Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Unit - 4 (Statistical Physics) - SEM - 2
Unit - 4 (Statistical Physics) - SEM - 2
SEM-II
Statistical Physics – Unit IV
Prof. S. B. Kondawar
Matter exists in three conventional states solid, liquid and gas. Phase transition is
most commonly used to describe transitions by various processes such as melting, freezing,
deposition, sublimation, vaporization, condensation, ionization and recombination
between solid, liquid, and gaseous states of matter and rarely in plasma (the fourth state of
matter, Fig. 1.1). The common three states of matter co-exists with each other in equilibrium
are the different phases (Fig. 1.2). All the three phases may exist in equilibrium at constant
pressure and temperature at a point, called as triple point. The point at which density of liquid
and that of the gas becomes zero at certain temperature and pressure is called as critical point.
The phenomenon at the point of critical temperature and critical pressure is called as critical
phenomenon. The transition of a matter from one phase to another which co-exist with the
first is called phase transition. Phase transitions involve a change in the mutual arrangement
of molecules and in the thermodynamic properties of the system. During a phase transition of
a given medium, certain properties of the medium change, often discontinuously, as a result
of the change of external conditions, such as temperature and pressure. Phase transitions
commonly occur in nature and are used today in many technologies.
Fig. 1.1: Phase transitions of states of matter Fig. 1.2: P-T phase diagram of three states
Two phases are said to be in equilibrium only when their temperature, pressure and
chemical potential are equal. Gibbs free energy of two phases vary with temperature and
pressure in two phases but have the same value at the point of transition of the phases as
shown in Fig. 1.3. Gibbs free energy is the function of P and T.
Phase transitions are divided into two broad categories, namely first order and second
order phase transitions. First order and second order phase transitions can be easily
distinguished from each other as given in table 1.1. Apart from isolated, simple phase
transitions, there exist transition lines as well as multicritical points, when varying external
parameters like the magnetic field or composition. Several transitions are known as infinite-
order phase transitions. They are continuous but break no symmetries. The most famous
example is the Kosterlitz–Thouless transition in the two-dimensional XY model.
Many quantum phase transitions, e.g., in two-dimensional electron gases, belong to this class.
Table 1.1:
The phase transition between two phases is The phase transition between two phases is
said to be the phase transition of first order said to be the phase transition of second
only when Gibbs free energy of the two order only when Gibbs free energy and their
phases are continuous but their derivatives first derivative of the two phases are
are discontinuous at the point of transition. continuous but the higher derivatives
(second, third, etc) are discontinuous at the
point of transition.
Examples of first order phase transitions Examples of second order phase transitions
are the phase transitions between solid, are (i) the phase transition between normal
liquid and gas fluid to superfluid, (ii) the phase transition
between conductor to superconductor, (iii)
the phase transition between ferromagnetic
to paramagnetic
Let us consider a system with two phases 1 and 2, which can exist simultaneously in
equilibrium with one another between which the phase transition takes place under the
condition given by (1) or (2);
(1)
(2)
If the temperature T and pressure P of the two phases have been changed by dT and dP in
such a way that the two phases continue to be in equilibrium in the new states, Gibbs free
energies of the two phases will obviously be equal. The new condition will be given by
equation (3).
(3)
Using Taylor series expansion up to first order, we have
Where,
(4)
Where, ;
Equation (4) gives;
(5)
be the Latent heat of transition or the heat of transition. Thus, the phase
transition of first order is accompanied by the evolution or absorption of a certain quantity of
heat.
During the phase transition of first order, Gibbs function is continuous but the first
order derivatives of Gibbs function such as, ; change discontinuously. The
continuous change of G and discontinuous change of V, S and Cp at point of transition during
the first order phase transition is shown in Fig. 2.1.
Fig. 2.1: The continuous change of G and discontinuous change of V, S and Cp at point of
transition during the first order phase transition
3. Phase transition of second order
The phase transition of second order is continuous in the sense that the state of the
system changes continuously, but the symmetry changes discontinuously at the transition
point. For example, crystal modification of BaTiO3 from cubic to tetragonal at the transition
point is an example of phase transition of second order. At high temperature BaTiO3 shows
cubic lattice, but it becomes as tetragonal as shown in Fig. 3.1 at the transition point.
During the phase transition of second order, we can show that the second order
derivatives of Gibbs function for two phases are discontinuous and first order derivatives are
continuous. Let us consider a system with two phases 1 and 2, which can exist
simultaneously in equilibrium with one another between which the phase transition takes
place under the condition given by (1) or (2);
(1)
(2)
If the temperature T and pressure P of the two phases have been changed by dT and dP in
such a way that the two phases continue to be in equilibrium in the new states, Gibbs free
energies of the two phases will obviously be equal. The new condition will be given by
equation (3).
(3)
Using Taylor series expansion up to second order, we have
(6)
We know that the function at equilibrium. If both and are finite, but the
sum of the first order term is zero, then we get;
(7)
This leads to phase transition of first order. However, when and are individually zero,
we must consider the second order term.
When and are zero at (P,T) and (P+dP, T+dT), we have
(8)
And
(9)
From (7),
This leads to
(10)
Equation (10) corresponds to the phase transition of second order. If such an equality holds,
then individually,
(11)
(12)
Thus from (11),
OR
And from (12),
OR
Where,
Hence, during phase transition of second order, second derivatives of Gibbs functions
are discontinuous at the transition point. On the other hand, during the phase transition of
second order, Gibbs function is continuous as well as the first order derivatives of Gibbs
function such as, ; change continuously. The continuous change of G, V, and
S at point of transition during the second order phase transition, but discontinuous change of
Cp and KT, where Cp and KT are specific heat at constant pressure and isothermal
compressibility.
4. Order parameters
Order parameter is defined as the measure of the degree of order across the
boundaries in a phase transition system. It has nonzero value in one phase (order phase) and
zero value in other phase (disorder phase). The zero value of order parameter is usually above
the critical point. The nonzero value of the order parameter corresponds to the unsymmetric
phase (order phase) and the zero value corresponds to the symmetric phase (disorder phase).
Thus, the order parameter takes different values in the co-existing phases and hence changes
discontinuously in the course of a phase transition. The basic idea of order parameter is that
near the critical point, it is the only important thermodynamic quantity which describes
precisely the problems of all phase transition. An example of an order parameter is the
difference of the densities in liquid-gas phase transition of first order. At low
temperature below Tc, is large (nonzero). It decreases with increase in temperature and
tends to zero at the critical temperature Tc and phase transition disappears above Tc.
Similarly, in case of a ferromagnetic system undergoing a phase transition of second order,
the order parameter is net magnetization which decreases when temperature
increases and tends to zero at Tc called as Curie temperature. Above Tc, phase transition
disappears corresponds to zero value of order parameter with symmetric phase. In the phase
transition of first order, the order parameter has discontinuous change but in phase transition
of second order, the order parameter has continuous change.
From a theoretical perspective, order parameters arise from symmetry breaking. When
this happens, one needs to introduce one or more extra variables to describe the state of the
system. For example, in the ferromagnetic phase, one must provide the net magnetization,
whose direction was spontaneously chosen when the system cooled below the Curie point.
However, note that order parameters can also be defined for non-symmetry-breaking
transitions. Some phase transitions, such as superconducting and ferromagnetic, can have
order parameters for more than one degree of freedom. In such phases, the order parameter
may take the form of a complex number, a vector, or even a tensor, the magnitude of which
goes to zero at the phase transition. There also exist dual descriptions of phase transitions in
terms of disorder parameters. These indicate the presence of line-like excitations such
as vortex- or defect lines.
And
(19)
(20)
(21)
Thus, when , the minimum of G occurs for and when , the minimum of G
occurs for
The variation of G for the two cases and are shown in Fig 5.1.
Fig. 5.1: Variation of G for the two cases and
Therefore, G above the transition point is given by
, for T
And G below the transition point is given by
, for T
(22)
Now, (23)
For T ,
(24)
And (25)
From (23),
For T ,
Therefore, the jump in specific heat at constant pressure is given by
Fig. 5.2 shows the variation of specific heat at constant pressure with T. The curve shows
the discontinuity in at T=
Fig. 5.2: Variation of with T shows the discontinuity at T=
= N+
= N-
Fig. 6.1
(for 2D square lattice)
= N+
= N-
Fig. 6.2
From (31),
(35)
Since, (36)
And
(37)
The behaviour of the number of physical properties can be described by similar power laws.
(1) Critical exponent
Specific heat at TC,
(41)
(2) Critical exponent
Density difference between liquid and gas at TC,
(42)
(3) Critical exponent
Isothermal compressibility at TC,
(43)
(4) Critical exponent
Pressure difference between liquid and gas at TC,
(44)
In most of all phase transitions, the behaviour of the system shows fluctuation in the critical
region. Fluctuations are quantified by calculating the correlation function which falls off
exponentially with the distance (x) from the critical point.
The correlation function is defined to be
(45)
Where, is called correlation length which provides a measure of distance over which
fluctuations are strongly correlated.
In critical region, it is found that the long distance behaviour of as a function of
involves a critical exponent as given by;
(46)
Where, d is the dimension of space.
The correlation length diverges as T approaches to TC with the critical exponent as;
(47)
Thus, the critical exponents namely , , , , and are found to be the same above and
below the critical temperature TC, called as critical indices or exponents.
8. Scaling Hypothesis
To reduce the independent number of critical indices, scaling laws are used in the form of
linear combination of indices. All six critical indices are connected by scaling laws which are
given by;
(48)
(49)
(50)
(51)
These scaling laws are initially showing inequalities but with some assumption made them
equalities called as scaling hypothesis. With this hypothesis only two of the six critical
indices must be independent and others must be determined by using scaling laws.
The scaling laws concerning the thermodynamic functions can be derived from the simple
assumption that near the critical point, the correlation length ( ) is only the characteristic
length of the system in terms of which all other lengths must be measured. This assumption is
made for the derivation of scaling laws, called as scaling hypothesis.
Scaling hypothesis can be implemented by dimensional analysis. One way to implement the
scaling hypothesis is to assume that the quantity of dimension is proportional to
near the critical point. Let us consider the dimension of various functions of interest to
derive scaling laws. Some of them are listed in table 8.1 along with their dimension, scaling
hypothesis.
Table 8.1:
Now equating the exponents for the given functions according to the scaling hypothesis and
by definition, scaling laws can be derived as;
(52)
(53)
(54)
(55)
Equations (52) and (54) give directly Fisher and Josephson scaling laws respectively.
Now adding (53) and (55),
This gives,
(56)
This gives,
(57)
Using (57),
This gives
This is Rushbrooke scaling law. Thus, all scaling laws can be easily derived from scaling
hypothesis using dimensional analysis.
Fig. 9.1
(65)
Where, and
Now squaring and time averaging of A(t), we have from (65),
(66)
(67)
Now ensemble averaging of , we get from (67) as
(68)
Or,
(70)
Thus, time-auto correlation function of A(t) can be expressed as Fourier cosine of spectral
density of A(t).
The inverse of equation (70) is also determined by Wiener-Khintchine as
(71)
Equation (70) and (71) represents Wiener-Khintchine theorem which is general for finding
the fluctuation in voltage in the resister of resistance R as;
(72)
Equation (72) is known as Nyquiste theorem exclusively applied for motion of electrons in
electronic devices.
11. Brownian Motion
Robert Brown a Botanist in 1827 had observed the random motion of very small particles of
the order of micron such as pollen grains when suspended in a fluid. The random motion of
such tiny particles suspended in fluid caused due to collision with the molecules of the
surrounding fluid is called as Brownian motion and the particles which show this motion are
called as Brownian particles.
The random or zig-zag motion due to collision with the molecules of the surrounding fluid of
Brownian particles may be as shown in Fig. 11.1. The motion of the Brownian particles in a
fluid is random, continuous. It is slower in more viscous liquids whereas faster if the particle
size of the Brownian particles are smaller.
(75)
Solution of equation (75) is give as
(76)
(77)
The ensemble average of or the mean square fluctuation of displacement x of the particle
will be obtained from normalization of equation (77) as
(78)
Therefore, the mean square fluctuation of displacement of the particle is proportional to time.
This shows that Brownian particles are initially concentrated at the origin and diffuses out as
the time increases.
(79)
Where, and
(79) (80)
We know,
(81)
Now using (81) and (81), we have
(82)
On averaging (82),
(83) Since,
(84)
Let,
Equation (84) gives,
Now integrating,
(85)
Again integrating,
(86)
(87)
Let, , where, is relaxation time
(87)
Thus, if t <<
or
This shows that the particle moves with the thermal velocity which does not lead to
Brownian motion.
Now, if t >>
(88)
This shows that the mean square fluctuation of displacement of the particle is proportional to
time as predicted by Einstein.
Comparing (82) with diffusion process according to Einstein prediction (78),
the coefficient of diffusion D will be given by
(89)
(90)
At an initial time t’,
(91)
Where, and
(92)
Mean square velocity will be obtained from (92) as;
Since,
(93)
Let t’+t” = 2u and t” = t’+
Consider,
(94)
At time t,
(96)
Equation (96) represents the relation between damping coefficient due to viscosity of fluid
which oppose the motion and correlation function due to fluctuation in molecular
collision. This is dissipation-fluctuation theorem for Brownian particles.
13 Fokker-Planck equation for Brownian particles
The differential equation for the probability f(v, t) that a particle has a velocity v at time t is
called Fokker-Planck equation. In case of Brownian motion due to fluctuation of molecular
collision, this equation when applied leads to the Brownian motion as the change of state
from non-equilibrium to the state of equilibrium.
Let is the probability that the particle in the ensemble has a velocity between to
at any time t.
(97)
(98)
Where, (99)
Thus,
(100)
(101)
(102)
(103)
(105)
(106)
(103)
(107)
Fokker-Planck equation plays an important role in the theory of fluctuation and Brownian
motion. The differential equation for velocity distribution function as the probability f(v, t)
given by (107) is known as Fokker-Planck equation.
(108)
Where, and
Integrating with respect to t over , we have
(109)
Where, (110)
Since, <A(t)>=0, <J>=0
This gives (111)
And from and we have (112)
Now applying Fokker-Planck equation (107) to Brownian particles using X and Y.
(107)
(113)
In order to solve equation (114) we introduce a new variable
(114)
Or, (115)
Thus,
(116)
Using (114) and (116),
(117)
(118)
Similarly,
(119)
(113)
(120)
Where,
Equation (120) can be further simplified by introducing a variable
(121)
(122)
Now, (120) gives
This gives
(123)
(125)
Similarly, the solution of (123)
(126)
From (116)
(127)
At time
(128)
Thus as the time progresses, an ensemble of Brownian particles approaches a state of
equilibrium due to molecular collision.
Equation (128) is a molecular distribution of velocity, which means that every system shows
the same velocity distribution as defined by Maxwell classically at infinite time.
Questions:
1. Define phase transition of first order and show that during the first order phase transition,
Gibbs free energy is continuous but first derivatives of Gibbs free energy are discontinuous.
Derive the following equation for first order phase transition,
10. What is Fokker – Planck equation? Apply it for Brownian particles and show that an
ensemble of Brownian particles approaches a state of equilibrium with the time progresses.
11. What are critical indices? Develop the different scaling relations connecting the critical
indices.
12. Explain the change in order parameters in liquid – gas phase transition and in ferromagnetic
phase transition.
13. Explain Einstein model of diffusion of Brownian particles through the medium of fluid.
14. Explain the properties of time-auto correlation function.
15. Explain the terms (i) cooperative phenomenon and (ii) random walk