Professional Documents
Culture Documents
What Is The Book of Breathings
What Is The Book of Breathings
4-1-1971
Recommended Citation
Nibley, Hugh (1971) "What is “The Book of Breathings”?," BYU Studies Quarterly: Vol. 11 : Iss. 2 , Article 5.
Available at: https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5
This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at BYU ScholarsArchive. It has been
accepted for inclusion in BYU Studies Quarterly by an authorized editor of BYU ScholarsArchive. For more
information, please contact scholarsarchive@byu.edu, ellen_amatangelo@byu.edu.
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
what is
the book of Brea
breathings
things
Nl BLEY
HUGH NIBLEY
153
rr- h
jti
3
Tvi
11
A
i3 w
1
a0
0z
O
lia
ila
117
itt
lei
lot
i
OQ
2
sij
elj
mij
1I a
it
a A y tig
s 7 iti
0 iri
CT
1b y
AL
iltpi
y
4
Y
siE
i
2
u
S
D
5
z&
za
E
fr
ftste
faste
sfs
2
T
o4i1
ir
5
nfs
edi
eds
i 4
rr
S
is
giai1
sigsa
Q
ji j lgi cl 1 n
ill
ili
iii
i
111
.111
3dp1st Si gSA
jy
i
yei
agi fi T
31
i
sigdajyels
l
isa
jyils
1 0 li r 133
1
zd
0 rai
ral f t
KIN
r sar
s&r
li
IP
IISSIHI i
ils
STI
btl hilr
ir
htlr
F
1
tw
a
1
T
sseli
iseli
1
d- rl
r
L
olt
0
od hf
J
gilr
ylie
elie iis
ais
tilr lallas
1lallls
F uirr
birr
hirr
illi
ill TG
jslc
jalc
leiz
i
0 olli
ili
iii
011 obil
0511n
a
10
ltls1
1
0
U
U
y
3
l
75 ur if
151
s 13 7 i
1
J
is
41
i 3 tat5
sbsatllxirl t
fj
aj
qj
rafeii sb
rffeii
imijag
22
ab
a
1I imijan
smi
1 ilan
j in
jar
sals iMI
i
ls
il
s ti
Jag
stis
stls
sils UO
0 0.0
j3 z s aija
ilxn i St
i i yh
itl
4ija
g wI t
ti
i ta
s t1
fij3x M
1
wr i 1
t
h1 fijux
14
T tt at 1l 14t H 1 sl 15
1
pt atl
1
ha
mit
la
ifsal t
tal in idsal H Iil
1
Jtyt
tat
S t S
all
alt
akl
x
4
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 2
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
sa on 0 dueL
4- 11l i w a 00 ot
ilsaiitel
G a U 4i
ai
1 0 0
nsf
1
1l
1npilpl
AM
t
ns1 wl
tltt
ss yn ti yabj
1 nt
0
2
13
hitt
hite
O
stltt
tj
.5
5
i
tr 1.1
rar3
1
0
IJ
r
kg
abaA
r I1
I1
TL
1
1 I
I
S1
N0
ai
1I ia
i1
51
P
to
sM
smlwis
i
sl1
sii
sli
sla
y r
pori
wors lWiS
iti A
w 3
yib
btw sa
s1 sl ils
i
lit
117
og it
cc
v
ol
01
3
0
2
t
4r
io ar
n
jl yhti
ahti
N
na
4
n1
LL
itell
itesl nt
t1 lu
tlh0
11 ije
cje
lle oi
i p fm xo it
1
tl
l
brb4
1
jl tim
tin taQ U S sa s1 iiilt1
tl
R
TM j
&
0 0 a- to a t a fl sl lr 0 r s
0 4 .99
4 xa
x0
0 N 74
ig
aq
pq v 40 ci 340
4 113
14
1
00 0 fl
t F
SJ
tk
of
0
albl
blbl
BIBL EGYPT T XVII
XVIL al
PL XI
aua
ar
tap tuaua
rop
top
FCT iu
5r
T uflfcliiiob
il lilbllalh iljsdli4ft idi
lol
idl
101 i
wf flotnoiffdsilllrtl
f4ilotnoiffdsiii
rz4wff4iioifrjoii5j
caf y a n
5
r vaf0 1I
1 T
r i t
2
yiuiriiuufoks omi
14 T
fl ikleiiirigfl
itytenwf
ten
ken Wf 5
tst m t5t
tat
est
roar
it
ro5r utu
ulu ilt
zit
zil
ailt
i5irtff4fiiifllli
2
fftp4j&tlurfefhtjit
iliffjfriitt
jaa
R 4 ta
t7W1I
09foftolfi
soa
so7 6
7
8
lia
ila 46ltq I1
43106
dylag
t1
2lnsfoji ta
SSSMW 1 91
401-
W 111
1 1
55 1
3
p
tj
t j
27
t
ta
t8
lvtfl
jlillygt
ID
lt J
7
gjtai
ajtai
gj malTAi
mai z
9
0o
fiotitota
y toti
tot1 11
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 4
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 157
at the time over one hundred copies of the work were available
and the most striking thing about it was the liberty displayed
by the scribes the things reported wrote chassinat
Chassi nat the
conceptions presented are identical in all of them the mss ass
but the form in which they are expressed varies almost to
infinity according to the caprice or personal beliefs of the
scribe and the resources of the buyer 7
the writers of the
Brea things do not take such liberties and yet the
first book of breathings
two writings are so closely associated that the ancient scribes
often made no distinction between the two books giving both
11
158
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 6
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 159
160
showing not only that much authentic egyptian matter was car-
ried over into judaism and christianity but that such egyptian
stuff instead of being the spoiled and rancid product of a late
and degenerate age represented the best and oldest the egyp-
tians had to of
offer
fer 17 L kakosy
kakony for example bids us compare
the classic egyptian descriptions of heaven and hell with those
found in an egyptian christian grave of the ath 8th or ath
9th cen-
tury AD specifically in the apocalypses of enoch and peter
to see for ourselves how little they have changed 18 egyptolo
fists can no longer brush such resemblances aside as coinci-
gists
dences and nowhere are they more striking and more frequent
than in the breathing texts and their closest relatives 19
of particular interest to us is the close association of the
book of breathing with the facsimiles of the book of abra
1lL
kakony problems
al
11
kakosy problerne
probleme agypt ischen jenseitsvorstellungen in der ptole
ierne der agyptischen
Prob leme
lerne
inkrund Kaiser
maerund zeit in religions en egypte
kaiserzeit Hellenist ique et romaine paris
egypto hellenistique
presses universitaires
Universita ires 1969 ap 59
pp 596868 many others are referred to in our
commentary
ibid p 68 also in ariens oriens antiques
antiquus 3 1964 p 19 where he notes
how the 18th dynasty book of amduat carries over into the coptic christian
Philon enko in religions en eg hellenist et rom pp
phlonenko
pistis sophia M philonenko
Phlon ap 109-
110 finds an egyptian and iranian background for the jewish secrets of enoch
EAW budge apocrypha in the dialect of upper egypt london
1913 iliff
ixiff lists twenty coptic christian borrowings from ancient egypti-
ap 1xiff
pp
an imagery cf OHE burmester egyptian mythology in the coptic apocry-
pha orientalia 7 1938 pp ap 355
355367 hollenror
altigyptische h511envor
367 E hornung altagyptische
stel lungen berlin akademie verlag 1968
stellungen p 8 notes resemblances between
the coptic christ an texts and a number of egyptian writings coffin texts
christian
amduat book of gates book of quererts Quer erts whi ch are all strongly reflected in
which
the book of Brea bargues livre des morrs
things P barguet
breathings motts p 19 observes that chap
marts
morts
85 of the book of the dead one of the sections included in the jdseph jaseph smith
joseph
papyri finds earlier expression in coffin text no 307 which contains letter
for letter almost the first sentence of the gospel according to st john and
JG griffith in religion en egypto egypte etc
egyple above n 17 p 51 does not
Rames seum papy-
hesitate to compare allegorical expressions in the very ancient ramesseurn
ramesseum
rus with the christian equating of bread with flesh and baptism with resurrec-
tion S schott die leutungdeutung der geheimnisse des rituals fur die abuehl abuehr des
Wies baden fr steiner 1954
wiesbader
bosen wiesbaden p 6 notes parallels in this egyptian
text which is closely related to the book of Brea breathings
things and the christian
sacraments
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 8
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS igl
igi
161
P
C
cd
R
w
X
s
162
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 10
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 163
budge
2budge p 33
chassinat
Chassi nat p 316
2g
ag
G thausing das grossegypfische
agypt ische Toten
grosse agyptische totenbuch
buch p 19
at
2tP barguet
bargues livre des motts
marts ap 11
morts pp 1112
12
164
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 12
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 165
nose 41 canum
chnum who created the animals by the breath of his
mouth and breathed forth the flowers of the field 42
As
the apis bull he is also the living breath of ptah atah the cre
horns of edfu
ator43 he is horus
ator eddu who puts breath into the nose of
the dead 44 he is re who announces to them in the under-
world 1 I bring light to the darkness who sees me shall
E hornung alag alfg
alfag hollenhorst
hollenvorst
Hollen vorst p 11
h51lenvorst
so chapters 54 to 59 inclusive
36
E otto gort gott
golt und mensch nach den dgyptischen tempelinschriften
tempeljnschriften der
griechisch romischer zer
zel heidelberg C winter 1964 p 54
zelt
rimiscben zeir
romischen 7eit
beit
J bergman ich bin isis upsala Up sala 1968 acta univ upsaliensis historia
kupsala
Religion
renqu
religionum
brenqu um 3 pp ap 186f
H junker die Stunden stundenuachen
stundenwachen
wachen in den osirismysterien vienna 1910
p 2
39
otto gott und mensch ap l49rf 159rr
pp 149ff 159ff
these and other pertinent quotations in G posener de la divinity divinite
Divi nite du
pharaon paris 1960 cahiers cashiers de la societe asiatique
Asia tique XV p 66
Plutar
T hopfner plutarch cb ilber isis und osiris 11II teil prague orientalisches
institut
institute 1941
ibid p 141
421bid
ill
iii
lii
lil
p 111
ae
4eE chassinat travaux
Chassi nat in receuil de tramaux
Tr avaux 38 1938 ap pp 44f
wreszinski
Wre szinski in AT
W wereszinski AZ 45 111 cf 112 1157 115 7 122
166
ibid p 19
hopfner plutarch siber
siger
udey
uder isis und osiris 1I 15
uber
fiber 1511
aj
5jJ bergman ich fin
rin ap 186 190 treats this familiar theme
din isis pp
bin
hin
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 14
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 167
maat 52susn is the air that infuses and pervades thy nos-
yuju the air thy nose breathes susn the north
trils inhale susu
incorporate
wind thy throat gulps in air thou incorporatest st life into thy
body 53 isis and nephthys prevent decay and evil odor by fan-
ning with their wings but that is also the favorable wind which
enables the dead to progress on his journey in the hereafter 54
but breathing is only half the story it is significant that
the clear statement of the purpose of the sensen papyrus as
given in its introductory lines makes no mention whatever of
breathing this bids us consider the broader and more vener-
able ritual background of the word the rites set forth in the
shabago
shabako document the earliest coronation drama and perhaps
the oldest of all egyptian ritual texts culminate when the new
king unites himself with the royal court and mingles susn juju
snsn
with the gods of ta tenen 55 the expression for mingle with
snsn r sethe finds also in the pyramid texts and means ac-
susn
gesellen he duly notes that
cording to him sich zu iemand gesellen
geseller
the writing is commonly used in later times for susn
snsn inhale
being mistakenly regarded as a reduplication of sn to kiss 56
another document going back to the earliest times uses the
same word in the same way telling how maat came down
from heaven in their times and united herself to those
who dwell upon the earth another version maat came
down to earth in their time and mingled with susn snsn hn the
gods and another maat came from heaven to earth and
mingled susnsnsn n s with all the gods 57 the word mingled
both as snsns and snsnns otto renders as sie verbriiderte
verbmderte
sich mit and indeed in the last sentence the word is writ-
ten simply with the picture of two men shaking hands 57
this picture of maat mingling freely with mankind in the
golden age before the fall forcibly brings to mind Ps
8511 truditrudl emeth possibly cognate with the eg maat
truth
shall spring out of the earth and righteousness maat is the
egyptian word for righteousness shall look down from heav-
en but even more relevant is the less familiar verse that pre-
a de buck the egyptian coffin texts univ of chicago 1938 11II
34 35 spell 80
3435
from the book of passing through eternity W wreszinski
wereszinski
Wre szinski AZ 45 115
bergman irh
ich bin isis pp
ap 198205
198 205
ak
5kK sethe das denimal memphitischer theologia
theologie
The ologie der schabakostein
Schaba kostein des
br mus leipzig 1929 p 73 line 64
ibid p 76
ae
5eE otto das goldene Zei zel
zeitafter
zeitalter
tafter
talter in religions en egypto
egypte etc above
n 17 p 103
168
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 16
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 169
al
1
ill
thl
E
to
w
170
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 18
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 171
172
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 20
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 173
175
174
out into the day the rebirth as a triumphant sun 71 one finds
the very same situation way back in the old kingdom as a
number of recent studies makes clear 772 not only are the
cults of egypt simply saturated with the idea of a continua-
tion of life elsewhere as it was lived on earth as dr speleers
noted with strong disapproval 773 but separation between life 11
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 22
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 175
176
graph and publish all the ritual scenes from ramses 11 II s outer
wall of the temple at karnak 1968 did E winter do the
same at the philae 1970 did mrs reymond bring to-
gether all the founding legends of the egyptian temples
1969 all these sources and many more are now being
studied thoroughly for the first time though they have been
well known to egyptologists for over a hundred years what
interests us particularly is that all have direct bearing on the
Brea things why have the ex-
understanding of our book of breathings
perts neglected to give them the only treatment that pays off
helck answers that question in the preface to his important
study the reliefs he examines have all been skecthed photo-
graphed and described countless times yet systematic publi-
cations even for the great temple of karnak are almost com-
pletely lacking 80 why
in the first place according to helck the ritual scenes in
dian t look particularly significant taken alone
the reliefs didn
each one looks perfectly ordinary and familiar the student or
tourist has seen that sort of thing a thousand times so he
yawns and moves on yet when the same scenes were brought
together and the detailed photographs placed side by side a
recognizable order and meaning at once appeared an order
and meaning that had completely escaped generations of egyp egypt
tologists 81 then again helck observes they were ignored be-
cause they were religious compositions and the experts were
convinced that they had taken the measure of egyptian religion
and found it sorely wanting in the solid historic and scientific
content they were looking for 81 but the greatest block of all
was that the numerous sacrificial scenes in the temples were
regarded as stereotyped compositions from which it was
believed no really significant data were to be had 81 the fact is
that they are stereotyped and look enough alike to convince
any casual observer that when you ve seen one you ve seen
em all E winter has found the same situation at philae
1I
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 24
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 177
178
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 26
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 179
180
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 28
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 181
182
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 30
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 183
185
during various rites for the living and the dead persons or
G foucart in BIFAO 24 1924 p 1
132
122
H nibley tenting tool and taxing in western polit poiit quarterly
pol
19 1966 pp ap 609612
609 612
bargues in RHR 177 67 bergman ich hn
P barguet ap 88f
din isis pp
bin
H brunner in saeculum 21 1970 p 159
kin isis p 165 otto gott u mensch p 84
bergman ich fin
bin
hin
S schott in nacar
nachr ak wiss g&tlngen 1958 no 4 pp
gottmgen ap 350 370
2lL speleers la reurrestion et la toilette du mort revue degyptologie
al
21
3 1938 p 37
12aA blackman in JEA 31 512f
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 32
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 185
documents 130 though the content of the text clearly shows that
it was meant for the king alone instead of bearing the name
of a particular king it refers only to pharaoh indicating that
it was a stereotyped text that any old king could use 130 3
or for
that matter anybody else since private owners of such texts
sometimes put their own names right inside the cartouche re-
117
served at all times for the king s name alone 113
alone113
137
186
whatever the reason the egyptian in his funeral rites was cer-
tainly treated as a candidate for initiation he was tested for
purity had to stand judgment in a court had to demonstrate
special knowledge by answering specific questions identifying
objects and giving certain code words at a succession of gates or
doors etc in fact the egyptian word for burial means to ini-
tiate one into the mysteries 146 As his ultimate objective the
dead requests permission to enter into the holy of holies of
the temple of heliopolis on the grounds that as an elder
he has been initiated into the deepest secrets of the temple
and knows the stories that explain the various institutional
aspects of the cult 147
bargues defending the traditional view against the rising
barguet
initiationism insists that there is nothing in the book
tide of initiationism
of the dead to indicate an initiation for the living 1118 well
that is hardly where one would expect to find such and yet
bargues himself is quick to add in a footnote
barguet that is
not to say that there was no initiation in egypt on the con-
trary the formulas of chapters 112 115 prove that there
112115
was he calls attention to chapters in the book of the dead
plainly describing rites performed by the living and for the
living 149 but explains that the living initiates since they were
required to possess special knowledge as all initiates are
must have been priests but the question is not about the rank
hierophantes but only whether the living were initiated
of the hierophants
into the ordinances from the egyptian and mormon point of
view of the question is an academic one since all ordinances
are meant to be of eternal validity and to apply both in this
world and the next after all the fundamental purpose of
ordinances is to bridge the gap between the worlds all are in a
G thausing in mel maspero 1I 40
SGF brandon in CJ bleeker ed initiation p 41
bergman ich gln
gin iszs p 231 cf CJ bleeker egyptian fesh
klu isis
kiu
bin
hin festivals
zais lei-
vals
dais
den brill 1967 p 45
K sethe Sp spruche
sprilche
ruche fur das kennen der seelen der hei ligen orte AZ
heiliger
heiligen
57 1922 p 11 BD ch 1146 114 6
bargues livre des norrs
TP barguet norts p 24 on the general opposition thausing
morts
marts
nofts
gr toteno
tolenh p 6
totenb
bargues
barguet p 25 n 47 citing BD chapters 18 19 135 163
https://scholarsarchive.byu.edu/byusq/vol11/iss2/5 34
Nibley: What is “The Book of Breathings”?
breathings
THE BOOK OF BREA THINGS 187