Professional Documents
Culture Documents
AABR 6 - 2 - 2 - Robi-10 Minute School Sample2
AABR 6 - 2 - 2 - Robi-10 Minute School Sample2
1
This case was selected as the Bronze medal Award-winning case among the Top 10 best cases
based on World Asian Business Case Competition (WACC) 2020.
2
Md. Ridhwanul Haq is a Professor of Institute of Business Administration, University of Dhaka
(email: mrh@iba-du.edu)
Sibbir Riyan (Corresponding author) is a student, Institute of Business Administration, University of
Dhaka (email: ryanprottoy3016@gmail.com)
Akibur Rahman is a student, Institute of Business Administration, University of Dhaka
(email: akib.93.ar@gmail.com)
Faiyaz Uddin Ayeshik, is a student, Institute of Business Administration, University of Dhaka
(email: ayeshik98@gmail.com)
Mahir Hossain is a student, Institute of Business Administration, University of Dhaka
(email: hossainmahir1911@gmail.com)
Bangladesh was 20%, whereas the dropout rate is 38% in the lower secondary level.
The figure among girls was even higher- a staggering 42% dropped out before the
secondary level. Poverty along with the high cost of education was identified as the
core issue. Moreover, other issues such as poor administration, unavailability of
quality teachers, high student to teacher ratio, societal barriers against female
education and impractical study materials made quality education a luxury good in
Bangladesh.
The quality of tertiary education is even worse. According to UNESCO, the
gross enrolment ratio in tertiary education in Bangladesh stood at only 17.6% in
2017. Bangladesh has only a handful number of top tier universities all of which
are mostly based in the capital city of Dhaka. Because of the over-centralized
nature of education exacerbated by the high population, only 5% of the total upper-
secondary graduate students can study in the low-cost public universities. Others
have to resort to private universities, a relatively new establishment in Bangladesh
marked by their exorbitant course fees. The total fees in undergraduate courses the
private universities can range between 10,000 USD to 18,000 USD, whereas the
GDP per capita income of Bangladeshi people was recorded 1203.30 USD in 2018
(Bangladesh GDP per capita, 2018). Therefore, students resort to high-cost tuition
centers. However, the quality coaching industry is offline and extremely
centralized in major cities. Hence 25.5 million rural students of the total 40 million
student base spend 26.13% of their education cost on low-quality coaching (Trines,
2019).
Ayman Sadiq identified these loopholes in the education system of Bangladesh
and came up with a solution: 10 Minute School, a free internet-based quality
education platform. The next section will discuss the target market of 10 MS.
Defining the target segment will help us understand how 10 MS captured the
largest market pie share and why it underpinned their future strategies.
areas. They are born netizens. The demographics are active on social media,
especially Facebook.
Development Timeline
Figure 1
Development Timeline of Robi-10 MS
Source: 10 Minute School: Pordar Pechoner Golpo’ (Story Behind the Scene), 2017
Robi-10 Minute School 35
Turning Points
Figure 2
Comparison of YouTube Videos Published before and after the Partnership
Source: YouTube
36 ACADEMY OF ASIAN BUSINESS REVIEW, DECEMBER 2020
The partnership is considered the biggest milestone for 10 MS for the right
reasons. Firstly, with the technical and financial support, 10 MS could create the
largest digital content library in Bangladesh, an entry barrier too high for any
competitor to overcome. Its website became the storehouse of digital study
materials for NCTB students. Secondly, the wide content coverage became the
source of growth and sustainability for 10 MS. YouTube views and subscribers
went up exponentially. The brand promise of providing free education for everyone
was well-lived.
Figure 3
Rise of YouTube Subscribers before and after the Partnership
Source: YouTube
During the time 10 MS was booming, the whole country was going through a
massive digital transformation. In 2009, the Bangladesh government adopted its
agenda of ‘Digital Bangladesh’ to digitize the whole country through elevated use
of technology in all sectors. The effort became stronger over the years along the
time when 10 MS was founded. The ICT-friendly government policies put wind to
the sails and 10 MS readily grabbed the opportunity. On 15th January 2017, the
company signed a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the ICT Division
of Bangladesh Government in the agreement of promoting digital education in the
country together. This event brought a big turning point for Robi-10 MS in terms
of reaching out to the students, creating a social impact, and building goodwill
across the country.
In an interview with a national daily in 2017, CEO Ayman Sadiq identified
reaching out to students in the farthest corners of Bangladesh to be one of the
biggest challenges for his company (Mizan, 2017). In the socio-cultural context of
Bangladesh, ensuring the access of the students to the platform is a huge obstacle.
The country did not yet join the digital revolution happening worldwide. According
to the World Bank, only 18% of a total of 158 million people had access to the
internet in 2016. The numbers went down to 15% in the following year making the
task of Robi-10 MS even more difficult.
Figure 4
Comparison of Internet Penetration Rate of Bangladesh with Global Average
The collaboration with the ICT division became a gamechanger for 10 MS.
Firstly, they could go beyond the constraint of individual access to the internet.
Leveraging the government infrastructure, the team was able to connect to many
students who did not have access to the internet. Furthermore, Robi-10 MS along
with ICT Division could now broadcast its classes to 2,001 training labs across the
country benefiting thousands of students (Mizan, 2017). Secondly, 10 MS started
working on a project called ‘Learning and Earning’ in association with the ICT
division in 2017 to facilitate basic ICT training for 20,000 girls in the secondary
education level. Through this program, the team empowered thousands of
underprivileged female students. Achieving these feats would not be possible
without national support (Robi-ICT division, 2017). Thirdly. it became
significantly easier for the 10 MS to reach out to its targeted segment more
accurately and efficiently. In the end, Robi-10 MS reached 50,000 individuals and
10% of all educational institutions in the country, through digital labs in 2017
(Jahan, 2017). This extended reach further helped the company in terms of keeping
its brand promise of ensuring free education for everyone, even people at the root
level of the country.
between the urban and rural landscape makes the figure even more outraging.
According to a study by LIRNEasia (2019), the number of internet users in rural
areas in Bangladesh was 42% less than that in the urban areas. As if to make the
matter worse, 64.14% of the country’s population is rural inhabitants (Moore,
2019). Therefore, learning through a website was not a possible solution for rural
students for two reasons. Firstly, broadband connection is still an alien concept in
the villages of Bangladesh. Secondly, the stability of the internet connection is
another grave concern. The average mobile internet speed in Bangladesh is 9.06
Mbps, whereas the global average speed stands at 25.06 Mbps (Molla and Islam,
2020). Since the application is suited for both online and offline learning, it has
been able to bring a greater pool of students under the platform enabling Robi-10
MS to march with greater force.
Success Factors
materials. Finally, their teaching and assessment methods were not standardized
(Rahman et al., 2019).
Robi-10 MS understood the vast demand for standardized and affordable English
language courses and thus created multiple playlists and smartbooks on learning
the English language. The domain later expanded and covered study materials of
various aptitude exams, i.e., IELTS, SAT, GRE, GMAT, and so on. In an interview
with the Business Development Team of Robi-10 MS, they are even planning to
launch an English app in the future. The course content will be categorized based
on difficulty level and professional needs.
The third step was to leverage the rising extra-curricular culture in Bangladesh.
Since 2010, every major university club was launching its debate competitions,
presentation competitions, business case solving competitions, cultural programs,
and Model United Nations discussion forums. In response, Robi-10 MS in
December 2015 released its playlist on how to crack a business case. The playlist
was an instant hit among business students and got more than 430,000 views on
YouTube. To capture this potential market, 10 MS later launched different
YouTube channels for different needs. The company also started creating content
on topics based on popular demand, i.e., digital marketing, software skills, job
skills, life skills, etc.
The strategy of broadening the pond proved valuable for three reasons. Firstly,
Robi-10 MS could reassess its frame of reference: they were not in the academic
business but the learning business. Such a definition allowed them to not only grab
the biggest chunk of the market pie, rather enlarge the pie itself. Secondly, the
massive content library has become a non-imitable unique selling proposition for
the foreseeable future. Finally, doing so enabled them to move into any industry
that is even remotely related to learning, a topic further discussed in the Future
Recommendations Section.
Robi-10 Minute School 41
Figure 5
Content Library of Robi-10 MS
Influencer Marketing
Influencer marketing is a blend of traditional and contemporary modes of
marketing. It combines the conventional ways of celebrity endorsement with
modern-age content marketing. Many companies nowadays use influencer
marketing as a useful tool in their marketing campaigns, but few have been as
successful as Robi-10 MS in channeling influencer marketing to boost its cause.
Founder CEO Ayman Sadiq with his loud and charismatic appearance in different
social media has played a key role in the company’s marketing ventures.
42 ACADEMY OF ASIAN BUSINESS REVIEW, DECEMBER 2020
One of the key factors that solidified Ayman Sadiq’s brand image in the country
is his oratory skills. So far, he has conducted 53 activation sessions at different
institutions and 133 motivational sessions across the country. His vibrant online
and offline presence has earned him a large number of followers across different
platforms. Ayman Sadiq was also endorsed by several internationally recognized
media in the last four years. Forbes included him in 30 under 30 Social
Entrepreneurs list in 2018. In the same year, he received The Queen’s Young
Leader’s award that recognized his work in promoting education. Over the years,
these accolades concreted his brand image in the country and abroad.
Although the overall internet penetration rate in Bangladesh is much lower than
the global average, people’s access to social media is relatively high. Sadiq used
this high ratio of social media access to his advantage and successfully created a
large follower base. As of now, he has 1.3 million followers just on Facebook, and
815 thousand subscribers on YouTube. A majority of the videos that are published
through the official 10 MS Facebook page and YouTube channel are also published
through Sadiq’s profiles simultaneously. Soon, Ayman Sadiq and Robi-10 MS
became synonymous to the mass public. Moreover, people started to recognize him
as a poster boy of online education in Bangladesh due to his extraordinary work in
the area.
Apart from Ayman Sadiq, other public figures in the education sector also
onboarded the Robi-10 MS Team such as Sadman Sadik and Sakib Bin Rashid. For
better clarity, both of these influencers have than 200,000 followers across
different social media channels. As with Ayman Sadiq, major official 10 MS
contents are published simultaneously on their channels as well. Robi-10 MS thus
leveraged the publicity and trust of these influencers, used multi-channel
promotion, and reached a wider segment of audiences, hence a larger website
traffic and app usage with low acquisition cost.
Bangladesh. This response was overwhelming. On 31 May 2016, they created their
first-ever Facebook community called “10 MS Live!”. The purpose of this group
was to conduct live classes, engage the right users, and solve any problems the
students might be having. As of now, the group has more than 1.5 million members.
The success led to the formation of 9 other official groups and numerous unofficial
groups. These Facebook groups became the source of positive word-of-mouth and
user reviews. This example of building communities around the brand by Robi-10
MS became a textbook example of understanding user needs and delivering values
accordingly.
Table 1
Facebook Groups under Robi-10 Minute School
Source: Facebook
Challenges to be Addressed
are looking to modernize and economize their HR activities. Till now, the new
application has been adopted by 11 major corporations in Bangladesh including
Unilever Bangladesh, Robi Axiata Ltd., British American Tobacco Bangladesh, etc.
The training modules are now offered based on monthly/yearly subscriptions.
The new application was important to the future of Robi-10 MS for two reasons.
Firstly, it offered 10 MS a chance to create a subscription-based revenue model.
Secondly, the application contains features such as training videos, quiz assessment,
field assessment by employers, document archives, onboarding training modules
for recruits, and analytics dashboard to assess employees. These new features can
later work as the foundation for future applications if 10 MS were to move into the
HR recruitment industry, cloud-based peer-to-peer software platform, or paid
master course platform.
In this regard, Udacity’s business model can be an inspiration for Robi-10 MS.
The company reported a 120-percent year-over-year increase in Quarter 3 of 2020.
According to Gabe Dalporto, the CEO of Udacity, most of the revenue has been
generated from the enterprise and government side, including even Fortune 500
Companies and the United States Department of Defense; the organizations want to
partner up with Udacity to build custom courses catered to their specific needs. The
CEO also reported that the demand is strong enough to send out an outbound sales
team to acquire the segment (Lunden, 2020).
Table 2
The Axiata Opportunity: Entering Asia
Source: MoEYS, 2018.; Roach, E., 2018.; Roach, E., 2019.; Unicef.org. 2018
Recommendations
People thus jumped on the bandwagon of creating digital agencies. Since then,
hundreds of agencies have mushroomed in the metropolitan cities. However, there
was no unified definition of digital marketing in Bangladesh. Most of the agencies
are run by run by 5-6 part-time students having no real-life experience.
Furthermore, digital marketing in Bangladesh translates into Facebook marketing
only. There is no dedicated service for SEO, content marketing, or big data analysis.
Only a handful of agencies such as Analyzen and ADA offers 360° marketing
services.
Thus, we recommend Robi-10 MS to venture into the digital industry. The
company can open a digital marketing and content consultancy wing as a part of its
B2B services. The execution can open potential doors for Robi-10 MS. The
justification for undertaking such a massive step is discussed below in detail.
Firstly, considering the prospects and pain points of the digital sector, a true
digital marketing agency backed by proper industry experience and offering a wide
range of solutions to negate the pain points would be welcomed in the industry.
Secondly, Robi-10 MS has 5 years of industry experience in content creation and 3
years of experience in blog writing. Its present IT department has the experience of
working in collaboration with the National IT Division. Moreover, its in-house
digital marketing department has run extremely successful campaigns for Robi-10
MS on a national scale for the last 6 years.
Thirdly, ADA, a data-driven marketing and analytics company, is a sub-brand of
Axiata Ltd. The agency, however, caters to high profile clients and industry
leaders. Therefore, ADA can mentor the newly formed digital marketing wing of
Robi-10 MS to operate in the mid-market segment of the digital industry.
As discussed before, Robi-10 MS is currently dependent on sponsorships.
Therefore, we believe that opening a digital marketing wing can be a potential
revenue source for Robi-10 MS without hurting its brand promise. Since it is
already a trusted name in the content creation industry, the company can easily
leverage its expertise, network, and popularity to create a clientele base in no time.
students enrolled in the courses, respectively. But the accounts will be deactivated
after the lockdown ends. Therefore, a large segment of students familiar with
MOOCs will be looking for an alternative after the lockdown.
However, the payment procedure is considered as one of the greatest obstacles in
availing courses on international MOOC platforms because they require credit card
payment. But credit card penetration is only 0.86% in Bangladesh. On the other
hand, Mobile Financial Service (MFS) is pervasively used in Bangladesh. As per
Bangladesh Bank, there are 81 million registered MFS accounts and 27 million
active users (Mobile Financial Services data, 2020). Robi-10 MS can thus
incorporate MFS payment and introduce freemium advanced courses. The master
courses will include learning through video courses, practice quizzes, study
materials including practice files for software courses and personalized assessment
and feedback channels. Awarding certificates upon successful completion can act
as further incentives. 10 MS can thus gain a competitive edge through personalized
assessment and feedback, since the absence of such facilities is marked as one of
the biggest drawbacks for most MOOC platforms, thereby reducing the validity of
the certificate. In the freemium model, course materials on the basic contents will
be kept free as before. However, advanced, and practical lessons along with
personalized assessment features and certificates would be granted upon payment.
Figure 7
Proposed Revenue Model for Robi 10 Minute School
Robi-10 Minute School 51
Conclusion
UNICEF claimed that 11.3 million children in the elementary level and 20.6
million at the lower secondary level are out-of-school. Among the rest that
graduates, millions of children complete primary education without a solid
foundation in basic numeracy and literacy. Since the last 6 years, Robi-10 MS
under the robust leadership of Ayman Sadiq has solved similar deep-rooted
problems in the education sector of Bangladesh and, in the process, built authority
and goodwill across the country. However, bigger challenges lie ahead. Shouldered
with the massive task of maintaining content quality for 1 million students and
generating a solid revenue model, 10 MS is now channeling its expertise to create
corporate training solutions and leveraging its national and corporate network to
expand into Asia. As part of future recommendations, we coined the concept of the
virtual coaching model. We further provided justifications as to why 10 MS should
leverage its content expertise to enter the highly potential digital marketing
industry. Furthermore, with the advent of the pandemic, Bangladeshi students have
readily adopted MOOCs. Hence, we recommend 10 MS to cater to the rising niche
segment by creating more values.
However, offering video-based educational content has a relatively low entry
barrier. Therefore, diversifying the business scope may threaten the core mission of
Robi-10 MS of serving poor students with high quality content. Nonetheless, we
believe that the revenue generated from the diverse sectors can be channelled to
render the current business model a success financially and operationally.
The imminent problem concerning trade-off between the core value proposition
of Robi-10 MS and the sustainability of the business model had been uniquely
solved by Robi-10 MS without catering to any of these extremes. On one hand,
Robi-10 MS has been catering to the still underdeveloped corporate training
domain by leveraging its expertise in B2C training modules to drive the B2B
segment. On the other hand, it has released a new segment comprising of the
advanced versions of courses with reasonable cost, keeping the basic and
intermediate versions free of cost. This case of Robi-10 MS can be generalized
across multiple South Asian countries and thus lies as a testament to all the
struggling EdTech startups out there.
(Received November 17, 2020; Revised December 17, 2020; Accepted December 18, 2020)
References
52 ACADEMY OF ASIAN BUSINESS REVIEW, DECEMBER 2020
10 Minute School: HSC Section. 2017. 10 Minute School: Pordar Pechoner Golpo’
(Story Behind the Scene). [online] Available at:
https://10minuteschool.com/hsc/history-of-10ms/>[Accessed 30 April 2020].
Jahan, I., 2017. Ayman Sadiq, Founder and CEO, Robi-10 Minute School. [Online]
Available at: https://ibtbd.net/ayman-sadiq-founder-and-ceo-robi-10-minute-
school/ [Accessed 7 May 2020].
LIRNEasia (2019). After Access: ICT access and use in Asia and the Global South
(Version 3.0). Colombo: LIRNEasia
Mahmood, M. and Akhter, S., 2011. International briefing 24: training and
development in Bangladesh. International Journal of Training and Development,
15(4), pp.306-321.
Mizan, M. U., 2017. Ayman Sadiq & his 10 Minute School. [Online] Available at:
https://www.observerbd.com/details.php?id=80508 [Accessed 4 May 2020].
Molla, M. and Islam, M., 2020. Slow Internet Speed: Blame Game Is All They Can
Offer. [online] The Daily Star. Available at: https://bit.ly/37qhKhR [Accessed 7
May 2020].
Pandey, A. 2016. 10 Reasons Why You Should Use Mobile Apps for Learning in
Your Learning Strategy [Online] Available at
https://elearningindustry.com/mobile-apps-for-learning-strategy [Accessed on 5
May 2020]
Roach, E., 2018. Education in Nepal - WENR. [online] WENR. Available at:
https://wenr.wes.org/2018/04/education-in-nepal [Accessed 18 May 2020].
Robi-10 MS, n.d. Case Study on the impact of 10MS E-Training App: IDLC
Finance Limited.
Rahman, M., Islam, M., Karim, A., Chowdhury, T., Rahman, M., Seraj, P. and
Singh, M., 2019. English language teaching in Bangladesh today: Issues,
outcomes and implications. Language Testing in Asia, 9(1).
Robi.com.bd. 2020. Robi-10 Minute School App Hits Million Downloads. [online]
Available at: https://www.robi.com.bd/en/corporate/media-room/press-
release/robi-10-minute-school-app-hits-million-downloads [Accessed 27 May
2020].
Shah, D., 2020. Moocwatch 23: Pandemic Brings Moocs Back in The Spotlight.
[online] classcentral.com. Available at:
https://www.classcentral.com/report/moocwatch-23-moocs-back-in-the-
spotlight/ [Accessed 27 May 2020].
The Asian Age. 2017. Robi-ICT Division to Work Together For 10-Minutes
School | The Asian Age Online, Bangladesh. [online] Available at:
https://dailyasianage.com/news/43323/robi-ict-division-to-work-together-for-10-
minutes-school [Accessed 27 May 2020].