Capabilites of A Consummate Networker

You might also like

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 15

Organizational Dynamics, Vol. 36, No. 1, pp.

13–27, 2007 ISSN 0090-2616/$ – see frontmatter


ß 2006 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. doi:10.1016/j.orgdyn.2006.12.001
www.organizational-dynamics.com

Capabilities of the
Consummate Networker
N. ANAND JAY A. CONGER

WHERE TO TURN TO BECOME ceed. So while folk wisdom on networking is


AN EFFECTIVE NETWORKER: intuitively appealing, its application can be
FOLK WISDOM, STRUCTURAL limited. More importantly, we feel that folk
ANALYSIS OR PLAIN OLD wisdom often imparts an inaccurate under-
BEHAVIOR? standing of what it takes to be an effective
networker. We will highlight just how mis-
We live in an age that could be described as leading folk wisdom can be in a moment.
the ‘‘age of networking.’’ Improved network- The second camp consists of academics
ing has been proclaimed as the panacea for who deploy the rigor of mathematical and
many of today’s organizational ailments, graph theoretic models to understand how
ranging from the increase of bureaucracy certain roles and positions within the overall
in organizations to the erosion of solidarity network structures of an organization pro-
in civil society. Technology has facilitated the vide relative advantage. We can think of
activity of networking thanks to Web sites network structures as the myriad of actual
such as MySpace, LinkedIn, and Facebook. working and social relationships between
As a consequence, much has been written employees in an organization. These struc-
about networks and networking. Despite the tures reveal the complexity of relationships
volume of writing, the literature on creating far beyond the simple boxes portrayed on an
effective networks can be distilled into two organizational chart. This research has pro-
basic camps. vided crucial insights about structural con-
The first camp describes portraits of figurations of the relationship networks that
managers who are acknowledged to have enable or hinder effective performance of
mastered the art of cultivating relationships. both the individual manager and the orga-
Much of the advice from this camp comes in nization. While this research is highly reveal-
the form of folk wisdom. There are tips about ing, it has a fundamental shortcoming. Most
what works and what does not, how to max- managers rarely think about networks in
imize the benefits of one’s network, and the terms of graphical structures cutting across
pitfalls to avoid in networking. Examples of an organization. The complexity of these
such wisdom can be found in the discussion structures alone can appear overwhelming
below on the popular myths about the con- to those trying to improve their networking
summate networker. While folk wisdom can capability. Equally important, managers
be useful, what is often lacking is verification tend to think in terms of concrete practices
about its efficacy. For example, it may be and behaviors. This literature offers limited
based on a small sample of managers or guidance on concrete practices.
research that does not tie networking to We will bridge between these two camps
longer-term performance indicators. The by providing advice for managers on effec-
advice may work only in very specific con- tive networking behaviors that is based on
texts and not others. The advice may require academic scholarship, yet practice-focused.
a certain personality or disposition to suc- Our emphasis is on behaviors, in other words
13
the specific actions that managers can take in nothing could be further from the truth –
order to modify their network structure and good networkers are generally aware of the
to improve their effectiveness. expectations that other people bring with
them. They realize that a self-serving
approach over the long run actually harms
one’s networking capability. Instead a rela-
THE POPULAR MYTHS ABOUT
tionship built around reciprocation strength-
THE CONSUMMATE
ens the influence of the networker. This
NETWORKER
mindset helps effective networkers to struc-
In the course of our research, we came across ture fair exchanges with others. They invest
four important and popular myths about the in their relationships rather than simply take
consummate networker which proved to be from their relationships. For example, one
untrue. We describe each and then contrast manager reported that when he is unable
them with the reality we discovered. to allocate the material resources (increased
budget, new equipment, or an additional
1. The best networkers are ‘‘born networ- hire) that a colleague requests, he usually
kers.’’ compensates by ‘‘making up the difference’’
Without fail, the managers who are most in terms of social support, mentoring, and by
effective at networking that we researched providing a ‘‘heads up’’ to a new opportu-
told us they worked hard at developing their nity within the company.
networking skills. It required a serious 3. They carefully guard the network they
investment of time and focus on their part. have built.
While gregarious individuals have an initial Great networkers generally do not think of
advantage, even such people need to be their network as a precious personal asset
selective in order to prevent their network that needs to be guarded from prying indi-
activities from becoming a distracting time- viduals. While they know the value that
sink. One highly effective networker in our connections bring, they also focus on build-
study is an introverted manager who began ing the networks of those around them as
her career as a police detective. She realized well – a key strategy for empowering others.
the value of effective networking behavior by Their generosity is constantly being repaid as
observing a colleague in her station who those they have helped more willingly share
solved more cases than others due to his their own networks. Paradoxically, their
extensive relationship network. Our man- power comes from their lack of selfishness
ager mimicked her role model by spending and their eagerness to share their network
a number of hours cultivating contacts that contacts. For example, one senior manager
helped generate vital breakthroughs. These makes a point of providing young managers
skills stood her in good stead in her subse- in his firm with access to his network of key
quent career as the business relationships players in the organization. Early in his own
manager for a large British bank. As she career, an executive provided similar access
and the others in our study explained to that proved immensely critical to his success
us, networking takes a great deal of proactive in his first management assignment. While
effort. It is not a birthright of the chosen few. he carries no expectation that the young
2. Effective networkers are self-interested managers reciprocate, our senior manager
individuals. receives frontline access to information and
From personal experiences, everybody is news that few executives in his firm can
likely to be familiar with the archetype of the match.
manipulative networker who builds relation- 4. They constantly keep in touch with all the
ships in order to exploit others. Even the term people they know.
networker carries the connotation of a self- While this is true of some effective net-
serving activity. Our research reveals that workers, this does not apply across the
14 ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS
board. Like all managers, the most effective focused on learning the capabilities that we
networkers are pressed for time. They too do not actively use. And yes, there are skills
have activity-filled days. While they invest that can be learned to improve each capabil-
more energy into networking than others, ity. Learning these skills appears to be quite
they do so judiciously. They know that net- critical – since in the course of our research,
working activities could consume their day. we found that each networking capability is
Great networkers are rooted in the present associated with specific role demands in the
and are extremely interested in how current jobs that managers do. Each capability pro-
connections can shape their future, so they duces very specific positive outcomes for the
prioritize the people that they keep in touch networker.
with. They tend to be less engaged with
contacts from the past that are no longer
relevant to their present situation.
NETWORKING CAPABILITY #1:
SEEK OUT THE KINGPINS IN
EVERY SITUATION
THE FOUR NETWORKING
In any given situation, there are usually one
CAPABILTIES
or two individuals who have more informa-
In our research, we identified four critical tion about what is going on than anyone else.
networking capabilities: (1) Seeking out the Such individuals are able to put that infor-
kingpin in situations to ensure the appropri- mation to good use in order to influence how
ate outcomes in decisions; (2) Match-making events will turn out. As a result, they simply
people to get the right things done; (3) Proac- have more control over a situation than
tively enhancing network access; and (4) others – we call these individuals ‘‘king-
Interacting amiably with others to build posi- pins.’’ In many organizations that we have
tive relationships. After identifying the four observed, the kingpin is often not the CEO or
capabilities, we found that only about quar- formal leader; instead it is someone who is
ter of us are really good at one of the four respected and trusted within the informal
capabilities. In one survey that we conducted network of friendship and solidarity. They
of 200 managers, we surprisingly found that have more time and opportunity than the
only two percent were truly consummate CEO to attend to people with delicate pro-
networkers – that is they were effective at blems, or to those who require support dur-
all four capabilities. In Table 1, we report the ing a time of private crisis. This makes them
relative distribution of the percentage of influential behind the scenes. The ability to
managers actively using one, two, three or spot such kingpins in every situation is one
all four networking capabilities based on the hallmark of consummate networkers. Those
survey results. that have honed this capability look beyond
The statistics in Table 1 suggest that most titles, formal authority or expertise in spot-
of us have significant room to improve our ting in the kingpin. They cultivate the knack
networking skills. The implication is that we of observing who is talking to whom, who
could become consummate networkers if we seems to be in charge, and which person

TABLE 1 RELATIVE DISTRIBUTION OF NETWORKING CAPABILITY


Number of networking capabilities actively used Percent of managers using
One type of networking capability 25%
Two types of networking capability 10%
Three types of networking capability 5%
All four types of networking capability 2%

15
appears to exert the most informal influence. keep the scope of the bill limited. Johnson
Their network of relationships also keeps persuaded Russell by asking him to support
them informed of who is most influential a decade-long effort by senators from Wes-
in a given decision. In addition to developing tern states to obtain federal funding for a
awareness, kingpin-seekers are adept at dam on the Snake River marking the bound-
being able to connect to that crucial person ary between Idaho and Oregon. In turn, those
who can alter the course of events. Consum- senators joined in with Russell in getting the
mate networkers therefore learn to spot king- weakened civil rights legislation passed
pins quickly and relate to them as soon as through the Senate. As a politician, Lyndon
possible. Johnson’s hallmark was in recognizing the
The medieval Florentine banker Cosimo kingpin in any situation and then taking
de Medici (1389–1464), who was admired by steps to align his interests with theirs.
Nicolo Machiavelli, is perhaps the best his- We observed this capability in the mod-
torical example of a kingpin-seeking networ- ern-day networking patterns within an
ker. Cosimo lived at a time when Florence advertising agency specializing in the retail
was ruled by shifting coalitions of various sector. A formal network survey of the orga-
family clans, and through his networking nization revealed Scott James as the most
behavior created a stable ruling dynasty. In central individual within the firm. In addi-
addition to being born into an elite family, tion, many employees attested that he was
Cosimo was active in seeking out influential the best networker with whom they had ever
figures in various networks: as a banker, he worked. James is part of the top management
sought out merchants, aristrocrats, and other team, but two levels below the very top of his
clients all over Europe would help increase organization. He is skilled at reading the
wealth; as a patriarch he sought matrimonial importance of various people involved in a
alliances for his extended family so as to situation. With customers, he is careful to
increase the Medicis’ prestige; and as a understand who is responsible for interpret-
patron he sought out talented artists such ing his own firm’s performance. He makes
as Donatello, who helped usher in the certain they receive the appropriate informa-
Renaissance; and as a statesman he sought tion on how effective his agency is. He notes:
to make alliances that could help keep the ‘‘Often, the key person in the client firm
peace in Florence. assessing my performance is not the VP or
Former U.S. president Lyndon Johnson’s the general manager, but someone more
political skills also exemplify the kingpin- junior who is in a day-to-day operations role
seeking capability. In his time in the U.S. – it is their perceptions that filter upwards, so
Congress, Senate and in the White House, I am always keen to spot that person.’’ One
he was able to accurately identify and then episode that happened recently provides a
persuade coalitions and individuals who good example of his kingpin-spotting cap-
opposed his agenda. As senate majority lea- ability. James’s largest client is a large U.K.
der, Lyndon Johnson made his mark as an supermarket that had just announced the
effective networker in 1957 by championing acquisition of a smaller chain of grocery
President Eisenhower’s civil rights legisla- stores. James was expecting greater advertis-
tion, the first of its kind in 82 years. There ing revenues as a result of the client’s acqui-
was vehement opposition to the bill by sena- sition, but he found his counterpart within
tors from the southern states. Lyndon John- the client organization unusually mum when
son identified their ring-leader as Georgia he enquired about the matter. He quickly
Senator Richard Russell and convinced him made a few phone calls to other relationships
that a weakened civil rights bill was in the at the client organization – he made it his
interest of the South, given the changing business to keep an ear to the ground at each
times. However, Senator Russell needed evi- client company – and found out that a new
dence that Lyndon Johnson had the power to VP of marketing (Eve) had been appointed
16 ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS
recently. Eve had previous worked as a decision-makers. In one example, his firm
senior marketing analyst with a large gen- had an opportunity to purchase the infra-
eral-purpose advertising agency. He learned structure operations of another energy com-
that it was highly likely Eve would switch the pany. A myriad of decision-makers would be
company’s account to her former employer, involved in the purchase, including federal
because she seemed to have made remarks to and state governments, the local courts, and
her new colleagues to that effect. Sensing that the community. These bodies carefully assess
she was the kingpin in this decision, James the buyer in terms of corporate citizenship,
quickly sought a meeting with Eve and reliability, and financial wherewithal. How-
impressed on her that she would stand to ever, a significant portion of their assessment
gain much more by retaining his own firm for is shaped by experiences with the handful of
two reasons: first, the firm was more effective individuals who represent the company in
because of its exclusive focus on the retail meetings. In this case, those individuals
sector and second, owing to its small size it would be comprised of the governmental
was much more customer-focused than lar- affairs director and company executives.
ger agencies. He also asked her verify this No one had substantive contacts in the state
view with her colleagues. Eve, who had had where the project was being developed.
little experience within the retailing industry, In his search to determine the kingpins,
concurred with James after consulting her the governmental affairs director used a
colleagues. As a result, James won the multi-pronged approach. He first identified
enlarged business, owing to his networking who was currently managing the project for
and persuasion efforts. the seller: Was there someone there who
The last example showcases a number of could be informative? He also tapped into
behaviors concerning those good at ‘‘seeking a national networking organization of lobby-
the kingpin’’ capability. James was expecting ists. They identified an individual who had
his client’s acquisition to increase his own ad worked for the seller, was a native to region
agency’s revenues – he was active in scan- and well connected within the local commu-
ning the environment. When James did not nity. This local individual set up a series of
encounter an expected outcome – increased meetings to help introduce the governmental
business – he sought to find out. Because he affairs director to the kingpins involved in
had multiple connections within the client the permitting decision. In addition, the
organization, he was able to quickly obtain director also learned that wetlands restora-
an accurate interpretation of what was going tion was very important to the community,
on. James was proactive in meeting with Eve and that a local environmental organization
to impress upon her the mutual benefit of was active in the area. Recalling that his
working together with an agency specializ- company had worked with this environmen-
ing in retail – he knew what type of informa- tal organization in another region of the
tion to use to persuade someone new to a country, the director contacted the environ-
situation. mental group to see whether they knew any-
Another example of this behavior was one in the area hosting the new development.
discovered by studying the activities of a They did. And they too became important in
governmental affairs director for a multi- the permitting decision.
national energy company. His day to day We have found that certain personality
tasks require a finely tuned sensitivity to traits and roles are helpful for this kingpin
the networks of decision-makers who grant capability. Those who are skilled at seeking
permits for the company’s energy projects. out kingpins tend to be bold, assertive and
Relationships can be profoundly influential self-assured. They tend to be central players
in permitting decisions. Yet assignments can in connecting critical individuals that get the
take him into geographies where the com- work done. Kingpin-seeking networkers are
pany has no prior relationships with critical sensitive to the quality of information – and
17
the accuracy of interpretation of events – that of various activities important to the growth
people pass on to them. One executive that and profitability of your organization – the
we interviewed likened this to developing ability to influence situations does not
the traits of ‘‘a good spy-master.’’ She said, always flow top-down. Oftentimes, front-line
‘‘There are two rules when you handle espio- individuals and managers are highly influ-
nage agents: you should never trust the infor- ential.
mation of any one individual, and you A final piece of advice concerns attitude.
should be aware of the relative quality of Always assume that the individuals you
each source.’’ When something important meet have the possibility of becoming more
is about to occur (e.g., rumour of an impend- influential over time. In other words, they
ing merger), get the news and views of at may become tomorrow’s kingpin. As our
least two people. Note the ways in which the governmental affairs director notes: ‘‘When
two sources differ – the well-connected per- you meet someone, it is always important to
son is likely to provide more timely news and assume that you never know who they may
a more accurate interpretation of the event. become. For instance, I know that a state
The kingpin-seeking capability is espe- senator could go on to become a U.S. senator.
cially suited to four specific role demands in In one case, we had five fully permitted
a manager’s job: (1) gathering information in facilities but later decided not to go forward
uncertain situations; (2) obtaining multiple with the projects. Instead of simply bowing
interpretations of ambiguous events; (3) gen- out, we had a big community celebration to
erating accurate knowledge of how power is say goodbye. At that dinner, we had a judge
distributed; and (4) understanding who are who stood up and announced he was run-
pivotal decision-makers and understanding ning for Congress. You never know who will
their perspectives, concerns, and needs. become who.’’

Developing the kingpin-seeking


capability NETWORKING CAPABILITY #2.
MATCH-MAKE THE RIGHT
We were able to isolate a number of beha-
PEOPLE TO GET THINGS DONE
viors that enable this capability. Learning
these behaviors can help you become effec- The second capability of effective networkers
tive at spotting the kingpin. (1) When a is excellence at being able to make connec-
critical event occurs in your organization tions between people. Like match-matchers
(e.g., a pivotal investment, loss of a big cus- in the days of old, they enjoy putting people
tomer, a merger, or new line of business), with complementary needs and abilities
seek out multiple interpretations and locate together. Individuals skilled at this capability
the kingpins who might have triggered the are adept at creating remarkable work out-
event and shaped the final outcomes. (2) comes from these connections. In organiza-
Always strive to assess how well connected tions, the presence of individuals who
the individuals around you are and to figure routinely introduce and join up disconnected
out who is the ‘‘central player’’ in any net- departments and people is particularly criti-
work that you encounter. Central players are cal to innovation. What is unique about such
those who are the best connected and who connecting individuals is their lack of self-
have access to news and information the interest in ‘‘hoarding’’ the benefits of making
earliest. (3) Cultivate multiple mentors (both such connections. On the contrary, such
inside and outside the organization) who will match-makers are rather indiscriminate
share their insights about influential people about networking in this manner because
in various situations that are relevant to your they are much more oriented towards help-
job and career. (4) Stay connected to junior ing the organization as a whole become more
colleagues who are involved in the front line productive. Match-makers are able to frame
18 ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS
issues around a common ground to unite discover complementary issues and inter-
people with disparate interests and back- ests. When we asked members of a research
grounds. department in one pharmaceutical company
Helen Boaden headed up BBC ‘s Radio 4 to identify who was the best connected
(one of Britain’s most loved and respected among them, many pointed to Ralf. Surpris-
radio stations) between 2000 and 2004 in her ingly, Ralf had neither a distinguished aca-
role as controller. She viewed her job at Radio demic background nor the most patents to
4 as one of making connections that resulted his name. When asked about the secret of his
in the production of great programming. The success as a networker, he revealed: ‘‘Early
station by itself has a very small staff, since on in my career in the company, I took the
external suppliers make most of its pro- initiative to organize two or three highly
grams. Boaden routinely connected people focused conferences. At that time, my man-
who supplied ideas for programs with inter- ager thought it was a waste of time because it
ested producers, regardless of whether she was distracting me from my individual con-
could be present when the two individuals tribution, but the conferences led to a break-
met. Boaden worked hard at making connec- through discovery for the firm just based on
tions by instituting events such as a ‘‘produ- connections that people were able to make.
cers’ lunch.’’ These events were designed to After that, I continued to host the occasional
bring together producers who had never met half- or full-day seminar that put people from
even, though they contributed frequently to different parts within the firm in touch with
the station. During such occasions, she each other – and with me. Pretty soon I
helped producers discover programme developed a reputation as someone who con-
topics that were related to each other. She nects people up.’’
also encouraged producers to explore how This match-making capability is espe-
they could benefit from each other’s cially suited to three types of role demands
resources to provide a ‘‘shared’’ service to in a job: (1) seeing the possibility of mutual
viewers. Her skill at connecting people both interests, benefits and common ground
within and outside her organization is stand- between unfamiliar parties; (2) building dee-
ing up in good stead in her new and challen- per relationships between departments or
ging job as director of news for the BBC. business units or between one’s vendors,
People who have an extroverted and suppliers, and customers; and (3) sparking
sympathetic personality tend to be strong creative joint-outcomes from two parties that
at this capability of match-making. Indivi- normally do not interact with each other.
duals taking on roles that bridge different Managers who are good at the match-making
departments have some natural advantages capability tend to create synergy between
in cultivating at match-making. Over time, individuals and groups. They are better at
they may develop this capability simply due coordinating cross-organizational activities.
to the demands of the job – match-making They also excel at obtaining access to infor-
across departments to get things done. In mation, ideas, resources, and talent that are
contrast, those who have a laid-back person- not accessible through normal channels, and
ality – not very conscientious in terms of at deepening connections across the business
following up on leads or opportunities – tend community that supports a firm.
to be poor matchmakers.
Our research suggests that those skilled
Developing the match-making
at the match-making capability do not neces-
capability
sarily remember the individual needs of var-
ious people in their organization. Rather they We found several behaviors common to
are skilled at creating various kinds of for- those with a well-developed match-making
ums that bring people together. In such meet- capability. Specifically, it is important to cul-
ing places, people talk to each other only to tivate the following. (1) Learn ‘‘brokerage
19
skills’’ – discover what is scarce and how you catering staff to find out how his cost-cutting
can provide such resources not on your own initiatives were being received in the com-
but with the help of others. (2) Trust the rule pany. Mark Leslie, who ran Veritas Software
of reciprocity (‘‘you scratch my back, I from 1988 to 2000, overseeing its growth
scratch yours’’) to work on your behalf, but from 12 employees to 5,600 globally along
do not keep a running tally while helping with revenues from $ 400,000 per year to $ 1.6
others, and do not demand a return of a favor billion, worked hard at keeping connected
immediately after providing one. Doing so with his key employees. During his tenure,
fosters strong impressions of someone highly Leslie answered all of his telephone calls,
transactional and manipulative. (3) Actively mail, and e-mail personally, ensuring that
help others around you develop their net- he was not left out of the vital information
works by creating events where ideas and flow because of the good intentions of his
information can be exchanged – such as secretarial or administrative staff. Leslie was
seminars, workshops and even simple meet- also meticulous in attending every induction
ings. (4) When you detect networks that event at his company so as to reduce the
appear to be disconnected, bridge the gap social distance between himself and the new-
not through yourself, but helping represen- est employees of Veritas. When we asked
tatives from the different networks connect. him whether there was a downside to this
If someone needs information and you know level of access, he replied: ‘‘When people
an expert, put the two in touch with one know that you are available, they do not tend
another using yourself as the reference or to abuse the privilege.’’
doorway. Andres Amezquita, a senior manager, at
the Mattel Inc. toy company, was promoted
from the boys toy division in Latin America
to a broader international role in the girls
NETWORKING CAPABILITY #3:
division at the company’s California head-
ENHANCE ACCESS
quarters. While he had established an inter-
CONTINUOUSLY
national network of contacts over the years at
Individuals who are skilled at this capability Mattel, his network beyond Latin America
of network access strive to improve three and the boys division was limited. He used a
aspects of their network. First, they strive crisis situation in the European operations to
to increase the size of their network. They rapidly expand the size of his network and
work to use every occasion to get to know his connectedness. Andres explained: ‘‘I
more people that are not already part of their knew that the business was in crisis due to
network. Second, they try to improve their a serious product delay, and I also knew that
connectedness to others. They find ways of I did not have a lot of time to learn what was
keeping in touch with their critical contacts. happening. It was a business that I was new
Finally, they seek to boost the variety of to. Yet I needed to get my own European
contacts. They appreciate the value of diver- network alive very quickly.’’ He leveraged
sity in their network. his early morning walks with his dog to
CEOs who are handed the task of trans- enhance his access: ‘‘In California, we only
forming their company are conscious about have two morning hours a day that overlap
building a supportive network of relation- with Europe’s business hours. As we are
ships. When David Simon (now Lord Simon waking up, they are typically heading home
of Highbury) took over the reins of BP plc in from work. Now I always take my dog for a
1992 with a mandate to refocus the troubled walk at 5 a.m. My dog doesn’t care with
oil giant, he built his network in multiple whom I talk, so I decided to take that time
directions. In addition to reinforcing corpo- to call the marketing and brand managers in
rate and diplomatic ties at the highest level, Europe to discuss the product delay. If I call
he cultivated links with his chauffeur and his them at 5 a.m. my time, it is a surprise for
20 ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS
them. My call is still in the middle of their contact to find out who within the company
work day. What I discovered was that these can best help him with operations issues. The
calls built trust and a relationship. I spent a contact also helps him to get ahead of the
lot of time listening to these individuals. competition – a critical advantage given the
Historically, corporate did not share things cyclical nature of the business, when
with the countries such as market research. demands swings up and lead times to obtain
So I decided to become very transparent. I turbines lengthen.
told our European managers things more Vernon Jordan, Jr., a business executive,
candidly.’’ He also began to help them out Washington lawyer, and former civil rights
by acting as an information source about leader exemplifies the access networking
company resources. Andres described what capability. In 1971, as the head of the
he also did in those calls – match-making National Urban League, he was invited by
behavior: ‘‘There are many areas and Chairman John W. Brooks of Celanese Corp.
resources inside the company that the coun- to join the board of directors. Jordan was then
try managers do not know about. They may nominated by Brooks to the board of Bankers
want to use some type of media, and so I will Trust New York as an outside director. A
connect them with media folks at corporate. member of the Bankers Trust board that
During my early morning calls, I started served as a director at J.C. Penny Company
identifying some of the country needs and Inc. then nominated him to their board. In
helping them connect to the key people at this way, by building close connections with
corporate.’’ all members on a board, Jordan was able to
Another effective networker who is vice gain access to yet more boards by 1980,
president of asset management at an electric including Xerox Corp., American Express
utility company illustrates how effective net- Co., and R.J. Reynolds. A couple of decades
workers keep in touch socially. ‘‘When we later, Jordan became the most connected
were building power plants, I developed a director in corporate America thanks to skill
friendship with an individual at the manu- at cultivating access.
facturer who sold us electrical turbines. Now People who are extraverted – talkative,
we have not been buying turbines in recent warm, social, and excitement seeking – find it
years, but I have kept in touch with him. For easy to cultivate this capability. One of our
example, I call him on a regular basis. He effective networkers told us: ‘‘On my report
likes golf, and I do too. If I know of a golf cards in school, there is one common the-
outing, I will invite him. If he knows of an me. . .‘He is a bright young man but he talks
outing, he will invite me. I knew that he too much.’’’ Another explained: ‘‘I person-
spends a lot of time in Carmel, California. ally like my business activity to be very
My wife and I were going up to Carmel for a social. I try to connect when there is no
weekend recently, and so I called him to get business whatsoever. If a business opportu-
some recommendations. After our trip, I nity arises later, we have a relationship. It
called again and told him about some good makes the dancing a lot quicker when you
places in Carmel and confirmed his recom- keep in touch.’’
mendations. I was at a charity event. It turns On the other hand, those who are shy or
out that this individual is left-handed, and I anxious by nature have trouble improving
happened to see that one of the items – a left- the access of their network. When it comes to
handed golf club – had no bidders. So I put a organizational roles, we find, surprisingly,
low bid on it and won. I sent him the club.’’ that the higher up you go, the more your
For our networker, keeping a relationship access within the organization shrinks. In a
with the sales force is highly beneficial. He number of companies that we are very famil-
often deals with the operations and repair iar with in Europe, the U.S., South Africa, and
side of the turbine manufacturer. Whenever India, there is one unnerving fact that we
he has a problem, he will call on his sales observe repeatedly: it does not take much for
21
top managers in a company to become and information. (2) Before attending orga-
divorced from the front line of the business. nizational or industry events (e.g., confer-
Physical location is the single biggest predic- ences, seminars, annual meetings) study
tor of networking patterns. Being ensconced the participant list and make plans to meet
in the corporate headquarters cuts senior people you need to know. Such research time
executives out from their factories and mar- pays off in a richer connection with the peo-
kets – where all the information of changing ple you meet. (3) Schedule formal times to
business conditions resides. For example, ‘‘reach out and touch’’ – birthdays, anniver-
given their external orientation and busy saries, New Year, and festive seasons. One
schedules, most chief executives rely on a manager who was transferred from a multi-
small number of trusted subordinates to filter nation in Mumbai to London used the British
news from the rest of company to them. Over custom of sending Christmas cards to busi-
time, these executives’ networks become ness contacts to increase access in his net-
more selective and homogenous. Conse- work. He commented: ‘‘I took out my
quently, they are more impaired in their organizer and started selecting names of
ability to accurately convey what is going people I wanted to send a card to. In the first
on. Executives who are good at access net- year, I made a list of forty, mostly those in
working keep direct lines of communication India and some outside the firm in London.
open in all active parts of a company. They By the third year, the list had swelled to over
avoid being held hostage to a small net- two hundred people around the world.
work’s view of the world around them. Every Christmas time I carefully prune and
The access capability is especially suited add to the list. While travelling to different
to three types of role demands in one’s job: cities, I make an effort to meet with or talk to
(1) connecting with a large and diverse audi- the people in my list. After meeting a new
ence; (2) spending ‘‘face time’’ in interacting person who has made a deep impression on
with one’s customers and other business me, I make a mental note to add them to my
partners; and (3) modelling trustworthiness, list. Thanks to the Christmas card list, I had
candor, and openness to all forms of infor- become quite well connected.’’ The well-
mation. Managers who are good at the access known networking expert Keith Ferrazzi
capability are able to receive more up to date suggests birthdays as an occasion for keeping
and accurate information. As a result, their in touch. (4) Initiate communication with
decisions are often of higher quality, given others in your circle when a life- or career-
access to better and timely information. changing event occurs in your life or that of
your contacts (e.g., promotion, marriage,
new baby, etc). (5) For more critical contacts,
Developing the access capability
schedule periodic informal meetings or calls
During the course of our research, we if you do not see these individuals often (e.g.,
gleaned a number of approaches that effec- lunch meeting, dinner at home, sports or
tive networkers use to build this access cap- cultural events). Our governmental affairs
ability. Focus on the following. (1) Build a list director’s approach is illustrative. Through
of your network contacts. Use information in his work in Louisiana, he has gotten to know
your personal organizer, e-mail program, a tanker ship’s pilot quite well. This indivi-
and correspondence files to list the names dual has two sons in college football. From
of critical contacts. A number of our infor- time to time, he will call the pilot up to say he
mants reiterated that just the act of making a saw his son playing on television. It will be a
list makes them aware of who is missing and casual conversation with no reference to
therefore who needs to be added. With business. The pilot is also the head of the
knowledgeable colleagues, determine who local tanker pilots association. They move
has access to whom in your organization, ships into gas terminals. The Coast Guard
and who has access to what kinds of people looks to the pilots for the safety of the ship
22 ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS
traffic and for facility design. Our networker enterprise in the outsourced catering market
explains: ‘‘You cannot move a ship up the in South Africa) oversaw a company that
channel without a pilot. As an energy com- managed over 600 catering and cleaning con-
pany you have to start with a good relation- tracts. The company operates in a tough
ship with the person who is piloting your environment, where the growth of the busi-
ships. You seek their input on berth designs. ness depends on tight control over wafer-
You get to know them. If you do not build a thin profit margins. Quinn believes that
relationship, it can get your projects in trou- keeping the workplace sociable is critical to
ble. The pilots are well connected in the state spirit of the company in the face of a business
capital. They are part of the economic fabric environment that exerts a great deal of pres-
of the area. They are smart and honest. If you sure on its employees to be cold, efficient,
have a good dialogue with them, you might and instrumental. Quinn promoted amiabil-
learn something.’’ (6) If you work in a remote ity by presiding over a number of rituals that
location, make sure you visit the head office were designed to share emotions, stories, as
on occasion to invest in ‘‘face-time.’’ (6) If you well as company news and information.
are out of the inner circle in your organiza- Chief among these rituals was the monthly
tion, actively develop ties to one or more of birthday celebration held at the head office,
the insiders. where each department hosted a breakfast
buffet that was designed to outdo the pre-
vious one in terms of creativity and eccen-
tricity. After the festivities, Quinn took time
NETWORKING CAPABILITY #4:
to announce important initiatives and
INTERACT AMIABLY WITH
changes within the company. The rituals
OTHERS
were cascaded down the organization, so
Those who are skilled at being amiable leave that the spirit of amiability was preserved
others with the impression that they always even in the field offices where much of the
have the time of the day to lend an ear to the tough work of the company was done. When
concerns of others. They focus on the context we asked Quinn, who is routinely described
of their interactions as well as the content. as ‘‘personable’’ by the business press,
They regulate their own mood so as to create whether he has difficulty in making and
a positive atmosphere and carefully avoid communicating tough decisions, he replied
expressing negative feelings. When a mes- without hesitating: ‘‘Being amiable is not an
sage is delivered to them, they are alive not open door to the lowering of respect or per-
only to the news, but also to the manner and formance expectations. I worked hard to
appearance of the messenger – following ensure that my style of networking allowed
Marshall McLuhan’s dictum they believe the coexistence of amiability and high stan-
that ‘‘the medium is the message.’’ By doing dards of business performance.’’
so, good networkers create an ambience that Christoph, a successful equities analyst
is conducive to the sharing of sensitive news whom we interviewed, provided us with a
and information, and consequently they good example of the importance of amiabil-
learn more out their interactions with others. ity. Christoph arrived at his current firm with
Other people tend to naturally gravitate a reputation for brilliant analysis of semi-
towards individuals who are amiable. There- conductor firms. While people flocked to
fore those who have a well-developed cap- him initially, they found him overbearing
ability for amiability find it easy to make new and arrogant. Subsequently, although people
contacts. They tend to be central players in acknowledged that he was very bright, his
informal friendship networks that develop in reputation was such that ‘‘no one in their
and around organizations. right minds would sit besides Christoph on
Peter Quinn, the former CEO of Fedics an airplane, even if the flight was only an
Foodservice Group (the largest black-owned hour long.’’ At his first performance review,
23
his manager preached the value of humility. level. Look beyond the pressures and
Christoph said that the meeting made a deep requirements of tasks and seek to assist
impression on him: ‘‘I was trying to impress and be supportive. Learn and enquire about
others with how knowledgeable and impor- the family and personal interests of collea-
tant I was. However, most of the important gues when it is appropriate. (2) Try to
contacts that I had to make were in Asia, develop interests outside of the workplace
where a softer – more humble – manner with co-workers. Those who are rated highly
was preferred. When I toned down my in the capability report that their best friends
style, I found more people volunteering are also close colleagues at work. (3) Reduce
information, which was critical to making formality and hierarchical differences in
the right call about companies that I was your workplace. If you insist on pulling rank,
researching.’’ you will lose the opportunity of attracting
When we asked one manager who is well people spontaneously. Schedule to meet over
regarded for this capability how she became lunch or dinner or coffee with colleagues.
skilled at it, she replied: ‘‘It was honed over These kinds of settings foster informality
time through my various interactions, busi- and a more personal touch. (4) Design events
ness experience and exposure to different for sharing emotions. These can be small-
kinds of people. However, I do also believe scale and fun rituals such as a birthday party
that there are different character traits in or festive celebrations or a team-building
people that will predispose them to this event.
approach to networking.’’ Individuals with
an agreeable and kind personality develop
this capability with ease. Being amiable,
CONCLUSIONS
however, is difficult for people who are emo-
tionally touchy or temperamental. Organiza- In this article we have shown that consum-
tions that are extremely busy and focused mate networking requires one to see through
also deter amiability among employees. folk wisdom (which points to inborn traits
The amiability capability is especially and a fixed set of skills) and to go beyond
well suited to the following role demands complex graphical representations of net-
in a management job: (1) where there is an work structures (which are complicated to
explicit focus on relationship building; (2) map accurately in any given situation). Effec-
when there is a need to read body language tive networking instead very much depends
and other subtle forms of communication to on your behavioral capabilities and the con-
assess what is going on; (3) when there is a text of outcomes that you want to achieve.
need for a level of comfort with discussing Our research has identified four behavioral
personal issues; (4) there is a need to be capabilities that underpin consummate net-
plugged into the informal or gossip network; working: (1) seeking the kingpin; (2) match-
and (5) there is a need to obtain social sup- making; (3) increasing access; and (4) amia-
port from friends and well-wishers. Man- bility. Although these capabilities are helped
agers who are good at the amiability by favorable personality traits, they can be
capability often play the role of confidante learned because they are rooted in specific
and are effective at strengthening the morale role demands within an organization (see the
of a team or organization. middle column in Table 2). Ask yourself
which of these capabilities you seem to be
good at, and to what it extent it is due to your
Developing the amiability
personality rather than the demands of your
capability
role. It is also important to consider what
The following types of behaviors can be kinds of outcomes you would like to achieve
practiced to develop the amiability capabil- given the demands of your current role (see
ity. (1) Relate to colleagues on a personal the rightmost column in Table 2) and
24 ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS
TABLE 2 NETWORKING ROLE DEMANDS AND INTENDED OUTCOMES
Networking capability Role demands Intended outcomes
Seeking the kingpin Gather information in Greater influence across and upwards
uncertain situations in your organization
Obtain multiple interpretations More favorable decisions
of ambiguous events Getting your tasks done more effectively
Generate accurate knowledge of and efficiently
how power is distributed
Recognize pivotal decision-makers
and understand their perspectives,
concerns, and needs
Match-making Build deeper relationships between Better coordination of cross-organizational
departments or business units or tasks and cross-departmental activity
between one’s vendors, suppliers, Obtaining access to information, ideas,
and customers resources, and talent that are not
Explore the possibility of mutual accessible through normal channels
interests, benefits and common Creating synergy between individuals
ground between unfamiliar parties and groups
Spark creative joint-outcomes from two Deepening connections within and
parties that normally do not interact across your business community
with each other
Increasing access Connect with a large and diverse Strengthening decision quality with
audience more up to date and accurate information
Spend time ‘in the field’ or engaging in Accessing information from the ‘front lines’
‘face time’ Enhancing your public reputation as a
Model trustworthiness, candor, and leader
openness to all forms of information
Amiability Focus on relationship building Fostering the sharing of sensitive and
Ability to read body language personal information
Comfort with discussing personal issues Strengthening the morale of a team or
Require to be plugged into the informal organization
or gossip network Increasing the number of individuals that
Need to obtain social support from can turn to you for support during
friends and well-wishers stressful or sensitive times

whether you have the necessary capability concerted effort and a deep appreciation for
that is required. Create or seek out roles and its profound value.
assignments that can help you develop and
refine a particular capability that is not your
strong suit. Networking, as we noted earlier,
is not a birthright: rather it is the product of

25
SELECTED BIBLIOGRAPHY

Wayne Baker’s book Achieving Success detail by Robert Caro in the third volume of
Through Social Capital (San Francisco: his biography titled Master of the Senate: The
Jossey-Bass, 2000) provides a superb intro- Years of Lyndon Johnson (New York: Knopf,
duction to the importance of networking in 2002). The importance of the match-making
the workplace. A good overview of structural capability in achieving successful career out-
approaches to networking can be found in comes is emphasized by Keith Ferrazi in the
the article ‘‘Informal Networks: The Com- book Never Eat Alone and Other Secrets to Suc-
pany Behind the Chart,’’ by David Krac- cess, One Relationship at a Time (New York:
khardt and Jeffrey Hansen, Harvard Currency Doubleday, 2005). A theoretical
Business Review, July–August 1993, 104–111. analysis of the importance of match-making
Rob Cross and Lawrence Prusak provide a behavior in the context of innovation is pro-
good description of various structural posi- vided by David Obtsfeld’s article ‘‘Social
tions in ‘‘The People Who Make Organiza- Networks, the Tertius Iungens Orientation,
tions Go – Or Stop,’’ Harvard Business Review, and Involvement in Innovation,’’ Administra-
June 2002, 5–12. tive Science Quarterly, 2000, 50, 100–130.
In his book The Tipping Point (London: Carole Stone’s extremely readable book Net-
Little, Brown, 2000) Malcolm Gladwell dis- working: The Art of Making Friends (London:
cusses ‘‘mavens’’ – networkers who can dig Vermillion, 2000) contains a number of tips on
out intricate details from various sources of improving one access capability. Gerald
information and may share this quality with Davis, Mina Yoo, and Wayne Baker describe
the kingpin-seeking capability that we have how Vernon Jordan’s skills at improving
identified. A historical account of Cosimo De access led to him to multiple corporate boards
Medici can be found in Paul Strathern’s in their article ‘‘The Small World of the
book The Medici: Godfathers of the Renaissance American Corporate Elite, 1982–2001,’’ Stra-
(London: Jonathan Cape, 2003). A more tegic Organization, 2003,1: 301–326. Donna
detailed sociological analysis of Cosimo’s net- Fisher and Sandy Vilas offer a number of
works can be found in the article ‘‘Robust suggestions on how to be amiable while build-
Action and the Rise of the Medici,’’ by John ing relationships with others in Power
Padgett and Christopher Ansell, American Networking, 2nd edition (Austin, TX: Bard
Journal of Sociology, 1993, 98, 1259–1319. The Press, 2000). A psychometric questionnaire
kingpin-seeking networking skills of Presi- measuring the four networking capabilities
dent Lyndon Johnson are described in vivid can be obtained from N. Anand.

N. Anand is Reader in Organizational Behavior at the Tanaka School of


Business, Imperial College. He has also taught at London Business
School, the Indian School Business and at the Owen Graduate School of
Management, Vanderbilt University. Anand has consulted on social
network issues for wide range of organizations, including Mc-Graw Hill,
The Museums Libraries and Archives Council, Tractors and Farm
Equipment Limited, and Credit Suisse Financial Services. Anand’s
current research examines social networking behavior in entrepreneurial
organizations, new forms of organizational design, and knowledge-based
26 ORGANIZATIONAL DYNAMICS
innovation in professional service firms. His scholarly work appears in
journals such as Academy of Management Journal, Annual Review of Sociology,
Journal of Management Studies, Organization Science, Personnel Psychology
and Popular Music (e-mail: anandnar@gmail.com).

Jay A. Conger holds the Henry Kravis Research Chair Professorship of


Leadership at Claremont McKenna College in California. He is also a
visiting professor of organizational behavior at the London Business
School. In recognition of his extensive work with companies, Business Week
named him number five on its list of the world’s top ten management
educators. The magazine also selected him the best business school
professor to teach leadership to executives. Author of over 90 articles
and book chapters and 12 books, he researches leadership, organiza-
tional change, boards of directors, and the training and development of
leaders and managers. His articles have appeared in the Harvard
Business Review, Organizational Dynamics, Business & Strategy, the
Leadership Quarterly, the Academy of Management Review, and the Journal
of Organizational Behavior. He has taught at the Harvard Business School,
INSEAD (France), the London Business School, McGill University, and
the University of Southern California. Outside of his work with
universities, he consults with a global list corporations and non-profit
organizations (Claremont McKenna College, Claremont, California;
e-mail: jay.conger@claremontmckenna.edu).

27

You might also like