Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Elijah Decoteau - Asl Template
Elijah Decoteau - Asl Template
2022-2023
AnnotatedSourceList
Crownhart,C.(2023,January4).What'snextforbatteries.MITTechnologyReview.
https://www.technologyreview.com/2023/01/04/1066141/whats-next-for-batteries/
Thisarticleoverviewssomeadvancementsinbatterytechnologyandhowtheycouldshape
thefutureofelectricvehicles.Climatelegislationinmanycountriesispushingtheautomotive
industrytowardselectricvehicles,makingbatterytechnologyanimportantfocusofcarcompanies
today.Mostelectricvehiclestodayarepoweredbylithiumionbatteries,butchangingtime,
capacity,andtheneedforrarematerialslikecobaltandlithiumarepushingcompaniestoinvestin
newtechnologies.Solidstatebatteriesuseasolidelectrolytematerialinsteadoftheliquid
electrolyteusedinlithiumbatteries,allowingthemtobemorecompact,safer,andhaveshorter
chargingtimes.However,thistechnologyisstillindevelopmentandwon’tbeusedinvehiclesany
earlierthan2025.Sodiumionbatterieshaveasimilardesigntolithiumionbatteriesbutusemuch
cheapersodiummetalintheirproduction,althoughtheymightnotbeabletodeliverthenecessary
powerforelectricvehicles.Iron-airbatteriesuseacompletelydifferentprocesstostoreand
releaseelectricalenergy,buttheyareonlypreferableinstationarypowerstorage.Whilethereare
lotsofrisingcompetitors,lithiumionbatterytechnologyisstillimprovingwiththingslikelithium
ironphosphatecathodesandreplacinggraphitewithsiliconforionstorage.Toaccompanythe
increaseinEVsandtheneedformorebatteries,morebatteryrecyclingcentersaresettoopenin
thenearfuture.
Thisarticleprovideslotsofinformationonemergingtechnologiesinthebatterysector.
Thisisusefulforresearcherstryingtodeterminethefutureviabilityofbatterypoweredvehiclesor
compareittoothervehicletypes.Thissourceiscrediblebecauseithaslinkstoallofitssources.
Dubey,L.,Speirs,J.,Balcombe,P.,Tariq,N.,Brandon,N.,&Hawkes,A.(2023).Futureuseofnatural
gasundertighteningclimatetargets.Futures,150(103158).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.futures.2023.103158
Thisjournalanalyzesthemeritsofnaturalgasandhowitislikelytobeusedinthefuture.
Whilefutureuseofnaturalgasislimitedbyclimategoals,therearestillmanyincentivestouseit.
Naturalgasisinexpensive,abundant,easytotransport,hasahighenergydensity,andproduces
lessairpollutantsthanotherfossilfuels.Theseadvantageswilllikelymakeitprominentinthe
futureduetotheshortcomingsofcarbonneutralfuelslikehydrogenandbiomethane.However,it
isstillafossilfuel,meaningitproducesmethaneduringitsproductionandcarbonemissionswhen
itisburned.Theauthorsofthisjournalpredictthatnaturalgasusewillcontinuebutatadeclining
rateduetoclimategoals.Although,insomescenarios,naturalgasusewillincreasetomeetrising
energydemands.Inorderfornaturalgastoremainrelevant,theremustbeadvancementsincarbon
capturetechnologytooffsetitsemissions.Advancementsinotherfieldslikehydrogen,electric
vehicles,andrenewableenergywillalsopushnaturalgasoutoffavor.Overall,mostfuture
scenariosshownaturalgasusedroppingforavarietyofreasons,andanimprovementincarbon
capturetechnologyisnecessaryforitsviabilityandsustainabilityinthefuture.
Thisjournalarticleprovidesanindepthanalysisofpossiblefutureusesofnaturalgas,
whichwillproveusefultoresearcherstryingtodeterminethefutureviabilityofnaturalgasor
compareittootherfuelsources.Otherarticlesbytheauthorsandsourceslistedattheendcanalso
beusedtofurtherresearch.Thisjournalisverycrediblebecausealltheauthorsareexperiencedin
thisfieldandalloftheirsourcescitedattheend.
Fenske,J.(2021,June2).Thebigproblemwithsyntheticfuels[Video].Youtube.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0d0MPg7DxbY
Inthisvideo,JasonFensketalksaboutsomeofthedisadvantagesofsyntheticfuel,
showingthatitisnotacarbonneutralsolutiontoallautomotiveindustry’sproblems.Asynthetic
fuelisanyfuelcreated100%byhumansandnotpulledfromanynaturalsource.Whileburning
fossilfuelsbringsmoreCO2 fromundergroundintotheatmosphere,syntheticfuelstakecarbon
fromtheatmosphereinproductiontooffsettheemissions,makingthemcarbonneutral.An
advantageofsyntheticfuelsisthattheycanbemadeidenticaltogasoline,havethesamehigh
energydensitythathydrogen,batteries,andotherrenewablesourcescannotevencomecloseto.
Thismakessyntheticfuelagreatoptionforlongrangeneedslikeshippingandaviation.However,
thereareseveraldisadvantagesthatneedtobeconsidered.Syntheticfuelsmustbemadewith
cleanrenewableenergyinordertohaveanyadvantageoverfossilfuels.Thisisnotthecasewith
electricvehiclesduetotheirmuchhigherefficiency.Electricbatteriesandmotorsretain40-70%
oftheenergyputintothem,butsyntheticfuelproductionandcombustionisalong,andexpensive,
processthatonlyallows6-18%oftheenergyputintobeactuallydeliveredtothewheels.While
Frenskeagreesthatsyntheticfuelisstillthebestoptionforhighenergydensityapplications,he
believesitshighcostandlowefficiencywillmakeitdifficulttojustifyfutureuse.
Thisvideoprovideslotsofinformationontheadvantagesanddisadvantagesofsynthetic
fuels,andwillbeveryusefultoresearchersdoinganextensivestudyonthistopic.Italso
comparessyntheticfuelstoothercompetingrenewableenergysourceslikehydrogenand
batteries,whichisveryusefultoresearcherstryingtocomparegasolinealternatives.Thissourceis
verycredibleasitsauthorhasabachelor’sinmechanicalengineeringandhelinksallofhis
sources.
Fenske,J.(2022,March4).Americawaswrongaboutethanol-studyshows[Video].Youtube.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F-yDKeya4SU
Thisvideoarguesthatcornbasedethanolisnottheperfectcarbonneutralalternativeto
gasolinethatcongressmadeitouttobe.Ethanolcanbeaddedtogasolinetoimproveoctaneand
reduceemissions;mostgasolinecontains10%cornbasedethanol.In2005,Congresscreatedthe
renewablefuelstandardaftertheyfoundthatcornbasedethanolhada21%reductionin
greenhousegasemissionscomparedtogasoline.Therationalebehindthisiscorntakescarbon
dioxideoutoftheatmosphere,thenthecarputsitbackintotheatmosphere,creatingaclosed
cyclewithnonewcarbonadded,makingitcarbonneutral.However,inastudyfromUniversityof
Wisconsin-Madison,TylerLarkstatesthatcornbasedethanolcreates24%greateremissionsthan
gasoline.Farmingequipment,processingofthecorn,andtransportationofthecornallcontribute
tothehighemissions.Centuriesofstoredcarbonarealsoreleasedintotheatmosphereduringthe
preparationoffieldssuchascuttingtreesandplowing.Whilethisisonlyaonetimereleaseof
carbon,ittakes14yearsfortheethanolproducedtomitigateenoughemissionstobreakeven,and
somesourcessaymorethan30yearsarerequired.Theamountofcarbonreleasedfrommodifying
thelandissohighitnullifiesanyadvantageinclimateimpactaccordingtoCynthiaGilesina
Harvardstudy.Ethanolfromothersources,suchasswitchgrass,couldbemadewithfewer
emissionsandhaveamuchshorterbreakevenpoint.
Thisvideopresentsanargumentwithsubstantialevidenceagainsttheuseofcornbased
ethanol,whichcouldproveusefulforresearchersevaluatingtheeffectivenessofthistypeof
biofuel.Therearemanysourceslinkedandthereisinformationaboutothersourcesofethanol,
bothofwhichcanbeusedtoresearchfurtherintothissubject.Thissourceisverycredibleasthe
creatorhasabachelor'sdegreeinmechanicalengineeringandlistsallhissourcesinthe
descriptionofthevideo.
Fenske,J.(2023,December18).[Videoconferenceinterviewbytheauthor].
Itisverydifficulttoaccuratelypredicthowtheautomotiveindustrywillchangeinthe
future,butitissafetoassumethatelectricvehicleswillbecomeveryprominent,withthe
possibilityofhydrogenhavingnicheusesaswell.TheinterviewbeganwithMr.Fenske
explaininghowhegotinterestedincarsasachildandhowittransitionedintohimmaking
automotiveyoutubevideos.Mysecondquestionwashowheenvisionedcarsinthefuturedueto
tighteninglegislationandemergingtechnology.Hestatedthatitwasveryhardtopredict,buthe
believedthat“therewillbealongbutveryrealtransitiontomoresustainableoptions,andIthink
thatelectricvehicleswillbetheoverallwinnersintheendofallthat.”Hedoesnotbelievethat
combustionengineswillbegoneanytimesoonduetotheaveragelifespanofcombustionvehicles
andhownewtheanti-combustionlegislationis.AftertellingMr.Fenskethatmyresearchhad
shownthatelectricityandhydrogenwerethemostpromisingalternativestogasoline,heagreed
thathydrogenisbetterforapplicationslikeairplanesandshipsduetoitslowerweightandhigher
range,butnotedthathydrogenhasmorechallengeswithitsinfrastructureandproduction
efficiencyandbelievedthatelectricitywouldwinoutinmostapplications.Thefinalquestionwas
whatcantheaveragepersondotohelppushautomobilesintherightdirection,andhesaidthere
aretheroutesoflegislation,“tryingtofigureoutrulesandlawsthatcanbenefitusall
collectively,”andthescientificrouteofmakinggoodengineeringsolutionssuchascheaperor
moreefficientvehicles.Thesemethodsallowonepersontohavemuchmoreimpactonothersthan
justbuyinganelectriccarforthemselves.
Thisinterviewprovidedanexpertviewofwhattheautomotiveindustrycouldlooklikein
thefuture,whichisusefulforthosetryingtojustifytheirclaimsaboutfuturetechnologies.There
isalsoinformationaboutwhattheaveragepersoncandotohelpinthiscrisis,greatinformation
forresearcherstryingtodeterminehowpeoplecanhavethemostimpactontheclimatechange
crisis.ThissourceiscrediblebecauseJasonFenskehasabachelor’sdegreeinmechanical
engineering.
Hossenfelder,S.(2023,January14).Hydrogenwillnotsaveus.Here'swhy.[Video].Youtube.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zklo4Z1SqkE
Thisvideodiscusseshowalthoughhydrogenisapromisingfuelfromthefuture,thereare
stillmanyhurdlesthatitneedstoovercometoreachwidespreaduse.ItstartswithSabine
Hossenfelderexplainingthathydrogengeneratesenergybyreactingwithoxygentoproduceheat,
withwaterbeingtheonlybyproduct.Storinghydrogenisverydifficultduetohowmuchspaceit
takesupasagas.Whilehydrogenfuelcellshaveexistedsince1839,theyhavefoundlittleuse
outsideofNASAspacecraftduetothedifficultiesofstoringhydrogen.Despitethat,many
companies,likeGreenHydrogenInternational,andgovernmentassociations,liketheEU,have
ambitiousplanstoproducemuchmorehydrogenandhydrogenpoweredvehicles.Hossenfelder
arguesthatalargeproblemfacinghydrogenishowitisproduced.Therearemultipledifferent
methodsofproducinghydrogen,witheachmethodbeingreferredtoacertain“color”ofhydrogen.
Eachonehasadifferentflawthatstopsthemfrombeingwidelyused:Whitehydrogenoccurs
naturallyandisextremelyrare;black,brown,gray,andbluehydrogenareproducedfromfossil
fuelsandemitgreenhousegassesduringproduction;andgreenandpinkhydrogenaremadefrom
climatefriendlyresourcesbutareexpensiveandrequirefreshwater,whichisnotavailable
everywhere.Evenifhydrogenwasreadilyavailable,therearestillproblemswithfuelcells,such
astheirinabilitytofunctioninlowtemperaturesandtherare,expensivemetalsrequiredtomake
them.
Thisvideocontainslotsofinformationregardingthestrengthsandweaknessesof
hydrogen,beingveryhelpfulforresearchersquestioningtheviabilityofthetechnology.Thetopics
mentionedinthevideo,suchasthecolorsofhydrogen,andthesourcesinthedescription,likethe
studyonbluehydrogen,arealsogreatstartingpointsformoreresearch.Thissourceisvery
credibleasthecreatorhasaPhDinphysicsandlistsalloftheirsources.
InstituteforEnergyResearch.Environmentalimpactsoflithium-ionbatteries.(2023,May11).
https://www.instituteforenergyresearch.org/renewable/environmental-impacts-of-lithium-ion-batte
ries/
ThearticlebeginsbystatingthatelectricvehiclesarebeingpushedupontheAmerican
publicduetotheirperceptionofproducinglessgreenhousegassesthanelectricvehicles.However,
thelithiumionbatteriesthatpowermostelectricvehicleshaveissuesrelatedtorecyclingand
greenhousegasemissionsfromminingandproduction.Lithiumionbatteryproductioncreates
morecarbondioxideemissionthangasolineproduction,and40%oftheseemissionscomefrom
theminingandprocessingphase.Thisphasetakesalargeamountofenergy,mostofwhichis
generatedbycoalpowerplantsinChina,theleadingproducerofelectricvehiclebatteries.
Disposalofusedbatteriesisalsoanissue,astheypollutelandfillswithtoxinsandheavymetals
thatcontaminatetheenvironmentandcauselandfillfiresthatcanburnnonstopforyears.While
governmentsarepassingrulestomandatebatteryrecycling,currentlyonly5%oflithiumbatteries
arerecycled,andduetotheprocessbeingveryhazardousanddifficult,itisusuallycheaperto
purchasemoremineralsandmakeanewbattery.Themethodsofmininglithiumarealsovery
damagingtotheenvironment.Brine-extractioniswhenlargeamountsofwaterarepumped
underground,forcingthemineralstothesurface.Thisprocesscancontaminatethewatersupply
andtakesahugeamountofwater,asmuchas60%,fromthelocalsupply,manyofwhichare
runninglowalreadyinlithiumrichareasliketheAndesmountains.Othermineralsinlithiumion
batteriesalsohaveissuesrelatingtotheirmining,suchascobaltminesproducingsulfuricacidand
usingchildlabor.Inconclusion,lithiumionbatteriesareveryenergyintensiveduringproduction,
difficulttorecycle,andcancauseenvironmentalhazardsinlandfills.Whilethisnewtechnology
mayseemperfectonthesurface,thereareamultitudeofissuesplaguingit.
Thiswebsitecontainslotsofinformationonthenegativesoflithiumionbatteries,whichis
veryusefulforresearcherstryingtodeterminetheviabilityofelectricvehiclesorcompareitto
othertechnologies.Thissourceiscrediblebecausetheauthorslinktheirsourcesthroughoutthe
article.
Leachman,J.(2017,March17).Sojusthowdangerousishydrogenfuel?WashingtonStateUniversity.
https://hydrogen.wsu.edu/2017/03/17/so-just-how-dangerous-is-hydrogen-fuel/
Forvariousreasons,hydrogenisnowherenearasdangerousasmanybelieve.Thisarticle
startswiththeauthorexplaininghowpeoplereactwhentheylearnheworksonhydrogenfuel.
ManycomparehisworktoexplosionsortheHindenburg,notknowingthatithadahigherquality
sistershipGrafZeppelinthatwasmuchsaferandflewforover10years.Hisworkalsogets
comparedtotheChallengershuttle,butthatdisasterwascausedbyano-ring.NASAhasdone
manyteststodeterminethesafetyofhydrogen.Whenliquidhydrogentankswereruptured,the
fluidusuallyescapedwithoutignition.Ifignitiondidoccur,thefireballdissipatedquicklydueto
hydrogen’shighflamespeedandlowdensity.Insimilartests,thegasolineflamestayedcloserto
thecontainerandcausedmuchmoredamage.When.50caliberroundswerefiredathydrogenand
kerosene(aviationfuel)tanks,resultsfromearlierexperimentswereconfirmed:hydrogenissafer
thanaviationfuelincertainaerospaceapplications.Theseexperimentspavedthewayforbulk
hydrogentransportsrunningonU.S.highwaysforover50years.Similartestsbytransportation
companyAirProducts,theUKHealthandSafetyLaboratory,theU.S.Military,andTheNational
HighwayTransportationandSafetyAdministrationallconfirmtheseresults.Asshownbythe
manytestsonthesubject,hydrogen’sresistancetoignitingandlowdensitymakeitdifficultto
explodeandcausesthefueltodisperserapidly,makingsuffocationandprolongedflamesvery
unlikely.InToyota’stests,theirpressurizedcarbonfibertanksrefusedtoigniteafterbeingshot,
anddidn’tevenruptureinavehiclecollision.In2017,thereweremorethan25,000fuelcell
forkliftsand7000fuelcellvehiclesontheroad,withnolargeproblemstoreport.Thismakes
hydrogenevensaferthanlithiumionbatteries,asdamagingonecellcancauseanothertocatchfire
orexplode,resultinginvehicleinfernosthatcanburnfordayswhileproducingtoxicfumes.In
manycaseshydrogenislessdangerousthangasoline,batteries,andotherfuels.However,itisstill
veryflammableandhaslowignitionenergy,sostoringandhandlingitproperlyisrequired.
Thissourceprovidesindepthreasonswhyhydrogenisnotasdangerousasmanybelieve
andsupportsitsargumentswithcrediblesourcesandamultitudeofconductedtests.Thissource
wouldbeextremelyusefultoresearchersjustifyingtheuseofhydrogenbycomparingitssafetyto
otherfuelsources.Thissourceisverycrediblebecausetheauthorisaprofessorattheschoolof
mechanicalandmaterialsengineeringatWashingtonStateUniversity,hasaPh.D.inmechanical
engineering,andlinkstheirsourcesinthearticle.
LePan,N.(2020,May19).6wayshydrogenandfuelcellscanhelptransitiontocleanenergy.Visual
Capitalist.
https://www.visualcapitalist.com/6-ways-hydrogen-and-fuel-cells-can-help-transition-to-clean-ene
rgy/
Thisarticlehighlightsthemanyadvantageshydrogenhaswhenusedtopowervehicles.
Whilemostelectricvehiclesusebatteriestosupplytheirpower,hydrogencanalsobeusedforthis
purpose.InordertoabidebytheUN’sCOP21Parisagreement,theworldmustreduce
energy-relatedcarbondioxideemissionsby60%by2050,andhydrogeniswellsuitedtoallow
thattohappen.Hydrogenissaferthanfossilfuelsbecauseitdispersesquicklyintheair,produces
lowradiantheat,islesscombustiblethangasoline,anddoesnotproducetoxicemissions.Ithas
alsobeeninuseforover50years,sotherearemanyindustrieswithexperienceonhowtosafely
manufacture,transport,andusehydrogen.Therearemanydifferentwaysofproducinghydrogen,
anditcanevenbemadefromwater,ensuringthattheworld’shydrogensupplywillneverrunout.
Hydrogenvehiclesalsoproducesignificantlylessemissionsduringmanufacturingandfuel
productionthanbatteryelectricvehicles,oneofitsmaincompetitors.Whilebothbatteryand
hydrogenelectricvehiclesproducezeroemissions,havehighefficiency,andareveryquiet,there
areafewdifferencesbetweenthem:Batteryvehicleshavealowoperationalcost,aresustainable
cityvehicles,havelowinitialinfrastructurecosts,andhavethehighestefficiencywhentakinginto
accountfuelproduction.Hydrogenvehiclescandrivefurther,canberefueledfaster,andhaslower
longterminfrastructurecosts.Oneofthebiggestadvantagesforhydrogenvehiclesistheir
significantlydecreasedweightwhencomparedtobatteryvehicles.Globally,countriesareplanning
tobuildover2800hydrogenrefuelingstationsby2025,andwithgrowingmarketacceptancein
manydifferentvehicletypes,thefutureofhydrogenisverypromising.
Thissourceprovideslotsofreasonswhyhydrogenisbetterthanbatteriesforpowering
electricvehicles,whichcanbeusedtoprovehydrogen’susefulnessinthefutureorcompareitto
otherpowersourceslikebatteries.Thissourceiscrediblebecausetheauthorlinkstoalloftheir
sourcesinthetext.
Lindwall,C.(2023,November17).Electricvs.gascars:IsitcheapertodriveanEV?NaturalResources
DefenseCouncil.https://www.nrdc.org/stories/electric-vs-gas-cars-it-cheaper-drive-ev
Thisarticleexplainsthat,inmostcases,anelectricvehiclewillbecheaperthanagasoline
vehicleinthelongrun.TheaveragepriceofanEVdecreasedby$14,300overtheyearof2023
accordingtoCoxAutomotive.Pricesareexpectedtocontinuetodropinthefutureascompanies
investinthetechnology.TaxincentivesliketheU.S.federaltaxcredit,andstatetaxincentivescan
shavethousandsofdollarsoffthepriceofelectricvehiclesaslongastheymeetmanufacturing
requirements.HomechargersalsocontributetothelongtermcostofanEV;althoughtheyusually
costaround$2000,itisaonetimepurchaseandmanygovernmentsandutilitycompanieshave
programstocoversomeofthecosts.Electricityhasamajoradvantageovergasolinewhenit
comestorefuelingcosts,wherea2018studybytheUniversityofMichigan’sTransportation
ResearchInstitutefoundthattheaverageyearlycosttofuelanelectricvehiclewas$485,whilethe
averageforgasolinewas$1117.MorerecentstudiesbyConsumerReportsandEnergyInnovation
haveconfirmedcostsavingsofrefuelingelectricvehicles.ThisismainlyduetothefactthatEVs
aremanytimesmoreefficientattravelingamilethangasolinevehicles,accordingtotheU.S.
departmentofEnergy.However,calculatingcostsavingsisnotthatsimple.Theactualefficiency
ofEVsvariesfromvehicletovehicle,impactinghowmuchonewouldneedtospendtochargeit.
Installingahomechargerincreasesone’selectricitybill,andtheamountitincreasesdependson
whereandwhenitisbeingcharged.Charginginareaswithexcesselectricityandchargingatnight
whendemandislowcanlowercostssignificantly.Astudyfrom2020calculatedthatEVownersin
Washingtonstatecansaveasmuchas$14,480overthelifetimeoftheirvehicle,whileEVowners
inHawaiishouldexpecttheirexpensestobe$2,494morethanagasolinevehicleover15years.
Publicchargingstationsalsotendtobemoreexpensivethanhomecharging,whichcancontribute
torisingcostsovertime.Asformaintenance,electricvehiclesusuallycosthalfasmuchto
maintainthangasolinevehicles.Theauthorstatesthatonecancalculatetheirlifetimecostsby
combiningtheinitialpurchasepricewithongoingcostslikemaintenanceandrecharging.Overall,
theybelievethatwhileitisn’tguaranteed,onecansavemoneyoverthewholelifetimeoftheirEV,
andsparetheEarthintheprocess.
Thissourceprovidesinsightastohowthelongtermcostsofelectricvehiclescompareto
gasolineones,whichisusefultoresearchersaimingtopitchelectricvehiclesasasuperior
alternativetogasolineorotherfuelsources.Thissourceiscrediblebecausetheauthorhaslinksto
theirsourcesinthetext.
Nikolaidis,P.,&Poullikkas,A.(2017).Acomparativeoverviewofhydrogenproductionprocesses.
RenewableandSustainableEnergyReviews,67,597-611.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.rser.2016.09.044
Inthisscholarlyarticle,theauthorsdiscussthecommonmethodsofhydrogenproduction
anddeterminesteamreformingandgasificationtobethemostpromisingforfutureuse.Hydrogen
iscarbonfreeandhighlycombustible,givingitamuchhigherenergycontentthanallfossilfuels
andothersourceslikebatteries.Itcanbestoredasaliquid,gas,orsolid,anditscombustiononly
emitswater,makinghydrogenaveryappealingfuelsourceforthefuture.However,thejournal
articleproposesthatthemainissuepreventinghydrogen’swidespreaduseisproduction.Pure
hydrogenisexceedinglyrareinnature,soscientistshavedevelopedmanydifferentmethodsof
producingit.Hydrogencanbeproducedbyremovingcarbonfromfossilfuelsinprocessessuchas
steamreformingandpartialoxidation.Thesemethodsofproductionarecurrentlythemost
commonandcosteffective,buttheyrelyonfossilfuelsandwillcreatecarbonemissionsunless
anotherviablesourceofhydrocarbonsisfound.Hydrogencanalsobeharvestedfrombiomass
usingtechniquessuchasgasification,combustion,pyrolysis,andliquefaction.Thismethodis
promisingduetoitseconomicviabilityandlackofdependenceonfossilfuels.Bacteriacanalso
beusedtoproducehydrogeninbio-photolysisanddarkfermentation.Theauthorsbelieve
biologicalmethodsarepromisingbutwillrequiremuchmoreresearch.Lastly,watercanbesplit
intohydrogenusingelectricityinelectrolysisorheatinthermolysis.Whilewatersplittinghasthe
potentialtobecompletelyzeroemissions,itiscurrentlyovershadowedbyothertechnologiesthat
areefficient,anditwillnotlikelybethemainmethodofproductionunlesscarbontaxesare
enforcedandmoreresearchisdoneintothearea.Overall,NikolaidisandPoullikkasbelievethat
steamreformationandgasificationarethemostpromisingmethodsofhydrogenproductionforthe
futureduetotheirenergyandcostefficiency.
Thisjournalarticleprovideslotsofvaluableinformationonthemethodsofhydrogen
production,howtheywork,andtheiradvantagesanddisadvantages.Thisjournalwouldbevery
helpfultosomeoneresearchingtheviabilityofhydrogenasafuelsource.Itisverycredibleasthe
authorslistalloftheirsourcesattheendofthearticle,whichcanalsobeusedtoaidfurther
research.
St.John,A.(2023,August1).Mostcarsstillcostmoretochargethantofillupwithgas—whenyoutake
otherexpenseslikehomechargingandfeesintoaccount.BusinessInsider.
https://www.businessinsider.com/ev-charging-cost-versus-gas-car-truck-suv-2023-7
Thoughitvariesdependingonlocationandvehicle,inmostcasesrecharginganelectric
vehiclewillcostmorethanrefuelingacomparablegasolinevehicle.Manyelectricvehiclesstill
costmoretorechargethangasolinevehiclescosttorefuel.Mostpickuptruckscostthesameto
refuelandcharge,whileentryandmidlevelvehiclescostmoretocharge(within-homeand
publicchargers).Luxuryvehiclesfallsomewhereinbetweenthetwo.Thisinformationcamefrom
a2020studyfromtheAndersonEconomicGroup.Thisstudylookedataveragegasandelectricity
prices,buttheyalsoincludedchargerinstallationcosts,EVregistrationfees,andtimespent
drivingtoandwaitingatarecharging/refuelingstation.TheaverageEVstillcosts$5000more
thantheaveragegasolinevehicle,andthisdisparitymustbereducedtoincreasetheamountof
EVspurchased.Chargingcostsarealsoveryimportant,andtheychangedependingonthevehicle.
Truckscostaboutthesametorechargeandrefuelwhenconsideringregistrationfeesandcharger
installationcosts,butthatisonlywhenusinghomecharging.Publicchargerscost48%more,
changingtheaveragecosttochargeper100milesfrom$17.70to$26.38.Refuelingelectricentry
levelvehiclesandSUVscostabout3dollarsmoreper100milesthancomparablegasoline
vehicles.Usingpublicchargingstationsfurtherincreasestheprice,makingthemcost16-64%
more.Refuelingluxuryvehiclesactuallycosts$4lessper100milesthanacomparablegasoline
vehicle,butonlyiftheyareusinghomechargerstosave23%.Usingpublicchargersmakesthe
priceaboutthesameasgasoline.FormidlevelcarsandSUVs,rechargingonlycosts1$moreper
100milesthanrefueling,butthiscostsaddsupovertime.Ifpublicchargersareused,thedisparity
growsto$4.00.
Thissourcelistsstatisticsontherefuelingandrechargingcostsofvehiclesinthesame
sector.Thisinformationisusefultoresearcherstryingtocomparethepriceofelectricvehiclesto
gasolineorotheralternatives.Thissourceiscrediblebecauseitlinkstothestudyreferenced
throughoutthearticle.
Tabuchi,H.,&Plumer,B.(2021,March2).Howgreenareelectricvehicles?TheNewYorkTimes.
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/03/02/climate/electric-vehicles-environment.html#:~:text=Broadly
%20speaking%2C%20most%20electric%20cars,up%20those%20plug%2Din%20vehicles.
Thisonlinenewsarticleexplainshowelectricvehicles,whileoftencitedasthegreen
vehiclesofthefuture,stillhavemanyhurdlestoovercomebeforetheycantrulyclaimthattitle.
Electricvehiclescannotbezeroemissionsuntiltheirproductionandchargingisdonewithoutthe
useoffossilfuels.TheU.S.powergridcurrentlyusesamixofrenewablesandfossilfuelsto
generateelectricity,makingelectricvehiclesgreenerthanconventionalvehiclesandhybrids,but
notemissionsfree.However,inareasoftheU.S.thatgetthemajorityoftheirpowerfromfossil
fuels,electricvehiclesareworsefortheenvironmentthanhybridsduetotheemissionsproduced
bythepowergrid.Anotherhurdleforelectricvehiclesisthematerialsrequiredtomakethem.
Miningcobalt,lithium,andotherrareearthmetalsisdamagingtotheenvironmentandthepeople
workinginthemines,withcarcompaniesmakingstepstowardethicallyminedcobaltorremoving
itfrombatteriesentirely.Newbatteriescanalsobemadefromoldrecycledones,buttheprocessis
longandonly5%oflithiumionbatteriesarerecycled.
Thisarticleprovideslotsofinformationontheareasofimprovementforelectricvehicles,
whichisveryhelpfulforresearcherstryingtoconstructanargumentfororagainstelectricity
whencomparedtoothervehicletypes.Thecredibilityofthisarticlecomesfromthesourcesthat
theauthorsembedded,whichcanalsobeusedtoresearchmoreindepthaboutelectricvehicles
andemissions.
U.S.DepartmentofEnergy.(n.d.).Alternativefuelsandadvancedvehicles.https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/
ThiswebpagefromtheofficialwebsiteoftheU.S.DepartmentofEnergylistsmany
alternativefuelsthatarecurrentlyavailableorindevelopmenttobeusedinsteadofgasolineor
diesel.Alternativeinternalcombustionfuelsincludenaturalgasand propane,whichboastlower
costsand/oremissionsthangasoline.Therearealsoplantbasedfuelslikeethanolandbiodiesel
thatarealmostcompletelycarbonneutral.Otherfuelslikerenewabledieselandgasolineare
capableofnetzeroemissionsbuthavemuchhighercosts.Sustainableaviationfuelsaremixed
withstandardfueltoreducenetcarbonemissionsfromaircraft.Therearealsopowersourcesthat
donotutilizeinternalcombustion.Electricvehiclesusebatteriesandmotorstostoreanddeliver
powercompletelyfreeofanyemissions.Similarly,hydrogenfuelcellsusechemicalreactionsto
turnhydrogendirectlyintoelectricity.Bothofthesehavethepotentialtobecompletelyzero
emissionsbutareexpensivetoproduce.
Thiswebsiteisveryhelpfulforresearchintoalternativevehiclefuels.Itprovidesalistof
topicsthatgiveabasicunderstandingofavarietyofoptions.Thesetopicscanalsobeusedas
promptstoaidinfurtherresearch.ThissourceiscrediblebecauseitwasmadebytheU.S.
DepartmentofEnergy,anofficialgovernmentagency.
Yowell,G.(2022,September6).Howdoesthecostofhydrogenstackupagainstgasoline?Stillwater
Associates.
https://stillwaterassociates.com/how-does-the-cost-of-hydrogen-stack-up-against-gasoline/
Hydrogenfuelismoreexpensivethangasoline,evenwhenfactoringinitshigher
efficiency.Oneofthechallengesfacinghydrogenfuelcellvehiclesistheirhighfuelcost.With1
kilogramofhydrogenbeingroughlyequivalentto1gallonofgasoline,highgaspricesover
$4/gallonarenothingcomparedtotheaverage$14/kgpriceofhydrogeninCalifornia.Thehigh
efficiencyoffuelcellvehiclesiswhatkeepsrefuelingcostscompetitive,astheactualpriceofthe
fuelismuchhigher.In2022,theEPAstatedthattheaveragefueleconomyofafuelcellvehicle
was60milesperkilogram,comparedtotheaverage30milespergallonforgasolineand42for
hybrids.Whilethisseemslikeanadvantageforhydrogen,itshigherpricemeansthathydrogen
fuelcellvehiclesaretwotimesmoreexpensivepermilethangasolineandthreetimesmorethan
hybrids.Inordertoremaincompetitive,hydrogenneedstoretailat$5.88/kg;however,theaverage
pricewas$16.50/kgthatyear.TheCaliforniaAirResourcesBoardestimatesthatthepriceswill
decreaseovertheyears,comparingittoafuelwithsimilarproperties,compressednaturalgas.
Thissourcehasstatisticsthatshowhowmuchhydrogencostsrelativetogasolineandhow
thisaffectsitscompetitivenessinthevehiclemarket.Thissourceisusefulforresearcherstryingto
justifyorargueagainsthydrogenuseinvehicles.Thissourceiscrediblebecausetheauthorlinks
theirsources.