Professional Documents
Culture Documents
PD in Acute Kidney Injury
PD in Acute Kidney Injury
PD in Acute Kidney Injury
A High
1
(strong) B Moderate
Strength of Quality of
Recommendation Evidence C Low
2
(weak) D Very Low
Which PD fluid should be used in Acute PD? What to do when it is not available?
Intervention HVPD vs daily HVPD vs daily High vs low Intensive vs Minimal Tidal APD vs
HD EHD intensity PD Standard CVVHDF
Population 120 143 61 75 125
Ventilated 68% vs 75% 83% vs 87% 68% vs 72% 87% vs 89% 62% vs 69%
APACHE II 26.9 vs 24.1 27.5 vs 26.7 26.4 vs 24.8 26.9 vs 25.7 21.1 vs 21.3
PD Catheter Flexible (TK) Flexible (TK) Flexible (TK) Flexible (TK) Flexible (TK)
PD Technique Automated Automated Automated Manual Open Automated PD
Homechoice Homechoice Homechoice System, single bag 70% TV,
Cycler Cycler Cycler Biocompatible
Weekly Kt/V 3.6 vs 47 (p <0.01) NR 4.13 vs 3 (p=0.03) 3.3 vs 2.25 (p=0.01) NR
UF (L) 2.1 vs 2.4 (p=0.39) 0.6 vs 1.44 (p <0.01) 2.4 vs 2.1 (p=0.42) 1st: 1.55 vs 0.05 (p <0.01) 0.95 vs 1.39
2nd: 2.1 vs 0.9 (p <0.01)
30 Day 58% vs 53% 63.9% vs 63.4% 55% vs 53% 79% vs 63% 30.2% vs 53.2%
Mortality (p=0.48) (p=0.94) (p=0.42) (p=0.13) (p <0.01)
Renal Recovery 83% vs 77% 93.5% vs 90.3% 86% vs 86% 97.4% vs 91.7% 60.3% vs 35.5%
(p=0.84) at 30 (p=0.23) (p=0.64) at 30 (p=0.29) at 90 days (p <0.01)
days days
There is little or no difference between PD and
extracorporeal therapy for treating AKI
Cochrane review of six trials and 484 patients with AKI treated with
PD compared with patients treated with extracorporeal therapies
(HD, extended daily HD, or CRRT)
Survival and recovery of kidney function (moderate certainty of
evidence)
Infectious complications (low certainty of evidence)
Correction of acidosis (very low certainty of evidence)
Fluid removal (low certainty) and weekly delivered Kt/V (very
low certainty) may be higher with extracorporeal therapy
Lui L, et al, Cochrane Database System Rev
Is PD a suitable modality for treating AKI?
Which PD fluid should be used in Acute PD? What to do when it is not available?