Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Anewlydeveloped10kA levelHTSconductor Innovativetenon Mortise basedmodularizedconductorTMMCbasedonChinaancientarchitecture
Anewlydeveloped10kA levelHTSconductor Innovativetenon Mortise basedmodularizedconductorTMMCbasedonChinaancientarchitecture
net/publication/380201778
CITATIONS READS
0 31
7 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Jinxing Zheng on 16 May 2024.
E-mail: jxzheng@ipp.ac.cn
Abstract
We proposed a new type of high-temperature superconducting (HTS) conductor concept:
modularized conductors (MCs) connected by Chinese traditional tenon-mortise (TM)
connection structure, referred as TMMC (tenon-mortise modularized conductor). The conductor
consisted of multiple concentric round sub-conductors with slots for stacking
rare-earth-barium-copper-oxide (REBCO) tapes. Innovatively, the REBCO stacks in the
adjacent sub-conductors were arranged with the fully-misaligned configuration to enhance the
critical current’s isotropy with respect to magnetic field and reduce ac loss. For example, the
angle between the adjacent stacks in the two adjacent sub-conductors was 45◦ if each
sub-conductor contains 4 REBCO stacks. In order to construct the fully-misaligned
configuration, the sub-conductors were designed with two open half-circular formers and
connected by TM structure which makes the conductor modularized and simply to assembly
and disassembly. Based on the design concept, a prototype conductor containing 160 REBCO
tapes distributed in the four concentric sub-conductors was fabricated. The conductor’s
measured critical current was 13.69 kA at 77 K and self-field, which was consistent to the
simulation result. In order to further improve the TMMC’s engineering critical current density
(J ce ) and bending performance, we proposed two enhancement approaches: reducing the
former’s thickness and re-arrange stacks in the outer sub-conductors. With the enhancements,
both TMMC’s radius and J ce were comparable to the existing slotted-core conductor. The study
shows the TMMC’s advantages of non-twisted structures, easy assembly, high-current carrying
and low ac losses, which made it promising for constructing large-scale scientific devices.
Keywords: tenon-mortise structure, modularized HTS conductor, TMMC, REBCO tapes, ac loss
∗
Author to whom any correspondence should be addressed.
2
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
3
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
Figure 3. The prototype TMMC: the tendon–tenon connection and the assembly of TMMC conductor.
4. Fabrication and performance test of the Table 1. Geometric parameters of the prototype TMMC.
prototype TMMC Parameters Value
4
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
5
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
Figure 5. Ic measurement for TMMC: (a) DC source and the prototype TMMC; (b) Hall sensor and TMMC; (c) the voltage probes for
conductor.
Parameters Value
DC source 100 kA
Voltage acquisition equipment EF721
Signal acquisition frequency 10 Hz
dI/dt 50 A s−1
V th 70 uV
Estimated I c 15 kA
comparable to the that of the unidirectional-stack conductor. of the conductor was tethered to a roller with the fixed radius
Besides, the diameter of the all formers in the enhanced con- (1000 mm). The constraint between the HTS stack and the
figuration is 18 mm, close to that of the slotted-core con- surrounding copper former is modeled as frictional constraint
ductor (diameter 19 mm) [11], therefore, bending the TMMC (friction factor = 0.2), allowing for slight slippage of the
to manufacture magnets is feasible. In the current design, the REBCO tapes. This aligns with the actual manufacturing pro-
enhanced TMMC’s engineering critical current density is sim- cess of the conductor. In practice, after the tape stack is inser-
ilar to that of the slotted-core conductor, but it can be signific- ted into the slots of the former, a layer of copper tape is applied
antly improved with the approach of re-arranging the stacks to the surface. Simultaneously, as in TSTC cable, the cop-
in the outer sub-conductors compared to the latter when the per wires are used to fill the gaps between adjacent layers
conductor contains more tapes. Because more slots can be cut of TMMC. In order to simulate the bending state of the con-
in the larger-radius formers of TMMC to contain more tapes, ductor when winding large superconducting coils, as depicted
while the tapes can be only stacked in unidirectional direction in the figure 8(b), there are two wheels on either side of the
in the traditional slotted-core conductor. conductor used to fix and bend the conductor. It is worth not-
To assess the bending radius of the TMMC conductor, the ing that both wheels are rigid bodies in the simulation and do
mechanical simulations were conducted. In the actual layered not undergo deformation or displacement. The surface at the
structure of the ReBCO tapes, it comprises superconducting terminal of TMMC conductor is bound to the wheel below,
layers, silver layers, a Hastelloy alloy layer, copper layers, which rotate as the conductor bends. After the conductor has
and others. During modeling, the Y m , µ, α of HTS tape was been bent to 90◦ , the stress and strain of the internal tapes are
172 GPa, 0.33 and 13.2 × 10−6 K−1 . As figure 8, one end observed.
6
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
Figure 6. Ic of the prototype TMMC at 77 K: (a) Ic under self-field, (b) Ic under self-field and external 0.7 T.
Figure 7. Enhancing the conductor’s critical current density with less sub-conductors. The gray lines in every sub-conductor represent the
joints of the two half-circles. The width of the tapes is 4 mm. The diameter of the black circles decreases from 31 mm to 18 mm.
Figure 8. The simulation model for the bending behavior of TMMC (bending radius 1000 mm). The bending strain of tape 1 and tape 2
would represent the performance of the entire TMMC conductor.
The critical bending radius of the conductor is influ- bending radius of 1000 mm, the maximum strain in the strip
enced by the direction of bending. As depicted in the is −0.308%.
figure 8(c), the surface of the superconducting tape near the This approach enables a simplified representation of the
rigid wheel is perpendicular to the radial direction of the bend- complex internal structure of the tapes for computational
ing, while tape 1 is parallel to the direction of the bend- efficiency, allowing for a focused analysis of the mech-
ing. This implies that tape 1 will reach the critical strain anical response under bending. But in a long conductor,
threshold more rapidly. Additionally, for ease of compar- the tapes can be considered as bonded (friction = 1), then
ison, during post-processing, particular emphasis is placed the peak strain will reach 10 mm/1000 mm = 1.0% and
on extracting the strain distribution and numerical values 10 mm/600 mm = 1.7%. It elucidates the limit bending radii
of tape 1 and tape 2. The results of the bending simula- exceeding one meter under the actual manufacturing process
tion, depicted in the figures 9 and 10, indicate that at a of a long (>100 m) conductor.
7
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
Figure 9. The results of the mechanical analysis of the TMMC conductor under a 1000 mm bending radius: (a) the strain distribution of the
conductor (εmax = 0.68%); (b) the strain distribution of the tape 1 and tape 2 in figure 9 (εmax = 0.308%).
Figure 10. The results of the mechanical analysis of the TMMC conductor under a 600 mm bending radius: (a) the strain distribution of the
conductor (εmax = 0.71%); (b) the strain distribution of the tape 1 and tape 2 in figure 9 (εmax = 0.52%).
5.2. AC loss comparison study During the T-A simulation, the peak intensity of the back-
ground magnetic field for the TMMC conductor reaches
For the operational conditions of TMMC in a fusion reactor, 10 Tesla. The direction of the external magnetic field is the
magnetization loss constitutes a significant component. The y-axis in figures 11(a)–(f). Since the transmission current is
following investigation focuses on the hysteresis loss of TSTC zero, the Dirichlet boundary condition is employed to ensure
cable (1-layer) and TMMC (4-layer). These conductors are that the magnetic vector potential at both ends of the tape
positioned within a background magnetic field generated by a remains at zero. As depicted in the figure 11(g) (Bmax = 10 T),
magnet, with the central magnetic field being adjusted sequen- distinct from transmission loss, ReBCO tapes exhibit induced
tially by varying the current in the background magnet. The currents under varying magnetic fields, particularly at the tape
internal current within the conductor is set to zero through- edges where the current may exceed the critical current, lead-
out the experiment. The TMMC conductor contains 160 ing to local flux quenching and consequent magnetization
HTS tapes internally. Taking into consideration the compu- losses. Conversely, the central portion of the tape manifests
tation time, a two-dimensional model is employed to calcu- comparatively smaller induced currents. In the presented res-
late hysteresis losses. In addition, simulating coupling losses ults, for a multilayered conductor with a misorientation angle
for ReBCO tapes with extremely high anisotropy is challen- of 45◦ , this specific arrangement results in an elevation of
ging. Firstly, simulating coupling losses among the stacks magnetization losses. This phenomenon may be attributed to
requires defining the transverse resistivity, which is influ- the shielding effect of outer layers, causing the inner layers
enced by factors such as pressure and manufacturing pro- to be exposed to the magnetic flux and consequently escalat-
cesses. Moreover, the numerous mesh points at the tape con- ing losses. In light of this principle, we have adopted a more
tact locations result in a significant increase in the number of dispersed arrangement for the outer layers of superconduct-
elements. Therefore, this study focuses solely on hysteresis ing tapes. For instance, maintaining a constant total number of
losses in the ceramic layer. tapes (160 superconducting tapes), each tape stack comprises
8
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
Figure 11. The magnetization loss with no transport current (Bmax = 10 T, ∆B/∆t = 0.2 T s−1 ): (a)–(c) the magnetic flux density norm of 1
layer of TSTC conductor, 3 layer of TMMC conductor and a better distribution of tape stacks in the outer layers of TMMC; (d)–(f) the J z /J c
of 1 layer of TSTC conductor, 3 layer of TMMC conductor and a better distribution of tape stacks in the outer layers of TMMC; (g) the
comparison of AC loss.
9
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
Figure 12. Distributions of normalized current density in conductors: (a)–(d) represent TMMCs (160 tapes) with 4.5 mm, 3.5 mm, 2.5 mm
and 2 mm formers, respectively. Figure (e) is the enhanced configuration based on the 2 mm former. Figure (f) represents the traditionally
unidirectional-stack conductor.
(w)[2 ]
only 5 HTS tapes, with a greater distribution of tape stacks in ehy = µ◦ Hm Hp ln (cosh θ) − tanh θ (θ ≡ Hm /Hp )
the outer layers. Due to the pronounced magnetic field vari- δ θ
ations, the outer-layer tapes suppress magnetic flux penetra- (1)
tion, leading to diminished magnetization losses in the inner
( )2
layers and, consequently, an overall reduction in ac loss. 1 Hm ( w )
Moreover, we have found a method to calculate the mag- ehy ≃ µ◦ H2m (0 ⩽ Hm ≪ Hp ) (2)
6 Hp δ
netization losses of TMMC conductor under high background
magnetic fields in [32]. Considering the relatively high aspect (w)
ratio of the ReBCO tapes, the formulas (1)–(3) from table 5.1 ehy ≃ µ◦ Hp (Hm − 2Hp ln 2) (Hm ≫ Hp ) . (3)
δ
on page 441 are used for the calculations. Additionally, the
external magnetic field is oriented perpendicular to the surface AC losses of the prototype TMMC with different radii
of the tape. The specific formulas (1)–(3) is provided below. are calculated under the same engineering current density.
Since the tapes within the TMMC conductor are arranged in The normalized current density distributions and ac losses of
multiple layers, with a total of 160 tapes, each HTS stack con- different conductors are shown in figure 12. Triangle-wave
taining 10 tapes is considered as a unified entity. The calcu- currents (500 A s−1 ) are applied in the whole conductor.
lated results from the formula indicate that, at a background Therefore, non-even current distributions are considered.
magnetic field intensity of 10 T, the magnetization losses for a From figure 12, it can be seen that the imposed currents are
single tape stack amount to 842.32 J m−3 , thus resulting in a mostly distributed in the outmost tapes, and the current pen-
total magnetization loss of 13 477.13 J m−3 . To facilitate com- etration becomes shallower with the TMMC’s former redu-
parison with the simulation results, the numerical value of the cing. As shown in figure 13. With the former of sub-conductor
calculated AC losses obtained from the formula is divided by decreasing by 1 mm, the peak loss of TMMC reduces by more
the cross-sectional area, resulting in a final value of 0.86 J m−1 . than 75%. And among all the conductors, the enhanced con-
It is evident that this numerical value is lower than the results figuration based on the 2 mm former achieves the minimum
obtained from the T-A model (about 4 J m−1 of one cycle). ac losses. Due to the increased engineering critical current
We speculate that this discrepancy may be attributed to the density, the peak loss reduces by 57% compared with the non-
arrangement of HTS stacks of TMMC conductors, enhanced 2 mm former TMMC.
10
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
Figure 13. AC losses comparisons of TMMCs with different radii and traditionally unidirectional stack’s conductor under the same
carrying current density.
6. Conclusions The data that support the findings of this study are available
upon reasonable request from the authors.
In this paper, a new kind of HTS MC concept is proposed,
in which the conductor consists of multiple concentric half-
circle sub-conductors connected by Chinese traditional TM Acknowledgments
structure. Therefore, the proposed HTS conductor is referred
as TMMC. Innovatively, the REBCO stacks are arranged This work was supported by the National Natural Science
by the fully-disaligned configurations of the adjacent sub- Foundation of China General Program 52077211, by the
conductors, which benefits for improving the isotropy of con- National Science Found for Excellent Young Scholars of
ductor’s critical current on magnetic field and reducing ac loss. China 52222701, and by the Anhui Province Key Research
According to the design concept, prototype TMMCs are and Development Plan 2022i01020019.
manufactured. The measured critical currents of 1-layer and
4-layer TMMCs are 4.012 kA and 13.69 kA, respectively, at
77 K and self-field, which are close to the predicted values of ORCID iD
4.072 kA and 15.328 kA.
In order to further improve the TMMC’s engineering crit- Jinxing Zheng https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4624-0571
ical current density (J ce ) and bending performance, we pro-
pose two enhancement approaches to reduce TMMC’s radius:
reducing the former’s thickness and re-arrange stacks in the References
outer sub-conductors. With the enhancements, the TMMC’s
[1] Zheng J et al 2022 Innovation 3 100269
J ce is increased by four times. The TMMC’s radius, J ce and ac [2] Zheng J, Cheng Y, Li M, Liu F, Liu X and Liu H 2023
losses are comparable to the unidirectional-stack conductor, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 36 115032
which makes it feasible to construct magnets. [3] Bruzzone P, Fietz W H, Minervini J V, Novikov M, Yanagi N,
With the advantages of non-twisted structures, easy Zhai Y and Zheng J 2018 Nucl. Fusion 58 103001
[4] Barth C, Mondonico G and Senatore C 2015 Supercond. Sci.
assembly, high-current carrying capacity and low ac losses,
Technol. 28 045011
the proposed TMMC is promising for constructing large-scale [5] Li M, Zheng J, Sheng J, Cheng Y, Hong Z, Ye H, Wang X,
scientific devices. And we are planning to implement more Liu X and Liu H 2022 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 35 125001
tests to verify the performances of TMMC and promote it to [6] Uglietti D, Kang R, Wesche R and Grilli F 2020 Cryogenics
be employed more widely. 110 103118
[7] Goldacker W, Frank A, Heller R, Schlachter S I, Ringsdorf B,
Weiss K-P, Schmidt C and Schuller S 2007 IEEE Trans.
Data availability statement Appl. 17 3398–401
[8] Wang J, Kang R, Chen X, Yang C, Wang Y, Wang C and Xu Q
2022 Superconductivity 3 100019
The data cannot be made publicly available upon publication [9] Hartwig Z S et al 2020 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 33 11LT01
because the cost of preparing, depositing and hosting the data [10] Shi Y, Liu F, Liu H, Tan Y, Zhang X, Jin H, Yu M, Lei L and
would be prohibitive within the terms of this research project. Guo L 2020 IEEE Trans. Appl. 30 1–4
11
Supercond. Sci. Technol. 37 (2024) 065006 J Zheng et al
[11] Celentano G, De Marzi G, Fabbri F, Muzzi L, Tomassetti G, [22] Wang L and Zheng J 2024 IEEE Trans. Appl. 34 4902605
Anemona A, Chiarelli S, Seri M, Bragagni A and Della [23] Wang L and Zheng J 2024 IEEE Trans. Appl. 34 4300207
Corte A 2014 IEEE Trans. Appl. 24 1–5 [24] Zermeño V, Sirois F, Takayasu M, Vojenciak M, Kario A and
[12] Mulder T, Dudarev A, Mentink M, Silva H, van der Laan D, Grilli F 2015 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 28 085004
Dhallé M and ten Kate H 2016 IEEE Trans. Appl. [25] Shi Y, Ma T, Dai S, Jin H and Qin J 2023 Supercond. Sci.
26 1–5 Technol. 36 115011
[13] Li W, Sheng J, Zheng J, Shen B, Hu R, Ye H, Hong Z and [26] Yagotintsev K, Anvar V A, Gao P, Dhalle1 M J, Haugan T J,
Jin Z 2021 IEEE Trans. Appl. 31 1–5 Van Der Laan D C, Weiss J D, Hossain M S A and
[14] Uglietti D, Wesche R and Bruzzone P 2014 IEEE Trans. Appl. Nijhuis A 2020 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 33 085009
24 1–4 [27] Mulder T, Dudarev A, van der Laan D C, Mentink M G T,
[15] Wolf M J, Bayer C M, Fietz W H, Heller R, Schlachter S I and Dhalle M and ten Kate H H J 2015 IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater.
Weiss K-P 2016 IEEE Trans. Appl. 26 1–4 Sci. Eng. 102 012026
[16] Nie Y, Wang Y, Lu Y, Yuan X and Wang J 2020 IEEE Trans. [28] Li W, Ye H, Sheng J, Jiang J, Shen B, Zhuyong L, Hong Z and
Appl. 30 1–5 Jin Z 2020 IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 30 4801105
[17] Ito S, Yusa N, Yanagi N, Tamura H, Sagara A and [29] Li Q, Yao M, Jiang Z, Bumby C W and Amemiya N 2018
Hashizume H 2016 IEEE Trans. Appl. 26 1–10 IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 28 6600106
[18] Wang Y, Baasansuren S, Xue C and Hasegawa T 2016 IEEE [30] Han J, Kim W-S, Choi K and Lee J-K 2022 IEEE Trans. Appl.
Trans. Appl. 26 1–6 Supercond. 32 5900705
[19] Oh S et al 2023 IEEE Trans. Appl. 33 1–5 [31] Zhao J, Gao S Y, Wu B H, Yang X S, Shen B, Chen W and
[20] Hartwig Z S et al 2024 IEEE Trans. Appl. 34 0600316 Zhao Y 2022 Supercond. Sci. Technol. 35 115007
[21] Vieira R F, Arsenault D, Barnett R et al 2024 IEEE Trans. [32] Iwasa Y 2009 Case Studies in Superconducting Magnets:
Appl. 34 0600615 Design and Operational Issues 2nd edn (Springer)
12