedicine services. Patients

in that study reported extreme contentment with the management of their health

concerns, highlighting the success of telemedicine consultations. This suggests that

telemedicine was perceived as a valuable tool enhancing current healthcare and

enabling better monitoring of health conditions by healthcare providers.

Consistent positive results were also observed in studies conducted by

Wenshuo et al. (2021) and Park et al. (2021). Despite varying patient attitudes
46
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

toward telemedicine, an overall positive outlook prevailed, emphasizing its

convenience, interactivity, and reliability.

Sub-theme 1.2: Useful for Consultation

Elaborating on its usefulness in consultation, the participants, through their

feedback, conveyed the swift and effortless manner in which their healthcare

provider attended to their health concerns via telemedicine. They received

comprehensive information, fostering clear communication between patients and

doctors. This, in turn, contributed to the patient's recovery from the disease

process and played a role in promoting overall well-being.

Participant 5 elaborated on how Telemedicine removes the need to go the

hospital because of the protocols during the COVID-19 pandemic. “Para sakin yun

pandemic ano yun telemedicine malaki tulong talaga sya para sakin especially

madami protocols na bawal lumabas sa mga establishment so ayun ang

telemedicine during pandemic is helpful at accessible sa lahat.”

Similarly, Patient 9 also verbalized how telemedicine proved to be beneficial

by offering avenues for doctor-patient interaction, resulting in time and resource

savings for regular consultations. “Telemedicine has been very helpful in providing
47
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

a platform for doctor-patient interaction, saving time and resources to conduct

regular consultations, especially during peak Covid-19 pandemic.” Which shares the

same sentiment as Participant 10, ““Malaking tulong sya actually nun pandemic lalo

na bawal lumabas kase mataas yun cases ng covid. Gamit na gamit sya nun

pandemic dahil no choice tayo kundi magpa online consultation.”

This outcome finds support in various studies. Aashima et al. (2021) reported

similarly satisfactory results in addressing patients' concerns and questions through

telemedicine. Zhu et al. (2020) highlighted that most doctors effectively addressed

patients' concerns, with patients noting effective communication with providers and

the added benefits of avoiding COVID-19 exposure. Moreover, Tenforde et al.

(2020) identified telemedicine as well-suited for follow-up consultations, providing

synchronous or asynchronous communication options. This versatility contributes to

clearer discourse between patients and providers regarding their health concerns.

Collectively, during the COVID-19 pandemic, telemedicine emerges as a viable and

positive tool for health consultations with healthcare professionals.

Theme 2: Choosing Telemedicine Services Among Others

Sub-themes: Wellbeing, Conveniennce, Accessibility

SUB-THEMES THEME

Wellbeing Choosing Telemedicine Service


48
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Among Others

Convenience

Accessibility

Table 2. Choosing Telemedicine Service Among Others

The second overarching theme is choosing telemedicine service among

others, which includes the subthemes of safety, convenience, and accessibility. The

second main theme revolves around the preference for telemedicine services over

other options, highlighting subthemes of safety, convenience, and accessibility.

Wellbeing is a crucial consideration, especially during the ongoing pandemic, as

telemedicine allows individuals to receive healthcare without exposing themselves

to potential risks associated with in-person visits. Convenience plays a pivotal role,

offering users the flexibility to engage in medical consultations from the comfort of

their homes, eliminating the need for travel and waiting times. Additionally,

accessibility ensures that individuals, regardless of location or mobility constraints,

can easily connect with healthcare providers, promoting inclusivity in healthcare

delivery.

Sub-theme 2.1: Wellbeing


49
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The spread of COVID-19 infection has a direct impact on wellbeing,

intertwining with the theme of choosing telemedicine services. As the virus spreads,

individuals face heightened health risks when venturing into crowded places,

including healthcare facilities. The fear of exposure to the virus during in-person

medical visits becomes a significant concern, influencing the decision to opt for

telemedicine. This choice aligns with the overarching theme of prioritizing safety.

By utilizing telemedicine services, individuals can protect their wellbeing by

minimizing the risk of infection while still accessing necessary healthcare resources.

This connection underscores the interplay between the spread of COVID-19 and the

considerations that drive the adoption of telemedicine for the preservation of

individual well-being.

Participant 1 elaborated that out of fear of contracting COVID-19, she opted

to use Telemedicine for her wellbeing. “I had like a sting from an “alupihan” or a

centipede. So, it was really an onset pain and I really felt like I needed to go to an

emergency hospital but I chose not to because like I said, out of fear of the COVID-

19 pandemic, so I stayed at home.”

Participant 2 verbalized that using telemedicine prevents the spread of the

virus from patient to patient. “Para sakin yun advantages nya is during pandemic is

to prevent yun pag spread ng virus sa patient

tapos kung malayo yun patient and yun doctor makakapg consult padin”
50
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Participant 6 relatively have the same sentiments, “...And then yun naman

talaga ang purpose ng telemedicine during that time is not to spread yung covid

19.”

The Philippine government implemented the "enhanced community

quarantine" (ECQ), imposing restrictions on travel and community activities. Large

gatherings, including hospital services, were prohibited to curb the spread of

COVID-19 (Amit et al., 2021). In response, the Department of Health (DOH)

introduced telemedicine as an alternative to face-to-face consultations, aiming to

alleviate patient saturation in hospitals.

Former Health Secretary Francisco T. Duque III highlighted the DOH's

emphasis on technology, enabling the public to connect with medical professionals

for advice without leaving their homes. This initiative, available even to healthcare

workers, aimed to reduce hospital congestion and mitigate the virus's spread,

aligning with quarantine restrictions (DOH, 2020; CDC, 2022).

Many patients expressed apprehension about visiting hospitals due to the

fear of contracting the disease. Concerns for safety prompted them to choose

telemedicine to avoid potential exposure and protect their families. Additionally,

patients worried about potential misdiagnosis in hospitals sensitive to respiratory

illness symptoms, triggering COVID-19 surveillance protocols. Using telemedicine


51
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

provided a way for patients to seek professional opinions, gain insights into their

health concerns, and mitigate the risk of COVID-19 transmission.

Sub-theme 2.2: Convenience

This sub-theme delves into the convenience reported by patients through

their utilization of telemedicine. According to the study by Walczak et al. (2022),

telemedicine leverages the internet and related technologies, amalgamating

affordability, easy access to health information, and communication, contributing to

the overall convenience experienced by patients. Patient transcripts consistently

highlighted the efficiency and comfort related to travel in most interviews. They

emphasized the opportunity to rest and make the most of time saved by eliminating

the need for travel in their telemedicine consultations. Additionally, patients noted

substantial savings in travel costs as a further advantage of this convenient

healthcare approach.

The following participants share the same sentiments regarding the

convenience of telemedicine. Participant 2 verbalized, “I would say na it’s more

convenient nung ginamit ko siya that time since I didn’t have to leave the house

and go to a hospital.”, moreover Participant 3 mentioned that, ““For me, yun

telemedicine is ano malaking tulong sya para dun sa mga patients during

pandemic.”
52
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Participant 4 mentioned that, ““Maganda sya kase hindi kana ah.. tatawag ka

nalang hindi kana lalabas ng bahay at bawal din naman lumabas nun mga araw na

iyon at pahirapan makapunta sa hospital.” While Participant 5, “For me

napakaconvenient nya since hindi mo na kailangan lumabas ng bahay and di mo na

din kailangan pumila ng napakahaba, tapos di mo na din kailangan gumastos ng

pamasahe papuntang hospital. Tapos napaka accessible niya pa since kailangan mo

lang is cellphone and internet para makapag appointment sa doctor mo and kahit

nasan ka man pwedemong makausap yung doctor mo and consult about your

health.”

Participants 4 and 5 emphasized the convenience of telemedicine by

highlighting the fact that there is no need to leave the house. This observation

underscores the ease with which individuals can access healthcare services from

the comfort of their own homes, eliminating the necessity for physical travel to a

medical facility. By not having to leave the house, participants like Participant 4 can

enjoy the added convenience of receiving medical attention without the associated

challenges of commuting, such as travel time, transportation costs, and potential

exposure to external factors. This aspect of telemedicine aligns with the broader

theme of convenience, emphasizing its role in simplifying and improving the overall

healthcare experience for participants.


53
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

These findings were supported by the study of Sardar (2022) aligned with

our findings, indicating that telemedicine consultations eliminate inconvenient

waiting times in clinics and the time spent traveling to medical facilities. This

improvement in efficiency not only enhances the quality of life for patients but also

reduces the necessity for travel, echoing the overarching sentiment that

"telemedicine saves time, money, and energy" as highlighted in Dam et al.'s

(2022). Notably, participants expressed a preference for the option of staying at

home in their familiar setting.

Furthermore, participants emphasized the positive impact of not having to

travel, particularly for those who did not reside near the nearest health service. The

saved time afforded them the opportunity to engage in other activities. This time

efficiency aspect was consistently noted by several participants, echoing the

sentiments shared in Jitender et al. (2022) study. In that study, patients found

telemedicine not only helpful for time savings but also for protecting them from

infections, providing basic primary care close to home during the pandemic. These

consistent findings underscore the broader theme of time efficiency as a significant

benefit of telemedicine, aligning with various research perspectives.

Sub-theme 2.3: Accessibility

This theme elucidated clients' seamless utilization of telemedicine without

encountering challenges. As described by DeFranco and Metro (2022), telemedicine


54
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

is the provision of medical care over the internet, synonymous with "healing at a

distance." Accordingly, a majority of the interviewed patients confirmed that with

the widespread availability of technology, they now have the convenience of

accessing healthcare from the comfort of their homes. This, in turn, facilitates easy

access to medical consultations. The use of telemedicine provides patients with

advantages such as convenient and hassle-free consultations.

Participant 7 expressed that telemedicine is easy to access, “Madali lang po

maaccess ang telemedicine”

Participant 8 highlighted the convenience of telemedicine, emphasizing that

one no longer needs to leave the house, endure long queues, or incur travel

expenses to reach the hospital. “For me napakaconvenient nya since hindi mo na

kailangan lumabas ng bahay and di mo na din kailangan pumila ng napakahaba,

tapos di mo na din kailangan gumastos ng pamasahe papuntang hospital. Tapos

napaka accessible niya pa since kailangan mo lang is cellphone and internet para

makapag appointment sa doctor mo and kahit nasan ka man pwedemong

makausap yung doctor mo and consult about your health.”

The accessibility of telemedicine was emphasized by Participant 8, who noted

that all that's required is a cellphone and internet connection to schedule

appointments and consult with a doctor from anywhere., “Since madali syang
55
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

gamitin and super accessible sila kase 24/7, pwede kang magconsult sa kanila and

then pwede ka din magpadeliver ng mga medicines.”

Additionally, Participant 8 explained that telemedicine is user-friendly and

highly accessible, available 24/7 for consultations and even offering the

convenience of medicine delivery. Participant 10 echoed the sentiment, noting that

telemedicine eliminates the need for travel, allowing individuals to wait for their

doctor in the comfort of their homes through a Zoom link. “Hindi mo na need mag

travel ng ilang minutes or hours para lang makapunta ka ng hospital unlike pag

nasa bahay ka chill kalang hihintayin mo nalang yun doctor mo pumasok sa zoom

link na binigay sayo.”

Participant 9 shared their experience, describing the straightforward process

of scheduling consultations through telemedicine. Although setting up a third-party

software was required, the overall procedure, including confirmation and payment

validation, took only a few minutes., “I only did schedule for a consultation twice at

the time. Creating an account and filling in details such as

payment method were fairly straightforward. Scheduling for a consultation and all

the following bits and pieces only took a matter of a few minutes. though I needed

to set up a third-party software to use as a platform for the on-call consultation.

Schedule confirmation and payment validation through the doctor-secretary were

also necessary prior to the doctor-patient meet.“


56
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Furthermore, Participant 8 stressed the accessibility of telemedicine anytime

and anywhere, emphasizing its advantages in terms of convenience and safety. “For

me, yung advantage ng telemedicine talaga is yung convenience and safety

since ...tapos accessible pa sya anytime and anywhere you are.”

Similarly, Participant 10 highlighted the universal accessibility of telemedicine

across various gadgets, as long as there is a Wi-Fi connection. “...very accesible sya

sa lahat ng gadgets basta may wifi ka.”

These collective accounts highlight the consensus among participants

regarding the user-friendly nature and extensive accessibility associated with

telemedicine. This echo similar findings in the study of Ng and Park (2021), which

emphasized the immediate availability of doctors through digital means and the

broader access to medical services facilitated by technological advancements,

including the use of various applications and social media in e-health strategies

during the pandemic.

In our study, participants emphasized the role of telemedicine in providing

accessibility during follow-up consultations, allowing for the addressal of patients'

inquiries at different stages. The establishment of virtual connections through

telemedicine notably enhanced the accessibility of the follow-up process,

particularly when patients faced medical situations prompting questions about their
57
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

health. This heightened accessibility proved critical during the pandemic, enabling

doctors to monitor patients and conduct follow-ups effectively.

The findings of Tapodoc and Lasala's (2022) study further support the notion

that telemedicine services were indispensable during the pandemic, especially for

doctors tracking patients and conducting follow-ups. Patients' heightened

confidence in telemedicine for follow-ups stemmed from the ease of contacting

doctors and receiving prompt responses. This consistent reinforcement underscores

the substantial accessibility benefits of telemedicine, aligning seamlessly with our

study's emphasis on clients' positive perceptions of the ease of access to

consultations and follow-up services amid the pandemic.

II. Challenges Experienced by the Patient during the Consultation

Theme 3: Problems Encountered during the Consultation

Sub-themes: Limitations on Physical Examinations or Procedures, Lack of Internet

Connection during the Consultation, and Delayed Response from the Healthcare

Provider,

SUB-THEMES THEME
58
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Limitations on Physical Examinations Problems Encountered during the

or Procedures Consultation

Lack of Internet Connection during

the Consultation

Delayed Response from the

Healthcare Provider

Table 3. Problems Encountered during the Consultation

The third overarching theme is the struggles encountered during the

consultation, which include the subthemes of Limitations on Physical Examinations

or Procedures, Lack of Internet Connection during the Consultation, and Delayed

Responses from the Healthcare Provider,

A notable number of interviewed patients highlighted a key limitation of

telemedicine: the inadequacy of a comprehensive physical assessment, which holds

significant importance in the medical diagnosis process. The absence of a physical

examination poses a challenge to the fundamental principle of patient care, even in

an online platform.

Sub-theme 3.1: Limitations on Physical Examinations or Procedures


59
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Participants 2, 5, and 8 voiced shared concerns about the limitations of

physical examinations and procedures in the context of telemedicine.

Participant 2 elucidated the challenges in providing access for the doctor to

assess their sibling effectively, particularly mentioning activities like catching a ball

that the doctor would typically perform. However, due to telemedicine constraints,

the family had to take on this role, creating a situation where the doctor couldn't

fully assess the participant's sibling remotely. The participant expressed, “Actually

yun nga yun need maacess ng neuro yun kapatid ko actually mahirap sya kase yun

mga ano yun mga activities na dapat yun doctor yun nagawa is kame yun nag-

implement sa kapatid ko like yun nag catch ng ball kase yun doctor dapat nagawa

ng mga ganon kase nga para maaccess nga ng maayos so ayun nga kami yun nag

implement so parang hindi maaccess ng doctor yun lagay ng kapatid ko.”

Participant 5 highlighted the absence of a physical assessment during their

telemedicine interaction, underscoring that only their temperature was inquired

about. The participant emphasized the challenge of the healthcare provider not

being able to conduct a more comprehensive examination remotely, stating,

"Tapos, temperature lang tinanong niya sakin nung time na ‘yun kasi obviously ‘di

naman nila ko ma-check."

Furthermore, Participant 8 pointed out the struggle with limited physical

assessment in online consultations, particularly in explaining the extent of pain or


60
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

discomfort. They emphasized the disparity between online and in-person

consultations, where healthcare professionals can directly observe and thoroughly

examine the body, allowing for a more comprehensive assessment. The participant

stated, “Siguro yung struggle lang sa online consultation is yung pag eexplain ng

kung anong masakit sayo, kung gaano kasakit di ba kasi inaano nila yung pain

level, kunware sa sakit ng ipin, tatanungin ka nila unlike pag sa personal makikita

nila through your actions and machecheck up talaga ng masinsinan yung katawan

mo.”

Moreover, Participant 10 echoed concerns about limited physical and

laboratory assessments in telemedicine, citing difficulties in conducting these

assessments at home. The participant stressed the challenge of managing

laboratory tests and assessments remotely, emphasizing the importance of

immediate access to healthcare professionals, especially in urgent situations. They

stated, “Siguro yun laboratories and assessment kase nga nasa bahay lang paano

magagawa yun.”

In summary, these participants collectively point to the challenges posed by

the limitations of physical assessments and procedures in telemedicine, including

difficulties in accessing necessary activities, conducting comprehensive

examinations, and managing laboratory assessments remotely.


61
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

This sentiment is echoed in the research article by Lahat and Shatz (2021),

where patients pointed out the drawbacks of telecare, with the most common

concern being the absence of physical examination. Therefore, patients articulated

concerns about the limitations and constraints associated with physical procedures

when conducted through telemedicine. While telemedicine facilitates remote

consultations, patients recognize challenges related to certain physical aspects of

healthcare interactions, procedures, or examinations that are traditionally

conducted in a face-to-face setting.

Sub-theme 3.2: Lack of Internet Connection during the Consultation

Enumerating the drawbacks of telemedicine, the lack of internet connectivity

emerges as a significant concern. Dow-Fleisner et al. (2022) emphasized that

virtual connections to facilitate healthcare necessitate sufficient broadband access,

a resource that is often constrained or unavailable.

Participants shared various challenges related to internet connectivity during

telemedicine consultations. Participant 3 highlighted instances where healthcare

providers were difficult to contact, with unanswered calls or choppy connections

that hindered effective communication. They mentioned, "Minsan hindi sila ma-

contact, walang sumasagot sa phone nila or minsan naman choppy, hindi mo sila

maintindihan, hindi ka nila maintindihan, ganun connection lang."


62
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Participant 4 acknowledged that the quality of telemedicine interactions

depends on the individual's signal strength. They stated, "Siguro depende nalang sa

signal mo, pero overall okay naman."

Similarly, Participant 6 attributed the success of telemedicine to internet

quality, stating, "Siguro sa internet, diba nga thru online."

Participant 7 identified slow internet as the primary problem, leading to

potential lags or call disruptions during consultations. They noted, "Ang number 1

problem po is internet po, since mabagal yung internet may possibility po na mag-

lag yung call or mamatay yung call during consultation po."

Participant 9 emphasized the impact of unstable internet on audio quality

during video calls, making it challenging to understand the doctor's instructions.

They expressed, "It was certainly the noise in the audio during the video call that

made the communication process difficult. I was having a hard time understanding

my doctor's instructions and other explanations regarding my case because of her

broken audio... most likely caused by her unstable internet connection."

These accounts collectively underscore the critical role of internet stability in

ensuring effective communication and successful telemedicine consultations.

Sub-theme 3.3: Delayed Response from the Healthcare Provider


63
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Participants highlighted instances of delayed response from healthcare

providers during telemedicine consultations.

Participant 3 succinctly expressed the impact of a lack of signal on

telemedicine, stating, "Telemedicine is not possible without a signal." This

underscores the essential role of a stable signal in facilitating effective

communication.

Participant 2 elaborated on their experience, noting a delayed response from

the healthcare provider. They shared, "Nung time na pala ‘yun na nagco-

communicate ako sa doctor, medyo matagal lang talaga siya mag-reply. I’m not

sure kung bakit, siguro marami din siyang patients hina-handle? I think it would be

best na meron siyang mga nurses or tumutulong sa kanya para mag-entertain sa

mga patients. Medyo may delayed time lang talaga. Well, in my case anyways."

This account emphasizes the need for healthcare providers to manage their

workload efficiently, possibly with the assistance of support staff, to address delays

in responding to patients.

These experiences collectively highlight the challenges associated with

delayed responses during telemedicine consultations and underscore the

importance of addressing such issues for optimal patient care.

The findings in our study align with those of Turchioe (2022), highlighting

recurring delays in responses from healthcare providers in telemedicine


64
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

consultations. Technical challenges, particularly the essential requirement of a

reliable internet connection, were emphasized by participants for seamless

interactions. Signal issues, contacting difficulties, and choppy connections were

identified as contributors to delays. Participants also acknowledged the impact of

high patient loads on healthcare providers, suggesting the need for additional

support staff. Technical competence issues, including audio quality problems and

broken connections, were noted as further hindrances to effective communication.

Addressing these challenges is imperative for enhancing telemedicine efficiency and

ensuring a positive experience for both providers and patients.

III. Benefit of Telemedicine during the Covid-19 Pandemic

Theme 4: Advantages of Telemedicine during Consultation

Sub-themes: Safety, Cost-Effective, Effective Communication, and Cessation of

Travel Time

SUB-THEMES THEME

Safety Advantages of Telemedicine during

Consultation
Cost Effective

Effective Communication

Cessation of Travel Time


65
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Table 4. Advantages of Telemedicine during Consultation

The fourth overarching theme is the advantages of telemedicine during the

consultation, which include the subthemes of Safety, Cost-Effective, Effective

Communication, and Cessation of Travel Time.

Sub-theme 4.1: Safety

This sub-theme centrally addressed the concept of COVID-19 infection,

highlighting telemedicine's role in prioritizing security. Clients emphasized their

focus on safety during the pandemic, opting for telemedicine as reflected in their

transcripts. Furthermore, utilizing telemedicine helps prevent the spread of

infections, contributing to a reduction in the number of cases due to this reason,

one of the advantages of telemedicine during the Covid-19 pandemic is for safety.

Participant 1 emphasized the safety of online consultations compared to

physically visiting hospitals and the associated risk of contracting COVID-19. They

articulated, "So, I chose the online platform of seeking healthcare—online rather

than going physically to a hospital or a clinic as an outpatient because of fear of

contracting the COVID-19 virus."

Similarly, Participant 2 chose telemedicine during the peak of the pandemic,

expressing concerns about the high risk of contracting COVID-19 in hospitals. They

stated, "I chose telemedicine service at the time mainly because it was during peak
66
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Covid-19 pandemic, as visiting hospitals were very risky and unsafe... to avoid

physical contact essentially, that's why."

Participants 1 and 2 both emphasized the safety aspect of telemedicine as a

primary reason for choosing online consultations over physically visiting hospitals

during the COVID-19 pandemic. Participant 1 expressed a clear fear of contracting

the virus, highlighting the perceived safety of seeking healthcare through

telemedicine from the comfort of their home. This aligns with the general sentiment

that telemedicine helps reduce exposure to infectious diseases by eliminating the

need for in-person visits to healthcare facilities.

Similarly, Participant 2's decision to opt for telemedicine during the peak of

the pandemic was driven by concerns about the high risk and perceived unsafety of

hospitals at that time. They specifically mentioned the avoidance of physical contact

as a crucial factor in choosing telemedicine, reinforcing the idea that telehealth

services provide a safer alternative to traditional in-person healthcare visits.

The perspectives shared by Participants 1 and 2, emphasizing the safety

advantages of telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic, align with the findings

of Baudier et al. (2021). According to Baudier et al., teleconsultation is considered a

viable tool by medical teams to lower contact and infection rates. The participants'

choice of telemedicine over in-person visits to hospitals resonates with the medical
67
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

community's acknowledgment of telehealth as an effective strategy to sustain

patient care while minimizing the risk of infections.

As Participants 1 and 2 expressed concerns about the high risk and fear of

contracting COVID-19 in hospitals, their decisions to opt for telemedicine reflect a

broader trend observed in healthcare. The implementation of telemedicine, as

highlighted by Baudier et al., becomes a preferred alternative to alleviate patients'

fears, reduce infection rates, and ensure the continuity of patient care. The

alignment between participants' choices and medical team considerations reinforces

the role of telemedicine as a valuable tool for promoting safety, especially in the

context of infectious disease control during a health crisis.

Sub-theme 4.2: Cost Effective

Participant 1 emphasized the convenience of telemedicine, highlighting its

time-saving and cost-effective nature. In expressing their perspective, they stated,

"At the same time, I wanted to save on transportation fees and my time was also

limited since I’m also a nursing student at St. Michael’s." This aligns with the

findings of the study conducted by Walczak and colleagues (2022), which

underscored the role of telemedicine in combining affordability with easy access to

health information and communication through internet-based technologies. The

study emphasized how patients, in various interviews, consistently highlighted the

advantages of telemedicine in terms of travel efficiency and comfort. Many


68
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

participants expressed that they could use the time saved from eliminating travel

for rest, and they appreciated the cost savings associated with not having to incur

transportation expenses for in-person consultations. Thus, the insights from both

Participant 1 and the study by Walczak et al. collectively reinforce the notion that

telemedicine contributes to enhanced convenience, financial savings, and

streamlined access to healthcare information.

Sub-theme 4.3: Effective Communication

Telemedicine emerges as a pivotal solution for ensuring ease of

communication between patients and healthcare providers during the COVID-19

pandemic. Virtual consultations, enabled by telemedicine platforms, facilitate

ongoing communication without necessitating in-person visits, thereby minimizing

the risk of viral transmission.

Participant 3 expressed the convenience of telemedicine, emphasizing its role

in easier communication during the pandemic. In their statement, "Mas pinili ko sya

minsan ay nun pandemic kase syempre hindi ako makakalabas ng bahay pupunta

sa psychiatrist so thru phone call ko nalang sya ginagawa".

Ali et al. (2022) emphasizes the positive impact of effective communication

on health outcomes, particularly the crucial role of physician communication


69
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

behaviors. This resonates with the paradigm shift enabled by telemedicine during

the COVID-19 pandemic, highlighting its pivotal role in ensuring ease of

communication between patients and healthcare providers. Telemedicine serves as

a transformative solution, offering virtual consultations that overcome physical

distance barriers and minimize the risk of viral transmission. Secure messaging

systems and video calls enhance real-time communication, providing patients a

safe platform to discuss symptoms and seek medical advice.

The convenience and accessibility of telemedicine contribute to

comprehensive healthcare delivery, including remote monitoring, prescription

management, and health education. Timely updates and alerts further streamline

communication, keeping patients informed about appointments and medications.

Participant 3's preference for telemedicine in mental health consultations

reflects the broader sentiment seen in Ali et al.'s research. It highlights

telemedicine's accessibility and ease of communication, particularly crucial in

situations limiting physical mobility, such as the pandemic. In essence, telemedicine

acts as a transformative and effective means of communication, ensuring

individuals access necessary healthcare services while prioritizing safety.

Sub-theme 4.4: Cessation of Travel Time

The patient transcripts consistently highlighted the significance of travel

efficiency and comfort during telemedicine consultations. Participants emphasized


70
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

the relief derived from the time saved by eliminating the need for travel, allowing

them to rest and prioritize their well-being. Additionally, the convenience of

telemedicine not only provided a respite from travel-related stress but also resulted

in tangible cost savings associated with commuting to healthcare appointments.

Participant 6 emphasized the absence of travel requirements in telemedicine,

stating, "Kasi...hindi mo na kailangan mag travel hindi mo na kailangan pumila kasi

diba minsan pag nagpapacheck pa tayo sa hospital kailangan nating pumila unlike

kasi sa teleconsult or elemedicine."

Similarly, Participant 2 highlighted the advantage of not needing to go

outside for a consultation, expressing, "The way I see it, ‘yung advantage lang

talaga is ‘yung hindi mo na kailangan lumabas kasi online lang talaga."

Participant 3 echoed this sentiment, emphasizing the convenience of not

having to go to the clinic for a consultation, stating, "Yun advantages nya lang ay

yun hindi muna need pumunta sa clinic para magpaconsult sa doctor mo and ayun

easy access sya yun lang."

Likewise, Participant 4 pointed out the convenience of not having to go to the

hospital for a check-up, stating, "Convenient tapos ahm hindi kana mahihirap

pumumta sa hospital para magpacheck up tungkol sa nararamdaman mo."


71
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

The statements made by participants regarding the elimination of travel in

telemedicine consultations are supported by the study of Rodler et al. (2023) This

study aligns with the participants' perspectives, emphasizing that telemedicine

consultations remove inconvenient waiting times in clinics and eliminates the need

to spend time traveling to medical facilities. Additionally, the findings highlight that

telemedicine contributes to improving the quality of life for patients while reducing

the necessity for travel. It emphasizes that telemedicine not only saves time,

money, and energy but also brings attention to the preference of staying at home

in their own setting. These findings collectively underscore the convenience and

efficiency associated with telemedicine, reinforcing the participants' viewpoints on

the advantages of not needing to travel for healthcare consultations.


72
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

CHAPTER 5

SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS

This chapter presented the summary of findings, conclusions, and

recommendations of the study to further enhance the concepts and the facts

discussed in the preceding chapters as provided by the results of the analysis of

data.

Summary

The study focused on patients' experiences on utilizing telemedicine during

the COVID-19 epidemic, the difficulties they encountered during their consultations,

and how telemedicine aid in addressing their health concerns. Since the study's

outcome delved into the experiences of patients who used telemedicine during the

COVID-19 pandemic, the researcher opted for a phenomenological approach. Ten

(10) adults from Biñan to Sta. Rosa, Laguna, aged 18 and above, who accessed

telemedicine through online screening via social media applications and the web

during the COVID-19 pandemic was included in the study. Individual interviews in

person interview, were employed for the study. Recurring themes in the interview

data were identified, analyzed, and interpreted using thematic analysis.


73
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Conclusions

These conclusions encompass key themes drawn from the participants'

experiences and perceptions related to telemedicine, shedding light on both its

limitations and advantages in the context of healthcare delivery:

1. The study illuminates the positive experiences of patients utilizing

telemedicine during the COVID-19 pandemic. Participants express a

favorable perception of telemedicine, citing its accessibility, convenience, and

contribution to their overall well-being. The decision to choose telemedicine

is rooted in its utility and positive impact on the healthcare consultation

process, providing insights into the transformative role of telemedicine in

enhancing patient experiences.

2. Alongside the positive experiences, participants share challenges

encountered during telemedicine consultations. Notable issues include

limitations on physical examinations or procedures, reflecting the constraints

of remote healthcare assessments. Challenges related to the lack of internet

connection and delayed responses from healthcare providers are also

identified. These challenges underscore the existing limitations of


74
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

telemedicine, contributing valuable insights into areas that may require

improvement.

3. Despite the challenges, the study highlights significant benefits associated

with telemedicine in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic. These

advantages encompass enhanced safety measures, cost-effectiveness,

effective communication channels between patients and healthcare providers,

and the elimination of travel time. The identification of these benefits

positions telemedicine as a promising avenue for improving healthcare

delivery, particularly in times of crisis, emphasizing its potential to address

key healthcare concerns and enhance overall patient experiences.

Recommendations

Given the results and conclusions, the following are suggested:

1. The researchers propose that this study could assist the National Telehealth

Center in enhancing their service delivery for quality healthcare, particularly

through video conferencing and other platforms. This improvement may

involve the development of innovative solutions to address challenges

identified in this study. For instance, the creation of user-friendly software

could help bridge technological gaps and enable telemedicine consultations

without relying on paid internet connections.


75
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

2. The researchers suggest using this study as a foundation for enhancing

telemedicine services in the Philippines. This could involve allocating a

budget to improve laws, policies, and regulations related to telemedicine.

Such improvements would contribute to a more comprehensive and

competent experience for both patients and healthcare workers engaging in

telemedicine services.

3. This study could serve as an educational reference for medical and allied

health course students, raising awareness about telehealth and telemedicine

services. Students could become advocates for promoting telemedicine as an

alternative to traditional consultations, especially during situations like

pandemics that strain hospital resources. This knowledge would empower

them to understand the lived experiences of clients who have undergone

telehealth consultations, ultimately enhancing their ability to provide

improved healthcare in the future.

4. The researchers propose that healthcare workers use this study as a guide to

enhance their competence in delivering quality healthcare through

telemedicine. By assessing the advantages and disadvantages outlined in the

study, healthcare workers can refine their services and adapt their

professions to be more technologically congruent, ensuring better provision

of telemedicine care to patients.


76
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

5. Patients who have utilized telemedicine during the pandemic are encouraged

to continue using it, particularly for mild diseases. The study's conclusive

evidence supporting the role of telemedicine in understanding health

concerns makes it a valuable resource for patients. Continual use allows

patients to compare and contrast experiences during the pandemic and post-

pandemic periods, providing valuable insights for future research, academia,

and the healthcare system.

6. This study can serve as a reliable resource for future research on telehealth

and telemedicine services. Future researchers can use it to bolster their

claims and contribute to the improvement and development of telemedicine.

Additionally, the researchers suggest exploring not only the lived experiences

of patients but also those of physicians and other healthcare workers.

Conducting face-to-face interviews may enhance the validity of studies in the

telehealth domain, considering the diverse services available beyond

telemedicine and telehealth.


77
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

References

References

Aashima et al. (2021). A Review of Patient Satisfaction and Experience with

Telemedicine: A Virtual Solution During and Beyond COVID-19 Pandemic.

Mary Ann Liebert, Inc. https://doi.org/10.1089/tmj.2020.0570

Almedia, J. A. L., Dalisay, R. M., Pelaez, T. C. L., & Dimaculangan, E. D.

(2022). Awareness and Acceptance of Telehealth among Filipinos in the

National Capital Region+.

https://ijosmas.org/index.php/ijosmas/article/view/194

Ali, D., O’Brien, S., Hull, L., Kenny, L., & Mandy, W. (2023). ‘The key to this

is not so much the technology. It’s the individual who is using the

technology’: Perspectives on telehealth delivery for autistic adults during the

COVID-19 pandemic. Autism, 27(2), 552-564.

https://doi.org/10.1177/13623613221108010
78
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Amit, A., Pepito, V., & Dayrit, M. M. (2021). Early response to COVID-19 in

the Philippines. Western Pacific surveillance and response journal: WPSAR,

12(1), 56–60. https://doi.org/10.5365/wpsar.2020.11.1.014

Bahl, et al. (2020). Telemedicine Technologies for Confronting COVID-19

Pandemic: A Review. Journal of Industrial Integration and Management. Vol.

5, No. 4. https://doi.org/10.1142/S2424862220300057

Balestra, M. L. (2018). Telehealth and legal implications for nurse

practitioners. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nurpra.2017.10.003

Braimoh, et al. (2021). There is a global shortage of nurses. COVID-19 is

making it worse. Clinton Health Access. Retrieved from:

https://www.clintonhealthaccess.org/there-is-a-global-shortage-of-nurses-

covid-19-is-making-it-worse/

Browne, R. (2020). Demand for telemedicine has exploded in the UK as

doctors adapt to the coronavirus crisis. CNBC LLC. Retrieved from:

https://www.cnbc.com/2020/04/09/telemedecine-demand-explodes-in-uk-

as-gps-adapt-to-coronavirus-crisis.html
79
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

CDC. (2021). Public Health Guidance for Potential COVID-19 Exposure

Associated with Travel. Retrieved from:

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/php/risk-assessment.html

CDC. (2021). Using Telehealth to Expand Access to Essential Health Services

during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Retrieved from:

https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/telehealth.html

CDC. (2022). Telehealth and Telemedicine during COVID-19 in Low Resource

Non-U.S. Settings. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/global-

covid-19/telehealth-covid19-nonUS.html

Chiron H. (2022). Remote Patient Monitoring from

https://isalushealthcare.com/blog/category/types-of-telemedicine/

Chuo, J., Macy, M. L., & Lorch, S. A. (2020). Strategies for Evaluating

Telehealth. Pediatrics, 146(5), e20201781.

https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2020-1781

Cresswell, J. W. (2013). Research Design: Qualitative, Quantitative, and

Mixed Methods Approaches. Sage Publications.


80
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Cui, F., Ma, Q., He, X., Zhai, Y., Zhao, J., Chen, B., Sun, D., Shi, J., Cao, M.,

& Wang, Z. (2020). Implementation and Application of Telemedicine in

China: Cross-Sectional Study. JMIR mHealth and uHealth, 8(10), e18426.

https://doi.org/10.2196/18426

Dario, C., Luisotto, E., Dal Pozzo, E., Mancin, S., Aletras, V., Newman, S.,

Gubian, L., & Saccavini, C. (2016). Assessment of Patients' Perception of

Telemedicine Services Using the Service User Technology Acceptability

Questionnaire. International journal of integrated care, 16(2), 13.

https://doi.org/10.5334/ijic.2219

Department of Health. (2020). DOH BOOSTS TELEMEDICINE SERVICES FOR

NCR; SERVICE TO EXPAND TO OTHER REGIONS SOON. Kagawaran ng

Kalusugan. Retrieved from: https://doh.gov.ph/doh-press-release/DOH-

BOOST-TELEMEDICINE-SERVICES-FOR-NCR-SERVICE-TO-EXPAND-TO-

OTHER-REGIONS-SOON

Department of Health. (2020). DOH'S TELEMEDICINE INITIATIVE

STRENGTHENS PROVISION OF PRIMARY HEALTH CARE SERVICES. Retrieved

from: https://doh.gov.ph/press-release/DOH%27S-TELEMEDICINE-
81
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INITIATIVE-STRENGTHENS-PROVISION-OF-PRIMARY-HEALTH-CARE-

SERVICES

DeFranco, J. F. (2023). Computing in Telemedicine. Computer, 56(9), 15-17.

https://doi.org/10.1109/MC.2023.3286957

Dow-Fleisner, S. J., Seaton, C. L., Li, E., Plamondon, K., Oelke, N., Kurtz, D.,

... & Rush, K. L. (2022). Internet access is a necessity: a latent class analysis

of COVID-19 related challenges and the role of technology use among rural

community residents. BMC Public Health, 22(1), 1-11.

https://bmcpublichealth.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12889-022-

13254-1

Fronczek, A. E. (2019). Nursing Theory in Virtual Care - Nursing Science

Quarterly.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0894318418807926?

fbclid=IwAR2SYAEXmb2RWXZ5BXnZ52gydCr6XDyGqGDe-

XHk7TrHTtikMGxQ8gnh-Hc

Galiero, R. The Importance of Telemedicine during COVID-19 Pandemic: A

Focus on Diabetic Retinopathy. Journal of Diabetes Research.

https://doi.org/10.1155/2020/9036847
82
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Gonzalo, A. (2023). Dorothea Orem: Self-Care Deficit Theory. Retrieved

from: https://nurseslabs.com/dorothea-orems-self-care-theory/

Gunasegaran, T. (2021). Telemedicine provider reports high teleconsultation

uptake in the Philippines. Healthcare IT News. Retrieved from:

https://www.healthcareitnews.com/news/asia/telemedicine-provider-reports-

high-teleconsultation-uptake-philippines

Hellqvist, C. (2021). Promoting Self-Care in Nursing Encounters with Persons

Affected by Long-Term Conditions—A Proposed Model to Guide Clinical Care.

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18(5),

2223. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18052223

HIPAA Journal (2022). Types of Telehealth. HIPAA Journal. Retrieved from:

https://www.hipaajournal.com/types-of-telehealth/

Hollander, J. E. & Carr B. G. (2020). Virtually perfect? Telemedicine for

covid-19. N Engl J Med.

https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMp2003539.

Hosam A., et al. (2020). Telemedicine in Middle Eastern countries: Progress,

barriers, and policy recommendations, International Journal of Medical


83
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Informatics, Volume 141, 104232, ISSN 1386-5056,

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijmedinf.2020.104232

Hyder, M. A., & Razzak, J. (2020). Telemedicine in the United States: An

Introduction for Students and Residents. Journal of medical Internet

research, 22(11), e20839. https://doi.org/10.2196/20839

Institute of Medicine. (2012). The role of telehealth in an evolving health care

environment: Workshop summary, 134. Washington, DC: National

Academies Press

Jitender, A., & Arora, S. (2021). Telemedicine and ethics: opportunities in

India. Indian journal of medical ethics, VI(4), 314–320.

https://doi.org/10.20529/IJME.2021.042

Kim HS., (2021). Towards Telemedicine Adoption in Korea: 10 Practical

Recommendations for Physicians.

Lahat A, & Shatz Z. (2021) Telemedicine in clinical gastroenterology practice:

what do patients prefer? Therapeutic Advances in Gastroenterology, 14.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/1756284821989178
84
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Ng, B. P., & Park, C. (2021). Accessibility of Telehealth Services During the

COVID-19 Pandemic: A Cross-Sectional Survey of Medicare Beneficiaries.

Preventing chronic disease, 18, E65. https://doi.org/10.5888/pcd18.210056

Park H. Y. et al. (2021). Satisfaction Survey of Patients and Medical Staff for

Telephone-Based Telemedicine During Hospital Closing Due to COVID-19

Transmission. Telemedicine and e-Health.Jul

2021.724-732.http://doi.org/10.1089/tmj.2020.0369

Rodler, S., et al. (2023). The Impact of Telemedicine in Reducing the Carbon

Footprint in Health Care: A Systematic Review and Cumulative Analysis of 68

Million Clinical Consultations. European Urology Focus. Elsevier. DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.euf.2023.11.013

Sardar, Z. M. (2021). The Telehealth Spine Physical Examination: A Practical

Approach Learned During the COVID-19 Pandemic. World Neurosurgery, 154,

e61-e71. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.wneu.2021.06.116

Tapodoc, J. A., & Lasala, L. L. (2022). Effectiveness of telemedicine in

increasing the self-efficacy of patients with gestational trophoblastic

neoplasia at a Tertiary Hospital in Davao City. Philippine Journal of Obstetrics

and Gynecology, 46(4), 171-176. https://doi.org/10.4103/pjog.pjog_33_22


85
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Tenforde, A. S., et al., (2020). Telemedicine During COVID-19 for Outpatient

Sports and Musculoskeletal Medicine Physicians. PM & R: the journal of

injury, function, and rehabilitation, 12(9), 926–932.

https://doi.org/10.1002/pmrj.12422

Turchioe, M. R., Ancker, J. S., Volodarskiy, A., Vapnik, J., Sunkaraneni, S.,

&Turchioe, M. R., Ancker, J. S., Volodarskiy, A., Vapnik, J., Sunkaraneni, S.,

& Slotwiner, D. (2023). Experiences of care delays and telehealth use during

the COVID-19 pandemic among socioeconomically diverse cardiovascular

patients and clinicians in an urban hospital. AMIA... Annual Symposium

proceedings. AMIA Symposium, 2022, 1091–1100.

Van Dam, P. J., Caney, D., Turner, R. C., Griffin, P., Dwyer, M., & Prior, S.

(2022). Telehealth experiences of vulnerable clients living in Tasmania.

Australian Journal of Rural Health, 30(2), 188–196. DOI: 10.1111/ajr.12835

Walczak, R. (2022). Use of Telemedicine Technology among General

Practitioners during COVID-19: A Modified Technology Acceptance Model

Study in Poland. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public

Health (IJERPH), 19(17), 10937. DOI:10.3390/ijerph191710937.

Wenshuo, L. et al. (2021). Perceptions of patients with chronic obstructive

pulmonary disease towards telemedicine: A qualitative systematic review.


86
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Journal of Cardiopulmonary and Acute Care.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.hrtlng.2021.03.081

Zhu et al. (2020). Implications for Telemedicine for Surgery Patients After

COVID-19: Survey of Patient and Provider Experiences. Sage Journals.

https://doi.org/10.1177/000313482094519

Cervantes, F. M. (2021, November 17). House approves Bill on Nat'l eHealth System.

Philippine NewsAgency. Retrieved September 26, 2022, from

https://www.pna.gov.ph/articles/1160052

Institute of Medicine. (2012). The role of telehealth in an evolving health care environment:

Workshop summary, 134. Washington, DC: National Academies Press.

Intan Sabrina, M., & Defi, I. R. (2021, January 13). Telemedicine Guidelines in South East

Asia-A scoping review. Frontiers in Neurology. Retrieved September 26, 2022, from

https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fneur.2020.581649/full

Latifi, R., & Doarn, C. R. (2020, September). Perspective on COVID-19: Finally, Telemedicine

at Center Stage. Telemedicine Journal and e-Health : The Official Journal of the

American Telemedicine Association. Retrieved September 25, 2022, from

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32408804/
87
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Mayo Foundation for Medical Education and Research. (2022, September 14). Coronavirus

disease 2019 (covid-19). Mayo Clinic. Retrieved September 25, 2022, from

https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/coronavirus/symptoms-causes/syc-

20479963

Omboni, S., Padwal, R. S., Alessa, T., Benczúr, B., Green, B. B., Hubbard, I., Kario, K., Khan,

N. A., Konradi, A., Logan, A. G., Lu, Y., Mars, M., McManus, R. J., Melville, S.,

Neumann, C. L., Parati, G., Renna, N. F., Ryvlin, P., Saner, H., … Wang, J. (2022,

January 4). The worldwide impact of telemedicine during COVID-19: Current evidence

and recommendations for the future. Connected health. Retrieved September 25, 2022,

from https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7612439/#__ffn_sectitle

“Philippine eHealth Systems and Services Act,” no. 10245, House of Representatives (2021,

November 17). https://legacy.senate.gov.ph/lisdata/2690923123!.pdf

Whitelaw, S., Mamas, M. A., Topol, E., & Van Spall, H. G. C. (2020, August). Applications of

digital technology in COVID-19 pandemic planning and response. The Lancet. Digital

health. Retrieved September 25, 2022, from

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7324092/?report=reader

Fronczek, A. E. (2019). Nursing Theory in Virtual Care - Nursing Science Quarterly.

https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0894318418807926?

fbclid=IwAR2SYAEX
88
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

mb2RWXZ5BXnZ52gydCr6XDyGqGDe-XHk7TrHTtikMGxQ8gnh-Hc

Hellqvist, C. (2021). Promoting Self-Care in Nursing Encounters with Persons

Affected by Long-Term Conditions—A Proposed Model to Guide Clinical Care.

International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 18(5), 2223.

https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph18052223

Chuo, J., Macy, M. L., & Lorch, S. A. (2020). Strategies for Evaluating Telehealth.

Pediatrics, 146(5), e20201781. https://doi.org/10.1542/peds.2020-1781

Pearce K, (2020). ‘Social Distancing’ in application to COVID-19 from

https://hub.jhu.edu/2020/03/13/what-is-social-distancing/

Noceda, A.V., Acierto, L.M., Bertiz, M.C.,Dionisio, D.E.,Laurito, C.B.,Sanchez, G.A.,Amit,

A.M. (2022, May 23). Patient satisfaction with telemedicine in the Philippines during the

COVID-19 pandemic.medRxiv 2022.05.21.22274939;

doi:https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2022.05.21.22274939
89
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Rossow (2022) The Various Types of Telemedicine Services from

https://isalushealthcare.com/blog/the-different-types-of-telemedecine/#:~:text=The%20most

%20well%2Dknown%20type,own%20their%20own%20private%20practice

Chiron H, (2022) Remote Patient Monitoring from

https://isalushealthcare.com/blog/category/types-of-telemedicine/

H, L. (2022). What is Phenomenological Research Design? — Delve.

https://delvetool.com/blog/phenomenology#:~:text=Phenomenological%20resear

ch%20is%20a%20qualitative,preconceived%20assumptions%20about%20the%

20phenomenon.

Almedia, J. A. L., Dalisay, R. M., Pelaez, T. C. L., & Dimaculangan, E. D. (2022).

Awareness and Acceptance of Telehealth among Filipinos in the National Capital

Region+. https://ijosmas.org/index.php/ijosmas/article/view/194

Balestra, M. L. (2018). Telehealth and legal implications for nurse practitioners.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nurpra.2017.10.003

Cabatbat, K. P. M. (2021). Telemedicine: keeping patients safe during a pandemic.

Journal of Public Health, 44(3), e429–e430.

https://doi.org/10.1093/pubmed/fdab273
90
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Hani, A., & Hani, A. (2021). The rapid development of telehealth services in the

Philippines - OpenGov Asia. https://opengovasia.com/rapid-development-of-telehealth-

services-in-the-philippines/

Ong, A. K. S., Kurata, Y., Castro, S. a. D., De Leon, J. P. B., Rosa, H. V. D., & Tomines,

A. P. J. (2022). Factors influencing the acceptance of telemedicine in the

Philippines. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techsoc.2022.102040

Smith, Y. (2023). Types of Telemedicine. https://www.news-medical.net/health/Types-

of- Telemedicine.aspx#:~:text=There%20are%20three%20main%20types,both%20h

ealthcare%20workers%20and%20patients.

Yang, Y. T., & Kozhimannil, K. B. (2016). Medication abortion through telemedicine.

https://doi.org/10.1097/aog.0000000000001251
91
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

APPENDIX A
(RESEARCH INSTRUMENT)
92
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

APPENDIX B
(RESEARCH INSTRUMENT)
93
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

APPENDIX C
(THEMATIC ANALYSIS)
LEGEND:

Perception on Telemedicine

Choosing Telemedicine Services Among Others

Problems Encountered during the Consultation

Advantage of Telemedicine during Consultation

Q1. Based on your experience, what are your views on


telemedicine?
Participan Q1 Significant Q1 Cluster Emergent
t Statements Formulated Themes Themes
Meanings
2 “I would say na It is more Convenience Choosing
it’s more convenient Telemedicine
convenient nung and doesn't Service
ginamit ko siya have to leave Among
that time since I the house and Others
didn’t have to go to a
leave the house hospital.
and go to a
hospital.”
3 “For me yun Telemedicine Convenience
telemedicine is is a big help
ano malaking for the
tulong sya para patients
dun sa mga during the
patients pandemic.
during pandemic”
94
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

4 “Maganda sya It is Convenience


kase hindi kana convenient
ah.. tatawag ka because you
nalang hindi kana do not have
lalabas ng bahay to leave the
at bawal din house during
naman lumabas pandemic and
nun mga araw na it is hard to
iyon at pahirapan go to the
makapunta sa hospital.
hospital.”
7 “Madali lang po Easy access Accessibility
maaccess ang of
telemedicine” telemedicine.
8 “For me It is Convenience
napakaconvenient convenient
nya since hindi mo since it will
na kailangan not consume
lumabas ng bahay your time and
and di mo na din effort,
kailangan pumila affordable
ng napakahaba, andaccessible.
tapos di mo na din
kailangan
gumastos ng
pamasahe
papuntang
hospital. Tapos
napaka accessible
niya pa since
kailangan mo lang
is cellphone and
internet para
makapag
appointment sa
doctor mo and
kahit nasan ka
man pwedemong
makausap yung
doctor mo and
consult about your
health.”
95
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

1 “My views Positive Positive Perception


regarding experience Experience on
Telemedicine has with Telemedicine
been positive Telemedicine
experience.”
5 “Para sakin yun Telemedicine Useful for
pandemic ano yun is useful Consultation
telemedicine during
malaki tulong pandemic in
talaga sya para consulting
sakin especially with health
madami protocols professionals.
na bawal lumabas
sa mga
establishment so
ayun ang
telemedicine
during pandemic is
helpful at
accessible sa
lahat.”
9 “Telemedicine has Telemedicine Useful for
been very helpful was helpful in Consultation
in providing a providing
platform for platforms for
doctor-patient doctor-patient
interaction, saving interaction, it
time and saves time
resources to and resource
conduct regular to conduct
consultations, regular
especially during consultations.
peak Covid-19
pandemic.”
10 “Malaking tulong Telemedicine Useful for
sya actually nun is helpful Consultation
pandemic lalo na during
bawal lumabas pandemic to
kase mataas yun prevent the
cases ng covid. spreading of
Gamit na gamit COVID-19. I
sya nun pandemic used
96
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

dahil no choice itbecause I do


tayo kundi magpa not have a
online choice but to
consultation.” have
online
consultation.

Q2. Why did you choose this telemedicine service among others?
Participan Q1 Q1 Cluster Emergent
t Significant Formulated Themes Themes
Statements Meanings
1 “So, I chose Online Safety Advantage
the online consultation is of
platform of much safer Telemedicin
seeking than e during
healthcare— visiting Consultation
online rather hospitals and
than going being at risk of
physically to a having
hospital or a COVID-19
clinic as an
outpatient
because of
fear of
contracting
the
COVID-19
virus.”
9 “I chose Choosing Safety
telemedicine telemedicine
service at the due to high risk
time mainly of
because it was having COVID-
during peak 19 since it is
Covid-19 during the
pandemic, as peak
visiting of the
hospitals were pandemic.
very risky and Which felt
unsafe... to unsafe and too
avoid physical risky to go to
97
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

contact the hospitals


essentially,
that's why.”
1 “At the same Telemedicine Cost Effective
time, I wanted saves time and
to save on transportation
transportation fee.
fees and my
time
was also
limited since
I’m also a
nursing
student at St.
Michael’s.”
3 "Mas pinili ko Telemedicine Effective
sya minsan ay allows easier Communicatio
nun pandemic communication n
kase syempre .
hindi ako
makakalabas
ng bahay
pupunta sa
psychiatrist so
thru phone call
ko nalang sya
ginagawa."
6 "Kasi...hindi Telemedicine Cessation of
mo na does not Travel Time
kailangan mag involve travel
travel hindi time.
mo na
kailangan
pumila kasi
diba minsan
pag
nagpapacheck
pa tayo sa
hospital
kailangan
nating pumila
unlike kasi sa
98
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

teleconsult or
telemedicine"
8 “Since madali It is easy to Accessibility Choosing
syang gamitin use. Also, Telemedicin
and super accessible 24/7 e Services
accessible sila and Among
kase 24/7, can deliver you Others
pwede kang your
magconsult sa medicines.
kanila and
then pwede ka
din
magpadeliver
ng mga
medicines.”
10 “Pinili ko ang You don't need Accessibility
telemedicine to travel and
kase takot din wait in line for
ako hours if you
mahawaan ng went to the
covid and sa hospital. Unlike
bahay lang in
naman hindi the convenient
mo na need of your own
mag travel ng home, it
ilang minutes prevents
or hours para you to catch
lang COVID-19.
makapunta
ka ng hospital
unlike pag
nasa bahay ka
chill kalang
hihintayin mo
nalang yun
doctor
mo pumasok
sa zoom link
na binigay
sayo.”
5 “Convenient It is convenient Convenient
and and
99
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

comfortable.” comfortable.
2 "They It is convenient Convenient
provided us because it is
health provided by the
insurance that
comes with health
the job.So, insurance
every time during the
kailangan pandemic.
naming mag
ano—gamitin
‘yon, they
refer us to
their medical
doctor since
it’s—I think
parang
accredited sa
kanila or
parang
affiliated sa
kanila yung
doctor para
ma-sure nila
yung—yun nga
may sakit nga
talaga.”
4 “Mas It is convenient Convenient
convenient because you do
hindi kana not have to
pupunta sa go to the
mga doctor hospital. The
pag face to attending
face unlike sa physician
online will only ask
consultation about your
tatanungin ka complains.
lang about sa
nararamdama
n mo kaysa
pumunta ka
pa sa hospital”
100
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

7 “I tried it po It is a fast and Convenient


since convenient.
kailangan ko Since the
din po ng clinics
mabilis na that are near
gamutan nung are all close
time na yun
and
sarado na din
po yung mga
clinic near sa
house namin
po”

Q3. Can you tell me about your experience with telemedicine


during the COVID-19 pandemic?
Participan Q1 Significant Q1 Cluster Emergent
t Statements Formulated Themes Themes
Meanings
7 “Base on my It is very Accessibility Choosing
experience po sa accessible Telemedicine
telemedicine since you Services
during covid 19 don't have to Among
pandemic is go outside to Others
sobrang accessible go for a
nya po check-up and
dahil po di mo na those clinics
po kailangan nearby need
lumabas pa para an
magpacheck up appointment.
and ang mga clinic
po kasi dito
malapit samin ay
kailangan pa ng
appointment.”
9 “I only did It is accesible Accessibility
schedule for a and easy to
consultation twice use.
at the time.
101
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

Creating an
account and filling
in details such as
payment method
were fairly
straightforward.
Scheduling for a
consultation and
all the following
bits and
pieces only took a
matter of a few
minutes, though I
needed to set up a
third-party
software to use as
a
platform for the
on-call
consultation.
Schedule
confirmation and
payment
validation through
the
doctor-secretary
were also
necessary prior to
the doctor-patient
meet.”
4 “Mabilis lang pag You can Accessibility
nasa trabaho ka access
pag may sakit ka telemedicine
tapos tatawagan even when
ka nila for you're at
consultstation tas work, they
ayun will call you
sesendan ka nila for a
sa email after nila consultation
idiagnos yun then they'll
nararamdaman send an
mo.” email after
102
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

diagnosing
what you
feel.
1 “I had like a sting Due to the Wellbeing
from an “alupihan” fear of
or a centipede. COVID-19, it
So, it was really is easy to
an onset pain and stay at home
I really felt like and not risk
I needed to go to yourself
an emergency going out
hospital but I and having a
chose not to check up at
because like I the hospital.
said, out of fear of
the
COVID-19
pandemic, so I
stayed at home.”
3 “For me mas It is Convenient
convinient sya convenient
kase ayun nga because you
hindi ko na don't have to
kaylangan go outside to
pumunta sa see a health
psychiatrist.” professional
8 “Napakalaking Telemedicine Positive Perception
tulong sakin ng is a big help Experience on
telemedicine kase since you Telemedicine
nga di na ko don't have to
kailangan lumabas go outside
pa ng bahay tapos the house
and it is also
napakadali nya easy to use,
lang gamitin, click with just a
click ka lang and few clicks
then, sagutan mo and then
lang yung mga answer your
tanong sayo ng doctor's
doctor mo kung questions
ano yung masakit about what
sayo.” pains you
103
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

10 “Mas nakaka save Telemedicine Positive


ako ng time, saves time, Experience
super helpful at very helpful
napakadali nya and easy to
lang gamitin.” use.
6 “Convenient siya, It is Cessation of Advantage of
convenient bakit?, convenient Travel Time Telemedicine
kasi aahhhh hindi since you during
mo na kailangan don't have to Consultation
mag travel hindi travel, and
mo na kailangan you don't
pumila kasi diba need to line
minsan pag up because
nagpapa-check pa sometimes
tayo sa hospital when you go
kailangan nating for a check-
pumila unlike kasi up at the
sa hospital, you
teleconsult or have to line
telemedicine is up and wait.
ikaw yun mag Unlike
schedule or teleconsult or
titignan mo yun telemedicine,
schedule ng you're the
doctor so kung one who will
alin do the
yung schedule schedule or
niya yun yung you get to
pipiliin mong day, check your
date, and time.” doctor's
schedule.
2 “Actually yun nga Difficulty in Limitations Problems
yun need maacess physical on physical Encountered
ng neuro yun assessment. examinations during the
kapatid ko actually or Consultation
mahirap sya kase procedures
yun mga ano yun
mga activities na
dapat yun doctor
yun nagawa is
kame yun nag-
implement sa
104
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

kapatid ko like
yun nag
catch ng ball kase
yun doctor dapat
nagawa ng mga
ganon kase nga
para maaccess
nga ng maayos so

ayun nga kami


yun nag
implement so
parang hindi
maaccess ng
doctor yun lagay
ng kapatid ko.”
5 "Tapos, Lack of Limitations
temperature lang physical on physical
tinanong assessment. examinations
niya sakin nung or
time na ‘yun kasi procedures
obviously ‘di
naman nila ko
ma-check."

Q4. Based on your experience, what are the struggles you encounter
during the consultation?
Participant Q1 Q1 Cluster Emergent
Significant Formulated Themes Themes
Statements Meanings
3 “Minsan hindi Sometimes, Lack of Problems
sila they're hard to internet Encountered
macontact,wal contact, no connection during the
ang one answers during Consultation
sumasagot sa the phone or consultation.
phone nila or sometimes, it
minsan naman is choppy, like
choppy hindi you can't
mo sila understand
105
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

maintindihan them or they


hindi ka nila can't
maintindihan understand
ganun you.
connection
lang.”
4 “Siguro It depends on Lack of
depende your internet internet
nalang sa connection. connection
signal mo pero during
overall okay consultation.
naman.”
6 “Siguro sa The problem Lack of
internet diba encountered internet
nga thru by the connection
online.” participant is during
the internet. consultation.
7 “So ang The number Lack of
number 1 one problem of internet
problem po is telemedicine is connection
internet po, the internet during
since mabagal connection, consultation.
yung internet since the
may possibility connection is
po na slow, there's a
mag-lag yung possibility that
call or the call will lag
mamatay yung or will end
call during during the
consultation consultation.
po.”
9 “It was It was Lack of
certainly the certainly the internet
noise in the noise in the connection
audio during audio during during
the video call the video call consultation.
that made the that made the
communication communication
process process
difficult. I was difficult. You'll
having a hard have a hard
time time
106
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

understanding understanding
my doctor's your doctor's
instructions instructions
and other and other
explanations explanations
regarding my regarding your
case because case because
of her broken of the broken
audio... most audio, most
likely caused likely caused
by her by the
unstable unstable
internet internet.
connection.”

5 “Actually It's difficult Limitation on


mahirap sya since there are physical
kase yun mga procedures examinations
ano yun mga that your or
activities na doctor is procedures.
dapat yun supposed to
doctor yun do but they
nagawa is can't.
kame
yun nag-
implement sa
kapatid ko like
yun nag
catnch ng ball
kase yun
doctor dapat
nagawa ng
mga
ganon kase
nga para
maaccess nga
ng maayos so
ayun nga kami
yun nag
implement so
parang
hindi maaccess
107
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

ng doctor yun
lagay ng
kapatid ko.”
5 “Yun nga yun Limited Limitation on
mga struggles physical physical
namin yun assessment. examinations
mga or
assessment na procedures.
dapat yun
doctor nag-
implement or
gumawa tas
kami yun
gumawa and
medyo ano
kase para sa
side namin
during
consultation
para
naiinis yun
doctor kase
nga yun bagay
na dapat sya
yun nagawa is
kami yun
nagawa tapos
hindi
namin sya
magawa ng
maayos kase
yun kapatid ko
diba nga
autistic so
ayun para
hindi sya
nasunod
samin kase
kilala nya kami
pero kase pag
sa iba tao
parang
108
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

nasunod
naman sya
kahit mejo
nahihiya
so ayun kaya
medyo
nahihirapan
kami ipagawa
yun mga
activities.”

8 “Siguro yung Limited Limitation on


struggle lang physical physical
sa online assessment. examinations
consultation is or
yung pag procedures.
eexplain ng
kung anong
masakit sayo,
kung gaano
kasakit di ba
kasi inaano
nila yung pain
level, kunware
sa sakit ng
ipin,
tatanungin ka
nila
unlike pag sa
personal
makikita nila
through your
actions and
machecheck
up talaga ng
masinsinan
yung katawan
mo.”
10 “Siguro yun Limited Limitation on
laboratories physical and physical
and laboratory examinations
assessment assessment. or
109
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

kase nga nasa procedures.


bahay lang
paano
magagawa yun
3 Telemedicine Telemedicine Delayed
is not possible is not possible response
without without signal. from the
signal.” healthcare
provider
2 “Nung time na There was Delayed
pala ‘yun na delayed response
nagco- response from from the
communicate the healthcare healthcare
ako sa doctor provider. provider
medyo
matagal lang
talaga siya
magreply.
I’m not sure
kung bakit,
siguro marami
din siyang
patients hina-
handle? I think
it would be
best na
meron siyang
mga nurses or
tumutulong sa
kanya para
mag-entertain
sa mga
patients.
Medyo may
delayed time
lang talaga.
Well, in my
case
anyways.”

Q5. During your consultation, what would you consider the advantages of
110
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

telemedicine?
Participan Q1 Significant Q1 Cluster Emergent
t Statements Formulated Themes Themes
Meanings
1 “Because everyone Telemedicine Convenient Choosing
uses the internet is convenient Telemedicine
nowadays, so it and easy to Services
was just as easy as use. Among
like the “tap of a Others
button”
or the “click of the
mouse” over the
computer. So, it
was like in an
instant health is
provided— I
mean health
service is provided
to you at your own
fingertips.
Accessible siya
sobra.”
7 “Sobrang laking Convenient Convenient
advantage po na because
meron silang reseta certificates
na pinipresent and and
sinisend po sa inyo prescription
through pdf na din were sent
po sya and isesend online.
po nila through
telemedicine din
po. And then,
idodownload
mo na lang po yun
and then ipapakita
mo po sya since
ang mga mercury
drugs and other
drug
store po, di po sila
nagbebenta ng
gamot ng wala
111
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

pong reseta.”
9 “Well, of course, it's Convenient Convenient
time-saving as because
consultations can certificates
be done anytime... and
anywhere. Ease of prescription
transactions as were sent
payment through online.
my health card was
done swiftly in just
a few clicks of a
button.
Generally, in my
opinion,
telemedicine is very
advantageous for
people who wants
to save time
for a regular check
up, maybe just a
one-time
consultation for the
most common
diseases.”
5 “Para sakin yun Prevent the Wellbeing
advantages nya is spread of
during pandemic is infection.
to prevent yun pag
spread ng virus sa
patient
tapos kung malayo
yun patient and
yun doctor
makakapg consult
padin.”
6 “Ayun nga Prevent the Wellbeing
convenient and spread of
then save ng infection.
money and then
yun nga yung
comfort andoon
padin. Yung
112
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

patient and then


yun naman talaga
ang purpose ng
telemedicine during
that time is not to
spread
yung covid 19.”
8 “For me, yung Telemedicine Accessibility
advantage ng is accessible
telemedicine talaga anytime and
is yung anywhere.
convenience and
safety since di mo
na
lumabas ng bahay,
tapos di mo na
kailangan humarap
sa napakahabang
pila, tapos
accessible pa
sya anytime and
anywhere you are.”

10 “Malaki nasasave Telemedicine Accessibility


na time and hindi is accessible
mo na need and easy to
lumabas/ pumunta use.
hospital para
pumila ng
napakahaba para
magpacheck up and
very accesible sya
sa lahat ng gadgets
basta may wifi ka.”
2 “The way I see it, The patient Cessation of Advantage of
‘yung advantage does not Travel Time Telemedicine
lang talaga is ‘yung need to go during
hindi mo na outside for Consultation
kailangan lumabas consultation.
kasi online
lang talaga.”
3 “Yun advantanges The patient Cessation of
113
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

nya lang ay yun does not Travel Time


hindi muna need need to go
pumunta sa clinic outside for
para magpaconsult consultation.
sa doctor
mo and ayun easy
access sya yun
lang.“
4 “Convenient tapos The patient Cessation of
ahm hindi kana does not Travel Time
mahihirap pumunta need to go
sa hospital para outside for
magpacheck up consultation.
tungkol sa
nararamdaman
mo.”
114
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

APPENDIX D.
(INTERVIEW TRANSCRIPT)
Interview #1

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, ma’am. My name is Joanna Bren de Leon. These are my
groupmates po: Ms. Aira Dominguez, Mr. Ireneo Desquitado, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Danielle
Anne De Leon, and Ms. Aivee De La Cruz po. We are third year nursing students po kami from
University of Perpetual Help Laguna. So, andito po kami para magconduct ng interview para po
sa research naming na entitled “The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine
During the Covid-19 Pandemic.” So, ask ko lang po kung pwede kayong mainterview po,
ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: Sure, I give my consent.

INTERVIEWER: Pwede rin po ba namin i-record ang conversation natin po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: Of course, no problem.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po, ma’am. So based po sa experience niyo, ano po ba ang mga views
niyo sa Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: My views regarding Telemedicine has been positive experience. I’ve never had
any trouble when I started or when I acquired or sought help from Telemedicine services.

INTERVIEWER: Why did you choose this Telemedicine service among others po?

PARTICIPANT: So, I chose the online platform of seeking healthcare— online rather than going
physically to a hospital or a clinic as an outpatient because of fear of contracting the COVID-19
virus. At the same time, I wanted to save on transportation fees and my time was also limited
since I’m also a nursing student at St. Michael’s.

INTERVIEWER: Can you tell me about your experience po with Telemedicine during nung
COVID-19 pandemic po?

PARTICIPANT: Okay so basically, I actually just took Telemedicine services last year— sorry, I
made an appointment online and it was ConsultaMD, specifically because I had like a sting from
115
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

an “alupihan” or a centipede. So, it was really an onset pain and I really felt like I needed to go
to an emergency hospital but I chose not to because like I said, out of fear of the COVID-19
pandemic, so I stayed at home.

INTERVIEWER: So, ma’am, halimbawa po kung mangyari po sainyo yan ngayon would you still
go— I mean choose the Telemedicine service po imbis na pumunta na lang po sa ospital para
mapatignan po kayo?

PARTICIPANT: Definitely. I did not see any difference except yun lang you’re not able to see the
doctor or the nurse in person, but it really felt like there was no difference in the service that
they provided for me so I was really satisfied.
INTERVIEWER: Based po sa experience niyo po, meron po ba kayong naencounter na mga
struggles po during the consultation?

PARTICIPANT: Honestly, no because it was really much cheaper than having to pay 600 or 500
pesos when you go to the hospital or clinic to have a check-up. So, I only paid like 150, via
GCash pa—online. Other than that, the waiting time, I actually chose the time of the
appointment so there was no problem at all, it was really easy.

INTERVIEWER: So, convenient po sainyo yung oras po?

PARTICIPANT: Yes, bali ano, convenience ng time, ng money, and actually yun din—yung
parang comfort ko—that I was at home, and I was able to rest instead of having to struggle with
the pain and then go to the hospital and wait there.

INTERVIEWER: So, ano pa po ba ang mga advantages para sainyo ng Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: Bali ayun, because everyone uses the internet nowadays, so it was just as easy as
like the “tap of a button” or the “click of the mouse” over the computer. So, it was like in an
instant health is provided— I mean health service is provided to you at your own fingertips.
Accessible siya sobra.

INTERVIEWER: So, given a choice po, magpapaconsult po ulit kayo sa Telemedicine app or for
you po, do you think na mas better po para mas thorough po yung pacheck-up niyo po or
consultation, mas better po ba na pumunta na lang po physically sa ospital po?

PARTICIPANT: The only thing I can say regarding yung assessment or yung full physical profile
mo na malalaman nila or maddiagnose nila yung pinaka ano mo—symptoms, signs ganun diba?
116
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

So, yung full diagnosis pati yung sabihin natin the diagnostics ng mga laboratory, of course,
those are impossible over sa online because we do not have the equipment at home, so you
really have to go to laboratories or to the hospital to have that done. I would say for minor
cases or like hindi siya severe cases pwede siya, pwede si Telehealth or Telemedicine. But, if
you have a severe case like CHD mga ganon, or parang hypertension which Is like you really
need medication and then monitoring for that, then yeah, you’d really have to go to the
hospital.

INTERVIEWER: So, for you po ma’am, ano po bang mga pwede pa nating maimprove po sa
Telemedicine yung gusto niyo pa po sanang makita in the future po?

PARTICIPANT: I would rather have it na maging mas accessible siya to all parties—to all sectors
—sa government, even sa mga less fortunate or underprivileged kasi there are not so many
people who have access to the internet. Diba they don’t have mobile phones and what not? So,
if the government were to actually support Telemedicine and provided along with
telecommunication providers diba? like free internet for everybody ganun. Tapos even sa mga
rural areas, they could provide mga barangays with internet access, I think that would be
something to promote Telemedicine because it’s really helpful, it can save money as well. Save
you money as well, sorry.

INTERVIEWER: Paano niyo po pala pinatignan yung kagat niyo po sa centipede?

PARTICIPANT: Actually, I just took pictures of it and then I told the doctor—or I explained to her
yung time and duration ng pain. Bali sinabi ko rin na how many hours from the start yung pain
nag-occur. Then she gave the medication for the pain, then yung para bang for the swelling. So,
atleast, dun ko narin nakuha yung ano—E ano, anong tawag dun?

INTERVIEWER: E-Prescription?

PARTICIPANT: Yeah, e-prescription or electronic prescription. So, it’s like paperless siya and
then yun nga, I was only just able to show it sa Mercury, holding up my cellphone. I didn’t have
to print it out and they were able to see yung prescription, yung license number ni Doc, and
then yung date and time na—para atleast ano siya, real time talaga, like hindi siya like fake
ganun.

INTERVIEWER: Tapos hiningian po ba kayo ng I.D. or something para ma-verify po yung ano…?

PARTICIPANT: Identity?
117
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: Opo.

PARTICIPANT: Actually, yeah. They really asked me if my name is this and that and then I
showed my number that it’s registered to my name.

INTERVIEWER: Okay, po. I think yun lang po, ma’am. Thank you po for your time.

PARTICIPANT: Thank you.

Interview #2

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, sir. I am Joanna Bren de Leon. These are my groupmates po: Ms.
Aira Dominguez, Mr. Ireneo Desquitado, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Danielle Anne De Leon, and Ms.
Aivee De La Cruz po, third year nursing students po kami from University of Perpetual Help
Laguna. So, andito po kami para mag-conduct ng interview para sa research naming entitled
“The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During the COVID-19 Pandemic.” So,
ask ko lang po kung puwede kayong ma-interview po, sir?

PARTICIPANT: Ok po.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po. Pwede rin po ba naming i-record ang conversation natin, sir?

PARTICIPANT: Sure.
118
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po. Based po sa experience niyo po, ano po ba yung mga views niyo
on Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: I would say na it’s more convenient nung ginamit ko siya that time since I didn’t
have to leave the house and go to a hospital and meron din mga downside but, yun nga, I just
think it’s convenient than having to go to an actual hospital or clinic.

INTERVIEWER: Kelan niyo po ba ito ginamit, sir?

PARTICIPANT: I think it was 2021? Around 2021. I’m not sure kung anong month, basta year
2021.

INTERVIEWER: Ok. Why did you choose this Telemedicine service among others po, sir?

PARTICIPANT: I was working for a BPO company at that time, since they’re based in Cebu, they
provided us health insurance that comes with the job. So, every time kailangan naming mag
ano—gamitin ‘yon, they refer us to their medical doctor since it’s—I think parang accredited sa
kanila or parang affiliated sa kanila yung doctor para ma-sure nila yung—yun nga may sakit nga
talaga. Since obviously, BPO company, they need to make sure na hindi naming ma-fake or
whatever yung pa-check-up.

INTERVIEWER: Can you tell me po yung buong experience niyo sa Telemedicine during the
COVID-19 pandemic po?

PARTICIPANT: I think I just used it like a few times. Yung time na may parang slight fever ako
tapos may sore throat. Natakot ako that time baka COVID, pero hindi naman pala. So ‘yun, nung
ni-report ko yun sa supervisor ko, nirefer niya kami sa ‘yun parang—I’m not so sure if it’s
company doctor, pero doctor ng Telemedicine sa—it was a clinic that’s affiliated sa company
nila. So ‘yun, the check-up was done through Zoom. Yeah, we did it through Zoom. He
interviewed me, asked me about my symptoms and all that. Tapos, temperature lang tinanong
niya sakin nung time na ‘yun kasi obviously ‘di naman nila ko ma-check.

INTERVIEWER: Ano po ba yung diagnosis niyo po and may nireseta po ba?

PARTICIPANT: Meron siyang nireseta. Actually, before niya ko niresetahan pala, nag-request
siya na magpa-laboratory ako. So, parang strep throat lang naman pala ‘yon kasi nawalan narin
119
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

ako ng boses then slight infection. So, antibiotics lang din naman. Tapos para sa mga symptoms
‘yung—I think it was a mouthwash na—ano ba ‘yun? Betadine mouthwash or something?

INTERVIEWER: Bactidol po?

PARTICIPANT: Yeah!

INTERVIEWER: Bali nagpa-lab test po kayo?

PARTICIPANT: Yes, nagpa-lab test pa ako. After nung makuha ko yung result, I just had to take a
screenshot and e-mail it to the doctor.

INTERVIEWER: Ano pong lab test po yung ginawa?

PARTICIPANT: Parang throat swab? ‘Yun.

INTERVIEWER: Based po sa experience niyo, ano po yung mga struggles po na na-encounter


niyo during the consultation po?

PARTICIPANT: Sa consultation, so far parang wala naman, wala namang struggles.

INTERVIEWER: Nasa magkano po nagastos niyo po?

PARTICIPANT: Hindi ko na siya ma-remember, but since it was part of our insurance, covered
nadin ng ano ko—I think it was Medicare—oo, Medicare I think? Ay, MaxiCare pala! Sorry.
Covered ‘yun ng MaxiCare.

INTERVIEWER: During the consultation niyo po, ano po yung maco-consider niyo pong mga
advantages ng Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: The way I see it, ‘yung advantage lang talaga is ‘yung hindi mo na kailangan
lumabas kasi online lang talaga. Well, except for ‘yung ni-request niya ‘ko magpa-laboratory
and ‘yun syempre lumabas para bumili ng mga gamot.

INTERVIEWER: So, sa tingin niyo po were they able to provide quality care naman po like kung
ikumpara natin to sa traditional na consultation na face-to-face po, may pagkukulang po ba sila
in that regards?
120
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: In my case, I would say wala naman kasi parang yung sakin simple lang naman na
parang sore throat or slight fever. Pero if ever na malala na ‘yung sakit ko, I don’t think I would
recommend that kasi obviously the doctor needs to do more check—physically check you para
malaman niya talaga kung ano ‘yung problema or whatever. Pero ‘yun, it has its ups and downs.

INTERVIEWER: So, halimbawa po ngayon, would you rather—I mean would you recommend
Telemedicine po? For you po, halimbawa, mangyari po ulit na magkasakit po kayo, would you
opt for Telemedicine imbis na traditional na lang po na pumunta na lang po sa ospital or clinic?

PARTICIPANT: For me, if it’s something simple lang, yeah, I think that would be a good option.
Pero kung medyo iba na, I would prefer to go to the hospital or the clinic.

INTERVIEWER: What would you consider na medyo malala na po?

PARTICIPANT: Like say for example, mga severe na ano—grabe na talaga ‘yung lagnat mo—or
siguro mga worse case na mga sakit.

INTERVIEWER: Ano po bang masa-suggest niyo pong magandang—para ma-improve po natin


yung Telemedicine natin for our future use po?

PARTICIPANT: Ah yes, I forgot to mention this, meron lang times—nung time na pala ‘yun na
nagco-communicate ako sa doctor medyo matagal lang talaga siya magreply. I’m not sure kung
bakit, siguro marami din siyang patients hina-handle? I think it would be best na meron siyang
mga nurses or tumutulong sa kanya para mag-entertain sa mga patients. Medyo may delayed
time lang talaga. Well, in my case anyways.

INTERVIEWER: This was prior to your Zoom call po?

PARTICIPANT: Yes, prior to the Zoom call.

INTERVIEWER: Bali may waiting period po? Pero naka-set po ‘yung time niyo po sa kanya?

PARTICIPANT: Yes, naka-set ‘yung time since company ‘yun. Alam naman ng—since it’s a BPO
industry, lahat kami may schedule, so kahit magkasakit ka you have to inform them in advance
for some reason, I don’t know why, pero ‘yun.

INTERVIEWER: That’s all of my questions po, sir, thank you po for your time.
121
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: Okay, thank you.

Interview #3

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, ma’am. My name is Ireneo Desquitado. These are my groupmates
po: Ms. Aira Dominguez, Ms.Aivee De La Cruz, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Danielle Anne De Leon,
and Ms. Joanna Bren de Leon po. We are third year nursing students po kami from University of
Perpetual Help Laguna. So, andito po kami para magconduct ng interview para po sa research
naming na entitled “The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During the Covid-
19 Pandemic.” So, ask ko lang po kung pwede kayong mainterview po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: opo

INTERVIEWER: Pwede rin po ba namin i-record/ ivideo ang conversation natin po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: sure

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po, ma’am. So based po sa experience niyo, ano po ba ang mga views
niyo sa Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: for me yun telemedicine is ano malaking tulong sya para dun sa mga patients
during pandemic na ano hindi makapunta sa mga hospital dahil madami mga checkpoint at sa
mga hindi din makalabas dahil wala sila mga sariling sasakyan ganyan.

INTERVIEWER: ahh okay po mam, so ano po apps ang ginamit nyo nun gumamit po kayo ng
telemedicine pwede ko po ba malaman?

PARTICIPANT: so bali ano yun ginamit ko ay hindi app bali thru phone call lang sya

INTERVIEWER: ahh okay po so bali may nakausap naman po kayo na Doctor?

PARTICIPANT: meron

INTERVIEWER: ask ko lang po mam bali hindi po kayo nagpa appointment since thru phone call
lang naman po yun consult sainyo and nun tumawag po kayo naconsult agad kayo ng doctor?
122
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: oo
INTERVIEWER: next question is why did you choose this telemedicine among others?

PARTICIPANT: mas pinili ko sya minsan ay nun pandemic kase syempre hindi ako makakalabas
ng bahay pupunta sa psychiatrist so thru phone call ko nalang sya ginagawa.

INTERVIEWER: ilang beses po kayo nagpapaconsult

PARTICIPANT: siguro mga 6 times

INTERVIEWER: ano po yun sunod sunod consult nyo or pag inaatake lang po kayo?

PARTICIPANT: pag inaatake lang

INTERVIEWER: ang third question po ay can you tell me about your experience with
telemedicine during the Covid-19 pandemic?

PARTICIPANT: so bali for me mas convinient sya kase ayun nga hindi ko na kaylangan pumunta
sa psychiatrist ganon pero ano minsan iniisip ko din what if yun sa kabila line na patient nila is
hindi- alam nyo yun para ano hindi nya talaga macontrol yun gagawin nya talaga kung ano
gagawin para ayun lang siguro yun disadvantage

INTERVIEWER: ano po mas prefer nyo face to face or yun thru phone call consultation lang kayo
kung papapiliin kayo?

PARTICIPANT: thru face to face padin kase nakikita ka nila

INTERVIEWER: kumbaga mas malaki po tulong ang face to face consultation sainyo?

PARTICIPANT: opo

INTERVIEWER: next question is based on your experience, what are the struggles you
encountered during the consultation?

PARTICIPANT: ayun minsan hindi sila macontact,walang sumasagot sa phone nila or minsan
naman choppy hindi mo sila maintindihan hindi ka nila maintindihan ganun connection lang.

INTERVIEWER: pag ganon mam ano yun ginagawa nyo pag hindi nyo sila macontact.
123
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: pinapatayan ko hahaha

INTERVIEWER: pero tinatawagan nyo padin po pabalik pag hindi nyo na sila macontact?

PARTICIPANT: minsan, minsan naman pag ayoko na pag ayoko may kausap ako hindi ko na
tinatawagan.

INTERVIEWER: pero natritrigger po ba nararamdaman nyo pag di nyo sila macontact?

PARTICIPANT: hindi naman para ano lang nag rereach out nalang ako sa friend para lang
gumaan loob ko.

INTERVIEWER: next question po during your consultation, what would you consider the
advantanges of telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: yun advantanges nya lang ay yun hindi muna need pumunta sa clinic para
magpaconsult sa doctor mo and ayun easy access sya yun lang.

INTERVIEWER: during your consultation nyo po may binabayaran po ba kayoor wala po?

PARTICIPANT: kapag doctor ko yun kausap ko may fee sya pero kapag yun emergency hotline
nila doon wala.

INTERVIEWER: mas mahal po ba pag online compared sa face to face?

PARTICIPANT: actually no, same lang sila ng fee mapa online or face to face

INTERVIEWER: paano nyo po binabayaran thru gcash po ba or bank transfer po?

PARTICIPANT: thru gcash minsan thru bank

INTERVIEWER: after your consultation nyo po nalelesses or gumagaan naman po lobb nyo like
nasasatisfy po ba kayo after you consultation?

PARTICIPANT: yes
124
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: since nagamit po kayo ng telemedicine app ano po yun masusuggest nyo para
mas maimprove po nila yun services nila like po nun naexperience nyo po sometimes hindi nyo
po sila macontact.

PARTICIPANT: yun ano kase pandemic feeling ko kulang sila sa staff tapos yun signal nila parang
hindi po sila maintindihan kase mahina pero ngayon naman pag natawag ako sakanila hindi na
ganon katulad dati pag tawag ko kaylangan pa ilang ring bago pa sagutin ngayon kase alala nila
kumbaga unang ring sasagot agad sila tas hindi na ganon na walang signal.

INTERVIEWER: until now po ba nagamit padin po kayo ng telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: oo pag emergency

INTERVIEWER: kelan po huli nyo paconsult?

PARTICIPANT: last december.

INTERVIEWER: Ok po maam maraming salamat po maam sa lahat po ng pinag usapan natin ito
po maging pribado po so kami lang po ang nakakaalam ng pinag usapan natin so ang purpose
po ng ginawa natin interview is a reference lang po sa thesis namin so maraming salamat po ulit
maam, at salamat po sa inyo pagpapa unlak.

PARTICIPANT: thank you din!


Interview #4

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, Sir . My name is Aivee De La Cruz. These are my groupmates po:
Ms. Aira Dominguez, Mr. Ireneo Desquitado, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Danielle Anne De Leon, and
Ms. Joanna Bren de Leon po. We are third year nursing students po kami from University of
Perpetual Help Laguna. So, andito po kami para magconduct ng interview para po sa research
naming na entitled “The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During the Covid-
19 Pandemic.” So, ask ko lang po kung pwede kayong mainterview po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: pwede naman

INTERVIEWER: Pwede rin po ba namin i-record/ ivideo ang conversation natin po, sir?

PARTICIPANT: sure pero walang video


125
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER:Thank you po, ma’am. So based po sa experience niyo, ano po ba ang mga views
niyo sa Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT:Maganda sya kase hindi kana ah.. tatawag ka nalang hindi kana lalabas ng bahay
at bawal din naman lumabas nun mga araw na iyon at pahirapan makapunta sa hospital.

INTERVIEWER: So bali po ano po pinaconsult nyo nun gumamit po kayo ng telemedicine

PARTICIPANT: nilagnat

INTERVIEWER: Thru phonecall po ba or video call po kayo during consultation nyo po?

PARTICIPANT: thru direct phone call

INTERVIEWER: next question po is why did you choose this telemedicine service among others?

PARTICIPANT: Ano kase mas convenient hindi kana pupunta sa mga doctor pag face to face
unlike sa online consultation tatanungin ka lang about sa nararamdaman mo kaysa pumunta ka
pa sa hospital

INTERVIEWER: next question po ay can you tell me about your experience with telemedicine
during the Covid-19 pandemic?

PARTICIPANT: mabilis lang pag nasa trabaho ka pag may sakit ka tapos tatawagan ka nila for
consultstation tas ayun sesendan ka nila sa email after nila idiagnos yun nararamdaman mo.
mabilis lang pag nasa trabaho ka pag may sakit ka tapos tatawagan ka nila for consultstation tas
ayun sesendan ka nila sa email after nila idiagnos yun nararamdaman mo tsaka mas convenient
hindi kana pupunta sa mga hospital/clinic para magpaconsult unlike sa online consultation
tatanungin ka lang about sa nararamdaman mo kaysa pumunta ka pa sa hospital tas what if dun
ka makakuha ng virus mahirap na kaya mas mabuti sa bahay nalang para hindi nadin makakuha
ng virus.

INTERVIEWER: Ano po yun madalas nyo pinapacheck pag gumagamit kayo ng telemedicine

PARTICIPANT: ano lang yun ubo,sipon at body pain


126
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: So until now ginagamit nyo padin yun telemedicune?


PARTICIPANT: Oo lalo na sa work namin kahit may face to face consultation gumagamit padin
kami ito kase mas mabilis at less hassle nadin.

INTERVIEWER: next question is based on your experience, what are the struggles you
encountered during the consultation?

PARTICIPANT: Sakin wala naman problema siguro depende nalang sa signal mo pero overall
okay naman

INTERVIEWER: ahh okay po eto po sir next question po ay during your consultation, what
would you consider the advantanges of telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: Uhm ano convenient tapos ahm hindi kana mahihirap pumuta sa hospital para
magpacheck up tungkol sa nararamdaman mo tas yun disadvantange for me siguro yun pag
may pilay ka yun mga hindi pwede ipacheck up thru phonecall or video call na need talaga
ipaconsult sa hospital kase may mga test or laboratories na need gawin para maaccess talaga.

INTERVIEWER: last question po sir ano po kaya pwede nyo na suggestion about this app po
kung meron po?

PARTICIPANT: Siguro yun ano dagdagan nila yun mga available na doctors sa online
consultation

INTERVIEWER: Okay, po. I think yun lang po, ma’am. Thank you po for your time.

PARTICIPANT: thank you.

Interview #5
127
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, ma’am. My name is Aivee De La Cruz . These are my groupmates
po: Mr. Ireneo Desquitado, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Danielle Anne De Leon, Ms. Joanna Bren de
Leon,and Ms. Aira Dominguez po. We are third year nursing students po kami from University
of Perpetual Help Laguna. So, andito po kami para magconduct ng interview para po sa
research naming na entitled “The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During
the Covid-19 Pandemic.” So, ask ko lang po kung pwede kayong mainterview po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: opo

INTERVIEWER: Pwede po ba namin record or video po yun buong interview po namin sainyo
ngayon?

PARTICIPANT: pwede naman basta walang video ah

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po, ma’am. First question based po sa experience niyo, ano po ba ang
mga views niyo sa Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: Para sakin yun pandemic ano yun telemedicine malaki tulong talaga sya para
sakin especially madami protocols na bawal lumabas sa mga establishment so ayun ang
telemedicine during pandemic is helpful at accessible sa lahat.

INTERVIEWER: ahh okay po mam next question po why did you choose this telemedicine
service among others?

PARTICIPANT: Actually wala naman ako choice kase nga pandemic bawal pumunta sa labas
para kumain mga clinics, hospitals for face to face consultation kaya nag required sila for online
consultation nalang so ayun diko naman pinili pero yun at yun lang talaga ang required kaya
wala ako choice.

INTERVIEWER: Ano po pinaconsult nyo that time

PARTICIPANT: actually hindi ako yun nagpaconsult yun kapatid ko yun nagpaconsult kase may
autism sya and need sya maacess ng neuro so ayun kasama lang ako durimg ano consultation
na ano ahm online.

INTERVIEWER: Paano po yun consultation nyo thru videocall po ba or phonecall?


128
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT:oo thru videocall kase kaylangan sya maaccess ng doctor kase may mga activities
na pinagawa ng sakanya para makita ng doctor kung ano nga bayun mga skills, abilities nya.

INTERVIEWER: ahh okay po mam next question can you tell me about your experience with
telemedicine during the Covid-19 pandemic?

PARTICIPANT: Actually yun nga yun need maacess ng neuro yun kapatid ko actually mahirap
sya kase yun mga ano yun mga activities na dapat yun doctor yun nagawa is kame yun nag
implement sa kapatid ko like yun nag catnch ng ball kase yun doctor dapat nagawa ng mga
ganon kase nga para maaccess nga ng maayos so ayun nga kami yun nag implement so parang
hindi maaccess ng doctor yun lagay ng kapatid ko.

INTERVIEWER: During consultation po may ginawa po ba laboratories ginawa?

PARTICIPANT: Ay wala sya lab more on occupational bayun? Yun activities ganun pero nun
binigay yun result samin nag advice sila ipa CT scan.

INTERVIEWER:Based on your experience, what are the struggles you encountered during the
consultation?

PARTICIPANT: Yun nga yun mga struggles namin yun mga assessment na dapat yun doctor nag
implement or gumawa tas kami yun gumawa and medyo ano kase para sa side namin during
consultation para naiinis yun doctor kase nga yun bagay na dapat sya yun nagawa is kami yun
nagawa tapos hindi namin sya magawa ng maayos kase yun kapatid ko diba nga autistic so ayun
para hindi sya nasunod samin kase kilala nya kami pero kase pag sa iba tao parang nasunod
naman sya kahit mejo nahihiya so ayun kaya medyo nahihirapan kami ipagawa yun mga
activities.

INTERVIEWER: Pero nagawa nyo naman po yun pinagawa ng doctor?

PARTICIPANT: Oo nagawa naman pero yun result nun hindi agad naibigay mga following day pa
bago ibigay.

INTERVIEWER: Mga ilang beses po kayo nagpaconsult that time

PARTICIPANT: actually isang beses lang sya tapos yun follow up nun matagal nadin kase
andami din pinapahanap na doctors kumbaga magpa second opinion kami tsaka nirequire din
129
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

sya mag CT scan eh diba pag ct scan face to face nayun so nito lang yun kase nga during
pandemic natin mahirap makapunta hospital kase nito lang sya nakapag CT scan.

INTERVIEWER: next question during your consultation, what would you consider the
advantanges of telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: para sakin yun advantages nya is during pandemic is to prevent yun pag spread
ng virus sa patient tapos kung malayo yun patient and yun doctor makakapg consult padin and
actually hindi naman anytime sasabihin ko sana anytime pwede macontact may times kase may
schedule din yun mga doctors para makausap mo sila so ayun lang yun advantanges nya para
sa akin.

INTERVIEWER: May masusugest po ba kayo para improve yun telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: Siguro yun time nila kase minsan minamadali nila katulad nun autistic yun
patient tas may mga activies na ano siguro sa isang patient may a lot sila ng time like haliwbawa
one hour mag alot sila g extra minutes like 30 mins more kase hindi naman during consultation
na 1 hour maaacess agad nila completely yun patient since online consultation nga lang

INTERVIEWER: Pero on time naman po sila dumating sa sinabi nila oras?

PARTICIPANT: thru zoom kami tas antagal dumating nun doctor kami payun nag antay sakanya
pabalik balik kami sa zoom

INTERVIEWER: Pero nagpa appointment po kayo bago kayo magpaconsult?

PARTICIPANT: oo sa email

INTERVIEWER: Matagal po ba sila mag reply?

PARTICIPANT: Mabilis naman sa email ang matagal lang is yun mismo session

INTERVIEWER: ilan oras po yun consultation nyo po?

PARTICIPANT: 2 hours yun consultation pero hindi naman nasagad yun oras nabigay samin

INTERVIEWER: And lastly paano po yun sa payment nyo po paano po thru gcassh or bank
transfer?
130
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: gcash pero ay bank transfer sila pero mas convinient yun gcash diba?

INTERVIEWER: ahh okay po. I think yun lang po, ma’am. Thank you po for your time.

PARTICIPANT: Thank you.

Interview #6

INTERVIEWER:Good day po, ma’am. My name is Ireneo Desquitado. These are my groupmates
po: Ms. Aira Dominguez, Ms.Aivee De La Cruz, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Danielle Anne De Leon,
and Ms. Joanna Bren de Leon po. We are third year nursing students po kami from University of
Perpetual Help Laguna. So, andito po kami para magconduct ng interview para po sa research
naming na entitled “The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During the Covid-
19 Pandemic.” So, ask ko lang po kung pwede kayong mainterview po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: ah sure ok naman

INTERVIEWER: Pwede rin po ba namin i-record/ ivideo ang conversation natin po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: yes you can

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po, ma’am. So based po sa experience niyo, ano po ba ang mga views
niyo sa Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: Ahhh my views or my own views po for telemedicine is ay isang way para
maging para di mag spread lalo yung nag pandemic, kasi ang telemedicine or teleconsult by the
way first time gumamit ng teleconsult during pandemic so yun, it's a way na para di lalo mag
spread yun covid ahhh nacoconsult sya na nasa isang place siya na komportable siya, like yun
nasa bahay sya sympre nasa bed sya unlike kasi na nasa ospital parang, ako kasi parang anu eh
nung nasa ospital ako hindi ako parang ganun ka komportable parang yun worries, aaahhhhhh
na baka dun pa ako makakuha ng sakit or baka mamaya lumala pa yun kung anu yung
nararamdaman ko and then at the same time convenient siya, convenient bakit?, kasi aahhhh
hindi mo na kailangan mag travel hindi mo na kailangan pumila kasi diba minsan pag nagpapa
131
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

check pa tayo sa hospital kailangan nating pumila unlike kasi sa teleconsult or telemedicine is
ikaw yun mag schedule or titignan mo yun schedule ng doctor so kung alin yun schedule niya
yun yung pipiliin mong day, date, and time, para atlis diba, actually doon naman yun sa
expirience mo kung anu yun pinili mong day at yun time nasunod siya so aattend ka ng doctor
or makakausap mo talaga yun doctor sa binigay mo oras tsaka unlike sa ospital diba mag aantay
ka di mo alam kung anu oras ka ma accommodate and then at the same time for me kasi save
din ng money gaya ng sa amin na wala namang sasakyan or yung alam mo yun? Sarili sasakyan,
kailangan namin ahhhh mag travel by transportation so instead na gumastos kami ng pamasahe
so yun sa bahay na lang so naka save din kami for anu ng money, so in terms naman doon sa
anu fee ng consultation,para sa akin mas mura kasi parang anu eh para magagastos lang namin
nun is parang 400 unlike yun mag aanu kami pag nag walk in or dun sa actual talaga doon sa
ospital mga anu 500 to 600 ganun so ayun, so tsaka pag anu pag kailangan mo ng medcert.
Libre nila binibigay, unlike doon sa mga experience na pag kailangan ng medcert. May separate
fee.”

INTERVIEWER: Oh, so bali maam na cater naman po ng lahat ng telemedicine yun mga
pangangailangan ninyo, so ma'am ahhh kung halimbawa po na magkakasakit po ulit kayo.
Would you still use telemedicine service instead of going to hospital consultation?
PARTICIPANT: “For, for now, for us of now mas prepared ko pa rin siya kasi aahhh kasi ahhh
ngaun kasi hinde naman, nandun pa din yun anu eh.”

INTERVIEWER: Worry?

PARTICIPANT: worry, lalo na pag ospital na ang pinag uusapan parang merong, meron na
parang meron na kasi.

INTERVIEWER: Fear?

PARTICIPANT: oo fear, ganun or parang minsan napa praning tayo kasi ayaw ko pumunta ng
ospital kasi meron naman naman ibang way, yun anu nga yun teleconsult or so yun ahhhhh mas
prepared ko pa din siya.

INTERVIEWER: So parang na provide ng telemedicine ang pangangailangan nyo po?

PARTICIPANT: ah oo, actually kasi

INTERVIEWER: Ah pag dating sa cater po?


132
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: oo, kasi anu naman kasi sa teleconsult or sa telemedicine kasi is naka video call,
so anu parang doctor kung anu man tatanungin yun like actual anu din ang question ng nasa
walk in or nasa ospital mismo and then for example nagkaroon ka tonsillitis or kati sa lalamunan
yun ganun, yun camera itatapat mo lang so ayun naman so far is base naman din yun sa video is
nakita naman nila yun, yung kung anu yun sakit talaga ng tao, siguro yun ang difference nila na
actual is sympre for example heartbeat yun kailangan nila kunin yn lang talaga ng pagkakaiba
nila pero in terms naman dun sa talagang ipapa- consult mo is ok naman na naaanu din nila yun
sakit.

INTERVIEWER: So ahhh, additional po diyan maam. Based on your experienced po, What are
the struggles you encounter during your consultation po?

PARTICIPANT: Actually ahhh parang wala naman siguro anu lang that time kasi yun signal kasi
siguro sa internet diba nga thru anu tnruu aahh.

INTERVIEWER: Online po?

PARTICIPANT: online lang yun so yun, yun lang naman pero hindi naman ganun ka struggles
kasi parang bumabalik naman agad ganun, actually pag ganun nga pag nawawala sila mismo
tumatawag, tinatawagan uli kunwari naputol yun line so tinatawagan ka nila hindi yun parang
maaanu ka na tatawagan ba ako, ganun so tinatawagan ka nila, binabalikan ka nila and then at
the same time diba for example diba nag anu sila ng reseta ng gamot, and then dapat ay 7 days
mo dapat ittatake minsan ahhh kinakamusta ka nila after 7 days kung kamusta na yun patient or
anu may progress ba? So yun nga and lahat ng documents na kailangan mo like resita, medical
certificate, ini email nila after mo mag request or after ng consultation.

INTERVIEWER: Ah ok po,during your consultation maam. What do you consider the advantage
of telemedicine ?
PARTICIPANT: ang advantage po gaya nga ng sinabi ko kanina ayun nga convenient and then
save ng money and then yun nga yun komportable yun comfort nung tao na yun or yung
patient and then yun nga ang pinaka pina talaga purpose ng telemedicine during that time is
not to spread yun covid 19.

INTERVIEWER: So kung papipiliin kayo maam ang mas prepared ninyo pa din ay yun
telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: yes for me


133
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: So maam, What would you suggest to improve telemedicine for future uses?

PARTICIPANT: based kasi sa experience ko so far wala pa ako ano, wala pa ako ahhh
masusuggest at marerecomend na improvements maliban lang dun sa internet connection
hinde ko kasi alam kung kami ba or sila yun may problema pero, ayu nga na kahit na ganun
agad agad naman kami binabalikan so yun, so far wala ako recommendations, siguro isa pa,
siguro anu na lang sana mas marami doctor na available and yun oras nila sana mas convenient
yun anu nila availability and yun nga sa oras ng schedule nila.

INTERVIEWER: So ma'am overall experience po kung mas komportable nyo po gamitin?

PARTICIPANT: Yes, actually doon pa lang sa biyahe minsan dun pa lang kasi na stress ka na eh.

INTERVIEWER: So ayun po yun nagiging barriers ninyo maam kay pinili nyo po ang
telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: actually anu eh, hindi ah before i know ayun nga may sakit nga nag spread nag
worry talaga ako paano mag papa check up buti na lang may telemedicine na nirecocomend or
nabanggit na teleconsult na lang instead of pumunta pa ng ospital kasi nga nakakatakot yun
time na yun. Actually, kahit naman ngayon kasi lalo ngayon diba dumadami yun case ngayon ng
covid 19 so for me its ahh mas prepared ko pa din yun telemedicine kasi mas ok naman siya.

INTERVIEWER: ahh in some point po ang telemedicine ay pwede ma recommend sa mga


kaibigan nyo po?

PARTICIPANT: yes actually, after kung gamitin everytime na meron nagkakasakit or meron may
gusto mag pa check up, kasi minsan may mga praning na ubo sipon pa ng lang ganun diba, sabi
why not to try yun teleconsult kasi ayun ok siya gamitin convenient talaga sya at makaka save
kapa ng pamasahe kasi diba hindi muna kailangan pumunta so ang kailangan mo na lang gawin
download yun apps `hahanapin mo lang kung anu yung nararamdaman mo, like nandun naman
yung mga choices sobrang friendly use naman yun apps nila and then yun din titingin ka lang
ng mga doctors na available then yun araw, yun time, ganun, tinitry din nila actually yun
teleconsult or yun telemedicine and that time ko lang nalaman na may ganyan pala eh. Pero di
ko lang sure noong wala pang covid meron ng teleconsult pero ayun very convenient, and very
helpful very effective.

INTERVIEWER: Ok po maam maraming salamat po maam sa lahat po ng pinag usapan natin ito
po maging pribado po so kami lang po ang nakakaalam ng pinag usapan natin so ang purpose
po ng ginawa natin interview is a reference lang po sa thesis namin so maraming salamat po ulit
134
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

maam, at salamat po sa inyo pagpapa unlak.

PARTICIPANT: thank you din, goodluck sa research nyo.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po.

INTERVIEW #7

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, sir. I am Danielle Anne de Leon. These are my groupmates po: Ms.
Aira Dominguez, Mr. Ireneo Desquitado, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Joanna Bren De Leon, and Ms.
Aivee De La Cruz po, third year nursing students po kami from University of Perpetual Help
Laguna. So, andito po kami para mag-conduct ng interview para sa research naming entitled
“The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During the COVID-19 Pandemic.” So,
ask ko lang po kung puwede kayong ma-interview po, sir?

PARTICIPANT: Ok po.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po. Pwede rin po ba naming i-record/video ang conversation natin,
mam?

PARTICIPANT: Sure.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po. Based po sa experience niyo po, ano po ba yung mga views niyo
on Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: based on my experience po, madali lang po maaccess ang telemedicine lalo napo
sa mga student or sa mga minor cases lang po na sakit, pwede po sya maccess through
appstore or apple store idodownload po so sobrang easy lang po para po mapabilis po yung
paggaling ng isang pasyente po.

INTERVIEWER: Ano pong apps ang ginamit nyo

PARTICIPANT: Konsulta MD po.

INTERVIEWER: Why did you choose this telemedicine service among others?
135
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: So nakita ko lang yung telemedicine through online and then I tried it po since
kailangan ko din po ng mabilis na gamutan nung time na yun and sarado na din po yung mga
clinic near sa house namin po, so parang nagtry lang po ako ng telemedicine para po makabili
na agad ng gamot. Sobrang less hassle since wala din kayong babayaran.

INTERVIEWER: Can you tell me about your experience with telemedicine during the CoVid-19
pandemic?

PARTICIPANT: So ang telemedicine po during covid 19 pandemic is sobrang accessible nya po


dahil po di mo na po kailangan lumabas pa para magpacheck up and ang mga clinic po kasi dito
malapit samin ay kailangan pa ng appointment and before po, hinddi po alam ng parents ko yun
since matanda na din po sila so kapag lalabas po sobrang hassle po para sa kanila , kaya po nag
try po kami ng telemedicine para po mas mapadali po yung pagpapacheck up ng lola ko po or
ng mga tita ko po or tito ko na may sakit po.

INTERVIEWER: Based on your experience, what are the struggles you encountered during the
consultation?

PARTICIPANT:So ang number 1 problem po is internet po, since mabagal yung internet may
possibility po na mag-lag yung call or mamatay yung call during consultation po. So that time
po, nagpaconsult po ko and mabagal po yung internet so medyo chappy po yung doctor na
nagcoconsult. Inuulit naman po nila if ever may question po kayo or may hindi kayo
naintindihan.

INTERVIEWER: During your consultation, what would you consider the advantages of
telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: During my consultation po, sobrang laking advantage po na meron silang reseta
na pinipresent and sinisend po sa inyo through pdf na din po sya and isesend po nila through
telemedicine din po. And then, idodownload mo na lang po yun and then ipapakita mo po sya
since ang mga mercury drugs and other drug store po, di po sila nagbebenta ng gamot ng wala
pong reseta. So, kailangan po ng reseta and sobrang laking advantage po na may pinipresent
ang telemedicine na reseta para po sa kung ano man pong gamot na para sa inyo.

INTERVIEWER: Were your medical needs fully met by the telemedicine service you availed?

PARTICIPANT: Naprovide naman po nila yung help na kailangan namin. Natutuwa po ko dahil
madali lang po syang iaccess,snce idodownload mo lang po sya and magwawait lang po kayo
136
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

ng doctor na available para po macheck up kayo at makausap kayo, mabigyan po kayo ng reseta
na pwede po kayong makabili gamot.

INTERVIEWER: Would you still use telemedicine services instead of going to an actual clinic or
hospital for consultation?

PARTICIPANT: Yes po, kasi po as a student po mas madaling magcontact sa mga telemedicine
since wala po kaming time para po magpacheckup dahil ang klase po namin eh simula morning
until afternoon which is sarado na po yung mga clinic.

INTERVIEWER: What are your suggestions to improve telemedicine for future use in the field of
healthcare.

PARTICIPANT: Isa lang po masusuggest ko para po sa improvement ng telemedicine, dahil ang


internet dito sa pilipinas ay di naman po ganon kabilis so ang masusuggest ko po ay sana may
offline din po ang telemedicine para po sa mga Filipino na walang pong pang internet or walang
internet sa bahay.

INTERVIEWER: That’s all of my questions po, sir, thank you po for your time.

PARTICIPANT: Okay, thank you.

INTERVIEW #8

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, mam. I am Danielle Anne de Leon. These are my groupmates po:
Ms. Aira Dominguez, Mr. Ireneo Desquitado, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Joanna Bren De Leon, and
Ms. Aivee De La Cruz po, third year nursing students po kami from University of Perpetual Help
Laguna. So, andito po kami para mag-conduct ng interview para sa research naming entitled
“The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During the COVID-19 Pandemic.” So,
ask ko lang po kung puwede kayong ma-interview po, sir?

PARTICIPANT: Opo.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po. Pwede rin po ba naming i-record/video ang conversation natin,
mam?

PARTICIPANT: pwede po.


137
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po. Based po sa experience niyo po, ano po ba yung mga views niyo
on Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: For me napakaconvenient nya since hindi mo na kailangan lumabas ng bahay


and di mo na din kailangan pumila ng napkahaba, tapos di mo na din kailangan gumastos ng
pamasahe papuntang hospital. Tapos napaka accessible nya pa since kailangan mo lang is
cellphone and internet para makapag appointment sa doctor mo and kahit nasan ka man pwede
mong makausap yung doctor mo and consult about your health.

INTERVIEWER: Why did you choose this telemedicine service among others?

PARTICIPANT: pinili ko yung Konsulta MD since madali syang gamitin and super accessible sila
kase 24/7, pwede kang magconsult sa kanila and then pwede ka din magpadeliver ng mga
medicines.

INTERVIEWER: Can you tell me about your experience with telemedicine during the CoVid-19
pandemic.

PARTICIPANT: During Covid-19 pandemic, napakalaking tulong sakin ng telemedicine kase nga
di na ko kailangan lumabas pa ng bahay tapos napakadali nya lang gamitin, click click ka lang
and then, sagutan mo lang yung mga tanong sayo ng doctor mo kung ano yung masakit sayo.

INTERVIEWER: Based on your experience, what are the struggles you encountered during the
consultation?

PARTICIPANT: siguro yung struggle lang sa online consultation is yung pag eexplain ng kung
anong masakit sayo, kung gaano kasakit di ba kasi inaano nila yung pain level, kunware sa
sakit ng ipin, tatanungin ka nila unlike pag sa personal makikita nila through your actions and
machecheck up talaga ng masinsinan yung katawan mo.

INTERVIEWER: During your consultation, what would you consider the advantages of
telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: For me, yung advantage ng telemedicine talaga is yung convenience and safety
since di mo na lumabas ng bahay, tapos di mo na kailangan humarap sa napakahabang pila,
tapos accessible pa sya anytime and anywhere you are.

INTERVIEWER: Were your medical needs fully met by the telemedicine service you availed?

PARTICIPANT: For me, maayos naman nilang naprovide yung mga medical care na kailangan
ko since nadiagnose naman nila kung ano yung sakit ko and nabigay naman nila yung mga
medicines or mga kailangan kong gawin para gumaling ako. And yon, gumaling naman ako.
138
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: Would you still opt for telemedicine services instead of going to an actual clinic
or hospital for consultation?

PARTICIPANT:For me, mas prefer ko pa rin magpacheck up sa actual clinic or hospital kahit
napaka convenient ng telemedicine kasi for me, mas malalaman ng doctor kung paano ka ida-
diagnose eh kapag sa actual, tsaka minsan kasi pag through online lang, mahihirapan kang na i
identify yung masakit sa yo unlike sa in person i guguide ka talaga ng doctor kung paano mo i
identify yung mga masasakit sa katawan mo.

INTERVIEWER: What are your suggestions to improve telemedicine for future use in the field of
healthcare?

PARTICIPANT:yung suggestions ko lang is sana mas maguide pa nila ng mas mabuti yung mga
patients nila and sana mas dumami pa yung mga telemedicines, para mas madami pang
makakagamit.

INTERVIEWER: That’s all of my questions po, mam, thank you po for your time.

PARTICIPANT: Okay, thank you.

INTERVIEW #9

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, ma’am. My name is Nicky Dapitin. These are my groupmates po:
Ms. Aira Dominguez, Mr. Ireneo Desquitado, Ms.Joanna Bren de Leon, Ms. Danielle Anne De
Leon, and Ms. Aivee De La Cruz po. We are third year nursing students po kami from University
of Perpetual Help Laguna. So, andito po kami para magconduct ng interview para po sa
research naming na entitled “The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During
the Covid-19 Pandemic.” So, ask ko lang po kung pwede kayong mainterview po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: Sure, .

INTERVIEWER: Pwede rin po ba namin i-record ang conversation natin po, ma’am?

PARTICIPANT: Of course, no problem.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po, ma’am. So based po sa experience niyo, ano po ba ang mga views
niyo sa Telemedicine?
139
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: Telemedicine has been very helpful in providing a platform for doctor-patient
interaction, saving time and resources to conduct regular consultations, especially during peak
Covid-19 pandemic.

INTERVIEWER: Why did you choose this telemedicine service among others?

PARTICIPANT: I chose telemedicine service at the time mainly because it was during peak
Covid-19 pandemic, as visiting hospitals were very risky and unsafe... to avoid physical contact
essentially, that's why.

INTERVIEWER: Can you tell me about your experience with telemedicine during the Covid-19
pandemic?

PARTICIPANT: I only did schedule for a consultation twice at the time. Creating an account and
filling in details such as payment method were fairly straightforward. Scheduling for a
consultation and all the following bits and pieces only took a matter of a few minutes, though I
needed to set up a third-party software to use as a platform for the on-call consultation.
Schedule confirmation and payment validation through the doctor-secretary were also
necessary prior to the doctor-patient meet.

INTERVIEWER: Based on your experience, what are the struggles you encountered during
the consultation?

PARTICIPANT: It was certainly the noise in the audio during the video call that made the
communication process difficult. I was having a hard time understanding my doctor's
instructions and other explanations regarding my case because of her broken audio... most
likely caused by her unstable internet connection.

INTERVIEWER: During your consultation, what would you consider the advantanges of
telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: Well, of course, it's time-saving as consultations can be done anytime...


anywhere.

Ease of transactions as payment through my health card was done swiftly in just a few clicks of
a button

Generally, in my opinion, telemedicine is very advantageous for people who wants to save time
for a regular check up, maybe just a one-time consultation for the most common diseases... and
for patients looking for, perhaps, a particular doctor in a specific field that is maybe unavailable
near the patient's location... to consult about an uncommon case.

INTERVIEW #10
140
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

INTERVIEWER: Good day po, mam. I am Aira Dominguez . These are my groupmates po: Mr.
Ireneo Desquitado, Mr. Nicky Dapitin, Ms. Joanna Bren De Leon, Ms. Danielle Anne De Leon,
and Ms. Aivee De La Cruz po, third year nursing students po kami from University of Perpetual
Help Laguna. So, andito po kami para mag-conduct ng interview para sa research naming
entitled “The Lived Experiences of Patients who used Telemedicine During the COVID-19
Pandemic.” So, ask ko lang po kung puwede kayong ma-interview po, sir?

PARTICIPANT: sure no problem.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po. Pwede rin po ba naming i-record/video ang conversation natin,
mam?

PARTICIPANT: yes.

INTERVIEWER: Thank you po. Based po sa experience niyo po, ano po ba yung mga views niyo
on Telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: telemedicine? Uhmm malaking tulong sya actually nun pandemic lalo na bawal
lumabas kase mataas yun cases ng covid. Gamit na gamit sya nun pandemic dahil no choice
tayo kundi magpa online consultantation diba? Lahat naman ay nag benefit.

INTERVIEWER: Why did you choose this telemedicine service among others?

PARTICIPANT: pinili ko ang telemedicine kase takot din ako mahawaan ng covid and sa bahay
lang naman hindi mo na need mag travel ng ilang minutes or hours para lang makapunta ka ng
hospital unlike pag nasa bahay ka chill kalang hihintayin mo nalang yun doctor mo pumasok sa
zoom link na binigay sayo.

INTERVIEWER: Can you tell me about your experience with telemedicine during
the Covid-19 pandemic?

PARTICIPANT: ayun nga tulad ng sabi ko kanina mas nakaka save ako ng time, super helpful at
napakadali nya lang gamitin basta may maayos ka signal para tuloy tuloy yun interview sayo.

INTERVIEWER: during your consultation nyo po satisfy po ba kayo or nabigay naman po yun
needs nyo?
141
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

PARTICIPANT: actually yes imagine online consultation pero ginawa padin nila yun best para
mabigay yun need or maccess yun nararamdaman namin.

INTERVIEWER: Based on your experience, what are the struggles you encountered during the
consultation?

PARTICIPANT: siguro yun laboratories and assessment kase nga nasa bahay lang paano
magagawa yun mga laboratories and assement na need para masure kung tama bayun
diagnose sayo ng doctor so far yun lang naman. Kase that time abdominal pain yun pinaconsult
ko

INTERVIEWER: During your consultation, what would you consider the advantanges of
telemedicine?

PARTICIPANT: malaki nasasave na time and hindi mo na need lumabas/ pumunta hospital para
pumila ng napakahaba para magpacheck up and very accesible sya sa lahat ng gadgets basta
may wifi ka.
INTERVIEWER: Would you still opt for telemedicine services instead of going to an actual clinic
or hospital for consultation?

PARTICIPANT: for me yes lalo na busy person ako wala na ako time para pumunta hospital para
magpacheck not unless need talaga need or very emergency cases kase pag online consultation
anywhere pwede mo makausap sila for consultation.

INTERVIEWER: ahh okay po mam, how about your payment naman po mam thru gcash or bank
transfer po?

PARTICIPANT: thru bank transfer para mabilis.

INTERVIEWER: Okay, po. I think yun lang po, ma’am. Thank you po for your time.

PARTICIPANT: Alright, Thank you.


142
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

CURICULLUM VITAE
143
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING
144
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING
145
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING
146
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING
147
UNIVERSITY OF PERPETUAL HELP- DR. JOSE G. TAMAYO MEDICAL UNIVERSITY
Sto. Niño, City of Biñan, Laguna

COLLEGE OF NURSING

You might also like