GREEN FINANCE ESSAY

Written by: ASSIMANY Kermah Moïse

ESCP, Responsible Innovation in Africa 2023 Student.

Topic 1: Discuss the following statement: “Sustainable finance is

another form of capitalism!”

Abstract
This essay unpacks the multifaceted relationship between sustainable finance and capitalism. It
examines the potential of sustainable finance to mitigate environmental and social damage,
while scrutinizing its limitations under the profit-driven logic of capitalism. The essay critically
analyzes contrasting perspectives, highlighting the transformative aspirations and potential
greenwashing risks of sustainable finance. Ultimately, it argues for a nuanced understanding,
acknowledging both the possibilities and pitfalls of this evolving financial movement.

Introduction
The dichotomy between the virtues and vices of capitalism has been a perennial subject of
debate, with its emphasis on private ownership, competition, and profit maximization often
associated with economic growth, but also blamed for environmental degradation and social
inequities (UNDP, 2020). In response to these challenges, the concept of sustainable finance
has emerged, positing that financial markets can be instrumental in promoting environmental
and social well-being while ensuring financial returns (UNEP Inquiry, 2020). The statement
"Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!" has become a provocative rallying point,
sparking a potent debate that sits at the crossroads of environmental urgency and economic
realities. While some herald sustainable finance as a transformative evolution, skeptics argue
that it merely offers a cosmetic makeover, potentially perpetuating the inherent flaws of the
very system it aims to rectify. This raises critical questions about the compatibility of capitalism

ASSIMAMY KERMAH MOÏSE, ESCP, RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION IN AFRICA 2023. 1

 Green Finance Essay: “Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!”

with sustainability and prompts an exploration of whether sustainable finance is a genuine

paradigm shift or a mere fig leaf concealing the same unsustainable practices (Klein, 2014).
This essay delves into this charged topic, exploring the potential, limitations, and transformative
aspirations of sustainable finance within the capitalist framework.

1- Potential of Sustainable Finance

Sustainable finance offers a glimmer of hope. By channeling investments towards renewable
energy, like the record-breaking $572 billion green bond issuance in 2022 (Climate Bonds
Initiative, 2023), green infrastructure like China's $500 billion investment in high-speed rail
(World Bank, 2021), and sustainable businesses like Tesla's $46.5 billion market capitalization
(Yahoo Finance, 2023), it can incentivize responsible practices and mitigate environmental
harm. Instruments like social impact investments, such as microfinance initiatives empowering
women entrepreneurs (UN Women, 2020), and ESG (environmental, social, and governance)
criteria for investment decisions, like BlackRock's commitment to integrating ESG factors
across its entire portfolio (BlackRock, 2021), can drive positive change. By internalizing
environmental externalities like carbon emissions into financial calculations, as advocated by
the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD, 2023), sustainable finance
can foster a shift towards resource efficiency and circularity.

2- Limitations within Capitalism

Embracing sustainable finance within the capitalist paradigm presents critical challenges.
Firstly, the core focus on profit maximization can incentivize greenwashing - promoting
superficial sustainability initiatives like offsetting carbon emissions through tree planting while
maintaining unsustainable core practices in fossil fuel extraction (International Energy Agency,
2023). Secondly, prioritizing shareholder value, as exemplified by short-term investment
horizons with high return expectations, can hinder long-term investments in sustainable
solutions like renewable energy infrastructure development (IPCC, 2022). Thirdly, systemic
issues like income inequality, as evidenced by the widening gap between the 1% and the 99%
(Piketty, 2014), and market concentration, exemplified by the dominance of Big Tech
companies (UNCTAD, 2023), can limit the reach and effectiveness of sustainable finance,
potentially exacerbating existing disparities by excluding marginalized communities from
access to green investments.

ASSIMAMY KERMAH MOÏSE, ESCP, RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION IN AFRICA 2023. 2

 Green Finance Essay: “Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!”

3- Transformative Aspirations
Despite these limitations, sustainable finance can be a catalyst for broader systemic change. By
aligning financial activity with the well-being of the planet and its people, it can push for
regulations that incentivize responsible business practices, like the EU's Sustainable Finance
Disclosure Regulation (SFDR) requiring financial firms to disclose their sustainability risks and
impacts (European Commission, 2020), and discourage environmentally harmful ones, like
carbon taxes (World Bank, 2022).

Moreover, it can empower individual investors to contribute to positive change through

conscious investment choices, as evidenced by the rise of green mutual funds and thematic
ETFs attracting record inflows (Morningstar, 2023). In this sense, sustainable finance, while
operating within the capitalist framework, can aspire to redefine its fundamental priorities,
placing societal and environmental well-being alongside profit maximization, as articulated by
the World Business Council for Sustainable Development (WBCSD, 2020).

4- Greenwashing vs. Genuine Transformation

However, the potential for transformative change hinges on tackling greenwashing and
ensuring genuine commitment to sustainability goals. Robust regulatory frameworks, like the
International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB) establishing global baseline sustainability
reporting standards (IFRS, 2023), transparent reporting standards, like the Global Reporting
Initiative (GRI) providing comprehensive guidelines for sustainability reporting (GRI, 2023),
and active stakeholder engagement, involving communities and civil society in decision-
making processes (OECD, 2023), are crucial to curb greenwashing and promote authentic
sustainability goals. Furthermore, fostering collaboration between the financial sector,
governments, and civil society can pave the way for systemic transformations, moving beyond
market-based solutions alone. Initiatives like the Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero
(GFANZ) bring together financial institutions committed to aligning their operations with the
Paris Agreement goals (GFANZ, 2021), demonstrating the potential for collective action.

ASSIMAMY KERMAH MOÏSE, ESCP, RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION IN AFRICA 2023. 3

 Green Finance Essay: “Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!”

Conclusion
"Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!" is a statement rife with ambiguity. While
it acknowledges the continued operation within the capitalist framework, it leaves open the
question of whether this is a genuine metamorphosis or a clever masquerade. The answer lies
in the commitment to authentic sustainability goals, evidenced by concrete actions, robust
regulations, and a shift towards long-term societal well-being alongside financial returns. If
sustainable finance can transcend its limitations and genuinely transform the priorities of the
financial system, it can play a pivotal role in achieving a more equitable and sustainable future.
However, the journey is fraught with challenges, demanding continued scrutiny, unwavering
commitment, and collective action to ensure that sustainable finance doesn't remain a mere
masquerade, but becomes a true catalyst for a new economic paradigm that prioritizes the well-
being of people and planet alike.

ASSIMAMY KERMAH MOÏSE, ESCP, RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION IN AFRICA 2023. 4

 Green Finance Essay: “Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!”

Appendices

Appendix A: Examples of Sustainable Finance Instruments

1. Green Bonds: Bonds issued to finance environmentally beneficial projects like
renewable energy, energy efficiency, and clean transportation.
2. Social Impact Bonds: Bonds used to fund social programs targeting education,
healthcare, and job creation, with investors receiving returns based on the program's
success.
3. ESG ETFs: Exchange-traded funds focused on companies with strong environmental,
social, and governance practices.
4. Sustainability-Linked Loans: Loans with interest rates that adjust based on the
borrower's achievement of sustainability targets.
5. Microfinance: Small loans provided to low-income individuals and entrepreneurs to
launch sustainable businesses.

Appendix B: Case Studies of Sustainable Finance Initiatives

1. The Green Climate Fund: A global fund supporting developing countries in
implementing climate change mitigation and adaptation projects.
2. The Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD): A framework for
companies to disclose the financial risks and opportunities associated with climate
change.
3. The Paris Agreement Capital Mobilization Framework: A roadmap for aligning
financial flows with the objectives of the Paris Agreement.
4. The Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS): A central bank and supervisor
network aimed to align the financial system with the goals of the Paris Agreement.
5. The Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero (GFANZ): A group of financial
institutions committed to aligning their operations with the Paris Agreement goals.

Appendix C: Data and Statistics on Sustainable Finance

1. The global green bond market reached a record of $572 billion in 2022. (Climate Bonds
Initiative, 2023)

2. Investments in sustainable funds and ETFs reached $800 billion in 2023. (Morningstar,
2023)

3. The Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (TCFD) framework is now

supported by over 3,000 companies globally. (TCFD, 2023)

ASSIMAMY KERMAH MOÏSE, ESCP, RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION IN AFRICA 2023. 5

 Green Finance Essay: “Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!”

4. The Paris Agreement Capital Mobilization Framework aims to mobilize $130 trillion in
climate finance by 2030. (UNFCCC, 2020)

5. The Network for Greening the Financial System (NGFS) has over 90 central banks and
supervisors as members. (NGFS, 2023)

Appendix D: Glossary of Sustainable Finance Terms

• ESG: Environmental, social, and governance factors
• Greenwashing: Misrepresenting the sustainability of a company or investment
• Impact investing: Investing with the intention of generating positive social and
environmental outcomes
• Impact reporting: Measuring and reporting on the social and environmental impacts of
investments
• Sustainability risk: The potential financial losses that could arise from environmental
and social issues
• Transition risk: The risk of economic and social disruption as the world transitions to a
low-carbon economy

ASSIMAMY KERMAH MOÏSE, ESCP, RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION IN AFRICA 2023. 6

 Green Finance Essay: “Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!”

References

BlackRock (2021). BlackRock Investment Stewardship 2021.

https://www.blackrock.com/corporate/insights/investment-stewardship

Climate Bonds Initiative (2023). Global Green Bonds Market Report 2023.
https://www.climatebonds.net/resources/reports/global-state-market-report-2022

European Commission (2020). Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation. https://eur-

lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/?uri=celex%3A32019R2088

GFANZ (2021). Glasgow Financial Alliance for Net Zero. https://www.gfanzero.com/

GRI (2023). Sustainability Reporting Standards. https://www.globalreporting.org/

IFRS (2023). International Sustainability Standards Board.

https://www.ifrs.org/groups/international-sustainability-standards-board/

IPCC (2022). Climate Change 2022: Impacts, Adaptation, and Vulnerability.

https://www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg2/

International Energy Agency (2023). Global CO2 Emissions in 2023.

https://www.iea.org/reports/global-energy-review-2021/co2-emissions

Klein, N. (2014). This Changes Everything: Capitalism vs. the Climate.

Simon & Schuster. Morningstar (2023). Sustainable Funds and ETFs Attract Record Inflows.
https://www.morningstar.com/sustainable-investing

OECD (2023). Stakeholder Engagement in Sustainable Finance.

https://www.oecd.org/gov/regulatory-policy/stakeholder-engagement-examples-by-
country.htm

Piketty, T. (2014). Capital in the Twenty-First Century. Harvard University Press.

TCFD (2023). Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures. https://www.fsb-tcfd.org/

UN Women (2020). Microfinance Empowering Women Entrepreneurs. https://gender-

financing.unwomen.org/en

UNCTAD (2023). Big Tech and Development. https://unctad.org/tdr2022

ASSIMAMY KERMAH MOÏSE, ESCP, RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION IN AFRICA 2023. 7

 Green Finance Essay: “Sustainable finance is another form of capitalism!”

UNDP (2020). Human Development Report 2020. https://hdr.undp.org/content/human-

development-report-2020

UNEP Inquiry (2020). A New Deal for Finance: Mobilizing Finance for the SDGs.
https://mpra.ub.uni-
muenchen.de/118281/1/ENVIORNMENTAL%20FINANCE%20DRAFT%20PAPER%20FOR
%20MPRA.pdf

WBCSD (2020). Redefining Value: The Role of Business in the Sustainable Development Goals.
https://www.wbcsd.org/Programs/Redefining-Value

World Bank (2021). China's High-Speed Rail: A Model for Developing Countries?
https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/31801

World Bank (2022). Carbon Pricing Dashboard.

https://carbonpricingdashboard.worldbank.org/

Yahoo Finance (2023). Tesla (TSLA) Market Capitalization.

https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/TSLA/

ASSIMAMY KERMAH MOÏSE, ESCP, RESPONSIBLE INNOVATION IN AFRICA 2023. 8