Professional Documents
Culture Documents
IDMS Guidebook Guidebook (Digital)
IDMS Guidebook Guidebook (Digital)
Data Management
System
A GUIDE TO DISABILITY-INCLUSIVE
AND DATA-DRIVEN
LOCAL GOVERNMENT PLANNING
Inclusive
Data Management
System
A GUIDE TO DISABILITY-INCLUSIVE
AND DATA-DRIVEN
LOCAL GOVERNMENT PLANNING
ON THE COVER: Brgy. Kagawad Jesebel Ocoy of
Brgy. San Jose in Bislig City presents pivot tables
and charts they created using actual data collected
from the pilot testing of the IDMS tool.
Published by:
Center for Disaster Preparedness Foundation, Inc.
Address: B31 L19 A Bonifacio St., New Capitol Estates I, Batasan
Hills, Quezon City, Philippines
For more information please contact inquire@cdp.org.ph
Acknowledgments
T
his guide to disability-inclusive and data- Salvador, Christine Derafera, Mayfourth Luneta,
driven government planning is dedicated to Steven Paul Evangelio, Nonilon Abao,
all persons with disabilities, organizations Jamme Robles, Brian Sulicipan, Janine Maniego,
of persons with disabilities, local government Noah Loyola, and Cheryl Tagyamon.
units, civil society organizations, and government
agencies that actively participated in the We’d also like to thank the National Council
consultations we’ve conducted in four cities on Disability Affairs (NCDA), the Office of Civil
across the country. Your comments, suggestions, Defense, the Bureau of Local Government
and recommendations shaped the data collection Development (BLGD) of the Department of the
tool which we’ve primariy use for this IDMS pilot Interior and Local Government, and the Office of
implementation. Civil Defense for the guidance and helpful inputs
to our implementation of the project.
Our utmost gratitude to the Voice Philippines
for their support, without whom this project and We express our indebtedness to the City
guidebook would not have been possible. Governments of Las Piñas and Bislig City, the
officials and the people of Barangay Zapote and
Special mention to all the members of Las Piñas Ilaya in Las Piñas City, and San Jose and San
Persons with Disability Federation, Inc., led by Roque in Bislig City.
Ms. Ana Fe Maravillas, and Loving Presence
Foundation, Inc. (LPFI) in Bislig City, led by Our biggest thanks to Crispy Salilin, Danniel
Ms. Elsie Bayonla, for their invaluable support, Pagaran, Emelie Casulocan, Grace Guillena,
guidance, and tireless commitment to persons Helbert Casil, Hydie Anne Avila, Jean Modesto,
with disability in the communities they serve. Your Joan Gumpay, Julius Dave Tecson, Mark Benjie
warmest welcome and ownership of this project Porras, Meldrin Cordova, Rudy Jed Pomoy,
inspired us to continue capture all our learnings and Teresita Placer from Bislig City; and Adela
from our shared field experiences in your Yepes, John Lester Pusing, Josie Llarenas,
communities. It is an immense privilege to now Kathleen Elbo, Kenny Rey Gacosta, Leah Mae
be able to present them in the most useful and Tomazar, Marialie Gabriel, Maribeth Veluz,
meaningful way to other organizations that hope Mylene Loza, Rosita Batitis including Epifania
to collect accurate and high-quality data. We hope De Guia, Gilda Delgado, and Almario De Guia
that they find value in this book and the online from Las Piñas City, who all worked tirelessly in
training videos that come with it. collecting data and generously poured in their
ideas and recommendations in our collective
We too recognize the brilliance and creativity of attempt to gather an accurate data so that the
our collaborators in producing this guidebook disability sector may have a fighting chance to be
and the training videos: Lorna P. Victoria, Clare recognized, counted, and be accounted for.
Contents
Collecting the data and saving the form 13 Why we need data? 30
Disability-inclusive data collection tool15 Guide to Data Analysis 31
IDMS Tool: Full List of Questions17 Generating a summary sheet 32
The Washing Group Questions19 Steps on using Microsoft Excel
in data management and analysis 33
Using WGQs to identify
people with disability 19 Preparing the Data 34
IDMS GUIDEBOOK v
The common notion when conversing and 2. Being visible makes it safer for others to
tackling about disability inclusion is the lack be visible as well.
of disability data and this is attributed to the
failure of development actors to proactively Disability is far more nuanced and complicated
plan for inclusion of people with disabilities than many people may think. Their
in their programming. But this is an incorrect experiences differ and not identical in any way.
assumption. There is now a growing amount of
disability data available. However, disability is an As being visible matters, the more visibility
extremely complex phenomenon, with disability makes it safer for other disabled persons
definitions vary across contexts including to become visible. As was shared by one
variations in methodologies to measure it. As person with disability – she felt safer because
such, it is not comprehensive, often low quality she could form a sense of community and
and lacks comparability. To date, the need for belonging around being disabled.
comprehensive, high quality disability data is
an urgent priority that could bring together a 3. It makes disability a political and personal
good number of disability actors with concerted identity to be proud of.
response.
Let us remember that our identities shape us,
Claiming disability and being visible about it and disability, on the other hand, is something
challenges what we all think of, when disability to be proud of and embrace as an identity.
comes to our mind. It is important that we
understand: disability visibility matters. 4. Lastly, it challenges what people expect
Why does it matter? when they think of disability.
1. Being visible, adds to the much-needed Even for some of those who have been
representation. disabled their entire life did not use a word to
describe themselves. Claiming disability and
For persons with disabilities, some of them being visible about it, challenges what we all
understood that being disabled persons, they think of when we think of disability.
have limits that are different from their abled
peers, and that is part of their reality. In the words of one person with disability: ‘If
my visibility offers just one person a new point
By coming out as disabled persons, they of view on the disabled experience, whether
are making disability as part of who they are they’re learning something new or seeing
and offering themselves as a member of the themselves reflected for the first time, then,
persons with disabilities community. They are my efforts have been worth it.’
claiming that they want safe spaces for their
community, and they can serve as resource of
their community.
vi IDMS GUIDEBOOK
We all need to help with disability visibility and
evidence-based data on people with disabilities
at the national and global levels is very important,
to identify the challenges they face. Through this,
policy-makers can be supported to address gaps
and amend policies and regulations to ensure
disability inclusion and mainstreaming.
Ultimately, the very core message of the disability
data issue is the fact that persons with disabilities
are being left behind across key indicators in the
majority of countries. Persons with disabilities
are central to achieving the global community’s
commitment to ‘leave no one behind’, along
with policy-makers, fellow civil society
organizations and together, need to ensure that
disability inclusion is at the forefront of policy
implementation and program with disaggregation
of data by disability as essential tool to monitor
and evaluate change.
Let’s all promote disability visibility relentlessly
so that we can achieve ‘no one is left behind’.
Padayon and mabuhay!
“W
ithout accurate data, the sector Why the need for IDMS?
cannot be recognized, counted,
and accounted for.” All plans — local and national — should adhere
to fundamental laws of the land. In particular, the
Collecting accurate data of persons with 1987 Constitution provides important mandates
disabilities is an important step towards more from which these plans, public policies, and
inclusive projects and programs especially in actions must be based on:
local government units. Undertaking steps for • The State shall adopt an integrated
the sector to be seen, heard, included, and and comprehensive approach to health
empowered such as generating disaggregated development which shall endeavor to
data was one of the highlights of the National make essential goods, health, and other
Conference on Disability-Inclusive Disaster Risk social services available to all the people
Reduction and Management or NatCon in Cebu at affordable cost. There shall be priority
City in 2017. for the needs of the underprivileged, sick,
elderly, disabled, women, and children.
The IDMS or Inclusive Data Management The State shall endeavor to provide free
System for Persons with Disabilities is a system medical care to paupers (Sec. 11, Art XIII,
for collecting and analyzing data of persons 1987 Constitution)
with disabilities to involve them in the planning,
budgeting, and other development processes of • The State shall establish a special
local governments and agencies, specifically, in agency for disabled persons for their
the Local or Barangay Disaster Risk Reduction rehabilitation, self-development, and
and Management Plan. It was supported by Voice self-reliance, and their integration into the
Philippines and fully launched in September 2018. mainstream of society (Sec 13, Art. XIII,
1987 Constitution)
The Center for Disaster Preparedness (CDP)
piloted the IDMS Project in the cities of Las Pinas
and Bislig from September 2018 - March 2021.
1 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Though the sections mentioned were under Health It also defined vulnerable and marginalized
of the Article XIII, accurate data on persons with groups as those that “face higher exposure to
disability could help the national government disaster risk and poverty including, but not limited
and local government units, in a more effective to, women, children, elderly, differently-abled
formulation and management of programs for people, and ethnic minorities (Letter “oo”, Sec. 3
members of the sector. of the Definition of Terms). As such, the National
DRRM Law acknowledges persons with disability
Policies that support IDMS as active players and contributors in resilience
Other sections of the Constitution also point out building.
the responsibility of the state to guarantee active
The Magna Carta for Persons with Disability (RA
participation of the sector. These include the
7277) has been the most important legal basis for
Section 2 of Article V on Suffrage calls on the
persons with disability in the country, as it provides
Congress to “design a procedure for the disabled
a clear and comprehensive input on the rights and
and illiterates to vote without the assistance of
privileges of persons with disability. There are also
other persons”; and Section 2 of Article XIV on
existing legal instruments focused on accessibility
Education, Science and Technology, Arts, Culture
(Batas Pambansa 344), institutional mechanism
and Sports that requires the State to “provide
for persons with disability programs and services
adult citizens, the disabled, and out- of- school (RA 10070), incentives (RA 9442), and economic
youth with training in civics, vocational efficiency independence through employment and
and other skills.” opportunities (RA 10524; EO 417). The RA 7277
Moreover, the Philippine Disaster Risk Reduction has been adopted to ensure their rehabilitation,
and Management Act of 2010 (RA 10121) self-development, and self-reliance, thereby
stipulates that it is the policy of the state to achieving the necessary skills and capabilities to
“develop and strengthen the capacities of take an active part in their community.
vulnerable and marginalized groups to mitigate,
prepare for, respond to, and recover from the
effects of disasters (Letter “n” of the Sec. 2 of
State Policies).”
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 2
Despite existing laws and policies that respect, events. Ultimately, the main output of the project
protect, and fulfill the rights of people with is the establishment of a comprehensive data
disabilities in the country, as well as the national management system for persons with disabilities
declaration of the ‘Decade of Persons with at the municipal or city level.
Disabilities’ from 2013 to 2022, the disability
sector is largely ignored when it comes to Using the IDMS Guidebook
making decisions that affect their lives. Hence,
contributions must be made in strengthening This guidebook is intended for organizations, local
the sector and engaging the state to create government units, government agencies, and
channels, adhere to practices that build inherent other development actors in capturing specific
and emerging sector capacities, and enable and accurate data about persons with disabilities.
meaningful engagement in order to raise voices It is best used in conjunction with the IDMS
and be heard. Online Course available at the CDP website:
https://www.cdp.org.ph/online-courses. The online
This user-friendly manual is designed for local course features videos that guide learners on
government units to help them include people how to navigate the different tools, platforms, and
with disabilities in their decision-making, planning,
programs that are used in the IDMS. Needless to
and budgeting, particularly in disaster risk
say, you may pause, repeat, and skip parts within
reduction and management (DRRM). IDMS aims
the videos or sessions to maximize learning.
to increase the capacity of local governments
to capture specific information on persons with Download the IDMS Resource Materials through:
disabilities in their localities by collecting and http://bit.ly/idmsmaterials so you can easily follow
recording information on disability and DRRM the online lessons. It contains helpful files such as
through the use of KoboCollect, an integrated set the Primer on Barangay Development Planning,
of tools for building forms and collecting interview IDMS Tool, Lahat Handa Training Manual, sample
responses. The IDMS used the Washington exercises, pivot tables, charts, and IDMS reports,
Group of Short Set of Questions on Disability to Quality Assessment Tool, Barangay DRRM
identify persons with disabilities while gathering Plan Template, and other relevant materials and
their relevant information, needs, vulnerabilities, references to help you better understand how
and capacities before, during, and after disaster IDMS works.
3 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
To get started, we’ll look at the manpower, Reminders on mobile devices for use in
equipment, tools, and skills needed to implement data collection
IDMS:
KoboToobox is the main platform and tool that
• Android devices: Smart phones or was used in the development and design of the
tablets where the KoboCollect app will be IDMS. As such, its main data collection app, the
installed. These must be made available KoboCollect, will be the focus of this guidebook.
to enumerators who will conduct the data
collection in the barangay. KoBoCollect is available on any android device,
whether tablet or phone, as long as they run
• Enumerators: The people who are Android 2.1 or higher. Said version was released
expected to do house-to-house data on January 2010. Web forms, however, will run on
collection. Enumerators need to be any device, including Apple iOS devices, PC, or
properly trained before they go out for Mac.
fieldwork.
Recommending devices for field data collection
• Caretakers: Barangay and local is difficult due to the large number of available
government units must delegate officers devices, each with different features and
who will create, monitor, manage, and advantages. When choosing a device you need to
analyze the data using both KoboToolbox weigh the importance of:
and Microsoft Excel.
• Screen quality
• Laptop/Desktop: All offices, • Durability
organizations, agencies involved • Battery capacity
in a data collection project in IDMS • Camera (Do you need front-facing, back-
must have a computer with Microsoft facing, or both?)
Excel and internet connection. This is • Internal storage and memory
required in the storage, management, • Internal sensors (GPS, movement),
visualization, and analysis of IDMS data. connectivity options
• Planning templates and people’s (WiFi, cellular,
participation: The issues, needs, and BlueTooth),
concerns that are reflected in the IDMS • Accessibility features
data must be addressed, included, and such as voice over,
provided with budget in the plans that text-to-speech,
the barangay and LGUs are mandated dictation, etc.
to submit. Organizations of persons
with disabilities (OPDs), community- It is best if the mobile
based organizations (CBOs) or people’s device has higher RAM
organizations (POs) that are present (above 64mb) and
in the barangay can help identify the memory storage (minimum
problems that must be given priority of 32gb).
and the measures that could be done to
confront such problems.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 4
Introduction to KoboToolbox
What is KoboToolbox?
K
oBoToolbox is a suite of tools for field technology that can easily store data online
data collection for use in challenging and offline especially in areas where internet
environments. The software is free and access can be a challenge. Furthermore,
open source. Most of its users are people working since KoboToolbox allows unlimited access to
in humanitarian crises, as well as aid professionals humanitarian organizations such as CDP, there is
and researchers working in developing countries. no risk of losing data regardless of the number of
sample populations for the survey.
KoBoToolbox, developed by the Harvard
Humanitarian Initiative, is funded entirely through The technological innovation of using
generous grants and donations from partners. smartphones in data collection has started in the
Philippines just almost a decade ago.
Why KoboToolbox? In IDMS, we’ve endeavored to include persons
with disabilities and empower them to be at the
CDP has conducted several studies utilizing
forefront of data collection and analysis, even
KoboToolbox in collecting data from the field.
in areas that are geographically isolated and
It recognizes the need for a mobile-based
disadvantaged (GIDAs).
5 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
A female head of the household and her son are being
interviewed by Mr. Crispy Salilin, one of the trained enumerators
in IDMS, during the field practice in using KoboCollect in a
covered court in Brgy. Poblacion, Bislig City.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 6
How to use the KoboToolbox?
Organizations, offices, LGUs or BLGUs are the caretaker of the main KoboToolbox account.
encouraged to collaborate together in IDMS They will be in-charge of providing access to
in order to cover as many communities as the various partner organizations, barangays or
possible. Each stakeholder must assign a officials that are part of the data collection project.
caretaker who shall create and manage the At the barangay level, the barangay secretary can
organization’s KoboToolbox account. be the caretaker. In CDP’s pilot implementation,
the partner federation of persons with disabilities is
The Local Disaster Risk Reduction and
included in the KoboToolbox data collection project
Management Officer (LDRRMO) or Persons
and has their own KoboToolbox account.
with Disability Affairs Office (PDAO) shall be
1
Steps:
Create a web account 1. Go to https://kobo.
humanitarianresponse.info/ on
KoboCollect is the app that is installed on your web browser.
the android device and used for actual data
collection, while KoboToolbox is the database 2. Click SIGN UP from the menu tab.
where you can deploy and organize forms,
analyze data, generate reports, and download 3. Register an account by providing
files. the following information:
7 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Steps:
6. Once upload is successful, you will be The IDMS Tool then needs to be deployed
asked to provide the project name. We online.
recommend for you to name it: IDMS
Data Collection Tool_Name of your
LGU.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 8
Once you click the form, you will see
the following tabs:
3 1. Summary
• This tab shows the current status of
Deploy and manage your form submissions. It also shows Quick Links
to the form and data.
2. Form
Once you have deployed the form, it will be • The Form tab allows you to set the data
accessible to KoboCollect app installed in collection settings of the form. For the
android devices. IDMS Tool, you must select Online-
Offline (multiple submission). You
also have the following options for data
collection:
a. Online-Offline (multiple submission)
b. Online-Only (mutiple submissions)
c. Online-Only (single submission)
d. Embeddable web form code
e. View only
f. Android application
3. Data
• Data tab appears when submissions are
received either through the KoboCollect
app or web form.
• This tab allows you to generate visual
reports of the data collected. There is
a REPORT automatically generated by
KoboToolbox, but there is also an option
to CREATE A NEW REPORT based on
your visualization needs.
• An option to print the visual report or
save it in PDF is also available.
4. Settings
• This tab will allow you to archive or
delete the project. Deleting the project
will delete all the data collected.
9 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Aside from being proficient in using the KoboCollect app,
enumerators must also be familiar with the IDMS Tool questions
before performing data collection. The full list questions in the
IDMS tool can be found on pages 17-18.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 10
Steps in KoboCollect Installation
Keep in mind that the IDMS Tool can only be The username of said lead organization must be
accessed through the KoboCollect app once the made known to all enumerators who will be trained
form is uploaded and deployed in KoboToolbox. and will later collect IDMS data. They will need it in
The organization, agency, or office that is downloading the IDMS Tool to the KoboCollect.
leading the data collection shall deploy the IDMS
tool using their KoboToolbox account. Here are steps in installing the KoboCollect app in
your android devices:
11 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
4. In General Settings, go to Server and change the
URL to:
https://kc.humanitarianresponse.info/USERNAME
Use the username of the KoboToolbox account that
deployed the IDMS Tool.
No, no difficulty
Cannot do it at all
6. To start collecting
have difficulty hearing even if using a
hearing aid?
Even if using a hearing aid refers to dif ficulty hearing with
a hearing aid if the respondent has, and uses, that device -
NOT how hearing would be if hearing aids, or better
hearing aids, were provided to one who needed them.
No, no difficulty
Cannot do it at all
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 12
Collecting the
data and saving the form
le us in g Ko bo Co lle ct so they would
be comfortab sending accurate
Enumerators need to sa vi ng fo rm s, an d
collecting data, ese are the steps
be more efficient in To ol d atab as e. Th
e field to the Kobo
information from th
ving the forms:
for collecting and sa
1. To collect the data, you need to swipe 2. For questions with checkboxes, you may
from right to left. choose more than 1 answer.
13 IDMS GUIDEBOOK *
Important T ip
pi es of th e IDM S To ol as backup in case
uate co
ea to print out adeq
It’s always a good id g Ko bo Co lle ct in your Android de
vice.
es acce ss in
you’ll have difficulti
HH_013_Dela Cruz
5. Once you are done in collecting the 6. Change the NAME of the form. Example:
information, you will reach the last page. HH_Number_yourlastname
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 14
Disability-inclusive data collection tool
T
he IDMS Tool is a data gathering tool The IDMS Tool is currently available in English
that gathers relevant information on and Tagalog versions and is divided into the
persons with disabilities; aiding in the following sections:
identification of persons with disabilities through
the Washington Group Questions (WGQs), along Part A. Household Information
with their needs, vulnerabilities, and capacities This section collects information from the Head of
in peace time as well as in times of disaster. the Household or a representative of the Head of
This tool was developed following five regional the Household. It collects demographic data from
consultations held in Manila City, Baguio City, the household which includes the following:
Borongan in Eastern Samar, Tagum City, and
Cebu City, including eight exploratory meetings • Sex and Civil Status of the Head of
with government agencies and international Household
non-government organizations. Suggestions and • Number of families in the household
• Income and expenses of the household
recommendations from multi-stakeholders on
related to the needs of the members of the
what information must be captured were included household with disabilities
in the tool. • Washington Group Questions (WGQs)
Using the Washington Group Questions Note that in both Parts A and B, an item asking
for respondent’s Barangay is added. This is not
It is very important to be familiar with the
IDMS Tool before conducting the survey. It is an error. However, make sure to put the same
recommended to go through all the included answer in both items as this will make data
questions before proceeding with the data management later less complicated. The simple
gathering. explanation to this is that, in the file that will
be downloaded from KoboToolbox once data
Since not everyone has the same definition of collection is complete, responses to Parts B to
what disability is, and since disability has a stigma
D will appear in a separate sheet (the first sheet
attached to it, it’s critical that the questions used
to collect disability data are well-designed and includes all Household Information or Parts A,
applied.The Washington Group has created E, F, and G). This is because Parts B to D of the
comprehensive documents on how to ask the IDMS Tool, by design, are sections that duplicate
questions and interpret the results. DO NOT use based on the respondent’s answer to question
the word ‘disability’ when introducing yourself and 12.a. (number of persons with disabilities in the
the IDMS project to the respondents and when household who can/be assisted to respond to the
asking the six questions from WGQs. survey).
This includes other negative terms and phrases
that denote the same. Never change the question
or response options’ wording.
15 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Part B. Profiling of Persons with Fees and Professional Fees of Attending
Disabilities Doctors, Domestic Air and Sea Travel, and
Land Transportation Travel
This part focuses on the individual profile of the • Educational Assistance
person with disabilities. Questions include:
• Benefits from GSIS, SSS and Pag-Ibig
• Sex based on their respective charters
• Gender • Sidewalks, ramps, and railings in public
• Age/Date of Birth spaces
• Civil Status • Express Lanes
• Registration Status
• Employment Status Part E. Participation in governance
• Skills and Education The fifth part solicits information on household
• Type and Cause of Disability participation in government or non-government
• Resources needed and resources the initiated activities related to disaster risk
household member/s with disability currently reduction, government planning, emergency
have preparedness, and programming for persons with
disabilities.
Part C. Policies and Laws
This part gauges the level of awareness and Part F. Institutions
involvement of persons with disabilities in the The household’s access and frequency of
implementation of policies related to disability interaction with the following public and private
and disaster risk reduction and management. It institutions that support the needs and provide
also looks into the roles of various agencies and services to persons with disabilities are included
sectors in the effective implementation of these in this part of the tool:
laws:
• Magna Carta for Disabled Persons • Person with Disability Affairs Office/Officer
• Accessibility Law • Local Disaster Risk Reduction and
• Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Management Office (MDRRMO)
Law of the Philippines • Barangay officials
• Children’s Emergency Relief and Protection • Local health officer
Act • Non-government organizations
• Schools
• Religious organizations
Part D. Services and Benefits
Services and Benefits looks into the respondent’s Part G. Awareness on DRR and disaster
level of awareness and ease of access to basic experience
benefits and services as mandated by the law.
These benefits and services include: The last section probes respondent’s experiences
in preparing for and responding to disasters. This
• 20% Discount and Value Added Tax part seeks to assess their understanding of their
Exemption on the purchase of certain exposure to hazards, particularly for persons with
goods and services such as Lodging disabilities in the household. It also allows them to
Establishments, Restaurants, Recreation share their expertise and skills that can contribute
Centers, Purchase of Medicines and Foods to the implementation of DRRM activities.
for Special Medical Purposes, Medical and
Dental Services, Diagnostic and Laboratory
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 16
l
t i o n ( I DMS) Too
c
s i ve D a ta Colle
ty-Inclu estions
Disabili t o f Q u
Full Lis
17 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Part E. Participation in governance Part F. Institutions
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 18
a s h in g to n Group on
The W
ta t is t ic s Q u estion Sets
Dis ability S
The IDMS Technical Working Group Each question has four response categories,
recommended the integration of the Washington which are read after each question:
Group Questions (WGQs) to the IDMS tool. 1. No, no difficulty
WGQs is a standard tool used internationally 2. Yes, some difficulty
and is advocated by different disability groups. 3. Yes, a lot of difficulty
Its method of use can be easily taught to 4. Cannot do it at all
enumerators. Essentially, WGQs are used to
document the relationship between functional These questions do not outright ask respondents
limitations and inclusion.1 to identify themselves as having a ‘disability.’
Rather, an individual’s answers to the six
questions are used to define whether that
Using WGQs to identify people with
person is ‘with disability’ or ‘without disability.’3
disability Enumerators must not use the word ‘disability’
Disability is generally understood to mean ‘at or its local translations when asking the WGQs.
greater risk for limitations in participation.’ The Asking the respondents, “do you have a
six Washington Group Questions can be used disability?” must be avoided at all cost.
to collect data on functioning limitations. The
WGQs consists of the following six questions It is of vital importance that enumerators
that ask about the degree of difficulty in doing accurately capture responses in the WGQs.
activities in six basic functioning domains: These questions allow for the rapid collection and
1. Do you have difficulty seeing, even if disaggregation of population data by disability
wearing glasses? status, allowing researchers and organizations
2. Do you have difficulty hearing, even if to see whether people with disabilities are fairly
using a hearing aid? represented in all areas of society.4 However, one
3. Do you have difficulty walking or of the pitfalls in using the WGQs is not capturing
climbing steps? the real characteristics of the respondent’s
4. Do you have difficulty remembering or disability. Those who express a level of difficulty
concentrating? in the six questions must further be probed with
5. Do you have difficulty (with self-care follow-up questions to determine if there is indeed
such as) washing all over or dressing? a disability.
6. Using your usual language, do you
have difficulty communicating (for There are six universal basic activities (functions):
example understanding or being seeing, hearing, walking, self-care, cognition,
understood by others)? 2 communication that the Washington Group
Short Set on Functioning looks into to determine
whether the respondent has a disability.
19 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Individuals reporting ‘a lot of difficulty’ or ‘cannot
do at all’ to the questions should be counted as
having a disability when doing data analysis.
Categorizing Disability
The IDMS Tool integrated both the general
categorizations of disability (Physical, Sensory,
Learning Disability, Mental Disability, Multiple) and
the official government categorization of disability
based upon the recommendation of National
Council on Disability Affairs:
• Deaf/Hard of Hearing
• Intellectual Disability
• Learning Disability
• Mental Disability
• Orthopedic Disability
• Physical Disability
• Psychosocial Disability
• Speech and Language Impairment
• Visual Disability
5 Ibid.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 20
Training enumerators
for data gathering
No, no difficulty
No, no difficulty
Cannot do it at all
No, no difficulty
encouraged
Yes, some difficulty
Cannot do it at all
21 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Here are a few things to keep in
mind when selecting enumerators Here are some reminders to
and surveyors for data profiling enumerators before going to the
using android devices with the field:
KoboTool app:
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 22
Upon reaching the household, as
DOs
Conduct careful
enumerator, you must: •
translation following
guidelines on WGQs
• Cognitively test the
translated questions
1. Introduce yourself, explaining who you • Thoroughly train
interviewers to read the
are and for who you are working in a questions and response
manner that compels the participation of options as written
individuals in the survey; • Use neutral language
23 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
DONTs Humanity and Inclusion
recommends the following actions
• Use the word ‘disability’
or other negative terms when interviewing persons with
and phrases disabilities:
• Add an initial screener
question (e.g., “Do you
have a disability?”)
• Change the question • Use people- first language – for example,
or response options don’t say disabled person, but person
wording with disabilities.
Most of the enumerators selected by CDP for its pilot testing were persons with
disabilities. In so doing, it allowed them to regain their self-confidence. They
related how they felt a deep sense of fulfillment in obtaining and providing vital
information to members of the community; while the community witnessed their
capacity to help and perform when given the opportunity to be included, to be
involved, and to participate.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 24
Sample Training Design
In collecting data, enumerators are required to We recommend that enumerators be given
undergo training and sensitization with focus on enough time and opportunity to appreciate and
tool mastery so that they are better equipped understand modules on Disability Sensitization
with the necessary skills and knowledge, imbued and Disability-Inclusive DRRM, among other
with the proper temperament in interacting with things. You can also design the training according
community members. Having said that, the topics to their capacities and needs.
included in their training must be based on their Below is a sample training design that CDP
needs to boost their confidence and ability to used in training its enumerators for its pilot
capture a more nuanced and accurate data from implementation. These topics were suggested by
the community. its partner organizations of persons with disability
Prior to the training, mobile devices must be (OPDs). It took into account the experience of the
adequately charged. If enumerators will be using enumerators, their practices, and their familiarity
their own android devices (KoboCollect is not with the processes of community-based disaster
available on iOS devices), remind them to free up risk reduction and management (CBDRRM).
enough storage prior to the training and to bring
their mobile chargers.
25 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Guide for Disability-Inclusive CBDRRM
You may refer to Fostering Inclusive
Communities: A Guide to Facilitating
Disability-Inclusive Community-Based
Disaster Risk Reduction and Management,
a guide developed by CDP, in partnership with
CBM, in facilitating disability-inclusive CBDRRM.
It integrates inclusive approaches to community-
based DRRM and promotes the rights and
capacities of children, youth, older people, and
persons with disabilities.
their opinions, and do/lead particular tasks) and
The Lahat Handa manual is also made available make choices about themselves and their sectors
to learners and is included in the IDMS Resource on a long-term basis. This can be accomplished
Materials. It is based on the Community-Based
by forming and strengthening sectoral
Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Basic
Instructor’s Guide (BIG), a guidebook developed associations, implementing training programs,
and prescribed by the National Disaster Risk and developing skills.
Reduction and Management Council (NDRRMC)
The Twin Track Approach, as discussed in Lahat
for CBDRRM trainers and practitioners in the
Philippines. This manual explains why disability Handa,6 promotes the advancement of vulnerable
should be included in the CBDRRM process for individuals and groups by emphasizing the value
relevant practitioners. It also explains how to of developing an enabling environment in which
incorporate inclusive community risk assessments DRRM systems, authorities, and programming are
and inclusive planning to ensure disability inclusive and barriers to inclusion are removed.
inclusion in the CBDRRM decision-making Nondiscrimination, inclusion, and accessibility,
process, as well as the position of stakeholders,
on the other hand, ensure that everyone in the
especially representatives of organizations of
persons with disabilities, at various levels of the DRRM has an equal chance, particularly the most
Community-Based Disaster Risk Reduction and vulnerable.
Management process.
Since it incorporates the two main techniques
The Twin Track Approach of (1) making an inclusive system and (2)
To ensure that general services are accessible to empowerment, it is known as the twin-track
all, an inclusive system requires the elimination approach.
of barriers and inequalities. It allows vulnerable Both policies — promoting an inclusive system
groups to be included in a system that respects and empowering people — are needed to ensure
their rights and interests, ensures their that people with disabilities, older people, and
involvement, and responds to their needs. In an children have the same access to resources
inclusive system, they are actively engaged in and opportunities as the rest of the population.
planned operations and policies are in place to They are referred to as “twins” because they are
promote their active involvement and respond to related. Inclusion efforts could not be maintained
their unique needs. without the other.
Empowerment, on the other hand, refers to the
6 LAHAT HANDA: Inclusive Community-Based Disas-
process of improving the capacities of people with ter Risk Reduction and Management Training Manual Based on
disabilities, older people, and children to engage NDRRMC’s CBDRRM Basic Instructor’s Guide First Edition,
in DRRM activities (actively discuss and share English (2016)
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 26
Data Management
& Analysis
PDAO
LDRRMO SEC
BRGY.
Who should be the caretaker of the As the main account administrator, LDRRMO and
PDAO, can share data collection projects in each
KoboToolbox account?
barangay, office, or department that are part of
A
the IDMS project by giving access to forms and
s mentioned in the chapter on submissions in KoboToolbox. For this to happen,
KoboToolbox, it is recommended that said barangay, office, or department must also
KoboToolbox accounts be created by the each create a KoboToolbox account.
organization/office/agency that will undertake the
data collection. ‘Caretakers’ of the account must Sharing of projects between and among
also be designated, preferably from the Local stakeholders allows collaborative monitoring of
Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Office the progress of enumerators and validation of
(LDRRMO) or Persons with Disability Affairs their submissions; but more importantly, data
Office (PDAO) in the LGU, and the barangay analysis may be a shared responsibility among
secretary in the barangay level. It is best if the different agencies and stakeholders within
the caretakers to be assigned have a level of the municipality, city, or province that will promote
familiarity in working with Microsoft Excel. the inclusion of persons with disabilities in their
processes.
27 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Collaborating in a data collection project
With the LDRRMO and PDAO as the main 2. Enter the username of the agency, office,
caretaker, data collection projects can be shared barangay, and organization to be granted
to barangays, agencies, OPDs, etc. by granting access.
them varying levels of access to the form and
submissions.
BARANGAY
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 28
Managing the data on your To edit data entries, open the DATA tab in the
IDMS DATA COLLECTION PROJECT, and click
KoboToolbox account TABLE on the left. You will see two icon options
next to the checkboxes: OPEN or EDIT.
Monitor the database for: When the EDIT icon is selected, go directly to
editing the submitted form. Scroll down and
• Duplicate entries - follow-up with the go to the item that needs to be edited and
enumerator on possible duplicates click SUBMIT once you’re satisfied with your
corrections. NOTE: WHEN A RECORD IS
• Errors in responses - while the form has
DELETED IN KOBOTOOLBOX, IT CAN NEVER
restrictions to lessen possible errors in
BE RECOVERED.
the responses, it is always best to check
their responses from time to time.
Remember, once the completed form has been
submitted to the server, it enters the database
and is no longer available for editing in the
KoBoCollect app. It can only be edited via
KoboToolbox. It can be duplicated and sent again
to the database but this must be coordinated with
the caretaker for proper handling of duplicate
entries.
29 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Data Analysis and Interpretation
Understand
Identify Discover Select and Support
the
problem or useful filter IDMS public policy
community
issue information data or action
better
Disability affects the daily life of an individual We need data because we need information, but
in many different ways and IDMS hopes to these information need to be carefully selected,
enable organizations to collect and make use of filtered, analyzed, and interpreted in order for
information they need to make positive changes, them to show the realities on the ground. If done
improve outcomes, and generally help the lives of right, the results of the IDMS Data Collection will
people living with disability. make it easier for its users to pinpoint problems
and opportunities that need to be tackled for the
community’s development.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 30
Guide to Data Analysis However, if you split employability into
‘educational attainment’, ‘presence of educational
The impact of an impairment and the barriers that institutions’ and ‘livelihood opportunities’
persons with disability face can differ from city to available, you may stumble upon important
city. Even the barriers present in a large city are connections and get the answers you want.
not necessarily the same as those faced by the
same sector in a rural community. Once you have identified the specific themes you
Revisit your local plans and examine the recurring need data for, the second phase is to decide what
issues that perennially affect your community. type of data you will be needing.
What questions from the IDMS Tool are relevant
to these issues? Does your organization have The indicators you choose and the summaries
existing documents that can help you understand you generate from those indicators must satisfy
the problem further? Asking these questions is the themes you listed down in Step 1.
often a good way to start with data analysis. But
the questions you really must be asking yourself
when working with disability data are:
Employment status
• What is happening? 50
• Why is it happening?
40
Essentially, data analysis is providing answers to
these questions and supporting them with more 30
data. There are millions of ways of interpreting a
given data which makes it difficult and confusing. 20
31 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Generating a summary sheet
KoboToolbox interface allows users to generate you’ve listed down. This is the beginning of data
quick DATA SUMMARY REPORT. It also allows management and analysis. Here are the easy
you to look at relevant indicators for the themes steps in generating a summary sheet:
2 Click the form that you would like to generate a summary for.
On the Reports page in the Data tab of your project, you can create and
configure multiple summary reports with custom graphs, tables, and color
3 schemes. The custom reports are shareable by either printing, saving as a
PDF, or storing them in an external cloud service.
The Configure Report Style Feature allows you to change the graph types,
5 color scheme, and group the report by selected questions.
Click the Printer icon to print the custom report, save it as PDF, or store it in
6 an external cloud storage service, like Google Drive.
To begin, download all the data collected in the IDMS Project from DOWNLOADS in the
DATA TAB of the IDMS Data Collection Tool Project. Select XLS in the Export Types. Data can be
EXPORTED in English or Tagalog. Click EXPORT and wait for a few seconds for your file to become
available.
33 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Mistakes in the spelling or capitalization of streets, barangays, provinces, etc., during data collection
is very common, especially when covering large areas. This underscores the importance of checking,
validating, and editing submissions in the KoboToolbox by following the steps discussed on page 29.
The downloaded Excel file contains two worksheets: Household Information and Persons with
Disability Profile. Both sheets must be thoroughly checked before proceeding to data analysis.
Here are the steps in preparing your data for data analysis:
1. In your Excel file, select the first ROW that contains the headers of the
Preparing columns. These are the titles of the indicators taken from the IDMS
the Data TOOL. After selecting them, go to SORT AND FILTER in the MENU and
select FILTER.
2. Move to columns to the right so that Province, Municipality and
Barangay COLUMNS are showing on the screen. Touch the down arrow
in the HEADER of the column, and type the correct spelling of the area.
Make sure the box next to the correct name of the place you want to
correct is checked and click OK.
3. Choose the correct spelling, highlight and DRAG DROP to the very end
of the list. Do this for all barangay entries until they all show uniform
spelling. Move to the COLUMN of provinces and municipalities and do
the same.
4. After that, select all columns with NUMBER data. After selecting, an
exclamation mark will appear next to it. Click the exclamation mark
and the choices will appear. Select ‘Convert text to number’ in the
options.
5. Do this for all numbered data.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 34
After cleaning the data, PIVOT TABLES can already be created. This is the most difficult yet exciting
part of data management and analysis. Go back to the indicators you selected for data analysis based
on the themes you identified earlier on page 31. Focus on these indicators. Do the following steps in
both worksheets.
1. On the left side of COLUMN A is the SELECT ALL button. Click it to select
Creating the entire sheet.
Pivot Tables 2. Go to the INSERT MENU and select PIVOT TABLE. In other versions of
Excel it is in ‘Summarize with Pivot Table’ on the DATA TAB.
3. An option will appear to create a new spreadsheet for the Pivot Table.
Click OK.
4. In the new sheet, HEADERS from the selected spreadsheet will appear
on the right side of the screen. These are, basically, the indicators/
data gathered from IDMS.
5. HEADERS can be double-clicked or dragged into the FILTERS,
COLUMNS, ROWS, and VALUES boxes to view and display IDMS data
collection results. Try putting more than one HEADERS or INDICATORS.
6. See also different examples of PIVOT TABLES that can be generated.
35 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Using the Pivot Table, one can easily make
simple summaries from the many Pivot Table
Fields available in the IDMS Data. Just follow Tips
these steps:
If you want to get the total number of
1. Duplicate a pivot table, by selecting the respondents of a specific indicator, select
entire cells it covers. it from the Pivot Table Fields and put it
in the Values box. Drag it to either the
2. Copy and paste it in blank cells below the
columns, rows, and values to show the
copied table.
data you wish to reflect on the Pivot Table.
3. Select the new Pivot Table. The PIVOT You may do this with any indicator you
TABLE FIELD should reappear on the want to use.
right side of the screen.
To get the average value of numeric
4. Easily add or modify the indicators of a data such as age, number of persons
given Pivot Table by dragging, deleting, with specific disability type, etc., put the
and manipulating the data on the Filters, relevant indicator/header to the values.
Columns, Rows, and Values areas.
When you hover over any indicator and
5. Select an indicator from the Pivot right-click, the value field settings will
Table Fields. Indicator selected will appear. When it appears, you can choose
automatically appear in the Column field what value you want to summarize.
of the table
Please check out sample pivot tables and charts
using the data from CDP’s first field testing of the
IDMS Tool available in an Excel File included in
the IDMS Resource Materials.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 36
A single pivot table can have more than one Types of Data
indicator. An example of indicators that could
be crammed in one pivot table is Number of There are several types of data but the IDMS Tool
Respondents by Age, Sex, or Disability. By contains specific types of data: quantitative and
combining these indicators in a single pivot categorical. Quantitative data or those that show
table, organizations can easily illustrate the most numerical values, but this type of data can’t be
prevalent type of disability in a given community analyzed on its own. Categorical variables, on the
for both women and men, including the age other hand, represent types of data which may
groups where the persons with disabilities belong be divided into groups. Examples of quantitative
to. Keep in mind that pivot tables that are most data with categorical variables are sex, age
appropriate and relevant to the context of your group, and educational level. While age group
community can be created. and educational attainment can be interpreted
as numerical data, it is often more informative to
There are many indicators included in the IDMS categorize such variables into a relatively small
Tool that can help organizations see more clearly number of groups.
what’s happening in the community. Take note of
the indicators that provide compelling answers to
Quantitative data can also be considered
why certain issues exist. Check out the page 17
as cross-sectional when the data provides a
and review the full list of the questions and the
indicators available. snapshot of what the community looks like or
what is happening at a particular group at a
A sample of indicators that can be considered for given point in time. These allow you to look at
the development of Barangay, City, or Municipal
the features of your target group and explore
Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Plan
is shown on the next page. Focus on specific their relationships. An example of cross-sectional
indicators that are relevant to the thematic issues data is the status of registration for persons with
you’ve identified so far. Feel free to expand or disability ID card in Bislig City as shown below.
limit the indicators you’ll be preparing for data
analysis.
Lost ID 4
Others 6
21
20
37 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Sample Local DRRM Plan Outline Indicators from the IDMS Tool for the
development of the Local DRRM Plan
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 38
Tables and charts are a great way to make sense This table alone can inform the local health
of the hundreds of columns and rows that make office which services or assistive devices must
up the IDMS Data you’ve downloaded from the be made available to their community. They can
KoboToolbox. Below is an example of a table also reduce access barriers to health services for
showing the types of disability present in a different types of impairments included in this list.
barangay disaggregated by sex.
Grand
Type of Disability Female Male
Total
Deaf/Hard of Hearing 17 8 25
Deaf/Hard of Hearing Orthopedic Disability 1 1
Deaf/Hard of Hearing Speech and Language Impairment 1 5 6
Deaf/Hard of Hearing Speech and Language Impairment Visual 1 1
Disability
Deaf/Hard of Hearing Visual Disability 2 2
Intellectual Disability 11 11 22
Intellectual Disability Learning Disability Speech and Language 1 1
Impairment
Intellectual Disability Orthopedic Disability 1 1
Intellectual Disability Speech and Language Impairment 3 3
Learning Disability 3 4 7
Learning Disability Mental Disability 1 1
Mental Disability 5 5 10
Mental Disability Orthopedic Disability Physical Disability Speech 1 1
and Language Impairment
Needs further assessment 2 9 11
Orthopedic Disability 40 53 93
Orthopedic Disability Needs further assessment 1 1
Orthopedic Disability Speech and Language Impairment 1 1
Orthopedic Disability Speech and Language Impairment Visual 1 1
Disability Learning Disability
Orthopedic Disability Visual Disability 2 2
Physical Disability 7 8 15
Physical Disability Needs further assessment 1 1
Physical Disability Speech and Language Impairment 1 1
Physical Disability Visual Disability 1 1 2
Psychosocial Disability 7 7 14
Psychosocial Disability Needs further assessment 1 1
Speech and Language Impairment 10 9 19
Speech and Language Impairment Learning Disability 1 1
Visual Disability 13 13 26
Visual Disability Needs further assessment Deaf/Hard of Hearing 1 1
Grand Total 126 145 271
39 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Using the Pivot Tables created from both Household Information and Disability Profile
worksheets, simple charts can now be easily generated. Here’s how:
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 40
s a n d w h e n to use them
Differen t chart type
tand
at th e ID M S Da ta must help us unders
n th
ing data easier. Give e to present the data
we
Charts make analyz t ty pe of ch ar ts to us
needs, knowing wha hich interventions w
ill
what the community ory an d su bs ta nt ia tin g w
helpful in telling a st or in the community
.
chose to focus on is th e di sa bi lit y se ct
sitive impact to
most likely bring po
Bar Charts
Pie Charts
Line charts
41 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Area charts
Scatter plots
Bubble Charts
Heatmaps
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 42
u a li z a t io n of IDMS Data
s of data vis
Here example San Jose in Bislig City.
from
?
t d o e s t h e s e data tell us
Wha
40
20
Out of 974 households surveyed in Brgy. San A considerable number of persons with
Jose in Bislig City, 860 are headed by male while disability (42) have pointed out that there are
114 are headed by female. no educational facilities that are available in
the area where they could learn and maximize
their full potential; while 82 said there are public
institutions available in their area and only 11
private ones.
600
Widow
500 Single
400 Separated
300 No Response
200 Married
100 Cohabitee
DRRM-related info include respondents’
perception of their hazard exposure; and based
0
43 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Respondents were asked if they have
coordinated with PDAO, LDRRMOs,
Barangay officials, local health offices,
NGOs, schoolteachers and administrators, There are more examples of data and
and religious organizations on the needs charts with data interpretation from the
of persons with disabilities. Based on their DMS Pilot Testing Results both from Las
responses: Piñas City and Bislig City included the
IDMS Resource Materials.
• 60 of the household heads said that
coordination with the PDAO is not
applicable in their case.
• 89 responded that they have frequently
coordinated with their LDRRMO on their
needs.
• Household heads would rarely or
sometimes go to barangay officials and
local health offices to coordinate needs of
persons with disabilities.
• 70 respondents said that they never
reached out to school teachers and
administrators for students with disabilites.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 44
Analyzing the IDMS data patient’s illness could lead to illness, impairment,
or worse, death; wrong analysis of the
Make sense of the data. Look for causal community’s current situation could result to plans
relationships. Always keep in mind that analysis that do not cater to the needs or the community
is precise – each finding tells you one thing – so nor address their real and most urgent concerns.
you need to be careful not to misuse data. In the
same way that wrong diagnosis by a doctor to a Here are some of the common techniques in
analysis that you can use:
Trends
Trends can be up and down, linear or exponential,
steady or fluctuating, seasonal or random and
there can be changes at a defined rate. Check Up and down vs. Flat
out your data. Do you see apparent direction or Linear vs. Exponential
trends when looking at the data on: Steady vs. Fluctuating
• Level of knowledge about disaster? Seasonal vs. Random
• Disability type and access to services? Rate of Change vs. Steepness
• Involvement in community activities by
age?
• Household income?
Comparison
Comparisons can be based on ranking, Categorical comparison and
measurements, range, context, relationships. Do Proportions
you see a difference or similarity in data such as:
• Gender and access to services? RANKING: Big, small, medium
• Gender and knowledge about disaster? MEASUREMENTS/VALUES: Absolutes
• Family costs for disability according to Range and Distribution
types of disability? CONTEXT: Targets, forecasts, averages
Hierarchical Relationships
Patterns
45 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Here are additional guide questions that can help No. of persons with
in data analysis: Reason for unemployment
disability
• Are there any similarities or differences? Communication barrier 21
Do you see any pattern? Difficulty in daily commute/
3
transport
• Compare your data. It can be based on
time, amount, quality of data Functional limitations 40
Inaccessible workplace/s 2
• Find relationships in your data – is the Lack of education 18
type of housing of the household relevant Lack of opportunity 24
to their income? Other reason/s 32
• Trigger questions – and make sure you Personal choice 24
answer them. Refused to be allowed by
8
family to work
Indeed, there are many different ways of making
TOTAL 172
sense of data and the following techniques are
not new. Organizations do it all the time. The
most basic way of analyzing something is by There are many available indicators we could
using comparisons. Drawing comparisons can zoom into. For one, examining the capacities of
put your analysis into context, it brings in the persons with disability which are captured in the
wider picture and it becomes easier to understand IDMS Data can certainly provide stakeholders and
and appreciate what the data is telling us. The duty-bearers adequate bases which livelihood
comparisons you can do are: projects to fund or which skills training are much
needed by the sector.
• Compare your community data to the
national or regional average;
Non-technical skills No. of persons with
• Compare your results to past results, to get acquired disability
a view of how the issue/topic has changed
Auto mechanic 3
over time;
Carpentry 10
• Compare your results with other
Computer literacy 12
communities near you; and
Domestic chores 40
• Compare your results with other Driving 8
communities with similar characteristics to
your own. Tailoring 13
Electrician 4
Look at the sample table to the right showing
Plumbing 1
summary for reasons for unemployment among
persons with disability. Notice that the primary TOTAL 91
reason for unemployment in the barangay is
functional limitations, followed by the lack of
opportunity. What other indicators do you think
organizations can look into if they plan to design
and implement interventions aimed at reducing
number of the unemployed among the sector?
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 46
Analyzing data from WGQs risk of being excluded if faced with physical,
informational, attitudinal, or institutional barriers in
One of the intended purposes of WGQ is to their surrounding environment.
identify the prevalence of disability in order to
measure the inclusion of programming.8 The type This approach is based upon the social model
of disability and responses to the Washington of disability which lies at the heart of the UN
Group Questions in the IDMS Tool can be used Convention on the Rights of Persons with
to analyze the relationship between functional Disabilities (UNCRPD). The social model
limitations and inclusion by identifying if there are was groundbreaking in its view of people with
differences, say, in employment.9 disability. The model distinguishes between an
impairment (e.g., a problem of body structure
If the employment rates of people with and such as a person’s inability to move their legs)
without a disability are compared and a gap and a disability. Disability is the result of the
is found, that can be taken as evidence of interaction of the impairment and the surrounding
environmental barriers. If people of the same age, environment (e.g., unable to move her legs,
gender, area of residence, etc., who have difficulty this woman has not been able to attend school,
seeing, for example, have lower employment marry or be hired for a job because of a non-
rates than similar people with no difficulty seeing, accommodating environment). In other words,
then the conclusion is that barriers are present for disability is not the same as an impairment but
people with seeing difficulties.”10 emerges through the interaction of a person’s
While the WGQs only ask about a single aspect functional ability (which results from problems
of the social model, that is a person’s functional with body structure and function) and their
limitations, these six questions can be used in environment. People are not excluded in society
conjunction with participation measures (such because they cannot move their legs. Rather, they
as employment) to analyze the relationships are excluded because they live in an inaccessible
between individual functioning and participation environment without access to assistive devices
as affected by the environment. More importantly, and often also face discrimination.
11
B
arangays and local government units are Put simply, the BDC must lead the preparation
mandated to have a comprehensive and of Barangay Development Plan (BDP). The BDP
multi-sectoral development plan,13 and a must then be approved by the Sangguniang
harmonized planning and budgeting.14 Barangay or the legislative body in the barangay
level. It is an official document of the barangay
that specify policy options, programs, projects,
The Barangay Development Plan and activities intended to contribute towards the
achievement of the barangay’s development
The barangay is the primary planning and goals and objectives.17
implementing unit of government policies,
plans, programs, projects, and activities in Here are some of the information that must be
the community.15 As such, it must prepare, “a included in the plan:
comprehensive multi-sectoral development • Situational analysis,
plan that is formulated through an inclusive and
• Organizational philosophy,
participatory approach led by the Barangay
Development Council (BDC) and approved by the • Policy options,
Sangguniang Barangay.16 • Programs, projects, and activities,
• Implementation timelines,
13 Local Government Code, Section 106 • Resource requirements, and
14 DILG, NEDA, DBM AND DOF Joint Memorandum Cir- • Monitoring and evaluation system.
cular No. 1, Series of 2007 on Harmonization of Local Planning,
Investment Programming, Budgeting, Revenue Administration
and Expenditure Management
15 Local Government Code, Section 384
16 National Barangay Operations Office - Department of In-
terior and Local Government, Primer on Barangay Development
Planning, 2020. 17 Ibid.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 50
Inclusive planning at the barangay The BDC is mandated to formulate the BDP.
It shall include members of the Sangguniang
level
Barangay and Representative of the
Governance in the context of development Congressman with the Barangay Captain as the
planning is about upholding the interest of the chairperson (see diagram below). Barangay-
governed. As such, its primary purpose is to based non-government organizations (NGOs)
protect public interest and that of every individual shall also be part of the council, and they shall
who has a stake in the planning process. It’s constitute not less than one fourth (1/4) of the
important therefore to rationalize Barangay members of the fully organized council. This is
Development Plans (BDPs) to ensure that important to note as this ensures participation
its contents directly address the needs of the of community-based people’s organizations (i.e.
community and its residents.18 organization of persons with disability, women,
children and youth, and older persons) in
BDP processes are open to ALL stakeholders. governance and developmental process.
People from different sectors must actively
participate in these processes. They should bring By encouraging sectoral groups and NGOs to
attention to their issues and suggest priorities participate in the planning process, the current
and strategies through the help of the BDC. The planning system attempts to avoid multiplicity
BDC, on the other hand, must allow them to of plans and efficient use of resources. The
spell out the various issues that concern them. Sangguniang Barangay must accept or accredit
The representation and active involvement NGOs that will have a seat in the BDC.19
of numerous groups, especially marginalized
groups, will ensure that issues affecting
communities that cut across sectors are heard.
19 (DILG MC No. 2018-146: Accreditation of Barangay-
Based Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs) and their
Membership in the Barangay-Based Institutions (BBIs)
18 Ibid.
BARANGAY HALL
Punong Barangay
(BDC Chairperson)
All Sangguniang
Representative At least 4 NGO
Barangay SK Chairperson
of Congressman Representatives
Members
51 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
WHY WHAT
is there a need WHO HOW are the activities
for the local are involved in is the plan that will ensure the
government to planning? accomplished? implementation of the
plan? prepared plan?
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 52
Organization of Barangay The key responsibilities of the BDC-TWG in IDMS
are the following:
Development Council - Technical
Working Group • Help the BDC in data analysis and
Aside from accrediting sectoral groups or NGOs interpretation;
to be part of its BDC, the barangay can also invite • Priority issues, concerns, and needs of
sectoral representatives and organizations as persons with disabilities;
members of the Barangay Development Council • Recommend solutions to address priority
- Technical Working Group (BDC-TWG). This problems; and
is formalized by the issuance of an Executive • Monitor the implementation of programs
Order by the Punong Barangay. Formation of
and projects.
sectoral planning groups is highly recommended
to ensure that specific concerns of each of the
five Development Sectors (Economic, Social, Many tools can be used to identify priority issues.
Environment, Infrastructure, and Institutional One of such tools is the Problem-Solution
Development) are considered.20 Matrix (shown below).
In organizing the BDC-TWG, representatives of By facilitating a workshop on the Problem-
OPDs and NGOs working with the sector shall Solution Matrix, the BDC allows BDC-TWG
be convened by the barangay. An orientation members to have a deeper analysis of their
and workshop must be conducted for them to community context and situation. They are
become familiar with the processes and principles encouraged to express their needs and concerns
involved in the planning process. This will also be in their own colorful, meaningful, and realistic way.
an opportunity to level off expectations especially
Identifying projects, programs, and activities
on their roles and responsibilities with regard to
(PPAs) that will help the community, especially
the preparation and updating of BDP so they can
the persons with disabilities, will become
create work plans germane to the task at hand.
straightforward and uncomplicated. The results of
the Problem-Solution Matrix shall be one of the
barangay’s main bases for the development of its
20 National Barangay Operations Office - Department of In-
plans and budget.
terior and Local Government, Primer on Barangay Development
Planning, 2020.
Problem-Solution Matrix
53 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
How to use the Problem-Solution The BDC must meet at least once every six
Matrix months, or as required, to deliberate and
review the plan’s requirements.
1. After listing down the problems and issues
\When deciding on priorities, keep in mind
that were reflected in the IDMS Data that the Barangay Development Plan should
(including their proposed solutions), the focus on the impacts and effects that will
participants shall rate the problems and propel the community forward and further its
needs of the disability sector according to a development. It is also necessary to consider
set of criteria they’ve agreed upon. whether a development program is beneficial
to the majority of the barangay population
2. Examples of criteria are: before prioritizing it. In poverty-stricken
• Number of people to be affected (the areas, for example, PPAs such as livelihood
and anti-poverty alleviation programs are
more people to be affected, the greater
vital and important. PPAs can be classified
the importance) as follows:
• Urgency
• Urgent - initiatives that cannot be
• Barangay capacity and resources postponed and can help to alleviate
safety concerns, etc.;
3. Rate each issue 1-5, 1 being the lowest • Essential - projects that can finish
score that can be awarded, 5 being the pending ones;
highest; • Necessary - projects that must be
implemented in response to potential
4. Get the total score of each item. The ones needs;
with the highest scores are the ones to • Desirable - initiatives that could lead
prioritize. to the expansion of other services;
• Acceptable - programs that can be
5. Include in the plan (BDP, BDRRMP, etc.)
put on hold without having an impact
proposed solutions to the issues with the
on the current situation.21
highest scores; at
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 54
Barangay Development Investment On the next page is the Barangay Planning and
Budgeting Calendar for the preparation and
Program (BDIP)
submission of development plans and budget.23
As you can see, data gathering and validation
The BDP sets the priority areas of services and must be scheduled and completed by Barangay
specifies target outputs and accomplishments LGUs from August to September upon
of the barangay. It usually covers a five- assumption to office during the Situational
year period or the medium term of 3 years. Analysis and Problem Identification. However,
Furthermore, PPAs of LGUs must be consistent IDMS can be adopted and undertaken by
with AMBISYON NATIN 2040 and have a results- Barangay LGUs even after the first year of
oriented emphasis on national development the barangay officials’ assumption to office by
targets.22 including the IDMS activities and corresponding
budget in the formulation of the Annual
The Barangay Development Investment Program Investment Program (AIP).
(BDIP) is the primary tool for putting the BDP into
action. It is a document that translates the BDP Furthermore, sectoral groups, NGOs, CSOs, and
into initiatives, projects, and events, as well as POs need to identify the entry points in each step
the corresponding resource specifications, all of of the planning and budgeting process where they
which are expected to be completed within three may assist the LGU, especially in mainstreaming
(3) years. issues and concerns of the vulnerable groups. If
the Barangay Development Plans have already
Gender and Development Plan (GAD Plan), been prepared, an entry point for CSOs may be
Barangay Disaster Risk Reduction and
through the preparation of the sectoral/thematic
Management Plan (BDRRMP), Barangay Peace
and Order and Public Safety (BPOPS) Plan, plans and annual investment plan.
Barangay Anti-Drug Abuse Council (BADAC)
Plan of Action, Barangay Ecological Solid
Waste Management Plan (BESWMP), and Barangay Development Plan (BDP)
Comprehensive Barangay Youth Development
Plan are examples of sectoral plans that should Practical Vision/Strategic Directions
be included in the BDP.
Long Term (5 Years)
For many years, CDP has advocated for higher
budgetary allocations for persons with disabilities
at the local and barangay levels. As a result,
local government units have increased support
Annual Investment Program (AIP)
for investment in disability-inclusive disaster risk Priority PPAs; Major Final Output;
reduction activities.
Performance Indicators/Targets
Now, CDP continues to advocate for the same
with a strong emphasis on the collection and
Short Term (1 year)
maintenance of database where activities and
expected results to be included in plans and
budget could be derived from. Annual / Supplemental Budget
(1 year)
22 Executive Order No. 27 s. 2017, Directing all government
agencies and instrumentalities, including local government units,
to implement the Philippine Development Plan and Public Invest-
ment Program for the period 2017-2022 23 National Barangay Operations Office - Department of
Interior and Local Government, Primer on Barangay Development
Planning, 2020.
55 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Barangay Planning and Budgeting Calendar
(Upon assumption to office)
Timeline
Barangay Budgeting Process
(*occurs ever year)
JULY 1. Organization of BDC-Technical Working Group (TWG)
AUGUST -SEPTEMBER 2. Situational Analysis and Problem Identification
AUGUST 3. Formulation/Review of Barangay Vision and Mission
SEPTEMBER 4. Determination of Vision – Reality Gaps
Year 1
14. Submit detailed and itemized revenues and expenditures for the
SEPTEMBER 15*
current year by the Barangay Treasurer to the Punong Barangay
SEPTEMBER 16* 15. Prepare annual barangay budget
OCTOBER 17–NOVEMBER 16* 16. Approval of the Barangay Budget by the Sangguniang Barangay
OCTOBER* 17. Present the Annual Budget to the Barangay Assembly
OCTOBER –NOVEMBER 26*
18. Submit appropriation ordinance to the Sangguniang Panlungsod/
(within 10 days upon enactment
Bayan
of Appropriation Ordinance)
"NOVEMBER –ONWARDS*
(within 90 days upon receipt of 19. Budget Review
the Appropriation Ordinance)
20. Budget Execution
Year 3
JANUARY –DECEMBER*
21. Budget Accountability
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 56
Annual Investment Program (AIP) Budget Preparation
The AIP is the annual slice of the Barangay The Barangay Budget is a document that
Development Investment Program (BDIP). lists the costs of expenses in relation to the
It is the yearly program of expenditures both barangay’s income for a given period of time.
for capital and operating requirements of The Punong Barangay, in collaboration with
the barangay that will serve as basis for the the Barangay Treasurer and the Barangay
preparation of Annual and Supplemental Budgets. Development Council, prepares the barangay
It contains the total resource requirements for all budget, which includes: (a) revenue estimates;
PPAs consisting of the annual capital expenditure and (b) overall appropriations as proposed by
and regular operating requirements of the LGU. the Punong Barangay.24
This means, the AIP contains the specific PPAs
PPAs earlier identified in the Problem-Solution
with corresponding costs including the necessary
Matrix can be used not just for the preparation
fund flows for the timely release of funds in a
of the BDP. The BDC must also consider PPAs
year.
that could be included in the Barangay Disaster
The Punong Barangay, with the assistance of the Risk Reduction and Management Plan or
Barangay Secretary and Barangay Treasurer, will BDRRMP. Remember, all approved and ratified
prepare the AIP based on the authorized BDP. programs and projects must be adequately
financed in accordance with the law’s mandate.
Without data on the needs, issues, and concerns
of the vulnerable groups such as the persons with Each barangay are required to allocate no less
disability, there simply is no basis for the BDC than:
to identify which priority programs, projects, and
activities must be pursued to better serve their 1. Twenty percent (20%) of Internal
constituents, particularly the vulnerable sectors. Revenue Allotment (IRA) for
And without priority programs and projects, development projects as mandated
there is no basis for the programming of funds; under Section 287 of RA No. 7160;25
therefore, there is no basis for budgeting.
Preparing for Data Collection Bearing this in mind, you can now decide how
many days and how many enumerators are
As was discussed at the beginning of this guide, needed to cover the entire barangay for the IDMS
data collection requires only android devices to data collection project. If you have 10 available
collect data; but training and practice for both enumerators, for example, you can allocate six (6)
the use of gadgets and the proper approach days of data collection in a barangay with a total
in administering the data profiling tool must be of 1200 households using this formula:
conducted prior to data collection. The barangay
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 58
Making the Barangay Disaster Risk
Reduction and Management Plan
(BDRRMP) disability-inclusive
M
ore specifically, data collected can be Part of the Quality Assurance System developed
used during capacity building activities by the Local Government Academy (LGA) is a
in Community-Based Disaster Risk Simplified BDRRMP Template that could guide
Reduction and Management, particularly during barangay DRRM committees in crafting their
the Community Risk Assessments (CRA). It BDRRMPs.
can also be used to further develop certain risk
In this chapter, we’ll look at the Barangay
assessment tools, like the Elements-at-Risk tool,
Disaster Risk Reduction and Management Plan
which determines the resources, capacities,
(BDRRMP) and identify where the responses
and vulnerabilities of a community. Information
from the IDMS tool could be useful. The standard
collected from the CRA process is the foundation
tool endorsed by the Department of Interior and
of a community’s disaster risk reduction and
Local Government (DILG) that could be used to
management plans.
measure the quality of a BDRRMP is the Quality
The more comprehensive the data on persons Assessment Tool (QAT). It is mandated by the
with disability are, the more likely an LGU is able Philippine DRRM Law – RA 10121 – for use by
to produce and implement local development LGUs to enhance their plans and integrate the
and DRRM plans that cater to the specific needs concerns of women, children, older persons,
and concerns of the sector, further boosting the persons with disability, and ethnic minorities.
community’s over-all resilience and reducing its
Putting emphasis on persons with disability, the
disaster risk.
QAT focuses on nine (9) Key Elements which
contains Quality Benchmarks (QBs) with specific
sets of required Criteria and Sub-criteria that
should be reflected in the BDRRM Plan.
59 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Outline of LDRRM Plans
Local DRRM Plans are important as they are the
main document that articulates the barangay’s
vision of a safer, developed, and resilient
community. As such, it must detail the strategies
of the local government in achieving its goals
based on its susceptibility to hazards and its over-
all disaster risk.
Aside from the title, vision, mission, goals, and
objectives, here are the main sections that must
be included in the BDRRMP:
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 60
The Barangay DRRM Plan
Quality Assessment Tool
61 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
The main criterion for membership in the
barangay DRRM committee is the representation
of sectoral groups such the vulnerable
and marginalized sector, schools, faith-
based organizations, livelihood sectors, and
environmental sector. Thorough consultations
enables them to articulate their needs, issues,
and concerns better.
Active and meaningful participation of persons in the community), in the risk assessment. Part
with disabilities and other vulnerable groups G (Awareness on DRR and disaster experience)
are also given weight in the QAT. The maximum of the IDMS Tool may contain important risk
point of three points can be taken by BDRRMPs information from the community as it presents
that show involvement of children and youth, households’ perceived susceptibility to hazards,
women, pregnant and lactating mothers, persons disasters they experienced and their effects.
with disability, older persons, and indigenous
people (if there are indigenous groups present
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 62
3 Collection and use of disaggregated data in elements at risk
It is not enough that BDRRMPs contain results that will be funded by the local government
of community risk assessment (CRA) tools for disaster preparedness, prevention and
(e.g. elements at risk, seasonal calendar, etc.). mitigation, emergency response, and recovery
The maximum score can only be attained by and rehabilitation. Some examples of PPAs per
fulfilling all the sub-criteria under the section thematic area is provided on page 75. The use of
C, which includes data of the elements at risk IDMS data must not be limited by the barangay
disaggregated by age, sex, and abilities. This LGU strictly for its Barangay DRRM Plans only. It
highlights the different and varying needs of can also be the basis for other development plans
affected families and individuals depending on with much larger fund allocation. For example,
their age, sex, disability, and susceptibility to if the data shows a large number of persons
hazards. with disability from ages 18-60 years old are
unemployed, skills enhancement or livelihood
The criteria for this key element looks at how
training could be included as priority program
risk information are linked to programs, projects,
of the barangay in its BDP under the economic
and activities (PPAs) included in the BDRRMP.
development sector, which has greater fund
This is where data analysis OF IDMS data
allocation.
can be crucial in substantiating the priorities
63 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Major issues and concerns of persons with disability
4
are addressed
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 64
Persons with disability are given roles in the
5
implementation of the plan
Aside from the roles of barangay officials, and that identify the trainings received by the
local government units and agencies, the QAT members of the community (Question no. 36) on
also looks at the role that families and sectoral livelihood and trade, governance, and emergency
groups play in the implementation of the PPAs. preparedness. A thorough knowledge of the skills
The level of participation of persons with disability and capacities available for the LGU to tap can
in local governance can be gleaned from the help them assign roles to persons with disability
responses in Part E (Participation in Governance) easily.
of the IDMS tool. Part E also includes responses
65 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Part E also takes note of DRR-related experience monitoring and evaluation; hence, mechanisms
and training members of the community have must be in place so they can partake in
received in the last three years. This includes governance. After all, the Section V on the Role
coordination, information management and of Stakeholders, under Paragraph 36(a) of the
sharing, communication, evacuation, food and Sendai Framework for Disaster Risk Reduction
relief goods packaging, service delivery, and (SFDRR) 2015-2030 ‘recognizes the critical role
transportation. of persons with disabilities and their organizations
in the assessment of disaster risk, as well as the
The QAT emphasizes the potential contributions
design and implementation of plans that are in
of the sector in not only the development and
line with the principles of universal design.’
implementation of the DRRM plan, but also in its
Early warning systems in both the municipal/city the barangay and LGU in ensuring that EWS
and barangay-level can be made more accessible are appropriate for the community’s vulnerable
for persons with disability by incorporating population. Responses to the population’s main
accessible signals for the various impairments sources of disaster preparedness information
present in the community. This means that sirens (Question no. 47) can also be examined to
or auditory warnings could be paired with visual determine the channels that the barangay and
signals such as color-coded flags or any alternate LGU can take advantage of to disseminate and
accessible formats. raise awareness around how the local EWS
works.
The IDMS Tool collects detailed information
regarding the types of disability present in the
barangay (Question no. 22). This could help
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 66
Recommendations for Programs, Projects, and Activities
improvement of the plan (PPAs) per thematic area
Those are only some of the parameters that are The main aim of IDMS is to promote the inclusion
included in the Quality Assessment Tool (QAT) to of persons with disabilities in planning, budgeting,
evaluate the quality of BDRRMPs (You may refer and other development processes of local
to the full texts included in the tool from the IDMS government and agencies particularly in DRRM.
Resource Materials). LGUs are encouraged to
The collected and recorded information on
peruse the whole document and examine all the
disability and disaster risk reduction and
key elements and the criteria that go with them.
management must be highlighted in the PPAs of
List down all the key elements where your current not only the local DRRM plans, but in other local
BDRRMP scored poorly and take note of any development plans as well, given the modest 5%
recommendations that will help improve the budget allocation for local DRRM fund. Integration
BDRRMP. Use the template included in the QAT of the BDRRMP in the approved barangay
(as shown below). development plan and annual investment plan
allows the barangay in identifying other possible
sources of funds to cater to the specific needs
and concerns of the sector, thereby reinforcing
the community’s preparedness and response
capacities. Samples of PPAs per thematic area
can be found on pp. 75-82.
67 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Conclusion
We have tackled each of the steps included in We hope that this guidebook provided the users a
the IDMS process — building a KoboToolbox clear grasp of what the IDMS entails and inspired
account, using its mobile application on an among them creative ideas and strategies how it
Android device, training enumerators in data can be adopted into their own setting and context.
collection, data management, and analysis, and
integrating IDMS with LGU or barangay planning Changing the system by which any organization
— to achieve the goal of giving voice and service operates on will always be challenging. This
to the disability sector. arduous task entails collaborative efforts between
and among disability actors in a community, their
Keep in mind that your LGU or barangay will only dedication, and their conscious decision not to
be able to implement the IDMS project once the revert to the old practices which are easier and
following have been completed or are in place: convenient, but often leads to generic proposals,
inadequate budget allocations, and execution.
• The IDMS Tool has been uploaded We all must work together to make sure that
and deployed in the main KoboToolbox disaggregated data on disability are updated
account that will be used in the data regularly and that data collection, analysis, and
collection project; management is sustained (until it becomes a
common practice).
• The caretakers are confident in
managing, analyzing, and interpreting
The more we exercise steps on IDMS, the more
data using the KoboToolbox and
persons with disabilities will be given space
Microsoft Excel;
and opportunities to actively take part in our
• The KoboCollect app is installed on democracies. They must be heard and seen
android devices and the IDMS Tool is so that they are able to effectively influence
ready to use. policies and government actions that affect them,
understand their full potential, and be at forefront
• Training and lots of field practice for of the positive social changes we’d like to see in
enumerators; our society.
• Organizations that work with people with
disabilities are part of the BDC-TWG or
are accredited member of the councils in
the barangay or local government unit.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 68
Annexes IDMS and COVID-19
On March 12, 2020, President Rodrigo Duterte ordered the observation of
community quarantine in the National Capital Region (NCR) following an
increase of Coronavirus or commonly called Covid-19 cases in the region.
On March 16, this was changed into an enhanced community quarantine
(ECQ) across Luzon.
The IDMS Technical Working Group composed of The Disability-Inclusive Data Collection Form was
different DPOs agreed to create an online survey created on March 21, 2020 for the partners of the
that would assess the basic needs of persons Inclusive Data Management System managed by
with disabilities while in community quarantine. Center for Disaster Preparedness for purposes
Recognizing the difficulties of managing the of generating data on persons with disability. The
database and focusing on ease of access for data to be generated for this report will be used
target respondents, the team used Google Form by partner organizations for sharing with local
to collect the data. government to support response planning during
the Covid-19 community quarantine in Metro
Manila and nearby provinces.
Online survey results
The results of the survey can be accessed
Upon declaration of the community quarantine, through this link: http://bit.ly/idmscovidsurvey .
local government units were instructed by the
national government
to implement
measures to
address health
issues, workers
displacement,
and people’s
survival within
their respective
communities.
69 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Key results from the survey
Questions from the survey include:
showed that:
• What are the current needs of the • 36% of those who responded have
household for the persons with physical disability, while 820 of them
disabilities have multiple disabilities.
• Have you received feedback/support • The top three most needed support
from the LGUs while on community quarantine are:
1. Financial support - 2,829
2. Medicines/maintenance medicine
- 1,763
3. Therapy - 1,221
• The major effects of the lockdown to
the respondents are the following:
• Loss of income/livelihood,
Age group of persons with disability
• Inability to undergo treatment/
therapy,
• Inability to purchase medication/
205 assistive devices,
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 70
Type of Disability
Combination of disabilities*
Physical, Intellectual 172
820*
Psychosocial, Physical, Sensory, Intellectual 124
1,535
Psychosocial, Physical 121
530
Psychosocial, Intellectual 113
Physical, Sensory 89
598 736 Sensory, Intellectual 67
Psychosocial, Physical, Intellectual 48
Psychosocial, Sensory, Intellectual 28
Physical
Physical, Sensory, Intellectual 25
Multiple disabilities Psychosocial, Sensory 24
Intellectual Psychosocial, Physical, Sensory 9
Sensory Total 820
Psychosocial
3000
2500
2000
1500
1000
500
71 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
Effect of community quarantine to the households in
addressing the needs of persons with disability
Have you received support/feedback When asked if they already received support
from your LGUs? or feedback from their LGUs, more than half
of the respondents said they are yet to receive
assistance as of April 21, 2020. This is according
to respondents from over 800 municipalities/
cities all over the Philippines who had access to
the survey.
In Las Piñas, particularly, only 25% of the
1,710 Yes respondents — or 69 out of 207 — said they
have received any type of relief from their
2,510 No barangay or local government units.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 72
Lessons learned Assessing the needs of persons with
disability
The implementation of community lockdown
In any type of hazard or emergency, there
was startling for most LGUs. Communities were
poorly prepared for emergency crises such as must be tools and survey questions that are
the Covid-19 pandemic. In a country exposed to readily available to be used for rapid needs
several hazards, both human-made and natural; assessment of the sectors most vulnerable in
health crises of this magnitude are hardly talked the situation. Simple surveys that pinpoint their
about, revealing serious and harrowing realities immediate needs will provide LGUs clear grasp
beleaguering the country’s response capacity of the types of support and services they must
and management of health risks. Still, there are
provide to their most vulnerable constituents.
lessons to be picked up by different levels of
government from the experience, especially the The advantage of IDMS and the availability of
health sector. data to inform government decisions especially
in crisis situations could not be stressed enough.
In the data collected from Brgy. Ilaya in Las Piñas
City during the tool’s pilot testing, medicines,
assistive devices, and therapy are three of the
top needs of persons with disability that surfaced.
These remained true even during the community
60
50
40
30
20
10
Prosthesis/orthosis Therapy
Accessible transportation None
Medical operations Assistive devices
Personal assistant Medicines/maintenance medicine
73 IDMS GUIDEBOOK
quarantine where public transportations were They were encouraged to utilize all available data
suspended and economic activities stifled. on persons with disability such as:
As a result, the need for financial support and
accessible transportation increased making it a a. The Listahanan database of the Department
top priority during the community quarantine. of Social Welfare and Development as main
source of information of who are persons with
disabilities;
Data-informed responses
Online data collection tools have greatly helped b. The records of every LGU issuing Persons with
in acquiring data from various places especially Disability ID cards to complement the database
during the lockdown. However, access to the of Listahanan;
internet remains to be a challenge in a lot of
places in the country. Exploring other ways of c. The data of organizations of persons with
collecting data during pandemic or lockdowns disabilities, organizations of parents of children
should also be given careful consideration.
with disabilities, and organizations for persons
There are many tools for data visualization and children with disabilities to complement the
available online. They update instantaneously database of Listahanan.
as answers come in. This enables other local
government units, individuals, groups, agencies, Given the absence of reliable data to account for
or organizations have access to the data being persons with disability, basic social services are
collected for data-informed immediate responses. less likely to reach them; more so during disaster
situations.
To ensure that people who are very vulnerable
Leave no one behind are not left out, communities and local
government units must adopt a data management
Using the data collected from the quick survey system that would facilitate the accurate,
via web, CDP also launched online petition and comprehensive, and complete collection of data
sent letters to local chief executives to call for about them. It’s only through understanding our
the urgent inclusion of persons with disabilities community’s problems that we are able to see
in their COVID-19 response, in coordination with clearly how best to serve them.
several organizations working with and for the
disability sector.
The petition contained specific measures to be
undertaken by LGUs to ensure that persons with
disabilities and their households are taken into
account in the social protection measures.
IDMS GUIDEBOOK 74
Sample PPAs per thematic area lindol.
3. Magkaroon ng kasanayan ang mga response personnel kung paano tutugon sa pangangailangan ng mga tao sa
Tematikong Gawain: PAGHAHANDA (Preparedness) panahon ng disaster,
Mga Layunin: 4. Magkaroon ng kakayahan ang bawat pamilya na maging handa bago, habang, at pagkatapos ng disaster,
1. Makapaglunsad ng pagsasanay, oryentasyon, seminar, at adbokasiya upang magkaroon ng sapat na kaalaman ang 5. Makumpleto ang mga kinakailangang kagamitan (equipment at devices) para sa paghahanda, pagresponde, at
mamamayan ukol sa pag-iwas sa disaster at pagbawas sa posibleng epekto nito, pagbangon, at
2. Makapagbuo ng mga contingency plans at sistema ng maagang babala para sa iba pang panganib tulad ng bagyo at 6. Magkaroon ng updated na database at hazard map na magagamit para sa DRRM.
Budget
Programa Time Frame Responsible
Proyekto Activity Inaasahang resulta Kinakailangang Resources allocation Fund source
(per sector) agencies
(PhP)
2021 2022 2023
• Facilitator + stipend,
1. Seminar 1. Bawat miyembro ng pamilya ay may 1. Marso • Folder, bond paper, printer,
Preparedness
Barangay Alerto Kami 2. Workshop on updating early nakahandang “go bag” 2. Pebrero • Kit, laptop, LCD projector, venue, 80,000.00 BDRRM fund
committee
warning system 2. Pamilyar ang mga tao sa EWS sound system, go bag
Mga Layunin:
1. Makapagpasa ng ordinansa para sa tree planting, tree trimming, at clean-up drive,
2. Mapataas at mas mapatibay ang river wall sa Ilog San Jose, at
3. Mapaluwag at mapalalim ng mga kanal sa mga lugar na mas bulnerable sa baha
Budget
Programa Time Frame Responsible
Proyekto Activity Inaasahang resulta Kinakailangang Resources allocation Fund source
(per sector) agencies
(PhP)
2021 2022 2023
1. Nabawasan ang tsansa ng pagguho
ng lupa sa gilid ng ilog, at nabawasan • Construction workers
“Kapaligiran, ang pagpasok ng baha sa komunidad • Volunteers
Mainte- Mainte- Prevention and Municipal
Barangay Kalinisan, 1. Riprapping repair mula sa ilog √ • Construction materials 170,000
nance nance Mitigaton Committee LGU
Kaligtasan” 2. Nakakuha ng logistical support mula • Equipment
sa municipal LGU
Donations,
• Dressmaking Prevention Partner
Person with Livelihood 1. Pagiging produktibo ng mga may • Makina
• Other options based on √ √ √ 200,000 and Mitigaton NGOs,
disabilities Program kapansanan at matatanda • Trainer/volunteer
their skills Committee Disability
Fund
1. Screening residente lalo
na ang hindi residente na
papasok sa komunidad. • PPEs
1. Nagpapatuloy ang pag-obserba sa
COVID-19 Health Monitoring 2. Temperature check √ • Healt professionals/ 80,000 Committee on Health
mga health protocols (
3. Contact Tracing health workers
4. Isolation (if necessary)
Mga Layunin: 3. Epektibong mapagana ang response clusters upang mabilis at agarang makapagresponde sa panahon ng disaster at/o
1. Mabigyan ng maagang babala ang mga naninirahan sa buong komunidad sa pagdating ng bagyo at malalakas na pag- emergency
ulan;
2. Mapangasiwaan ang ligtas na paglikas ng mga tao kung kakailanganin, maayos na pamamahala sa mga evacauation
center; at
Budget
Programa Time Frame Responsible Fund
Proyekto Activity Inaasahang resulta Kinakailangang Resources allocation
(per sector) agencies source
(PhP)
2021 2022 2023
1. Reorganization/
reconstitution ng 1. May nakatoka sa bawat response cluster • Facilitator
response team o 2. Zero casualty • Food
Barangay “Ligtas Lahat Q1 30,000 BDRRMC BDRRMF
committee 3. Malinaw ang designation, task at mga function • Venue
2. Response team
orientation
Emergency
1. Nabibigyan ng mga napapanahong abiso ang mga
3. Pagbibigay babala √ √ √ • Warning devices 10,000 Response BDRRMF
mamamayan
Committee
“Hindi kita 1. Referrals for medical 1. Nabibigyang pansin ang mga magpopositibo sa • Ambulance Committee on Health
COVID19 √ √ √ 50,000
Pababayaan” attention COVID-19, kung sakali • Referral slips Health Budget
Budget
Programa Time Frame Responsible
Proyekto Activity Inaasahang resulta Kinakailangang Resources allocation Fund source
(per sector) agencies
(PhP)
2021 2022 2023
• Participants
1. Cosmetology
Livelihood for 1. Kumikita mula sa gawaing • Venue
Kababaihan 2. Manicure/ pedicure √ √ √ 30,000 GAD Desk GAD Fund
Recovery pangkabuhayan • Materials needed
3. Body massage or therapy
• Therapist
Municipal LGU
1. May kita ang mga tao na magagamit • Cleaning materials Recovery and
1. Paglilinis (Social Services
Barangay Cash for work sa pang araw-araw pagkatapos ng √ √ √ • Seedlings 200,000 Rehabilitation
2. Pagtatanim Development
mga disaster • Gardening tools committee
Department)
1. Scholarship
1. Matapos ang kanilang pag-aaral • Resource persons
Kabataan (out-of- Agapay sa pag- 2. Seminars/ training SK Fund, External
2. Madagdagan ang kaalaman para √ √ √ • Venue/food/materials 40,000 BCPC
school youth) aaral 3. Maibalik at maihanda sila support
makatulong sa kanilang kabuhayan • ALS Consultant
sa pag-aaral